Free Essay

On the Rainy River

In: Novels

Submitted By rauls505
Words 762
Pages 4
On the Rainy River” is an exploration of the role of shame in war. The story develops the theme of embarrassment as a motivating factor, first introduced by Jimmy Cross in “The Things They Carried” and “Love.” Just as Jimmy Cross feels guilty about Ted Lavender’s death, O’Brien feels guilty about going to Vietnam against his principles. He questions his own motives, and in this story he returns to the genesis of his decision in order to examine with us the specifics of cause and effect.

Ironically, despite its specific details and its preoccupation with reality, “On the Rainy River” is the story most easily identifiable as fiction. The real Tim O’Brien did indeed struggle with his decision to heed his draft notice, but he never actually ran to the Canadian border, and he never stayed at the Tip Top Lodge. Still, as he states explicitly later in the work, the point of a story like this one is not to deliver true facts exactly as they happened but rather to use facts and details in order to give an accurate account of the feelings behind a given situation. Though the events in the story are not true, the story itself conveys an emotional truth.
By describing his personal history, O’Brien makes a broader comment on the confusion that soldiers experienced when the demands of their country and community conflicted with the demands of their princples and conscience. O’Brien’s description of his moral dilemma about going to Vietnam illustrates how the war was fought by soldiers who were often reluctant and conflicted. In the context of the collection’s later stories, “On the Rainy River” weighs the guilt of avoiding the draft against the guilt of committing atrocities against other humans. Though it seems obvious that killing is more ethically reprehensible than draft-dodging, O’Brien’s story explains how his largely uninformed community nonetheless wields a moral clout that overpowers his own opposition to the war.
This story references one of the recurring ideas in The Things They Carried: that war twists moral structures and makes it impossible to take a morally clear course of action. Joseph Heller’s World War II novel Catch- 22 also addresses the twisted morality of war by describing a situation, called a “catch-22,” in which a problem’s only solution is impossible because of some characteristic of the problem. O’Brien is trapped in a catch-22 because the only way that he can avoid guilt is by taking a course of action that will make him feel guilty. If he goes to war, he will feel guilty for ignoring his own objection to United States involvement in Vietnam, but the only way to avoid this guilt involves incurring the disapproval of his community—which will cause him to feel guilt and shame. In The Things They Carried, O’Brien shows how soldiers experience catch-22s both during the war and in the time surrounding it.
The bald, shrunken, silent Elroy Berdahl is a father figure for the narrator. Although the two do not explicitly discuss O’Brien’s dilemma, Elroy forces O’Brien to shake himself out of complacent confusion. But Berdahl’s presence isn’t sharp or invasive. Rather, his effect is that of a mirror—saying nothing, expecting nothing, perhaps not even knowing the situation at hand, he leads O’Brien to the river and forces him to confront Canada and the prospect of freedom from the draft sitting on the other side. O’Brien is compelled into action, not because Elroy forces him, but rather because the old man leads him to the river, where the necessity of making a choice once and for all becomes clear to O’Brien.
O’Brien’s narrative reveals that he feels the need to justify and explain his decision to us, his readers, by putting us in the position of ethical judges of his actions. O’Brien’s description of himself as a naïve, impressionable youth is part of a defense of himself and of his actions. Although his blunt questioning of “What would you do?” and “Would you cry, as I did?” forces us to recognize the difficulty of his position, it also invites us to evaluate the validity of his course of action. Later in the work, O’Brien illustrates the power of war to transform an individual by showing his own transformation from young and impressionable to disillusioned and uninspired. Here, he compares the act of remembering his young, naïve self to watching an old home movie, and this metaphor makes us the audience of this movie and forces us to take a more active role in considering O’Brien.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Africa- Comparing Nigeria & South Africa

