Recruiting Violations in College Athletics

In: Social Issues

Submitted By mpm5386
Words 5280
Pages 22
Michael P. Murphy
How Recruiting Violations and Academic Misconduct have effectively marred the Amateurism of College Athletics and a Proposal for a Local Solution
IDST J497
Professor Timothy C. Williams
November 30, 2012
Fall 2012

Recruiting Violations and Academic Misconduct in College Athletics
Michael P. Murphy
IDST J497
Williams

The issues of recruiting violations, academic misconduct, administrative negligence, illegal booster involvement, and a general lack of University oversight are all problems that continue to mar the once highly regarded reputations of academic institutions across America. These transgressions, which occur at shockingly consistent rates around campuses nationwide, (committed by faculty, coaches, players, administrators, and alumni), are effectively compromising the sacred amateurism college athletics has maintained to define its culture and provide credence for its illustrious traditions for over a century. Ethical questions of this magnitude have been pondered by academics and legal stalwarts alike with great depth both at the local and global level for years. Several studies reflect that a substantial percentage of the “major” NCAA recruiting violations and cases of egregious academic misconduct occur typically at institutions where local administrators and financiers have created a “win at all costs” culture pertaining to BCS (Bowl Championship Series) football and the NCAA Men’s Basketball tournament. A handful of local schools sanctioned by the NCAA in the last few decades for recruiting violations and academic misconduct include the University of South Carolina, Alabama, Auburn, Georgia Tech, LSU, Tennessee, Kentucky, and Arkansas. Each year the NCAA collects its constituents: college presidents, athletic directors, and compliance directors (among others), to discuss the current “integrity climate” of college…...

Similar Documents

Athletic Director

...Overview An athletic director (commonly "athletics director" or "AD") is an administrator at many american colleges and universities, as well as in larger high schools and middle schools, who oversees the work of coaches and related staff involved in intercollegiate or interscholastic athletic programs (ehow.com). They are in charge of an athletic department at a high school, college or university and at some colleges, the athletic director may hold academic rank. They are usually considered to be full-time administrators instead of, full time faculty members. Although technically in charge of all of the coaches, they are often far beyond well-compensated and also less famous, with few having their own television and radio programs as many coaches now do. In this paper I plan to describe the duties of an athletic coach, career paths, educational requirements and benefits of becoming an athletic Director. Athletic Director Job Description The Athletic director oversees funding and budgets for school athletic programs and are responsible for ensuring that the various teams at a school receive a fair distribution of resources. They may have to make tough decisions about how to allocate money. They work with coaches to ensure school and division regulations are being followed but don't usually handle the direct coaching and training of athletes. However, they usually oversee the hiring and firing of trainers and coaches. In addition to managing...

Words: 1173 - Pages: 5

Multinational Recruiting

...Multinational Recruitment Individuals need to prove their out-of-the-box working techniques in a multinational company. A multinational company operates in two or more countries. It manages production or delivers services internationally. The country that has the headquarters is called the home, while other countries are referred to as the host countries. The rapid expansion of organizations beyond borders has led to the need to pull, recruit, train and then retain employees who can adapt to relocating and can be equally productive in multiple countries Hiring Unit The boom of multinational companies around the globe has brought more employment among an already competitive market. Selection and recruiting is the job of human resources, known as the HR department of the entity. In "Managing Across Cultures: Concepts, Policies and Practices," Mohamed Branine says that the selection and hiring of workers in an organized structure is conducted by the human resources personnel who plan job specifications after completing a job analysis. The employers have to ensure they are employing the right person for the right job. They often pay top bucks for big positions, so they expect the best output from their employees. Requirements The primary recruitment step is describing the job description of that position. HR personnel or department managers devise a list of prerequisites for a person who would be best-suited for a multinational company. At this step, company...

Words: 502 - Pages: 3

Recruiting Violations in College Athletics

...Michael P. Murphy How Recruiting Violations and Academic Misconduct have effectively marred the Amateurism of College Athletics and a Proposal for a Local Solution IDST J497 Professor Timothy C. Williams November 30, 2012 Fall 2012 Recruiting Violations and Academic Misconduct in College Athletics Michael P. Murphy IDST J497 Williams The issues of recruiting violations, academic misconduct, administrative negligence, illegal booster involvement, and a general lack of University oversight are all problems that continue to mar the once highly regarded reputations of academic institutions across America. These transgressions, which occur at shockingly consistent rates around campuses nationwide, (committed by faculty, coaches, players, administrators, and alumni), are effectively compromising the sacred amateurism college athletics has maintained to define its culture and provide credence for its illustrious traditions for over a century. Ethical questions of this magnitude have been pondered by academics and legal stalwarts alike with great depth both at the local and global level for years. Several studies reflect that a substantial percentage of the “major” NCAA recruiting violations and cases of egregious academic misconduct occur typically at institutions where local administrators and financiers have created a “win at all costs” culture pertaining to BCS (Bowl Championship Series) football and the NCAA Men’s Basketball tournament. A handful of local...

