Porter's Six Forces Analysis General Retail: Merchandise/Department Stores

In: Business and Management

Submitted By julettas
Words 2385
Pages 10
February 25, 2010

Assignment 2
Porter’s Six Forces Analysis
General Retail: Merchandise/Department Stores
Prepared by:
Yulia Petukhova

ID# A30
The department store industry will be analyzed taking department stores as players, individual consumers as buyers, and manufacturers and distributors as the key suppliers.
The Rivalry among existing firms High
The period from the end of the 20th century up until now has been marked by the consolidation trend in the department store industry, characterized by major acquisitions by a few larger, powerful competitors, greatly intensifying the rivalry among them.9, 13 Since there are only a few of them in the industry, they tend to match each other’s steps in some way or another. After JC Penny introduced itself to Manhattan just a block away from Macy’s, it is only a matter of short time before Kohl’s will finally announce its move into Manhattan as well.10
Slowdown in the industry growth coupled with reduced consumer spending and low switching costs intensifies rivalry even further prompting the market players to differentiate their products by introducing exclusive brands and increasing innovation.3, 15, 17, 19, JC Penny contracted Cindy Crawford to extend her jewelry brand exclusively at their stores, while Macy’s has signed a strategic alliance agreement to become an exclusive retailer of Ellen Tracy branded women’s sportswear in spring 2010.18, 21
Yet there is another effect of the economic downturn on the rivalry among existing firms. As some retailers are closing stores, others take advantage of high vacancies in the real estate market and bargain for lower prices trying to increase their capacity in order to get market share and be at the lead when the market picks up.5, 6, 20
The Bargaining Power of Buyers…...

Similar Documents

Porter's Six Forces Analysis General Retail: Merchandise/Department Stores

...February 25, 2010 Assignment 2 Porter’s Six Forces Analysis General Retail: Merchandise/Department Stores Prepared by: Yulia Petukhova ID# A30 The department store industry will be analyzed taking department stores as players, individual consumers as buyers, and manufacturers and distributors as the key suppliers. The Rivalry among existing firms High The period from the end of the 20th century up until now has been marked by the consolidation trend in the department store industry, characterized by major acquisitions by a few larger, powerful competitors, greatly intensifying the rivalry among them.9, 13 Since there are only a few of them in the industry, they tend to match each other’s steps in some way or another. After JC Penny introduced itself to Manhattan just a block away from Macy’s, it is only a matter of short time before Kohl’s will finally announce its move into Manhattan as well.10 Slowdown in the industry growth coupled with reduced consumer spending and low switching costs intensifies rivalry even further prompting the market players to differentiate their products by introducing exclusive brands and increasing innovation.3, 15, 17, 19, JC Penny contracted Cindy Crawford to extend her jewelry brand exclusively at their stores, while Macy’s has signed a strategic alliance agreement to become an exclusive retailer of Ellen Tracy branded women’s sportswear in spring...

Words: 2385 - Pages: 10

World - Wireless Device Retail Store

...World - Wireless Device Retail Store Budget Proposal For [2011 to 2014/15] BUSN-278 [Term] Professor[name] DeVry University Table of Contents |Section |Title |Subsection |Title |Page Number | |1.0 |Executive summary | | |3 | |2.0 |Sales Forecast | | |4 | | | |2.1 |Sales Forecast |4 | | | |2.2 |Methods and Assumptions |5 | |3.0 |Capital Expenditure Budget | | |5 | |4.0 |Investment Analysis | | |6 | | | |4.1 |Cash flows |6, 7 | | | |4.2 |NPV Analysis...

