Premium Essay

Perception / Attribution

In: Business and Management

Submitted By dreadsgirlem
Words 347
Pages 2
Article 1 - Perception/Attribution: Narcissists Look Like Good Leaders. But Are They? (Jones, 2011)
In this article, the author discusses a study done on "narcissistic" leaders within small groups. A selection process (for a job candidate) was carried out in groups of 3, and one of the 3 members is selected as the leader. At the end of the selection process, the narcissistic tendencies of the leader are evaluated, to see how much it affects the results.
Strangely enough, it was discovered that the leaders who were the most narcissistic were the ones voted most successful by their teammates. Not only that, but it was noted that the ones with the most narcissistic leaders made the worst decisions (with regards to the groups' selection task).
I believe that this experiment reinforces the fact that people's perceptions of other people are very powerful. If a person can project a very confident image (as is often the case with narcissists), people will attribute many other qualities to them as well, even though the person themselves does not possess these qualities. In this case, we could say the "halo effect" is in play here - "our evaluation of others is dominated by only one of their traits" (Osland et al, 2009, p. 224). In this case - their own self-belief/self-confidence causes team members to bestow them with all the other qualities that a good leader possesses. Another perceptual distortion that could also be in effect here is that of the perceptual defense (Osland et al, 2009, p. 225) - namely "defenses acting as a screen or filter, blocking out that which we do not want to see and letting through that which we wish to see". In this case, again, the narcissistic leader's self-confidence blinded the team members to his or her other flaws.
I thought this article interesting, yet another illustration of the adage "Clothes make the man" -…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Perception and Attribution Theory

...Perception and Attribution Theory Understanding how people form perceptions and attributions is a necessary skill in order to succeed in communications and long lasting business relationships. In the study of social psychology person perception is defined as the process in which humans form impressions of one another which encompasses the perceptions and judgments people develop every day. A new acquaintance is encountered everyday especially when one works in the business arena and impressions are created due the persons attire, language, body language, and especially how well they communicate. Based on all these characterisis conclusions are drawn even tough not much is known about the other. Learning how people can form perceptions of one another can prevent a business professional from having their customers from forming negative impressions which may jepordize future relationships or even prevent a business transaction from occurring. Attributions the keys in understanding how an individual perceives the cause of events and behaviors of others. A persons actions are questioned at times and often times explications are necessary. Negative events and behaviors are associated with negative perceptions of an individual. For example when a person answers his cellphone during a meeting with an important client he is automatically perceived as a person who is irresponsible and disrespectful, even though his close friends and coworkers see otherwise. People often try to......

Words: 474 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Perception

...Social Learning Theory and Perception NAME Strayer University Online Business 520 Dr. Irene Zoppi 4 November 2012 Social Learning Theory and Perception Case Study Discuss how Joe could address the importance of understanding how people form perceptions and make attributions about others with his employees. Joe Salantino, as the President of the Great Northern American, has the charge of creating a successful sales force. A successful element in creating this successful sales force is the understanding of the perception of the sales team. According to Hellriegel & Slocum, perception “is the declaration of the way individuals sift, arrange, and interpret sensory information”. (Hellriegel & Slocum, 2011). It is Joe’s responsibility constantly assess the team develop a model and atmosphere that reflects his idea of type of people he envisions for his sales team. Also, this would include the development of a model for his sales team to use to screen customers and create a repeat customer base, which according to the case study, he believes is critical to become a top performer. Joe’s model should consider various internal and external factors that coincide with the vision that he believes makes up a successful sales force. The internal factors include learning, personality and motivation while the external ones consist of size, contrast, repetition, and intensity. These factors must be conveyed to the......

Words: 1411 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Perception

...Perception affects communication because people perceive things that are being said how they want to perceive it. One person can take things being said in a different way than how someone else takes it. If things are taken the wrong way, communication can get angry or hurtful. According to Robbins, perception can be defined as ‘a process by which individuals organise and interpret their sensory impressions in order to give meaning to their environment’ (2004, p. 132). Perception is not necessarily based on reality, but is merely a perspective from a particular individual’s view of a situation. In dealing with the concept of organisational behaviour, perception becomes important because ‘people’s behaviour is based on their perception of what reality is, not on reality itself; the world as it is perceived is the world that is behaviourally important’ (Robbins et al 2004, p.132). Perception affects our working relationships in many ways relating to the factors of organisational behaviour, such as: individual, group or structure. For example, based on the situation, perceiver and target we may have the perception that the people we are working with are no good at their job, and therefore we may tend to avoid working with them, in fear of being held responsible for their mistakes, and in doing so, affecting our working relationship with our team members, and ultimately, the effectiveness and efficiency of the organisation. Alternatively, it may affect the group within the......

