Free Essay

Persuasion, Politics, and Propaganda

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Teneal0510
Words 1843
Pages 8
Persuasion, Politics and Propaganda
Teneal Rusnak
COM/400
September 9, 2014
Margaret Garberina, Ph.D.

Persuasion, Politics and Propaganda
An issue that seems to raise some concerns in our society would be the National Security Agency (NSA) not only spying on people in our country but also other countries by wiretapping and keeping surveillance on certain people. There have been a number of different laws that have been instated that help to protect our privacy such as the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Acts of 1968 which acknowledged that there were extensive amounts of wiretapping that seemed to be going on without any sort of legal sanctions and without the consent of anyone involved. With this law it helped to protect innocent people and stated that wiretapping should only be allowed only when authorized by the court and should therefore remain under the supervision of the court throughout its duration. However, in 1968 our technology was not as advanced as it is now so this law went through many significant changes over the next forty plus years. By 1986 a new amendment had been written in response to the ever-changing technological advances. The 1968 law only protected individuals who communicated through telephone calls. The Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986 took it a step further to focus primarily on any email that would be transmitted as well as stored in any type of storage device.
The biggest improvement came when the Patriot Act of 2001 was instated in response to the September 11th attacks. This new law expanded the reach of the government into electronic communications. Search warrant privileges were expanded so that law enforcement could access electronic information on a computer or voice mail through a warrant rather then using a wiretap (Morgan, 2014). Unfortunately, this law was passed during a time when our society was fearful of threats of terrorism and because of that, this act may have given the government more rights to take advantage of their authority.
Intentionally Persuasive After reviewing an article entitled, “Wiretapping laws: [Chicago Final Edition],” the reporter Barbara Struthers states the differences between a democracy and an autocracy. In a democracy, a society and its people have a very extensive knowledge about government’s affairs, whereas the government has very limited knowledge to its citizens and their affairs. In an autocracy, a society and its people have very limited or little knowledge of the governments affairs, while the government has extensive knowledge of the citizens and people in the society. When the founding fathers were fighting in the revolutionary war it was to not be a part of an autocracy anymore. However, with the NSA tapping into millions of telephone conversations in our country and government insisting that they give us knowledge of what is going on is completely untrue. Barbara Struthers also goes as far to say that this type of activity or behavior is one that shouldn’t be found in the United States and it is something that we would expect to see from a country such as the Soviet Union, North Korea or even Iran. Although the laws in our country may seem like a hassle to deal with due to the government trying to keep tabs on supposed “terrorists” within our country they must obey and observe these laws no matter what (Struthers, 2006). This type of article is intentionally persuasive due to the reporter putting out the facts and really getting the readers engaged on what is going on with the country. She is even going as far as saying that the President and the government are intentionally keeping secrets from the people in order to keep them in the dark about any issues that may be going on with our society.
Completely Objective In the article entitled “Wiretapping oversight: [HOME EDITION],” it raises the issue about the NSA spying under the Bush administration many years before it was even publicized. During meetings between Congress and with the then House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, she prompted that she was uncomfortable with the very limited amount of access and details that congress was able to obtain about the NSA spying on the citizens of the United States. When our society talks about the NSA and their surveillance capabilities most would assume that they only target individuals that are thought to be in contact with any terrorist groups or people. However, that does not seem to be the case due to the fact that under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act it states that when emergency or dire situations occur the government has the right to eavesdrop on certain individuals for up to 72 hour before having to obtain any type of warrant. The NSA is going beyond those 72 hours though, and including a much wider range of electronic communication searches, which is completely illegal (Wiretapping oversight: [HOME EDITION], 2006). Due to the fact that Congress has little or no interest to fight the President and challenge him as to why these illegal acts are occurring, it is unlikely that this will be resolved anytime in the near future.
