Free Essay

Psy Reli

In: Social Issues

Submitted By greta1819
Words 809
Pages 4
Discuss issues of reliability and validity associated with the classification and diagnosis of schizophrenia (8+16)
One issue related to classification and diagnosis is reliability. Reliability refers to the consistency of a measuring instrument like DSM that is used when diagnosing schizophrenia. It can be measured by the extent to which psychiatrists can agree on the same diagnosis when independently assessing patients (inter rater reliability). The use of DSM III in 1990 was believed by Carson to have fixed any problems of IRR. Therefore the system is now more advanced with the DSM 5, there would be much greater agreement over who did and didn’t have schizophrenia by comparing the diagnosis which would make it reliable.
However there is little evidence that DSM is routinely used with high reliability by mental health clinicians. For example Whaley found that IRR between health professionals were low as .11 between different raters. This suggests that when independently assessing patients the diagnosis was rarely consistent between them, meaning the DSM tool is unreliable in accurately and consistently diagnosing schizophrenia.
There are also cultural differences about the interpretations of schizophrenia which poses a threat to reliability of the diagnosis of schizophrenia. For example Copeland et al gave a description of a patient showing clinical characteristics associated with schizophrenia to US and UK psychiatrists. From the US psychiatrists 69% diagnosed the patients as schizophrenic compared to only 2% of the UK. This suggests that the diagnostic criteria had a different meaning in a different culture and therefore the diagnostic criterion is not reliable when used in a different cultural setting. And contains culture bias; as behavior in one country can be seen as relatively normal within the context of that culture but possibly a symptom of schizophrenia in another country. On top of this the issue of classification and diagnosis is validity. This can be shown in Rosenhan study that found from his study of being insane in sane places, where 7 of the pseudo patients claimed that they had heard voices, were diagnosed as schizophrenics while 1 of 8 was given the diagnosis of depression. This raises the issue of comorbidity that refers to the extent that two or more conditions can occur i.e. schizophrenia and depression and therefore the extent to which the condition is real and distinct. This shows that schizophrenia is not a separate entity and therefore diagnosing category may not be useful for deciding treatment. This is supported by Buckley who estimates that comorbidity depression occurs in 50% of patients and 47% of patients also have lifetime diagnosis of comorbidity abuse.
In addition the unreliability of the classification and diagnosis come from in a follow up study by Rosenhan. Psychiatrists at several mental hospitals were told to expect psedopatients over a period of several months. This resulted in a 21% detection rate by psychiatrists even though none were actually sent. This shows that the diagnostic criteria used by psychiatrists could not reliability identify a person with schizophrenia.
One way to avoid the issue of comorbidity is to use first rank symptoms of schizophrenia like delusions and hallucinations when diagnosing a patient. However Bentall et al claims that many of the first rank symptoms of schizophrenia are also found in other disorders like bipolar and depression. This makes it difficult to separate schizophrenia as a distinct disorder and suggests that schizophrenia is not a distinct condition.
The above suggests that schizophrenia is not a discrete disorder but instead there is a spectrum of psychotic symptoms. For instance Allardyce et al claims that symptoms used to characterise schizophrenia do not define a specific disorder because its symptoms are also found in other categories of DSM and therefore it should just be a psychotic spectrum.
Another aspect of validity is predictive validity this is the validity of a diagnosis by demonstrating that it can predict scores on some criterion measure. So if a disorder has high predictive validity then it should be clear how the disorder would develop and how people would respond to treatment.
Research has found low predictive validity for schizophrenia. For example only about 20% recover their previous level of functioning but 40% never really recover. This much variation in the prognosis suggests that the original diagnosis is lacked predictive validity, thus the diagnosis was not helpful in dealing with the course of schizophrenia.
Research has shown other factors like ethnicity, poor housing may be more influential whether an individual has schizophrenia or not. For instance it seems more to do with ethnicity as rates of schizophrenia are high among Afro Caribbean population when compared to whites in the UK. This may be due to them being misdiagnosed as schizophrenia as they not able to explain their disorder. However vast majority of research is carried out on white middle class Americans who can afford to see a therapist.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Psy Critique

