Free Essay

Racial Profiling

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By japinderbrar
Words 1798
Pages 8
Racial Profiling & Police in Canada

Secondary Research

Abskortski, Milen. "The Pluralism Project at Harvard University." Harvard University. Web. 2 Dec. 2015.
Definition:

* racial profiling refers to the discriminatory practise of law enforcement that is designed to target individuals for suspicion of crime based on his or her race, ethnicity, beliefs, religion or national origin

History of Racial Profiling & Police in Canada

Policing over the Past 40 Years * extends from systematic issues debated in court processes to prison practises and routine aspects of policing outside of legal institutions

* aallegations that the Canadian criminal justice system is racially biased, were made at various junctures by different groups over the past several decades

* Since the early 1900’s, racial profiling by the police has been highly dominant. Public complaints, legal actions, empirical research and a number of high-profile incidents had brought several police practices to the forefront of the debates on racial bias of policing in Canada

Stereotypes Associated with Racial Profiling

Stereotyping becomes a particular concern when people act on their stereotypical views in a way that affects others. This is what leads to profiling. Although anyone can experience profiling, racialized persons are primarily affected.

Typically, but not always, profiling is carried out by people in positions of authority, and can occur in many contexts involving safety, security and public protection issues. Some examples of profiling presented include: * law enforcement official assumes someone is more likely to have committed a crime because he is African Canadian * school personnel treat a Latino child’s behavior as an infraction under its zero tolerance policy while the same action by another child might be seen as normal "kids’ play" * a private security guard follows a shopper because she believes the shopper is more likely to steal from the store * an employer wants a stricter security clearance for a Muslim employee after September 11th * a bar refuses to serve Aboriginal patrons because of an assumption that they will get drunk and rowdy * a criminal justice system official refuses bail to a Latin American person because of a belief that people from her country are violent * a landlord asks a Chinese student to move out because she believes that the tenant will expose her to SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome) even though the tenant has not been to any hospitals, facilities or countries associated with a high risk of SARS. Hitchens, Maldit. "Racial Profiling." Racial Profiling. Web. 2 Dec. 2015. Facts about Racial Profiling in Canada

1. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, one in three black men can expect to go to prison in their lifetime. * Individuals of color have a high degree number of encounters with law enforcement, indicating that racial profiling continues to be a problem. A report by the Department of Justice found that blacks and Hispanics were approximately three times more likely to be searched during a traffic stop than white motorists. African Americans were twice as likely to be arrested and almost four times as likely to experience the use of force during encounters with the police

2. According to recent data by the Department of Education, African American students are arrested far more often than their white classmates. * data showed that 96,000 students were arrested and 242,000 referred to law enforcement by schools during the 2009-10 school year. Of those students, black and Hispanic students made up more than 70 percent of arrested or referred students. * Harsh school punishments, from suspensions to arrests, have led to high numbers of youth of color coming into contact with the juvenile-justice system at an early age.

3. The war on drugs has been waged primarily in communities of color where people of color are more likely to receive higher offenses. * According to the Human Rights Watch, people of color are more likely to use or sell illegal drugs than whites and they have higher rate of arrests. * African Americans comprise 14 percent of regular drug users but are 37 percent of those arrested for drug offenses. * From 1980 to 2007 about one in three of the 25.4 million adults arrested for drugs was African American.

4. Once convicted, black offenders receive longer sentences compared to white offenders. * The U.S. Sentencing Commission stated that in the federal system black offenders receive sentences that are 10 percent longer than white offenders for the same crimes. * The Sentencing Project reports that African Americans are 21 percent more likely to receive mandatory-minimum sentences than white defendants and are 20 percent more like to be sentenced to prison.

5. Studies show that police are more likely to pull over and frisk blacks or Latinos than whites. In New York City, 80% of the stops made were blacks and Latinos, and 85% of those people were frisked, compared to a mere 8% of white people stopped.

