Free Essay

Philip Morris International

In: English and Literature

Submitted By iMahler
Words 1172
Pages 5
Textual Analysis

Philip Morris International

The move structure is expository with clearly defined sections for respectively situation, problem, solution and evaluation. Line 2 briefly states the situation and stipulate that litigations are inefficiency and unavailing, whereas lines 5 - 9 elaborate on the matter and describe the problem. The solution is diminutive stated in line 13, and bluntly claim their solution to be correct and de jure. The evaluation starts in line 13 and reaches a interim conclusion in line 15, and the remainder of the text can be seen as an elaborative evaluation of the litigations, and ends abruptly in line 52 without an actual conclusion. The move structure is rather unusual, as the evaluation constitutes the vast majority, hence the textual analysis will primarily revolve around the lines 1 - 15, and incorporate the evaluation as supplementary information.

The media text embraces all of the appeal forms to a certain degree, and uses argumentative discourse to persuade the reader. The primary appeal form is undeniably logos, which also aligns with the previously defined expository move structure. With the primary focus on logos, PMI undertake a historical approach to persuade the reader of litigation being insufficient as a means of control. An example of logos is found in line 38 - 44, where PMI elaborate on past and ongoing litigations. PMI utilize repetitions and enumerations of the countries implicated, which substantiate and emphasize PMI’s claim that litigations are tedious and futile. Additionally, repetition of countries involved is also an example of epiphora, as they are mentioned at the end of successive phrases.

PMI have through their extensive use of logos tried to achieve a percieved role of expertise, hence eliminating the need to include an expert to validate the claims. However, the idea of including an expert is to authenticate the information and facts declared by an unbiased third party. This self-proclaimed entitlement causes the reader to question the validity and credibility of the information, as there are no documentation or reference. One might argue that PMI’s
Page 1 of 4

Textual Analysis

Philip Morris International

attempt to enhance their perceived persona through extensive logos have backfired, and the overall trustworthiness is consequently being disputed and questioned.

Ethos is also present in the text, e.g. Line 13 - 15, where PMI states that they strive towards a common goal and aim for the best suitable solution for all parties involved, which is eunoia. PMI furthermore attempt to establish a “us vs. them”-frame, e.g. seen in lines 13 - 14, which will increase the readers consensus and acceptance of the text and its intended purpose, as a sense of belonging is established between the sender and receiver. This can be seen as pathos, as PMI explicitly express their emotions towards the subject at hand.

There is an array of speech acts present in the text, but the most predominant speech act is representative, as seen in line 13, where PMI proclaim that litigation is not the correct procedure, but instead regulation, and it is obvious that PMI genuinely believe this to be the true. When a text has an abundance of representatives, the dominant appeal form should be logos, which indeed was the case as previously mentioned, and thereby substantiate postulation. Indirect expressive speech acts are also present in the text, e.g. in line 5 - 6, where PMI indirectly convey their disapproval of thousands of lawsuits against tobacco companies by pointing out that they the smokers - merely have won a handful. Additionally are indirect directive speech acts present in the text, e.g. line 2, where PMI states their dismissive perception of litigation and thereby indirectly implore the readers not to commence future lawsuits against them.

The framework, cooperative principle, in the text have been identified as being tolerable and concise, yet border lining inadequacy and paucity. Based on the Gricean maxims, the reader is presented with carefully quantified amount of information on the matter of litigations, but the actual argumentation falls short, consequently resulting in reduced quality. Furthermore, the vast
Page 2 of 4

Textual Analysis

Philip Morris International

majority of the text revolves around cases, but in a superfluous manner that merely skims the surface, and in truth does not constitute any major insight seen from the readers’ perspective. Therefore, one can argue that PMI fail to embrace the cooperative principles, which cause the reader to question credibility of the text, and PMI as a whole. There are also a wide array of inductive topois, as PMI generalize and define their reality and perception of the world, but fail to use adequate argumentation to validate their claims. The style and formality of the text is suitable for the pressumed readers.

Chain of three are used numerous times in the text, amongst line 15, where PMI attempt to shed a negative light upon litigations through the use of three words with negative connotations, which is an example of dysphemism, the opposite of euphemism. A fallcy of reasoning is that there are no facts and figures mentioned in text, thereby not substantiating their claims, as previously mentioned.

