Free Essay

Pharmacist Refusal

In: Other Topics

Submitted By kasey
Words 631
Pages 3
Hiring a pharmacist for a rural 100-bed hospital does not leave a CEO many

options for alternative dispensing of medications. There are usually only a few

pharmacist in the hospital and in the town itself. The pharmacist is mandated by

standards that manage their practice. The physician writes an order that is specific and in

good standing for a patient. The pharmacist checks the order and other medications the

patient is on at the time of the new prescription. The pharmacist must make sure that

there is no interaction between any of the medication. A pharmacist is obligated to

contact the physician if there is any other medication in the system that is not a good

interaction with the new medication. A pharmacist must now offer all patients a

consultation regarding their new or old medications.

When hiring any employee, it is not legal to ask them their religious beliefs

therefore, one cannot know if prescribing a certain type of medication would be against

those beliefs. As a CEO, she would have to come up with an alternative plan for

dispensing these medications. The CEO would need to meet with the affected parties. In

a small hospital, this would be any other pharmacists, director of nursing and possible

other pharmacists in the community. This would need to be a confidential meeting. The

pharmacist that is refusing to give certain medications due to religious reasons does not

need to vilified due to religious beliefs in the community. A plan can be discussed with

alternative schedules and the ability to have an on call pharmacist to fill the need if a

prescription is needing to be filled.
Identify at least two applicable laws that impact this situation and describe the steps you would take as CEO to resolve this dilemma. Discuss your final decision.

The Access to Legal Pharmaceuticals Act was 2005-2006
Regular Session 1st House HR 1652 & Senate S 809
Summary: The Access to Legal Pharmaceuticals Act would ensure that a patient's prescription be filled without delay or harassment, regardless of the religious or moral beliefs of a specific pharmacist.
Best Help for Rape Victims Act
2005-2006 Regular Session 1st House HR 1214
Summary: The Best Help for Rape Victims Act would amend would ensure that women who have been raped are informed that emergency contraception (EC) -- a.k.a. Plan B or the "morning-after pill" -- is an option, and be provided with EC if they so desire.

The first law was enacted to assure that a patient would receive medication without

harassment. This means that the pharmacy must have a plan in place to assure that the

patient will get the medication prescribed by the physician.

The second law would allow a woman to ask for the Plan B or “morning-after pill”

without questioning. The law does allow for a woman to ask for this medication without

a prescription and to receive the medication. Again, a pharmacy must have a plan in

place to make adjustments for any pharmacist who may be unwilling to comply with the

law. The pharmacy is held accountable and may be liable under the law

http://religionclause.blogspot.com/2005/04/illinois-sued-over-requirement-for.html. A

woman could potential bring a sex discrimination suit against the pharmacy for failure to

comply with the law (Spreng, 2008).
References

http://religionclause.blogspot.com/2005/04/illinois-sued-over-requirement-for.html

http://www.guild.org.au/qcpp/content.asp?id=807

http://www.hpso.com/resources/article/63.jsp

http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/policy-watch/access-to-legal-pharmaceuticals-act

http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/policy-watch/best-help-for-rape-victims-act

Spreng, J. (2008). Pharmacists and the "duty" to dispense emergency contraceptives.

Issues in Law & Medicine, 23, 215-77.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Refusal Clauses

...Carina Smith Rosemont College Week 6 paper Abstract The broad structure of this case is whether a pharmacist has the right to refuse a prescription if the pharmacist is morally opposed to a possible outcome of the use of that prescription or whether a patient has the right to have that prescription filled without the pharmacist opinion of whether the use of that medication is either ethical or moral. In America we have access to all types of things that others don’t have access to; For instance, Twitter, Facebook, weed delivery services, supermarkets bigger than the Comcast building. But yet, when a women get prescribe legitimate medication from her doctor for either HIV, miscarriage or birth control, she is being denied by her pharmacist. Pharmacist are now refusing to dispense emergency contraception based on their own religious or moral beliefs overriding women's decisions about their bodies, lives and also denying referrals from physicians. In this case it shows no right or wrong with the decision the pharmacist choose to take. A pharmacy can refuse to fill your prescription because of refusal clauses. These laws allow people and corporations to put their beliefs before your needs. Some refusal clauses even let people and companies deny you information on where else you can get the services they refuse to provide (prochoiceamerica.com). As the customer I will feel angered and stressed, because you would think that you’ll be able to get a prescription......