Words: 705 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Perception

...developed a perception of her new boss is that he might be sexist. She feels that he might be overlooking more qualified female instructors for men. Perception is a process by which individuals organize and interpret their sensory impressions in order to give meaning to their environment. (Robbins & Judge, 2013) I will be discussing Miranda’s perception of her boss and the factors that have influenced her judgment. I will talk about the way she sees her boss Hank and if there might be any errors in her judgment. Finally I will discuss what I believe this young ski instructor should do. Miranda’s perception of the situation is that her boss Hank does not treat the men and women fairly at the ski resort. Miranda might be correct as all the men instructors were assigned to adults while the women taught all the children The men instructor’s would report to Hank and the women to Hank’s Japanese wife Harika, 10 years his junior, and unable to speak English with confidence. (Cohen, Fink, Gadon, Wilits,, & Josefowitz, 2013) The only supervisor’s for the ski lodge would be men and all assignments would be handled through the front desk and that no instructors were to schedule own classes. The changing room for the instructors’ turned into a men’s locker room where inappropriate conversation became the norm and included Hank, Miranda’s boss. Hank had even begun to comment on how Miranda looked. A number of factors operate to shape and sometimes distort perception. These......

Words: 1257 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Perception

...Running head: ARGUMENT AND COLLABORATION Perception elskandisa University of Phoenix Perception Perception is how a person makes sense of the world around them. Individuals use stimulation and senses to make judgments about people, places and things. Each person has a different perspective of certain stimulation which gives them a sense of his/her surroundings. This explains how two individuals can witness an event, yet perceive the same event in different ways. Individuals are constantly being bombarded by stimulation of his/her environment that affects his/her physical senses. Because each individual has a filter that was shaped by his/her childhood and life experiences, they may only focus on things that are familiar, blocking out important information that would allow them to make informed decisions. Individuals perceive stimulation he/she are used to, which satisfies basic needs such as emotions, attitudes and self awareness. An individual’s perception may be flawed if they misinterpret the event, leading to perceptual errors. Each individual selectively picks up on cues that influence his/her perception of the event. Often individuals interpret or project the behavior of others, thus possibly seeing themselves in the role of the person being judged. It is often said that perception is reality. What a manager or co-worker sees or perceives to be reality is very real to him/her. Thus this can cause perceptual processes to determine......

Words: 982 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Attribution Theories

...Application of Theories Vignette #2 Social Cognition – Psych 6201-2 December 28, 2013 The two attributions theories I have chosen for this paper are Heider’s “Naive Psychology Theory” And Kelley’s “Covariation Model.” The vignette I chosen is number two, James, 35-year-old African-American male. Heider’s Attribution Theory: The Naive Psychology of Traits. Heider founded the study of how ordinary people think about each other. In 1958 Heider contributed to two central ideas in which the idea of studying how regular people make sense of each other. The first study is how people think about other people which can keep these two meaningful data for scientific analysis. We shall make use of the unformulated or half –formulated knowledge of interpersonal relations as it is expressed in our everyday language and experience -- this source shall be referred to as common -sense or naïve psychology (Heider). Heider made a suggestion that we should listen to what people say about how they think about other people during gathering, peoples every day theories. In order to be able to do that one must talk to ordinary people which are a good source of information. Heider had a very great deal of respect for ordinary people, even to the fact that Heider invented the term naïve psychology. Heider’s second major proposal argued that psychologists have to customize every data from people’s everyday experience, making them more precise, coherent, and scientific (Fiske, 2012).......

Words: 882 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Attribution Theory

...ATTRIBUTION THEORY (Attribution - to explain by indicating a cause) ATTRIBUTION THEORY - motivational theory looking at how the average person constructs the meaning of an event based on his /her motives to find a cause and his/her knowledge of the environment. Att. Theory basically looks at how people make sense of their world; what cause and effect inferences they make about the behaviors of others and of themselves. Heider states that there is a strong need in individuals to understand transient events by attributing them to the actor's disposition or to stable characteristics of the environment. The purpose behind making attributions is to achieve COGNITIVE CONTROL over one's environment by explaining and understanding the causes behind behaviors and environmental occurrences. Making attributions gives order and predictability to our lives; helps us to cope. Imagine what it would be like if you felt that you had no control over the world. (talk about later) When you make attributions you analyze the situation by making inferences (going beyond the information given) about the dispositions of others and yourself as well as inferences about the environment and how it may be causing a person to behave. Two basic kinds of attributions made: INTERNAL and EXTERNAL INTERNAL - dispositional EXTERNAL - situational Consequences of making inferences: 1) gives order and predictability; 2) inferences lead to behavior - you......