The perspective of the text is receiver orientated, as PMI strive to affect the public’s perception of litigations as a means of control. Tobacco companies are notoriously known and perceived as immoral multinational businesses exploiting consumers for a profit, as they become addicted to the nicotine, yet societies condone the industries to flourish and grown. This is furthermore substantiated by the fact that smoking is now scientifically proven to be harmful and potentially lethal. This might be one of the primary reasons for the high amount of lawsuits against not only PMI, but also the industry as a whole.

Throughout the text, PMI strive to defend and justify their industry as a whole, but especially themselves. The vast majority of the text revolves around their almost impeccable track records in terms of litigations in a global context. Furthermore, PMI exert themselves to remove focus and

Page 3 of 4

Textual Analysis

Philip Morris International

responsibility from themselves and onto the respective governments. One might therefore argue that the text function is to vindicate PMI through an informative text function approach.

Litigation is one of the only actions the public can embark on in order to stand up against tobacco companies, who are earning billions of dollars each year on products that reduce life expectancy and generally harmful. However, PMI proclaim that they are merely following the laws and regulations, and they cannot be held accountable for any consequences caused by their products. By doing so, PMI attempt to shift the focus from themselves onto the governments, thereby holding them responsible and use them as a scapegoat.

The argumentation and foundation is sound, as no one can dispute the validity of laws and regulations, but the framework and the actual argumentation are flawed. The text therefore comes across as self-righteous and self-absorbed, which undermines the validity of the text, and thereby not achieving its intended purpose of being informative.

Page 4 of 4

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Corporate Evaluation of Philip Morris International

...Corporate Evaluation of Philip Morris International Study Programme Master of Business Administration (MBA) Module: Assignment: Course Instructor: Financial Management No 1/1 Authors: Student ID Number: 1st Academic Semester 2013 Place, Date Dortmund, 28th February 2014 Corporate Evaluation of Philip Morris International I Executive Summary The task of this assignment was to evaluate a company (if possible, listed) by two different evaluation methods: DCF method and multiplier method. The DCF analysis is divided into two separate evaluations: DCF entity method (WACC) and DCF equity method. In addition to calculating a corresponding theoretical foundation as well as a critical analysis of assessment methods / results was expected. Philip Morris International, as one of the biggest cigarette sellers of the world, is evaluated in this assignment to date of 31st December 2012. During evaluation by multiplier method the multipliers “price-earnings-ratio” and “market capitalization / EBITDA” were chosen and as peer companies British American Tobacco p.l.c., Imperial Tobacco Group p.l.c. and Japan Tobacco Inc. were used. The result of Philip Morris International evaluation by multiplier method is a value between $111 billion and $160 billion. The theoretical analysis of the different evaluation methodologies indicated that an evaluation by multiplier method can only give a rough guidance of the real corporate value. The evaluation by DCF method......

Words: 10115 - Pages: 41

Free Essay


...information that team 3 has retrieved from annual report of Philip Morris International. The annual reports we obtained shows the management changes and how the four functions of management have improved the operational efficiencies of Philip Morris International. All of the information in this summary, will be interesting to management students and managers. On March 28, 2008, Louis C. Camilleri became the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Philip Morris International. This happened following the spin-off of Philip Morris International from Altria Group, Inc. prior to this, he had been the Chairman and the Chief Executive Officer of Altria Group Inc., since 2002. He had previously served as Altria Group Inc.’s Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer since November 1996. Camilleri joined Philip Morris Inc. in 1978 as a Business Development Analyst with Philip Morris Europe. Prior to joining Philip Morris International Inc., Camilleri was a Business Analyst with W. R. Grace & Co., in Lausanne, Switzerland. Louis received a degree in Economics and Business Administration from Lausanne University in 1976 (Philip Morris International, 2002-2012). Louis C. Camilleri is a person of significance to use for this project; he is the Chief Executive Officer of Philip Morris International and has held other various positions in Philip Morris International. In 2009, as Chairman and CEO of Philip Morris, Camilleri wrote a shareholders letter that reflected on......

