Free Essay

Poverty Measurement

In: Science

Submitted By moh0333
Words 1497
Pages 6
In order to understand poverty one must be able to identify exactly what it is, in the oxford dictionary the definition of poverty is ‘the condition of being extremely poor’. But then one must question what is defined as poor? I will be looking at two approaches of this question, the first is the ‘monetary approach’ and the second is the ‘capabilities approach’. I will also be analysing two different measures of poverty, ‘absolute’ and ‘relative’ and to conclude which is a more accurate or a more suitable instrument in poverty measure.
The monetary approach is probably the most common method of understanding poverty. It is highly used by economists and is significantly connected with microeconomic theory. Utility maximisation is the base for this approach and the main instrument used is a poverty line; this sets a threshold where if income or consumption is below, people are then classified as poor. An example of this would be the ‘dollar a day’ where any income below $1 a day is classified as poor. This approach suggests that income or consumption is equivalent to well-being. In developing countries measuring welfare with consumption would be more appropriate than using income, as income is a small component and would be an overestimate. There is plenty of data which can be analysed at household levels. However, poverty is an individual phenomenon where individuals are situated within households. After assuming some measurements between income and consumption, data at the household level can be changed to an individual level by using empirical tools which are ‘equivalence of scales’. Since this approach portrays well-being with income or consumption it may not be suitable as the world is more complex. Human interaction and social behaviour varies significantly which means there are many critiques to this approach. This approach is strongly linked to utility, and utility on its own may not be enough to measure welfare. Overall the monetary approach poses some restrictions and limitations to understanding poverty. Income alone cannot be used as a measure in the real world, social relations are not included and there are many different types of welfare not being considered. These negative aspects make the monetary approaches of understanding poverty quite misleading. Work by Amartya Sen (1992) states that welfare is not limited to obtaining utility, even though it is very important there are other aspects that also have important parts. Another critique is that according to microeconomics, people always have different preferences. Another is that utility maximisation is limited, finally poverty is multidimensional and for it to be seen from a monetary view is also makes it limited.
Since ‘Sen’ criticised this approach, arguing that the possession of commodities does not necessarily mean welfare and this depends on personal or social characteristics, he pioneered the ‘capabilities approach’. This suggests that well-being can be measured by one being able to reach certain goals. Where in this approach, monetary situations are ’one of the many’ factors which are related to well-being. Everywhere in the world is different, therefore well-being is dependent on a person’s ability to achieve these goals. The commodities or wealth people have or their mental reactions (utility) are an inappropriate focus because they provide only limited or indirect information about how well a life is going (Alkire, S., 2002). An example of this would be a standard bicycle, it has the characteristics of transportation but the question is will it actually provide this transportation? This is dependent on the characteristics of the user of the bicycle. It does make one’s life easier by increasing mobility; however this will be of no use for a person without legs (Sen, A., 1992). The ability to reach a goal using a commodity is called a ‘functioning’, this is not the same as capability. The difference is that capability is the potential to achieve; however on the other hand functioning is when one actually does achieve (Basu, K., 1987). Sen argues that individual welfare is about capability, this is different from the monetary approach of utility maximisation and the possession of commodities. The greatest thing about Sen’s approach is its flexibility, this allows a researcher to use it in many different contexts (Alkire, S., 2002) meaning there is no certain list of capabilities in order to have a good well-being. The capabilities approach has also has quite a few criticisms, one of these is that it is not easy to identify the basic capabilities which are needed for one not to be in poverty, the main criticism to this point is that Sen has not stated a list of the capabilities needed to define well-being (Nussbaum, M., 1988). Another issue brought about by Thomas Pogge is ‘how should capabilities be weighed against each other and non-capability concerns?’ (Pogge, T,. 2002). Another problem is that in order to measure capabilities there would be the need of a significant amount of information and in many cases the indicators are not available (Clark, D,. 2005). Despite the limits of this approach, it is still a very good theory and contributes significantly to understanding poverty.
The approach one uses to define poverty is very important as the type of approach taken can have a huge effect on empirical studies and the understanding of poverty determinants. There have been significant differences in past empirical studies on poverty; this is due to the approaches that have been taken resulting in different outcomes. Some claim that poverty in the developing world has declined (Deaton, A,. 2002). While on the other hand there are others which argue that poverty in developing countries has in fact increased (Ravillion, M., 2003). The different approaches of poverty can identify different things; the monetary approach can identify a lack of income or consumption, while the capabilities approach can identify a lack of public services. There are many advantages and drawbacks to both the approaches, however if one wants to find out how macro-economic variables can affect well-being then it would be more suitable to define poverty using the monetary approach (which is an absolute measurement of poverty). This is because there is a vast amount of data to analyse from, Deaton (2005) states that the methods are very clear and simple (such as dollar a day poverty line) and one would be able to facilitate comparisons across time and countries.
There are many conflicts and debates over the measurement of poverty, is it absolute or is it relative? According to a report by ‘Shaohua Chen and Martin Ravallion’ the approach of relative poverty measurement has been more common in the Western European region. The poverty line is set at a constant proportion of the country’s mean or median income. On the other hand the approach of absolute poverty measure has been adopted in wealthier countries such as the US and other developing countries. This is more of a monetary approach and as previously stated this is where one can employ the World Bank’s dollar a day poverty line. One can observe and understand the difference in two ways, the poverty line selected can be a substitute of well-being, or the selected poverty line can be seen as a social norm. However it is obvious that the social norms between wealthier societies are completely different to those of a poor one, in this case poverty is then relative. On the other hand a lower poverty line in a poor society is no longer consistent; this means that two people with the same well-being can be totally different depending on their location. Moreover, the use of an absolute rather than a relative poverty line seems to be more relevant in the case of developing countries, where large parts of the population survive on low levels of consumption (Coudouel et al., 2002).

