Free Essay

Project Failures from the Top Down Can Marchionne Save Chrysler Suggestions and Rise Up Challenges

In: Business and Management

Submitted By kinnaird
Words 1235
Pages 5
Project Failures From the Top Down: Can Marchionne Save Chrysler

When Chrysler merged with Fiat on June 10, 2009, there was cause for hope and optimism. After an endless string of bad news, perhaps, the auto industry was not dead yet.
On paper it looked like a good deal for everyone. Fiat would return to the US market and sell its popular 500 (Cinquecentro), Chrysler would acquire a line of cars that consumers might actually buy, and tens of thousands of workers would keep their jobs.
But the real prize might just be Sergio Marchionne, CEO of Fiat and now CEO of FiatChrysler.
When he first became CEO of Fiat in 2004, Marchionne inherited a company on the brink of failure. It manufactured a lackluster product line and had suffered more than $12 billion in losses over the previous five years.
To transform the company he embarked on several strategic and operational projects. He fired senior managers, upended a bloated bureaucracy, and brought a team of young aggressive managers on board. Then, he reviewed all projects and killed those that could not pass the market test. And he hired new designers, and demanded a portfolio of exciting projects that would bring customers back to dealer showrooms.
In less than three years he succeeded in one of the most impressive turnarounds in automotive history.
Now, as part of his plan to grow Fiat into a global competitor he has taken on Chrysler. But, can he perform his magic again? Can he save yet another company whose circumstances in many ways, but not all, are strikingly similar to those faced by Fiat just five years ago? Can his leadership style as well as the Fiat 500 be successfully exported to the other side of the Atlantic?
If we look at Marchionne's record by itself, not only is it impressive, but it suggests that he might be the right person at the right time. But, before we can reach this conclusion, his ability to succeed must be considered in the context of what has happened to Chrysler in the last decade. In that case, success may not be assured.
In May 1998, Daimler-Benz merged with Chrysler. Jurgen Schrempp, CEO of Daimler-Benz, called it a "merger of equals." Robert Eaton, CEO of Chrysler, promised that "within five years we will be among the Big Three automotive companies in the world." Even bringing together two companies from Europe and the United States was not considered a hurdle; Robert A. Lutz, Vice-Chairman of Chrysler, argued that there was "definitely no culture clash here."
But behind this display of public enthusiasm and corporate kinship, Schrempp took complete control and his actions made it clear that this was indeed no "merger of equals." Eaton responded by deferring to Schrempp, often retreating to the safety of his office in Auburn Hills; his top managers responded by defecting to Ford and General Motors. Soon Chrysler was rudderless, projects were lackluster, and within just a few years not only was the product line in trouble but the merger was too. While there were many reasons for its failure, the one most frequently cited was a clash of corporate cultures.
In 2007 DaimlerChrysler sold Chrysler to Cerberus Capital Management, a private equity firm with no experience in making cars. Bob Nardelli, former CEO of Home Depot, was chosen to head the company. For many, it was clear that the deal was strictly financial and few believed that Cerberus was committed to building a competitive company in an increasingly competitive auto industry plagued with too much capacity.
Nardelli was a "tough-as-nails" CEO. Business Week, in August 2007, said that he "alienated ... virtually all of the management he inherited." While many thought that his military style was exactly what Chrysler needed, it didn't work. In that Business Week article, a University of Michigan Professor, Gerald Meyers, said that Cerberus had the right idea, but Nardelli was the "wrong guy."
Then, Chrysler was hit by the perfect storm. Oil rose to over $140 per barrel, the economy went into a tailspin, and Chrysler was caught with a product line dominated by gas guzzlers no one wanted to buy.
Marchionne's Challenge
It is within this context that Fiat has taken a 20 percent stake in Chrysler. Marchionne inherits an organisation shattered by the distant, yet dominant, style of Schrempp and the "tough-as-nails" style of Nardelli. He inherits a workforce that has endured job losses, pay cuts, deterioration in benefits, and the anxiety of an uncertain future. But above all, he inherits a workplace that has suffered one lackluster project after the other, and a project culture that has failed to stress markets not methodology.
Here is the problem; his leadership style, characterised by the quick and disruptive changes he made five years ago, may not be very different from the leadership style practiced by his two predecessors at Chrysler.
But he must be different if he is to succeed in making sustainable changes.
Is he flexible enough to become the transformational leader that Chrysler so desperately needs or will he ignore Chrysler's rough ride over the last ten years, grab the reins, ignore the cultural differences, and simply repeat history? Can he be tough on the problems but at the same time restore morale and create a project-based environment that motivates not alienates its project teams?
Or, will he be the third in a string of tough CEOs and continue with the beatings until the morale at Chrysler improves? The simple answer of above challenges can be filled by understating and suggesting the implementing the global project strategies

