Free Essay

Removing Subjectivity

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By pmorton
Words 3702
Pages 15
Removing Subjectivity: Wittgenstein, Carnap and Modernist Architecture.
Peter Morton

1. Introduction In this paper I want to address the coincidence of two powerful cultural forces of the early 20th century: modernist design in architecture and the philosophy of logical empiricism. This coincidence is most dramatically represented in the connection between two groups, who have each had powerful cultural influence in this century: The Bauhaus (1919 - 1933: Weimar, Dessau, Berlin, Chicago) The “Vienna Circle” (1922 - 1938: Vienna, Amsterdam. The former became the premier school of modernist design, and contained as faculty many of the most influential artists, designers and architects of the century. The Vienna Circle was a group consisting mostly of non-philosophers, who met weekly for discussion of philosophical issues. These informal meetings brought about the birth of logical empiricism, a movement which set the agenda for philosophy in America after the second world war. Herbert Feigl, Otto Neurath and Rudolph Carnap, central participants in the Vienna Circle, gave public lectures at the Bauhaus beginning in summer of 1929, when the Bauhaus was in Dessau under the leadership in Hannes Meyer. Their influence was sufficiently strong that logical empiricist philosophy became part of the standard curriculum of the school. A second very clear connection between modernist architecture and logical empiricism is the work of Ludwig Wittgenstein. Although Wittgenstein was not a licenced, practicing architect, he oversaw the construction of one of the most important examples of modernist architecture: the Kuntmanngasse, for his sister Margaret Wittgenstein-Stoneborough. In addition to these direct connections between philosophy and architecture, there are similarities of general aim and temperament in modernist architecture and logical empiricism. In both movements there is a strong commitment to the following broad ideals: 1. functionalism - the centrality of practical ends and empirical facts; 2. atomism - the analysis of complex structures into combinations of simple fixed units; 3. formalism - the emphasis of fixed rules and operations. (Colquhoun, 67-79)

One explanation for the connections between philosophy and architecture in the early part of the century is the existence of set of shared cultural forms: “a vocabulary and reservoir of images evolved that were shared by both the positivists and the Bauhausler” (Galison) However, the idea of a common shared goal obscures important distinctions between the aims and strategies of specific individuals. My purpose draw more precise connections between philosophy and architecture in the work of Ludwig Wittgenstein and Rudolf Carnap.

2. The aesthetic problem.

The field of design had entered a crisis by the turn of the century through the development of industrial manufacturing and advances in constructional engineering. Forms and design principles that had formerly been the product of craftsmanship could now be reproduced by machine in quantity. Engineering principles freed the designer from traditional physical and material constraints. As a result, the domains of designer and craftsman were divided, and the designer was free to create objects and structures that had once been impossible. One product of these developments was a proliferation of highly ornamented, cheaply produced goods. Another product was the fact, deplored by traditional architects, that the most interesting structures of the time were examples of pure practical engineering, such as suspension bridges and the Eiffel Tower. At the same time as this evolution of design and production, Europe popular and high culture went through the most romantic and introspective period in its history. A couple of quotations from Peter Gay capture the idea: “The nineteenth century was intensely preoccupied with the self, to the point of neurosis.” “… so-called ordinary bourgeois massively joined the pilgrimage to the interior with their intimate diaries, confessional journals, and confidential correspondence, with their love-letters and religious ruminations. But it was necessarily the men of letters – and women – who laid out the agenda for the rest.”

The effect of excessive introspection and romanticism, combined with the ready availability of cheaply ornamented articles, is described by a contemporary as follows: Theirs were not living rooms, but pawn shops and curiosity shops … [There was] a craze for totally meaningless articles of decoration. … a craze for satin-like surfaces: for silk, satin and shining leather; for gilt frames, gilt stucco, and gilt edges; for tortoise shell, ivory and mother-of-pearl, as also for totally meaningless objects of decoration, such as Rococo mirrors in several pieces, multi-coloured Venetian glass, fat-bellied old German pots, a skin rug on the floor complete with terrifying jaws and in the hall a life-sized wooden Negro. Everything was mixed, too, without rhyme or reason. … The more twists and scrolls and arabesques there were in the designs, the louder and cruder the colour, the greater the success… Every material used tires to look like more than it is. Whitewashed tin masquerades as marble, paper mache as rosewood, plaster as gleaming alabaster, glass as costly onyx .. The butter knife is a Turkish dagger, the ashtray a Prussian helmet, the umbrella stand a knight in armour, and the thermometer a pistol. (in Janik and Toulmin, 97)

