Position Power and Personal Power

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ralo729
Words 2890
Pages 12
Position Power and Personal Power

A View of Leadership vs. Management


owner

12/18/2020


GM:591: Leadership and Organizational Behavior
Instructor:

INTRODUCTION
In the past twenty to forty years, the face of corporate America has changed drastically from family owned businesses to conglomerates that absorb smaller businesses by the dozens. Those days where a person works for a single company until retirement are long gone. Retirement funds, 401k’s, investment accounts, and high efficiency technology dominate lunch counter conversations, versus our parent’s conversations about family matters and how the kids are doing. Something has been lost from those days where people actually cared about coworkers and each other. I’m sure if you would ask ten people for a reason for the lack of concern, you would get different responses. According to what I have learned through this course in Organization Behavior, all the case studies, and the research on personal and position power, I have concluded that people are not put first. This has lead to and lack of success in business as well as failures. In most recent times, Enron Corporation comes to mind, along with other companies that accepted government bailout money in order to avoid massive layoffs or closing altogether.
My group in this course chose to do the group project on position power and personal power. My individual subtopic deals with how a manager with only position power affects his/her subordinates in the work environment. This term paper will deal specifically with leadership versus management. When one thinks of power in corporate America, leadership or a lack there of comes to mind. I will distinguish the difference between traditional managers and leaders.
This subject was of particular interest to me because of a transition that has occurred within the company that I…...

Similar Documents

Power

... per Capita consumption of Electricity Year Per Capita Consumption ( kWh) (As per U. N. methodology) 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 566.7 592.0 612.5 631.5 671.9 704.2 h All India Transformation, T&D and AT&C losses : Year T&D losses 2002-03 32.54 2003-04 32.53 2004-05 31.25 2005-06 30.42 2006-07# 28.61 2007-08$ 26.91 * PFC Figs. # Provisioal $ Estimated a) All India Village Electrification (as on 30.06. 2008): b) Pumpsets Energised (as on 30.06. 2008): All India Coal Consumption for Power Generation (Utilities) YEAR Coal Cunsumption ( Million Tonnes ) 240 2001-02 2002-03 253 2003-04 263 2004-05 278 2005-06 280 302 2006-07 2007-08 330 AT&C Losses* 32.54 34.78 34.33 34.54 32.07 NA i 488353 (82.3%) 15669253 (80.0%) j k Average cost of power supply & average realization ( paise/kWh ) Year cost of supply realization(paise/unit) (paise/unit) Including Only Agriculture Agriculture 2001-02 246 181 58.67 2002-03 238 195 77.48 2003-04 239 203 72.39 2004-05 253 208 72.44 2005-06 257 220 77.80 i Power Supply Position 2008-09 (APRIL'08-JULY' 08) Region Northern Western Southern Eastern North Eastern All India Energy(MU) Deficit% Peak Deficit% Requirement Demand(MW) 71,289 -9.3 32,616 -9.8 84,108 -16.4 37,171 -25.7 67,959 -5.8 26,640 -6.0 27,418 -5.7 11,655 -7.8 3,150 -14.9 1,744 -23.0 253,924 -10.4 106,922 -14.6 ENERGY SAVED IS ENERGY PRODUCED ...

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Power

...How much position and personnel power do leaders need to be effective? Power has been the subject of much research. The purpose of this essay is to establish how much power leaders need to be effective. Although effective leaders rely more on personal power than on position power, some position is important in order to get the job done. The amount and type of power required depends on the situation, whether the influence is upward, downward or lateral, whether goal congruence exists, the size and make-up of the group as well as the targeted outcome (compliance or commitment). Too much position power should be avoided as it can lead to abuse of the power and hence negative outcomes, yet too little position power will limit a leader from being effective. Also research has found complex interrelations between power bases. Effective leaders need a moderate amount of position power to make decisions, implement changes and punish ongoing belligerent behaviour and they need fairly high level personal power to create relationships, trust and respect and persuade target persons of the benefits of undertaking a task or project and therefore obtain commitment rather than simple compliance. While effective leaders have great skills in influencing target persons, they must also be receptive to influence from others. Leadership is about influencing people to achieve the objectives and goals of the organisation, tasks or projects. Effective leaders influence subordinates to carry out...