Words: 1923 - Pages: 8

Choosing a Retail Store

..., refers to ‘the process of planning and executing the conception, pricing, promotion and distribution of ideas, goods and services to create exchanges that satisfy individual and organizational objectives.” Organizational buyers purchase in order to perform a task or sell a product effectively, efficiently and at a profit. They could be industrial buyers or intermediary buyers. Industrial buyers are those who purchase goods and services to be used in or to aid manufacturing process. Intermediary buyers are those (i.e. wholesalers and retailers) who buy merchandise for resale. Retailers include street Vendors, local supermarkets, department stores, restaurants, and hotels. Barbershops, airlines and even bike and car showrooms. Still retailing may or may not involve the use of a physical location. Mail and telephone orders, direct selling to consumers in their homes and offices and vending machines - all fall within the purview of retailing. In addition to it, retailing mayor may not involve a “retailer.’ Manufacturers, importers, non-profit firms and wholesalers are acting as retailers when they sell goods and/or services to final consumers. Whatever the form of retailing, a retail marketing strategy defines the execution of the marketing process and facilitation of customer satisfaction. This retail marketing strategy involves selecting a retail target market (i.e. the carefully/exactly identified group of final consumers that a retailer seeks to satisfy) and then...

Words: 21282 - Pages: 86

Case Study Frazers Department Store

... were in use at the department store. The highlighted methods were; A) Written Communications – Employee Newsletter, Door Hand Outs, Paycheck Inserts, Bulletin Boards, Intrastore Messages and Correspondence B) Meetings – Departmental Meetings, Store Meetings C) Counseling – Six month interviews, Attitude Survey D) Informal Communications – Manager / Employee Relationship, Grapevine Problems While the report was thorough and fairly well written, nearly the entire report was written from a “negative” perspective. It appeared that Ms. Prentiss found it very difficult to include any positive aspect of the communication channels currently in place at the department store. In almost every instance highlighted in A through D above, Ms. Prentiss expounded on the all of the negative faults of these communications rather than just reporting on the communication channels currently being used at the company. Affected Parties The affected parties primarily include Ms. Fiske, Mr. Stone and Ms. Prentiss; however, since several of the employees were interviewed throughout the store, I feel that the problem affected nearly all members of the organization. Since the survey that was conducted was seemingly only looking for the complaints about the communication methods, I feel that the negativity could have been passed along through the company. People who may have been feeling okay with their jobs and positions may be agitated when presented with such a negative......

Words: 490 - Pages: 2

Norton's Department Store

..., stand-alone stores are becoming obsolete, with the move to smaller, trendier locations in more accessible locations such as malls. Norton's should follow suit. 3. Once it is financially viable, an e-commerce website should be immediately created. This is assuredly the way a lot of markets are moving since "the industry is growing at about percent each year" (Das, 2005). With a future focus on an online marketplace, a lot of costs associates with expensive retail space can be substantially minimized. Evaluation of Recommended Solution: The easiest way to determine whether or not all of the changes have been effective, is simply by keeping and observing the financial records of the company. Increases in sales, market share, growth, profit margins, return on investment and other financial formulae can all indicate that measures have been effective. Other measures can include employee turnover rates and customer satisfaction ratings. A third party client can be hired to help make these findings in a fair and unbiased manner. All of these can be measured in the short term and the long term, but they will be more useful in the latter. Talking to the Norton family and getting their viewpoints on the success of the changes can be useful too. References: Das, H. (2005). Norton's Department Stores. Halifax: Sobey School of Business. Appendices: SWOT: Strengths * History of success and innovation * Established brand equity * Diverse business......

Words: 2741 - Pages: 11

Mcgregor's Ltd. Department Store

...McGregor’s Ltd. Department Store | To: | Staff members | From: | President James McGregor | Date: | 10/22/2012 | Re: | New discount program | Comments: | McGregor’s Ltd. Department Store in this year has increased in sales, and sales are above the average for retail stores; However, it has acquired the image of being old fashioned and traditional. I would like to change the image of the Store and to achieve higher efficiency and profitability by creating more business sense in the policies of the store. The outdated employee discount program is the place to start. Under the current employee’s discount program which is complex and in egalitarian, the size of the discount depends on the position of an employee, and there are six possible discounts existed. Some discounts are eating into profit margins such as major electrical appliances, calculators, cameras, and typewriters. In the other hand, salespeople, maintenance workers, and clerks are not getting a fair shake; therefore, new policy, which is more generous for most employees would encourage spending on high-profit-margin goods and increase the involvement of employees in the store and should lead to a significantly greater volume of sales. The new policy is based on simplicity, equality, and profitability. The discount would vary according to the goods purchased, not the status of the purchaser. There are three tiers in this program: 1. 10 percent discount would be given on low margin goods, such as large...