One response to this deep aesthetic problem was to attempt to create a new aesthetic, which would express the cultural forms of the machine age and restore the purity of form lost with the demise of craftsmanship. This is well represented by a quote from Walter Gropius, the founder of the Bauhaus: The coming age demands its own expression. Exactly moulded form leaving nothing to chance, clear contrasts, the ordering of elements, the joining of equal forms and the unity of form and colour will become the aesthetic armamentarium of the modern archictect as artist, corresponding to the energy and economy of modern life. (in Wijdewilde, 190)

A different response was to abandon the idea of artistic or aesthetic creation altogether, and replace it with the principles of efficiency and practical engineering. Here is Hannes Meyer’s description of housing design: Building is not an aesthetic process … the new house is a product of industry and as such it is the work of specialists: economists, statisticians, hygienists, climatologists, experts in norms, heating techniques… building is only organization: social, technical, economic, mental organization. (in Galison, 717)

Meyer's description of the elements of house design is also interesting: We determine the annual fluctuations in the temperature of the ground and from that calculate the heat loss of the floor and the resulting depth required for the foundation blocks. … We calculate the angle of the sun's incidence during the course of the year according to the latitude of the site. With that information we determine the size of the shadow cast by the house on the garden and the amount of sun admitted by the window into the bedroom. … We compare the heat conductivity of the outside walls with the humidity of the air outside the house. (in Galison, 740)

In the final section I will argue that these two responses to the aesthetic problem are supported by Wittgenstein’s and Carnap’s philosophy respectively. To see this, we need to review the central philosophical issues they address.

3. The philosophy of Carnap and Wittgenstein.

A problem of cultural renewal similar to that in aesthetics was recognized by philosophers at the turn of the century. Just as the 19th century saw an excess of romantic introspection, it also suffered from an excess of metaphysical speculation. The origins of this metaphysics lies mainly in the post-Enlightenment response to Immanuel Kant’s transcendental idealism. Following Kant a succession of metaphysical theories were devised, each of which attempted to describe the detailed structure of the ultimate reality behind our sensory apprehension of the physical world. Just as artists and designers attempted to reign in the romanticism of the previous century, many philosophers attempted to reform the field of metaphysics by the adoption of empiricism and scientism. The Vienna Circle was the most radical, and ultimately most influential, of these movements. The origins of logical empiricism lie in the philosophy of mathematics at the turn of the century, especially the work of Bertrand Russell and Gottlob Frege. The fundamental idea introduced by this work is that solutions to philosophical problems are revealed through an examination of the logical structure of language (or, alternatively, that philosophical problems are problems concerning the logical structure of language.) A central element of the Frege’s work is the idea that properties and relations could be understood in the same way arithmetical functions. We can treat the expression “x is red” or “x is a sister of y” in precisely the same way that we treat the expressions “x > 10” and “x = y2.” There are, however, two central problems in making this idea work: First, what do we do about nonreferring names and descriptions, such as “Santa Claus” and “the present King of France?” Second, without some form of restriction on the objects that can be given as arguments for the functional expressions, we run into paradoxes. This particular problem, known as Russell’s Paradox, convinced Frege before his death that his life’s work was in ruins. The solution offered by Russell to the first problem was his famous “theory of definite descriptions.” The basic idea is that sentences containing names and definite descriptions (such as “the present King of France”) are not of the simple subject-predicate form suggested by their surface appearance. “The present King of France is bald” is really an abbreviation of the more complex sentence, “There exactly one person who is the present King of France, and that person is bald.” Presented in this form the sentence contains no nonreferring terms, and so is unproblematic. Russell’s solution to the second problem is his “theory of types.” The idea is that sets or classes are stratified into logical types: objects, classes of objects, classes of classes