Alkire, S., 2002, Valuing Freedoms: Sen's Capability Approach and Poverty Reduction, New York: Oxford University Press.
Sen, A., 1980, “Equality of What?” in McMurrin (ed.), Tanner Lectures on Human Values, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sen, A. (1987). “Commodities and capabilities”. New Delhi, Oxford University Press.
Basu, K. (1987). "Achievements, capabilities and the concept of well-being: a review of Commodities and Capabilities by Amartya Sen." Social Choice and Welfare.
Nussbaum, M., 1988, “Nature, Functioning and Capability: Aristotle on Political Distribution,” Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy.
Thomas Pogge. 2002. “Can the Capability Approach Be Justified?” Philosophical Topics
Clark, D A. "Sen's Capability Approach and the Many Spaces of Human Well-Being." Journal of Development Studies (2005).
Deaton, A.S (2002). “Is World Poverty Falling?” Finance and Development: A Quarterly Magazine of the IMF.
“Measuring Poverty in a Growing World (or Measuring Growth in a Poor World),” The
Review of Economics and Statistics, 87(1), 1–19, 2005.
Ravallion, M. (2003) “The debate on globalisation poverty and inequality: Why Measurement Matter”, International Affair Vol. 79.
Chen, S. & Ravallion, M. (2012). “More Relatively-Poor People in a Less Absolutely-Poor World” Policy Research Working Paper 6114

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Poverty

...| Economics vs. Poverty | | | Cindy Moore | 12/2/2012 | | Poverty has several definitions however it basically means “a state of privation or lack of the usual or socially acceptable amount of money or material possessions.” There is no universally accepted definition of “socially acceptable money or material possessions” that exists because poverty is a relative concept. In other poorer countries it is said to mean living at the brink of subsistence, while in America many suffer from undernourishment, not many confront starvation. A key concern in the area of poverty is the reality of inequality. Inequality has been and continues to be a problem in all societies. There is no society that distributes income evenly. In spite of all the theoretical and technical problems of measurement, the government has developed a widely cited poverty index that reflects the diverse intake requirements of families depending on their size, sex, age and family location, while also surveying the gender of the head of household. Based on previous surveys, the creators of the poverty index determined that families of three or more persons would spend approximately one-third of their income on food. Based on the poverty index the poverty level for these families would be set at three times the cost of the economy food plan. For smaller families and people who lived alone, the cost of economy food plan were multiplied at higher factors taking in consideration larger......

