Free Essay

Rem Sleep and Order

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By smchung
Words 1264
Pages 6
Human beings spend significant amount of their time into sleeping. During their sleep, human beings often experience the ‘magical’ state, the dream. In the dream, people maybe part of a Wonderful Wizard of Oz, horror stories or even reality shows. This chimerical state has caused dream researchers to question the cause of dream or even the contents of dream. Despite the fact that the state of dreaming has gathered researchers’ attention for long time, researchers have only begun to conduct thorough investigation on dreaming. However, as Robert E. Haskell (1986) states, “…The study of dreams and dreaming is an area of research that seems either to stimulate almost boundless, yet imaginative, theories regarding the meaning and function of dreaming; or conversely, it stimulates an equally boundless and irrational skepticism, denying any meaning or function to dreaming whatsoever…” (p.1). As stated, the field of dream research is very elusive. Pioneers in dream research, such Jung and Freud, developed various notions and models to explain the cause and content of dream, however, these theories and models are controversial and cannot be solidified. One of the most important factors that make dream research perplexing is the method of obtaining data. For example, as discussed later, participant drop out rate, small sample size and accuracy of data report hinder researchers from developing accurate notions on dreaming. In order to establish a solid explanation for dream, it is imperative that the methodology used for obtaining the data be improved. One of the many problems in obtaining dream reports is the drop out rate of participants. For instance, a study was conducted by Winegar and Levin (1997) in order to study the adolescence maturity. The study initially began with 182 volunteers of ages between 15 to 18. Of these students, 115 had turned in at least two dreams of 35 words or more. From this experiment, Winegar and Levin concluded that girls showed more maturity in relationships than boys and the difference was greater in the later years (Domhoff, P.50). The problem with this experiment is the drop out rate. Also, the length of dream description by participants imposes a problem of small sample size, but problem on sample sizes will be discussed later. According Cote et al. (1996) and Lortie-Lussier, Schwab & de Koninck (1985) describes that it takes atleast several weeks to obtain a minimum of two dreams from a participant (Domhoff, P.50). Hence, large drop out rate becomes likely because of the length that it takes for a participant to clearly identify their dream. This may cause frustration to the participants; as a result, their participation may become oblivious to them. Although a clear solution is hard to obtain for this methodology, a study by Tonay (1990) provides a possible solution. Tonay’s study conducted among students in University of California, Berkely, indicates that most of students who had chosen not to volunteer for a dream diary for 2 week, 43% of them said that they would continue the dream diary if it were part of a course assignment (Domhoff, P.51). Instead of having dream diary as a volunteering, it should be assigned as a task that may affect the participants, such as the grade, or even provide substantial amount of reward to the participants. In order to develop conclusions for studies that suffer from drop out rate, researchers should develop a conclusion after removing participants who dropped out of the experiment. However, most of the times, the result of the experiment may then suffer from small sample size.
The issue of drop out rate consequently leads to another problem that dream reports suffer from, the small sample size. Beck (1967)’s study in the effect of divorce, such as depression, on dreaming indicates the problem of small sample sizes. Initially, the experiment started with 300 participants, half women and half men, who were either divorced or formerly divorced. Of the 300 participants, only 87 gave the report. Furthermore, to make the matters worse, the number of participants who were depressed dropped significantly. Originally, 47% of the men and 51% of the women were classed as depressed; however, during the follow up, only 7.5% of the men and 6.3% of the women remained depressed. Conclusion has yet been developed for this experiment for it is still in progress (Bootzin, P.184). As seen from this experiment, the result of this experiment had suffered heavily from the small sample size. Again, this has contributed by the length of the experiment. Not only did the length of time discourage people from remaining in the study, but the time was also long enough to convert the mood of people, and the mood was an essential factor of the experiment. Although the solution to preserving the mood of participants of experiment may not be evident, in order to encourage the participants to remain in the study, as stated before, experimenter should reward substantially to the participants. This would allow the sample size to remain similar to that of initial. In order to develop conclusions for studies that suffer small sample size, researchers should build conclusion and re-attempt the identical experiment with new set of participants and develop conclusion based on that group. In the end, they should develop the final conclusion after examining conclusions of the same experiment. Among the small sample size and drop out rate, another important issue is the accuracy of report. Bernstein & Belicki’s (1995) study demonstrates the distortion of data by self reporting. In order to examine the rank-order correlation between expressed opinion and content analysis of social interactions, four different samples of college students were asked about the frequency of the dream content, Friendly, Aggressive and Sexual interactions. The result of survey was as following: 1.Friendly interaction, 2.Sexual interaction, 3.Aggressive interaction. However, through other analysis, such as the Sleep Laboratory, the accurate survey result was as following: 1.Aggressive interaction, 2.Friendly interaction, 3.Sexual interaction. Hence the correlation turned out to be negative (Domhoff, P.41). It is always a challenge for dream researchers to confirm the validity of dream reports. Dream cannot be directly observed by third person observation unless the participant reports it. However, the solution to this problem has been the Sleep Laboratory until the government decided to reduce the funding for dream research. In the laboratory, observers may record the sleep talk, which accurately describes the dream of participant’s. In addition, researchers may interrupt participant’s sleep during REM (Rapid Eye Movement) cycle, when the dreams are seen and remembered most vividly. Unfortunately, due to the high cost expense and reduction of government funding, this solution has become impractical and the alternatives are under investigation by dream researchers (Domhoff P.47). For now, the results from the laboratory should be used to further explore the dream states for those results are more accurate. The field of dream research is still at rudimentary level. It is once said by Haskell (1986), “…dream data have not historically been incorporated into cognitive psychology because the canons of scientific research excluded the adequate control and manipulation of such data…”(P.3). It is dream researchers’ objective to build the model that can wholly illustrate dreams. In order to do so, like all the other scientific procedures require, an approved method, in which flaws are minimally presented, must be present. The dream researchers’ main goal for near future may have to be to establish procedures that would minimize most of the flaws, such as drop out rate, small sampling size and accuracy of data.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Parkinsons