...Garret Necaise 5/7/12 PSY 435 TuTh 11:00-12:15pm Article Critique #1 (Addiction Theories) “Television addiction: Theories and Data Behind the Ubiquitous Metaphor” This article was presented in the American Psychological Association by Robert Mcllwraith, Robin Jacobvitz, Robert Kubey, and Alison Alexander. Mcllwraith is the head of the Department of Clinical Health Psychology and the director of the Rural and Northern Psychology Program. Jacobvitz is a Psychology educator and consultant in Albuquerque, NM. Kubey is the professor of Journalism and Media Studies, and director of the Center for Media Studies at Rutgers University. Alexander has a Ph.D in Communication at Ohio State and has taught research methods, writing, media and society, and seminars in children and television. The reader population for this article is focused on an interest or relation to television addiction. The authors wrote this to present four theoretical models of television addiction derived from existing psychological data on this subject. These models are valuable because they give the reader a viewpoint on where this type of addiction is based from: the television's effects on imagination, the arousal level affected from the effect of television, a manifestation of a dependent or addictive personality, and a pattern of uses associated with the television medium. However, it still remains to be determined whether or not this use of television for effect modulation represents a......

Words: 3526 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay


...Drug-Free Workplace Evaluation Andrew Rhea, Rebecca Chiavetta, Jami Krebs, and Lisa Meier PSY 425 November 12, 2012 Dr. Elizabeth Riegner Drug-Free Workplace Evaluation Imagine an employee is returning from a lunch break, and a coworker is collaborating with this individual in an erratic manner. The coworker’s actions make this employee feel unsafe, and cause him or her to become unproductive. The coworker has an accident, and the company is shutdown to investigate the accident. The previous scenario has often occurred throughout the United States, causing companies to lose money from possible lawsuits, and decreased productivity in the workplace. Illicit, and prescription drug use is prevalent in the United States, and causes absenteeism, accidents, downtime, turnover, theft, morale issues, and decreased productivity in the workplace (University of Phoenix, 2012). This proves that companies benefit from instituting drug-free workplace policies with mandatory drug testing within the workplace. Creating a drug-free work environment is a cost-effective necessity in the workplace, and establishing a drug-free work environment will have positive effects on a company. Prevalence of illicit and prescription drug users in the United States workforce Prescription drugs are "dispensed to the public only with an order given by a properly authorized person" (The Free Dictionary, 2012, p. 1). In 1999, American's spent nearly $104.7 billion on prescription drugs, which......

Words: 1401 - Pages: 6

Free Essay


...|[pic] |Course Syllabus | | |College of Social Sciences | | |PSY/301 Version 2 | | |Emotional Intelligence | Copyright © 2010, 2009, 2006, 1997 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. Course Description This course examines the concepts and practical applications of emotional intelligence. Emotional intelligence is the ability to manage one's own internal emotional environment and one's ability to participate in relationships with others. Through a highly interactive format, the course will focus on how to assess basic skills in emotional intelligence, how to develop strategies to improve and enhance basic skill levels, and how to experiment with techniques that facilitate dealing with others of varying emotional backgrounds and competency levels. Policies Students/learners will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents: • University policies: You must be logged into the student website to view......

Words: 719 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Psy 201

...Caitlin Hildenbrand Motivational Program Proposal Week 4 Assignment Psy/201 When a person has heard all the points of view of different people around him and being able to determine which statements to believe and what statements not are not believe many times that people only focus on what they heard first without asking for other parties about what really happened. Motivational proposal is to plan to achieve a few different goals. By setting these goals, we are making milestones in our goal. We need to keep these milestones realistic but achievable. If we overwhelm ourselves. The motivation will not be there when we fail to meet our first milestones. There still incentive involved but the overall goal will not be achieved if not properly planned accordingly. Since the incentive is to make money the motivation is there and I am ready to work hard for these next few months to get my crops in the dirt. I have some farming experience. I can find motivation in what I will be trying to accomplish. I actually I have a friend that is going to be there helping me with the work so with our strategy planned out and goal set. As long as we stay determined and motivated we can accomplish for your set out to do an important thing to do is to get our seeds started early so that were harvesting in the right time of year depending on the appropriate crops that we plan. The details can be a little technical because of all the different plants and time frames but the general idea is......