The Existence of Racial Profiling & Policing in Canada

* The Ontario government recognizes racial profiling as an issue in Canada. But through many perceptions, it is not actually that big of a deal since we live in a pluralistic and very diverse country today. * Many different religious minorities including aboriginals show that the Canadian government treats everyone equally * "We do not tolerate racism or racial profiling in the Toronto Police Service.”- Chief of Toronto police

Existence and acceptance of the authority in the past

* In 1988, the Solicitor General of Ontario appointed Clare Lewis as chair of the Race Relations and Policing Task Force. The Task Force’s 1989 report concluded that visible minorities believed they were policed differently: “They do not believe that they are policed fairly and they made a strong case for their view which cannot be ignored.” * The Task Force found that racial minorities would like to participate in law enforcement and crime prevention but are “denied integration into community life when labelled as crime prone.” * In 1992, the Ontario government also established the Commission on Systemic Racism in the Ontario Criminal Justice System. This Commission studied all facets of criminal justice and in December 1995 issued a 450 page report with recommendations

Harcourt, Bernard E. Against Prediction Profiling, Policing, and Punishing in an Actuarial Age. Chicago: U of Chicago, 2007. Print.
Alternatives Being Used to Eliminate Racial Profiling in Canada
The effects of racial profiling raise significant human rights issues to which society must respond. Canada cannot afford to allow racial profiling to be tolerated and practiced in Ontario. The cost is simply too great. It is important to take action on this particular issue. * The Human Rights Commission is proposing some measures for action to address racial profiling.

1. Police services across the province should install cameras in police cruisers to allow for monitoring the interaction between the police and public. 2. Police officers and private security guards should wear name badges that are clearly displayed. 3. Organizations or institutions that have, or are alleged to have a problem with racial profiling should provide new staff with sufficient support to ensure that they learn appropriate practices and not resort to racial profiling due to the stresses of the job. 4. In conjunction with local communities, police services should develop educational materials, particularly aimed at youth, explaining citizens’ rights.

Eddins, Maynard. "Police Racial Profiling 'corrosive': Ontario Human Rights Commission - Macleans.ca." Macleansca. 11 June 2015. Web. 2 Dec. 2015.
Ontario puts new rules on carding and banning random stops

Ontario's Liberal government is proposing new regulations that would ban the random stopping of citizens by police — known as carding — and require officers to provide a written record of any such exchanges.

* police will not be allowed to stop people based on how they look or in which neighborhood they live, but there would be "narrow exemptions" in the rules to cover routine traffic stops or when someone is being arrested or detained.

* Officers must also inform a citizen that a stop is voluntary and they have the right to walk away. They will also be required to provide a reason for the stop, documentation about it afterwards, and must inform citizens how to file a complaint or access information obtained during the stop.

* "We're saying: one, [a carding stop] cannot be random or arbitrary nor can it be based on race or the neighborhood you live in," – Canadian minister of transportation

Panwins, Karly. "The Existence of Racial Profiling." Ontario Human Rights Commission. Web. 2 Dec. 2015.
Incidents of Racial Profiling
Shooting of Albert Johnson in his home in 1979

* On August 26, 1979, Albert Johnson, a black Jamaican immigrant, was shot to death by Metropolitan Toronto Police in his home. * Two out of three police officers stood trial for the manslaughter death and were later acquitted. * Johnson was known to the police as he suffered from mental illness. Toronto’s Black community was galvanized and a protest demonstration was organized by 32 groups.

Post 9/11 Police Discrimination

* October 11, 2004 in Minneapolis where a female hijab-wearing Muslim student of Somali background was pulled over by police. The policemen searched her car and threw her belongings onto the street, including her Islamic books and the Qur'an. They then left her to pick them up by herself. * June 10th, 2004 in Colorado where a Muslim family's house was raided by the IRS and armed FBI agents who drew their guns. The family was told that an IRS investigation was being conducted and the agents proceeded to ask them questions such as "Are you Shiite or Sunni?" and questions about "Hamas, Hezbollah, and suicide bombings." They were also asked "If the US went to war with Iran, which side would you be on?"

"Home Page — Statistics Canada." Government of Canada, Statistics Canada, Racial Profiling. Web. 2 Dec. 2015.
Statistics

* Graph clearly shows how racial profiling and carding by the Canadian police is dominantly low because of the increasing level of diversity and rules put In place by the new liberal government.

