Free Essay

Poor Economics

In: Other Topics

Submitted By marianjoi03
Words 1571
Pages 7

1st Argument: Foreign aid is not the answer to poverty

Reason: Foreign aid actually has its own benefits because as what was stated in the book, it would increase the investments of poor countries, thus, make them more productive. If they become more productive, it would result to higher incomes that will generate more investments in the future. Moreover, according to Jeffrey Sachs, poverty could have been eliminated in the near future if rich countries just committed to foreign aid yearly from 2005 to 2025. However, despite of its benefits, it actually does more bad to the economy and people. There will be a tendency that people get to be more dependent on foreign aid. They will stop looking for other solutions to solve their problems thinking that foreign aid will be the only answer whenever problem arises. Moreover, sine more money will be collected from the foreign aid, it could possibly lead to corruption. Another reason that foreign aid is not the answer was that, money from foreign aid actually only contributes a little to poverty. Nonetheless, where the aid is coming from is not important but rather is knowing the right kind of projects where money can be allocated to.

Interventions: One of the interventions implemented was prioritizing the needs of the people in order to choose the right kind of project to fund. Such projects are food for the indigent, pension for the elderly and clinics for those who are sick. Also, in order to solve poverty, people should have the capacity to help but before doing that, it is important for them to know of the different ways how to help. With this, another intervention used was through the help of Peter Singer. He regularly updates is website containing different example of things or solution that people can do or support.

Effects of the Interventions: Singer’s list of examples helped other people become knowledgable of the potential ways to help other people especially the poor ones. Moreover, the purpose of this list was to make the people realize that foreign assistance is not the only answer to their problems, thus, knowing that there are actually other specific answers/solutions to their problems. This realization would also help people limit their dependence to other countries. Also, through prioritising the needs of the people, more services will be provided to the people which will also reach the most needy ones.

2nd Argument: Poverty trap for poor countries is not always true

Reason: Poverty trap means that in context as having poor countries unable to surpass the poverty line or unable to pay for the investments merely because they are poor. Usually, a lot believed that poverty trap exists and that many had believed to the thought that poor countries who are in the poverty trap zone and have low income today will have a tendency to have lower income in the future, thus, will end up trapped in the poverty zone. Despite of this, I believed that poverty trap for poor countries is not always true. The economy is not linear which means that what happens now will not entirely indicate of what will happen in the future. Knowing this, poverty is not really permanent and in reality, many countries that used to be poor are now rich. It is just really dependent on the people and the steps taken by the said countries for them to get out of that poverty zone. There are actually a lot of ways on how these poor countries get out of that zone. According to the book, free market, just political system and right incentives would greatly aid solve the people’s problem, which in this case, is poverty.

Interventions: Since poverty trap is not always true and not permanent, there are a ways on how to get out of that poverty zone. As suggested from the book, one of the interventions that can be implemented would be the onetime infusion of aid, expecting that it could make a huge difference in the economy. Moreover, Jeff Sachs wants to spend on aid by means of giving away things to the poor. Another intervention was Jeffrey Sachs’s Millennium Villages Project which provides free fertilizers, school meals, working health clinics, computers in schools and etc.

Effects of the Interventions: One of interventions would be the onetime infusion of aid and as what I’ve stated on my first argument, aids could have negative effects. If the aids were coming from the foreign countries, there will be a tendency for the government to just corrupt the money collected. Moreover, many opposed aid believing that people’s freedom should be respected in more ways than one. As what was stated in the book, if people don’t want something you’re giving, then they should not be forced. Despite of this, onetime aid gives the people the chance to start on their own. Once having enough money to pay for their investments, they’ll be able to earn more, thus, gives a way for them to escape from the trap. On the other hand, The Millennium Villages Project benefits a lot of people. People get to receive a lot such as fertilisers, food, equipments and such for the betterment of their community. Estimating, half a million dollars a year were contributed per village. Its aim was to help villages have a self-sustainable economy coming from a subsistence farming. Another result of the said intervention was the benefits of the free harvest. One of the farmers in Kenya was provided by the free fertilizers and as a result, he became a lot more profitable from the harvests of it. And that according to him, the use of the aid, specifically the fertilizers, was the way that he was able to escape the poverty trap.

