Premium Essay

Perception / Attribution

In: Business and Management

Submitted By dreadsgirlem
Words 347
Pages 2
Article 1 - Perception/Attribution: Narcissists Look Like Good Leaders. But Are They? (Jones, 2011)
In this article, the author discusses a study done on "narcissistic" leaders within small groups. A selection process (for a job candidate) was carried out in groups of 3, and one of the 3 members is selected as the leader. At the end of the selection process, the narcissistic tendencies of the leader are evaluated, to see how much it affects the results.
Strangely enough, it was discovered that the leaders who were the most narcissistic were the ones voted most successful by their teammates. Not only that, but it was noted that the ones with the most narcissistic leaders made the worst decisions (with regards to the groups' selection task).
I believe that this experiment reinforces the fact that people's perceptions of other people are very powerful. If a person can project a very confident image (as is often the case with narcissists), people will attribute many other qualities to them as well, even though the person themselves does not possess these qualities. In this case, we could say the "halo effect" is in play here - "our evaluation of others is dominated by only one of their traits" (Osland et al, 2009, p. 224). In this case - their own self-belief/self-confidence causes team members to bestow them with all the other qualities that a good leader possesses. Another perceptual distortion that could also be in effect here is that of the perceptual defense (Osland et al, 2009, p. 225) - namely "defenses acting as a screen or filter, blocking out that which we do not want to see and letting through that which we wish to see". In this case, again, the narcissistic leader's self-confidence blinded the team members to his or her other flaws.
I thought this article interesting, yet another illustration of the adage "Clothes make the man" -...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Perceptions and Attributions

...Perceptions and Attributions Please respond to the following: • Analyze the way you perceive your coworkers or classmates and the perceptual or attribution errors you are likely to make, and discuss what steps you could take to address those errors. Provide specific examples to support your response. Being in accounting and based on my years of experience, I have developed my own style of working and require things to be done in a certain way. But when I saw that they are not getting done in the way that I want them to, I would get annoyed and uneasy even when people around me were doing things in a more efficient way than I was used to doing. I always believed that I was a perfectionist and expected people to be at par with me when they worked with me. I always had bias over people who had similar traits like mine, though they might not have been the brightest among the pack (similarity error). But with time and education, I have realized that many things have changed with time and I have to adapt to the new ways of doing things even if it meant that I had to put in a lot of effort to learn these new skills. I now have a different view when I see and work with people around me and try to acknowledge good and efficient work when I see one. When I interviewed and selected people to work in my organization, during orientation of the employees, I would give examples of people whose work I had liked and would make recommendations to the new employees to follow in their......

Words: 775 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Perception and Attribution Theory

...Perception and Attribution Theory Understanding how people form perceptions and attributions is a necessary skill in order to succeed in communications and long lasting business relationships. In the study of social psychology person perception is defined as the process in which humans form impressions of one another which encompasses the perceptions and judgments people develop every day. A new acquaintance is encountered everyday especially when one works in the business arena and impressions are created due the persons attire, language, body language, and especially how well they communicate. Based on all these characterisis conclusions are drawn even tough not much is known about the other. Learning how people can form perceptions of one another can prevent a business professional from having their customers from forming negative impressions which may jepordize future relationships or even prevent a business transaction from occurring. Attributions the keys in understanding how an individual perceives the cause of events and behaviors of others. A persons actions are questioned at times and often times explications are necessary. Negative events and behaviors are associated with negative perceptions of an individual. For example when a person answers his cellphone during a meeting with an important client he is automatically perceived as a person who is irresponsible and disrespectful, even though his close friends and coworkers see otherwise. People often try to......

Words: 474 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Social Psychology

...Review Author(s): Susan H. Gray Review by: Susan H. Gray Source: Teaching Sociology, Vol. 17, No. 3 (Jul., 1989), pp. 416-418 Published by: American Sociological Association Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1318129 Accessed: 09-09-2015 19:22 UTC Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/ info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. American Sociological Association is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Teaching Sociology. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 197.220.150.185 on Wed, 09 Sep 2015 19:22:08 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 416 TEACHING SOCIOLOGY place of a consultant.Yet if the user does not have the statistical language necessary to answer the questions Ex-Sample asks, the program cannot reduce itself to a lower level, as a consultantcan. I believe that this latter point is a serious one, especially in using the programwith undergraduate students. On the other hand, if students have a strong background in statistics and if the research or statisticsclass includes a lab, the......

