Free Essay

Proctor & Gamble Competitive Intelligence Case

In: Business and Management

Submitted By tleeder83
Words 926
Pages 4
Proctor & Gamble Competitive Intelligence Case
Tristen Leeder
RES/351
January 14, 2013
Instructor: Steve Roussas

Abstract In this paper I will show the usefulness of corporate intelligence. While this tool

is helpful in making solid business decisions effort needs to go into monitoring of the

gathering process. Intelligence gathered by unethical means does more harm to an

organization then good. The financial repercussions of involvement in corporate spying

are steep, and the damage it does to an organizations reputation can take years to repair.

Management teams must continually monitor how intelligence is gathered to make

corporate intelligence work for their benefit. Proctor & Gamble Competitive Intelligence Case

In spring of 2001 John Pepper, then chair of Procter and Gamble was

faced with a dilemma (Tuck School). It had been brought to light that P&G’s competitive

analysis department had engaged in corporate spying (CNN). An outside firm hired by

P&G had engaged in spying on Unilever, P&G’s main competitor in the hair care

industry. According to Jordan and Finkelstein “the spying operation gathered about

eighty documents detailing Unilever’s plans for its U.S. hair care business over the next

three years, including information on its launch-plans, prices, and margins (Tuck School,

p. 1).”

In April 1999 John Pepper was the keynote speaker at an SCIP CEO

Roundtable, held in Montreal. In his address Mr. Pepper honed in on the growing

importance of Corporate Intelligence, or “Business Intelligence” as he referred to it, in

the shaping of corporate strategy (speech). Competitive Intelligence, in Mr. Peppers

opinion must be a focal point of management. Proper utilization of Competitive

Intelligence leads to swift change; setting the pace, not keeping pace, in the marketplace

(speech).

With such a passion for the evolving industry of Corporate Intelligence, and a

high level of commitment to implementing CI into the business structure of Proctor and

Gamble, what would move John Pepper to admit that Proctor and Gamble had gone too

far? Proper use of a tool is a key to success. A misused tool can lead to harm. This was

the case with Proctor and Gamble. The management team at Proctor and Gamble misused

the tool of competitive intelligence.

Corporate Intelligence

Obtaining intelligence on competition is a key success in the competitive business

environment. Stephen Miller, in his overview of competitive intelligence defined

competitive intelligence as, “a systematic and ethical program for gathering, analyzing,

and managing information that can affect a company’s plans, decisions, and operations

(Miller, p. 1).” Management teams at every level of an organization utilize competitive

intelligence to plan and execute business strategies. Competitive intelligence allows a

management team to rely on action instead of reaction (Miller).

Intelligence Gathering

The ethical dilemmas surrounding the competitive intelligence field are linked to

the gathering process. There is a “fine line between the ‘legitimate’ tactics of competitive

intelligence gathering and the ‘illegitimate’ practice of industrial espionage (Crane, p.

1).” Firms that specialize in competitive intelligence utilize public forums, such as the

Internet, to gather information to analyze. A firm specializing in competitive intelligence

will conduct interviews with the managers of their client’s competitors, as well as

industry insiders. Both methods are universally accepted as legal and ethical

(Tuck).

Dumpster Diving

The methods that the firm that Procter and Gamble hired to gain intelligence

about Unilever’s operations utilized clandestine intelligence gathering methods. The

firm searched through the trash of Unilever, searching for any piece of information that

would shed light on Unilever’s product development and business strategies. The firm

operated a safe house known as the “Ranch” where agents would store gathered

information to analyze later (CNN). Agents of the firm would interview Unilever

employees, misrepresenting themselves as marketing agents, in an attempt to gather

privileged information.

The method of data collection used by the firm hired by Procter and Gamble did

not break the law. However, dumpster diving is considered highly unethical, especially

within the competitive intelligence community. A researcher who misrepresents his or

herself to the person being interviewed is also engaging in an unethical activity (book).

The firm utilized by Procter and Gamble crossed the line from intelligence gathering,

over to corporate espionage.