Words: 5280 - Pages: 22

Athletic Director

...Alexis Mr. Daily Literature April 23, 2012 Chapter 1 Analysis In the book “The Great Gatsby”, by Francis Scott Fitzgerald, the narrator Nick Carraway tells about his life. At first he tells about some advice that his Dad gave him. His dad told him to never judge anyone or hold anyone to his own standards. If he did, then everyone would fail in his image, because everyone has different morals and standards. Nick also went on to say that throughout his life, others looked to him for advice. Through college he was always the go to person for questions to be answered, but he would always pretend to be too busy to talk. Nick moved from Minnesota to New York to work in the bond business. He looked for a new house and found one to rent on a part of Long Island in a place called West Egg. Compared to another place called East Egg, it was a place for the newly rich. East Egg was more conservative, while West Egg was a place that individuals blew their money in extravagant ways. One night, Nick drives back to East Egg to have dinner with his cousin Daisy and her husband Tom. They also have a friend named Jordan over for dinner. That night, Jordan tells Nick that Tom is having an affair. Throughout chapter one, I find that Nick is trying to analyze a story. But he is involved in a large part in the story. I feel that he is trying to point out others flaws even though his father told him not to. There are so many things that tempt Nick into falling into society’s trap, but so......

Words: 297 - Pages: 2

Illegal Recruiting

...Abstract College football has become a major money making event. Major college schools can bring in well over one hundred million dollars over a season. In 2008 Texas brought in $120,288,370 for the school that also help fund other sports throughout the university. (Robbins, 2009) This is due to the major network deals, sponsorships, donations from boosters, attending major college bowls, and many other benefits of being a major college program. These programs are expected to compete for a championship each and every year and are expected to fill the seats that normally average between eighty thousand to one hundred thousand seats. In order to do this there is high competition to get the very best players all around the country and the NCAA has very strict guidelines on what colleges can do to persuade the players to come play there. This isn’t a new problem but with modern technology the problem has become very visible because NCAA officials and competing schools are able to trace the exact moves that teams are doing for the players. Also players are being offered money and benefits that seventeen and eighteen year old kids have never seen before in their life. Penalties are becoming harsher every year and coaches and schools are starting to really suffer but what there is a fine line to walk between cheating and just putting your best effort towards getting the player. Process of Investigating Illegal Recruiting The NCAA has broken the process of...

Words: 1662 - Pages: 7

Mercury Athletic

...Active Gear, Inc. Active Gear, Inc. is an athletic shoe company, which, at the time of the case focuses on casual and recreational footwear aimed at a core demographic of suburban family members aged 25-45. The shoes are generally considered to be fashionable and functional. The casual line of shoes is sold in general retail stores, department, and specialty stores via wholesalers and independent distributors. The athletic line is made through independent sales representatives to a small number of sporting goods stores, pro shops, and specialty athletic stores. AGI has in part maintained their perceived high quality brand image by abstaining from selling through discount retailers. Although they feel this decision has preserved operating margins, they believe it has hurt sales growth. By focusing on a smaller portfolio, Active gear has been able to maintain relatively simple and efficient production an supply chains. This has led to a competitive advantage by way of avoiding poor industry cycles, write-downs, and missed profit opportunities. AGI’s days in inventory is 42.5, much lower than the industry average of 50.9. Despite the fact that AGI is among the most profitable firms in the industry, AGI has started to believe their smaller than industry average size is resulting in a competitive disadvantage. Mercury Athletic Mercury is a smaller shoe company with a highly niche market. The demographic for the company is 15 to 25 year olds with an interest in extreme...

Words: 436 - Pages: 2

E Recruiting

...Over seventy five percent of Career Centers across the country use E-Recruiting. It has become a new way to work around the traditional ways of addressing job openings. Most company’s today main goal is to figure out how to make the most money, while spending the least amount of money. And e- recruiting falls right in line with helping them achieve this goal. But what some HR personnel are starting to worry “Is this form of e-recruiting working too well?” Today e- recruiting has become one of the fastest and easiest ways for potential job workers to apply for their jobs. A few key stokes is all it may cost to apply for a job. The country likes the new idea of not having to take time to spend and create paperwork just to get an interview. But with easier applying processes comes more applicants, and this cannot always be a good thing. As stated in the textbook, “Lockheed Martin received 300,000 resumes from which it filled 900 positions.” And although some view this as a good problem, it is still a problem that is causing burdens. Because as the applicant pool grows so is the number of recipients that will potentially be rejected. “Now organizations are compelled to ask themselves how this mass of failed applicants influence their reputation.” Companies need to stay a step in front of the game and be prepared for any obstacles that may come their way with e- recruiting. They need to be cautious with the number of candidates that apply online for a position...

