Free Essay

Open Source vs Closed Source

In: Computers and Technology

Submitted By p00lg33k
Words 668
Pages 3
vs

Open Source versus Closed Source

Open Source versus Closed Source

There are basically two types of operating systems when it comes to how the code is handled. These are open source operating systems and closed source operating systems. One isn’t necessarily better than the other, but they both have situations and areas that they work best in. Open source isn’t for everyone, and neither is closed source. It’s always better to have both sides available so there is some variety.
Open source and closed source operating systems have are completely different, almost like night and day. Closed source operating systems like Microsoft Windows, for example, are developed by an individual or a company. The final product is available to run on a system, however all the source code, the recipe for the operating system, is kept secret and no one except the developers have access to it.
The closed source operating system is exactly the opposite, because the source code is made readily available to the user, and if they have programming knowledge, they can debug it and tweak it into their own style. Basically they can personalize it to fit what suits them and their needs.
Closed source operating systems, such as Windows can definitely meet the needs in a market. Because people pay for closed source operating systems, they can be guaranteed to get documentation and support for the software. One bad thing about closed source software is that developers often rush it out the door before it is ready. This makes the software vulnerable, and the developers have to make patches when these flaws occur.
If the user doesn’t install these patches, they could open their system up to all sort of problems. Another problem with closed source operating systems is the security. Take Microsoft Outlook for example. When you receive a message, there is a previewer that automatically starts investigating what’s in the attachment. Therefore, if there’s anything malicious attached, you’re infected.
Open source operating systems are quite the opposite. They are created for use by the ones who want to use them. The source code of open source operating systems, as the name implies, is open and made readily available to users. This allows them to debug the source code to fit whatever needs they may have that are specific to them. Also, flaws in the source code of an open source operating system are often resolved quickly and cleanly. This happens because of the availability of the code to every user.
There is no specific individual or company that makes open source operating systems, such as Linux. The bad part about this is that there is no documentation or support if a user occurs some sort of a system malfunction. Most of the time, there aren’t many situations that come across open source operating systems that can’t be resolved.
One reason for this is that open source software is much more secure than closed source software. Unlike Outlook, when you receive an email in Linux, you don’t have a preview function. You are forced to save the attachment to disk, mark it as executable, and run it. In open source software, security takes precedence over convenience.
The bottom line is that neither open source operating systems nor closed source operating systems are perfect. As I mentioned before, people have different wants and needs, as well as different skills and abilities. This is why one operating system isn’t for everyone. If you’re a beginner with computers, I would opt for closed source. However if you are proficient in programming, then delve into the world of open source and personalize your own version. Either way, you will find something great about both as well as things you wish could be better.

References
Basha, A. (09/2001). Open-Source Systems vs Closed-Source Systems. Retrieved from http://http://www.enderunix.org/docs/opensource_vs_closedsource.html

Grant, A. (01/2004). Open vs Closed Source Software. Retrieved from http://http://www.scienceinafrica.co.za/2004/january/software.htm

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Closed-Source vs. Open-Source Databases

...system to choose: closed-source or open-source. Each option has its advantages and disadvantages, and mainly depends on the organization itself; where one will benefit, the other will face some difficulties. For example, open-source software is usually is more flexible, but it sometimes requires some extra work or knowledge from the user to customize the database. The main reason why I would prefer using open-source database, is that in closed-database systems it is not possible to see the source code. It means that the user cannot detect bugs and other system vulnerabilities. The crucial factor in favor of the open-based system is the question of the price, as open-source database systems are free. Open-source database systems, such as MySQL, are great for users, who agree to tolerate some minor limitation (which sometimes do not matter for a particular company) in preference to simple and fast performance. Many organizations remain cautious about using new open-source software. For these companies, they might use systematic software implementation; for instance, start using open-source databases like PostgreSQL or MySQL, after they have successfully tested Linux or Open Office (Amant & Still, p. 259). Moving in that direction will lead to a formation of a strategy, which I would suggest using - the hybrid strategy. In order to use any benefits of open-source database systems and to lower the risk, this strategy suits perfectly. With the help of the open source concept, it emphasizes...

