Free Essay

Professional Workplace Dilemma

In:

Submitted By shadiaavila
Words 1142
Pages 5
Introduction Working at in an educational institution you would think that we have the upmost professional employees, staff and students, causing this paper a hard one to write. Unfortunately that is not the case as I have dealt with many professionals who have acted unprofessional and uneducated. I have been employed for the past seven years to one of the top colleges in the country. The college has eight campuses in different parts of South Florida allowing it to be diverse in cultures both with students as well as with our faculty and staff and creating for ethical issues to arise at all times.
The Experience Working for the Quick Copy Center at one of our campuses I must follow policies and procedures set out not only by the college, but by the state and the federal government. Many professors think that because they have Master’s or Doctorate degrees they have rights in not following procedures that I must enforce. I enforce policies and procedures not only to protect myself, but also to protect my employees, department and the college. On this particular day professor Fried came into the office requesting copies from a book for her class. I asked her to please provide me with a copy of the book and she refused. I immediately told her that I would need to see the book in order to abide by copyright laws that are not only in place at the college, but it was a federal law. She got very angry said I was stupid and was too much trouble for her and the students. She proceeded with breaking up our Quick Copy Form and throwing them at my face. I was furious, but thought quickly and remained calm. I told her I was following department regulations and if she would bring the book allowing me to make the copies That I would be more than happy to do them for her immediately and if they had copyright reserved then she would need a chairperson signature and that I would be more than happy to assist her no matter what she decided. She proceeded by calling me an ignorant uneducated woman, to what I thought was the other way around. As she walked out the door she called me a bit_ _, not knowing that it would really upset me creating more anger and causing me to walk up to her department chairperson’s office.
The Ethical Dilemma As I walked up the stairs I thought I would just blow up into Dr. Johnson’s office and tell him how rude this woman had been, but the long walk up to the third floor made me calm and realize that talking to him and having her understand me was probably going to make her listen to me and not just hear my point and why I was doing what I was doing. Professor Fried thought that because she had been here for so many years and that she had made copies before from the book that I was just making a big deal. She thought that her degree made her my boss and that she can overrule policies and procedures because she had a higher position than I did. She had insulted me not only by cursing at me, but by thinking that her position was higher than mine she was unethical from the beginning creating for her moral values to be degraded no matter what education she had received. I thought while sitting in his office waiting for her to be called in, that all I wanted was for her to understand why I did what I did and why it was uncalled for her to treat me the way she did as we were in an educational institution giving an education to others.
The Outcome As I explained to Dr. Johnson what had happened and he waited for her to come and join us I thought to myself that I was only doing my job and why could someone so professional not understand my position and I was having to lecture her on how things worked. She walked in and shook her head and she immediately told Dr. Johnson that she knew why she was there and that she did not understand why I was so difficult. I turned to her and said well I will explain that there are copyright laws set by our federal government and apart from those laws the college had their own policies and procedures that followed the federal and state laws. I explained to her that I was protecting my job that if an inspector came in and caught me doing the copies that the college would be fined and then I would be fired. I explained that writing to the publisher of the book was an easy way as I had helped other professors do it and receive and e-mail allowing me to make copies. I explained that I was there to serve not only her, but our staff and most of all our students. Making her understand that she was not above me, because of her education and that I felt that her education was not what made her educated that her actions towards me were very uneducated. She quickly realized that I had poised myself with dignity and honored my job and the college; she apologized and explained she only wanted copies for the students in order to save them money and I understood as I am a student and know how expensive it is. I told her to take me to her office so that we could write to the publisher. They got back to her in 24 hours with an approval to make copies out of that book and she was grateful for my help. She understands now why I did what I did and Professor Fried now comes to my office for advice and help with regarding copies. I would not change how I handled myself as I think that I did the best I could in explaining myself and communicating to her our policies and procedures and also made her understand that I was here to help and not to cause any headaches for her as I did follow the college motto “One College, One Goal”.
Conclusion
Working in such a diverse organization can sometimes become difficult, but learning how to act intelligently and maintaining a hostile free attitude creates a hassle free working environment. I think in the end it was an educational experience for all the parties involved as to showing a professor that no matter how high of a degree you have learning from someone else can benefit all involved to get the goal accomplished.