Words: 1449 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Poverty

...Alleviating poverty is one of the major obstacles to achieving sustainability as, “ it is widely acknowledged that poverty is one source of environmental degradation (United Nations 2009). In its report, “Our Common Future”, The Brundtland Commission refers to poverty “as being the major cause and effect of global environmental problems. It is therefore futile to attempt to deal with environmental problems without a broader perspective that encompasses the factors underlying world poverty and international equality” ( United Nations 2009) But, just what exactly is poverty and what is the impact it has on business. For most, the definition of poverty centres on the economic notion of income poverty which is defined by, where there is the non- existence of food, money, housing and clothing. Simplified, poverty is often understood as having insufficient money to provide the basics of everyday life. However poverty is much broader than that and is a concept with “many faces that mirror dimensions of human welfare” (Sudan Institutional Capacity program Food Security Information for Action 2011) At the UN’s World Summit on Social Development, the ‘Copenhagen Declaration’ described poverty as “…a condition characterised by severe deprivation of basic human needs, including food, safe drinking water, sanitation facilities, health, shelter, education and information. It depends not only on income but on access to social services. When people are unable to eat, go to school...

Words: 2362 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Poverty

...Poverty Student’s names Professor’s name Course Title Poverty Poverty is a state of not accessing basic needs such as food, clothing, and shelter. Poverty is primarily caused by hunger, illness, and thirst and affects the entire society by generating many problems and making people to live substandard lives. It is normally classified in absolute and relative poverty. Absolute poverty refers to a state of not being able to obtain basic needs such as food, shelter and clothing that are very important in sustaining life. Relative poverty, on the other hand, is a state of not being able to obtain resources in relation to a certain mean resource and normally applies to people who are not able to meet societal social needs. According to Townsend (1979), a family is considered to be in relative poverty if it is not able to afford the required diet, get involved in societal activities, and use basic health and educational facilities. Problems connected to poverty bring political, economic, and social disorder in the society. There are two theories that apply to poverty; conflict theory and structural theory. Conflict theory explains that poverty leads to class conflict in a society (Giddens & Simon, 2006). This comes as a result of the oppression of the poor by the rich. It says that conflict must remain in order to create a positive change in the society and that the wide gap between the rich and the poor is very significant. Structural......

Words: 1064 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Poverty

...How are different governments trying to solve poverty compared to Hong Kong’s in the past 10 years? What is poverty? Poverty is about not having enough money to meet basic needs including food, clothing and shelter.  However, poverty is more, much more than just not having enough money. In addition to a lack of money, poverty is about not being able to participate in recreational activities; not being able to send children on a day trip with their schoolmates or to a birthday party; not being able to pay for medications for an illness.  These are all costs of being poor. Those people who are barely able to pay for food and shelter simply can’t consider these other expenses.  Global perspective Many countries around the world have people living under the poverty line. But many countries in Africa are suffering major cases of poverty. There are other bigger countries that suffer major cases of poverty such as India and China. In this essay I will be focusing on how India, China and the United States of America try to solve poverty in their countries. The United States of America has a population of 317,128,000, which is the third biggest country in the world after China and India. In 2008 35% if the American population lived in poverty and now in 2013 around 15% live in poverty which a huge improvement. Kiryas Joel, New York is a city in the United States, which has the lowest GDP (Gross Domestic Product), with a population over 10,000. The main reasons......

Words: 1329 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Measurement

...Vershire also has some issues on the performance measurement report and evaluation system. Besides the inefficient way to measure manufacturing efficiency, performances of plant managers are measured based on the metric that they cannot directly control, i.e. sales. Therefore the related compensation packages and promotions mislead and lack sufficient incentives to motivate plant managers. As illustrated before, it is inappropriate to treat a plant as a profit center, rather than an expense center. Due to the manufacturing nature, plants have fully control on costs and should be motivated to lower the cost to make contributions to the revenue. Monthly performance evaluation report and supporting report for a plant showing both sales and costs in Exhibit 2 and 3 are submitted by each plant and reviewed by corporate management. Items that failed to meet the budgeted targets require explanations from plant managers, no matter it is cost-related or sales-related. Moreover, sales report on plant basis is confusing by itself since products are sold on district basis. The sales department had sole responsibility for the price and delivery schedules, which are not identical in each order because of contingencies such as traffic, weather, and sick staff. Plant managers have no way to explain the detailed decision making process of sales department to provide a sufficient explanation to sales failures without asking sales department. Furthermore, second-hand information tends to be......

