Premium Essay

Ocean Carrier Case Solution, Harvard Business Case

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ytterfors
Words 1231
Pages 5
Corporate Finance and Value Creation Memorandum

Ocean Carriers

November 2015

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Due to an attractive lease agreement proposed by a larger client, the investment department has conducted an extensive evaluation of the possibility to invest in a new $39 million capesize carrier. This material should be distributed as a basis for the decision regarding the commission of the carrier and includes current assumptions and calculations. The investment department has come to the absolute conclusions to decline the offer to enter into the lease agreement, due to the unprofitability of commissioning a new vessel. This conclusions hold both under U.S. tax law as well as Hong Kong tax law. The net present value of the project is currently -$6,968.828 under U.S. tax law and -$1,228,132 under Hong Kong tax law. The internal rate of returns is 5.5% under U.S. tax law and 8.4% under Hong Kong tax law. The project has been discounted at Oceans Carriers current hurdle rate of 9%.

Investment Opportunity Ocean Carriers are currently in negotiations with a well esteemed charterer regarding a three-year charter on a capesize ocean freighter. Our client has made an offer of $ 20,000 per day with an annual escalation of $200 per day starting in the beginning of year 2003. As we, Ocean Carriers, do not currently have a capesize of the required specifications available for chartering we hereby present an investment opportunity involving the commission of a new vessel. This memorandum asserts possible future market conditions in an effort to determine whether this investment is likely to be profitable or not.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Daniel Kim Harvard Business Case

...board, due to the time constraints of the audit. Kim should minimize the time period to 48 hours to speak with board. If Sanchez speaks to the board within that time frame, the decision rests in the board’s hands to decide what to do. If at that point Sanchez has not spoken to the board in the allotted time, Kim should address the situation at hand to the board. When addressing the board, Kim should present them with a detailed outline that Sanchez is breaking policy by covering up personal expenses as business expenses. Then he should stress the importance of why he did not go straight to the auditors and plead for Sanchez to retain a job within company just maybe not as CEO. Action Plan Short Term - Kim will give Sanchez 48 hours to confess his financial offenses to the board o If Sanchez does not expose himself in 48 hours, then Kim will go to the board to reveal his wrongdoings - By doing this, Kim will prove that Sanchez is covering personal expenses as business expenses - The board will take further action at their own discretion Long Term (6 months) - Kim and the board will discuss the possibility of firing Ms. Jones due to conflict of interest - Kim will take drastic measures to monitor company spending and check spending frequently - Sanchez will work towards repaying the company for his personal expenses...

Words: 442 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ocean Carriers Case and Assumptions

...The Charles H. Kellstadt Graduate School of Business DePaul University FIN 555: Financial Management Thomas M Carroll Phone: 312.362.8826 Office: Loop Campus tcarroll@depaul.edu Case Study Questions Capital Budgeting In Practice Ocean Carriers These questions relate to the Ocean Carriers case in your course packet. You can find the data for this case on the course website in a spreadsheet named: Ocean Carriers Exhibits.xls. This case provides the opportunity to make a capital budgeting decision by using discounted cash flow analysis to make an investment and corporate policy decision. Ocean Carriers is a shipping company evaluating a proposed lease of a ship for a three-year period beginning in 2003. The proposed leasing contract offers very attractive terms, but no ship in Ocean Carrier’s current fleet meets the customer’s requirements. The firm must decide if future expected cash flows warrant the considerable investment in a new ship. 1. Do you expect daily spot hire rates to increase or decrease next year? Give the reasons for your choice. Which are the factors that drive average daily rates? What does this imply in terms of your cash flow projections? Daily hire rates are determined by supply and demand, as well as the size, age, and efficiency of the ships in service. Due to a high number of vessels expected to be delivered in 2001, as well as the fact that imports for iron and coal were......