References
Miami Dade College (2010). About Us. Retrieved April 17, 2010 from http://www.mdc.ed

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Professional Workplace Dilemma

...Professional Workplace Dilemma University Of Phoenix GEN/480 Professional Workplace Dilemma A dilemma that I experienced has to do with my place of work at ABC. In 2002 I had a values conflict that had to do with my job situation. My company had hired a new director for our accounts payable department in 1997. His name was MB.MB was a financial director from Coca Cola with a bachelor’s degree in Accounting/Finance. For several years, MB had held strategic positions and his fame increased with great accomplishments and was recognized as one of the best director in our company. He was gifted in many areas as procurement direct for payables. He had a tremendous leadership skill and was a role model. He managed the accounting department and brought productivity up to speed. In 2002 MB was nominated as Chief Financial Officer (CFO). Prior to his appointment our CEO A H had an interview with him to make sure that he was the right candidate for this position. After his interview with our CEO, Walter ordered a security clearance screening to be done on MB to make sure that there were no skeletons in the closet. Shortly after his interview, human resources had completed a background and security screening on MB. Our human resources personnel Stacy had called for his college transcripts as well. And they discovered that MB had not graduated from Accounting, despite the fact that this was listed on his resume. Our human resources director Stacy contacted MB...

Words: 798 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Professional Workplace Dilemma Paper

...Professional Workplace Dilemma Paper Alicia Huff GEN 480 June 19, 2012 Alexander Dunham Professional Workplace Dilemma Paper Although everyone experiences a dilemma in the workplace at least once in their life, the most important aspect of the dilemma is to learn from it and gain some knowledge and wisdom that can be used the next time you are faced with dilemma within the workplace. Furthermore, while experiencing these dilemmas in the workplace we have to ensure that it is not a repeat deal. Meaning that you are a confrontational person and always have issues with other employees, because you gossip too much or your just plain old not doing your job and causing other people to get in trouble because they have to pick up your slack. Or maybe there is a fellow employee who is looking to get a promotion as a manager soon. Currently he or she is doing some shift leading from time to time. However, you notice that sometimes while he or she is shift leading he or she takes advantage of the little bit of authority that they have been granted for his or her eight hour shift. Now you have brought the change in the shift leader’s attitude to the attention of your managers. You have explained that there is a little abuse of authority with, yelling, name calling, snatching things from other employees hands, not giving lunch breaks, gossiping about other employees to their employee friends who happen to work there, and so forth. The managers state that they will...

Words: 1658 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

A New Hr Professional´S First Workplace Dilemma

...the case incident “A New HR Professional´s First Workplace Dilemma” I can say that I agree with Laura decision. As a new Human Resources coordinator at a small company in charge of updating the HR manual, she should first read the current policies of the company related to Computer, Email and Internet use to see if they already have existing anti-harassment or anti-discrimination policies, statements, and if it has been properly shared within the company. In the event there were no policies for this specific situation, she should create new policies that meet the requirements of the Occupational Health and Safety Act, and show them to her superiors. I agree with her decision to not report the Director of Marketing to the CEO as this would threaten the Director´s reputation and alter the company´s environment. I think it is important to research on the company’s history and employees’ in order to set new rules and policies that will work efficiently. It is a fact that a corrective action must be taken because this situation is considered as “harassment” under the Ontario´s Human Rights Code as it is an unwelcome conduct that negatively impacts a co-worker. “It is important to address any unwanted behaviour early to minimize the potential for workplace harassment to lead to workplace violence” . I advise Laura to introduce these new policies in moderation and not instantly as majority of people are reluctant to change. She must be professional and confidential to avoid coworkers...

Words: 583 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gen 480 Week 2 Individual Assignment Professional Workplace Dilemma Paper

...In this archive file of GEN 480 Entire Course you will find the next documents: GEN-480 WEEK 1 DQS.doc GEN-480 Week 1 IndividualAssignment Ethics Awareness Inventory.doc GEN-480 WEEK 2 DQS.doc GEN-480 Week 2 Individual Assignment Professional Workplace Dilemma Paper.doc GEN-480 Week 2 LTA Skills Assessment Paper Matrix.doc GEN-480 WEEK 3 DQS.doc GEN-480 Week 3 Individual Assignment Critical Thinking Case Study Acuscan Executive Summary.doc GEN-480 Week 3 Individual Assignment Critical Thinking Case Study.doc GEN-480 Week 3 LTA Business Specialties.doc GEN-480 WEEK 4 DQS.doc GEN-480 Week 4 Individual Assignment Past Present Future Presentation.ppt GEN-480 Week 4 LTA Role Responsibilities Identification.doc GEN-480 WEEK 5 DQS.doc GEN-480 Week 5 LTA Consulting Presentation.ppt GEN-480 Week 5 LTA Consulting.doc Business - General Business GEN 480 Week 1 Individual Assignment Ethics Awareness Inventory Analysis GEN 480 Week 2 Individual Assignment Professional Workplace Dilemma Paper GEN 480 Week 2 Learning Team Assignment Skills Assessment Paper and Matrix GEN 480 Week 3 Individual Assignment Critical Thinking Case Study GEN 480 Week 3 Learning Team Assignment Analysis of Business Specialties GEN 480 Week 4 Individual Assignment Past, Present, and Future Paper GEN 480 Week 4 Learning Team Assignment Role Identification...