...Disease and REM Sleep Behavior Disorder Sukhwinder Randhawa Introduction: “Parkinson’s is a neurodegenerative disease” (7). When the cells that produce dopamine die then Parkinson’s disease arises. Dopamine is a “chemical that carries signals between the nerves in the brain” (7) to control movement. Since movement is no longer monitored and controlled certain body parts start to shake uncontrollably. Although Parkinson’s disease has no cure it can be somewhat controlled through medication. However Parkinson’s disease would be easier to control if it could be diagnosed earlier. By the time Parkinson’s disease is diagnosed, a person has already lost 80% of their dopamine neurons. In order to diagnose Parkinson’s disease earlier on doctors and patients need to see the sign and symptoms beforehand. Researchers have come upon the fact that an earlier way of diagnosing Parkinson’s disease might be through watching the patients sleeping patterns. Researchers are saying that REM sleep behavior disorder might share a common cause with Parkinson’s disease. REM sleep behavior disorder is a disorder in which there is rapid eye movement while a person is sleeping. It is a type of parasomnia in which vivid dreams are associated with the enactment of dreams. This disorder is a “dysfunction in REM sleep and the motor control circuitry in the pontomedullary structures” (2) which causes the loss of control over movement, especially of the eyes. Within this new discovery the REM sleep behavior...

Words: 888 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Sleep - Psychology

...INTRODUCTION Dalai Lama once said “ Sleep is the best meditation”. Sleep is just like a medicine; it can perform wonders, only if it’s given an adequate amount of time. Science has proved that sleep deprivation can cause sleepiness, malaise and a depression of the immune system. The quality and quantity of sleep often go hand in hand. Through this paper I will be evaluating the role of adenosine and melatonin on sleep and will discuss the human sleep stages, in particular, the REM phase, using the sleep log. ROLE OF ADENOSINE Adenosine is an inhibitory neurotransmitter believed to play a role in promoting sleep and suppressing arousal, with levels increasing with each hour when an organism is awake. Adenosine makes a person drowsy after a day’s accumulation and recovery after a night’s depletion. On evaluating my sleep log, I realized the effect of adenosine on human sleep. On the 21st of September I had a cup of coffee an hour before I took a power nap at 4:30pm. I was suffering from a slight headache and had a coffee, not realizing it would act against me. The caffeine increased my heart rate and made me feel more energetic. I thought I’d take a power nap so that I could concentrate on my work again. I tried very hard to take a good nap, but I didn’t succeed. I kept tossing from side to side. On doing my research I realized what was happening to me. Caffeine related drinks mask the effect of adenosine, which can prevent a person from feeling drowsy as the day proceeds. A...

Words: 1022 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Sleep Paralysis Research Paper

...explanation of Sleep Paralysis. My main source of this information was the Book “Sleep Paralysis- A guide to Hypnagogic Visions & Visitors of the Night” by Ryan Hurd (2011). The first thing I encountered in this book was the symptoms of Sleep Paralysis. The information gathered in the book state that these symptoms are “nearly universal and have been noted throughout history and across cultures.” Examples of these symptoms include, inability to move, feeling like being held down or experiencing a weight pushing down on the chest and throat, hearing strange noises such as buzzing, pounding heart, experiencing fear and terror, out of body experience, seeing weird creatures and difficulty in breathing....