Words: 2703 - Pages: 11

Power

...POWER PSYC 307 SPENCER NATH The word “POWER” has been defined as the ability or capability to do something. My personal definition would include the word effectively at the end of the statement as anyone has the capability to perform a task but a few can do it effectively if they possess power. The three-assigned video tutorials provided a general description of the five bases of power namely Referent, Reward, Expert, Coercive and Legitimate using a real life example of a server, his boss and a not-so-pleasant customer. The video gave me a clear understanding about the five power bases and made me realized that alongside ability, capability and effectively, the capacity to influence others is to be included in the definition. Moreover, I learnt that one does not have to be superior or hold a superior position to possess power but rather have personal sources of power. The most effective type of power from the list is the referent power category. Even though both reward and expert power have positive implication, the power is still limited to a single task rather than a long-term implication. Legitimate and coercive power seems a negative approach of using power, the outcome is simply a task done resentfully. The referent power actually makes the follower do a task because they want to. Personally, I possess a few attributions of reward and expert power. I believe in both reward and punishment, which makes it easier to transmit my power. And even......

Words: 369 - Pages: 2

Position Power and Personal Power

...Position Power and Personal Power A View of Leadership vs. Management owner 12/18/2020 GM:591: Leadership and Organizational Behavior Instructor:   INTRODUCTION In the past twenty to forty years, the face of corporate America has changed drastically from family owned businesses to conglomerates that absorb smaller businesses by the dozens. Those days where a person works for a single company until retirement are long gone. Retirement funds, 401k’s, investment accounts, and high efficiency technology dominate lunch counter conversations, versus our parent’s conversations about family matters and how the kids are doing. Something has been lost from those days where people actually cared about coworkers and each other. I’m sure if you would ask ten people for a reason for the lack of concern, you would get different responses. According to what I have learned through this course in Organization Behavior, all the case studies, and the research on personal and position power, I have concluded that people are not put first. This has lead to and lack of success in business as well as failures. In most recent times, Enron Corporation comes to mind, along with other companies that accepted government bailout money in order to avoid massive layoffs or closing altogether. My group in this course chose to do the group project on position power and personal power. My individual subtopic deals with how a manager with only position power affects his/her...

Words: 2890 - Pages: 12

Power

.... Richard wanted people to pay for the way he looked and used the crown to find happiness. He used the power of Manipulation to get a noblewoman to be his wife. Also he put out lies about his own brother, King Edward, just so the he would make his claim to become king. Richard killed whoever stood in his way or was a threat to his crown. He even had his wife Ann murdered so that he could marry young Elizabeth, his niece, to solidify his way to the throne. Once he was king, he did everything in his power to stay there. Richard was not forced to make these decisions. He made the decisions on his own to do anything he wanted. The Final Days is the true story of Germany's most famous anti-Nazi protest brought to life. Sophie Scholl was the fearless activist of the underground student resistance group, The White Rose. Firm in her convictions and loyalty to her friend, her cross-examination by the Gestapo’s quickly escalated into a intense test of will as Scholl delivered a passionate call to freedom and personal responsibility. The group wrote, printed and distributed the leaflets criticizing the Nazi regime's policy, and demanded a rise against tyranny. They distributed this leaflets at a University that they were close to, trying to deliver their message about the Nazi regime. As they were trying to deliver these leaflets they were caught by the Gestapo and put into jail and later sentenced to death by regime. Scholl and two others were interrogated for days. Later her and her......

Words: 1890 - Pages: 8

Power

...Kimani Sherrill May 6th, 2013 Dr. Mirescu Final Exam Relating Power to Political Identity What I shall attempt to do in this paper is display my knowledge of the definition of power. I will also attempt to discuss the different theories of power looked at during this course and apply them to another familiar topic, political identity. I will pick one of the many theories of power we looked at and explain how it relates to political identity. Political identity and power are directly proportional. The more power one has, the more vivid political identity he will have. The more clear political identity one has, the easier it is to gain power. Before discussing and applying power to political identity, I will explain each topic, for one may question the importance of engaging in either of the topics. After referring to Webster's Dictionary, the definition of power is the ability to do something or act in particular way. Power is also the capacity or ability to direct or influence the behavior of others or a course of events. Human power is very important to us. We utilize power as a way to feel superior to other humans who do not have the resources, or means to obtain power. Humans without power often need guidance, people to follow, look up to, and listen to. Political identity in the most obvious sense describes one of the different parties that one can possibly belong to. However, any part of ones identity used to vote can be considered a political identity...

Words: 1897 - Pages: 8

Power

...Social psychology examines the influence of groups on the developing self as well as the influence that an individual has on group. Although those with those with good intentions should use power with virtue, many of the world’s most powerful people use power in ways that purposefully harm other people. Social power refers to the force available to the influence in motivating change A power- abusing “religious” leader is Reverend Jim Jones, born 1931 in Crete, Indiana a rural community (Wikipedia). Jones was a voracious reader as a child studying Joseph Statin, Karl Marx, Mahatma Gandhi and Adlof Hitler (Reiterman, Tim and John Jacobs).He studied each carefully, noting their strengths and weaknesses. In psychological term this is referring to as behaviorism According to his childhood acquaintances, they recalled Jones as being a “really weird kid” who was “obsessed with religion….obsessed with death…” (Catherine Wessinger). In human, awareness of the fact that one is acting deceptively often leads to telltale signs of deception. Therefore, if self-deception enables someone to believe their distortions, they will not present such signs of deception and will therefore appear to be telling the truth. As known in psychology this referred to as Delusional Disorder, it was note that he might have this disorder. “Individuals with delusional disorder are not always dangerous, but they can be when they act on their delusions” (B.Lahey). “As a young man...