Subtly Persuasive After reviewing a final article entitled, “Warrantless Wiretapping: [Palm Beach Edition],” the reporter Brandon Scherff claims that due to the Bush agenda and their critical use of electronic surveillance on United States citizens, it should have been the “wake-up call” that our society needed. After continuously promising to uphold and protect the Constitution, President Bush’s decisions about how our electronic surveillance is being used are the exact opposite of what he claimed he would do (Scherff, 2007). Understanding that there is a war on terrorism and perhaps in some way the President thought it in his best interest that eavesdropping on people would be the easiest way to go about getting these terrorists, it is still unethical and even unconstitutional. As a society we have been instilled that the laws and rules that govern our country are for the best interest of everyone and they will protect and help us throughout our lives. However, when a commander and chief of our country decides that these liberties can be somehow molded into the governments own ideas it goes against everything that our founding fathers stood for.
Differences in Articles After going through each of the articles reviewed there are a few differences between the objective and the persuasive news articles. In the persuasive news article it gives the reader the differences of an autocracy and a democracy and tells them that we fought for a democracy during the revolutionary war. There was a reason why we as a people wanted to have a democracy instead of an autocracy because we wanted to always know what was going on in our government instead of knowing very little of what they were doing and the government knowing all too much about us. The NSA has the ability to tap into anyone’s phone, emails or mail and we may not even know that they are watching which is a scary thing to think about. In the objective article it gives people the facts about the NSA and that they are able to eavesdrop in emergency situations for up to 72 hours but after that time they need some kind of warrant to continue. But because Congress does not feel that the electronic surveillance is a big deal they will not challenge the President about his decisions about continuing surveillance on supposed “terrorists” or even regular people.
After reviewing the persuasive and informative news articles the key differences that stood out were that in the persuasive article we were given the reporters opinion on the topic of wiretapping in our country. The reporter was very adamant about how they thought the President was wrong and what steps needed to be taken in order to correct this behavior. Ultimately in the informative article it states the information that we were given about wiretapping without the reporters input about the specific topic. If one was strictly trying to find out just the facts about a particular topic this would be the best way to go since there are no opinions given.
Conclusion
When it comes down to the issue of the NSA eavesdropping on people throughout our country we have limited hard facts but we have many opinions throughout various newspapers and magazines about what is actually going on. Political persuasion throughout the Internet, papers and magazines can lead anyone to become vulnerable in a sense. Due to the amount of public opinions through television and radio it’s sometimes hard to produce your own thoughts about a topic without other people trying to persuade you a different way. In order to really persuade readers, reporters will mention the lack of government support towards the people and keep many things secret when it comes down to our security. By stating a possible fact and then concluding their own opinions on what is going on in our government, this leaves the reader to lean more towards the opinions of the reporter rather then trying to form their own opinions about a subject. While most of these articles are effective in their own ways the one that seems to stand out the most is when the reporter discusses how our founding fathers fought for a democracy in our country and wanted to be in a government where we knew exactly what was going on without the government interfering with our personal lives.
In order to reduce our vulnerability to political persuasion we can learn to form our own opinions about specific topics that are introduced to us. An extreme version would be to block out any television or radio newscasts that give opinion based news such as Fox news. Also if we made it a point to reduce the amount of junk that we were exposed to on a daily basis on the Internet that would be another great way to reduce ones vulnerability. It’s hard especially within today’s society to strictly be given the facts and facts alone without someone interfering and forcing their opinions on the public. We as Americans have the ability to gather information about a specific topic and form our own personal opinions this is our right. However, it seems as though the government is taking a different approach on what we should and should not know which is not only the wrong way to go about this but it is also unconstitutional as well. We must remember that this country was founded on our right to know what is going on with our government and for them to keep us in the dark is going against our liberties.