Words: 629 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Poverty

...Institute for Research on Poverty Discussion Paper no. 1044-94 Long-Term Poverty and Child Development in the United States: Results from the NLSY Sanders Korenman Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs and Center for Population Analysis and Policy University of Minnesota Jane E. Miller Institute for Health, Health Care Policy, and Aging Research Rutgers University John E. Sjaastad Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs University of Minnesota September 1994 This research was funded by a grant from the Institute for Research on Poverty at the University of Wisconsin. An earlier version of part of this paper appeared as part of Office of Population Research Working Paper No. 93-5, Princeton University, June 1993, which contains supplemental analyses and is available from the authors. We thank participants in seminars at the University of Maryland, the University of Michigan, Princeton University, the National Bureau of Economic Research in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and the 1993 meetings of the Population Association of America for their comments. Abstract The authors describe developmental deficits in early childhood associated with long-term poverty in the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth (NLSY). They compare estimates of the effects of long-term poverty (based on a thirteen-year average of income) to estimates of the effects of poverty based on a single year of income (at the time of developmental assessment). They find substantial developmental deficits......

Words: 4410 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Poverty and

...SUMMARY OF RESULTS OF THE SURVEY Franco Viciani Kostas G. Stamoulis Alberto Zezza Franco Viciani nd Alberto Zezza are consultants, and Kostas G. Stamoulis is a Senior Economist, Agriculture and Economic Development Analysis Division (ESA), FAO, Rome. | 1. Introduction 2. Poverty, Inequality and Food Insecurity 3. Policy Reforms Affecting Agriculture and Rural Development, and Changes in the Role of the State 4. Globalization and International Trade Liberalization 5. Increasing Agricultural Production: Sustainability and Technology Changes 1. INTRODUCTION The first step in the CUREMIS exercise was a survey conducted among all the regional and sub-regional policy officers and outposted staff of the Economic and Social Department of FAO. The survey was based on a questionnaire which was distributed to them and was structured around "major trends affecting food, agriculture and rural development" as identified in the process of preparing the FAO Strategic Framework, namely: * changes in the role and functions of the state and implication for food, agriculture and rural development * trade liberalization, globalization and increased reliance on regional blocks * persistence of poverty, mounting inequality, food insecurity and continuing risks of emergencies * population growth, urbanization and related changes in demand on agriculture; increasing pressure on natural resources and the environment * research and technology development and......

Words: 14312 - Pages: 58

Premium Essay

Poverty

...Poverty Reduction Strategy and Poverty Monitoring: Philippine Case Study By Celia M. Reyes and Lani E. Valencia* I. Introduction The overarching goal of development efforts is the improvement in the quality of life of the people. The Philippines is no exception. Being one of the nations who participated in the Millenium Summit in September 2000, it has committed to achieve 48 targets including eradication of poverty. In addition to international commitments, the Philippines has been working toward poverty reduction for decades. It has even included targets on human development and poverty reduction in its medium-term development plans. The growing consensus is towards a comprehensive approach to poverty reduction. Rapid and sustained economic growth is needed to improve the quality of life of the population; at the same time targeted interventions aimed at reducing poverty are needed to reach the very poor and marginalized sectors of the economy. With poverty reduction as main goal of the government, the demand for poverty statistics has become more important. Several poverty monitoring systems are being conducted both at the national and community level providing income and non-income based measures of poverty. These have become the basis for social and economic development plans and programs of national and local governments. The objectives of this paper are to examine the poverty situation in the Philippines and to assess the country’s poverty reduction strategy and......