of objects, and so on forever. Then properties and relations belong only to a single given level. A sentence formed by using an argument belonging to a function of the wrong level produces nonsense. The theory of definite descriptions led to an extremely fertile philosophical idea, which is still the basis of analytic philosophy: The surface grammar of a sentence does not display, and in most cases deeply disguises, the logical structure of that sentence. (Think of the logical structure of a sentence as given by the logical combinations of simpler sentences that determine its truth or falsehood, or as given by the relations of logical inference it has to other sentences.) So the idea is that a central component in philosophical work (or, as the logical empiricists would have it, the only philosophical work) is the structural analysis of complex sentences into their logical components. This idea led in turn to logical atomism, the idea that every meaningful sentence can be uniquely analysed into a set of logically primitive sentences (bound together in specific logical relations such as “either .. or …” and “if … then …”. ) Wittgenstein believed that logical atomism actually contained a better solution to the logical paradoxes than Russell’s theory of types: If every meaningful sentence can be analysed into a set of logically primitive sentences (lpf’s), then the set of lpf’s, together with the set of possible logical combinations, would determine every possible meaningful sentence, (i.e., would determine everything that can be meaningfully said.) It would follow that the paradoxes are avoided because they could not be constructed from lpf’s. Moreover, Wittgenstein believed that this fact reveals the essential nature of logic. Logic, according to Wittgenstein, consists of nothing more than (a) the internal semantic structure of lpf’s, and (b) the ways of combining lpf’s into meaningful complexes. It follows from this idea that logic itself cannot be expressed in language, for anything we might use to represent a logical rule will either presuppose logic or will be meaningless. What we take to be rules of logic (such as “Either p or not-p”) are actually tautologies that they say nothing about the world. Yet while tautologies say nothing, in the sense that they are true no matter what the world might be like, they still show the structure of logic in their form. So, according to Wittgenstein, two points follow: (a) logic delimits the boundaries of what can be said, and (b) what can be said is shown in the logical form of meaningful sentences and tautologies. He says, “What can be shown cannot be said.” (T 4.1212) As an illustration, think here of the relationship between the numerical display of a calculator and the mechanism that operates the calculator. Language corresponds to the display, which represents numbers. Logic corresponds to the mechanism, which, while not represented on the display, is what make the representation possible. Rudolph Carnap was deeply impressed with the work of Wittgenstein, and he based his own work on the ideas of Wittgestein, Frege and Russell. (Carnap was himself a student of Frege.) Carnap accepted the principles of logical analysis, but he did not accept Wittgenstein’s view that the logical principles of language could not be represented in language. According to Carnap, logical rules are simply syntactic (or formal) rules. No one set of rules is superior to another. Each represents one way of correlating formal symbols (i.e., letters and numerals) with one another. Moreover, syntactic rules of a language can be stated clearly and fully in a meta-language, just as the grammar of German can be written in English. Butt here is no extra-linguistic standpoint from which all of language can be displayed. Recently there is a new understanding of Carnap’s philosophy put forward by Michael Friedman. If Friedman is correct, his interpretation also extends to Wittgenstein’s philosophy outlined above. According to Friedman, Carnap’s central goal is not what has traditionally been ascribed to him. Since the adoption of Carnap’s work by English-speaking philosophers he has been seen as a champion of radical empiricism: a reduction of all meaningful language into lpf’s that consist solely of descriptions of simple sensations. Friedman argues that Carnap’s actual intent is to show that all meaningful sentences can be analysed into lpf’s that consist solely of purely formal or structural relations. Structural relations are those that can be described in purely logical terms, without reference to the meaning of the relation itself or the identity of the terms so related. The structural properties of relations include, for a relation R: reflexivity (For any object a, aRa) symmetry (For any objects a and b, if aRb then bRa) transitivity (For any objects a,b and c, if aRb and bRc then aRc).

