Free Essay

Punctuated Equilibrium

In: Science

Submitted By misfithatesyou
Words 600
Pages 3
Punctuated equilibrium, as proposed by Gould and Eldredge in 1972, is a model of species evolution to counter the explanation of evolutionary change through phyletic gradualism, or the slow accumulation of novel adaptations over evolutionary time, culminating in the appearance of new species (speciation). Gould and Eldredge argue that evidence of gradualism would require fossil evidence of intermediary stages in a species’ evolution, with different specimen of an evolving species exhibiting ancestral traits and an increasing number of derived traits leading towards the present form. Paleontologists, however, had long noted that the fossil record was marked by long periods of stasis (on a geological scale) with the sudden appearance of new species, though these gaps were interpreted as simply missing information (Gould and Eldredge 1993). While fossil preservation is notoriously problematic (Wood et al. 1992), Gould and Eldredge (1972, 1993) proposed that the gaps in the record arise not from artifacts of preservation, but from an alternate mechanism of evolution by which small populations become isolated from parent stocks and rapidly accumulate novel adaptations leading to speciation. Thus, parent stocks remain in the geological record parallel with newly adapted species. Successfully adapted species would thereafter remain in the fossil record as well. Thus, most species in the fossil record appear in a state of equilibrium across geological time (i.e. not exhibiting any significant morphological changes), after a seemingly spontaneous appearance. The theory rests on two central tenets: (1) that established species remain static, and (2) that macroevolutionary processes, rather than resulting from continuous processes across time within individual lineages, occur at discreet, high-level intervals as stable species achieve different evolutionary success (Gould and Eldredge, 1993).
Fossil evidence for punctuated gradualism in human evolution is given by the apparent bursts in the fossil record of novel and diverse African antelopes and primates about 5 million and 2.5 million years ago. These speciation events correlate with dramatic climactic and environmental changes estimated for those times, which could have led to widespread geographic alterations and population isolations, supporting conditions for large scale punctuated events (Klein 1989). At the same time, certain aspects of hominin evolution, such as linear increases cranial capacity and decreases in dentition (from Australopithecus to anatomically modern humans, with the exception of enlarged dentition in Paranthrapus sp.) support phyletic gradualism as a mechanism for evolutionary change. Here though, Gould and Eldredge (1993) argue that, brain growth in Homo actually occurred early in its lineage (punctuation), and that the intervening time (200, 000 years) has been too short to compare with static traits on larger geological scales. They argue that, if Homo sapiens had emerged 2 million years earlier, we would see a clear pattern of punctuation followed by long stasis consistent with the theory. The same argument can be turned around, however, and we might ask if 2 million years from now, human brains might be incrementally bigger. In essence, fossil evidence for either gradualism or punctuated equilibrium are essentially interpretations of scant evidence, with punctuated equilibrium derived solely from the available evidence, and gradualism derived from the veritable absence of evidence. While punctuated equilibrium may be the more pragmatic in terms of examining fossil evidence, it is plainly short-sighted to ignore vast swaths of missing evidence given the realities of fossil preservation (Wood et al. 1992). Just as Gould and Eldredge criticize assumptions made about the fossil record to support gradualism the criticisms could be levied against interpreting the record to support punctuated equilibrium. Writes Klein (1989), “it is the nature of the record, not logic or experiment, that most strongly supports punctuated equilibrium.”

Similar Documents

Free Essay


...In the first segment I will be talking about phyletic gradualism and punctuated equilibrium. In the second part of the paper I will be discussing fossil records and the connection they have with punctuated equilibrium. Finally I will be talking about rapid evolution and relative stasis. Explain the concepts of phyletic gradualism and punctuated equilibrium. Phyletic gradualism is a model of evolution. The theory of phyletic gradualism states that the rise of new species is slow, uniform and gradual. In this theory there is no real clear line between ancestral and descendant species. Punctuated equilibrium is a hypothesis, which holds that evolutionary changes usually occur in short bursts separated by long periods of stability. Both phyletic gradualism and punctuated equilibrium are different types of evolution. There are two types of evolution macroevolution and microevolution. Microevolution is slight short-term changes within a species. For example in humans there are different eye colors and hair colors. What predictions about the fossil record does punctuated equilibrium make? Evolution and punctuated equilibrium which state that changes in species occur in short bursts separated by periods of time. Many evolutionists believe that new species are descended from other species that have already existed. Evolution also states that many populations of pre-existing species have evolved into other species over a period of time....