Words: 814 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Lucid Vs. Non-Lucid Dreaming

...During REM sleep dreams can be characterized as being nonsensical, bizarre, and the individual is left unaware that they are dreaming. Certain neural patterns describe this state, such as, the deactivation of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Contrastly, lucid dreaming describes a state of sleep where the individual is aware that they are dreaming. Lucid dreaming can also be characterized by increase of 40-Hz wave activity and coherence in the frontal region of the brain. It is interesting to note that lucid dreamers are able to communicate their state by eye movements that can be tracked by an electrooculogram. Apart from the awesome idea of being aware that one is dream, lucid dreaming also have some benefits, such as, treating nightmares. In order to understand the neural changes in lucid dreaming and examine its neural correlates EEG and fMRI techniques were used in this study to compare lucid vs non-lucid REM sleep....

Words: 581 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Karen Horney

...the frequency, there is little variation to the dream. It usually points to a personal weakness, fear, or your inability to cope with something in your life – past or present. The repetitive patterns in your dreams can reveal some of the most valuable information on yourself. It may point to a conflict, situation or matter at work or at home, a situation in your waking life that remains unresolved or unsettled. Some urgent underlying message in your unconscious is demanding to be understood. Dreams are strongly associated with sleep. They may occur in all stages of sleep including the REM sleep and NREM sleep. It is implied that dreams are prevalent during the REM sleep, and the REM dreams can be recalled more easily than the NREM dreams. A human adult usually spends a total of 1% to 2 hours each night in REM sleep by spreading it over several periods. Thus, we may experience several individual REM dreams per night. The dreams during REM periods are long, complicated and visually...

Words: 1246 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Studying Sleep Through the Lifespan

...examining the relationship between REM sleep and memory. I will describe previous research and then research how REM and associated memory in young and older people. In a way, the sleep patterns of these two groups are very similar, but somehow are not. 1a For the adult brain changes sleep, REM sleep and slow wave to each other in cycles of about 90 minutes. Early in the evening, non-REM sleep is longer cycles, but as time passes, the REM cycles dominate. non-REM sleep involves minimal brain activity, EEG high amplitude and low frequency oscillations. REM sleep, on the other hand, involves a high amount of brain activity paradoxically and equally low amount of motor skills, with low amplitude and high frequency oscillations in the EEG. In the elderly, length and intensity of these cycles' occur in shorter periods. REM sleep occurs just and slow wave sleep occurs in shorter cycles. 1b REM sleep usually awakens the genitals in men and women. This effect is usually more deeply experienced in youth, with young men who have erection for a period of time that men and older. 1c When a person is awake and excited, high-frequency beta waves are observed. When a person is awake and relaxed, the low-frequency alpha waves are observed. In both REM and non-REM sleep-1, the waves are high frequency, low amplitude, and erratic. In non-REM-2 sleep, brain waves are a bit slower and less erratic, with brief bouts of high frequency brain activity. After REM-3 begins not sleep, the brain constantly emits...

Words: 1502 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Lucid Dreaming

...Tiesha Cooper Trinity Christian College Basic Research Skills Dr. King Lucid Dreaming Holzinger (2009), suggests that dreams have been a major importance to cultures throughout the ages. Native Americans viewed dreams as portals to the spirit world, paths to prophecy and quests. A common phenomenon states, there is an experience in which one is aware that one is dreaming and is able to control what happens in the dream. This experience is known as lucid dreaming. Aristotle may have been the first to write about lucid dreaming, although he did not have a term for it (Holzinger B. , 2009). And some Tibetan Buddhists have been practicing something like lucid dreaming for a long time. In Tibetan Buddhism, it was practiced as a form of yoga, called dream yoga, from the eighth century. The goal of dream yoga is to examine your consciousness and bring you to a constant state of awareness. A big part of the belief system of Buddhism is recognizing the world for what it is, free from deception. A lucid dreamer recognizes the dream world for what it is, a dream (Holzinger B. , 2009). A Dutch psychiatrist named Frederik van Eeden came up with the term for lucid dreams in 1913. He claimed that there are nine well-defined types of dreams in all, including ordinary, symbolic and vivid dreams. He recorded several of his own lucid dreams, and his thoughts during them and upon awakening. He remarked that they often involved...