Words: 345 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Embeded Software

...Open Source vs. Closed Source Open source and Closed source, two topics that have become quite the buzz in the world Information Technology (IT). Chances are, if you work in IT, you will eventually be faced with having to decide on witch of these technologies you will have to go with when planning for an upgrade or new IT system implementation. Before choosing which technology to go with we as IT professionals must first understand the difference between the two as well as carefully weight the benefits and disadvantages of each solution. An Open Source Operating system refers to software whose source code, the medium in which programmers create and modify software, is freely available on the Internet; whereas, by contrast the closed source code for proprietary commercial software is usually a closely guarded secret and is not available to the public. (Crooke, 2012) Notable open source operating systems include Android and Linux. Notable Closed source OS include Apple iOS. The two major benefit of using an Open source software is that the software is distributed under a variety of licensing terms, but almost all have two things in common: the software can be used without paying a license fee, and anyone can modify the software to add capabilities not envisaged by its originators. (Crooke, 2012) These benefit help to lower cost of products as well as offer customers the ability to customize platforms as needed to meeting business needs. The disadvantage that is associated...

Words: 803 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

World War 2

...Closed Source Vs Open Source Pao Yang POS/335 03/06/2013 Mr. STERNIERI Closed Source Vs Open Source In the world of operating system we have two options to choose from these is Unix/Linux which is an open source, meaning that its source code made available and licensed with an open source license in which the copyright holder provides the rights to study change and distribute the software to anyone and for any purpose. The other option is the closed source such as Microsoft’s Window which is software released or distributed without the corresponding source code. Generally, it means only the binaries of a computer program are distributed and the license provides no access to the program's source code. The source code of such programs might be regarded as a trade secret of the company. Access to source code by third parties commonly requires the party to sign a non-disclosure agreement. I also will like to discuss what source codes are and why having the right combination will give us free bees. What some of the major differences between an open source and a closed source? I see it all over the internet the heated debate of which is better open source or closed source and even though both sides have good supporting evidence to back up their claim about every from which is more secured to who has the better functional software. The argument of Windows vs. Linux is a greatly debated one, and in recent years has become quite heated. Because Microsoft's attempt to recover...

Words: 1283 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Open/Closed Source Operating Systems

...Open/closed source operating systems Scott Delaney POS/355 Introduction to Operational Systems June 8, 2014 Jeff Rugg Open/closed source operating systems There is often confusion over what is and what is not an open source operating system is. For example most people believe that if the operating system is free it is open source. Open source does not refer to whether the program is free or not, but the source code of the operating system being open to the public to change and improve upon (D'Amico, 2009). Traditionally open source operating systems are free of charge. A good example of a true open source operation system is ReactOS. This operating system was and is currently developed by a community of developers. ReactOS is unlike most open source operating system and is not Linux based (ReactOS, 2014). This operating system has been written from scratch with the same design principles as Windows NT architecture. The best part of ReactOS is that the drivers and applications that run on Windows can be run on this operating system without any change. This ability can allow the operating system to run on networks that are Windows based. The polar opposite of open source is closed source operating systems an example of this is HP-UX. This is an operating system created by Hewlett-Packard and is UNIX based. HP-UX is based on a traditional open source code but because it is not open to development by a community and is proprietary operating system for Hewlett-Packard...

Words: 591 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Comparison of Opensource Os and Closed Source Os

...Comparison of open source OS and closed source OS Ted Wallick University of Phoenix The definition of closed source Operating System(OS), is any OS made but it's code and functionality is private to the vendor that made it. The end user can neither look at it's core/kernel or change it in any way. If an end user needs a change made, a change request has to be sent to the vendor to get adjustments made. This is how most commercial software is developed. Microsoft Windows OS (PC and mobile), Apple OS X, IOS, and UNIX, are primary examples of closed OS. Closed OS has some Pros and Cons. Pros: * Vendors have complete control over hardware and functionality. * The vendor gets to set some standards with how software and hardware are developed to work with the OS. * Vendor controls Versions and updates * Vendor controls any security issues (personally I would not want this hot potato) * Vendor has some control over what 3rd party developers make * Easier for the OS vendor and 3rd party developers to make money. Cons: * Response to system exploits (things that allow hackers to do whatever) is slower than open source OS due to a limited amount of code monkeys that have intimate knowledge and access to the OS code base * Closed OSs cost end users money hand over fist. Major upgrades will cost money. Most 3rd party software will cost large amounts of money. This is only fair to the people that put great time, effort and money to develop the tools...