Words: 2080 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Attrabution Theory

...Organizational Managers judge employees according to their own perceptions. Sometimes, the misunderstanding of the causes behind employees’ behaviour affects decision making and leads to incorrect judgments. Attribution theory illustrates the different causes of behaviour. Applying attribution theory in any work place reduces some passive managerial outcomes which could lead to high absences and turnover. Additionally, a good awareness of attribution theory helps in achieving goal oriented organizational behaviour such as increasing the levels of productivity and achieving appropriate perception, job satisfaction, motivation and organizational citizenship among employees. Through this essay an example of a salesperson who is recently shifted from the warehouse department to the sales department and fails in achieving his monthly target will be applied. Heider who was the founder of attribution theory concentrated on internal and external causes of behaviour (Martinko, Harvey & Douglas, 2007; Harvey & Martinko, 2009). Accordingly, the internal causes of the salesperson’s failure to achieve his monthly target could be his laziness, his absence or failure to target the right customers, while the external reasons behind failing could be national economic status, the product failure to cover the customers’ needs or that product was competing with a new one. Moreover, another important behavioral cause is relational attribution which means that the cause of a situation can......

Words: 399 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Personality

...BUSN2007 Lecture-3 Lecture outline 1. Outline the perceptual process. 2. Explain how we perceive ourselves and others through social identity. 3. Discuss the accuracy of stereotypes. 4. Describe the attribution process and two attribution errors. 5. Diagram the self-fulfilling prophecy process. 6. Discuss three types of diversity initiatives. 7. Explain how the Johari Window can help improve our perceptions. 8. Identify the ‘Big Five’ personality dimensions. 9. Discuss the psychological dimensions identified by Jung and measured in the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator. Perception and personality in organisations Why do so few women opt for careers in Engineering and Information Technology? •Sex-role stereotyping •Fewer role models •Low self-confidence •Image of industry Perceptual process model Environmental stimuli Feeling Hearing Seeing Smelling Tasting Selective attention Organisation and interpretation Emotions and behaviour © Ian Cugley/News Limited Selective attention • Characteristics of the object –size, intensity, motion, repetition, novelty Perceptual organisation/interpretation • Perceptual grouping principles –trends –similarity/proximity –closure • Perceptual context • Characteristics of the perceiver –values and attitudes –perceptual defence –expectations − condition us to expect events • Mental models –broad world-views or ‘theories-in-use’ –can blind people to potentially better perspectives 1 Social identity......

Words: 1017 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Organizational Behaviour

...employers and employees are constantly posed with challenges of making the rational decisions so as to reach an optimal outcome for the business. However, research has repeatedly demonstrated that in the real world, most decision making in organizations are not completely rational. Person perception is the main issue in organizational behavior and decision making for the fact that based on M.J. Martinko et al.’s (2007) assertion the limited information or immediate impressions of employee performance could result in an inaccurate perceptual judgment made by the employers. In an attempt to explain the ways in which people form perceptions about each other, this essay will examine the influence of the attribution theory towards decision-making and illustrate three common biases and errors that distort the attribution formation through the application of three mini-case. This essay will also discuss the importance of attribution theory in relation to organizational behavior as well as decision-makers in organizations. Attribution theory is concerned with how individuals perceive and infer causality (Robert E. Ployhart and Crystal M. Harold, 2004). Johns et al. (2007) also state that the attribution theory is an attempt when individuals observe behavior to determine whether it is internally or externally caused. Internally caused behaviors refer to the behaviors which are under individual control while externally caused behaviors are the result of outside causes (Johns et......

Words: 1239 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Depression

...Attribution Theory and Depression Mike E. Calderin Christopher Newport   Attribution Theory and Depression Baron, Branscombe, and Byrne (2009) explain the attribution theory as not wanting to just know how ourselves and others act, but why we and others act that way. People assign attributes or reasons to why something happens to better perceive, justify, and understand why people act the way they do. The Attribution Theory can be applied to many different areas of peoples’ lives. In recent years the attribution theory has been applied to different areas including Depression (Baron, Branscombe, & Byrne, 2009). According to the Mayo Clinic Staff depression is defined as, “a medical illness that causes a persistent feeling of sadness and loss of interest” (2013). Depression affects how you act and how you think. It is long-term and not just a momentary feeling. A variety of factors are linked to causing depression and a great deal of variance exists amongst the different variables (Mayo Clinc, 2013). Many different variables are linked to depression and treatment works different for different individuals. Depression covers a wide spectrum in both causes and treatment. The Attribution theory relates to how we see others’ behaviors in an effort to understand people’s motives, goals and intentions (Baron, Branscombe, and Byrne, 2009). The attributions we assign to others may be bias or misinformed based on other variables. Attributes can be......