Words: 839 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Management Paper

... but more specifically, the planning function of management. These factors are often broad and can include issues such as ethics, legality, and social responsibility. The Altria Group, Inc. is a company that is often criticized for ethical and social issues, and these factors have a great deal impact on organizational planning. Previously known as The Phillip Morris Companies, Altria Group Inc. produces a wide variety of tobacco, beer, and food products. “Altria sells some of the world’s most successful and best-known packaged goods. Altria’s Philip Morris divisions make several leading cigarette brands and other tobacco products in the United States and internationally. The Philip Morris USA division is the nation’s leading cigarette manufacturer. Altria’s food division, Kraft Foods, Inc., produces a variety of popular cereals, prepared foods, and beverages. Altria is also the major shareholder in SABMiller plc, formerly known as the Miller Brewing Co., which makes some of the best-selling beers in the United States and in the world. Altria is located in New York City. The cigarette brands produced by the Philip Morris divisions include Marlboro, Virginia Slims, Chesterfield, and Basic. Kraft Foods is one of the world’s largest food companies. Its brands include Kraft, Maxwell House, Oreo, and Oscar Mayer” (Microsoft® Student 2008 [DVD], 2007). Altria has had some highs and...

Words: 1081 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Punitive Damages

...Harry Fryman 11/14/2012 BUSINESS LAW I, SECTION 321A Evaluating Punitive Damages America’s society operates in a way in which crimes and torts are inevitable. The means in which society assimilates this nature is through the use of our legal system. It is commonly known that in civil litigation, the purpose punitive of damages is to punish the tortfeasor and to prevent him or her from performing such conduct. Punitive damages are to be paid by the tortfeasor to the victim. Aspects of punitive damages can vary from state to state, such as the amounts in which the tortfeasor owes to the victim. The purpose of punitive damages may be just in nature, it is however susceptible to exploitation and deception through instigation and other means by the victim. The notion of exploitation and deception in society is not just at all, it is in fact the source of corruption. In order to avoid corruption in society, it would be best to remove the source of this corruption, by altering the law in which the victim does not receive punitive damages. According to Victor E Schwartz, “In their origins, punitive damages were a helpful auxiliary to state criminal Law.” The very nature of punitive damages appears to be an incomplete method of judging as it may punish the guilty at hand; it also fails to recycle the damage in a proper manner. The first issue at hand with punitive damages being rewarded to the victim of a certain case is figuring out how much is being rewarded.......

Words: 1194 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business Portfolio Paper

...application of the ethical conduct in an enterprise setting. Moral actions include not only the ethical compliance through the strict observations of rules and regulations but also setting aside selfish interests and allowing every individual in the workplace to achieve their self-actualization goals. Any ethical organization should foster the existence and practicality of moral behavior within the organizational environment. The association ought also to define certain baseline criteria for measuring the extent of moral behavior and the impact it has on the organization. An ethical-guided organization treats its employees with modesty and fairness. This portfolio paper will focus on the practices that are incorporated by the Philip Morris International (PMI) Company and its efforts to integrate business ethics into the workplace. A lot of companies and corporations have achieved strategic power that is evidenced by economic expansion and the complete access to strategic materials (Forst and Orris, 2002). Other companies have managed attaining the reach of worldwide markets. Most of the large and complex corporations yield mega profits that exceed the economic budgets of many countries, especially developing countries. Such increase in economic power tends to extrapolate, leading to various associative societal practices. These practices may be geared towards the maintenance of strategic power regarding the economic index in which they base their operations.......