Words: 497 - Pages: 2

Aj Davis Is a Department Store Chain

...DeVry University Miami Campus Math 533, Managerial Statistics Student: Elias Hane Professor: Norman Ebsary Course Project: AJ DAVIS DEPARTMENT STORES Date: 24th of January, 2013 Introduction AJ DAVIS is a department store chain, which has many credit customers and wants to find out more information about these customers. A sample of 50 credit customers is selected with data collected on the following variables: 1. LOCATION (Rural, Urban, Suburban) 2. INCOME (in $1,000’s) 3. SIZE (Household Size, number of people living in the household) 4. YEARS (number of years that the customer has lived in the current location) 5. CREDIT BALANCE (the customers current credit card balance on the store's credit card, in $) LOCATION // INCOME ($1000) // SIZE // YEARS // CREDIT BALANCE ($) Urban | 54 | 3 | 12 | 4016 | Rural | 30 | 2 | 12 | 3159 | Suburban | 32 | 4 | 17 | 5100 | Suburban | 50 | 5 | 14 | 4742 | Rural | 31 | 2 | 4 | 1864 | Urban | 55 | 2 | 9 | 4070 | Rural | 37 | 1 | 20 | 2731 | Urban | 40 | 2 | 7 | 3348 | Suburban | 66 | 4 | 10 | 4764 | Urban | 51 | 3 | 16 | 4110 | Urban | 25 | 3 | 11 | 4208 | Urban | 48 | 4 | 16 | 4219 | Rural | 27 | 1 | 19 | 2477 | Rural | 33 | 2 | 12 | 2514 | Urban | 65 | 3 | 12 | 4214 | Suburban | 63 | 4 | 13 | 4965 | Urban | 55 | 6 | 15 | 4412 | Urban | 21 | 2 | 18 | 2448 | Rural | 44 | 1 | 7 | 2995 | Urban | 37 | 5 | 5 | 4171 | Suburban | 62 | 6 | 13 | 5678 | Urban | 21...

Words: 1803 - Pages: 8

Drug Store Eye Shadow vs. Department Store Eyeshadow

... are perfectly primped, skin smooth and beautiful, not a blotch, blemish or crease in sight. These women look just like the cover of a fashion magazine causing her to wonder if they are made of plastic. Their demeanor is welcoming as they smile warmly and offer assistance to all those who would stroll into their piece of wonderland. Everything is so brightly lit, the colors and glass display cases are arranged to flawlessly represent each company. Each brand prominently displays their bestselling products. Although so different, they all appear to seamlessly flow together. In contrast to this picture the drug store cosmetic area can be much less assaulting. As the shopper enters the store, they are greeted by the employee closest to the entrance. The greeter will probably be dressed in a vest or store logo’d, collared shirt. Any assistance given will be asked for but will not be motivated by the opportunity to gain a commission or meet a weekly quota. The cosmetic aisles in the drug stores are not very different than those found in the department stores. Like the department store, there are samples and testers for most of the products for sale, even the nail polish. The products are grouped together by manufacturer, brightly lit and appealing to the eye, minus the glass display cases. The major differences are the substantially lower prices will be clearly marked under each row of products and the absence of the eager sales associate. Eye shadows come in a...