Ramifications

The clandestine operations carried out by the firm hired by Procter and Gamble

were done without the knowledge or consent of top executives. Once the means used to

gather information about Unilever were discovered by John Pepper and other top

executives the operation was stopped. All intelligence gathered during the operation was

discarded. Three managers directly linked to the intelligence gathering operation were

terminated, and several other managers with knowledge of the operations were reassigned

(CNN).

The executive committee, with John Pepper taking point, approached Unilever

and came clean about the details surrounding Procter and Gamble’s intelligence gathering

operation. Procter and Gamble came forwarded publically and admitted to the mistake,

making assurances that the information gathered was not, nor ever would be, used

(CNN). Unilever threatened to bring a lawsuit against Procter and Gamble. The two

companies settled out of court for a reported 10 million dollars (Carter).

Conclusion

In this paper I have shown the usefulness of corporate intelligence. While this tool

is helpful in making solid business decisions effort needs to go into monitoring of the

gathering process. Intelligence gathered by unethical means does more harm to an

organization then good. The financial repercussions of involvement in corporate spying

are steep, and the damage it does to an organizations reputation can take years to repair.

Management teams must continually monitor how intelligence is gathered to make

corporate intelligence work for their benefit.

References

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Png Bio

...global business? 4 2) Its Global business activity during the last 5-10 years ………………………………...6 3) What global initiatives the company has taken up currently and in the immediate future? 8 4) Can you suggest any alternative to its given future plan of expansion abroad? 10 5) Due to recent financial meltdown and the continuing recession/ slowdown in some developed countries , have some of the recently introduced expansion plans of your company become vulnerable? 12 6) What remedial measure / plan can you suggest? 14 7) Your suggestions for taking the company’s global businesses to the next level? 15 8) References…………………………………………………………………………….17 Executive Summary Procter and Gamble (P&G) was founded by William Procter and James Gamble on October 31, 1837. The company is now the largest company and brand in Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) industry. The company, today, deals with personal care product, pet food and cleaning agents. The company scored $83.86 billion sales in 2012 and ranks 1st in the Fortune magazine’s “Global Top Companies for Leaders.” The company as on February 19, 2013 has a market capitalization of $ 211.38 bn (Source: Yahoo Finance). The company has simple expansion plan. They have, since early days, have believed in both organic and inorganic growth. The company cultivated and grew in house brands for their organic growth. This includes the names of “Ivory” soap, “Tide” detergent, “Pampers” diapers, etc. These names...

Words: 3993 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Case Study, P&G

...business does best to create a competitive advantage.”(Lafley, 2008) COLLABORATION AND INNOVATION AT PROCTER & GAMBLE CASE STUDY Prepared by: xxxxxxxxx Lawrence Technical University Management Information Systems, MIS-6013 Professor Patrick Mach Evans February14, 2012 Table of Contents Introduction 3 Analysis 6 Conclusion 16 References 17 Introduction When the typical consumer hears the name Procter and Gamble they might think of Ivory Soap, Tide, Pantene, Pampers, or possibly Swiffer. The reason being is that these are a just a few of the everyday household products that have been contributors to the huge success of Procter and Gamble. But when another consumer product company hears the name Procter and Gamble – they think of innovation, leaders on the cutting edge of technology, and one of the front runners in globalization. Procter and Gamble, also known as P&G, has been a key element of American business for over 150 years. In 1837 a small soap and candle company formed in Cincinnati, Ohio. This little business, named after brother-in-laws, Procter and Gamble, has since grown to a global giant with 138,000 employees working in more than 80 countries. (P&G Revolutionizes Collaboration with Cisco, 2008) P&G is the largest manufacturer of consumer products in the world and one of the top 10 largest companies in the world by market capitalization. (Laudon & Laudon, 2012) p.75. Proctor and Gamble realized strong growth from...