Carnap’s idea is that all of meaningful language consists of merely the assertion or denial of purely structural relations. Carnap’s early work, on this view, is an attempt to carry out such an analysis fully and rigourously. There textual evidence that Wittgenstein also subscribed to this project of structuralism. The idea of structuralism, then, is that all that can be meaningfully expressed in public language is limited to purely structural or logical relations. Any other meaning that might be attached to a word will be purely subjective, and hence completely private and inexpressible. (Think, for example, of how you would describe in literal terms what the colour red looks like to a person blind from birth.) This strategy (were it to work) satisfies the primary aim of the Vienna Circle: the elimination of all metaphysics. Philosophy will become the project of completing a full analysis of everything that is meaningful into its logical components. Everything will be stripped away from language except purely logical structure.

Architecture In the second section above I identified two responses on the part of architects and designers to the aesthetic problem of the 19th century. In this section I will make two claims:
1. The early philosophy of Wittgenstein led him to an aesthetic outlook, realized in the Kundemanngasse, that represents the first of these two responses to the modern dilemma of design.
1. Carnap’s adherence to very similar philosophical aims guided to his own alliance with Hannes Meyer in an embrace of the second of the two responses.

First, let’s look at Wittgestein. The distinction Wittgenstein draws between what can be said and what can only be shown extends far beyond his theory of logic. He says, for example, “There are, indeed, things that cannot be put into words. They make themselves manifest. They are what is mystical.” (T 6.522) He also says, “It is clear that ethics cannot be put into words. Ethics is transcendental. (Ethics and aesthetics are the same.)” (T 6.421) What cannot be said, but what is in some way an important aspect of life, is the combined domain of ethics-aesthetics. Of course, precisely because ethics-aesthetics cannot be put into words, Wittgenstein says little about it. Leaving ethics aside, I want to look at Wittgenstein’s aesthetics, as revealed in the Kundemanngasse. The simplest explanation of the connection between Wittgenstein’s philosophy and his aesthetics is to claim that Wittgenstein attempts to present a visual equivalent of logic. There are strong evidence for this idea: The Kundemanngasse is starkly simple in design, completely lacking in ornamentation, and more so than any other work of the same time period. Wittgenstein’s sister Hermine described the building as “Hausgewordene Logik” – “logic become a house.” But there is evidence that this simple explanation is wrong. Recently Paul Wijdeveld has carried out a detailed study of the aesthetic principles that Wittgenstein follows in the Kundemanngasse. Wijdeveld correlates this study with Wittgenstein’s scattered remarks about ethics-aesthetics and arrives at very different conclusions from a simple correlation of logic and aesthetics. According to Wijdeveld, Wittgenstein’s (unspoken) principles of design consist of the balancing of visual forces through the exploitation of assymetrical relationships between symmetrically ordered wall planes. Wijdeveld argues that Wittgenstein’s architecture is closest in its aims to (Baroque) classicism. The dominant feature of classicism is volumetric clarity and an emphasis on solidity and severity. Wittgenstein attempts a modern classicism, by adopting these features and giving them emphasis through the elimination of ornamentation and the use of modern construction techniques and materials. Moreover, what is completely surprising is Wijdevelde’s convincing argument that Wittgenstein pays no attention to functional aspects of design whatsoever. First, the shape and arrangement of living space follows strict rules of proportion, even when this is contrary to the practical layout of the plan. Second, there is no correlation at all between form and structure – between the spatial arrangement of lines and volumes and the structural elements of the building. But why would Wittgenstein adopt such a surprising approach, given a rejection of subjectivism? One answer is supplied by Wijdevelde. In many ways Wittgenstein agreed with the ethics and aesthetics of the architect and writer Adolf Loos, with whom he was well acquainted. Loos believed that the most important goal of design was cultural authenticity. The crime of the 19th century was it had lost all authenticity, and hadreplaced it with shabby and false ornamentation. It is clear that Wittgenstein shared this same outlook. Loos initially followed the goal of replacing the old “criminal” aesthetic with a new one, formed especially for the new era. Thus he adhered to the first of the two responses to the 19th century outlined in section 2. Loos’s way of accomplishing this goal was through simplicity of ornamentation and the reintroduction of classical forms. But later Loos abandoned classicism, and replaced it with his principle of “Raumplannung” or spatial design. The idea of Raumplannung was to design in three dimensions, from the inside of the building outward, using only the practical arrangement of rooms as the guiding principle. Yet if the Raumplannung approach is carried to its fullest, it reduces to the simple rejection of aesthetic principles and their replacement with functional and structural considerations. Ultimately Loos did not adhere strictly to the practical use of space, but instead used wall planes and windows to construct abstract compositions (described derisively by Wittgenstein’s architectural partner and Loos’s student as “ornamenting with unornamented planes.) According to Wijdevelde, Wittgenstein avoided the dilemma that Loos found himself in by attempting a return to pure classical principles of harmony. Wittgenstein describes aesthetic experience as the ability to see the world “sub species aeternitas”. He says, “The artistic miracle of the world is that it exists. That what exists, exists.” (NB, 86) (See here also the story of seeing a man doing ordinary things.) The ethical side of life is the acceptance of the world and one’s place in it: to fulfill one’s lot in life to the best of one’s ability. He says, “If suicide is allowed then everything is allowed. If anything is not allowed then suicide is not allowed. This throws a light on the nature of ethics, for suicide, so to speak, is the elementary sin.” (NB, 91) Wijdevelde argues that in the Kundemanngasse Wittgenstein attempts a purification of architecture through an attempt to create a pure classical harmony. In place of Loos’s functional Raumplannung Wittgenstein’s use of space is monumental, intended to create a spatial experience of lightness and volumetric clarity. The design of the Kundemanngasse was, for Wittgenstein, an ethical act. By contrast, Carnap drew no such distinction between what can be said and what can be shown. Since logic is, for Carnap, a set of syntactical rules governing the use of formal symbols, there is no mystical union of logic and the world. We are free to use whatever syntax we like, and there are many equally useful logical constructions, each of which describes the logical structure of the world in its own way. For Carnap, then, the elimination of subjectivity from language opens no doors to aesthetic or ethical principles. There is nothing to be “shown” in a Wittgensteinian sense. To be sure, the subjective aspect of experience exists – indeed, it is the basis for our knowledge of the world. But only its purely formal or structural elements are of concern to the philosopher or the designer. Hence, Carnap joins Meyer in an adherence to strictly practical and functional principles of design. Design is a science for Carnap, and its principles of those of efficiency and functionality. Thus, through their different philosophical perspectives on the shared goal of removing subjectivity from language, Wittgenstein and Carnap come to adhere to fundamentally opposing view on the nature and objectives of architecture and design.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Saints and Sinners