Words: 1194 - Pages: 5

Mkt-646 Retail Store Paper

... retailer or return for additional shopping experiences with the store. As a company grows, it becomes increasingly important to focus on all of these areas. In fact, in order for a company to grow it must have a major focus on the branding and marketing techniques found most useful to business services. For example, Staples choice of lighting and use of bright iridescent lights add elegance to the products and induce a sense of quality and professionalism. This kind of lighting connects well with the office mindset of working alone at one’s desk in the late afternoon or after regular work hours. This use of lighting is especially prominent in the tablet and computer area because it increases the perceived value of a product, similar to the way led lights are found in jewelry stores to enable reflections that enhance the materials used in the chains, necklaces, etc. The spacing found throughout Staples is large. The aisles feature areas big enough to move big equipment and filled carts. The layout of the space creates friendliness as consumers are greeted by employees and other customers. Equally important is Staple’s signage, it is large and creates a very efficient way of navigating throughout store. Providing this type of self-sufficiency builds consumer confidence for when there is little time for searching out products or employee support. This will produce repeat and referral business. The quality of the merchandise relies on a...

Words: 992 - Pages: 4

Six Force Model

...Six forces model: The six forces model is a market opportunities analysis model, as an extension to Porter five forces analysis and is more robust than a standard SWOT analysis. However, factors internal to the firm, which are often perceived to be the only true sources of sustained competitive advantage (Barney, 1991) are omitted. The following forces are identified: Competition New entrants End users/buyers Suppliers Substitutes Complementary products/ the government/ the public Criticisms of the five force model: Porter's framework has been challenged by other academics and strategists such as Kevin P. Coyne and Somu Subramaniam who have stated that three dubious assumptions underlie the five forces: That buyers, competitors, and suppliers are unrelated and do not interact and collude That the source of value is structural advantage (creating barriers to entry) That uncertainty is low, allowing participants in a market to plan for and respond to competitive behavior. An important extension to Porter was found in the work of Brandenburger and Barry Nalebuff in the mid-1990s. Using game theory, they added the concept of complementors (also called "the 6th force"), helping to explain the reasoning behind strategic alliances. The idea that complementors are the sixth force has often been credited to Andrew Grove, former CEO of Intel Corporation. According to most references, the sixth force is government or the public. Martyn Richard Jones, whilst......

Words: 333 - Pages: 2

Department of the Air Force

... beginning to the act: To provide a comprehensive program for the future security of the United States; to provide three military departments: the Army, the Navy, and the Air Force; to provide for their coordination and unified direction under civilian control and to provide or the effective strategic direction and operation of the armed forces under unified control.3 Department of the Air Force The National Security Act created the civilian positions of the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of the Air Force, which are only appointed by the President. The functions assigned to the Commanding General, Army Air Forces, were to be transferred to the Department of the Air Force.4 The act provided for the orderly transfer of these functions as well as the property personnel, and records. The United States Air Force was established within the Department of the Air Force. The Army Air Forces, the Army Air Corp and the Air Force Combat Command would be transferred to the Air Force, and the agencies themselves would cease to exist.5 Under the Secretary of the Air Force, the Chief of Staff, was to command the new service. The Department of the Air Force is one of the three Military Departments within the Department of Defense of the United States of America.6 The Department of the Air Force is run by the Secretary of the Air Force, who is a civilian and has the authority to conduct all of its business, subject to the authority, direction and control of the Secretary......

Words: 2492 - Pages: 10

Retail Store Observation

...I visit a big shopping mall of my area and what I noticed there is their interesting promotional activity. The first Floor of the store was for the beauty products. There was very interesting beauty products promotional activity that I notice and I impressed a lot. What I see that there are multiple brands of beauty products available in store and every brand has their own promotional girl who applies the beauty and makeup products on customers face or give them an opportunity for trial at their own. This helps the customers to make the decision of buying those products from which they feel satisfied. Such type o marketing strategy is known as experiential marketing (Schmitt, 2000) This promotional activity benefits the retailor in many ways. It helps retailors to boost the sale. It also assist the retailors to satisfy the customers as well as it increase the percentage of loyalty of customers. It is because customers always like to test those beauty products that they tried once. It helps customers to decide about their desired products. And in future customers always like shopping in such retail store who adopts experiential marketing strategy for the sale of products. In other point of view it helps retailer to decide which products are demanded most by the customers. There are few other stores who are using experiential marketing for the sale of beauty products. Experiential marketing is very useful way to boost the sale level. It is good way to enhance customer’s......