Words: 362 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

His Is a Three-Part, 1,400- to 2,100-Word Paper in Which You Reflect on Your Personal and Professional Growth During Your University of Phoenix Program of Study. Reflect on Where You Were in Your Personal and

...Professional Workplace Dilemma Janeen Johnson GEN/480 January 19, 2013 Walter Hedgecock Professional Workplace Dilemma In this professional workplace dilemma is the exploration of an ethical dilemma, which happened in the workplace while figuring out the best actions of recourse regarding how to remain professional and courteous. This proposed circumstance is an issue that actually occurred in the environment of a family nature, but still a professional work relationship that without the reveal of names or locations or times there is still a lesson still to be learned in generalities (Koocher & Keith-Spiegel, 1990). The facts involving the issue and the circumstance it surrounds are explained in detail that is such so the reader can understand the dilemma that is being faced with this true-life story. A scenario, such as this could have many possible alternate circumstances but in this case, the events chosen are played out and described for understanding the thought process and effects of certain actions and decisions. My desire and eagerness in obtaining my bachelor's degree has been a lifelong journey. After finishing high school 23 years ago, I attended a two- year college where I received a diploma in Office Administration. The same year, I got married and had 2 children within two years. My dream or desire of continuing my education was put on hold. I have always said that one day that I would go back to school. I enrolled...

Words: 716 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Ethical Dilema

...Students entering the field of speech-language pathology or audiology recognize the rigorous academic coursework required to complete the degree. They are aware of the time, effort and dedication it will take to become certified professionals. Clinical practicum requirements, internship placements and comprehensive exams are at the forefront of their concerns. Conversely, professional issues including ethics and workplace dilemmas seem to be the least of their worries. Beginning clinicians may enter the workforce assuming all professionals adhere to ethical standards. They may think "workplace dilemmas" are simply fabricated scenarios they will never encounter. Unfortunately, the dynamic and evolving scope of the professions of speech-language pathology and audiology can present unforeseen challenges in the workplace, especially for beginning clinicians. However, with the proper education and training, students can enter the workforce prepared to handle any conflict that may compromise their ethicality. In order to demonstrate how to resolve ethical dilemmas occurring in the workplace, two scenarios involving support personnel, prescription and misrepresentation will be discussed in further detail. The first scenario involves the administrator of an outpatient rehabilitation clinic. She is requiring a certified speech-language pathologist (SLP) to supervise a speech-language pathology assistant (SLPA). While supervising a session, the SLP notices the SLPA performing a diagnostic...

Words: 1142 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Professional Dilemma

...Professional Dilemma Yona Mcmillan GEN/480 Interdisciplinary Capstone Course June 20, 2016 Jennifer Baker Professional Dilemma Introduction In life, many people will experience a professional dilemma in the workplace. How we handle it, reflect on our ethics. In this paper I will explain my professional dilemma that I have experience in the workplace with a co- worker. I will describe my experience, ethical issues I have encountered, and the outcome of the professional dilemma before I started the University of Phoenix. The Experience I have been employed with my company for ten years and before someone is hired we are required to sign an employee handbook which contains the company policies, procedures, benefits, and other programs. In signing this manual, each employee agrees that they have read and understand the company policies. If employees break, any of this policies will result in termination. As an Assistant Property Manager, I handle all of the accounts payables and is responsible for entering and taking checks and money orders to the bank. If I cannot make it to the bank, I have a safe that I put the money in (all employees have access to the safe). One day at work I walked in on my April taking money orders out of the safe, and I asked her about it. She responded that she was checking to see who paid their rent so far. She put them back after being approached. This was unusual because we have reports that provide us with this information. I seem very...