...between a righteous and a self-righteous spinner. Yes, I binge drink and you occasionally gulp in a couple of spirits. I wear condoms and aid in abortions while you literally kill people. Just like my liking for the color green and you, purple! You also point fingers at me for smoking while you safely harbor in lust; Avariciousness is what you wake up to yet you call me a thief; You spit on my existence and what I stand for, like a dustbin; While calling me names because I don’t indulge in your kind of sin; You call me a sinner while you live your illusive life as a saint. Forgetting that you cannot see through any object with a taint. How about removing the log in your eyes first – objectivity. Before proceeding to quenching my thirst – positivity. You sex two or more people yet call me a prostitute – subjectivity. We both engage in different and varied degrees of vices – relativity. So just allow your good self to live and let’s live – adaptivity. I want to be free; devoid of your labeling theories. To be referred to, as an individual and not this or that Hence my resolve to be true, thorough and tough, A force to reckon with and not to be written off, Accept my flaws for it is not your call to judge. Just do your bidding and wait for the clarion call, The only moment to know the true saints and...

Words: 337 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cooke Davies and Ntcp Model

...PROJECT MANAGEMENT INDIVIDUAL ASSIGNMENT ANSWER-1 In the article “The ‘‘real’’ success factors on projects” Cooke-Davies mentions 12 factors for ensuring the success of a project. Cooke-Davies differentiates between project success and project management success. He distinguishes success criteria which he describes as the benchmark to gauge success or failure and success factors which are management inputs that lead to project successes. In addition, he puts light on the existence of a relationship between project management and operations management before showing us how a successful project aligns with corporate success. On the other hand the NTCP is a part of adaptive project management approach that helps managers classify complex projects according to four dimensions namely novelty, technology, complexity, and pace. As per Cooke-Davies, project failure happens due to inadequate knowledge on the 12 critical factors while the NTCP model shows that whenever a project fails, there is always a mismatch between the risk profile of that project and the management style used to tackle it. Unlike Cooke-Davies, the diamond model goes beyond the Iron triangle of cost, time and quality and assigns the responsibility of attaining the metrics for project success solely on the manager thereby professing a unique style of management as required by that project. So at the start a manager must ask "What are the major sources of complexity and risk on this project?" and “What are...

Words: 852 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Pm Assignment

...1. In “The real success factors on projects” Terry Cook-Davies presents several factors that can lead to success of individual projects, project management success and the difference between success factors and success criteria. In one page, discuss how the NTCP model presented in class affects his conclusions. In the article “The ‘‘real’’ success factors on projects” Cooke-Davies mentions 12 factors for ensuring the success of a project. Cooke-Davies differentiates between project success and project management success. He distinguishes success criteria which he describes as the benchmark to gauge success or failure and success factors which are management inputs that lead to project successes. In addition, he puts light on the existence of a relationship between project management and operations management before showing us how a successful project aligns with corporate success. On the other hand the NTCP is a part of adaptive project management approach that helps managers classify complex projects according to four dimensions namely novelty, technology, complexity, and pace. As per Cooke-Davies, project failure happens due to inadequate knowledge on the 12 critical factors while the NTCP model shows that whenever a project fails, there is always a mismatch between the risk profile of that project and the management style used to tackle it. Unlike Cooke-Davies, the diamond model goes beyond the Iron triangle of cost, time and quality and assigns the responsibility of......

Words: 938 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Racism

...Racism is a word that can be defined in many different ways to people. To some, racism is a way of life, and to others, it is a repulsive term that represents closed-mindedness. Racism comes from different cultural values, ethnic backgrounds, as well as the physical appearances. The conflict of racism occurs when the majority group of society feels that the different cultures and values of the minority group brings the deviance to the society. The United States of America, which brought people from all over the world, is stated as the land of opportunity and freedom, it is also the country that is notorious for the racial discrimination. From the beginning of this country, there were conflicts with the Indians, slavery of blacks, and going against the people who immigrated here hoping to achieve the American dream. Racism have been one of the most significant issues that people have been facing and fighting for, and is still occurring around us without even knowing. I have not felt any serious racism against me so far since I am a student and had only been here for such a short period of time. Although the society that I am living in now is like the melting pot of all different cultures, I was able to figure out during my stay at school that most people who were in the same color used to get along together. I also heard about the experience of racism that my uncle had, who immigrated here about 6 years ago. My uncle owns a store in the city of Tustin, which he often had to...