* Graph clearly exhibits the likelihood of being stopped in different areas if one is black.

* Shows how police carding is decreasing in Canada because more white individuals are being stopped than black individuals which was more dominant in the past. But in the United States it still seems to be an issue.

Works Cited
Abskortski, Milen. "The Pluralism Project at Harvard University." Harvard University. Web. 2 Dec. 2015.
Eddins, Maynard. "Police Racial Profiling 'corrosive': Ontario Human Rights Commission - Macleans.ca." Macleansca. 11 June 2015. Web. 2 Dec. 2015.
Harcourt, Bernard E. Against Prediction Profiling, Policing, and Punishing in an Actuarial Age. Chicago: U of Chicago, 2007. Print.
Hitchens, Maldit. "Racial Profiling." Racial Profiling. Web. 2 Dec. 2015.
"Home Page — Statistics Canada." Government of Canada, Statistics Canada, Racial Profiling. Web. 2 Dec. 2015.
Panwins, Karly. "The Existence of Racial Profiling." Ontario Human Rights Commission. Web. 2 Dec. 2015.

MLA formatting

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Racial Profiling

...reason the officer wants to search your car. After much hassle you are finally free to go, yet still have no explanation as to why you were pulled over to begin with. Now imagine you are black and the officer is white. You have probably just experienced racial profiling. Racial profiling is a problem which is gaining widespread notoriety in the United States. It may be the most important homeland issue we face today. Racial profiling is a clear violation of the civil rights of United States citizens. Not only does racial profiling affect civilians, but it actually makes law enforcement ineffective. Most efforts to investigate and eradicate racial profiling have failed due to unclear findings and a lack of accountability on the part of law enforcement. New measures must be taken in conjunction with current measures to curb racial profiling. A stringent federal program to monitor and survey our nation’s police officers is needed. The public also needs to become more involved in efforts to stop racial profiling. Until these measures are taken, racial profiling will continue to eat away at the heart of our nation. Racial profiling is one of the most important civil rights issues facing our country today. Not only does racial profiling affect the direct victims, it negatively affects all people of color, in all generations, of all levels of economic standing. The integrity and accountability of...

Words: 3179 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Racial Profiling

...Racial Profiling Still Active Today Research Methodology in Public Safety Racial Profiling “It is said that Milwaukee Police Departments are said to be “racial profiling” due to their Police Chief implementing a “traffic stop initiative” only in African American Communities. The Police Chief tried to say it that it wasn’t “racial profiling” but rather “targeting the high crime areas of Milwaukee (White, 2010).” Racial profiling occurs when police routinely use races as a factor that causes an officer to react with suspicion to take action. Though the Police Chief feels he is doing the right thing by supposedly protecting “black victims,” the community feels that the police department is “racially profiling.” Racial profiling in my opinions an ineffective strategy. It says that you don’t want to learn about your community person’s behavior and you’re just ready to judge the person by the color of the skin. It cannot be disputed that the perception of racial profiling by police department still exist within minority communities and societies at large. This is a recurrent topic of debate and divisive issue in many communities. This was clearly seen and addressed when I saw the problem first hand when I worked in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Questions: Some questions to be asked are: 1. Should police do more to control excessive force? 2. ......

Words: 309 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Racial Profiling

...RACIAL PROFILING Racial profiling refers to the way by which law enforcers discriminately apprehend civilians based on race, nationality, ethic group or religion in suspicion of a crime. This contentious act has been in practice since time in memorial. The terrorist attack on 1sept2001 popularized racial profiling. Since the attack was carried out by Arabic descents, most of them were subjected to thorough frisking at public location .Racial profiling has been condemned by experts owing to minorities being subjected to harsh treatment for no apparent reason. They claim that those regarded as ‘criminals‘ are less likely to engage in illegal activities as opposed to those who are not closely monitored because of unsuspecting law enforcers. This argument is, however watered down by several evidences stating that many illegal practices are done by gangs considering they are minorities. According to Michael Boylan there are various and distinctive ways it can be appropriate. He states that racial profiling can be carried out in a decent manner especially during an investigation.(Boylan ,2010).However ,its prohibited if there is no crime committed. He used the “token analysis” to indicate that it targets an individual to be specific but not a group of people(Boylan,2010) J. Angelo corlet also argues that racial profiling is not unethical on its own. He further stated that the term is discordant and ‘color profiling” should be acquired instead citing that race is obscure and...