3rd Argument: The ideology and ignorance of the policy makers can lead to poverty

Reason: There are a lot of factors that really contributed to poverty and one of which would be the wrong ideology and ignorance of the policy makers. Many of them lack the sense of urgency with the emerging problem of poverty. Also, as stated in the book, policy makers had the wrong model of the world in mind. They are having two sides with regard to the problem, believing that poverty trap is there and that there was none. This led to the confusions as to what policies are more appropriate especially since even the policy makers itself were in conflict with each other towards their ideologies. Moreover, it is hard to match policies considering two different models. Thus, this leads to wrong policies being implemented. Also, too much focus on these debates and discussions as to whether poverty trap exists or not led to ignoring the real problem that is occurring. Another reason for the said argument would be the corruption that exists. Instead of using the funds to help alleviate poverty, money just goes to the pocket of these policy makers. This is also the reason why there’s a wrong appropriation of the funds. Less money goes to the poor and at the same time, their needs are not well prioritized.

Interventions: The wrong ideology and ignorance of the policy makers lead to wrong policies implemented, thus, worsening the poverty. Knowing this, it is important to ensure that proper policies are created and this can be assured through different interventions. There’s a need to practice the development policy which collects the right data that can be used to make more equipped/appropriate policies aligned to the environment of the country. They’ve implemented the use of Randomised Control Trials or RCT. Poverty Action Lab was also founded which basically aims to understand economy through the use of RCT. Moreover, through the implementation of RCT, they’ve evaluated the effectiveness of new drugs. Lastly, to aid the wrong policies of the policy makers due to their wrong ideology and ignorance, they’ve come to study well the behaviour of the people and understand how they decide.

Effects of the Interventions: With the Poverty Action Lab, it enabled a wide-range of research and experiments with the cooperation of a very large numbers of organizations, researchers and policy makers. Also, they’ve embraced the idea of randomised trials which gave the researchers the chance to work with a wide-array of respondents and a chance to implement large-scale experiments designed to test their theories. These experiments were very helpful since new theories will be formulated. If these theories regarding the economies are proven, it would greatly help design interventions and new experiments which can also aid the policy makers to create more appropriate laws. Moreover, it led to a closer interaction to the poor people, thus, enabled the researchers to study and understand the decision making and behaviour of these people. Knowing this would give solutions to the shortcomings of the policy makers. According to the book, policies regarding government subsidies are important. However, government subsidies can also pose negative effects to the people. But then, since through the experiments, behaviours were understood which identified the needs of the people. It then aids policy makers to understand the different levels of subsidy, thus, helps creating policies that provide a balanced government subsidy for the poor. Lastly, the new experiments carried out were beneficial to the health sector as new drugs were evaluated to cure illnesses such as Malaria.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

What Political Factors Explain Indonesia's Poor Economic Performance? What Economic Factors? Are These Two Related?

...This suppression of dissent robbed Indonesia’s economy of the vitality and incentives associated with a free-market economy in which individual property owners, who in the process of seeking to accumulate wealth enrich the entire economy and create economic growth. While Indonesia has since overthrown the dictatorial government, corruption and red tape remain rife at almost all levels of government in Indonesia. A World Bank study revealed how excessive red tape in Indonesia hurts business activities: An entrepreneur in Indonesia must wait an average of 151 days to complete the necessary paperwork to start a business, compared to 30 days in Malaysia and a mere 8 days in Singapore, severely hampering the Indonesian entrepreneur’s speed and desire to participate in the economy. In turn, the excessive red tape translates into long lines of government bureaucrats, whose low salaries make it attractive for them to seek a bribe at every step of the business transaction, further distracting and detracting the entrepreneur from legitimate business pursuits. In addition to these political factors, Indonesia also suffers from economics factors that hinder growth. Indonesia’s poor infrastructure makes it difficult to conduct business: A poor infrastructure in roads signifies that it is difficult to transport goods and services to the consumers, and may even hinder export-related businesses if companies cannot ship the finished intermediary or final products to their intended customers......

Words: 272 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Evaluating the Participating Countries of the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative for Economic Growth

...Evaluating the Participating Countries of the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative for Economic Growth | Introduction: Economic growth is vital to any countries livelihood. Economic growth within a country affects every industry, market, and household. In 1996, the World Bank, International Monetary Fund, and several other small creditors created the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative (HIPC) to help provide economic growth to poor and developing countries. The direct purpose of the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative was to offer low interest loans and debt relief to countries that meet the criteria for the initiative. Countries would have to be selected by criteria, which included, a countries past economic growth, amount of debt, poverty rate, lack of development, with many other factors. In creation of the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative, was in hopes that in could spur economic growth in development in many improvised nations. The Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative has only invited thirty-nine countries to participate in the initiative since its creation. Africa has had the majority of the countries, while the rest were located in Southeast Asia, and the Middle East. The Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative uses a two point system to meet the seven requirements the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank requires to receive debt relief. There are only two points that all participating countries in the......