Words: 848 - Pages: 4

Mercury Athletic

...Mercury Athletic Footwear: Valuing the Opportunity Team 10 / Mergers and Acquisitions West Coast Fashions, Inc (WCF) was a large business, which dealt with men’s and women’s apparel. One of their segments was Mercury Athletic Footwear. WCF wanted to dispose off this segment. They just wanted to divest because they wanted to focus more on their core business and move it up to the elite class. John Liedtke was the Business Development Head at that time in Active Gear Inc. He had a clear idea that acquiring Mercury will shoot up AGI’s revenues for sure. It would also ensure an expansion of the key business. In order to get a clearer picture on the acquisition, he needed to compare and analyze the company’s financials well. By this he could gauge the pros and cons of this acquisition. Are the strategic reasons behind the Merger good enough? Explain As a team, we had different views on this question. Some reasons make us think that it may be beneficial for AGI to grab the opportunity but some make us think that it might not be as promising as it seems. Let us see why we feel it is a good idea for AGI to acquire Mercury. | |Active Gear Inc. |Mercury Athletic Footwear | |Revenue |$470,285mn |$431,121mn | |% Revenue Product wise |42% Athletic 58% Casual...

Words: 2227 - Pages: 9

Athletic Footwear Industry Analysis

...Athletic Footwear Industry Analysis The global athletic footwear market has shown steady growth in recent years with only minimal slowing down during the global economic crisis. China, as a leader, contributing over 63% of the world’s production, followed by Vietnam, Italy, Indonesia, Belgium and Brazil. It grew by 2.6% in 2009 to reach a value of $196.3 billion. In 2014, the global footwear market is forecast to have a value of $230.8 billion, an increase of 17.6% since 2009 (starta.co.uk). The U.S. continues to be the leading consumer in this market, even though it was projected that in the coming years it will be preceded by Europe and Asia. The athletic footwear market will be analyzed using Porter’s Five Forces where footwear retailers are players, buyers are individual consumers, and footwear manufacturers are the key suppliers. The market is dominated by large retail groups such as Foot Locker, Inc. Nike, Inc, Adidas AG, Finish Line, Inc. that hold a strong position in the market bargaining power over suppliers. Rivalry is the strongest between these large groups. The footwear is a basic necessity, so sales volumes are high what reduce buyer power. Much of the footwear has been produced in low-cost manufacturing locations, such as South-East Asia. Many domestic manufacturers in Western countries are unable to compete effectively with South East Asia manufacturers, as a result, many Western suppliers have gained power within the market by offering highly...

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Athletic Training

... requirements, equipment, and the safety procedures, in order to understand Athletic Training. The life and times of an Athletic Trainer have changed over the past twenty years. Traditionally, an athletic trainer worked either in a high school or college setting with an occasional placement in a physical therapy practice. Or if you were lucky enough, you could work with a professional sports team. Today, athletic trainers can be found working in a wide variety of “non-traditional” settings. Not only do athletic trainers work in hospitals, corporations, industrial settings, but have delved out into the world of NASCAR racing, NASA, rodeo, police and fire safety to name a few. Potential for employment as an athletic trainer is left only to the imagination and creative problem solving of current vocational trends and shortages....

Words: 856 - Pages: 4

Recruiting & Staffing

... resources. The recommended recruitment tactic for HSS, while debatable, is electronic recruiting. It’s efficient and highly cost effective. An abundance of applicants can get beckoned with a few simple steps using a computerized device. In reference to the selection methodology, it seems logical to remain traditional and support the benefits of structured interviews. Utilizing the most appropriate questions and the interpersonal experience that takes place is instrumental to selecting a dynamic candidate. Hopefully, the forthcoming information is enlightening and satisfies pending questions on the recruitment and selection process. Recruitment Approaches The first recruitment approach to consider is in-house recruitment. It is an element that is extremely important to the functioning of an organization’s morale. “When you promote from within or fill new positions with internal candidates, there is a positive effect on staff morale” (Root, 2015, para. 2). Happy employees segue to committed and productive personnel. The cost associated with internal recruiting is lower than the expense incurred from external recruiting. Advertising fees are minuscule as they are confined to posting on the company’s Intranet or affixing vacancy publications to bulletin boards. Also, in-house candidates have previously completed the steps that accompany a new recruit or hire. As a result, time can be allocated to other corporate responsibilities. Another recruitment approach......