Words: 2498 - Pages: 10

Free Essay


...COMPANY PROFILE Philip Morris International Inc. REFERENCE CODE: 2DC85131-EA8B-49A3-8340-D00D9F5733D7 PUBLICATION DATE: 10 Oct 2014 COPYRIGHT MARKETLINE. THIS CONTENT IS A LICENSED PRODUCT AND IS NOT TO BE PHOTOCOPIED OR DISTRIBUTED. Philip Morris International Inc. TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS Company Overview..............................................................................................3 Key Facts...............................................................................................................3 SWOT Analysis.....................................................................................................4 Philip Morris International Inc. © MarketLine Page 2 Philip Morris International Inc. Company Overview COMPANY OVERVIEW Philip Morris International Inc. (PMI or 'the company') is one of the world's leading tobacco companies. It is engaged in the manufacturing and sale of cigarettes and other tobacco products. The company markets its products in more than 180 countries. It is headquartered in New York City, New York and employed about 91,100 people as of December 31, 2013. The company recorded revenues of $80,029 million in the financial year ended December 2013 (FY2013), an increase of 3.4% over FY2012. The operating profit of the company was $13,515 million in FY2013, a decrease of 2.5% compared to FY2012. The net profit was $8,576 million in FY2013, a decrease of 2.5%......

Words: 3039 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay


...PHILIP MORRIS COMPANIES- CASE ANALYSIS COMPANY HISTORY: Philip Morris International, Inc. engages in the manufacture and sale of cigarettes and other tobacco products in markets outside the United States of America. Its portfolio comprises international and local brands. The companys primary international brands include Marlboro, L&M, Philip Morris, Chesterfield, Parliament, Lark, and Virginia Slims. Philip Morris International operates in the European Union, the Middle East and Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Its local brands principally include Bond Street in eastern Europe; Red & White in central Europe; A Hijau, A Mild, and Dji Sam Soe in Indonesia; Diana in Italy; Optima and Apollo‐Soyuz in Russia; Morven Gold in Pakistan; Boston in Colombia; Best and Classic in Serbia; f6 in Germany; Delicados in Mexico; Assos in Greece; and Petra in the Czech Republic and Slovakia. The company is based in New York, New York. Philip Morris International, Inc. operates independently of Altria Group, Inc., as of March 28, 2008. PRODUCT MIX We have the industry's strongest and most diverse brand portfolio, led by Marlboro, the world’s number one selling brand and L&M, the fourth most popular brand. This portfolio includes a variety of blends and styles, across 150 distinct brands and over 1,900 variants. In fact, 7 of the top 15 brands in the world are ours. * MARLBORO Marlboro is the world’s leading cigarette brand, outselling the closest competitors by almost......

Words: 1293 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The Altria Group

...the world’s largest tobacco company. Altria operates its cigarette business through the companies known as Phillip Morris USA and Philip Morris International, both of which sell Marlboro – the world’s largest selling cigarette brand since 1972 (“The Altria Group,” n.d.). This company controls about half of the US tobacco market. This is also the parent company of Kraft Foods. I chose to do a paper on this particular company because of the practices of lies and deceit that it has followed for many years. Some of the behaviors that I find socially and ethically irresponsible are that the company continually down plays the addictiveness and severe risk to health that their product can cause. Over the years the company has been under scrutiny for many different things including the practice of employing under age children to hand out cigarettes, falsifying legal and medical documents, and the paying off of political and legal leaders to accomplish the things that it wants done. This corporation has also been listed in the Wall Street Journal as Number 1 in a list of the top 10 worst places for a woman to work because of the fact that there are no women in any upper management positions and they employ nearly 75,000 people in the Philip Morris US plant alone (“Unethical Companies,” n.d.). At the annual shareholders meeting in 2011, Philip Morris International celebrated a year of growth in spite of the world’s economic crisis. What they failed to mention, however, was the...

Words: 1426 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay


...Introduction Philip Morris USA is the leading cigarette manufacturer in the United States and boasts the highest in revenues, income and market share than all other cigarette manufacturers. Philip Morris USA began its inception more than 150 years ago selling tobacco and ready-made cigarettes in London, England (Philip Morris, 2011). In 2004, Western Michigan University honored Philip Morris USA as the employer of the year. Every year since 1991, Western Michigan University honors a major employer for its recruiting, educational partnerships and its support for professional development of selected students and alumni. The backlash Western Michigan University experienced in honoring this employer is for one thing: Philip Morris USA is a manufacturer of tobacco products. The author of the editorial piece, “WMU deserves credit for honoring Philip Morris as top employer”, clearly indicates opposition to the backlash WMU received for honoring such an employer and concludes that although the manufacturing of tobacco is unpopular in today’s society, it was the right and courageous thing for WMU to do. Discussion Philip Morris USA is a manufacturer of tobacco products. Their main products are cigarettes and smokeless tobacco. Philip Morris USA understands that smoking is hazardous to a person’s health and according to the company website,, is actively engaged in the health crusade against tobacco, cigarettes and second hand smoke. The article does not deny......