Words: 955 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Opinion Comparator

...ABSTRACT As e-commerce is becoming more and more popular, the number of customer reviews that a product receives grows rapidly. This makes it difficult for a potential customer to read them to make an informed decision on whether to purchase the product or not. This paper proposes a novel tool named as Opinion Comparator for analyzing and comparing consumer opinions on competing products. This tool is useful to both potential customers and product manufacturers. A potential customer can see a visual comparison of products, which helps him/her to decide which product to buy. For a product manufacturer, the comparison enables it to easily gather marketing intelligence. This tool shows the features of a product along with their polarity on a bar graph. This tool uses language pattern mining and it extracts product features from the reviews of the format containing Pros and Cons of a particular product. Experimental results show that the technique is highly effective as it summarizes product reviews given by different customers. It visualizes this summarization using bar graphs with opinion polarity which helps user for better decision making. 1. INTRODUCTION The Web has dramatically changed the way that consumer express their opinions. They can now post reviews of products at merchant sites and express their views on almost anything in Internet forums, discussion groups, and blogs. There are also dedicated review sites, e.g., epininons.com. With more and more people using...

Words: 2657 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Feminism: Implications of Language in Organisational Theory.

...Theories of work organisation have gone through considerable changes in the last couple of decades. Describe what you believe to be the main changes and evaluate their importance in the changing world of business. (You may choose a particular industry or occupation to illustrate your argument). Introduction to the feminist movement: In an constantly evolving society, theories of work organisations have undergone drastic changes over the past few decades (Tosi 2009). Organisational theory developed from the work of Taylor and Weber (Reed & Ross-Smith 1994) along with the management theory of Mintzberg (Bartram 2005). The application of these concepts needed to change to reflect the desires and expectations of the current working demographic. The ‘highly visible’ (Stanley & Wise 2000) feminist or women’s movements, particularly in developed countries throughout the past century, have allowed women to enjoy substantially increased levels of equality and the ability to enter male-dominated occupations which their predecessors could not. Modern philosophers such as Foucault and de Saussure (Kelemen & Rumens 2008) have been considering one facet of ‘poststructuralism’ (Tosi 2009, p. 263), leading to a new stream of though on the implications of language interpretation. Modern poststructuralist feminists such as McNay and Weedon (as cited in Kelemen & Rumens 2008) have been debating ways in which to instigate and enhance a shift from a male-centric organisation compositions......

Words: 2245 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

The Fraud Triangle

...fraud which includes fraudulent financial reporting and misappropriation of assets. It also describes the fraud triangle theory proposed by D. R. Cressey. Think back to when you were in elementary school during fire safety week when the fire department would come and visit. Do you recall the fireman explaining what can be referred to as the fire triangle? That is, the description of what is necessary for fire to exist and continue. In order to create fire you need three things: fuel, oxygen, and heat. To put out (or prevent) the fire you would need to remove one of those three sides to the triangle. You could stop the fire by removing either the fuel, oxygen, or heat. This is a simple analogy for the fraud triangle. Just as there are three sides to the fire triangle there are three sides to the fraud triangle. You can prevent fraud by removing one of the sides. The three sides to the fraud triangle, all of which need to be present for fraud to take place, are: 1) Incentive/pressure 2) Opportunity 3) Attitude/rationalization Errors and Fraud Material misstatement of the financial statements can occur through errors or through intentional fraud. Errors are...

Words: 2106 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Development of Accounting Theory Based on Islamic Teachings

...shaukat_amer@comsats.edu.pk Abstract The beauty of accounting based on Islamic principles is that it not only deals with the valuation but also deals with an inbuilt accountability mechanism. Generally the accounting should be able to perform roles like keeping safe custody of interests, certifying true and fair view of business, enabling accountability and providing reliable information for successful decision making to all the stakeholders. In this context there are three main issues with respect to present system of setting accounting standards. These are undue pressures of certain groups in setting these standards, no role of owners in setting these standards, and flexibility/discretion in applying these standards which may lead to subjectivity. These may results in incorrect valuation of business transactions, increasing management discretion which in return will increase corporate governance issues including incorrect financial reporting, earning management and limiting decision making ability of the stakeholders. In order to overcome to this situation there is an urgent need to revamp the accounting theory in such a way that when it is put into practice it performs its due role as being, discussed here. The best way to correct this situation is to develop a new accounting theory based on Divine guidance. In this background, the Islamic principles of “Amanah” (Custody) (Amer2007), “Shahadat” (Testimony), (Amer, 2008)...