Words: 3163 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Foundation School Paper

...Foundations Schools Generic Benchmarking Worksheet Team A University of Phoenix The Foundation Schools Generic Benchmarking Worksheet Task A: Problem/Opportunity Statement | Response to Task A: Problem Statement – The problem faced by Foundation Schools is the lack of committed board members to the set vision and goals. This could depict that there are too many programs in the objectives. The board of directors needs to analyze the program management to determine the viability of the projects. This way Nancy could select specific programs to run that will quickly realized the company’s vision, using what resource is availableProblem Statement – The board of Foundation School lacks the commitment to the mission and vision, to achieve their goals of growing enrollment and increasing revenue the school must embrace program management. Through the use of effective program management, Foundation management can prioritize the projects and staff with the appropriate resources to accomplish each task.Problem Statement – Foundations School major problem is the lack of follow- through necessary to achieve their goals and objectives. Everyone on the board has different plans on how to achieve increase in revenue and the resources to use that the communication surrounding the implementation has been unclear. The board’s strategic plan has to be clear, concise, provide strict guidelines and direction to achieve their objectives in the next two years.Problem Statement – Foundation...

Words: 2788 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Technology on the Business Strategies of Multi National Corporations

...Paradigm 17 3.4 Research Methodology 18 3.5 Ethical considerations 21 3.6 Challenges Encountered 21 3.7 Alternative Approach 22 4. Discussion and Findings 24 4.1 Introduction 24 4.2 Case Discussion and Analysis 24 4.3 Case Findings 29 5. Conclusion 31 5.1 Key Findings and Recommendations 31 5.2 Limitations 31 5.3 Future Research Options 32 6. Appendix 33 Appendix A: References 33 Appendix B: Interview Questions 36 Appendix C: Activity Plan 37 Abstract Gone are those days when firms used to just blindly invest in technology and forget. In this era of rapidly changing market needs and increasing use of technology, it is extremely significant and almost mandatory for firms to formulate a strong socio-technical network involving both technical and non-technical artefacts and structured around the organizational business strategies in order to attain set goals. Corporations all across the world especially Multi National Corporations (MNCs) which work twenty four hours round the clock and possess some of the best brains of the world, innovatively use technology as part of their business and operational processes. Similarly, this piece of study attempts to explore the way, one of the world’s best consumer goods manufacturer i.e. Procter & Gamble (P&G) uses the power of technology innovatively as part of its business strategies for achieving long term success and sustainable profitability....

Words: 8232 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

Pg Strategic Analysis

...| Procter & Gamble | GEB 4890 | | Hessum Zangenehpour | Fall 2013 | | Table of Contents Executive Summary ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… Page 2 The Company………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… Page 2 History and Evolution……………………………………………………………………………………………….. Page 2 Mission and Major Goals…………………………………………………………………………………………. Page 2 Current Strategies……………………………………………………………………………………………………. Page 7 Competitive Environment…………………………………………………………………………………………………….. Page 14 Industry…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… Page 15 Forces and Trends…………………………………………………………………………………………………… Page 18 Consolidating Retail Sector…………………………………………………………………………. Page 19 Private Labels…………………………………………………………………………………………….. Page 20 Competition……………………………………………………………………………………………… Page 20 Porter’s Five Forces………………………………………………………………………………………………. Page 21 Ethical Responsibilities and Challenges ……………………………………………………………….. Page 25 Environmental pollution…………………………………………………………………………… Page 26 Energy Consumption………………………………………………………………………………… Page 26 Possible challenges facing Procter and Gamble…………………………………………………….. Page 27 Internal Strengths and Weaknesses…………………………………………………………………………………. Page 28 Recommendations ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. Page 37,45 Implementation……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. Page 40,45 Evaluation…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………...