Words: 703 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Philip Morris Companies and Kraft Inc.

...BSc International Business CORPORATE FINANCE 2 GROUP ASSIGNMENT: Philip Morris Companies and Kraft Inc. Instructions Form a group of 3-5 members. Read the case and answer the following questions: 1. What is the total value created by the merger between Philip Morris and Kraft? Notes: Overall market movement on the announcement date may be taken into account for a more precise answer to this question. Kraft’s number of shares is given in footnote 2. 2. What are the most likely sources of value creation? 3. Why did the shares of Philip Morris drop on the announcement date? 4. Compare the price offered by Philip Morris to prices paid in similar transactions. Based on the transaction’s price/earnings ratio and market-to-book value of equity, show that Philip Morris is offering substantially more to purchase Kraft. 5. Without synergies would the earnings per share of Philip Morris increase or decrease after the Kraft acquisition? 6. Why can Philip Morris increase its financial leverage following this acquisition? 7. Assume that the acquisition is financed using the $12 billion available credit line and that the debt carries a 12% interest rate and is amortized linearly over the next 6 years. Calculate the incremental interest payments and the corresponding annual tax shields. The tax rate on corporate income is 34%. 8. Estimate the present value of the tax shields. Justify the discount rate that you use in your calculation. 9. Explain why Philip Morris has a......

Words: 459 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...product/brand * Substantial cash growth * Phillip Morris SWOT Analysis Phillip Morris SWOT Analysis Revenue Distributed in Important Areas * Excellent employee morale | Weaknesses * Key note product/brand unhealthy * Substantial cash growth obtained at the risk of human health * Social perception of product has negative effect on company image * Taxation & Regulation | Opportunities * Smokeless tobacco * Acquiring company for tobacco quitting aids | Threats * Laws prohibiting tobacco use * Competitors * Lawsuits | Strengths With any company, it is imperative that upper management is able to identify the strengths and weaknesses that are within the company. Having knowledge of this would allow those in controlling positions to stay abreast on the competition and to strengthen those weakened areas. When Mr. Phillip Morris established the Phillip Morris Company in 1847, he probably would not have imagined that one of the major strengths of the company after over a century, in this present day, is one of the largest tobacco companies worldwide (Phillip Morris International, 2015). In 1924, the company began to manufacture its famous brand known as Marlboro in Richmond, Virginia, a plant that still remains standing until this day (Phillip Morris International, 2015, para 4). It is just as important that the company introduces a product that would yield the revenue to sustain the company, as did Phillip Morris. In 1972, Marlboro became......

Words: 1079 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Philip Morris and Mission Statement

...Philip Morris the makers of Marlboro cigarettes, amongst other leading brands, have taken steps to alert its customers of the dangers of smoking. The company have faced a number of major legal actions in the United States the most recent being a $10 billion (£6 billion) damages settlement related to its marketing of 'light' cigarettes. The company have taken out adverts in major newspapers to advise customers that 'light' cigarettes offer no significant health benefits over any other type of cigarette. A Mission Statement defines the organization's purpose and primary objectives. Its prime function is internal – to define the key measure or measures of the organization's success – and its prime audience is the leadership team and stockholders. There are four main points in the Philip Morris’s mission statement. The first point is to invest in leadership, this meant they would take care and invest in only the best people to lead the product forward; this also includes investing in leading brands and external stock holders. The second point is to basically understand the concerns of the society and try to meet the demands relevant to their company. The third point is to create innovative products which will satisfy the demands of the adult portion of the public better. Lastly it is to have growth in the company; this includes executing plans correctly and having growth both in the marketing sector and the return for shareholders. In my opinion Philip Morris cannot satisfy all...