Words: 677 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


...The new species will only leave fossils at the same site as the old one if it becomes successful enough to move back into its ancestral range or different enough to exist alongside its relatives” (Evolution: Library: Punctuated Equilibrium, n.d., p....

Words: 275 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Theory of Evolution

...The controversial debate of punctuated equilibrium and phyletic gradualism still exists, but the interesting research continues with fossil records, patterns of punctuated equilibrium, and maybe even more with the use of innovations of today. It is safe to say that scientists agree there is two models of growth which theorizes evolution of species can emerge. A species can change by phyletic gradualism and punctuated equilibrium or both. Scientist believes species with a shorter evolution change is mostly by punctuated equilibrium, however, those with a longer progression developed mostly by gradualism. Phyletic gradualism happens gradually in variation and selection where change occurs “slow, constant, and consistent” over long periods of time leading to change in population (necsi). Phyletic gradualism is in difference to the theory of punctuated equilibrium, which suggests change comes in spurts where periods of slight change and then one or few massive changes occur. The species tend to change quickly over a few...

Words: 843 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business and Change

...The punctuated equilibrium model and emergent change model suggest that the current business environment is volatile and unpredictable, which make planned change hard to achieve every time, especially when change is reactive. This essay will also discuss of the role of a change agent in organisations and whether using internal or consultant change agents affect the change process. On the surface, the one right way to change is unrealistic and potentially goes against the best interests of the organisation. Burnes (1996) argues that theory not only prescribes what an organisation should do, but also denies the organisation to have choice over whether to adopt these prescriptions or not. Many change management theories attempt to offer the best way regardless of the organisation. One of the first planned change management models was presented by Lewin, called the three-step model. This model has set the standard for change theories for 50...

Words: 2514 - Pages: 11

Free Essay


...What appears to be the key elements of team effectiveness? In particular consider the importance of leadership in teams and reflect critically on your own leadership Effective team working is an essential ingredient for organisational success. Successful teams can help transform an organisation, increase outputs and deliver on organisational objectives. Gorman (1998) argues that the composition of teams, how they work together, how they are motivated and the quality of leadership within teams are just some of the elements that contribute to making a successful organisation. However it has been said that effective teams are not a natural phenomenon (Mcshane &Tavaglione, 2007). In conformance with the last statement a team is said to be a group of two or more people who influence and interact with one another, perceive themselves as a social entity within an organisation and who work towards, and are mutually accountable for, achieving shared goals associated with organisational objective (Mcshane &Tavaglione, 2007). This essay will discuss the key elements of team effectiveness; will then consider the importance of leadership in a team linking theory with practice, by critically......

Words: 1269 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Social Thinking and Infuences

...When gene flow between two populations ceases, the potential for _____ exists. Speciation Bird guides once listed the myrtle warbler and Audubon's warbler as distinct species that lived side by side in parts of their ranges. However, recent books show them as eastern and western forms of a single species, the yellow-rumped warbler. Apparently, the myrtle warbler and Audubon's warbler _____. A) Successfully interbreed and produce fertile offspring successfully interbreed and produce fertile offspring Imagine that part of a population of South American finches is blown by a storm onto an island far offshore and manages to survive and reproduce there for a period of 10,000 years. After that period, a climate change results in lower sea levels and the reconnection of the island with the mainland. Members of the formerly isolated island finch population can now interact freely with members of the original mainland population. Which of the following observations would, by itself, lead you to conclude unequivocally that the island finch population had evolved into a distinct species, according to the biological species concept? A) Individuals from the different populations sometimes mate with each other, but all of the resulting eggs are sterile. Which of the following conditions is necessary for speciation to occur? D) Reproductive isolation At which point in the adaptation of a population is it clear that speciation has occurred? B) Gene pool changes establish......

Words: 3591 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

12 Angry Men

...Organizational Behavior Assignment Group Behavior A1: The Punctuated Equilibrium Model Of Group Development The behaviours of the jury in the Movie supports the theory of punctuated equilibrium. The jury's deliberation which found the boy guilty eleven votes to one set the tone for the first half of the movie. During this time, the majority were still quite fixed in their guilty verdict and not very open or willing to consider other points of view. A significant transition took place when the old man supported the architect's (jury 8) questioning of the validity of the testimony. At this point the discussion the man from the slum, also changed his vote. This was right at the midpoint of the movie and soon after this the tone of the conversation of the group began to change. Following the midpoint transition, the second phase was marked by more skilful dialogue and genuine curiosity. The group moved towards a firmer conviction that the boy was not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Ultimately, even the most stubborn of the jurors changed their views. A2: The Group Think Phenomenon Group-think, which is agreeing to avoid conflict this theory exists most often when people are in a group, because some people have the tendency to agree with the majority instead of stating their own opinions. The members of the jury all vote guilty right off the bat except Juror No 8. The other jurors never had much reason to vote guilty in the first place....