Words: 13581 - Pages: 55

Free Essay

Phar-Mor

...EVIDENCE FORM I have read UB’s policy on cheating and plagiarism (see UB’s website for more information). I have done all work myself with no HELP from anybody or any source. Please put your name in the line below to certify the above statement. ____ Huang ___________Xinlu____ Last First MAX points 40 Start time__5:25__ End time__8:15____ Below ..TIME TAKEN to COMPLETE The EXAM(not including DFD time) ___150mins_________ GENERIC ANSWERS/ANALYSIS WILL NOT GET CREDIT * Use double space & 11 or 12 font * BE VERY SPECIFIC (Quality is important than quantity, but do not shortchange your answers) * TO GET CREDIT YOUR ANALYSIS MUST FOLLOW CONCEPTS IN THE BOOK & READINGS. * DO NOT GO OFF ON generic TANGENTS. * MAKE reasonable ASSUMPTIONS IF YOU NEED TO and list them READ CAREFULLY AND ALLOCATE YOUR TIME WISELY!!!!! TO BE SUBMITTED: Create a zip file and include the following: * This Exam with answers (including Evidence FORM) * Excel spreadsheet related to Q7 Q#1 Multiple Choice: (3 points) 1. A supervisor having to decide when to reorder supplies or how best to allocate personnel for the completion of the project is an example of a _________ decision. a. structured b. unstructured c. semi-structured d. none of the above 2. Each team has only one home stadium and each stadium can have many home teams. This is an example of what kind of relationship between TEAM and...

Words: 2938 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Unilever and P&G

...the beginning of twentieth century. He started off as a mining engineer and later director of mines. His concepts deal with the organisation of production in the ambience of a competitive price that has to control its cost of production. According to Fayol, the quality that a manager should possess is experience, knowledge, education, moral, physical. He strongly believed that the number of management principles that help to improve the organisations in potentially limitless. From his experiences, he developed his own concept of administration. He proposed the five functions of management that is plan, organise, command, coordinate and control. The 14 principles of management affirmed by him were explained in detail in his book “Administration industrielle et generale ". He was known as the FATHER OF GENERAL MANAGEMENT for his contribution to the contemporary management. Division of labour means specialisation of work. In Unilever the employees in the department are assigned to perform different functions and roles set by the top management. There are around 7 dept. in which a group of specialised people exist to perform the work best suited to them. For example in the human resource department the employees empowers people to perform at their very best, the IT dept. uses the technology to drive competitive advantage, the marketing dept. understands, creates and build demands for the brands and so on. In P&G there are mainly three heads which is divided into many departments. The...

Words: 2513 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Apple, Inc. Case Analysis

...APPLE, INC. CASE ANALYSIS Written by: Jessica A. Mahfoudi AMBA 640 Dr. Larry Williams University of Maryland University College February 25, 2013 This page is intentionally blank   EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Management Information Systems allow companies to remain competitive in today’s fast-paced world and especially when conducting business on the Internet. Organizations must adapt to technological advances and innovations to keep pace with today’s rapidly changing environment (Baltzan, 2012). Every day there is some type of new technology, new internet site, new software or hardware program that someone is learning how to use. Apple, being a major technology company needs to keep up with these advances to keep their customers happy. This paper focuses on Apple, Inc., its competitive advantage and the challenges Apple faces to stay in the top of consumer reports. Data, information, business intelligence and knowledge are discussed and how they are relevant to the production of Apple products. Knowledge cannot be acquired until data, information and business intelligence are researched. The paper then goes on to discuss Porter’s Five Forces Model and how it is applied to Apple, Inc. and its products. Apple has lowered the threat of substitute products by including a great variety of features on all of their products. Since the original iPhone's release about four years ago, the threat of substitute products or services has greatly decreased...

Words: 4317 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Dferewrwerwe

...Business AnAlytics And intelligence Course Starting: 29 June 2014 Application Deadline: Early Decision 28 February 2014 Regular Decision 15 April 2014 (Batch 5) (Classes conducted on-campus as well as off-campus) Certificate Programme on Business Analytics and Intelligence BATCH 5 in god We trust, All Others Must Bring data - W edwards deming he theory of bounded rationality proposed by nobel laureate Herbert Simon is evermore significant today with increasing complexity of the business problems; limited ability of human mind to analyze alternative solutions and the limited time available for decision making. introduction of enterprise resource planning (eRP) systems has ensured availability of data in many organizations; however, traditional eRP systems lacked data analysis capabilities that can assist the management in decision making. Business Analytics is a set of techniques and processes that can be used to analyse data to improve business performance through fact-based decision making. Business Analytics is the subset of Business intelligence, which creates capabilities for companies to compete in the market effectively. Business Analytics is likely to become one of the main functional areas in most companies. Analytics companies develop the ability to support their decisions through analytic reasoning using a variety of statistical and mathematical techniques. thomas devonport in his book titled, “competing on analytics: the new science of winning”, claims...