...Nigeria is found in the tropics and has two different seasons, the Dry season and Rainy season. The major rivers passing through Nigeria are the Niger, the third largest river in Africa and the Benue, which flows into the Niger River. The Niger Delta sometimes called the Oil Rivers, due to the past production of palm oil. South Africa is the southern tip of Africa, which includes two islands of the southeast tip of Cape Town, Prince Edward and Marion. South Africa is roughly twice the size of Texas. It borders Mozambique, Zimbabwe, Botswana and Namibia. There are two major rivers in South Africa, the Limpopo, a stretch of which is shared with Zimbabwe, and the Orange which flows into the Vaal. The Orange River flows from east to west across the central landscape, emptying into the Atlantic Ocean at the Namibian border ( South Africa is different from Nigeria in that it actually has another country within its borders, Lesotho. It is in the Drakensberg Mountains where South Africa obtains water from the snowcapped peaks of the landlocked nation. Also, South Africa has three capitals, while Nigeria has one, Abuja. Bloemfontein is the capital of the judiciary, Cape Town is the legislative capital, and Pretoria is the administrative capital, as well as the formal capital of the country. South Africa is divided into three major geographic regions, the African Plateau in the country's interior....

Words: 1302 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Rainy Season

...Importance of rains for agriculture The rainy season is the life of the agriculture in India. The failures of monsoons become a curse on us. The crops would fail, and famine and disease would break out. This would kill thousands people. Such is the great importance of rains. Hence it is quite proper for us to worship with great...

Words: 465 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Runaway

...The runaway This passage is untitled « The runaway » but it’s actually « On the Rainy River » which is a short story written by Tim O’Brien. This American author published in 1990 « The Things They Carried », a collection of related stories about a platoon of American soldiers in the Vietnam War. While modeled after the author’biography and sharing the same name, Tim is a fictional character and not the author who’s intentionally blurs this distinction, even though he has also been drafted overthere. To sum up briefly, the character, 21, tells us how his storybook world collapsed when he received a draft notice for the Vietnam War. We’ll fisrt develop the dilemma which tortures Tim. Then we’ll analyze the role of the second character, Elroy, and the unexpected « nonconformist » punch line. This excerpt takes place in Minnesota where Tim is fishing on the Rainy River which marks the border between the USA and Canada. It deals with the issues of whether the war he has been drafted into is right and if he should go to the war or be a coward and run away from the war. The dilemma is hard. The draft, at least during the Vietnam war, was a sort of lottery that determined the order of men, by birthdate, to serve as soldiers. This was instituted because there were not enough voluntary soldiers serving in the military. The ways a citizen of the U.S. could avoid going to the Vietnam War was either leave the country or contract some life threatening desease....

Words: 674 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...* Lakes and rivers- On the land surface, approximately 0.18 million cubic kilometre water is present in lakes while about 0.002 million cubic kilometre water is found in rivers. * Atmospheric moisture- The amount of water present as water is present in lakes while about 0.013 million cubic kilometre. It removes water vapor from air for drinking, cleaning, and other uses * Biological water- In addition to above categories, about 0.001 million cubic kilometre water is contained in the bodies of living organisms. Weather and Climate Weather is the state of the atmosphere at a particular time and place....

Words: 653 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Spanish History

...In the southwestern and southern area the climate consists of hot dry summers, rain during spring and autumn, and mild rainy winters. The western and the northwestern climate is characterized as a warm temperate moist forest climate, with dry summers and wet/rainy winters. The natural resources of Spain include coal, lignite, iron ore, copper, lead, zinc, uranium, tungsten, mercury, pyrites, magnesite, fluorspar, gypsum, sepiolite, kaolin, potash, hydropower, and arable land. The renewable water resource is very large due to the multiple rivers and lakes throughout the country. More than half of the land in Spain is agricultural and about a third of it is forest. The urban-rural economy of Spain has had its ups and downs over the years. 2014 marked the first full year of economic growth since the global financial crisis began in 2008. This is because of private consumption or the privatization of companies and businesses. Spain has the fourteenth largest economy by nominal GDP in the world and the sixteenth largest by purchasing power parity. The main four sectors of the economy include exports, tourism, energy and the automotive industry. The population of Spain is 48,146 people. Most of the population is Roman Catholic and it has been that way for a long time. The general age of the population is between 25 and 54 years. Spanish is the main language but the people of Barcelona speak Catalan and some other natives of Spain speak Galician or Basque....