Words: 2096 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Fundamental Attribution

...Activity 5.1: Overcoming the Fundamental Attribution Error 1. What is the fundamental attribution error? Our human tendency to assume that other people’s behavior is due to something about their personality, while at the same time failing to consider possible situational influence. 2. Describe a situation from your own life when you made an internal attribution about someone’s behavior, potentially committing the fundamental attribution error. There are times when I make internal attributions about people, especially if I see them yelling at their children or other people. I often catch myself speaking loudly when I am upset, It is something I am aware that I do, so I try to prevent myself from doing it especially sense I think so un-highly of those that do yell. 3. What internal attribution did you make in that situation? My internal attribution to a parent yelling at a child is that they are a bad parent and can’t control their anger. 4. What three questions would you have to ask yourself to see if your internal attribution was correct? The three questions that I would have to ask myself to see if my internal attribution was correct would be; consistency, distinctiveness and consensus. Consistency is whether a particular behavior typically occurs in that situation. Distinctiveness is whether a particular behavior typically occurs in other situations. Consensus is whether other people typically exhibit this behavior in this situation. 5. To the best of...

Words: 523 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Perception

...(12 marks). b) Assess the way in which such studies help to explain the development of perception (12 marks). In the following essay I intend to describe two studies of perceptual development. I then intend to assess such studies and how they help to explain the development of perception. By perceptual development, I mean how animals and humans alike develop their seeing capabilities. This development of perception could be learnt or innate. By innate, I mean to be born with the ability. a) Gibson and Walk conducted a study in 1960. The study was investigating Depth Perception. The study involved a 6-month-old child, 24-hour-old chicks, kids and lambs. Gibson and Walk used a 'Visual Cliff' to conduct the study. The 'Visual Cliff' was comprised of 2 floors. On one side there was a check-board pattern, on the other side there is glass floor. Below the glass floor there was another floor with check-board pattern. This was placed so that an illusion of a cliff and depth was created. At first the child was placed and was found to be reluctant to go onto the glass. The child's reluctance could be seen as even with encouragement from the child's mother, the child refused to go onto the glass. The study was continued on chicks, kids and lambs. All subjects studied refused to go onto the glass. Held and Hein conducted a study in 1965. The study was investigating Depth Perception. The study involved two kittens. The kittens were kept in the dark for a period......

Words: 370 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Perception

...Perception 1. Describe Jim’s self-concept. Jim is using a personal construct, or mental yardstick, to measure his intelligence and responsibility when he is discussing how he is performing in school (Wood, 2012). He compares himself to his father by claiming his father is brilliant and did not have any trouble in school versus himself who is struggling to pull C’s. Jim feels that no matter how hard he tries he will never be an A student because he is using a self-servicing bias that college is more difficult than when his father went to college and he has no control of the difficulty (Wood, 2012). Jim is attributing his grades to external forces, such as more difficult material, and believes that no matter how much studying he will not receive better grades. 2. Explain, using examples from the video and course concepts, how Jim’s self-concept impacted his interaction with his father. Was it positive or negative? Jim’s self-concept had a negative impact on his interaction with his father. Jim states that he does not know how to convince his parents that he is doing everything that he can do. Wood (2012) explains that perceiving another person as domineering can create a feeling of insecurity in ability to communicate. Jim could attribute his parent’s concern that he is spending too much time with friends and not enough time studying as domineering and may not feel comfortable explaining that he is doing the best that he can. Jim is using self-servicing bias in his......

Words: 1199 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Attribution Theory

...Attribution Theory The attribution theory focuses on how individuals perceive and interpret events and how they relate these events to their thinking and behavior. There are two different types of attributions: dispositional and situational. Dispositional attributions are those that play off of internal motives. They are driven by the emotions of the person. Situational attributions are those that play off of external motives, or those that can be attributed to environmental factors (Myers, 2010). Self-serving biases also play a part in the attribution theory. Most successes are attributed to the internal, dispositional nature of people while failures are attributed to the external, environmental factors. Individuals are faced with decisions that need to be made every day. In the above scenario, the woman is faced with whether or not to cheat on her husband. This woman more than likely desires an emotional connection or validation from another person, suggesting that she is not emotionally satisfied in her relationship with her husband. While she may have moral guidelines that tell her not to, there are many factors that are possible that may have attributed toward her decision making. Using the attribution theory, the factors can be divided into dispositional and situational categories. The dispositional attributes that possibly had an effect on her choice to cheat on her husband are: She feels neglected in her marriage. She may have a lack of respect for her......