Words: 4378 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Instructor’s Manual Erp

...CHAPTER OBJECTIVES 1. Develop an understanding of how ERP systems can improve the effectiveness of information systems in organizations. 2. Understand the business benefits of enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems. 3. Understand the history and evolution of ERP. CHAPTER OUTLINE 1. A Foundation for Understanding Enterprise Resource Planning Systems a. The Emergence of Enterprise Resource Planning Systems 1. What is ERP? 2. The Evolution of ERP 3. The Integrated Systems Approach b. Business Benefits of ERP c. ERP Modules d. ERP Design Alternatives e. The Business Case for ERP 1. Cost-Benefit Analysis for ERP 2. Can ERP Provide a Competitive Advantage? f. The Challenge of Implementing an ERP System g. Summary ANSWERS TO END-OF-CHAPTER QUESTIONS Questions for Discussion: 1. Use on-line library databases to identify articles in trade publications which provide case studies of ERP implementations. These articles may provide some insight into each of these questions. a. How widespread is the use of ERP across certain industries? b. What are the benefits reported from implementing ERP? c. What are its limitations? 2. Research and learn about the implementation of ERP. Use trade publications and on-line library databases (e.g. ABI Inform, ProQuest, First Search, Wilson Select Plus, available through your library) to conduct a search for articles. a. Find a success story of ERP implementation. What factors contributed to the success of this...

Words: 8305 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Information System

...Chapter 2 Information Systems in the Organization Teaching Objectives Students should be able to answer the following questions: 1. What are the major types of information systems in a business? What roles do they play? 2. Why should managers pay attention to business processes? Why do firms need to integrate their business processes? 3. What are the benefits and challenges of using enterprise systems? 4. What are the benefits of using information systems to support supply chain management and collaborative commerce? 5. What are the benefits of using information systems for customer relationship management and knowledge management? Key Terms The following alphabetical list identifies the key terms discussed in this chapter. The page number for each key term is provided. |Bullwhip effect, 53 |Management-level systems, 39 | |Collaborative commerce, 54 |Manufacturing and production information systems, 48 | |Collaborative planning, forecasting, and replenishment (CPFR), 55 |Office systems, 42 | |Decision-support systems (DSS), 44 |Operational-level systems, 38 | |Desktop publishing, 43 ...

Words: 5365 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Loreal Case Study

...1. Describe the Product Portfolio of L'Oreal The challenge at L'Oreal was to leverage its position and innovation capabilities to transfer the Plenitude product line to the United States market and achieve both bottom and top line growth. In 1988, the L'Oreal 'Plenitude' line was launched in the U.S. market consisting of a 14 SKU (Stock keeping units) line-up that was sub-divided under cleansers and moisturizers (both daily and treatment). By early 1995, the line had extended to 19 separate products. Each segment was further categorised according to criteria such as skin type and time of usage. The packaging of each product was captivating and informative and there was a very unique purpose for the information provided on the packaging as the strategy of L'Oreal was to push such products in retail outlets without dedicated sales staff which entailed that the consumer was to be educated via instructional packaging. To give a brief overview of the company, it was founded in 1907, in Clichy, France, by the chemist Eugene Schueller to provide advanced hair care products for customers of French hairdressers. Under the guidance and control of Schueller's family the company had evolved to provide cosmetic, skin and hair care products with the principle strategy of 'quality, innovation and geographic expansion'. Later the holding company 'Gesparal' and Nestle became major shareholders of the company which provided deep-pockets for it's innovation philosophy and geographic expansion...