Words: 5509 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

The Comparison of Inner Conflicts of Nathanial Hawthorne’s Characters

...The Comparison of Inner Conflicts of Nathanial Hawthorne’s Characters By: Francisco Avilez ENC 1102 Nathaniel Hawthorne’s stories consist of individuals that suffer from inner conflicts that are caused by sin, pride, untested innocence, hidden guilt, perverse secrecy, cold intellectuality, and isolation. In his stories “The Minister’s Black Veil", “The Birth Mark” and “Rapaccini’s Daughter” all suffer from pride, perverse secrecy, and sin. In these tree stories, Hawthorn’s characters use science and mind control to manipulate their victims resulting from their obsession to be or act like God. Neither of his characters felt as if they have sinned or show any remorse for their victims or actions. In the Minister’s Black Veil”, a minister wears a black veil to prove a point to his congregation, but when he realizes the power he has gained from his community through his veil, he decides to never take it off, as a result, he crushes his future bride’s heart along the way (Emmett). In Hawthorne’s story “The Birth Mark”, a scientist is obsessed with his wife’s birth mark and considers it as an imperfection; he believes his wife has. In the story of “Rappaccini’s Daughter,” a scientist is obsessed with science, and as a result he destroys his beloved daughter’s ability to love, and her life. Nathaniel Hawthorn’s story, “The Minister’s Black Veil” the main character “Minister Mr. Hooper” wears a black veil that hangs from his forehead, hiding his face from the world. All that......

Words: 1645 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Bar Code

...Kayla Wiggins November 19, 2015 Prof. Ronaszegi English 101 RFID Implants: “You won’t know it’s there but we will” It’s safe to say that none of us would be contempt knowing that we’re being tracked or recorded yet everyone carries a mobile phone, right? RFID (Radio-Frequency Identification) deprives us of our privacy rights. The chip is about the size of a grain of rice and is to be located on the dorsal side of your hand. Embedded in every phone is an RFID chip that tracks our every move when we open apps such as GPS, or microphones, cameras and cell tower triangulation (mathematical method that uses the distance of a cellphone from three or more cell towers to calculate the location of the cellphone.)(Regel, A., 2013). This seems to be okay since it’s not forced upon us, and besides, who doesn’t want the newest cell phone? We will even go as far as paying big bucks to have the best “tracking device” we can buy. Having a tracking device implanted in our skin is quite alarming and a little stalker-like. This tiny capsule, which has been approved by the FDA, allows doctors to confirm a patient’s identity and obtain detailed medical information from a database. Digital Solutions of Delray Beach, Florida, plans to market the chips to hospitals, doctors, and patients as a way to improve health care and avoid errors by ensuring that doctors know who they’re treating and their personal health information (Michael K., 2005). I believe some legislation should be put......

Words: 1813 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Crime

...Margie P. Permenter CJ 606: The Transferring of Juvenile Offenders Commentary Three Dr. Yaschica Williams The most serious juvenile crimes have always been the political Achilles’ heel of the American juvenile court Fagan & Zimring (2000). Even when public opinion is tolerant of juvenile delinquency, the teen killer is the nightmare case for the juvenile justice system. In an age where the phrase juvenile super predator is often heard in the federal congress and state legislatures, the deep-end adolescent offender is a particular threat to public acceptance of the mission and objectives of juvenile justice. It is little wonder, then, that legislation concerning transfer is a near-universal feature of the politics of juvenile justice. The traditionally stated purpose of judicial wavier is to permit individualization of the decision whether a particular person is capable of being rehabilitated in the juvenile system-the amenability decision Fagan & Zimring (2000). In addition, the judicial wavier procedure provides a safety value for the juvenile system to exclude children who commit offenses that are believed to require the imposition of sanction that are beyond the capacity of the juvenile system to provide. Some form of judicial wavier or a substitute safety value is necessary in order to preserve the juvenile justice system politically within the context of modern penological expectations. It is difficult empirically to evaluate the contemporary role of......

Words: 1870 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Cloning & Individualism

...Results May Vary: Adam Phillips’s Theory of Cloning and The Paradoxical Apotheosis of Individualism Adam Phillips’s essay “Sameness Is All” takes the form of a dialogue with two children to introduce the fantasy of cloning in which everyone is identical. Specifically, Phillips observes that cloning is a “denial of difference and dependence” which leads to a “refusal of need” (92). However, Phillip remains mindful that such fantasy of physical or psychological sameness is implausible as everyone is different - even clones. One then questions the significance of such wanting of sameness, or if the sense of sameness serves any purpose. Using the concept of Self and Other that Joanne Finkelstein examines in “The Self as Sign,” I propose that the sense of sameness that is offered by the illusion of cloning allows one to establish a sense of identity. In a final analysis, I will elaborate on Finkelstein’s arguments on the Self and Other to shed light on the question posed by Philips on whether cloning was the death or apotheosis of individualism, and suggest that cloning has the paradoxical outcome of reinforcing individualism even as one seeks uniformity. Cloning is supposed to lead to conformity and uniformity, the absolute sameness. Phillips argues that cloning is appealing to society because it seems to represent a cure for “the terrors and delights of competition” (90-91). What is interesting, however, is the eventual admission by Phillips that......