A clear project strategy, one that acknowledges and plans for the complexities of the project management process, is certainly a critical factor in achieving a successful project outcome. But a clear strategy is often challenging to achieve.

One complex factor is that an increasing number of project activities are no longer confined within the boundaries of an organization or even confined within the boundaries of a geographic region. Today, it is not unusual to have a product designed in one country with prototypes and production occurring in another. Or, it is not unusual for IT integration projects to be unfolded across many business units throughout the globe.

We can argue that all projects are basically the same regardless of where in the world they take place. After all, they proceed through the same stages from initiation to closing. And the management and control processes within these stages are more similar than they are different. If we accept this argument then projects are the same regardless of where they occur.

But the evidence - including my own research and experience with clients in India, EU, the Middle East, China, Korea and the US – points to some very significant differences once you cross borders. Work processes are different, governance structures are different, communications are different, stakeholder involvement is different and organizational cultures are different. And unless these differences are recognized it may be more difficult to succeed in using the concepts, methodologies, procedures, tools, and templates that support the project management process.

Sometimes these differences explain why deliveries are late, why quality has been disappointing, why costs are higher than expected, why business trips to suppliers are frustrating, and why instructions are not followed. And understanding the “Why” can help in improving the process.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Rise Up

...Rise Up Tiffany R. Sims African American Art Dr. Akua McDaniel 11/20/12 Struggle. Hope. Change. Since the colonial period, and even many years before this time period, African-American people struggled with inequality, lack of rights, and racial injustice. This struggle came to a historical high during The Civil War in the 1860’s. With much effort and persistence, the war ended and slavery was abolished in the nation. The result brought hope to black people in the United States. This newfound faith amongst black people was captured in many different forms, such as propaganda, literature, and most importantly, art. Two black, female artists portrayed this spirit in the forms of sculptures. During the Post-Civil War era, Edmonia Lewis and Meta Warrick Fuller created works that symbolized the struggle for freedom, hope for the future, and a need for change for African-American people. The American Civil War was arguably one of the most deadliest and important events in the nation’s history. Political tensions came to an all-time high and caused a split and war amongst the States from 1861-1865. Slavery was a root cause of the war. The North, also known as the Union, was fighting for the abolishment of slavery while the South, also known as the Confederacy, was fighting to preserve slavery laws in the nation. In the end, the North prevailed and laws were made to end slavery and give black people the rights and privileges they deserved.......

Words: 1676 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Daimler and Chrysler: Lessons from a Merger

...“Daimler and Chrysler: lessons from a merger”. This case study is about the merger occurred in 1998 between two big companies in the auto industry: German company Daimler-Benz and American auto manufacturer Chrysler Group. At the end, this merger appeared to be a failure because of different types of problems. Chrysler benefited from Mercedes while benefits to Daimler were harder to find, so that Daimler decided to sell 80% of its stake in Chrysler for just 7.4 billion dollars. They were two companies from different countries with different languages and different styles that came together although there were no synergies. First of all, these firms operated in the same sector but they had different customers, goals and cultures so there was a lack of common vision and values. Daimler was a luxury brand based on excellence and superior engineering that wanted to enter new markets and develop new products, especially by raising its standing in the North American auto market. On the other hand, Chrysler addressed to “blue collars” purchasers and decided to look for a partner being aware of the overcapacity in the industry. Originally, the plan was for Chrysler to use Daimler parts, components and even vehicle architecture to sharply reduce the cost to produce future vehicles. The operation started with the intention to realize a “merger of equals” but it ended up being more like an acquisition as Daimler strove to impose its own position, even though Chrysler was......