Words: 359 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Psy 1010

...other law abiding cars on the road I probably wouldn’t get pulled over. c. Cultural I guess? d.Positive, I didn’t get pulled over anymore and was eventually able to get my license back. Summary and Conclusions What insights have you gained from this exercise? What conclusions can you draw from your answers? I spend way to many years railing against conformity only to realize I was one of many many angry teens doing the exact same thing. My anti-conformity had become conformity. So now I just try to do what feels right and forget what everyone else is doing. ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________ PSY 101 Homework grading rubric □ Yes □ No Did you follow the instructions? □ Yes □ No Did you check for legibility/readability? □ Yes □ No Did you check for spelling/grammatical errors and understandability? Followed instructions|Did not follow the instructions of the assignment or did not follow key aspects of the assignment.0 points|Followed most of the instructions of the assignment.2 points|Followed all parts of the instructions of the assignment.4 points| Complete/Relevant|Assignment is not done or not relevant to the assignment.0 points|Assignment is partially complete or not fully relevant to the assignment.2 points|Assignment is complete and relevant to the assignment.4......

Words: 804 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY PSY/201 SCENARIO ASSIGNMENT PAPER. Social Psychology Paper ANGELA R. CARY PSY/201 October 03, 2013 Jennifer Baker Social Psychology Paper There were several factors that contributed to Sarah’s attitude in regards to her curfew. Some of these were motivation, compliance and conformity, Normative and Informational Social Influence. Other factors that affected Sarah’s behavior, action and thoughts may include persuasion and peer-pressure. Some of the ways that Sarah displayed cognitive dissonance were disobeying curfew, going to a party, and unnecessary worry. When Sarah decided to go to the party she displayed conformity in order to go along (comply) and fit in with a popular group from school. Sarah felt a need to be accepted by a new group because she was in a new social environment and wants to be accepted and popular in the group also. Sarah may have fears of meeting new people and being in a new environment therefore she conform to a large group of people which is a difficult task. Sarah is also experiencing “incongruous” emotions, actions and behaviors at this time which is not “normal” for her. Sarah begins to avoid her curfew time, and disobey the rules and guidelines her parents had set for her previously, by agreeing to go to the party and being late. She also decides that being accepted and popular by the new group has given her some self satisfaction and happy feelings as well as gained acceptance......

Words: 941 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...Psychodynamic Theories Jayme Terrigno PSY/405 October 6, 2014 Patti Tolar Psychodynamic Theories According to "Good Therapy" (2014), “The psychological interpretation of mental and emotional processes—is rooted in traditional psychoanalysis and draws from object relations, ego psychology, and self psychology” (para. 1). Psychodynamic theories draw most of their information from the idea of the unconscious, especially in the development of early childhood. This paper will describe personality, discuss the mail tenets of the theories presented, discuss how each theory applies to personality and behavior, and discusses the strengths and limitations of each theory. The degree to which individual humans vary from one another, both physically and psychologically, is quite astonishing and somewhat unique among species (Feist, Feist, & Roberts 2013). Personality id the physical characteristics of a person and how it reflects toward others. Personality is the thoughts and feelings that each person holds and shows to others. It is collection of a person, but these pieces of each person tend to remain the unchanged through the years. Psychodynamic theory was developed by a Sigmund Freud, a well-known theorist, and in his own words, scientist. Sigmund Freud began to combine philosophical speculations with a primitive scientific method. As a neurologist trained in science, Freud began to listen to his patients to find out......

Words: 829 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Psy. Brocher

... • Attention is given to the “relational unconscious” which is “experientially familiar” • Awareness comes through “not knowing” and , instead, “wondering together” References: • Psychodynamic Presentation. (2014). Retrieved from • Cherry, K. (2014). Psychology Center. Retrieved from • Google. (2014). Retrieved from Psychodynamic Brochure By: Stephanie Cotton PSY 405 in Prof. Morris October 13, 2014 1. [Google, 2014] Psychodynamic Brochure BY: Stephanie Cotton PSY 405 in Professor Phillip Morris October 13, 2014 1. [Google, 2014] Personality Psychology Personality Psychology is the center of a portion of the best known brain research speculations by various renowned scholars including Sigmund Freud and Erik Erikson. In this segment of the identity study aide, take in more about a percentage of the significant hypotheses of identity and the therapists who created them. • Drive / Structural Theory • Ego Psychology • Objective Relations Theory • Self-psychology • Attachment and Relational Theories Drive / Structural Theory • “Drives” are genetically determined & seek pleasure • Libidinal (sexual) drive &......