Words: 1044 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Social Work

...Students entering the field of speech-language pathology or audiology recognize the rigorous academic coursework required to complete the degree. They are aware of the time, effort and dedication it will take to become certified professionals. Clinical practicum requirements, internship placements and comprehensive exams are at the forefront of their concerns. Conversely, professional issues including ethics and workplace dilemmas seem to be the least of their worries. Beginning clinicians may enter the workforce assuming all professionals adhere to ethical standards. They may think "workplace dilemmas" are simply fabricated scenarios they will never encounter. Unfortunately, the dynamic and evolving scope of the professions of speech-language pathology and audiology can present unforeseen challenges in the workplace, especially for beginning clinicians. However, with the proper education and training, students can enter the workforce prepared to handle any conflict that may compromise their ethicality. In order to demonstrate how to resolve ethical dilemmas occurring in the workplace, two scenarios involving support personnel, prescription and misrepresentation will be discussed in further detail. The first scenario involves the administrator of an outpatient rehabilitation clinic. She is requiring a certified speech-language pathologist (SLP) to supervise a speech-language pathology assistant (SLPA). While supervising a session, the SLP notices the SLPA performing a diagnostic...

Words: 562 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Workplace Ethical Dilemma

...+ Workplace Ethical Dilemma Tanya W. Cooper BSHS/332 Professional, Ethical and Legal Issues in Human Services April 16, 2012 Kathleen Roberts Everyday individuals are faced with issues associated with ethical dilemmas. Ethical dilemmas involve an individual’s behavior toward a moral standard, which may have been established from previous generations and passed along. In upholding the standards taught individual may be forced to take a particular action involving a decision when a behavior is considered non-ethical is when an ethical dilemma occurs. It can become difficult at times in making the correct decisions or solutions to the situation, which is why a code of ethics is established in the workplace. The code of ethics in the workplace was established to assist with the process of a company analyzing the behavioral practices within the company procedures. Code of ethics in the workplace is used in defining, requiring, encouraging, and engaging employees in the direction of the correct behavior. The purpose is to correct the unethical behavior and avoid serious consequences such as lawsuits. In the workplace, conflicts with personal values may become a struggle in an organized business structure with ethical decision-making. Often individuals find it difficult to differentiate personal values from the corporate world, in those instances one must resolve and modify their behavior into a course of action and acceptance while maintaining balance and integrity. Many...

Words: 1299 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Issues in Management

...Ethical Issues in Management Charles Hall Axia Student Diversity in the workplace refers to the stark contrast of individuals within the same work environment. Many moral and ethical issues are faced by managers every day concerning diversity. Social Issues and ethically responsible management practices relate to workplace diversity in simple but important ways. Ethically it is irresponsible for managers to manage diversity in the workplace by acting insensitively towards employees. There are many ways that managers can avoid ethical issues concerning diversity in the workplace, but first they must understand the moral and ethical issues that they are faced with. Fifty years ago it was not uncommon to see any workplace filled with nothing but white adult males (Jr., 1990). Today that has changed. Walking into most workplaces will expose a person to an environment of diversity. This environment poses challenges to management that were not even a concern to doing business a generation ago. Programs like Affirmative Action have mandated that organizations heed government set quotas of employing minorities in their workplace (Jr., 1990). This has resulted in a complex new environment for managers where the bottom line is no longer the bottom line. Ethics are now the bottom line in a work environment where diversity plays a major role. Managers need to be in tune with their subordinates’ ethnicity, race, and background. Due to the political correctness (PC) movement of the 1980s...

Words: 1184 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Business Ecomics

...Running Head: WORKPLACE ETHICIAL DILEMMA Professional Workplace Dilemma Shamira Tarkhan GEN/480 - INTERDISCIPLINARY CAPSTONE COURSE 6/6/2011 SHARI L. LANE, MBA University of Phoenix Intro What is an Ethical Dilemma? According to Flamand, 1999-2011, “an ethical dilemma is situations were in moral precepts or ethical obligations conflict in such a way as to make any possible resolution to the dilemma morally intolerable”(para.1). “In other words, an ethical dilemma is any situation in which guiding moral principles cannot determine which of course an action that is right or wrong”( Flamand, 1999-2011, para.1). Dilemmas in the work force are quite common and require some sort of ethical explanation. Both employees and employers have to face dilemmas in any type of undersized or large organization. Some conflicts are bond to rise at even given moment because of gender, age, education, race, religion, and employment statues. The most common dilemmas I have experienced at work include honesty, power, loyalty, authority, and confidentiality. The Experience/Analyze Sometimes making a right decision can be difficult because as I think about my personal values and what they mean to me. Do I choose to do something unethical or do I use what I believe in and what I think is right so solve the dilemma. There was a situation with my mother and I believe it was back in 2002 where she had so many high hopes and dreams for me until it all came crashing down (at that moment)...