Words: 628 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Treasure Key

...PT HANJAYA MANDALA SAMPOERNA Tbk. DAN ENTITAS ANAK/AND SUBSIDIARIES LAPORAN KEUANGAN INTERIM KONSOLIDASI/ INTERIM CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 30 SEPTEMBER 2012 / SEPTEMBER 30, 2012 PT HANJAYA MANDALA SAMPOERNA Tbk. DAN ENTITAS ANAK/AND SUBSIDIARIES LAPORAN POSISI KEUANGAN INTERIM KONSOLIDASI 30 SEPTEMBER 2012 DAN 31 DESEMBER 2011 (Dalam jutaan Rupiah, kecuali dinyatakan lain) 30 September 2012/ September 30, 2012 ASET Aset lancar Kas dan setara kas Piutang usaha - Pihak ketiga - bersih - Pihak-pihak berelasi Piutang lainnya - Pihak ketiga - Pihak-pihak berelasi Persediaan - bersih Pajak dibayar di muka Uang muka pembelian tembakau Beban dibayar di muka dan aset lainnya Jumlah aset lancar Aset tidak lancar Investasi pada entitas asosiasi Aset tetap - setelah dikurangi akumulasi penyusutan sebesar Rp2.918.701 pada tahun 2012 (2011: Rp2.680.952) Tanah untuk pengembangan Aset pajak tangguhan Goodwill Aset lainnya - bersih Jumlah aset tidak lancar JUMLAH ASET INTERIM CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION AS AT SEPTEMBER 30, 2012 AND DECEMBER 31, 2011 (Expressed in millions of Rupiah, unless otherwise stated) Catatan/ 31 Desember 2011/ Notes December 31, 2011 ASSETS Current assets Cash and cash equivalents Trade receivables Third parties - net Related parties Other receivables Third parties Related parties Inventories - net Prepaid taxes Advance for purchase of tobacco Prepaid expenses and other assets Total current assets Non-current assets Investment in......

Words: 26066 - Pages: 105

Premium Essay

Global Social Policy

...Global Social Policy 'Trade policy, not morals or health policy': The US Trade Representative, tobacco companies and market liberalization in Thailand Ross MacKenzie and Jeff Collin Global Social Policy 2012 12: 149 DOI: 10.1177/1468018112443686 The online version of this article can be found at: Published by: Additional services and information for Global Social Policy can be found at: Email Alerts: Subscriptions: Reprints: Permissions: Citations: >> Version of Record - Aug 16, 2012 What is This? Downloaded from at Taylor's University on November 5, 2012 Article gsp Global Social Policy 12(2) 149–172 © The Author(s) 2012 Reprints and permission: DOI: 10.1177/1468018112443686 ‘Trade policy, not morals or health policy’:The US Trade Representative, tobacco companies and market liberalization in Thailand Ross MacKenzie Jeff Collin Macquarie University, Australia University of Edinburgh, UK Abstract The enforced opening of Thailand’s cigarette market to imports in 1990 has become a cause celebre in debates about the social and health impacts of trade agreements. At the......

Words: 12166 - Pages: 49

Premium Essay

Business Journal

...MAN 4653- 301 Global Business (Dr.Daaim Shabazz) 9:30-10:45 November 26, 2014 Global Business Journal Khan, Naureen, “Global tobacco marketing campaign accused of targeting minors”,, March 11, 2014 According to a recent report, Marlboro's new ad campaign seemingly targets youth and has appeared in Argentina, China, Indonesia, Israel, Japan, the Philippines, Qatar, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Ukraine, United Kingdom and many other countries. A group of tobacco activists released a report recognizing how the “Be Marlboro” campaign is designed to appeal to minors. The report estimates that the company spent, at minimum, 62 million dollars on the campaign in 2012 (most recent figures). Be Marlboro targets legal-aged smokers, however campaign advertisements around the world emphasizes on youth-oriented images and themes that appeal to teenagers while featuring young attractive adolescent models partying, falling in love, traveling, and being adventurous and cool. Advertisements appeared in Germany in 2011 but were banned in October 2013 after regional authorities confirmed that that the campaign violated Germany’s tobacco control laws pertaining to marketing to youth. Marlboro claims that the marketing and advertising is aimed toward adult smokers and is in compliance with local regulations and internal marketing policies. Places where marketing and advertising are permitted, campaigns are authorized to inform current consumers of their brands and......

Words: 1393 - Pages: 6