Words: 883 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Business Case Continental Carriers

...blundered down into the brambles and pushed his way up from the ditch. It was Bigwig. "Hello, Bigwig," said Hazel. "You're off duty?" "Off duty" said Bigwig, "and likely to remain off duty." "How do you mean?" "I've left the Owsla, that's what I mean." "Not on our account?" "You could say that. The Threarah's rather good at making himself unpleasant when he's been woken up at ni-Frith for what he considers a piece of trivial nonsense. He certainly knows how to get under your skin. I dare say a good many rabbits would have kept quiet and thought about keeping on the right side of the Chief, but I'm afraid I'm not much good at that. I told him that the Owsla's privileges didn't mean all that much to me in any case and that a strong rabbit could always do just as well by leaving the warren. He told me not to be impulsive and think it over, but I shan't stay. Lettuce-stealing isn't my idea of a jolly life, nor sentry duty in the burrow. I'm in a fine temper, I can tell you." "No one will steal lettuces soon," said Fiver quietly. "Oh, that's you, Fiver, is it?" said Bigwig, noticing him for the first time. "Good, I was coming to look for you. I've been thinking about what you said to the Chief Rabbit. Tell me, is it a sort of tremendous hoax to make yourself important, or is it true?" "It is true," said Fiver. "I wish it weren't." "Then you'll be leaving the warren?" They were all startled by the bluntness with......

Words: 164548 - Pages: 659

Premium Essay

Ocean Manufacturing Case Solutions

...Acct 4080 Ocean Manufacturing Case 1. 1) Obtain and review financial information about the prospective client: annual reports, interim statements, registrations statements, Form 10-k’s, and reports to regulatory agencies. 2) Detailed criminal background checks of senior managers. 3) Evaluate the public accounting firm’s independence with regard to prospective clients. 4) Inquire of the prospective clients’ bankers, legal counsel, underwriters, analysts, or other persons who do business with the entity for information about the entity and its management. 5) Consider the need for individuals possessing special skills or knowledge to complete the audit (e.g., IT auditor, valuations specialist, industry specialist) 2. Overall, after calculating a few of Ocean Manufacturing ratios and comparing them with the industry, the company’s figures are not performing up to others in the industry. ROE = NI/Stockholder Equity (2011,2010)= 8.9% and 7.1% ROA = NI/Assets= 4.5% . 3.8% Both return on equity and assets are lower than industry ratios but are improving. Accounts Rec Turnover—could not calculate without % of credit sales from cash sales. Profit Margin = Operating income/ Sales(rev) = 5.5%, 6.0% PM are also low compared to the industry average. 3. There are a few non-financial items the company should consider. a) The VP of finance was charged with a misdemeanor related to illegal gambling. Raises questions about the tone at the top and the......

Words: 493 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Harvard Business Review Case: Starbucks

...Harvard Business Review Case: Starbucks Harvard Business Review Case: Starbucks This case study will review how Starbucks is doing financially, examine marketing segmentation and life style changes impacting Starbucks based on the Harvard Business Review case information, and what Hambrick strategy elements Starbucks should focus on most for improvement. “Starbucks’ brand strategy was best captured by its live coffee mantra, a phrase that reflected the importance the company attached to keeping the national coffee culture alive. From a retail perspective, this meant creating an experience around the consumption of coffee, an experience that people could weave into the fabric of their everyday lives” (Moon & Quelch, 2006). Starbucks is the largest coffeehouse company in the world. Starbucks Corporation operates as a roaster, marketer, and retailer of specialty coffee worldwide. Its stores offer coffee and tea beverages, packaged roasted whole bean and ground coffees, juices, various food products, as well as beverage-making equipment and accessories. In addition, it licenses the rights to produce and distribute Starbucks branded products, as well as licenses its trademarks through licensed stores, grocery, and national foodservice accounts. Over the last ten years, with the exception of 2008-2009, Starbucks has had at least 9 percent + revenue increases from year to year (revenue spreadsheet attached).......