Words: 725 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Business Law

...CRITTENDEN (1968) The Protection of Wild Birds Act made it an offence for a person to offer wild birds for sale. Partridge had placed an advert in a magazine: “bramblefinch, peacocks, hens, 25 shillings”. Held this was an invitation to treat and not an offer so no offence had been committed. PHARMACEUTICAL SOCIETY OF GREAT BRITAIN V BOOTS THE CHEMIST (1954) Pharmacy and Poisons Act required the sale of drugs to take place under the supervision of a qualified pharmacist. Claimant said Boots were in contravention of this when they opened up and operated the first self-service shop. However, there was a qualified pharmacist at the point of sale and it was the customer offering to buy the goods, consequently the display of goods on the shelves was not an offer but an invitation to treat. .RAMSGATE VICTORIA HOTEL V MONTEFIORE (1866) D offered to buy shares in a letter dated 8th June 1864 and did not get a reply. On 23rd November, shares were allotted by C but D refused to accept them. Court held refusal was justified as the original offer had lapsed and therefore there was no contract. BYRNE V VAN TIENHOVEN (1880) D made an offer to C on 1st October and C sent an acceptance on 11 October. D revoked the offer in a letter sent on the 8th October and C received notification of this on 20th October. The revocation had come too late to be effective since a contract had come into existence on 11th October. d DICKENSON V DODDS ( 1876) D offered to sell......

Words: 431 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Pharmacy Law

...f. patient counseling, g. the provision of pharmaceutical care, and h. the responsibility for compounding and labeling of dispensed or repackaged drugs and devices, proper and safe storage of drugs and devices, and maintenance of proper records.  | “active practice of pharmacy” | the performance of the functions set out in this section by a pharmacist as his or her principal or ordinary occupation | “pharmaceutical care”Note: CAN enter into practice agreement | the provision of drug therapy for the purpose of achieving therapeutic outcomes that improve a patient's quality of life, including include a. the cure of disease b. the elimination or reduction of a patient's symptomatology c. the arrest or slowing of a disease process d. the prevention of a disease or symptomatology | Equipment and Reference material requirements for operating a pharmacy | * Not very specific anymore * Up to judgment of pharmacist based on what they will be doing in the pharmacy * References must be up to date, in either printed or electronic form, and available at all times while the pharmacist is practicing for that pharmacy. * The orange book or an equivalent reference is necessary | Credential to practice may be denied, refused renewal, or have disciplinary measures taken: 1. misrepresent facts (not reporting felony, etc) 2. immoral conduct 3. abuse, dependence, active addiction on drugs/alcohol 4. failure to comply with a......

Words: 7455 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Can Muslim Doctors Refuse to Treat the Opposite Sex?

...CAN MUSLIM DOCTORS REFUSE TO TREAT THE OPPOSITE SEX?   By: Wesley J. Smith First Things October 5, 2012 Link to Original Article Not too long ago, the ethics of medicine were pretty straightforward. Inspired by the Hippocratic Oath, doctors, nurses, pharmacists, and other medical professionals generally followed the “do no harm” maxim, seeing themselves (ideally) as duty-bound to protect and preserve all human life. But times have changed. Society has grown increasingly morally pluralistic, while at the same time medical technology has advanced, making the work of medical professionals far more complicated. For example, abortion is now considered a right throughout most of the West, but many physicians conscientiously object to participating in taking the lives of fetuses. Many gay couples use in-vitro fertilization, surrogacy, and sophisticated artificial insemination procedures to have children, while some fertility doctors resist participating for moral reasons. With health care cost-cutting coming strongly to the fore, most mainstream bioethicists want to grant doctors the right to refuse life-sustaining treatment they consider “futile” because it is expensive to merely “extend the time of dying.”  These moral conflicts have sparked an increasingly heated bioethical controversy: Whether—and to what extent—medical professionals have a right of conscience to refuse their services based on religious or moral objections to what the patient desires.  ...