Words: 597 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Top Down Cisco

... Top-Down Network Design Third Edition Priscilla Oppenheimer Priscilla Oppenheimer Cisco Press 800 East 96th Street Indianapolis, IN 46240 ii Top-Down Network Design Top-Down Network Design, Third Edition Priscilla Oppenheimer Copyright© 2011 Cisco Systems, Inc. Published by: Cisco Press 800 East 96th Street Indianapolis, IN 46240 USA All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the publisher, except for the inclusion of brief quotations in a review. Printed in the United States of America First Printing August 2010 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication data is on file. ISBN-13: 978-1-58720-283-4 ISBN-10: 1-58720-283-2 Warning and Disclaimer This book is designed to provide information about top-down network design. Every effort has been made to make this book as complete and as accurate as possible, but no warranty or fitness is implied. The information is provided on an “as is” basis. The author, Cisco Press, and Cisco Systems, Inc. shall have neither liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to any loss or damages arising from the information contained in this book or from the use of the discs or programs that may accompany it. The opinions expressed in this book belong to the author and are not necessarily those of......

Words: 79785 - Pages: 320

Premium Essay

Project Failures project failure? June Verner NICTA Alexandria Sydney Australia Jennifer Sampson NICTA Alexandria Sydney Australia Narciso Cerpa University olTalca Talca Chile It has been suggested that there is more than one reason for a software development project to fail. However, most of the literature that discusses project failure tends to be rather general, supplying us with lists of risk aod failure factors, and focusing on the negative business effects of the failure. Very little research has attempted an in-depth investigation of anum ber of failed projects to identify exactly what are the factors behind the failure. In this research we analyze data from 70 failed projects. This data provides us with practitioners' perspectives on 57 development and management factors for projects they considered were failures. Our results show that all projects we investigated suffered from numerous failure factors. For a single project the number of such factors ranges from 5 to 47. While there does not appear to be any overarching set of failure factors we discovered that all of the projects suffered from poor project management Most projects additionally suffered from organizational factors outside the project manager's control. We conclude with suggestions for minimizing the four most common failure factors. Abstract - Index terms software project failure, software project management,......

Words: 5556 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Erp Implementation-Procedures, Issues, Challenges & Failures

...MORE FREE TERM PAPERS ON SITE: SOFTWARE PROJECT MANAGEMENT A Term Paper ON ERP Implementation-Procedures, Issues, Challenges & Failures Introduction An Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system is an integrated computer-based application used to manage internal and external resources, including tangible assets, financial resources, materials, and human resources. Its purpose is to facilitate the flow of information between all business functions inside the boundaries of the organization and manage the connections to outside stakeholders. Built on a centralized database and normally utilizing a common computing platform, ERP systems consolidate all business operations into a uniform and enterprise-wide system environment. An ERP system can either reside on a centralized server or be distributed across modular hardware and software units that provide "services" and communicate on a local area network. The distributed design allows a business to assemble modules from different vendors without the need for the placement of multiple copies of complex and expensive computer systems in areas which will not use their full capacity. To be considered an ERP system, a software package should have the following traits: ➢ Should be integrated and operate in real time with no periodic batch updates. ➢ All applications should access......

Words: 4678 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Can Marissa Mayer Save Yahoo?