Words: 976 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Open and Closed Source

...Open and Closed Source Systems Students Name POS/355 Date Instructors Name Open and Closed Source Systems Open and closed sources is a term that not many people know the difference. According to Damicon (2003-2009), “True-open-source development requires that a community of software engineers band together to work on the software.” What the company is stating is the more minds are used to develop the software the better it will be. Now a closed source is a little different. “Closed-source programs are owned by someone (or some organization) and distributed through a variety of retail channels including the owner's website Damicon (2003-2009).” Basically a closed source is the complete opposite of an open source. Now that the two are clearly defined to a better understanding users will be able to tell the difference. Open sources are gathering of many users and putting the knowledge and experiences that they have obtained over the years and used to make software. Like the saying goes, “Two heads are better than one (Two heads better than one 2014).” Typically open sources are free of charge and can easily be download. For example most people have at least either downloaded one of these browsers; Goggle Chrome, Firefox, Java, or BitTorrent. There are many more open source systems, but these that were just mention can be installed in MAC OS, Microsoft Windows, and LINUX. The positive about having open source is that it is able to be customized to the users liking and can...

Words: 770 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Pos/355 Operating Systems Paper Week 3

...be categorized either as an open source operating system or a closed operating system on the basis of the source code availability for alteration and modification. An operating system that copies the source code into the system when operating installed whereas a closed operating system does not allow viewing, modifying, or updating the source, it only installs the executable files when this operating system is installed into any of the operating systems. Examples of open source operating systems are Linux, UNIX etc., and closed operating systems examples are Microsoft Windows, Mac OS X etc. Open source and closed source operating systems comparison Open-source operating will allow access to the source code by the users and programmers to make alterations. As source code is available in the public he person who has programming skills can read the source code and modify the code or here she can add some advanced functions in the existing operating system which can debug the code. In most cases new versions of the open source operating systems are introduced by the Open Source community programmers that debug the product for a special reason and make your own personalized version of the product. Possibilities in the personalize open-source product are limitless. As open-source product is debugged by numerous users worldwide, so open-source operating systems will be bug free. In case of the closed operating system, source is not revealed in the public...

Words: 883 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Open Closed Source Os

...Open Source and Closed Source Operating Systems POS/355 Jim W November 3, 2013 History repeats once again and proves that the saying, (two heads are better than one) continues to be true! The movement for the collaboration of the thinkers, inventors, and creators; to come together and share ideas and concepts that advance the development of mature and immature open source code is here to stay. The original hackers from the 1950’s (computer enthusiasts’) at MIT’s Tech Railroad Club left their programs in drawers for others to work on. This concept of sharing and developing source code for a wide range of functionality continues to enable programmers and students to use source code as a learning tool that sparks worldwide innovation! Open Source operating systems are usually free OS’s that can be manipulated via the source code format rather than the compiled binary code format, which is only available by closed source code. There are quite a few different open source code providers with the three most popular being GNU/Linux, BSD UNIX, and Solaris. Not only did the GNU/Linux open source operating system serve the standard OS features and function, it also produced many UNIX-compatible tools, including utilities, compilers and editors, but never released a kernel. The advantage of collaboration of the open source OS, Linus Torvalds, a student from Finland released a rudimentary UNIX-like kernel using the GNU compilers and tools and invented contributions worldwide. This...

Words: 716 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Week3Pos355

... | |Date: |11/11813 | |Re: |Individual Assignment for Week 3 | Today we need to discuss the difference between open source and closed source operating systems. When it comes down to the difference between the two we are going to look at difference with Android and iPhone. These two offer great insight and benefits with going one route vs. the other. • Android When it comes to open source the first thing that comes to my mind is Android. Android is an operating system that is an open source format and the benefits that it provides to its customer base is larger developer support, customizable, more secure, and extended community support. It has more developer support because anyone can develop for the platform; it is customizable because the developer can only change what the original developer chooses. It has the ability to be more securing because it is more transparent than closed source. This allows more people to look over the code to find any bugs and vulnerabilities are spotted much quicker and can be fixed. The community provides the extended support because the original developer might move on and stop developing the product and now the community can take over and extend the usable life. • iPhone Then when...

Words: 440 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Rock Bottom Records Proposal

...reducing the amount of time it takes for analyzing productivity, ordering and shipping, financial, and payroll. Adding a website with a RDMS and offering digital music downloads the company will be able to compete with other companies worldwide. The most popular affordable RDMS’s that are in use today are Microsoft Access that comes with Microsoft Office (Professional) is popular with most small businesses ("Microsoft Access Database: The Pros With Less Cons When Using Microsoft Access As Your Database", n.d.)., PostgreSQL which runs on multiple operating systems and is an open source database, meaning it is free (“PostgreSQL”, 1996-2012)., MySQL is also an open source database that runs on multiple operating systems ("Advantages And Disadvantages To Using Mysql Vs Ms Sql", n.d.)., MSSQL is a closed, propriety database that works great with Microsoft programs ("Advantages And Disadvantages To Using Mysql Vs Ms Sql", n.d.)., and Fire Bird which works well with Window and is also...