Words: 4931 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Critical Essay. the Poor Economic Climate in the Uk and the Affect's on the Marketing Mix of a Start-Up Retail Venture in the High Street.

...Assignment 1 Critical Essay Introduction: This essay will attempt to critically explain how the poor economic climate in the UK might affect the marketing mix of a start-up retail venture in the high street. This essay will walk through the processes of starting a retail business venture in the high street and discuss how the economy and the marketing mix directly effects each step. To do this it will be vital to explore the current economic climate and what a poor economic climate means? A definition of a poor economic climate “a recession is a decline in growth, domestic product for two consecutive quarters and a depression as a prolonged recession resulting in falling prices, reduced purchasing power, excess in supply, unemployment, and a general reduction in business activity” (Downes,j.,& Goodman,J.E.(1995).Dictionary of finance and investment terms Hauppage,nj:Barron’s educational series) This has been the case for the UK since 2007 as we are in what is known as a double dip recession narrowly escaping a triple dip recession. (BBC News 2013, This downturn indicates that the UK is indeed suffering from a poor economic climate having the effect of less spending and so less trade occurring in the local, regional, continental, or global marketplace. How this relates to a start up venture in the high street has both negative and positive effects. To look at each of these effects it is best to look at the......

Words: 1935 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Nickel and Dimed

...The author meets numerous people, including Holly a maid in Maine that she befriends. Ehrenreich’s view of low wage workers helps her understand their situation around the country as she comes to the realization that one cannot afford nutritious food, a protected living enviroment and provide for health insurance all on low earnings. My paper will discuss the repercussions of low wages on the working poor as well as how they are viewed by society. Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America The book Nickel and Dimed begins with the author, Barbara Ehrenreich (2011), contemplating how she will take on the task of living with limited money and assets as she has a Ph.D. in Biology, but her focus became social change. Ehrenreich must ground rules for her research and decides that she must have transportation, a place to live and food to eat as these are things that she will need to get by. "Transportation is also a major barrier to financial self-sufficiency for many working poor families. Many of the working poor do not get to work with the ease that most working non-poor enjoy" (Lambert, 1998). The second leg of Ehnrenreich’s journey begins in...

Words: 2072 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay


...PAPER TEORI SOSIOLOGI KLASIK PERLOMBAAN DI KAMPUS DAN KEHIDUPAN PERKULIAHAN ( Studi Kasus : Ketika Perlombaan UKM dan Solative Sosiologi Tidak Disesuaikan Dengan Jadwal Kuliah Mahasiswa, Serta Pembedaan antara Masa SMA dan Kuliah) Oleh: Ahmad Rofiki PENDAHULUAN Masa kuliah adalah masa dewasa dini yang telah memikirkan masa depan. Ini ditandai dengan adanya semangat bersaing dan hasrat kuat untuk maju dalam karir1. Tidak seperti pada saat SMA yang masih kental dengan aroma persahabatan kuat. Dalam masa dewasa dini ini kita hanya menyisihkan waktu yang sedikit untuk bergaul bersama teman-teman kampus. Begitu pula ketika kampus mengadakan kegiatan perlombaan UKM dan Solative Sosiologi, kebanyakan dari teman-teman mahasiswa tidak mengikutinya. Di karenakan jadwal perkuliahan mereka tidak di sesuaikan dengan jadwal perlombaan. Tidak seperti di SMA, yang melakukan classmeeting atau perlombaan diadakan saat setelah UAS. Perlombaan di kampus diadakan sebelum UAS, kendati pun perlombaan itu diadakan setelah UAS. Saya yakin tidak ada yang mau untuk menonton. Kenapa demikian, karena kebanyakan mahasiswa sudah sibuk untuk mengurusi liburan pulang kampung mereka. Bagaimana menanamkan kepada para mahasiswa di jurusan sosiologi maupun yang lain, supaya lebih mementingkan mengikuti perlombaan daripada mengikuti jadwal perkuliahan. Saya rasa mustahil, karena mereka lebih mementingkan mendapatkan nilai bagus, memikirkan masa depan dan membuat kedua orang tua bangga dengan cara lulus......