References
Morgan, S. (2014). Federal Wiretap Law. Retrieved September 10, 2014, from eHow: http://www.ehow.com/about_6318636_federal-wiretap-law.html

Scherff, B. (2007, November 11). Warrantless Wiretapping: [Palm Beach Edition]. South Florida Sun- Sentinel , p. 4.

Struthers, B. J. (2006, August 15). Wiretapping laws: [Chicago Final Edition]. The
Chicago Tribune , p. 14.

Wiretapping oversight: [HOME EDITION]. (2006, May 7). Los Angeles Times , p. 4.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

The Kite Runner

...Of course there are many things that are unsaid and under explained in this tragic novel which, in my observation, is an oversimplification. There is also a heavy use of emotional appeal, and an underlying message. This is a flag for propaganda. The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini begins in the 1970s in Kabul, Afghanistan, when the country is in a time of an ending monarchy. The main character, Amir, is the son of wealthy Afghanistan business man, and his playmate, Hassan, the son of his father's houseman, Ali. Hassan is a Hazara and Amir is a Pashtun, which makes them from different social classes. The author has undoubtedly stirred my emotions and I admit that I did cry several times. I think that this was the author's objective; this is an appeal to emotion, one of the fallacies of propaganda. Propaganda is a message or an idea that persuades the audience to change their perspectives in one way or another. There are many faces of propaganda but this to my knowledge is one that is easy to recognize. I ‘m not saying I didn't like The Kite Runner, the author had me after the first chapter and then I couldn't put it down. However I am naïve when it comes to politics and propaganda, so at first I didn't even consider this book a form of persuasion. But as I thought about it, I came to the conclusion...

Words: 1091 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

I'M Only Posting This so I Can Use This Site

...Of course there are many things that are unsaid and under explained in this tragic novel which, in my observation, is an oversimplification. There is also a heavy use of emotional appeal, and an underlying message. This is a flag for propaganda. The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini begins in the 1970s in Kabul, Afghanistan, when the country is in a time of an ending monarchy. The main character, Amir, is the son of wealthy Afghanistan business man, and his playmate, Hassan, the son of his father's houseman, Ali. Hassan is a Hazara and Amir is a Pashtun, which makes them from different social classes. The author has undoubtedly stirred my emotions and I admit that I did cry several times. I think that this was the author's objective; this is an appeal to emotion, one of the fallacies of propaganda. Propaganda is a message or an idea that persuades the audience to change their perspectives in one way or another. There are many faces of propaganda but this to my knowledge is one that is easy to recognize. I ‘m not saying I didn't like The Kite Runner, the author had me after the first chapter and then I couldn't put it down. However I am naïve when it comes to politics and propaganda, so at first I didn't even consider this book a form of persuasion. But as I thought about it, I came to the conclusion...

Words: 1102 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Media

...the way people think. Although it may not be true, many people don't do their research and end up believing what their told. Major news networks such as MSNBC, Fox News, and CNN tend to be either left or right wing. Left-wing politics are “political positions or activities that accept or support social equality, often in opposition to social hierarchy and social inequality” (1). Right-wing politics “are political positions or activities that accept or support social hierarchy or social inequality” (2), and is pretty much the opposite of left-wing. Many news networks tend to spew out government propaganda. Propaganda is defined as “information, esp. of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote or Rahim 2 publicize a particular political cause or point of view” (3). However, there is such a thing as good propaganda but most people tend to view it as a negative thing. During the 20th century, countries at war would use radio, television, posters and other means to “define the enemy”, often passing off a dehumanizing effect. Consequences of war such as shortages could help gain support for military action (4). Even today, propaganda is used to shape opinions about other countries and the “enemy.” A modern day example of government propaganda would be the Sandy...

Words: 768 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Drinking The Kool-Aid Rhetorical Analysis

...Kool-Aid? On November 18, 1978, at a commune often called “Jonestown” in the jungle of Guyana, 900 people died in a mass murder/suicide; all were members of the Peoples Temple, an American religious cult. At the request of their leader, men and women administered lethal doses of cyanide-laced punch to over 300 infants and children before gulping down their own. How could so many people be convinced to kill their babies and themselves? His name was James Warren Jones. Like his idol, Hitler, he was a dominant propagandist, a charismatic leader, and an evil human being. Summaries In the piece “Propaganda under a Dictatorship” (1958/2016), Aldous Huxley, renowned English novelist, and Oxford graduate expands on ideas he first presented in his 1932 novel, Brave New World, which examines a futuristic culture in which no individual thought takes form. Huxley’s essay explores the practical use of propaganda by Adolph Hitler in controlling the minds of eighty million German people in the years leading to the Second World War. He examines, with chilling account, Hitler’s...