Words: 571 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Lake Dziengel

...Journal of Gay & Lesbian Social Services, 22:165–182, 2010 Copyright © Taylor & Francis Group, LLC ISSN: 1053-8720 print / 1540-4056 online DOI: 10.1080/10538720903332578 Advocacy Coalitions and Punctuated Equilibrium in the Same-Sex Marriage Debate: Learning from Pro-LGBT Policy Changes in Minneapolis and Minnesota LAKE DZIENGEL St. Cloud State University, St. Cloud, Minnesota Policy change to actualize same-sex marriage requires planning and practices that can be most effective to advance marriage equality. This case study examines how building and maintaining strong coalitions aided in attainment and preservation of civil rights and protections for same-sex couples in Minnesota. As a historical policy analysis, it dissects collaborative strategies and events that led to a municipal domestic partner ordinance and state civil rights protections for sexual minorities in Minnesota during 1983–1995. Viewed through the lens of Advocacy Coalition Framework and Punctuated Equilibrium theory, findings support and highlight the importance of strategic planning of developing capable leaders, building strong coalitions, and capitalizing on events to garner public support and advance public policy toward civil rights protections and legal recognition for same-sex couples....

Words: 7472 - Pages: 30

Free Essay

12 Twelve Man

...1 Twelve Angry Men: An Analysis of Group Effectiveness The Infrareds Ruth Bradner, Penelope McFarline, Michelle McGregor, Jonathon West VCU ADLT 612 Dr. Terry Carter, Professor 2 Twelve Angry Men: An Analysis of Group Effectiveness Introduction Twelve men with diverse backgrounds are sequestered in a room and are unable to leave until a decision, a weighty one that will either condemn a young man to death or set him free, is made. The twelve strangers are bound to each other, trapped within the confines of four immovable walls, until the goal is achieved. They melt in the humidity of middle summer, which is exacerbated by the room's stuffiness and by the stress of their task. We, the audience, sweat as they grapple with each other and with the responsibility that is theirs to fulfill. One could spend a great deal of time debating if the jurors who comprised the cast of “Twelve Angry Men” (Lumet, 1957) were a group or a team. One could, and we will, cite definitions and descriptions from the literature to justify one conclusion or the other. The questions that are more interesting to us, and that constitute the thesis of this paper, are these: Were the jurors an effective group (or team)? And what factors contributed to group effectiveness? Schwarz (2002) has proposed a Group Effectiveness Model that provides facilitators who work with dysfunctional groups a road map, a way to identify where groups have gone wrong. Schwarz identifies three criteria for judging group......

Words: 5325 - Pages: 22

Free Essay

Demi Join in

...Catastrophism is the theory that the Earth has been affected in the past by sudden, short-lived, violent events, possibly worldwide in scope.[1] The dominant paradigm of modern geology is uniformitarianism (sometimes described as gradualism), in which slow incremental changes, such as erosion, create the Earth's appearance. This view holds that the present is the key to the past, and that all things continue as they were from the beginning of the world. Recently a more inclusive and integrated view of geologic events has developed, changing the scientific consensus to accept some catastrophic events in the geologic past. This held that there have been violent and sudden natural catastrophes such as great floods and the rapid formation of major mountain chains. Plants and animals living in those parts of the world where such events occurred were often killed off, according to the 19th-century French scientist Georges Cuvier. Then new life forms moved in from other areas. As a result, the fossil record for a region shows abrupt changes in species. Cuvier's explanation relied solely on scientific evidence rather than biblical interpretation. Immanuel Velikovsky's In the 1950s, Immanuel Velikovsky propounded catastrophism in several popular books. He speculated that the planet Venus is a former "comet" which was ejected from Jupiterand subsequently 3,500 years ago made two catastrophic close passes by Earth, 52 years apart, and later interacted with Mars, which then had a......

Words: 634 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Rational Management

...Running Head: Management process, linear and nonlinear management, ordinary and extraordinary management, rational management, chaos theory Management - from rational management to chaos theory Submitted to Dr. D. Coleman By JJ de Klerk In partial fulfillment of the requirement for the Doctorate in Business Administration Swiss Management University March 3, 2012 1 1. Introduction Developments over the last few decades have led to a new way of thinking in economic and management approaches. The scientific approach to management, which emphasizes the basic management functions of planning, organizing, leadership and control, now seems unable to explain the era of change that characterizes economies and organizations alike. This paper will focus on explaining the rational management model, focusing on ordinary management, and go on to discuss the new approaches such as chaos theory – also called complexity theory - and the need for extraordinary management and innovation. 2. Rational management Management and organization science literature have until recently focused on the objective control of agents and worked on the assumption that interactions can be described in linear terms (Webb, 2005). When difficult decisions have to be made, many managers and strategists rely on the economics view in which profit maximization is the guiding principle. Executives will us the rational model tools described above, and believe that precise solutions should be......