Words: 585 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Paper Psy

...Doctor Thompson PSY 370z6 23 January 2015 Social Loafing Our text defines social loafing as “a tendency for people to exert less effort when they pool their efforts toward a common goal than when they are individually accountable.” Social loafing, a term I am new to, but know all too well, is the reason I hate group projects. Well, I take that back, let me clarify, I hate doing group projects when I am placed in a group of people that I know will not try as hard as I. I work with social loafers all day, every day. I call them middle school-ers. Often time teachers put students into groups for projects and I can see the displeasure in so many faces when they don’t get to pic their own partners. I think social loafing, or slacking off happens more often when there is a lack of communication I the group. If someone does not assert themselves as a leader and delegate work and timelines, then standards tend to drop and frustrations rise. On the flip side, I notice that students who are hard workers and care about their grades loaf socially (can I use the term like that?) far less. I feel those students hold themselves to such a high standard, not to mention, they would not want a partner to put some of the load on them, so they don’t do it to others. I can’t say that this is always the case, but most times, it is. I think social loafing is acceptable and sometimes expected in our society. I have a wonderful husband, but, there are definitely aspects of our......

Words: 393 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Psy 105

...Dislike Negative, and Toxic People Name: Sarah Wheeler Institution: Strayer University Professor: Mrs. Andrews Course: PSY 105 Date: 11/3/2013 My dislike would be negative people with bad energy. There are many people in the world that can be negative and also toxic to your health. I dislike negative people who always try to put people down instead of lifting them higher. The subfield-(developmental psychology) I believe is best suited for providing psychological insight into your preference (the fact that you dislike the thing you do) and the reason I believe it is so, is in developmental psychology is the study of how changes of behavior and cognitive processes that occur over the lifespan. (Baron & Kalsher, 2008). My reasoning of this trait in a person becoming negative and toxic over time, from dealing with life experiences during their life span. Most people that I know that are toxics due to bad childhood or bad relationships from their past life. People who have experience these life situations never bounce back from recovery. Sometimes those bad memories and thought of reasoning never pass. (Baron & Kalsher, 2008). Another factor could also be the settings we choose to continue to be in. I feel we have to learn how to reprogram our way of thinking and also move to healthier setting environment ( The biological bases of behavior comes from our hormones. They are what...

Words: 824 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Psy 101

...PSY 101 Personality & Intelligence Paper The information included in this paper will be questions answered about the following tests’: Personality and Intelligence. PSY 101 Personality & Intelligence Paper The information included in this paper will be questions answered about the following tests’: Personality and Intelligence. Jasmine Caldwell 11/16/2014 Jasmine Caldwell 11/16/2014 PSY 101 Personality & Intelligence Paper * Personality Test The personality test that I had taken was called “Leverage Your Personality Type”. From the beginning, I did not approve of this website being valid, just based upon looks and as the old saying says “don’t judge a book by its cover”. As the test came to a close it gave me a type of ISFP: Introvert (11%), Sensing (12%), Feeling (25%), and Perceiving (11%). Including those results, it also said that I have a slight preference of Introversion over Extraversion, Sensing over Intuition, Perceiving over Judging and a moderate preference of Feeling over Thinking. The second time I took the test it gave me different results. INFJ: Intorvert (22%), Intuitive (12%). Feeling (38%), and Judging (1%). (Personality Test) * Introversion over Extraversion Introversion: The state of or tendency toward being wholly or predominantly concerned with and interested in one’s own mental life. Extroversion: A behavior where someone enjoys being around people more than being alone. ...

Words: 1182 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Reli 448 Final Exam Guide

...RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide RELI 448 Final Exam Guide ......