Words: 439 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Attribution

...The Chicago School of Professional Psychology Attribution EIO 604 Original research refers to material that is not attributable to another reliable published source which otherwise and in most cases, appropriate attribution can be provided by simply citing the original article. Thus the proper method of demonstrating that material is not original is to cite the source which provided the information directly related to the research. The sources include the collection, analysis, and integration of ideas that advance the work and all opinions, positions, and arguments. In addition, the source should include the people who are contributing to the work. In the provided example, Susan has prepared a manuscript based on the results of the research she completed. This research sought to discern the physical affects of light infractions in the workplace. In order to complete the research, Susan obtained assistance from people who can be regarded as reliable, trustworthy, and authoritative with respect to the topic and need at hand. Because the individuals were engaged in providing Susan with data, material, information, and advice they should be regarded as primary sources in her manuscript. The specific role that each individual played was critical to the development and progression of Susan’s research. The psychologist provided information; the electrician was the subject matter expert and author due to his knowledge of electricity and contribution to the methods section.......

Words: 549 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Optimistic / Pessimistic Attribution Theory

...Final Project Optimistic / Pessimistic Attribution Theory Introduction There are many theories in the field of social psychology that can be used to explain, predict, or forecast behavior. As events occur throughout history, patterns can be analyzed and attributed to known theories that were birthed by educated scholars in this field. However, no theory s absolute in its outcome. As society changes, the applicability of each theory also changes. “Social Darwinism” was coined by Richard Hofstadter to label theories created around 1870 and primarily addresses survival and creation, as it was known in that era (Leonard, 2009). It is well known that Charles Darwin theorized that only the fittest members of society would ultimately survive. Modern science and technology has expanded to depths far beyond that of the 1800s. Research and real-time information has provided an outlet which allows scholars access to information that was not available during this period. The result of this influx of data allows current day researchers – and students – the ability to expound and expand older theories to fit modern culture. Whereas Darwin’s theory may have specifically defines mortality and the ability to thrive as it pertains to life and death, survival of the fittest can now be applied to a plethora of modern day situations, such as the stock market (only those who are savvy in the art of trading will be successful), technology (on the......

Words: 2859 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Perceptions and Attributions

...Perceptions and Attributions Please respond to the following: • Analyze the way you perceive your coworkers or classmates and the perceptual or attribution errors you are likely to make, and discuss what steps you could take to address those errors. Provide specific examples to support your response. Being in accounting and based on my years of experience, I have developed my own style of working and require things to be done in a certain way. But when I saw that they are not getting done in the way that I want them to, I would get annoyed and uneasy even when people around me were doing things in a more efficient way than I was used to doing. I always believed that I was a perfectionist and expected people to be at par with me when they worked with me. I always had bias over people who had similar traits like mine, though they might not have been the brightest among the pack (similarity error). But with time and education, I have realized that many things have changed with time and I have to adapt to the new ways of doing things even if it meant that I had to put in a lot of effort to learn these new skills. I now have a different view when I see and work with people around me and try to acknowledge good and efficient work when I see one. When I interviewed and selected people to work in my organization, during orientation of the employees, I would give examples of people whose work I had liked and would make recommendations to the new employees to follow in their......

Words: 775 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Attribution Theory

...Topic: Attribution theory. I chose this topic because it interests me a lot. I have always had many difficulties when giving feedback to my students, writing reports is the most difficult thing for me to do. I never find the appropriate words, I don´t know how to motivate my students and how to tell them to improve without hurting their feelings. In unit 2 we talked about different topics but this is the one that called my attention. I would like first to summarize what this theory is about. It is widely know that people perceive events in different ways, not only at school but in their everyday lives, when something bad happens to us we generally blame someone or something else for the outcomes but when we do something right or something good happens to us we usually say it is because we for example put a lot of effort in the task, because we are lucky and so on. But, to what do we attribute our failures and success? Many theorists state that we attribute them to four factors, effort, ability, luck and task difficulty. The former factors are said to be internal and the latter external. On the other hand we can categorize them according to stability, in that case effort and luck are unstable and ability and task difficulty are stable. But what does internal, external, stable and stable mean? Internal means from within a person, external the opposite. Stable means that we can control it and unstable means the opposite. For example, a student is sad because he failed in......

Words: 820 - Pages: 4