Words: 1554 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Psyop Quotes

...one hundred victories in one hundred battles is not the supreme of excellence. To subdue the enemy without fighting is the supreme excellence. Sun Tzu "The first casualty of war is truth. Rudyard Kipling One need not destroy one's enemy. One need only destroy his willingness to engage. Sun Tzu There are but two powers in the world, the sword and the mind. In the long run the sword is always beaten by the mind. Napoleon Bonaparte In War, the moral is to the material as three is to one. Napoleon Bonaparte We were as hypnotized by the enemy's propaganda as a rabbit is by a snake. General Eric Von Ludendorf, German General Staff, 1918 The British bombarded our front not only with drum-fire of shells, but also with a drum-fire of printed paper. Besides bombs which kill the body, they drop from the air leaflets which are intended to kill the soul. Fieldmarshall Hindenberg, 1918 All propaganda has to be popular and has to adapt its spiritual level to the perception of the least intelligent of those towards whom it intends to direct itself. Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf ("My Struggle"), Vol. I ...there was no point in seeking to convert the intellectuals. For intellectuals would never be converted and would anyway always yield to the stronger, 'and this will always be the man in the street.' Arguments must therefore be crude, clear...

Words: 2186 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Everyday Uses of Propaganda Techniques

...The Everyday Uses of Propaganda Techniques Caitlin Matthew 27483147 February 19, 2016 Coms 361 Propaganda has been associated with both the terms technique and phenomenon, and it’s been questioned as to which term it best meets. The Webster dictionary defines phenomenon as “something (such as an interesting fact or event) that can be observed and studied and that typically is unusual or difficult to understand or explain fully”, and technique is defined as “a way of doing something by using special knowledge or skill”. I believe that propaganda as a whole is always a technique, the technique of trying to convince people of certain messages and ideas, and only in particular propaganda messages, not in all circumstances, are they subject to being a phenomenon, which is why propaganda, in its entirety, cannot be called a phenomenon, and this essay will argue why this is true. Propaganda is a technique, ancient, well known and studied; employed in all politics, religions, ideologies, and of course in every sales method known to man. “Propaganda is itself a technique, resulting partly from the application of the social sciences, including psychology, to technology. It is a technique used to promote acceptance of other techniques” (Marlin 2013, 23). There are multiple different forms of technique that propaganda uses, such as emotional appeals which aim at getting an emotional attachment out of the individual, or such as the use of morally evaluative language, which uses...

Words: 1368 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Final for Com220

...Propaganda, Media, and the Making of a President August 27, 2010 COM/220 Propaganda, Media, and the Making of a President August 27, 2010 COM/220 Propaganda, Media, and the Making of a President Dr. Joseph Goebbels Dr. Joseph Goebbels The use of propaganda is as popular today for swaying public opinion as it was from 1933 to 1945 in war ravaged Germany. If Nazi Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels were alive today, he would be proud to see his propaganda machine being utilized by the U.S. Government to manipulate the masses and used by political parties to elect presidents. From mass print to the “tenth great power” the internet, the persons in control manipulate the masses and systematically destroy our freedoms to truthful information. World War II Propaganda Poster World War II Propaganda Poster In 1938 Nazi Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels, filled the airwaves with propaganda that led to absolute control of the mass media to the Nazi Party and its Propaganda machine. It was about control, if you control what the masses hear and see, then you control the masses. Goebbels referred to the radio as the “Eighth Great Power”. Through mass exploitation of the media, and control of incoming and outgoing information, propaganda stands as the most effective form of control over swaying public opinion. “Propaganda has been practiced since earliest times, but modern mass media has made it much easier to appeal to wide domestic and foreign audiences” (Hutchinson...