Words: 1530 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Perception and Individual Decision-Making

...Perception and Individual decision-making (Robertson) Perception Perception is a process by which individuals organize and interpret their sensory impressions in order to give meaning to their environment. However, what we perceive can be substantially different from objective reality. People’s behaviour is based on their perception of what reality is, not reality itself. Factors that influence it Attribution theory The attribution theory is an attempt to determine whether an individual’s behaviour is internally or externally caused. Internally caused behaviours are those we believe to be under the personal control of the individual whereas externally caused behaviour is what we imagine the situation forced the individual to do. * Determinants of attribution 1. Distinctiveness: what we want to know is whether behaviour is unusual, if so we are likely to give it an external attribution. If not we will probably judge the behaviour to be internal. 2. Consensus: behaviour shows consensus when everyone who faces a similar situation responds in the same way. If consensus is high you will probably give an external attribution to the individual’s behaviour whereas if the consensus is low it will be attributed to an internal cause. 3. Consistency: does the person respond the say way over time? The more consistent the behaviour is the more we are inclined to attribute it to internal factors.......

Words: 1619 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Mgmt 3720

...The story is about a ski instructor named Miranda who is having several issues with her new boss, Hank because he has done and said many things over the course of the time that he has been there to show that he may be sexist. This scenario has a lot to do with perception. Perception is defined as “a process by which individuals organize and interpret their sensory impressions in order to give meaning to their environment” (Robbins & Judge, 166). This paper will discuss what perception is and how much of an impact in can have in the work place. Miranda’s perception of her boss Hank is that he is a sexist. The initial problem that is discussed is the fact that she did not like the fact that as one of the most experienced ski instructors at the resort but she was only being assigned to teach the children instead of the adults, the same for all the other female instructors. She sees how Hank separates the men and the women instructor to have a meeting about work procedure, “After introducing himself and Harika, he took the men to one room, and Harika took the women to another,” (Cohan, Fink,Gadon, Willits & Josefowitz, 2013). That was the first thing that bothered her because she could not understand what it is that had to be said to only the male instructors that could not also be said to the female. Although this bothered her initially, she decided to find a positive side to the situation, and went along with it. The more she went along with what was going around the job......

Words: 1342 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Test 2

...of the attitudes and feelings of workers Quantitative approach- includes applications of statistics, models System approach – provides useful framework for understanding how the elements of an organization interact among themselves Contingency approach – fit between organizational processes and characteristics of the situation. Three levels of analyses – individual processes (work attitudes), group processes (communication), and organizational processes (structure) Perception – set of processes by which an individual becomes aware of and interprets information about the environment. Perception influences – interpretation, spoken words, and visual images Perceptual biases (errors) – similar tone, harshness leniency, average tendency Schemas – abstract knowledge structures that are stored in memory and make possible the organization and interpretation of information about targets of perception. Schemas – make sense of confusing situations, choose what info to pay attention to, and guide their perception to information they confront. Work values – a...

Words: 583 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Interpersonal Communications

...negativity. As a student, my perspective on the situation is that the father is over reacting (Jim selects his father overreacting as what he notices) but means well. Jim then organizes that and attributes meaning to it by thinking that it was very easy for his father but things have changed since his father was in school. Finally, interpretation comes into effect, when Jim states that no matter how much he studies he cannot make an A, he is attributing an external factor for his failure. One tip that Jim’s father can use to help improve not only his perception of Jim but also the communication he has with his is by “Distinguishing Between Facts and Interferences.” Jim’s father is making the assumption that Jim is out there partying instead of studying but in actuality, this is a perception Jim’s father is making because of the grades. Another tip that could help Jim’s father is to “Guard against the Fundamental Attribution Error.” By doing this, Jim’s father would actually question the reason of the low grades instead of making an...