Words: 9270 - Pages: 38

Premium Essay

Measurement of Poverty

...Measurement of poverty By Name: Course code+ Name: Professor: Institution: City and State: Date: Measurement of Poverty Over the past few decades, there have been dramatic socio-economic and environmental changes around the globe. This has affected phenomena such as growth of the population, rapid urban development, and increased levels of poverty (D’Ambrosio, Deutsch and Silber, 2011). It has also influenced the changes in climatic conditions, increased natural calamities which impact the socio-economic development in different parts of the world. As a result, more people have been exposed to the negative effects of the occurrence of different hazards (D’Ambrosio, Deutsch and Silber, 2011). This leaves the affected populations suffering in poverty, thus increasing their numbers. Increased levels of poverty led to the formation of policies by the United Nations to combat the rising cases of poverty with the aim of reducing the number of people living in poverty by halve before the year 2015. Formulation of the millennium development goals which features the quantitative objectives and indicators set to measure the progress towards the war on poverty eradication took course. To establish the level of poverty in the society, therefore, measurement should be performed severally using a number of available tools (Davidson and Duclos, 2000). This will aid in determination of the extent of its effects throughout the world. This paper aims at discovering the......

Words: 3454 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Poverty

...Poverty Poverty has been a consistent problem throughout history. No matter what the average income, unemployment or overall prosperity level is, there will always be people who are homeless and hungry. Despite being one of the most richest countries in the world, the United States is not immune to it either. Even today, there are still people struggling to find shelter, feed their kids and find warm clothing. This social problem has various impacts on different institutions and people. However, there are feasible solutions that are available to dissolve this social problem. In discussing poverty in the United States, I will be utilizing three major perspectives: the general condition, the emerging middle class poverty and the relationship between small businesses and strategic measures to eradicate poverty. According to Howard Glennerster in United States Poverty Studies and Poverty Measurement: The past twenty five years, poverty has been a steady condition in United States history. Not only that, but today there is even more discussion focused on the “culture and race of poverty” (Glennerster, 10). More and more aid seems to be going to minorities in which there is a high density. Moreover, the attention has also been placed on women on welfare. This segment of the population has retracted to working multiple jobs while taking care of children (Glennerster, 13). Therefore, in the mainstream sense of the term, Glennerster attributed a majority poverty related issues to......

Words: 520 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Poverty

... 10-30-15 Poverty in the United States Arkansas is the second among states with the highest poverty rates, at 17.3 percent. The patterns of poverty in Arkansas have established and varied over time in relation to the physical characteristics of the state and to changes in economic and political behavior. Poverty is the high and low in different Arkansas counties. The counties with the highest poverty rates, in Arkansas, are Lee, Phillips, Lincoln, and Desha. The counties with the lowest poverty rates, in Arkansas, are Saline, Benton, Grant, and Lonoke. Only these four counties had poverty rates lower than the national average. Saline, Grant, and Lonoke counties benefit from their proximity to Little Rock (Maher, Daniel). In 2008 in Arkansas, most whites were in poverty. Within the population of those in poverty, whites made up most of the percentage in poverty. However, blacks came close with whites for being in poverty. Then, Latinos came last for being in poverty. Whites have obviously made up most of those in poverty (Maher, Daniel). Women and Children have made up a part of those in poverty in Arkansas. The gap of income variances between women and men means women are in more poverty then men are. In Arkansas, almost 19 percent of women are living in poverty, whereas only 14 percent of men are living in it. Children in Arkansas living in poverty under the age of 18 is almost 25 percent (Maher, Daniel). Arkansas, in poverty, is a......