Words: 3991 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Attemp Persuasion Advertisement Analysis

...It’s a tactic used with a goal to entice the customer to purchase the product. However, along with persuasion comes strategy and advertisers over the years have perfected this game. Through conventional approaches like Snob Appeal, Bandwagon Effect and Famous-Person Testimonials to name a few, businesses have invested millions of dollars in advertising with the hope of bringing attention to their brand and boosting sales (Campbell, Martin, Fabos and Harmsen). Take a look at Donald Trump or shall we say the “President of the United States”. The media has labeled him as the “Master of Persuasion” as his skills in this area take on a whole new meaning. Not only has his persuasive abilities been the weapon behind the Trump brand, we cannot forget his performance during his presidential campaign. It was at this time that he introduced our nation to the “Make America Great Again” slogan attempting to persuade voters through four simple words to place him into office. But what was it about this motto that incorporated the contemporary persuasive techniques of...

Words: 1047 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Hitler's Self-Interest

...World? How self-interest can corrupt justice and why history is repeating itself. G reed is one of seven sins and frowned upon by an abundance of people. So how is it power hungry moguls or ‘evil dictators’ are able to throw their weight around strategically and at the expense of minorities? Why do greedy agendas still slide ‘under the radar’ and slip through the cracks in our society… repeatedly? Unfortunately, it is the primal instinct of self-interest that fuels this behaviour. It has been demonstrated countless times throughout history and is still prominent in politics despite the obvious immorality. How you ask? Why? Simply, because it is allowed. Tactically exploiting the wishes or needs of people is frequently...

Words: 460 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Use of It in the Us Elections

...Introduction: The use of IT and social media was the differentiating factor in the US politics, which catapulted Barack Obama ahead of Mitt Romney and has secured Obama’s second term as the President of the United States. For a long time, traditional social media has been the medium of communication of ideas in politics. Dating back to the 1950s, shrewdly assembled team of social media experts would have designed and crafted political campaigns that appealed and rallied the emotional side of supporters. Most of the occasions, contesting candidates would have carefully selected controversial policies that the majority were against, to garner support by invoking them to think that dethroning the current office would be “changing for the better”. Social Media experts would then exaggerate these feelings of unrest and protest in the undecided voters by publishing contents that citizens feel that are controversial. The reigning party would also, with the help of traditional social media, attempt to strengthen their foothold in the office by reinforcing the pathetic few policies that they have implemented during their term. Traditional social media has indeed played a pivotal role in all political elections all around the globe. However, with the ubiquity of smartphones and personal computers, coupled with a massive surge of online social platforms, the pivotal change of politics seem to lie in the hands of the party who knows how to play the game of IT. There have been numerous...

Words: 4259 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Age Of Propaganda Analysis

...Through this class, I can broaden my points of view towards ways of persuasion in our lives, stereotypes, and discriminations. Reading, Age of Propaganda, was a very interesting book for me. This reading taught me that media, some companies, and politics know how to persuade people effectively. For example, I learned that, for persuading people, credibility is very important. I learned some companies understand that people’s feeling and desires when they buy something. In Japan, when we start job hunting, we need to dye my hair black color, ware neat suits, and make up in the way for job hunting. I thought this is kind of making credibility of myself for showing I’m a trustworthy woman. When I went shopping, I saw boxes of cookies were sold...