Words: 879 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Organizational Behavior

...of us has prejudices and hold them dear, one can begin to work more carefully with the prejudices of others rather than reacting to them with anger and force'(Clawson and Smith,1990:1). Armed with these information, I recently took a leap into entrepreneurship in establishing a cottage company. Amongst other issues discussed at the inaugural meeting was: gender ,ethnic diversity and prejudice. We were deliberate in discussing the issue of prejudice; because awareness is first step in the journey to reducing prejudice in the work place. The composition of our staff also reflects gender and ethnic equilibrium. We strategically positioned personnel's based on their ability to perform. The superintendent pharmacist(Male) is a Muslim from the south-west; Operational pharmacist(Male) is a Christian from the North-central ,the administrator(female) is from the South-west and the Nurse(female) from the South-East. We institutionalized what we termed: ''CARE: be your neighbors keeper''. Treat your colleagues same way you want to be treated. Address people same way you want to be addressed. Consequently, we agreed to bond and work harmoniously as one 'family'. It was conscious agreement to fight prejudice and to create a friendly and homely work environment for all. Through this, we also established that we all have a important role to play in fighting discrimination and prejudice, within and outside the organization. We also evolved a bi-weekly 'family meeting' where......

Words: 1797 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Business Research Paper

...violate the HIPAA Privacy Rule’s bans against disclosing protected health information for marketing purposes without an individual’s authorization, RICO law and trade secret misappropriation (Hunton & Williams LLP, 2011). The injured parties in this unethical research behavior are the patients, physicians, and other pharmacy chains. The patients involved in this case were injured in respect of violating their privacy, trust that they are receiving the correct or best treatment for their illness, disorders or diseases and trust in their physician and pharmacy. One of the articles stated that, “The American Pharmacies plaintiffs say patients report being forced, via higher copayments and refusal to cover maintenance medications, to leave their pharmacy where the patient and pharmacist have a long-time professional and personal relationship. Other patients report moving to a CVS Caremark network pharmacy out of fear of losing all health insurance coverage (Baggett, 2010, p. 1 p. 5).” It is extremely unethical and disturbing that a company could install enough fear in their patients that forces them to take a medication that costs a lot more money in the interest of profit for the pharmacy or fear of losing their insurance coverage. The physicians involved in this case could be injured in respect to their patients distrusting them to prescribe the best treatment plan for their illness, disease or disorder. The physician’s patients may also choose to change to......

Words: 918 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Silent Msrionette

...Even when the issue of taxes arises and the sheriff sends two men to talk to Miss Emily she is described in a morbid way; “her skeleton was small and spare…she looked bloated, like a body long submerged in motionless water…with that pallid hue.”(Faulkner 788). Just with physical description alone the town’s people can manipulate Miss Emily into an uninviting women. Miss Emily’s reclusive behavior doesn’t sit well with the inhabitants of the town. They’re in the habit of socializing and being a part of each other’s personal lives. In contrast, Miss Emily does not share in the lives of the town’s people. There are occasions where “a few of the ladies had the temerity to call, but were not received”(Faulkner 789). Miss Emily’s refusal to accept the town’s ladies’ hospitality gives the locals reason to pull the strings of Miss Emily’s character, in a negative way, like a marionette in a renaissance play. Over the years the locals weave the Tartaglione 2 shroud of mystery around Miss Emily’s life into a dense mix of gossip and legend. There are a few instances when Miss Emily is given a voice, a chance to let the reader know who she really is, through dialogue with other characters. The first time is when the sheriff’s men go to her house asking about taxes. Miss Emily is short on patience with the men and has Tobe, house keeper, show the men out. On, another occasion, when Miss Emily speaks she says “I want some poison”(Faulkner 792). As with her......

Words: 1139 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Competencies of Adn and Bsn

...more advanced nursing courses on leadership, Nurse management, Humanities and many more. Their approach on topics such as education in community health, psychological, and spiritual aspects of nursing. They can perform effectively as administrative Nurses, as well as present themselves more professionally, among Doctors, Pharmacist etc. They are appropriately trained to conduct research that enhances the quality of care to their patients. According to Kumm, Godfrey, Martin, Tucci, Muenks, and Spaeth (2014), BSN are strong advocates for their patients and their patients. They have knowledgeable workers with strong critical reasoning, clinical judgment, communication, and assessment skills (p. 217). They earn more respect and recognition from both society and healthcare professionals. An example of a patient care situation is a patient who is status post knee replacement and is admitted to a Rehabilitation facility, who takes their pain medicine which is a narcotic, refuses stool softener and rehabilitation therapy and wants to stay in bed all day. In this situation, a Nurse with an associate degree would administer the narcotic, document the refusal of the stool softener, inform the rehabilitation department that the patient is refusing therapy for their schedule appointment. The nurse failed to inform the patient that narcotic may cause constipation and with the aid of stool softener constipation can be prevented. This is because an ADN nurse is trained to......