Words: 897 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Reflective Models In Social Work

...definition, problematic and complex. A lot of situations in which social workers interfere become ethically complicated. These complications increase when we consider the general societal context and that of agency, and social workers’ professional and personal values. Though social workers’ professional values may be partly compatible with societal values, nonetheless there are some differences in emphasis, priorities and or understanding (Osmo and Landau, 2006). As a social worker making decisions about what to do in cases that feature ethical problems as well as dilemmas integrates our ethical judgements or evaluation of what is right...

Words: 1201 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Workplace Ethical Dilemma

...Running head: WORKPLACE DILEMMA Workplace Ethical Dilemma Rayna Cockett University of Phoenix Personal, Ethical, and Legal Issue's in Human Services BSHS 331 Judy Hill-Aleman January 14, 2007 Workplace Dilemma A young woman named Rayna worked in a residential drug treatment program starting as a treatment associate. Rayna also had other duties such as assisting with intake procedures, maintaining clientele charts, escorting clients to appointments and 12-step meetings. Andy Anderson, the clinical director of the residential drug treatment program constantly praised Rayna for her efforts and dedication to the clientele. Mr. Anderson urged Rayna to get a bachelor’s in Human Services and to get her certificate in substance abuse. Every three months all staff members at the institution go through an evaluation process. Rayna’s job duties, title, and pay increased with each evaluation. The program director, clinical supervisors, and other employees’ admired Rayna for the quality of work she produced. Rayna was moving up the ladder very fast. One day Rayna approached Mr. Anderson inquiring of the possibility of her son entering the residential side of this institution. Mr. Anderson referred Rayna to the “Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct.” 3.06 -Psychologists refrain from taking on a professional role when personal, scientific, professional, legal, financial, or other interests or relationships could...

Words: 892 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Creating an Ethical Organization

...[Type the company name] | Creating an Ethical Organization | | Business Ethics | Saurabh | How to Create an Ethical Workplace? Ethics in the workplace are vital, even to small business owners. No company wants to be known as unethical, and employees are more apt to display higher morale and more productivity when they know they are working for a morally sound company. It is important to create a conscientious workplace that is transparent, both to employees as well as the general public. Small business owners should never tolerate inappropriate behavior in an employee and employees should be properly trained on what is considered unethical and ethical. * Set an example for your workforce. In order for employees to behave in an ethical manner, they need to know that they are working for a moral boss. They will be much less likely to display signs of unethical behavior if they know that this type of behavior will not be tolerated or ignored. * Create a policy dealing with ethics. This company policy should state your expectations for your employees as well as outline what is and is not considered acceptable. Having a clearly written policy will help you take action should an employee act unethically. * Allow employees to report unethical behavior in a safe environment. No one enjoys ratting out a fellow employee, particularly if it will be made known who turned the person in. Give your employees a safe and anonymous way to air their complaints so...

Words: 3158 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Injuries and Safety in the Workplace

...Safety in the Workplace Gail Coates BUS642 Research Methods & Tools Kelly Bruning July 4, 2015 Introduction If safety procedure programs are not implemented in organizations’ rules and policy, the amount of workplace injuries will continue to rise. As a prospective manager and business owner, workplace safety is important to research so I can ensure that my business is productive as well as having productive employees. Knowing what the main causes of work related injuries and the responsibility as management and having the proper plan and procedure to follow will help decrease those injuries and help my business become more productive. The well being of an organizations employers and employees are contingent on the organizations workplace health and safety procedures. According to the International Labor Organization (ILO), “each year about 2.3 million people die from accidents and diseases that are related to their work” (Yarlagadda, Raju,, & Raju, 2010). The article also states that each day approximately 1 million employees suffer workplace accidents, and about 5,500 of those employees will die because of an accident or disease related to their work (Yarlagadda, Raju,, & Raju, 2010). Management Dilemma There are several different dilemmas that management deals with when it come to workplace injuries and safety. Management has to know what to do to prevent workplace injuries and how to deal with those injuries when they happen. Another dilemma that management...

Words: 741 - Pages: 3