Words: 1518 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Biopure Harvard Business Case

... Marketing Strategy: The product should be advertised in vet journals and trade shows as these are taken seriously and are treated as valued source of information. A strong network should be formed with the distributors with a mindset that Hemopure is the main target for release. Finally, I would conclude that Oxyglobin should be released soon to the market by distinguishing Oxyglobin and Hemopure as two independent products. Hemopure should be marketed on the brand established by Oxyglobin and should be compared with other human blood substitutes for pricing. Appendix Assumptions: * Here we are doing analysis for price per unit as $150 and $200. * We are considering distribution cost as 15% of Total Sales (Table C of case description, considering only local distributors). * Additional distribution cost due to “Manufacturer Direct”= $15 per unit (optional) Total Revenue: Estimated price per unit | $150 | $200 | Maximum number of units per year | 300,000 | 300,000 | Maximum expected sales revenue | $45,000,000 | $60,000,000 | Fixed Cost: Distribution Cost | $4,500,000 | $6,000,000 | Overall Production Cost | $15,000,000 | $15,000,000 | Total Fixed Cost | $19,500,000 | $21,000,000 | Contribution Margin: Cost of raw material per unit | $1.5 | $1.5 | Additional distribution cost | $15 | $15 | Contribution Margin per unit | $133.5 | $183.5 | Contribution Margin: Contribution Margin per unit = Estimated price......

Words: 738 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Dragon Soup Harvard Business Case

...1. Using the excel spreadsheet provided, and the recommended consequential disclosures as a basis you your analysis, what recommendations would you give Phillips on each of the items listed below? In each case, justify your recommendations and estimate how much the decision will change the “true” value of the company and its value in the eyes of an investor in a private company. a. The lease or buy decision, including whether to structure as an operating lease. The new canning equipment should be leased over the 14 year term with no bargain purchase option so as to structure it as an operating lease. The major factor to consider is what will boost Net Income the most given that the goal is raise the share price. After a side-by-side comparison, the Net Income is greatest under an operating lease structure with the capital lease and purchase outcomes being equal thereafter. This is due to a couple of factors. First off, under an operating lease, the payments to the lessor are considered rent (S,G&A for this case) and do not include interest. Therefore, there is no interest expense of $50,000 under the operating lease however, that is offset by an increase in S,G&A expense ($85,870). Secondly, the lessee, Dragon Soup, does not have to expense depreciation which saves them an additional $50,000. This reduction is made to Cost of Goods Sold because under GAAP, manufacturing firms are to apply direct PPE expenses to inventory when it is sold. The result of this decision......

Words: 1306 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Harvard Business Case: Options

...futures price. In order to make a profit, one has to "buy low, sell high". As Ft(t,T) = $312.30 < Fa(t,T) = $313.55 Jim should short March'86 MMI futures contracts. Thereby, he can buy them at the theoretical price of $312.30 and sell them at $313.55. To short the futures, Jim has to buy the underlying. Therefore, he has to invest some money. Part of it will be the company’s own funds; the major part comes from borrowed funds. Jim can have a total position of $5,000,000. Jim has the restriction that 10% of this amount must be kept as margin. Therefore, he would borrow $4,999,516.42 from the bank at a borrowing rate of 8%. The cost of capital for company funds is expected to be higher. However, as this number is not explicitly given in the case, we assume that it is 8% too. The total price for the index is adjusted by a mark-up of 0.0025% for a round-trip impact. As he cannot buy partial stocks, he will only make use of $4,999,516.42 (see Figure 1). Jim will use this amount to buy 3628 shares of the index (more precise, shares of each component stock) on February 26th. Moreover, he shorts 64 contracts of March '86 futures. The number of contracts is rounded 64 as 4999516.42/(313.55*250). The cost for that at t is zero. To calculate the return at T, several calculations have to be performed. The following formula is applied to calculate the future value of the loan taken, in other words, what Jim has to buy back at T: 〖FV〗_l (T)=〖PV〗_l (t)e^r(T-t) with 〖PV〗_l (t) =......