Words: 6032 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Race, Urban Poverty, and Public Policy

...the problems of ghetto poverty affecting blacks. In No Shame in My Game, Puerto Rican and Dominican immigrants are part of the changing demographics in Harlem. In Canarsie, the possible migration of blacks into a working/middle-class neighborhood prompts conservative backlash from a traditionally liberal community. In Streetwise, the migration of yuppies as a result of gentrification, and the movement of nearby-ghetto blacks into these urban renewal sites also invoke fear of crime and neighborhood devaluation among the gentrifying community. Not only is migration a common thread, but the persistence of poverty, despite the current economic boom, is the cornerstone of all these works. Poverty, complicated by the dynamics of race in America, call for universalistic policy strategies, some of which are articulated in Poor Support and The War Against the Poor. In When Work Disappears, William Julius Wilson builds upon many of the insights he introduced in The Truly Disadvantaged, such as the rampant joblessness, social isolation, and lack of marriageable males that characterized many urban ghetto neighborhoods. In the class discussion, Professor Wilson argues that it is necessary to disassociate unemployment with joblessness, as the former only measures those still seeking jobs while the latter encompasses those who may have dropped out of the labor market. Also, by focusing on neighborhood-level poverty, he highlights...

Words: 2489 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

History of Human Services

...when I found a reference to King Athelstan. He established what is the first recorded almshouse – in York in the 10th Century. I also found that the oldest established charity still in existence is thought to be the Hospital of St. Oswald in Worcester, founded around 990. What I found disturbing is that even though the almshouses in Great Britain survive and thrive – after many adaptations to this day – the almshouses established in the United States evolved to become very bad places. ( website) In our text, we read that in the United States, human services were established and modeled according to the Elizabethan Poor Law of 1601, and that the first principle laid down in the colonies defined poor relief as a public responsibility. Another principle stipulated that people would be denied support if they had family members who were not poor, i.e., parents, grandparents, adult children, or grandchildren. (Woodside, p. 33) This entire subject area is fascinating. Early Peoples Recorded In History In researching “human services from the early peoples recorded in history” we can go back pretty far. Human services,...

Words: 3058 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

How Did Benjamin Franklin Trying To Do To Help The Poor

...discussions of the poor laws were written in England during his stay there for 18 years. During this period there was heated discussion and condemnation of the poor laws in England. Franklin was a scholar with keen interest in economics, and political discourse and was easily drawn in the discussion. In 1766 he was upfront in questioning the poor laws, and advocating outright repeal. He made it clear that he was for helping the poor. His point of contention was the means to support them. Franklin was making the case, that the poor can workout of poverty. He believed what was needed was providing them jobs, leadership and motivation for them to work. He earlier mentioned that perhaps the order of God and nature of wants and miseries is about leading or driving...

Words: 491 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Poverty In Sappi

...Poverty Poverty would be defined as the state of being extremely poor, having little or no money, goods; or means of support and it gets to a stage where you can no more provide for the necessities in your life. Poverty is caused by a number of factors; such provide as; political instability, debt, discrimination & social inequality… Inequality There are many different types of inequality such being; income inequality, gender inequality, but a broad outline of what inequality is, is that it’s a condition of being unequal towards someone or a group of people. Example would be a male and female working the same job and same amount of hours and the one getting paid more than the other due to circumstances such as discrimination and prejudice...

Words: 2428 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Helping the Poor

...Helping the Poor Helping the Poor Friendly visiting, dole charities and dole queues Robert Whelan based on research by Barendina Smedley Civitas: Institute for the Study of Civil Society London First published October 2001 © The Institute for the Study of Civil Society 2001 The Mezzanine, Elizabeth House 39 York Road, London SE1 7NQ email: All rights reserved ISBN 1-903 386-16-0 Typeset by Civitas in New Century Schoolbook Printed in Great Britain by St Edmundsbury Press Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk Contents Acknowledgements Authors vi viii Introduction: Hand-outs and Leg-ups Section 1: The Visiting Charity The Charity Organisation Society 1. The Organisation of Charity 2. Preaching the ‘Gospel of Social Reform’ in West London 3. The Fulham and Hammersmith Committee and Its Cases Section 2: The Dole Charity The Mansion House Fund 4. From West End to East End 5. Lord Mayor Aid 6. The Aftermath 7. Moralities and Mathematics Appendices Appendix 1 Applications for Relief Received by the Fulham and Hammersmith District Committee of the COS, November 1879 - October 1880 Appendix 2 The 27 Extant Fulham and Hammersmith Casebooks Appendix 3 The Charity Organisation Society by Miss Octavia Hill Notes Index 1 9 24 39 51 59 85 90 99 137 164 166 182 v Acknowledgements This book has been made possible by a generous grant from the Wincott Foundation. The author would like to express his thanks to the trustees. The......