Words: 459 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Racial Profiling

...Racial profiling has been around for many years, with laws such as the "Black Codes", which were created during the reconstruction in the South. These laws imposed severe restrictions on freed slaves such as prohibiting their right to vote, forbidding them to sit on juries, limiting their right to testify against white men, carrying weapons in public places and working in certain occupations; and the “Jim Crow” laws, which were laws that discriminated against African Americans with concern to attendance in public schools and the use of facilities such as restaurants, theaters, hotels, cinemas and public baths. Trains and buses were also segregated and in many states marriage between whites and African American people. According to Heather Mac Donald, the term "Racial profiling" has two meanings, hard and soft profiling. “Hard” profiling uses race as the only factor in assessing criminal suspiciousness: an officer sees a black person and, without more to go on, pulls him over for a pat-down on the chance that he may be carrying drugs or weapons. "Soft" racial profiling is using race as one factor among others in gauging criminal suspiciousness: the highway police, for example, have intelligence that Jamaican drug posses with a fondness for Nissan Pathfinders are transporting marijuana along the northeast corridor. A New Jersey trooper sees a black motorist speeding in a Pathfinder and pulls him over in the hope of finding drugs (Mac Donald). Racial Profiling really......

Words: 1806 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Racial Profiling

...There are many pros and cons to Racial Profiling, and the law enforcement uses them in so many ways. Racial profiling is when people such as the Law Enforcement approach many people of the same races being accused of the same things that are most common in that race. Racial profiling has been around for a long time and it is very common. The law enforcement uses a lot racial profiling towards all the races. Policemen and Policewoman can easily pull over people because of their race. Mexicans are usually pulled over because they can be accused of being an illegal immigrant, or even drug dealing/using marijuana. African Americans are most commonly pulled over because they can be accused of drug dealing, being a thief or even being accused of doing cocaine. Caucasian people are usually pulled over to being accused of meth, unlawful possessions of weapons, or controlled substances. I think that in order to get the criminals off the streets it is okay to use racial profiling if they are using it in the right way. I think that if I were to see a truck or car with big rims and someone that gets out of the car is all tattooed up and is taking a smoke, I honestly would accuse them of being in the wrong and would be okay if a cop were to come and search them to see what they are getting themselves into. If a person is being suspicious then the law enforcement should be able to have a search warrant on them. Not only is it a good idea for them to stop the criminals from doing crime,......

Words: 781 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Racial Profiling

...1. What is your chosen topic, and how did you come across it? * The topic I choose is racial profiling. And the way I came across this is topic is because I see on the news all the time. Why is it interesting you? * The reason why it interest me is because I’m shocked that people in the 21st century can still have so much hatred towards a certain race. What do you personally hope to gain or accomplish by writing about this topic? * What I hope to gain from writing about this topic is I want get a better understanding of what triggers them to do these things. 2. Provide a brief summary of the topic. Explain the current issues surrounding the topic and share at least two different positions on the topic. Racial profiling is when an officer of the law abuses his authority targeting a certain race, ethnicity, or religion. One current issue surrounding this topic is the case about Freddie Gray. He was a Baltimore resident that got arrested. While he was being transported to the transport van he sustained injuries. He fell into a coma and died. The 6 officers could never account on how he sustained those injuries and the information they released would never add up. So protesters began attacking police officers, rioting, and destroying properties. They were doing this because they believed that Freddie Gray was targeting by these officers and they were abusing their power by the way he was treated. 3. What specific issue will you write about within the......