Words: 5304 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Wal-Mart

...| | | | | | This article appears in the Nov. 14, 2003 issue of Executive Intelligence Review. Wal-Mart Is Not a Business, It's an Economic Diseaseby Richard Freeman and Arthur Ticknor(See also ``Wal-Mart Collapses U.S. Cities and Towns,'' Nov. 14, 2003; ``Wal-Mart Eats More Manufacturers, Jobs,'' Nov. 21, 2003; Wal-Mart Family Trust--The Real Beast of Bentonville, Ark., Jan. 23, 2004.)The Wal-Mart department store chain, which employs 1.3 million people at 4,700 stores worldwide, and in 2002 became the largest corporation in the world, is levelling economies of the U.S., industrial nations, and the Third World.Wal-Mart is a driving force behind the decadent Imperial Roman model of the United States. Unable any longer to reproduce its own population's existence through its own physical economy, the United States has, for the past two decades, used an over-valued dollar to suck in physical goods from around the globe for its survival. Wal-Mart is both the public face and working sinews of that policy. It brings in cheap pants from Bangladesh, cheap shirts from China, cheap food from Mexico, etc. Workers who produce these things are paid next to nothing.Not since the days of the British East India Company as the cornerstone of the British imperial system, has one single corporate entity been responsible for so much misery. At the core of its policy, Wal-Mart demands of its suppliers that they sell goods to Wal-Mart at such a low price, that they can only do so by outsourcing...

Words: 5677 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Csr - Literature Review

...2.1 REVIEW OF LITERATURE & ANALYSIS OF PREVIOUS RESEARCH The concept of social responsibility is not new. Although the idea was considered in the early part of the twentieth century, the modern discussion of social responsibility got a major impetus with the book "Social Responsibilities of the Businessman" by Howard R. Bowen. Bowen suggested that business should consider the social implications of their decisions. Fortune magazine annually assess America's most Admired Corporations and does so by evaluating over 300 organisations against 8 criteria, one of the eight used is "Community and Environmental Responsibility". Firms such as Merck, Rubber maid, Procter and Gamble, Wal-mart, Pepsico, Coca-cola and 3 M have received consistently high overall ratings. The presence of strong social values such as social responsibility has a powerful impact on organisations and their actions. It leads them to use a socio-economic model of decision making in which both social costs and benefits are considered along with the traditional economic and technical values. “Corporate social responsibility in the form of corporate philanthropy, or donating to charities, has been practiced since early 1800 at least in the US (Sethi, 1977). It was legitimate in so far that it directly benefited the shareholders, and corporate donations were mostly on the agenda of those companies that could afford it. Today’s concept of corporate social responsibility was developed primarily during...

Words: 12892 - Pages: 52

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management

...teaching Chapter One, Managing Human Resources! This guide will provide you with a chapter summary, learning objectives, lecture outlines, solutions to in-chapter case questions, suggested use of internet exercises and self-assessments from the online learning center, video resource notes and discussion questions, and suggested uses for the PowerPoint slides contained in your Instructor Resources. Instructor’s Manual Highlights: Chapter One Roadmap We hope you find each chapter of your Instructor Manual practical and useful, but also, exciting! You can adapt the chapter text, the PowerPoint, and the video to work in an online class environment, a guided independent study environment, or a face to face or on-ground environment. ✓ When presenting Chapter One, have the students first read the chapter and encourage them to absorb the “big picture” of Human Resource Management. ✓ Use the PowerPoint for Chapter One to frame your lecture. This Instructor’s Manual will provide you with a suggested placement of the PowerPoint alongside your Lectures. ✓ Then, have your students watch the Video Case on the “Creative Corporation,” and facilitate an in-class or an on-line discussion highlighting the lessons contained in that Case. ✓ Have students read and discuss the end-of-chapter Cases and their respective Questions. ✓ Have students validate their knowledge of the chapter by working through the Discussion Questions at the end of the Chapter...

Words: 8124 - Pages: 33