Words: 341 - Pages: 2

General Differences Chart-Retail

...Generational Differences Chart Traditionalists Baby Boomers Generation X Millennials Birth Years 1900-1945 1946-1964 1965-1980 Current Age Famous People # 63-86 Bob Dole, Elizabeth Taylor 44-62 Bill Clinton, Meryl Streep 28-43 Barak Obama, Jennifer Lopez (1977-1994) 1981-2000 8-27 Ashton Kutcher, Serena Williams 51 Million Gen X, Xers, The Doer, Post Boomers, 13th Generation Civil Rights, Vietnam War, Sexual Revolution, Cold War/Russia, Space Travel Highest divorce rate and 2nd marriages in history. Watergate, Energy Crisis, Dual Income families and single parents, First Generation of Latchkey Kids, Y2K, Energy Crisis, Activism, Corp. Downsizing, End of Cold War, Mom’s work, Increase divorce rate. Experienced hard times while growing up which were followed by times of prosperity. Influencers 80 Million “Me” Generation, Moral Authority Raised by parents that just survived the Great Depression. Other Names Veterans, Silent, Moral Authority, Radio Babies, The Forgotten Generation WWII, Korean War, Great Depression, New Deal, Rise on Corporations, Space Age, Post War Babies who grew up to be radicals of the 70’s and yuppies of the 80’s. “The American Dream” was promised to them as children and they pursue it. As a result they are seen as being greedy, materialistic and ambitious. Their perceptions are shaped by growing up having to take care of themselves early and watching...

Words: 4654 - Pages: 19

Retail Store Database

...Fundamentals of Database Systems Individual Project: Retail Store Database Table of Contents Section 1: Project Outline 3 Project Overview 3 Section 2: Description of the Database Design Life Cycle 4 Database Design Life Cycle 4 Database Creation 7 Section 3: The Entity Relationship Diagram 9 TBD 9 Section 4: The Logical Model and Normalization 10 TBD 10 Section 5: The Microsoft Access Database 11 TBD 11 Section 6: The Microsoft Access Database Application 12 TBD 12 References 13 Section 1: Project Outline Project Overview This project will go over the process of designing a database. The database that will be designed will be a database for a typical retail store. The purpose of this database will be to manage and store the data produced or collected during normal day to day operations. Throughout the rest of this project the information and processes will be aimed toward the creation of this retail store database. This is to help provide an example of what is needed to create a database and how each process or step corresponds to each other. Section 2: Description of the Database Design Life Cycle Database Design Life Cycle In order to create a database you must understand that there are certain steps that are contained within the Database Design Life Cycle (DBLC). These seven steps help you design the database and they give a step by step process to guide you through the phases of development. These steps are listed as follows...

Words: 1683 - Pages: 7

Mcgregor's Department Store Case Analysis

...Mc Case DATE: April 19, 2016 TO: Staff and members FROM: James McGregor SUBJECT: Implementation of new policy INTRODUCTION / PROBLEM STATEMENT James McGregor is the president of McGregor. He was trying to improve sales above the average of the total retail stores for the coming years. However, the issue that he found out is about old fashioned and traditional goods. Those old fashioned goods which need to be change become fashioned affect sales keep staying. Moreover, the outdated discount policy is complex and unfair for whole employees, especially for lower level workers. More importantly, the policy stay in old fashioned idea so that it loss interested in young customers. To solve this problem, James McGregor come out new policy to make it simple and fair. The reason he think the new policy will work is it could attracts young customers and it also will help to decrease the remaining goods at inventory. FACTS AND ASSUMPTIONS 1. Goods that sold at our store is too old fashioned. There is not enough young customers and young employees willing to buy them. 2. Due to the old fashion products, it is difficult to recruit young employees or attract young staffs who already work at our store. 3. It is important to increase long term profits. 4. Lower level and maintenance staffs have not benefited from the previous policy, so that they may be stealing inventory while working. 5. It will improve the turnover of inventory. 6. The...

Words: 399 - Pages: 2