Words: 68635 - Pages: 275

Premium Essay


...Living in what feels like poverty, I feel as if school is my highest priority. With everything going on at home, I didn’t want to burden my parents with more problems. My family has not always been financially stable, making it a bit difficult for us at times. My academic studies have always been important for me, school overall was not always the safest place to be though, as well as the community. There were gangs everywhere you looked; as well as drugs; it almost felt as if everyone was into them. Everyone always either asked, or pressured you into trying them. I'd like to do something to change the way others live their lives, make a change in it. Being a registered nurse, I feel would be something I’d like to fulfill. Being a registered nurse, you help those who have been hurt and heal them. In the end, you feel good about yourself. My life isn’t all that comparable to those who are in the street and homeless, I might have been upset and stressed out about the bills although there are those out there who have nothing. The person you’re helping will lead a good life – after your involvement. Being a registered nurse, you help the homeless, the elderly, those with medical health conditions, as well as drug and alcohol abusers; I can help others lead a good life. Living in poverty, I feel as if I should further my education so my children won’t have to worry on what I had to. I love my family; they were always the biggest supporters throughout school. The thing was I was......

Words: 627 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Herifer International

...CCTs and UCTs seem very attractive to aid donors. I have summarized the following points to help you understand my analysis: CCTs: Purpose: CCTs usually has very distinctive priorities, such as supporting individual household with health, education and helping woman (The Economist, 2013). Pros: 1) CCTs can focus on helping the children improve their education and cut future poverty (Mohan, 2013). 2) CCTs usually works better when dealing with the root causes of poverty and, it can help families escape from poverty once for all (The Economist, 2013). Con: 1) Some recipients eligible for CCTs fail to meet the conditions due to some unmanageable condition (The Economist, 2013). UCTs: Purpose: It simply handing out cash to the poor without condition attached and relieves people from poverty (Mohan, 2013). Pros: 1) UCTs is cheaper than CCTs to run (The Economist, 2013). 2) UCTs is best suitable when the money is the main issue (Mohan, 2013). . 3) UCTs seem has better results than the traditional aid program (such as job-training programs) (Mohan, 2013). Con: 1) There is no long term effect has been able to assessed (Baird, 2013). Heifer...

Words: 461 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Single Moms

...Running head: Cultural Influence in Development Cultural Influences in Development Fhameka Lewis February 10, 2015 Argosy University Single Moms Single moms face a challenge within their lives. Some mothers become single through divorce and while others become single outside of wedlock. However, there is no set age for a single mom. Statics states that most females become single moms before they finish high school and is receiving some type of government assistance for help. The average single mom has either dropped out of school or working a minimum paying job. Because of the high cost of living rate it is impossible for these single moms to provide a healthy life for their children. Therefore the Department of Human Service is stepping up to the platform to help these moms seek better jobs and receive a better education. The Jefferson County Department of Human Services will be offering a variety of workshops for all single moms in the surrounding communities. The workshop is called Single Moms Taking Control, and will be on Thursday June 3, 2015 during the hours of 9:00 a.m. until 2:00 p.m. The purpose of the workshop will be to provide guidance and resources for all the single moms who which to go back to school to receive their GED or for those who which to obtain a degree in higher education. The workshops will also help the moms with resources to maintaining a healthy relationship with their family. Also throughout the workshops there will be venders......

Words: 1827 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Living Standards During the Industrial Revolution

...was substantial, and outweighed the negative effects brought by industrialization.  Pessimists argue that the quality of life for workers deteriorated greatly between 1780 and 1850, with very limited improvements for some skilled sectors before the 1870’s.  This purpose of this paper is to analyze the debate from an economic and social perspective. We will examine both arguments and prove that although there was a rise in real wages, that rise was not as high as many optimists believe, and that the rise in real wages did not mean that the living standards of the average citizen were necessarily improved. This paper will substantiate that the benefits resulting from the rise in real wages, did not outweigh the costs that followed. We will examine how pollution, poor working conditions, and an overall lack of basic human rights and equality, plagued the British population and did not initially raise the living standards of the average person in Britain.   The majority of debates between pessimists and optimists consist of exchanging evidence from various indices including money wages, and real wages. The optimist’s argument is one dimensional, purely economic, and boiled down to the fact that the Industrial revolution brought gains in real wages (P.H. Lindert, 1983). In a 1983 paper by optimists Peter Lindert and Jeffrey Williamson, the authors produced estimates of real wages in England from 1781...

Words: 2789 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Define Poverty In America

...What is poverty? According to Poverty is general scarcity, death, or the state of one who lacks a certain amount of material possessions or money. It is a multifaceted concept, which includes social, economic, and political elements. Poverty may be defined as either absolute or relative. Absolute poverty or destitution refers to the lack the means necessary to meet basic needs such as food, clothing and shelter. Relative poverty takes into consideration individuals, social and economic status compared to the rest of society. Poverty is a becoming an endemic in this day and age. Poverty is not only affected by lower class people. Poverty does not only affect the people who going through it, but it affects everyone and every...

Words: 758 - Pages: 4