Words: 368 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Rainwater Harvesting

...We have perennial rivers like Ganga, Brahmaputra, Yamuna, Beas and others along with their tributaries and distributaries besides in North and Eastern India, we have spring fed and rain fed rivers in central and peninsular India-the major among these being- Godavari, Krishna, Narmada, Tapti and Kaveri. These huge potential water resources notwithstanding, we are facing a water crisis across the country. Over the years, rising population, growing industrialisation and expanding agriculture have pushed up the demand for water. Monsoon is still the main hope of our agriculture. Water conservation has become the need of the day. Rainwater harvesting is a way to capture the rainwater at the time of downpour, store that water above the ground or charge the underground water and use it later. This happens in open areas as well as in congested cities through the installation of required equipment. The collection and storage of rainwater from run-off areas such as roofs and other surfaces has been practised since ancient times in India. It is particularly useful where water supply is inadequate. If the collection and storage equipment is designed carefully it is possible for a family of four persons to live for a year in areas where annual rainfall is as little as 100 mm. Observations in some other countries like Zimbabwe, Botswana and Israel have shown that up to 85 per cent of all measurable rain can be collected and stored from outside catchment areas....

Words: 1367 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Impact of River-Water Sharing on Bangladesh

...The Impact of River-Water Sharing on Bangladesh   Tatulia, one of the small villages in Bangladesh, is a representative of what problems occur due to the unavailability and shortage of clean water to the Bengali people. Can you imagine a 60 year-old woman, Aleya, who lived most of her life in Tatulia saying good-bye to her precious home due to such problems? Aleya says, “ Over the last few years, we have faced acute problems of safe drinking water; we have to drink arsenic-contaminated water!” Due to the fact that Bangladesh’s primary resources are tied to water consumption, Bengali officials are trying to study and implement many projects to increase the availability and quality of water and to manage it efficiently. A major predicament is that Bangladesh’s changing weather and flat topography produce severe flooding in the monsoon season and excessive drought during the dry season. This in turn affects the enhancement of its agricultural sector and damages its industrial sector. An immediate question comes to mind: why isn’t Bangladesh adopting some kind of project to collect the water in the flood season and use it in the dry season? The answer to this may hinge on Bangladesh’s neighboring countries, such as India, and their effect on the presence of water resources in the country. The present work focuses on the issue of Bengali-Indian relationships with regard to water sharing....

Words: 2366 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

The Role of English Teacher in Classroom

...The climate covers the tropics in the south creating the rainy season(that begins mid-June and ends mid-December) and the dry season(occuring between mid-December and mid-June of the following year), and the monon in the north, forming the rainy season from mid-May to mid-September and the warm, dry season from mid-October to mid –March.Typhoons coming together with floods, at times , bring havoc to many part of central Vietnam. Travelling from north to south and vice versa, tourists will find many interesting places alongside beatiful beaches, where, all year round, they can ẹnoy their stay and the charm of the seaside. There are more than 20 beatiful beaches along the coastline, such as Tra Co, Ha Long,Do Son, and Sam Son in the...