Words: 3143 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

The Imperative Automatic Functions Of Sleep

...It is routinely theorised that one of our most imperative automatic functions, sleep, has two prime purposes: restoring our bodies and minds, allowing us to rest and absorb the information that we have processed throughout our day, and aiding us in our continued survival, allowing us to be awake, alert, and able to avoid and survive potential threats. The first of these subcategories, Restoration theories, deals with such topics as reprogramming, problem solving, and wish fulfilment, and how they pertain to the refreshment of our mental and physical faculties. The first of these concepts, aptly named Restoration Theory, postulated by Oswald (1966), states that sleep is used primarily for bodily repair and the repletion of our energy reserves,...

Words: 399 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Stages of Sleep

...of Slumbering Activities in Your Brain By: Bill Pak Section: #1762 (I was allowed permission by you to turn in this term paper due to some personal issues with the original term topic) Ever wondered what in blue blazes your brain is doing when you sleep? Well so far, all the research and experiments that have been made to understand and answer this question have resulted with the so called six stages of sleep. The six stages of sleep starts from Stage 0 to Stage 5. Stage 0 is not really considered a stage since it involves the person of interest being awake. Sequentially, Stage 1 is considered to be the beginning of being asleep. Following Stage 1 is Stage 2 which is well known for its sleep spindles and K-complexes (L & F 8). Afterwards, Stage 3 is considered to be a transition phase towards Stage 4 and both stages are collectively often titled as deep sleep (McPhee 20). Lastly, but not the least, Stage 5 is identified as dream sleep and with REM (McPhee). Each stage is not just discerned by its major aspects, but by the activity in the brain in each stage. Although sleep can be described through the various behavioral changes, the different activities in the brain allow the discerning of each stage during sleep. Each stage is distinguished by various electrical activities and patterns across the brain (L & F 7). These electrical activities and patterns consistently change between each stage (McPhee 17). Obviously, each stage has its own unique electrical pattern,...

Words: 1583 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Lucid Dreaming Research Paper

...Being able to control everything around you is only possible by lucid dreaming which is an unusual experience in Rapid Eye Movement (REM) sleep where you are conscious that you are dreaming. In this way, people can control their dreams so to make them by preference. For the sleeper these dreams look real, however the dreamer knows that this is not a reality which makes this a skill that provides hours of enjoyable experience (Susan Blackmore, Lucid Dreaming: Awake in Your Sleep?) There are four sleep stages: Non-rapid eye movement (NREM) stage one, non-rapid eye movement (NREM) stage two, non-rapid eye movement (NREM) stage three and four, which are grouped together due to the many similarities, and lastly, rapid eye movement (REM) sleep. In the first stage we begin to lose self-awareness and muscle tone. In stage two our body is completely relaxed so as not to react to the upcoming dreams. Stages three and four are marked by the loss of senses and reaction to the environment. Finally...

Words: 639 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Dream Content and Schizophrenia

...disorders have been found to dream while they’re in REM sleep which is a major mental process that allows people to dream. The following articles, “Sleep Fantasy in Normal and Schizophrenic Persons,” “An Extension of Freud and Jung’s Theory of Relation of Dream States to Schizophrenia,” “The Neurochemistry of Waking and Sleeping Mental Activity: The Disinhibition-Dopamine Hypothesis,” “Dream Content of Schizophrenics, Nonschizophrenic Mentally Ill, and community Control Adolescents,” “Sleep Disturbance in Schizophrenia” “Rorschach Responses Subsequent to REM Deprivation in Schizophrenic and Nonschizophrenic Patients,” attempt to explain the problem statement: How do dreams differ in people with schizophrenia to those without the disorder, through REM sleep in normal individuals and schizophrenics. Dream content will also be investigated to answer the problem statement and certain sleep habits. In addition Jung’s and Freud’s theory attempt to explain how dreaming is connected with schizophrenia in their conscious state rather than in their sleeping state through thought processes and verbal patterns. Another article also attempts to explain how certain chemicals react in certain parts of the brain to allow dream states, whether in consciousness or unconsciousness. The following six articles supports the hypothesis that a person with schizophrenia cannot recall dreams as vividly as other people without the disorder because of sleep disturbances....