Words: 725 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Steven Pinker's TED Talk

...“collectivizing” Russia would “destroy” the “autonomy” Russia’s peasant had established since the Russian revolution (Keefe, pg.1). A push to make Russia industrialized and the decisions that were made by Stalin would have devastating effects on the people of Russia. The main reason why Russian leaders had serious incentives to make their economy stronger was to rival Western economies, but unlike the West, Russia had forced its citizens to do what their told to make this a reality (Keefe, pg.1). At the time Stalin was in office he had proposed two five-year plans to transition Russia into a modern industrial economy, however, it came the expense of brutal oppression, forced labor, and millions of deaths to all which initially were spread through propaganda messages that incited national pride among many and was in a sense “successful” in achieving “increased production” but would come at the cost of devastating the Russian peoples’ living conditions (Keefe, pg.1). The process of collectivization from the 1927 to the 1930s and beyond lead to “cataclysmic “famines in Russia, killing anywhere from “five to six million” or more people per famine (Keefe, p.2). The Russian peasant class were severely oppressed as their rights, property, and work were taken away from them through fear and intimidation. In general, as with Zedong’s political decisions, Stalin’s decisions to make Russia an industrialized economy neglected certain aspects of the economy, which caused a shortage of food supplies that...

Words: 2457 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Effects of Nazi Propaganda

...appeal to such vast number of people ? The most obvious one would be the incredible shocking and emotionally charged portrayal of the families which lived in great poverty and led immensely degrading lives due to the economic and political situation at the time. After having been defeated in the World War 1, a socialist revolution took place which led to the creation of the Weimar republic. They were also forced to pay an incredible amount of money due to damages and saw parts of its territory being distributed away between other nations. Such turn of events ruined the countries stability and the German people felt injusticed. Naturally the Nazi party generated their propaganda around such thematics, and film proved by far the most effective one. Joseph Goebbels was the Reich Minister of Propaganda and the ultimate responsible for whatever was shown to the German people. He "sought to transform the film apparatus into a tool of...

Words: 1911 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Paper

... CARLYN GAE ESTANISLAO COM32 Submitted to: Prof. ROEL S. RAMIREZ, APR mARCH 2011 1/11 I. Background Information / Additional Perspective "Why does a dog wag its tail? Because the dog is smarter than the tail. If the tail was smarter, it would wag the dog." This film is an incredibly witty movie, with a rare blend of cynicism, humor, and intelligence by Barry Levinson, Wag the Dog thus begins with these opening credits, an early indication of a dark socio-political satire that would unfold to criticize mass media and indecisive public opinion, but most importantly, the abuse of power by political leaders. Wag the Dog also satirizes the immaturity of the society and how people's unquestioning absorption of propaganda only encourages the media to exploit them on a higher level. Conrad Brean (Robert De Niro) is a retired political consultant, a spin doctor who resurrects the support for the US President's after his disastrous scandal with a teenage girl just eleven days before the election. In order to smother the sparks of rumor ignited by the media, Brean invents an international crisis to sway the people's vote he fakes a war on Albania. The president heroically ends the war and his compassion and exceptional 2/11 leadership qualities are presented through the mass media to the people, winning back their faith. (Lu, 2007) The movie is basically about a fraud of the American public conspired by the incumbent president’s White House...

Words: 1637 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mr Lei

...ChapterⅡComparison of Confucius Institute and Goethe Institute from the Intercultural Communication Perspective 1、孔子学院:大规模扩张背后的跨文化传播形态 Since November 2004, when China's first Confucius Institute was established overseas in Seoul, South Korea, in just a few years, the number of it has been increasing at a rapid speed, exceeding more than 100 in countries and regions around the world. On average, a new branch is set up per week. It can be easily seen that the newly founded Confucius Institute is expanding at an increasing speed, compared to Goethe Institute, which has a history of nearly 60 years. However, considering the essence of foreign language teaching and media organizations and the effect of the language and culture dissemination, rapid growth of number does not necessarily mean effective cultural transmission. This is actually the concern of study of foreign languages ​​and media organizations, on which all similar institutions should focus. It is of great importance to analyze, compare and indicate the effect of cultural transmission, so as to come up with solutions to improve the process. From the operating level, Confucius Institute mainly focuses on the teaching of entry-level Chinese, complemented by coaching tai chi and other activities of interest in traditional Chinese culture. Considering the large number of Confucius Institute around the world, Confucius Institute has made contributions to promoting Chinese worldwide, even though its activities are limited...

Words: 2221 - Pages: 9