Words: 3064 - Pages: 13

Free Essay


...The main attractions of Botswana are stated in the following: ~The Okavango Delta River cuts through the center of the Kalahari Desert, creating a unique ecosystem that gives life to a huge variety of birds and mammals. The Okavango is a unique safari destination because you can view much of the wildlife from a traditional canoe, a mokoro. ~The Chobe National Park lies in Botswana’s Okavango Delta and covers four distinct ecosystems. The Savuti marsh in particular, offers some of the highest concentrations of wildlife in Africa year round. Chobe boasts around 120,000 elephants so if you visit you’re unlikely to miss them. ------------------------------------------------- ~The Kgalagadi Transfrontier Park is full of Salt pans, Kalahari sand dunes, and, plenty of wildlife during the rainy season makes this a wonderful park to visit, but it’s not easy to get to. Location: Botswana is in Southern Africa, just north of South Africa. It borders Namibia to the west and Zimbabwe to the northeast. Area: Botswana covers an area of 600,370 sq. km., making it slightly smaller than Texas and slightly larger than France. Capital: Gaborone Population: Just over 1.5 million people live there. Language: English (Official), most people speak Setswana, but there are also some indigenous languages. Religion: Indigenous beliefs 85% and Christian 15%. Climate: Botswana is an almost all desert country that is covered by the semi-arid Kalahari Desert....

Words: 321 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Feeding Ecology of Hypostomus Punctatus in Costal Stream from Foutheast Brazil

...Feeding preferences were assessed through a sample of 138 specimens (67 from the dry and 71 from the rainy season) using the Index of Alimentary Importance (IAi). We registered five different food items (detritus, plant fragments, Diatoms, Chloroficeae and Cianobacteries) composing the species diet. Detritus was the most abundant one both during the rainy and dry seasons (IAirainny = 90.34 and IAidry = 96.30). No significant differences were registered for the volume of food items consumed during the rainy and dry seasons. The Frequency of Occurrence analysis showed that four (detritus, plant fragments, Diatoms and Chloroficeae) among the five all other consumed ones, were always frequent. Comparing our own results with those available for the study site, we suggest that the feeding habit of H. punctatus has changed according to environmental changes and that the species diet is strongly dependent upon environmental conditions. Keywords: stream-dwelling fish, detritivorous, benthonic behaviour. Ecologia trófica de Hypostomus punctatus Valenciennes, 1840 (Osteichthyes, Loricariidae) de um riacho costeiro do sudeste do Brasil Resumo No presente estudo, tivemos como...

Words: 3500 - Pages: 14

Free Essay


...Kodachadri – a paradise on earth Higher and still higher the road to Kodchadri rises through a landscape scorched by an uncharacteristically early onslaught of summer. Nature has blessed it with plenty green forest and meadows and cluster of rare trees. Kodchadri is a land of incredible natural beauty and medicinal plants. It is delight to trek this hill situated in Sahyadri region. An ecological hotspot, it still beckons those who are looking for off-beat trails. And as you climb up there, open up your senses and gear up to rediscover the Blue Mountains. A day time is the ideal to start trekking and the trodden path begins on the plane lands slowly leading to the vague path of ups and downs in the midst of tall wild trees. While climbing the thick white clouds embraces you gently refresh the trekker to continue the journey. Going up and up you will see the clouds below your destination seems like a snow white cotton spread on the mountains. Kodachadri is one of the rarest pinnacles in the Western Ghats which starts from Gujarat and ends in Kerala. It contains variety and rare animals and plants. It is at the height of 1343 meters from the sea level and 610 meters from the base. Kodachadri spreads in Hosanagar taluk in Shimoga district and Kundapur taluk in Udupi district. Kodachadri is considered as the Kashmir of Karnataka with evergreen forests, steep valleys, beautiful lawns and waterfalls. A trekker requires courage and a mind to enjoy the natural beauty of this......