Words: 1190 - Pages: 5

Power

...Man is born with a certain capability to know things in life such as common knowledge. He is born with the knowledge to distinguish good from bad and right from wrong. Man knows certain things other then this like what is true and untrue. This is my belief and other people who believe the rationalist thinking such as Descartes. A man already has an innate sense of the beings and things around which means that man has common knowledge. Human’s minds are very similar and drastically different when it really comes down to it. Certain people perceive things differently then others do and may have different thoughts on a certain subject. One thing that remains true however is that people perceive common things the same way. Such as one person can distinguish two different things and another person could come up and see the same thing and be able to tell the difference as well. This comes from mans already known knowledge of his/her surroundings and senses. Because if man didn’t know anything when he was born how would we be able to live? Without being born with some innate knowledge of our surroundings we couldn’t even begin our days. Imagine waking up in the morning and knowing a thing about the things that would be around you. You would be terrified and not know what to do and just utterly confused. It is my personal belief that we know certain things through our beliefs in religion. Because God in the Christian faith created all things and gave man the...

Words: 802 - Pages: 4

Power

...Do you agree that power, unlike authority, should apply only to relationships where there is a conflict of interests?It could be said, that politics is the studyof the locus of power - where power lies, or should lie. This encompasses all the main questions of political theory: Liberty, in to what extent the state should have power over the individual; justice, in looking at in what circumstances power has been used illegitimately; democracy, inthe mechanisms of how state power should be rightly yielded. Even topics such as the communitarian/liberal debate can be seen to boil down to a question of power, in this case, similar to the study of liberty, the balance between individual andcommunity power is at the core of this question.The question above raises a specific point about the actual definition of power, to what extent is the concept of power inherently linked to a 'conflict of interests'. This question requires a close examination of power itself, and the first step in doing this is to look at Steven Lukes' distinction between one-, two-, and three-dimensionalviews of power.In his seminal work, Power: A Radical View, Lukes goes about deriving a definition of power in three stages. The first is the 'one-dimensional' definition of power. This is based on attempts by political scientists such as Dahl to define power in such a way so that it is possible toobserve how power operates in empirical examples. The core of this view of power isthe statement 'A has power over B...

Words: 1827 - Pages: 8

Power

...The Alcan Case Description This case describes the evolution of IT management at Alcan during the period from 2006-2007. At that time, IT governance and the IT function itself were undergoing a complete transformation. The case follows the Vice-President of Corporate Information Technology from the time of his arrival at Alcan: his observations on the current state of IT management, his appointment to the position of Chief Information Officer and the development of his new strategic plan for IT management. Part A presents the main features and challenges of IT management at Alcan up until the middle of 2006.. Students are encouraged to reflect on the characteristics, implications and challenges represented by IT management in a large global organization. To which quadrant It belongs to In order to identify the class in which Alcan belongs to, we need to understand the specific business characteristics Rate of change in Alcan: Alcan belongs to the aluminium industry which involves mining and manufacturing: 1. Typically this kind of an industry is a stagnant and slow moving in terms of technological adoption and new process introductions 2. It depends on macro economic scenarios and industry performance is effected directly with the international pricing fluctuations 3. Slow rate of growth 4. Customer needs and preferences are not shifted rapidly 5. Dependent on government regulations 6. Competitive landscape is...

Words: 1260 - Pages: 6

Power

...Q2: There are a variety of definitions of power. Using these definitions analyse and discuss how you observe power being exercised in the world as you experience it. The term “power” has a number of different meanings and definitions relating to all aspects of life. In Kenneth E. Boulding’s book “The Three Faces of Power” he writes, “The various forms of power act and interact on each other so significantly that if the study of power were confined to a single aspect of it, … , much would be lost in the understanding of the over dynamics of the system.” Boulding broadly defines power as the ability of people to get that which they desire. In the context of politics; power concerns all social activities at each level of society. In a sense; politics is power i.e. “The ability to achieve a desired outcome, through whatever means” (Haywood, 2002). Politics can be seen as the fight for scarce resources, and the power lies in the ability to conduct and control this struggle. However power must not be confused with “force”, a much narrower concept, as this is “linked to the concept of domination, which, indeed is only a small part of the general nature of power”(Boulding, 1990). In this essay I am going to discuss some of the different definitions and aspects of power, referring mainly to the “Faces” of power, and giving examples of my observations of different types of power being exercised in the world today. The idea of power is key to the understanding of politics for...