Words: 694 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Poverty

...War on Poverty Begun officially in 1964, the War on Poverty was an ambitious governmental effort to address the problem of persistent poverty in the United States. Over the next decade, the federal government—in conjunction with state and local governments, nonprofit organizations, and grassroots groups—created a new institutional base for antipoverty and civil rights action and, in the process, highlighted growing racial and ideological tensions in American politics and society. Marked by moments of controversy and consensus, the War on Poverty defined a new era for American liberalism and added new layers to the American welfare state. Legislatively, the first two years were the most active. Between President Lyndon Johnson’s State of the Union address in 1964 and the liberal setbacks suffered in the congressional elections of 1966, the Johnson administration pushed through an unprecedented amount of antipoverty legislation. The Economic Opportunity Act (1964) provided the basis for the Office of Economic Opportunity (OEO), the Job Corps, Volunteers in Service to America (VISTA), Upward Bound, Head Start, Legal Services, the Neighborhood Youth Corps, the Community Action Program (CAP), the college Work-Study program, Neighborhood Development Centers, small business loan programs, rural programs, migrant worker programs, remedial education projects, local health care centers, and others. The antipoverty effort, however, did not stop there. It encompassed a range of Great......

Words: 3201 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Poverty

...Assignment 1: Investigate a Social Issue Part 1 Poverty Author: Josue Benitez Instructor: Tasha Anderson SOC100030VA016-1122-001: Intro To Sociology Publish Date: 03/17/2012 1 Abstract In this report we will define poverty in society, as well as describe the affects that it has on society today. We will also discuss how society has changed over time in regards to poverty. In addition, we will attempt to find at least two possible solutions to improve the social issue of poverty that is affecting mankind on a global scale. 2 Poverty When some people live below a level which a society defines as a reasonable minimum, they are in poverty, but there is no agreement on how to define it more precisely. Poverty is often identified as a lack of resources or its causes, or its deleterious consequences in human experience or behavior, but meanings and usages change over time. Debate often focuses on people in poverty (the poor) or disparate measurement methods rather than the concept of poverty itself. Many incompatible discourses are separately but simultaneously used to discuss its forms, dimensions, causes and cures, and to address different audiences in the industrialized societies and in developing nations, with little attempt to integrate the approaches. Until the twentieth century, poverty was used to describe the conditions in which much of the......

Words: 1238 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Poverty

...It has always become hard to explain what poverty is, and the cause. Poverty has lots of different definitions which resulted from different understandings or perspectives of people. Poverty is an age-old concern’, however, we cannot talk about any common or general reason of poverty. We can find many different reasons that engendering poverty and it is obvious that in every different age, the causes of poverty are changing. So, the dynamics of societies and relations are very effective factor that directly affecting poverty. This assumption seems more accurate for especially capitalist era. Naturally, there could be many different reasons of poverty between nations or within nations. However, I think capitalist production relations and the structure of global economy are the most effective factors that create poverty in all around the world. According to an article in the New York time, written by Paul Krugman in 2008, “Poverty is Poison”. The article states that according to neuroscientists “many children growing up in very poor families with low social status experience unhealthy levels of stress hormones, which impair their neural development.” The effect is to impair language development and memory and hence the ability to escape poverty for the rest of the child’s life. I think this has great impact on both poverty among nations and poverty within nations. Poverty among nations can be thought as a direct result of the structure of global economy. Rich and......

Words: 1159 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Measurement

...MEASUREMENT: Measurement is the heart of scientific discipline. It is the process of assigning numbers to objects or observations, the level of measurement being a function of the rules under which the numbers are assigned. According to Zikmund, “Measurement is the process of describing some property of a phenomenon of interest, usually by assigning numbers in a reliable and valid way”. In our daily life we are said to measure when we use some yardsticks to determine weight, height or some other features of a physical object. We also measure when we judge how well we like a song, intelligence, achievement, attitude, perception regarding quality. We, thus, measure physical object as well as abstract concepts. Measurement is a relatively complex & demanding task, especially so when it concerns qualitative or abstract phenomena. So, technically speaking, measurement is a process of mapping aspects of a domain onto other aspects of a range according to some rule of correspondence. It is a collection of quantitative data. TYPES OF MEASUREMENT: 1) Nominal measurement: All qualitative measurements are nominal, regardless of whether the categories differ from one another only in names. Nominal measurements represent the most elementary level of measurement in which values are assigned to an object for identification or classification purposes only. In nominal level of measurement, the categories differ from one another only in names. In other words, one category of a......

Words: 4319 - Pages: 18