Words: 534 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Leading Organizations

...Kelley’s Attribution Theory Essay In this essay, readers will be presented with the literature review of Kelley’s attribution theory (1967), which was developed after the research done by Fritz Heider on attribution theory (1944, 1958). Moreover, a real world example relating to the theory will also be discussed along with the limitations and the three elements of the theory, which are consistency, distinctiveness and consensus. With that, recommendations will be given on how my experience can be improved with the chosen theory. There have been a great number of research done on perception over the last decade and social psychology had been primarily focused, perceiving causes of a person’s behavior (Kelley and Michela, 1980). In Kelley (1973), it is mentioned that Heider (1958) research has played a major role in contributing to the origination of attribution theory and it is still the major source cited in publications. Kelley’s attribution theory was also built onto Heider’s (1958) theory with an understanding that humans are “naïve psychologists” determining behaviors based on causes and effects (Hewstone and Jaspars, 1987). In Kelley (1973), it was mentioned that the central idea of attribution theory is the causal concept where human’s behavior relies on either the characteristics of the person (internal attribution) or the environment (external attribution). To determine whether a person’s behavior is caused by internal or external attribution, Kelley’s theory......

Words: 2692 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Poetry Coursework

...Discuss the errors in attribution Attribution= how people interpret and explain casual relationships in the world Attribution theory= ways in which people explain the behavior of others, or themselves with something else. Faulty assumptions, individuals attribute events. Situational= causality on external factor. Dispositional= causality on internal factor. Fundamental Attribution theory Tendency to over value dispositional factors, undermining situational explanations. Promotes understanding of common errors in explanation. Culturally biased and low in ecological validity. Jones and Harris (1967) Aim: investigate whether people would attribute behvaiors which people had a choice in disposition. Procedure: sample of university students read political student essays that were either pro or anti Fidel Castro. Told some writers freely chose be the pro or anti others were assigned determined by a coin toss. Participants asked to rate how pro/anti the attitudes of the writers were. Findings: participants believed writers freely chose= rated people who spoke in favor have a more positive attitude towards Castro (dispositional). Determined by coin toss= write in pro= more positive. Participants unable to see the influence of situational restraints placed upon writers could not refrain from dispositional belief even though participants were randomly assigned. Evaluation: lead to further research, all American sample, and question ecological validity. Suedfeld......

Words: 1044 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Mgmt591 Project Proposal

...How can Perceptions and Attributions Of Certain Roles in the Organization Be Controlled Within Organizational Change? Christine Freese 4020 Derby Drive, Cumming, GA 30040 cfreese@ariba.com 770-402-6287 MGMT591- Leadership and Organizational Behavior Joseph Walkowicz September 29, 2013 * Introduction a) The organization discussed in this research paper is Ariba, Inc (an SAP Company). Ariba is a software and information technology services company located in Sunnyvale, California. It was acquired by German software maker SAP AG in 2012. Ariba provides "Spend Management solutions" which help companies "analyze, understand, and manage their corporate spending to achieve cost savings and business process efficiency." Currently, 94 of the Fortune 100 and more than 200,000 other companies use Ariba's SaaS (Software as a Service) solutions to manage their spend and commerce activities. (Ariba, 2013) b) The role of the researcher is Senior Director of Global Commercial Operations for the Sales Organization. She manages the following teams; Requests for Proposals, Deal Pricing, Deal Bookings, Non Corporate Compensation, Commissions and overall Sales Operations. For the purposes of this paper her role will be related to the Account Executives (Sales people). Specifically in the area of recruiting and retention. c) Prior to the acquisition, Ariba was a 3,000 employee company with approximately 100 Account Executives worldwide. The main......

Words: 1345 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Fran

...relatively permanent change in behavior through experience, instruction, or study. Whereas individual learning is selective, group learning is essentially political its outcomes depend largely on power playing in the group. Learning itself cannot be measured, but its results can be. In the words of Harvard Business School psychologist Chris Argyris, learning is "detection and correction of error" where anerror means "any mismatch between our intentions and what actually happens. perception noun 1.the act or faculty of apprehending by means of the senses or of the mind; cognition; understanding. 2.immediate or intuitive recognition or appreciation, as of moral, psychological, or aesthetic qualities;insight; intuition; discernment: an artist of rare perception. 3.the result or product of perceiving,  as distinguished from the act of perceiving; percept. 4.Psychology . a single unified awareness derived from sensory processes while a stimulus is present. 5.Law . the taking into possession of rents, crops, profits, etc. The word perception refers to what the body is able to perceive, that is, the informationthat the body is able to discern from the outside world. According to the Oxford English...

Words: 705 - Pages: 3