Words: 1117 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Administrative Ethical Paper

...ethical analysis. This article was about a woman named Jackie that was a nurse and she was overwhelmed with her job. She tried talking to her husband but was convinced to continue working because who pay check was making their saving grow extremely large. To make her husband happy she continues to work as a nurse. She was working in different units that she started to use the narcotic that were prescribing to the patient that she was caring for. She started to take the patient pain medications that weren’t asking for their medications. Then Jackie started to replace the medications with the saline. Jackie had an addiction to pain medication. The administrative Michelle found out because Jackie was working in the surgical unit and the pharmacist had notice there was errors on the medication log sheet. Michelle had requested for the entire narcotic log sheet and the names of the nurses that were working on those days. Michelle had to inform Karen who was another administrative and explain to her the issue. They both confronted Jackie and Jackie told the truth. There was a meeting called with Jackie, nurse managers, human resource and the chair of the nursing ethics committee. They decided that they need to bring this issue up with the rest of the nurses of the unit to see if everyone had seen or heard anything regarding this issue. Michelle felt that Jackie had a right to privacy and confidentially to her ethical issue. Other in the meeting didn’t think same way as Michelle......

Words: 1647 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Today

...The changing face of the retail pharmacy industry demanded adjustments and additions to business  strategies utilized by CVS, hence the reason for the IT initiative CVS.com. The customers that CVS  and  its  competitors  were  courting,  through  brand  awareness,  customer  service  and  other  value  added elements, constituted folks of three distinct segments. First, there are customers with acute  conditions  that  possess  ailments  that  may  require  a  30  days  or  less,  prescription.  Secondly,  there  are customers with chronic conditions that require a prescription for 30 days or more. Lastly, CVS’s  customers also include doctors that may contact the pharmacy to ensure that drugs are available or  to communicate information about a customer/patient to the pharmacist.  Merck­Medco: Competitor, Challenge or Menace?  Some  may  interpret  that  the  web,  independent  drugstores  and  other  major  pharmacy  chains may not be the only competitive force lurking in the retail pharmacy battle field. Others may  conclude that access to a particular customer segment may be a challenge, and can involve intense  strategic  thinking  and  maneuvering.  The  Pharmacy  Benefit  Manager  (PBM),  Merck‐Medco,  who  controlled a significant portion of CVS’s customer base which amounted to 51 million people, was  aggressively  controlling  the  access  to  that  customer  segment.  CVS  dealt  with  PBMs  by  brokering ......

Words: 1811 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Ethics

...ethical analysis. This article was about a woman named Jackie that was a nurse and she was overwhelmed with her job. She tried talking to her husband but was convinced to continue working because who pay check was making their saving grow extremely large. To make her husband happy she continues to work as a nurse. She was working in different units that she started to use the narcotic that were prescribing to the patient that she was caring for. She started to take the patient pain medications that weren’t asking for their medications. Then Jackie started to replace the medications with the saline. Jackie had an addiction to pain medication. The administrative Michelle found out because Jackie was working in the surgical unit and the pharmacist had notice there was errors on the medication log sheet. Michelle had requested for the entire narcotic log sheet and the names of the nurses that were working on those days. Michelle had to inform Karen who was another administrative and explain to her the issue. They both confronted Jackie and Jackie told the truth. There was a meeting called with Jackie, nurse managers, human resource and from the ethics committee the chair of the nursing. They decided that they need to bring this issue up with the rest of the nurses of the unit to see if everyone had seen or heard anything regarding this issue. Michelle felt that Jackie had a right to privacy and confidentially to her ethical issue. Other in the meeting didn’t think same way as......