Words: 2058 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Facial Reconstructions

...Forensic Facial Reconstructions Samantha McAnally CRMJ430 April 20, 2013 Abstract This paper will focus mainly on the history and the various techniques that forensic facial reconstruction has to offer. It will also go over some problems or an issue that is process has faced over the years. The Daubert Standard will discuss and how facial reconstruction was allowed as evidence thru this standard. I will go over all the periods of time that facial reconstruction was used. Computerized and Clay reconstruction will be discussed and how they have help investigators solved current and cold case crimes. Forensic Facial Reconstruction Forensic facial reconstruction is the method of restoring the appearance of a person (whose identity is frequently not recognized) from their skeletal remnants through a combination of creativity, forensic science, anthropology, osteology, and anatomy. The situation can also display what an individual would look like as an adult if they were abducted or gone missing as adolescents. In this paper, we will discuss the different approaches that can be used in facial reconstruction from computerized techniques to sketch artist techniques. The fortitude of forensic facial reconstruction is to yield an image from a skull that suggests an adequate resemblance of the thriving individual that the situation will assist in the proof of identity of the skeletal remnants while there are not any additional resources accessible. Finding skeletons......

Words: 2024 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Market and Its Performance

...2012 AUTUMN SEMESTER ECONOMICS LECTURE REPORT MARKET AND ITS PERFORMANCE : MAIN ELEMENTS AND FUNCTIONS TEACHER: EDITOR: Assoc Prof Yalcin BORLU Rasa ZABARAUSKAITE CONTENTS 1) What’s a Market? 3 2) Types Of Markets 4 1. Financial Markets 4 1. Stock Market 4 2. Bond Market 4 3. Foreign Exchange Market 4 4. Predictive Markets 4 2. Physical markets 4 3. Virtual Markets 5 4. Auction Market 5 5. Market for Intermediate Goods 5 6. Black Markets 5 7. Knowledge Market 5 3. Organization Of Markets 5 4. Mechanisms of Markets 6 5. Study of Markets 7 6. Size Parameters 8 Sources 8 1) What’s a Market? A market is one of many varieties of systems, institutions, procedures, social relations and infrastructures whereby parties engage in exchange. While parties may exchange goods and services by barter, most markets rely on sellers offering their goods or services (including labor) in exchange for money from buyers. It can be said that a market is the process by which the prices of goods and services are established. For a market to be competitive, there must be more than a single buyer or seller. It has been suggested that two people may trade, but it takes at least three persons to have a market, so that there is competition on at least one of its two sides. However, competitive markets rely on much larger numbers of both buyers and sellers. A market with single seller and multiple buyers is......

Words: 2010 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Embodying the Gay Self: Body Image, Reflexivity and Embodied Identity

...Copyright © eContent Management Pty Ltd. Health Sociology Review (2010) 19(4): 437–450. Embodying the gay self: Body image, reflexivity and embodied identity DUANE DUNCAN Australian Research Centre in Sex, Health and Society, La Trobe University, Melbourne, VIC, Australia ABSTRACT The emphasis on a sexualised muscular body ideal in gay social and cultural settings has been described as facilitating body image dissatisfaction among gay men. Drawing on a concept of reflexive embodiment, this paper uses qualitative interviews to analyse gay men’s embodiment practices in relation to discourses and norms that can be found across and beyond any coherent notion of ‘gay subculture’. The findings reveal body image to be more complex than a limited focus on subculture or dissatisfaction can account for. In particular, gay men negotiate a gay pride discourse in which the muscular male body generates both social status and self-esteem, and deploy notions of everyday masculinity that imply rationality and control to resist gendered assumptions about gay men’s body image relationships. KEYWORDS: body image; gay men; reflexive embodiment; sociology INTRODUCTION Body image dissatisfaction and gay men Following the shift from individual pathol-ogy to cognitive-behavioural and feminist perspectives in psychology (McKinely 2002; Pruzinsky and Cash 2002), a significant volume of psychological and health research has identi-fied a greater incidence of......

Words: 7590 - Pages: 31