Words: 1026 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Asdasf

...English 101 Prep Quiz #3 Genre Open-Form Prose Open-form prose resists reduction to a single, summarizable thesis. It is characterized by narrative or story-like structure, sometimes with abrupt transitions, and uses various literary techniques to make the prose more memorable and powerful. * Often organized chronologically or has a story like element * Often used to heighten or deepen a problem, or show human significance * Often has an implicit theme rather than a thesis. * Often violates rules of closed-form prose by using literary techniques Closed-form Prose Closed-form prose can be defined as writing with a hierarchical structure of points and details in support of an explicit thesis. It is characterized by unified and coherent paragraphs, topic sentences, transitions between sentences and paragraphs, and forecasting of the whole before presentation of the parts. * Thesis explicitly stated in introduction * All parts of essay linked clearly to thesis * Body paragraphs develop thesis * Body paragraphs have topic sentences * Structure forecasted Autobiographical Narrative Autobiographical narrative writing can help us explore, deepen, and complicate our perceptions of the world. This narrative is any significant even or moment in your life. * Focus on rhetorical aim “writing to express or share.” * Autobiographical narrative something significant in your life Literacy Narrative This narrative is centered on...

Words: 862 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Social Distribution of Religious Participation

...Social distribution of religious participation Many feminist sociologists argue that religious institutions and beliefs help legitimise gender inequality. Like Marxists, feminists argue that religion is a source of domination and oppression. However, unlike Marxism, they see religion as a product of patriarchy, rather than capitalism. They argue that religion is patriarchal in that women are exploited by men and seen as subordinate. Feminist sociologists are interested in how women have become subservient and how religion has promoted patriarchy. This view is not just shared by female and feminist sociologists. Anthony Giddens argues that; "The Christian religion is a resolutely male affair in its symbolism as well as its hierarchy. While Mary, the mother of Jesus may sometimes be treated as if she had divine qualities, God is the father, a male figure, and Jesus took the human shape of a man. Woman is portrayed Gender is a major part of religion, and it is believed that women are more religious than men. Religious participation is also a big part of religion along with religious organisations. A number of studies have proven different views on the relationship between gender, religious participation and religious organisations. There are a number of religious organisations including; churches, sects, denominations and cults. A number of studies have some that women are more religious then men. Whatever women's influence and status may have been in religious organizations...

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Os Comparision

...The Economics of Open Source Software Development Jiirgen Bitzer and Philipp J. H. Srhroder (Editurs) O 2006 Published by Elsevier B.V. Linux vs. Windows: A Comparison of Application and Platform Innovation Incentives for Open Source and Proprietary Software Platforms Nicholas Economides and Evangelos Katsamakas ABSTRACT The chapter analyzes and compares the investment incentives of platform and application developers for Linux and Windows. We find that the level of investment in applications is larger when the operating system is open source rather than proprietary. The comparison of the levels of investment in the operating systems depends, among others, on reputation effects and the number of developers. The chapter also develops a short case study comparing Windows and Linux and identifies new directions for open source software research. Keywords: Open Source Software, operating systems, technology platforms, Linux, innovation incentives. JEL Classification: L 10, L86, L3 1. 10.1 INTRODUCTION Open source software is an emerging type of software that may fundamentally affect the business and economic features of the software industry. Linux, an open source operating system, has been the prominent example of the potential of the open source movement, competing against Microsoft Windows, the incumbent operating system. 208 Nicholas Economides and Evangelos Katsamkas This chapter analyzes the incentives to invest in application software and an operating...

Words: 4770 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Nt1310 Unit 6 Case Study

...cannot control the congestion. Agree or disagree? Elaborate briefly (60-100 words) I agree with the above statement because in the end it is the physical properties of the the medium on which you are transmitting that ultimately decides how much total traffic , congested or not. Therefore a router could have infinite memory, but its memory would have more congestion control capacity then the physical medium would allow to put through the medium. So for this reason I Agree with the above statement. 2. Compare the following: Flow Control vs Congestion Control Flow control is based from the receiving side. It makes sure that the sender only sends what it can handle (R1) Congestion Control is making...

Words: 893 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Management

...|[pic] |Syllabus | | |College of Information Systems & Technology | | |POS/355 Version 9 | | |MU12BIT08 | | |Introduction to Operational Systems | | |Wk 1 June 10 | | |Wk 2 June 17 | | |Wk 3 June 24 | | |Wk 4 July 01 | | |Wk 5 July 08 ...

Words: 2247 - Pages: 9