Words: 1208 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

.Rivers of Bangladesh

...[pic] Name: I.D Sec Instructor Water pollution is the contamination of water bodies (e.g. lakes, rivers, oceans, aquifers and groundwater). Water pollution occurs when pollutants are discharged directly or indirectly into water bodies without adequate treatment to remove harmful compounds. The water pollution situation from Bangladesh could be the largest poisoning in history and the irony is that this situation could be the result of all the efforts in cleaning the water for some of the poorest nations of the world. Sources of pollution: Factories, power plants and sewage treatment plants are considered point sources of water pollution, because they emit pollutants at discrete locations, usually through a pipe that leads to a lake or stream. Nonpoint sources of water pollution are scattered or diffused. [pic] Rivers of Bangladesh Bangladesh is a riverine country. About 300 rivers including tributaries flow through the country constituting a waterway of total length around 24,140 km. Following is a list of some of the major rivers of Bangladesh. • Brahmaputra River • Buriganga River • Karnaphuli River • Meghna River • Padma River • Jamuna River • Turag River • Role of the rivers Rivers are the most important geographical features in Bangladesh, and it is the rivers that created the vast alluvial delta....

Words: 835 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

History of Sierra Leone

...Of the numerous short rivers that drain the country the most important are the Kolenté (Great Scarcies) and the Kaba (Little Scarcies), and the Rokel, Jong, Sewa, and Moa. Most are navigable only in the rainy season. A Climate facts and figures facts and figures Sierra Leone (country) Sierra Leone has a tropical climate; the mean temperature in Freetown is about 27°C (about 80°F) in January and 26°C (78°F) in July. Annual rainfall averages more than 3,800 mm (150 in) along the coast, diminishing to about 2,000 mm (about 80 in) in the northern interior. Most rain falls from May to October. B Mineral Resources Much of Sierra...

Words: 411 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

An Analysis of the Pile-Dwellings in the Hemudu Site

...An Analysis of the Pile-Dwellings in the Hemudu Site: The Natural Reasons of the Appearance and the Classification of the Pile-Dwellings in the Hemudu Site Abstract The pile-dwelling is a special architectural type, mainly popular in Yangtze River valley and the southern area in ancient China. It has been widely considered as the direct development of nest. The origin of this architectural style, in China, might be traced to the Neolithic Age. It can be found in amount of Neolithic sites of the Hemudu culture and the Liangzhu culture, together with other Neolithic sites located in the southwestern part of China, for instant, the Yun Menkou site (Mount Jian, Yunan province). Based on the report on the excavation, in this article, we discussed the natural causes of the appearance and the classification of the pile-dwellings in the Hemudu site. Keywords China; the Hemudu Site; pile-dwelling; natural environment; timberwork building Introduction The Hemudu site lays in the alluvial plain named Yu (Yuyao) --- Ci (Cicheng) which is located in the northern piedmont of Siming Mountain and surrounded by the Ningshao Plain together with the southern part of the hilly-country of Cixi. The ancestors in this area constructed their village directly on the cyan clay-like loam stratum (formed with marine deposit). As the village is located in the transition zone which lies between plains and hills, its terrain is geographically high in the south but low in the north....

Words: 2143 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay


...The short story brings us through a dangerous situation about a father and son trying to cross a wild river. It is a great trip for a father to spend some quality time with his son out in the wild nature and to bond with each other. It is very typical for an American family, to have such values about a “father and son relationship”. The father in this story takes his son to a place where he went with his own father, when he was young. This brings me to the theme of the story, which could be “disappointment” or “failure”. It is mentioned that the father has done a lot of “fuckups” and he does not want this experience with his son to become one of those fuckups. At the beginning of the short story we are introduced to the father, and the difficult period of his life that he is in. The father reminds himself of his own childhood, when he was seventeen years old and went with his father on a trip into the wild. He gets very disappointed when he returns with his son and realizes that the barn and all the other things in the forest are barely recognizable. He might have had a bad relationship with his own father and does not want the same relationship with his own son. He also remembers some of the bad things about his own father, especially the way he spoke to him as a child, when the father yelled “Don’t fucking fall” (p.2, l. 63). The father could also be divorced from the mother of his son, where he is looking at “..the azaleas he’d planted..”...

Words: 735 - Pages: 3