...Can Marissa Mayer Save Yahoo? By Brad Stone on August 01, 2013 Marissa Mayer is sitting in URLs, the Yahoo! (YHOO) cafeteria, making the case for the future of a company that almost everyone in Silicon Valley views as doomed. Employees swarm around her, assembling rows of chairs for the afternoon’s FYI, a new weekly ritual where employees get to lob questions at Mayer and her executive team. It’s been a long July, in which Mayer’s one-year anniversary as chief executive officer was marked with an uninspiring second-quarter earnings report. Mayer prefers to focus on the company’s increase in Web traffic. She won’t give numbers but says it’s enough to erase the entire decline from the previous year. “Name another Internet giant that went through three years of decline and then started to grow again,” she says. “It’s a very good sign.” When Mayer left her executive role at Google (GOOG), she knew she was taking on what might be the hardest job in the Valley. Yahoo has had a lost decade, laboring under a series of failed product strategies and CEOs. It was a Web directory under founders Jerry Yang and David Filo, then a Web portal under Tim Koogle. Terry Semel made it a tech company with Hollywood pretensions, and, most recently, it languished under Carol Bartz and Scott Thompson as a dot-com relic known mostly for losing its top talent to competitors. Now Mayer wants to transform it into...

Words: 2943 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Economic Ups and Downs

...a big change, up or down, in GDP. Negative GDP growth plays a role in determining a recession, a period when real GDP falls for six months. “Real GDP does not always grow smoothly—sometimes it collapses suddenly, and the result is an economic downturn.” (O’Sullivan, 2014, p. 302). Sometimes this economic downturn can lead to a depression, a severe recession. Moderate contraction and expansion cycles are part of the normal economic system. Throughout history there have been many fluctuations in the GDP of the United States caused for various reasons such as drastic changes in the stock market, oil prices, world events, and wars. Some fluctuations have had more wide-spread, lasting effects than others. The Great Depression was the time from 1929 to 1933 when the real GDP took a nosedive, creating the “most severe disruptions to ordinary economic life in the United States during the twentieth century.” (O’Sullivan, 2014, p. 303). The effects of the Great Depression were felt throughout the world. In 1933, the United States GDP was sitting at -45.32%. The country was still with the grip of the Depression. Many things contributed to that dark time in our history including the stock market crash of 1929, bank failures, reduction in purchasing (which, in turn, led to reduction in production and, therefore, reduction in the workforce making unemployment at 25%), and the Dust Bowl. The whole domino effect over the course of several years, made recovery from so many......

Words: 1048 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Top Qualities of a Project Manager

...Top 10 Qualities of a Project Manager What qualities are most important for a project leader to be effective? Over the past few years, the people at ESI International, world leaders in Project Management Training, have looked in to what makes an effective project leader. With the unique opportunity to ask some of the most talented project leaders in the world on their Project Leadership courses ESI have managed to collect a running tally on their responses. Below are the top 10 in rank order according to frequency listed. Inspires a Shared Vision An effective project leader is often described as having a vision of where to go and the ability to articulate it. Visionaries thrive on change and being able to draw new boundaries. It was once said that a leader is someone who "lifts us up, gives us a reason for being and gives the vision and spirit to change." Visionary leaders enable people to feel they have a real stake in the project. They empower people to experience the vision on their own. According to Bennis "They offer people opportunities to create their own vision, to explore what the vision will mean to their jobs and lives, and to envision their future as part of the vision for the organisation." (Bennis, 1997) Good Communicator The ability to communicate with people at all levels is almost always named as the second most important skill by project managers and team members. Project leadership calls for clear communication about goals, responsibility,......