Words: 1633 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Criminal

...as defined in this policy; and • possessing or consuming alcohol. 2. The presence of any detectable amount of any illegal drug or illegal controlled substance in an employee’s body system, while performing company business or while in a company facility, is prohibited. 3. [Company Name] will also not allow any employee to perform their duties while taking prescribed drugs that are adversely affecting the employee’s ability to safely and effectively perform their job duties. Employees taking a prescribed medication must carry it in the container labeled by a licensed pharmacist or be prepared to produce this if asked. 4. Any illegal drugs or drug paraphernalia will be turned over to an appropriate law enforcement agency and may result in criminal prosecution. REQUIRED TESTING Pre-employment: All applicants must pass a drug test before beginning work or receiving an offer of employment. Refusal to submit to testing will result in disqualification of further employment consideration. Reasonable Suspicion: Employees are subject to testing based upon (but not limited to) observations by the supervision of apparent workplace use, possession or impairment. ___Manager or Owners Name_____ shall be consulted before sending an employee for testing. All levels of supervision making this decision must utilize the “Observation Checklist” to document specific observations and behaviors that create a reasonable suspicion that the person is under the influence of illegal drugs......

Words: 3341 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Contract

...conditions, leaving to the offerer the options of acceptance or refusal. He must be prepared to implement his promise, if such is the wish of the other party. 2.2.1 Shop and self service situations The display of goods in a shop amounts only to an invitation to treat. By referring the case Fisher v Bell, the case established that, where goods are displayed in a shop together with a price label, such display is treated as an invitation to treat by the seller, and not an offer. The offer is instead made when the customer presents the item to the cashier together with payment. Acceptance occurs at the point the cashier takes payment. In this case the defendant, a shopkeeper, was prosecuted for displaying an illegal flick-knife for sale. Because it is an offense to offer such an item for sale Restriction of offensive weapons act (1951) he was convicted. On appeal, however, it was held that offer for sale has a technical meaning in law, and a shop window display is an invitation to treat, not an offer in contractual terms. The conviction was therefore quashed. In 1961 a further Act was passed making it an offense to 'expose for the purpose of sale' an offensive weapon. By referring another case Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots Cash Chemists , the brief facts of the case are as follows. The defendants were charged for selling a listed poison without the supervision of a registered pharmacist. The Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain objected and......

Words: 9665 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

Patient Safety Workshop

...international settings. However, errors related to the accidental administration of vincristine via a spinal route continue to occur. 4 Learning objectives By the end of this workshop, participants should: 1. Understand why errors occur 2. Begin to understand what actions can be taken to improve patient safety 3. Be able to describe why there should be greater emphasis on patient safety in hospitals 4. Identify local policies and procedures to improve the safety of care to patients Who should be invited to participate in this workshop? A multidisciplinary approach is recommended, but this may be adapted as required. This patient safety workshop is designed to be suitable for health-care workers (e.g. nurses, doctors, midwives, pharmacists), health-care workers in training (e.g. nursing students, medical students, residents), health-care managers or administrators, patient safety officers, and any other groups involved in delivering health care. Who should facilitate the workshop? This booklet should enable any health-care worker to facilitate a workshop. You may find it helpful to consult a health-care worker familiar with error prevention and root cause analysis techniques. However, this is not essential. How should the workshop be organised? The two sessions of the workshop can be delivered on separate days, or together with a short break in between. A schedule is suggested but can be adapted to fit the time available. Session One: root cause analysis After......

Words: 9127 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay

Nutrition Final Exam Study Guide

...supplements? A) FDA regulates supplements a. Are dietary supplements required to be approved (and therefore shown to be safe and efficacious) prior to marketing? A) Do not need to be approved prior to being marketed. And are not tested to show potency/ contents b. Why are dietary supplements on the market not monitored as closely as foods and drugs? 7. What are the steps you can take as a consumer to choose a dietary supplement that is safe and healthy for you? c. Who are good source(s) of information in helping to select a dietary supplement? A) Thinking carefully about the nutrients you need, buy from a brand you trust, carefully read labels (contents, claims), has it been tested by USP, talk with your doctor, pharmacist, and/or RD! 8. How could you look at a label and quickly know if it is a food or dietary supplement? A) Page 6 of (Module 11 Part 3) Vegetarian Diets * Broadly, what are reasons people choose to be vegetarians? A) Health benefits, economic reasons, religious beliefs, ethical concerns, world hunger issues, ecological responsibility * What are the possible health benefits of eating a vegetarian diet? A) Weight control, blood pressure, lower incidence of heart disease, lower incidence of cancer, healthier lifestyles * What are the different types of vegetarians, and what foods do they exclude? A) General vegetarian: a general term to describe people who exclude meat, poultry, fish or other animal-derived foods......

Words: 2589 - Pages: 11