Words: 392 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Racial Profiling

...The Unathletic Dept. Taken from JHU A blue seventh place athletic ribbon hangs from my mantel. Every day, as I walk into my living room, the award mockingly congratulates me as I smile. Ironically, the blue seventh place ribbon resembles the first place ribbon in color; so, if I just cover up the tip of the seven, I may convince myself that I championed the fourth heat. But, I never dare to wipe away the memory of my seventh place swim; I need that daily reminder of my imperfection. I need that seventh place. Two years ago, I joined the no-cut swim team. That winter, my coach unexpectedly assigned me to swim the 500 freestyle. After stressing for hours about swimming 20 laps in a competition, I mounted the blocks, took my mark, and swam. Around lap 14, I looked around at the other lanes and did not see anyone. “I must be winning!” I thought to myself. However, as I finally completed my race and lifted my arms up in victory to the eager applause of the fans, I looked up at the score board. I had finished my race in last place. In fact, I left the pool two minutes after the second-to-last competitor, who now stood with her friends, wearing all her clothes. The blue for the first loser went to me. However, as I walked back to my team, carrying the seventh place blue, listening to the splash of the new event’s swimmers, I could not help but smile. I could smile because despite my loss, life continued; the next event began. I realized that I could accept this failure,......

Words: 527 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Essay On Racial Profiling

...Racial profiling is a problem that has been going on in the United States for far too long. Everyday, people are being pulled over and searched just because of their race or because of their ethnic background. Police profiling is defined as being law enforcement officers targeting people based on a specific trait of theirs such as their race, religion, sexual orientation, national origin, or gender. One branch of police profiling that has been in the news a lot lately although it has been a problem for many years is racial profiling. Many people automatically think of black people when they hear the words racial profiling, when in fact, it is a problem amongst other races as well such as Mexican, Asian, and Middle Eastern. Racial profiling has led to many lawsuits and deaths recently and is a growing problem in the United States, as it has led to riots and protests. One case of racial profiling is the Michael Brown case. Michael was a 17 year old teenager from Ferguson, MIssouri who was gunned down by a white police...

Words: 976 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Racial Profiling and Its Consequences

...Racial Profiling and it's Consequences Racial profiling is unethical, because it violates human rights by degrading individuals; in addition, it is not cost effective and would be counterproductive. Racial profiling involves selecting people for a given purpose on the basis of their membership of a particular racial group (Thomsen p. 2). The main reason why law enforcement uses racial profiling is, because it can increase their chances of catching criminals. In other words, it narrows down suspects and find people that commit crimes. However, racial profiling can be wrong for a number of reasons. First of all it is wrong, when law enforcement uses it with a racist, derogatory, and humiliating attitude when stopping individuals for a traffic infraction. Second of all it is against the 14th Amendment. Racial profiling also prevents the latino community to work with law enforcement, because it creates fear; finally, it prevents law enforcement to properly serve the community. Why not reduce profiling or get rid of it for ever? We are after all one nation that has been able to embrace different people from different ethnicity and backgrounds in to America. Racial profiling is unethical, humiliating, and it violates human rights. “Racial profiling appears morally wrong and more troubling when the racial group that is being profiled suffers from background injustice” (Paul Bou-Habib p. 33). One main point I would like to make is that racial profiling is wrong when law......

Words: 301 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Everything Isn't Racial Profiling

...Everything Isn’t Racial Profiling By Linda Chavez Critical analysis Racial Profiling is a Good Bias "I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: 'We hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal.'… I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character."(King, 1963, P.49) These were the words of the infamous Martin Luther King, a man whose goal in life was to strain to give this world racial equality and stop racial profiling and injustice. Linda Chavez, the author of the article ‘Everything Isn’t Racial Profiling’ argues that racial profiling is an ugly business and that it is just wrong and unjust, as she herself was subjected to it. Linda’s argument is that racial profiling is undeniably wrong, but the fact that security puts people under scrutiny is correct. I think the author’ argument is quite legitimate and convincing. Racial profiling is biased, but in some cases it is permissible, especially when it comes to airline safety. ‘Everything Isn’t Racial Profiling’ is an article that talks about how racial profiling is generally immoral, but in some certain times putting certain people under scrutiny is logical. Chavez clarifies that it is unpleasant to be a victim of racial profiling especially if you know it happens because of your nationality or the color of your skin...