Words: 1250 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Project Failure Case Studies and Suggestion

...8887) Volume 86 – No 6, January 2014 Project Failure Case Studies and Suggestion Nilofur Abbasi Iqra Wajid Zahra Iqbal Fareeha Zafar, M.phill Business Administration, Kinnaird College Lahore, Pakistan M.phill Business Administration, Kinnaird College Lahore, Pakistan M.phill Business Administration, Kinnaird College Lahore, Pakistan Ph.D University of Derby, Currently Working in Govt. College University Lahore Pakistan ABSTRACT In this research paper three different case studies are taken under consideration. Step by step all three cases are described. These cases are about projects which had to face failure. Therefore, the reasons for failure of projects are identified and recommendations are given to ail failing projects. First case study is about British Petroleum which is oil and Gas Company had to face situation which was not just critical but new for any oil company. The incident occurred due to explosion in the deep-water horizon while BP technical staff was trying to drill a well. Moreover, BP was not able to stop oil flow for three months. Second case is about Chrysler and Fiat. Both were automobile companies and had to face failure. Marchionne was the one who saved both companies. The main focus of this case is merger of these two companies and the challenges faced by CEO due to organizational change after merger. Third case study is about Millennium Dome, one of the controversial projects in the history of construction projects because of number of......

Words: 4459 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Top Down vs Bottom Up

...Top-Down, Bottom-Up and Metacognition – Discovering the Mind Angelica Lipscomb PHYC102-1402B-10 Robin Redfern June 15, 2014 Abstract In scientific psychology the question of how information is processed is achieved by asking to what amount a psychological procedure is motivated by top-down as opposed to bottom-up information. The difference between top-down and bottom-up processing is commonly used in experimental psychology. Top-down processing proposes that we form our observations starting with a bigger objective, thought, or knowledge before working our way in the direction of more thorough information. Bottom-up processing, also identified as "small chunk" processing, proposes that we attend to or identify essentials by beginning with the slighter, finer specifics of that component and then move upward until we have a firm illustration of it in our minds. Top-down processing is also identified as conceptually-driven processing, because your observations are swayed by anticipations, beliefs, and perceptions. Sometimes people are mindful of these encouragements, but in other cases this procedure happens without mindful cognizance. Top-down processing can be useful when we are searching for similarities in our environment, but it can also obstruct our capability to recognize things in diverse ways. Our prejudice toward observing things in a particular way is recognized as a perceptual set. A good example of top-down processing is the sentence that is traveling......

Words: 1040 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Can India and China Rise Peacefully?

...Eli GreenspanGVPT409HKastner05-10-2012Can India and China Rise Peacefully?India and China are two of the world’s oldest civilization-states and are now aspiring superpowers engaged in the global economy and possess expanding military capabilities.1Cultural and economic ties date back to Ancient times when the Silk Road was used as a major trade route between the two great countries. Over the course of the 20th century, relations between the two ranged from allying and friendship, to intense conflicts over border disputes.2Despite these crisis’s, the two nations have developed close economic ties that are mutually beneficial. Trade has increased dramatically over the past decade and companies form joint ventures to further ties. History shows that this has not always been the case, and the competitivenature between the two states stems from border disputes from the early 1950s to the late 1980s.3Despite gestures towards a peaceful partnership throughout the 1950s, those gestures were challenged by actions in the disputed territories. The Five Principles of Peaceful Coexistence, signed in 1954, is an example of such cooperation. However, China nor India 1Malik, Mohan. "India-China Relations: Giants Stir, Cooperate and Compete." Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies (2004).2Malik, Mohan. 3 Malik, Mohan.1 followed these closely and still lead to major conflict following these meetings. Nevertheless, this agreement stated the principles as:1.Mutual respect for each other’s......

Words: 2676 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Top Down Ecology Worksheet