Words: 2769 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Sleep

...A Good Night’s Sleep- What is sleep? Sleep is defined as unconsciousness while are brain is still active processing and rejuvenating period. Sleep is a physical and mental resting period in which a person is unaware of their environment. In a normal sleep our body is changing by decreasing body temperature, blood pressure and other body functions. Sleep is very important to us and everyone for that matter because we all need to sleep and rest our bodies. It’s so important because it’s a vital biological function without sleep we know that our bodies are unable to function the way we want them to. We lose lack of day-time alertness, drowsiness and more susceptible to health problems such as stroke, diabetes, obesity and even depression. In the article ("Good night’s sleep") they discuss about College students sleeping patterns changing for example, not getting enough sleep. I felt that the article didn’t have information about sleeping patterns when there has been research about sleeping patterns. In 2002 Canadian Community health survey found that 18% of people sleep 5 hours or less a day. Sleep is put into two parts one being called non-REM and REM (Rapid Eye Movement). Non-REM consists of four stages of sleep, each deeper than the last. REM is when you are at the most active sleeping you are dreaming and your eyes are moving rapidly. Our sleep patterns consist of stages 1-4. Stage one last about 5 minutes, easily awaken. Stage 2 first stage of sleep about first 25 minutes...

Words: 745 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Sleep Disorders

...emotional care in the world but if we not sleep, we can't live an ordinary life and maintain health. For this crucial time, there shouldn’t be any disturb to get good sleep. There are various kind of sleep disorder such as insomnia, Sleep apnea or Narcolepsy, which are enemies of good night sleep. In this report, I would like to cover the importance of good, proper sleep to overcome various sleep disorders and why sleeping in the dark is crucial for human. In addition, the reason why I put this sub topic, why we should sleep in the dark room, because I’m the coward who can’t tolerate and sleep in the darkness. I desperately want to dig up the answer, how dangerous it is, to break my negative habit. First of all, Importance and purpose of sleep. Why human is sleeping? Many psychologists and sleep investors try to figure out why we sleep since ages ago. Basically, while we are sleeping, body start to repair cells and to strengthen the immune system and other crucial functions to live an ordinary life. But researchers have yet to discover any fundamental purpose of sleep. Is it to refresh the body? Frankly, muscles don't need sleep, just irregular periods of relaxation. Is it to refresh the mind? The brain get benefits from a good sleep but there is no agreement among researchers about what exact form that benefit takes. Normally, we have two cycles of sleep, one is described by rapid eye movement--the REM sleep. The other is called non-REM sleep. Humans generally take about 90 minutes...

Words: 1124 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Dreams: Informative Speech

...Thesis Statement: Understanding how dreams occur, how they affect our lives and what they mean help us grasp what dreams actually are. Intro: I. (Attention Getter) Have you ever dreamt that you were walking along the side of a road or along a cliff and suddenly you trip? You’re falling for what seems like forever, but before hitting the ground, you wake up? This is considered to be a falling dream, and ironically, falling dreams occur when you are falling asleep. They are usually accompanied by muscle spasms and twitches of the entire body. Although these dreams occur while we are falling asleep, they interpret a completely different meaning. Falling can mean you are insecure, you are losing grip, or you simply have fears that need to be faced. Patricia Garfield, the author of Creative Dreaming states: “there is some problem that is making you feel helpless like you have no support, so next time when you wake up startled from a falling dream, ask yourself what upcoming events do I fear I will fail?” II. (Introduce Topic) Since the beginning of time, people have been trying to understand the different functions of the human body, how we move, talk, and even act. Many of these physiological behaviors have been explained to some extent. However, one area of the human body that has baffled researchers, is that of the mind. Many things that go on inside the mind that don’t make sense, and serves no real explanation as to why or how things happen. One of the most fascinating...

Words: 1735 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Psy 240 Sleep Deprivation, Disorders and Drugs

...Sleeping and Dreaming CheckPoint PSY 240 The Brain, The Body, and The Mind January 18, 2012 Windy Baker Kuntz There are two main types of sleep; first you have Non-Rapid Eye Movement Sleep or NREM (also known as quiet sleep and Rapid Eye Movement Sleep or REM (also known as active sleep or paradoxical sleep. This is broken down into five stages. The first stage is the beginning of the sleep cycle. It is considered to be a light stage of sleep. It is a transition period between wakefulness and sleep. Stage one lasts only a brief time (around 5-10 minutes). The second stage is when the brain begins to produce bursts of rapid, rhythmic brain wave activity known as sleep spindles. This only lasts for about 20 minutes and your body tempiture begins to decrease and the heart rate begins to slow down. The third stage is a transition between light and deep sleep. Your brain develops slow deep brain waves known as delta waves. The fourth stage is a very deep sleep that lasts for about 30 minutes, this is where delta sleep occurs and bed wetting as well as sleep walking is most likely to occur. Stage five is where most of our dreaming occurs. This is where we have our REM sleep. Respiration increases and so does brain activity. REM sleep is also referred to as paradoxical sleep because while the brain and other body systems become more active, muscles become more relaxed. Dreaming occurs due because of increased brain activity, but voluntary muscles become paralyzed. Our text...

Words: 469 - Pages: 2