Words: 1903 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Arguments Against Racial Profiling

...Racial Profiling Racial profiling is a very controversial topic in today’s society. Racial profiling is the act of accusing, or targeting, a person based on their race. People can be targeted because of stereotypes about the race. Racial profiling is a common technique used by law enforcement to target potential criminals and suspects. Many people disagree with this technique because it cannot be defended. Other people agree with law enforcement using racial profiling because they believe that safety comes before liberty. No matter what people say, racial profiling is a problem in our society and in our government. Firstly, racial profiling is a problem is because it is ruining the relationship between the people and the law enforcement. Racial profiling is separating the community and the police force. The community is less likely to trust the police if they are being targeted because of their ethnicity. The affected communities would also be less active and would become less social due to the lack of feeling safe. Secondly, racial profiling is a problem is because of its effects on schools. Students of color can face harsher punishments than white students, which can cause higher numbers of incarcerated colored students. Many minority students fear the...

Words: 717 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Criminal vs. Racial Profiling

...Racial profiling is not the same thing as criminal profiling. Racial profiling is any police-initiated action that relies on the race, ethnicity, or national orgin rather than the behavior of an individual or information that leads the police to a particular individual who has been identified as being. or having been, engaged in criminal activity. Criminal profiling is any police- initiated action that used the compilation of the background, physical, behavioral, and motivational characteristics for a type of perpretrator that lead the police. Racial profiling does not only violate constitutional rights, but is also ineffective if used in policing. The major reason to oppose racial profiling (aside from constitutional and moral grounds) is that it simply doesn’t work. Empirical studies show that when police use race or ethnic appearance as a factor in law enforcement, their effectiveness in apprehending criminals decreases. Even worse, it has often led to “accidental” deaths, such as the fatal shootings of African American and Latino men. On the other hand, criminal profiling is effective when applied to policing. Profiling units examine criminal behaviour to discover the characteristics of the offender and the causes of their crimes. Profilers look at three areas of the criminal’s behaviour: verbal, physical, and sexual interaction with victims. To create a criminal profile, profilers consider statistics, basic psychological principles, crime scene behaviour,......

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

An Argument Against Racial Profiling

...despite the fact that they were intruders in his own home. Instances similar to this are a prime example of how groups of people aren’t being represented and how they need to be protected. Racial profiling is happening everywhere today whether it be “random selection” at an airport, someone following you around a store, or even getting pulled over by a cop for no good reason. Reasoning behind this, is because if there was a scare about a group of people of certain race doing something...

Words: 1411 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Racial Profiling and Male African Americans

...Racial Profiling and Male African Americans Racial Profiling and Male African Americans INTRODUCTION Imagine driving to the store on a cold winter day, dressed in a hoodie to keep warm. You simply pull into the parking lot in hopes of getting something nice for your daughter for the holidays. Driving the posted speed limit, you pull slowly into a parking space in the back of the store. All of a sudden, a car pulls up behind you, blocking you in. You look in your rearview mirror only to find the community crime watch officer staring you down. The officer immediately treats you like a suspect, smothering you with questions concerning what you’re doing, where you’re going; yet never really had any reasoning behind the questions. After an aggravating experience, they send you on your way. Now imagine you are black and the officer is white. You have probably just experienced racial profiling. WHAT IS RACIAL PROFILING? One of the most important civil rights facing our nation today is racial profiling. The main source of those accused of racial profiling are police officers. In the eyes of citizens, racial profiling by a police officer can be defined as “any police-initiated action that relies on the race, ethnicity or national origin rather than behavior of an individual or information that leads the police to a particular individual who has been identified as being, or having been, engaged in criminal activity” (Ramirez, 2000). For instance, concerning traffic......

Words: 1940 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Discussion Of The Arguments Against Racial Profiling

...Research on racial profiling suggests that minorities are disproportionately the subject of routine for traffic stops (Feder, 2012 pg. 1). Some will argue that racial profiling is a rational method of investigating and potentially stopping crime before it is committed. Others argue that it is not a legitimate security measure. Racial profiling has been reviewed on several accounts as to whether or not such profiling constitutes as a violation of the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment. The Fourth Amendment protects individuals against unreasonable searches and seizures. In the case of Terry v. Ohio the Supreme Court ruled that reasonable suspicion is sufficient enough for a police officer to briefly stop and question an individual for weapons....

Words: 256 - Pages: 2