...EcoBeaker: Top-Down Control Student Name: Please complete all questions on this worksheet, save and upload to Canvas. Please format your answers in bold font or a different color so that your instructor can find them. Exercise 1: Interactions in a Two-Level System [ 3.1 ] Which of the two is the better competitor under most conditions—green algae or 
 [ 3.2 ] Which of the two can grow to the larger size—Daphnia or Bosmina? [ 4.1 ] Examine the graphs of population size and record the number of each species in the DATA TABLE 1 below, in the Trial 1 column. You can click on the bars on the graph to obtain exact values. [ 5.1 ] Record the population sizes for Trial 2 and Trial 3 in the respective columns in DATA TABLE 1. [ 5.2 ] Calculate the average population size for each species from your three trials and record in DATA TABLE 1. DATA TABLE 1. POPULATION SIZES PRESENT IN THE LAKE TRIAL 1 TRIAL 2 TRIAL 3 AVERAGE Green Algae Cyanobacteria Daphnia Bosmina [ 5.3 ] Are your results consistent with what you learned about each species from the library entries? Explain. Exercise 2: Adding Alewife [ 3.1 ] Examine the graphs of population size and record the number of each species in DATA TABLE 2 below. [ 4.1 ] Record your data in the Trial 2 and Trial 3 columns in DATA TABLE 2. [ 4.2 ] Calculate the average population size for each species from your three trials and record in DATA TABLE 2. DATA TABLE 2. POPULATION SIZES......

Words: 671 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Top Pm Challenge

...Top Project Manager Challenge: Team Motivation Yevhen Grinman Executive Summary Practice to hire profession project manager (PM) to lead projects is becoming more and more popular in organizations. However, project managers’ scope of responsibilities is usually misunderstood. Yet the belief in that project manager is responsible for project’s success and failure is common among researchers. According to PMBOK (2008) successful project is the one that achieved on time, on schedule, and within the budget; this definition of success identifies only variables that need to be addressed, while there are more pieces to successful project management. According to common definition PM is responsible to ensure project’s “timely delivery, adherence to budget constraints, scope, and quality specifications” (PMBOK, 2008). However, successful project management is more than just following presumed project management methodologies and techniques. PM may have necessary skills to guide project team through various stages of project while lack basic people skills that in the future can cause project’s failure. Herein lays major scope of project manager’s responsibilities in meeting project objectives as well as fulfilling team members’ behavioral needs. Some project managers along with researchers tend to overlook less tangible elements of successful project which is team motivation. Top PM Challenge In Fundamentals of Project Management Heagney (2012) reveals that......

Words: 564 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


...Lee Iacocca Chrysler Turnaround Rodger Strother Keller Graduate School of Management Executive Summary Chrysler was founded by Walter Chrysler on June 6, 1925 when the Maxwell Motor Company (established 1904) was re-organized into the Chrysler Corporation. Walter Chrysler has arrived at the Maxwell organization in the early 1920’s and launched the Chrysler vehicle. This new vehicle had six cylinders with advanced engineering and was more affordable. This vehicle included (new at the time) air filter for carburetor, a high compression engine, full pressure lubrication. Among the new innovations at the time was the fact that it was the first mass produced practical four wheel hydraulic brakes and rubber engine mounts to reduce vibrations. It was during the early 1920’s that Walter Chrysler assumed the presidency of Maxwell and the company incorporated under the Chrysler name. From the company’s conception the Chrysler name continued down the path of continued growth and acquisitions of various and numerous brands that would in the years be associated with the Chrysler name. Dodge, Plymouth, AMC, DeSoto and various others over the years. The years following the Second World War with the restraint on consumer goods lifted there was an increase demand for automobiles. Vehicles steadily became more reliable and the implementation of interstate highway plans with more paved roads this attracted more motorist. This resulted in an overall expansion of the automotive......

Words: 4227 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Top Bookstore on the Rise

... | |TOP Bookstore on the Rise | |Technology in the Bookstore | | | | Table of Contents Proposal I. Subject of the Project II. Business Problem Statement III. General benefits to the organization IV. High level Approaches V. Audience Milestone 1 I. Company Background II. Discussion of Business issues III. Benefits of Solving the problem IV. Businses/technical Approach V. High Level Solution Milestone 2 I. Technology or business practices used to augment the solution II. Value of the Approach III. Business process changes Milestone I. Technology or business practices used to augment the solution (plus) II. Conclusions and overall recommendations III. High-level implementation plan IV. Summary of project PROPOSAL 1. Subject of Course Project The subject of my Course Project is TOP Bookstore using technology to increase competitiveness......

Words: 2704 - Pages: 11