Words: 2151 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Individual Reflection on Team Experience

...Another model for group development is the punctuated equilibrium (PE) model which was proposed by Gersick in 1988 (Hall, 2007). In the PE model groups do not go through stages by go through states of stability or equilibrium. The PE model has three phases. Phase 1 is the group developing agendas and norms, followed by and upset of the equilibrium followed by a new period of equilibrium Phase 2 (Hall, 2007). The punctuated equilibrium is a 3 stage...

Words: 3774 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Chapter 4

...Chapter 4 Types of Change First order: incremental change, maintain and develop the organization, they are changes designed to support organizational comunity and order. Fine-tuning, incremental Adaptive, incremental but recreative: * Individual initiatives: small-scale changes, personal initiatives, identifying and emplementing small-scale changes. Individual ability to create or exploit a tech. 1. Autocratic 2. Meritocratic 3. Social club Second order: discontinuos change “is transformational. Alters org core, not developing but transforming: * Downsizing, restructuring and reengineering are regarded as transformational. Ocurring recommendations for major change with hypercompetitive bussines eviroments: 1. Delayering; vertical levels 2. Networks/alliance; internal and external collaboration 3. Outsourcing; no distinctive competence 4. Dissaggregation, smaller bussines units 5. Empowerment; to provide employees with authority, resources and encouragement to take actions 6. Flexible work groups 7. Short-term staffing; short period, specific issues/tasks 8. Reduction of internal and external boundaries; to encourage communication and resource sharing Reorientation, Re-creation. Transformational Types: * Type 1, org moves from an entrepreneurial to a professional management structure; Apple Computers from an entrepreneurial company, larger professional. * Type 2, revitalization of already-established......

Words: 617 - Pages: 3

Free Essay


...Nesbitt-Johnston Writing Center Hamilton College Clinton, NY 13323 INTRODUCTIONS AND THESIS STATEMENTS Introductions The introduction is a key paragraph for both readers and writers. First impressions matter. The reader will be more inclined to read a paper and consider a position if the initial paragraph is clear, organized, and engaging. For the writer, a carefully crafted first paragraph acts as a springboard, establishing the order and direction for the entire paper. The form and content of an introduction depend upon many factors, including the specifics of the assignment, the intended audience, the style of the discipline, and the expectations of your professor. In general, your introduction should • capture the reader’s attention • reflect the question raised by the assignment • provide essential context for your topic • define key terms Most importantly, your introduction should • convey the pattern of organization you will follow in the paper • build to the thesis sentence: a clear, concise statement of the specific position you will explore in your paper Outline first Outline your argument as fully as possible before starting the first draft. Outlining first helps you to see the shape of your argument, making writing the draft much easier. Start focused Avoid broad openers; start your argument right away. Do not open with empty filler such as “Since the beginning of time” or “For thousands of years, men, both good and evil.” Open with a......

Words: 1348 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Enron Case

...Enron Case Study Seven years after the fact, the story of the meteoric rise and subsequent fall of the Enron Corporation continues to capture the imagination of the general public. What really happened with Enron? Outside of those associated with the corporate world, either through business or education, relatively few people seem to have a complete sense of the myriad people, places, and events making up the sixteen years of Enron’s existence as an American energy company. Some argue Enron’s record-breaking bankruptcy and eventual demise was the result of a lack of ethical corporate behavior attributed, more generally, to capitalism’s inability to check the unmitigated growth of corporate greed. Others believe Enron’s collapse can be traced back to questionable accounting practices such as mark-to-market accounting and the utilization of Special Purpose Entities (SPE’s) to hide financial debt. In other instances, people point toward Enron’s mismanagement of risk and overextension of capital resources, coupled with the stark philosophical differences in management that existed between company leaders, as the primary reasons why the company went bankrupt. Yet, despite these various analyses of why things went wrong, the story of Enron’s rise and fall continues to mystify the general public as well as generate continued interest in what actually happened. The broad purpose of this paper is to investigate the Enron scandal from variety perspectives. The paper begins with a......

Words: 5799 - Pages: 24