Words: 1580 - Pages: 7

Power

...The Balance of Power The older we get, the more we end up realizing how adults have the power to effect our decisions. We start off pushing them and their opinions away, wanting the freedom to do and make it by ourselves, but as we grow up, we start to hesitate and question ourselves: are we making the right decision? Just a couple of weeks ago, the deadline for college application was coming up, and I needed to make up my mind quickly, Vanier or Champlain? Which would be the better fit? And as I looked to my dad for his guidance and good judgement, a part of me wished that he would make up my mind for me, instead of just giving me his valued opinion. But as teenagers, we are often faced with our parents pulling the “Because I’m your parent!” card, and this has often led me thinking; how much power do we really give away to them? Do we decide whether they have the power over us, or is it just an unspoken rule that their decisions simply over rule ours? As I grew up I came to the conclusion that whether it’d be we give them the power or if it’s an unspoken rule, whatever the case is, is that it simply doesn’t matter. “Their knowledge itself is power”- Francis Bacon. If we think, at one point in our parents’ lives, they had to make the same exact decision that we are being faced with, whether it’d be college applications or moving out, they have been there and they do know what is best for us. We need a balance of power to guide us on to the...

Words: 605 - Pages: 3

Power

...Valeriia Karpenko ENC 1101 Professor Spera 6 October 2014 Power Every day people see “power” around themselves. When they go to work or school, when they walk into their classrooms, auditoriums, or offices, the first that they encounter is power. Power is everywhere. Power permeates every piece of the Earth. Power is on the radio and television, in your heart and thoughts. The definition of power is controversial because power is a loose concept that includes material and mental aspects. Commonly, people believe that power is connections, a successful career, and money. As a matter of fact, it is correct. Knowing “right people”, in most of cases, eventually leads to quick getting up the career ladder. It goes without saying that the higher position you take the more money you make, and money is a factor in many things that happen. People who have money also have certainty and confidence in their present and future life. Indeed, families with money can afford living in safe and nice neighborhoods without having to worry about being robbed or killed every day. Besides, they can meet the expenses of education, thus they have bigger chances of getting in prestigious universities even than people who has ever had only “A”. Also, the rich can see all the beauty of the world because there are no financial issues that would interfere with their traveling and visiting any place of our planet. All these factors give them...

Words: 587 - Pages: 3

Power

... * Actively applying legitimate and coercive power to influence others * Reminding the target of his or her obligations, frequently checking the target’s work, confronting the target, using threats of sanction * Applies or threatens to apply punishment if the target does not comply * Information control * Translates to influence when the power holder selectively distributes information * Keeping others in the dark if it helps ones own cause * Coalition formation * When one lacks power, forming a coalition of people to support * Influential in three ways * Pools the power and resources of many people for the coalition to have more influence * Mere existence can be a source of power by symbolizing legitimacy * Tap into the power of the social identity process * Upward appeal * Calling on higher authority or expertise or symbolically relying on these sources to support the influencers position * Reminding others that your request is consistent with the org overarching goals * Soft influence tactics: more on personal sources of power * Persuasion * One of the most effective influence strategies for career success * Ability to present facts, logical arguments, emotional appeals to change a persona’s attitudes * Effectiveness as an......

Words: 1425 - Pages: 6

Power

... hug. The stick and the carrot are familiar metaphors, the first for force and the second for enticement. The third is for a form of power which Boulding claims to be the most-often used -- integrative or collaborative power.[5] Coercive power, as mentioned above, is the form most meant when one refers to power. Coercive power is based on superior strength, often in the form of physical strength or superior arms. While the stick is its metaphor, force can be achieved through less overtly violent means, as, for example, when the necessities of life are withheld or when someone is embarrassed into submission. Coercion is often accomplished without the actual infliction of force. The mere threat of its use, when believed, can be sufficient to obtain compliance. The chapter on coercive and threat power will deal with this spectrum of power. The carrot represents a much gentler type of power, one that relies on a variety of exchange and reward possibilities. Oftentimes, an exchange is made or implied. Person A does the bidding of Person B because of something Person A will do in return. Global economies are run largely on the basis of exchange power. So, too, on a more personal level, are much of day-to-day finances. Workers perform their tasks in exchange for the pay they are given. A worker may choose to meet an early deadline requested by a manager in order to receive the manager's appreciation, perhaps even a raise or promotion. This spectrum of reasons that people...

Words: 2563 - Pages: 11