Words: 1074 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Case Ocean Carriers

...Discoount rate Ship life (years) Scrap value Initial investment M€ Depr./year 9% 25 6720000 39000000 1291200 Pinja Ruonala 241364 Case Ocean Carriers Since the consulting firm fee (200 000 USD) and internal marketing study expenses (150 000 USD) already occurred and thus are sunk costs, they are not taken into account in the investment calculations. Those expenses will realize, no matter whether the investment will be done or not, so they are not relevant. Net present value calculation was done in order to give a recommendation for Ocean Carriers whether to purchase of the $39M capsize. Only change in new working capital was taken into account in the calculations. I used the provided expected daily hire rates for the revenue calculation for the lifetime of the vessel. Annual hire revenue ( expected income) was calculated by deducting the days the vessel spent in maintenance and multiplying the remaining days with the daily hire rate. Annual growth of 4,03% was taken into account in the operating costs. Depreciation was added back in the calculations because of it not having a cash flow effect. Depreciation was added back in the calculations because of it not having a cash flow effect. Since the NPV of the investment is negative in the first setting (when tax rate is 38%), I advise Ocean Carriers not to purchase the capesize. However, in Hong Kong setting when there is no requirement to pay tax on profits, the investment is very profitable. Year Initial investment......

Words: 1260 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Dupont Case Harvard Business Paper

...Silva A01139056 Case. DuPont Kevlar Aramid Fiber Industrial. The DuPont’s major core has been the creation and innovation of fibers for several uses, such as Lycra spandex fiber, diverse polyester forms, Nomex Aramid fiber and Qiana nylon. The invention of Kevlar brought a new market cluster for DuPont to develop, and that one is the tire and aerospace industries. The important assumptions to have in consideration before making a decision is to first know who your market target is, who your competition is, and the pros and cons to start to develop a niche in this industry, for that I mean, what would be the production cost and what would be the selling cost, knowing those data, you can estimate the profit for a certain period, and with that, you can know if its profitable to start in this area. It’s important to understand, before starting a business to have the whole thing strategically planned. To have a good innovation starting I would say you need to try to develop in a market pull instead of technology push. With this, is easier to get your technology out there and sell it for sure, because the market is already there waiting for something to solve their problems. Returning to the part of “to have to whole thing strategically planned”, it is needed to be said that, part of that plan is to know who your market is, as it was said before. Being a fiber product, in the first line of costumers, it can be said that the market attended would be car’s business (for all the......

Words: 748 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Bailla Harvard Case Solution

...Barilla: Coordinating Supply and Demand OPIM: 615, Class 8 Kunal Mahajan (Penn ID: 56704329) Question 1: Diagnose the underlying causes of the difficulties that the JITD program was created to solve. What are the benefits and drawbacks of this program? JITD was targeted at solving two issues in the supply chain- high inventory and stock outs in stores. A. High Inventory Barilla, distributors and retailers were all carrying excess inventories which caused a drain on profits in the entire business chain because of the high cost of carrying inventory- warehousing, transportation, scrapping etc. The underlying reasons for the high inventory were:  SKU & Supply Chain Complexity: The safety stock/inventory required in the supply chain increases with increased complexity. Barilla made Pasta in 200 different shapes and sizes and was sold in over 470 different packaged SKUs. Additionally, the Barilla products were in 100,000 stores in Italy, which also increased the overall complexity.  Demand Fluctuation: The fluctuations in end demand for Pasta meant that there was a bullwhip effect across the supply chain leading to increased inventory at all points. o Lack of proper demand forecasting: The Distribuzione Organizzata’s (DO’s) did not employ any sophisticated forecasting methodologies to place order with Barilla. Instead the orders were based on replenishment of stock on need basis. o Over dependence on promotions: The Barilla sales teams used trade......

Words: 1304 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Case Ocean Carriers

...Case 1: Ocean Carriers   Our first case study is entitled Ocean Carriers (HBS Case No. 9‐202‐027) by Erik Stafford et al. Please go to the Harvard Business Publishing website http://hbsp.harvard.edu . The case is copyright‐protected and can be purchased after registration. Please register at the Harvard Business Publishing website with a student account. After login, make use of the following link: https://cb.hbsp.harvard.edu/cbmp/access/42497623. Integrate answers/discussions to the following questions into your memo (Please don’t write separate answers for each question, and also the order when you answer them is not relevant. Your memo should consist of one comprehensive and well‐structured text.) Assume that Ocean Carriers uses a 9% discount rate for its investments. Questions: 1. Do you expect daily spot hire rates to increase or decrease next year? 2. What factors drive average daily hire rates? 3. How would you characterize the long‐term prospects of the capesize dry bulk industry? 4. Should Ms Linn purchase the $39M capesize? Make 2 different assumptions. First, assume that Ocean Carriers is a U.S. firm subject to 35% taxation. Second, assume that Ocean Carriers is located in Hong Kong, where owners of Hong Kong ships are not required to pay any tax on profits made overseas and are also exempted from paying any tax on profit made on cargo uplifted from Hong Kong. 5.......