Words: 2569 - Pages: 11

Athletic Director

...Internship 390 1 Sept 2015 Expectations/Outline Upon graduation, I plan on taking the necessary steps to become a High School athletic director. In preparation, I have obtained an internship with Brian Thomas at Northern Guildford High School. During my internship I am going to shadow Brian to see exactly what being an athletic director entails. Also, I am going to ask him questions about his journey in becoming an athletic director.  My goal during my internship is to first, see what Brian does day by day, as I believe there is not a typical day for an athletic director. From what I understand, athletic directors do something different every day, whether it's budgeting, fundraising, planning home games and away games or prepping fields. Next, I plan to see where Brian started his career. I understand it's difficult to become an athletic director right out of college. It will be beneficial to see where he started and what kind of experience he obtained. Through my research, I have found, some athletic directors need a master’s degree. In addition, I am anxious to see how he budgets the allowances for things like team uniforms without favoring one team over another. Lastly, I hope to get enough insight and experience of what being an athletic director fully entails, to my decision of pursuing a career in this field.  I am very excited to start my internship and I am ready to adapt to the change of working and no just going to school. I am going to take in, and learn as......

Words: 336 - Pages: 2

Athletic Traine

...Athletes participating in every sport at the collegiate and professional levels have come to rely on an athletic trainer for all of their injuries and ailments. Athletic trainers' specialized scope of practice includes injury prevention, emergency care, clinical diagnosis, therapeutic intervention and rehabilitation of injuries and medical conditions. So if I was the head of an athletic training staff I would first trying to find ways to overseeing the general care of my student-athletes. The athletic trainer is the healthcare professional who takes care of student-athletes even after the school nurse and other staff have left for the day. This is when the athletic trainer begins the daily routine of injury rehabilitation, injury evaluations, protective taping, practice preparation, monitoring environmental conditions such as heat and humidity, consulting with physicians, checking the status of weather conditions, conducting concussion follow-up and honoring return-to-play protocols. Coordinating care with teachers and other administrative staff, and student workers to make sure that everyone is on the same page to what is expected and time schedule for treatment and thing of that nature. I would try to detect care for a wide range of injuries that occurs more often. Injuries vary from sprains and strains to more severe, unusual injuries or conditions that require specialized training, recognition, management and treatment. Along the way I would be developing relationships...

Words: 386 - Pages: 2

Do College Athletic Programs Benefit Their Education?

...Athletics Program I think college athletics programs do benefit their educational institutions. You can get scholarships; it helps you boost your confidence. Scholarships are a big deal to some students! Many students cannot go to college without an athletics scholarship. Over 125,000 student athletes are on full or partial athletic scholarships. Being in athletics gives you an opportunity to be awarded significant amount of money. An average athlete salary is around 400,000-1,800,000. Some schools have lots and lots of money because of their athletic program. One way that an athlete can keep their GPA range up is by being in athletics. They can get their dorm and books earlier other than other students, so you will not have to be in a rush whenever school starts. Athletics helps the athletes boost self of steam and increase their confidence in themselves. Sports gain a valuable lesson in life. Athletes set goals and they try to reach them no matter how hard it is. Their coaches motivate the athletes to do their best on the field or on the court. They are dedicated to their sport and never give up. They learn about teamwork and they win as a team and lose as a team. An athlete’s confidence before athletics is low and after a few years in athletics, their confidence has increased a lot. Some people say that it is not fair that the athletes do not have to do a lot of homework. Well they do not know what they have to do, they have to......

Words: 273 - Pages: 2

Mercury Athletic Case

...Mercury Athletic Footwear: Valuing Opportunity Case Summary: John Liedtke, head of business development for Active Gear Inc. (AGI), is evaluating the acquisition of Mercury Athletic (Luehrman & Hielprin, 2009). Both companies compete in the footwear industry which is a highly competitive industry characterized by low growth and stable profit margins (Luehrman & Hielprin, p. 1). Liedtke’s initial assumptions was that the acquisition of Mercury Athletic would double AGI’s revenue, increase its leverage with manufacturers and expand its distribution. In order to evaluate these assumptions and determine if the acquisition would be a good decision, Liedtke generated pro forma income from Mercury’s four main segments and key balance sheet account for the years spanning 2007 through 2011. In preparing these, he made the following assumptions: • Mercury’s women’s casual footwear would be merged with AGIs within the first year. • Overhead to revenue ratio would conform to historical averages • Capital structure would follow AGI post acquisition • Discount rate was calculated using AGI’s leverage and tax rate Additionally, he was counting on synergies between the two companies with respect to inventory management and the women’s casual footwear line. Using this information, he calculated projected EBIT margin of 9% and revenue growth of 3%. Case Questions: a. Is Mercury an appropriate target for AGI? Why or why not? According to Liedtke, Mercury...

Words: 1497 - Pages: 6