Words: 421 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Psy 1010

...Describe the ethical principles inherent in research, teaching, and practice in the field of psychology. | 4 | Apply psychological concepts to personal, social, and organizational issues. | 5 | Explain how culture influences behavior and mental processes. | 6 | Use appropriate technology to obtain scholarly information for the purpose of writing or making presentations on relevant psychological topics. | TEXTBOOK: Textbook (required): Licht, D. M, Hull, M.G., & Ballantyne, C. (2014). Scientific American: Psychology. New York: Worth Publishers. – Best purchase: PGCC Bookstore. Ancillary (required): Access to LaunchPad, the electronic resource for this textbook. The above mentioned textbook is required for all PSY 1010 classes. Access to the textbook ancillary LaunchPad is also required. LaunchPad access is necessary to complete required assignments in this course. If you do not have access to this resource you will NOT be able to successfully complete assignments. We are using a loose leaf version of the textbook which is a more cost efficient printed option. Purchase of any of the printed options comes with a LaunchPad access code. Purchase options are provided below. Compare prices at your discretion. 1. Prince George’s Community College Bookstore has the loose leaf version available. The ISBN in the bookstore is 978-1-3190-4823-5 2. The electronic version (e-book with LP access) can be purchased at your discretion by......

Words: 5920 - Pages: 24

Free Essay


...Moderne sharia Jens Forman: Muslimernes religion. s. 49-55. Hvem har ret til at definere sharia og hvad omfatter sharia – fire idealtyper. | Traditionalisme | Sekularisme | Modernisme | Fundamentalisme | Forholdet til den vestlige verden | Ignorer den vestlige verden og ser den som værende vantro. | Sekularisterne efterligner den vestlige verden. | Kritiske overfor den vestlige verdens indflydelse. Afviser den dog ikke, men islam skal stadig være den grundlæggendesamfundsværdi i et samfund. | Kritiserer de vestlige værdier, de tager afstand. | Forholdet til lovskolerne | Fastholder lovskolerne. | Afviser lovskolerne, da der menes, at den enkelte selv skal fortolke koranen. | Modernisterne mener ikke at lovskolerne skal have monofon på at definere islam og hajdith. Lovskolerne skal inspirere de politiske ledere, så samfundet stadigvæk har en islamisk påvirkende lovgivning. | Lovskolerne er falske, og de vil have islam tilbage til sine rødder, hvor man følger hadith og koranen. | Sharia skal styre | Sharia skal styrke tro, moral, søjler, spiseregler, familielov, påklædning og i mindre grad straffelov og statsrret. | Sharia skal styre tro og morale. | De mener, at det er individuel, der skal gøre og gældende, men samtidig så mener de, at koranen skal definere samfundets lovgivning. Bortset fra når vi kommer til straffelovene. | Sharia skal styre alt, inklusiv love. | Indadvendt/udadvendt islam | Indadvendt, da den fokusere på den individuelle og den ...

Words: 564 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Psy 315

...Basic Concepts in Positive Psychology Stuart Zarahn PSY/220 Alan Coffin 05/29/2015 Researchers refer to’ Subjective Well- Being’ as how people experience the quality of their lives, and includes both emotional and cognitive judgements. They have defined ‘happiness’ as a combination of life’s satisfactions and how frequently we experience positive and negative effects. SWB includes our mood swings and emotions, as well as an overall satisfaction of our lives. Basically, subjective well-being is the positive and negative things that happen to us, how frequently they occur, the importance as they pertain to our happiness or sadness, and are linked to our personality traits. Everyone responds in their own way to a crisis or to a joyful event, so how and why we respond depends upon our personalities. John Lennon said it best, “Life is what happens to you while you’re busy making other plans” As far as being hooked up to a feel great all the time machine, if it was temporary like the “orgasmatron” in Woody Allen’s movie, or having a tube in my mouth that was attached to a tank of nitrous oxide (reality for me in 1970), then sure, why not? If it is a permanent situation, then no thank you. I might as well be in a catatonic state, feeling no emotions, pain, or joy, disconnected from reality or in a coma. All social interactions would be gone as I sat there with a perpetual stupid grin. I knew a girl named ‘Frankie’ who dropped a lot of LSD back in the late 60’s, early......

Words: 362 - Pages: 2