Words: 252 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Harvard Business Case

...Harvard Business Case 10-16-07 The Overhead Reduction Task Force: A Case Analysis The Facts Central Foods Corporation just hired a new General Manager, Georgia Dixon, to run the deteriorating Countertop Appliances Division. This new division was formed after Central Foods acquired Kitchen Help, Inc. six years ago. With sales decreasing quite dramatically over the past three years and overhead costs at their peak, Dixon is in charge of implementing positive changes in her department. For one of her first moves she appointed Larry Williams as head of the new Overhead Reduction Task Force. This task force is being formed to decrease overhead costs by 20% in the next four months while also increasing sales. External Factors Affecting CFC There are three main external factors that are influencing the overall sales production in this case. First off, one of CFC’s major competitors introduced a new household coffee maker that sold at the same retail price as CFC’s coffee maker, but CFC did not have the same innovation incorporated into their product. Secondly, another main competitor of CFC launched a new and improved microwave oven, which severely hurt Countertop’s sales of the same product. CFC’s product line still has not made a comparable substitute for this newly designed microwave oven. Finally, competitors’ pricing of the kitchen products was 10% lower than CFC’s pricing for the same products. CFC believed that these competitors would eventually have to......

Words: 2152 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Harvard Business Apple Case Study

...Harvard Business School Case Study Analysis Harvard Business School Case Study Analysis Description At the end of 2014, Apple Inc. recorded the most profitable quarter of any firm in history, and its market capitalization soon topped $700 billion. 'Apple Inc. in 2015' explores the history of Apple, its successes under Jobs, its continued growth under Tim Cook, and the challenges facing the company in 2015. With iPod sales continuing their freefall, tablet sales in decline, and the Macintosh's market share remaining small, Apple was increasingly dependent on the iPhone to drive its growth. Could Cook continue Apple's dominance in the smartphone market in the face of growing competition? Could he revitalize the iPad business, become a leader in payments, with Apple Pay, and replicate Apple's success in other device categories, such as the Apple Watch, the first new product the company had released since 2010? Introduction:   Apple Inc has been an icon in American industry over the last three decades. The CEO Steve Jobs did a remarkable job turning around the company that was nearly bankrupt in 1996, however after his death in 2011 the questions has been brought forward of how sustainable will Apple be without Steve Jobs. Apple has always been trying to be simple and bring easy to use   products to a large market of consumers. On the beginning Apple focused on producing low-cost computers merged with...

Words: 1666 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Case Analysis: Airborne Express (a), Harvard Business School.

...Case Analysis: Airborne Express (A), Harvard Business School. Not so long ago, there was no such thing as overnight express service and freight delivery. Then Federal Express, United Postal Service (UPS) and Airborne Express, among six second-tier companies, came upon the scene. In 1973, Federal Express invented the concept of overnight express package, soon followed by the other two largest express companies–UPS and Airborne, during the 1980s. The fast growth of the Express Mail industry was mainly due to the success of the express delivery service. Thanks to Frederick Smith, a Yale undergraduate back in 1965, who had envisioned a whole different system on his economics term paper. Smith proposed an airline dedicated exclusively to express delivery of mail. Regardless of a “C” grade received on his paper, Smith incorporated Federal Express in 1971and officially began operations on April 17, 1973. Some of the features in the evolution of the Express Mail Industry includes but is not limited to the creation of the hub system and air express service. Created by Federal Express, the hub system is the symbol of the modern air courier industry. It made possible the large-scale, overnight deliveries and it has remained the standard operating method in use to this day. This system allows air courier industry to ship all freight to the company’s central hub, where it is sorted, and rerouted to its final destination. Also under consideration, the air express service played an......

Words: 1561 - Pages: 7