Free Essay

Research Paper on Violation of Human Right

In: Science

Submitted By Mutonyi
Words 4639
Pages 19
Environmental Technology iFirst, 2012, 1–8

Development of a simple model for anaerobic digestion based on preliminary measurements of the bacterial sulphur activity in wastewater stabilization ponds
Casimir Harerimanaa , Chéma Keffalab∗ , Hugues Jupsinb and Jean-Luc Vaselb a Centre b Département

Universitaire de Recherche Multidisciplinaire en Environnement (CURME), Université du Burundi, Bujumbura, Burundi; des Sciences et Gestion de l’Environnement, Unité ‘Assainissement et Environnement’, Université de Liège, Arlon, Belgium (Received 12 March 2012; final version received 26 August 2012 )

The present study was undertaken to develop a simple and practical model for anaerobic digestion, encompassing sulphate reduction and sulphur oxidation, in a waste stabilization pond. The basic microbiological phases of the model consisted of four processes, namely acidogenesis, methanogenesis, sulphate reduction and sulphur oxidation. It also incorporated multiple reaction stoichiometry and substrate utilization kinetics. The study also aimed to investigate the mutual interaction between sulphate-reducing bacteria (SRB) and photosynthetic sulphur bacteria (PSB) in an anaerobic sludge consortia using batch reactors. The results revealed that for an initial concentration of sulphate ranging between 250 and 2800 mg.l−1 , SRB activity ranged between 20 and 190 mgSO2− reduced . The gVSS−1 .d−1 and PSB activity varied between 60 and 4 320 mgSO2− produced .gVSS−1 .d−1 , and PSB activity was noted to be twice as high as that of SRB. PSB can, therefore, 4 be used effectively in the fight against odors. The most important environmental factors affecting the sulphur cycle in the waste stabilization pond were likely to be the availability of sulphate and light for SRB and PSB, respectively. Keywords: modelling; sulphate-reducing bacteria; photosynthetic sulphur bacteria; stoichiometry; odour

Introduction Wastewater stabilization ponds have been commonly used as a means of wastewater treatment because of their low cost, simplicity of operation and ease of maintenance. The efficiency of this technique has, however, often been limited by a number of inadequacies, particularly the release of offensive odours, often associated with the presence of hydrogen sulphide (H2 S), which is itself generated by the sulphate-reduction process [1–3]. In fact, sulphate stimulates the growth of sulphate-reducing bacteria (SRB), which out-compete methane-producing bacteria (MPB) for H2 and acetate substrates [4]. The optimum oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) for the growth of SRB ranges between −100 and −300 mV at pH 7.0 [5]. No growth was previously observed at potentials of more than +27 mV [6]. The main problems associated with the sulphate-reduction process arise from the generation of hydrogen sulphide, a phenomenon that not only creates troublesome odour and corrosion problems [7], but also is fatally toxic to humans, causing death within 30 min at gaseous concentrations of only 800–1000 ppm, and instant death at higher concentrations [8,9]. The sulphides in a stabilization pond can be oxidized by coloured photosynthetic bacteria in the presence of light [5].

A large number of photosynthetic sulphur bacteria (PSB) are found in stabilization ponds, particularly during the summer and autumn, imparting a characteristic brown or red colour to the pond. The appearance of PSB is often accompanied by a reduction in the odours generated by hydrogen sulphide, a phenomenon that earned them the name of ‘biological deodorizers’ in the literature. Both types of bacteria (phototrophic and sulphatereducing) contribute to the turnover of the sulphur cycle in waste stabilization ponds [10]. The development of a simple model that simulates and predicts anaerobic digestion based on the determination of bacterial sulphur activity in wastewater stabilization ponds would, therefore, help improve and optimize current wastewater treatment systems. In fact, modelling is one of the most important tools for the simulation, prediction and optimization of water and ecological systems [11]. This technique was previously applied by an International Water Association (IWA) expert group who developed a model for anaerobic digestion, ADM1 [12], that consisted of 19 biochemical processes, including 3 kinetic processes of gas-liquid transfer and 7 different bacterial populations. Although efficient, this model is quite sophisticated and demanding, for it requires a relatively good knowledge of the kinetic and stoichiometric parameters of

∗ Corresponding

authors. Emails:;

ISSN 0959-3330 print/ISSN 1479-487X online © 2012 Taylor & Francis


C. Harerimana et al.
H2 Xc
Complex organic material Proteins, carbohydrates, lipids

Xh2 Xac VFA

Xh2,so4 CH4, CO2 Xac,so4 H2S, CO2

Xh2,so4 Xpsb



Figure 1.

Schematic biochemical process stages of anaerobic digestion with sulphate-containing waste waters. Main trophic group bacteria used in the model. Trophic group Symbol Xc Xac Xh2 Xac,so4 Xh2,so4 Xpsb Substrate Complex organic matter VFA (acetate equivalent) H2 and CO2 Acetate and sulphate H2 and sulphate Sulphur and CO2 Product Volatile fatty acid (VFA) and H2 Methane, CO2 Methane Sulphur and CO2 Sulphur Sulphate

Table 1.

1 2 3 4 5 6

Acidogenic bacteria Acetotrophic methanogenic bacteria Hydrogenotrophic methanogenic bacteria Acetotrophic SRB Hydrogenotrophic SRB Phototrophic sulphur oxidizing Bacteria

the bioreactor to modelize [13]. Others authors [14] modified and extended the ADM1 model, through adding a sulphato-reduction process, which improved its predictive power but added to its complexity. Considering the troublesome limitations associated with wastewater stabilization ponds and the promising opportunities that modelling could offer with regards to their alleviation and/or prevention, this study was undertaken to develop a simple model of anaerobic digestion, including the sulphate-reducing and sulphur-oxidizing processes in waste stabilization ponds. To achieve this aim, a stoichiometric and kinetic model was developed, and the results were synthesized in a Petersen Matrix. The reduction of sulphate by SRB and the oxidation of sulphur by PSB in batch reactors were then submitted to kinetic investigation. Model description Figure 1 illustrates the basic microbiological phases of the model presented in this work. The model consists of four stages, namely acidogenesis, methanogenesis, sulphate reduction and sulphur oxidation. It describes an anaerobic reaction sequence in which substrates are transformed by the six trophic groups of bacteria presented in Table 1. The principles underlying the extension of the anaerobic digestion model, including sulphate reduction and sulphur oxidation processes, are basically stoichiometric and kinetic in nature. Stoichiometry According to [15], microorganisms obtain their energy for growth and maintenance from oxidation-reduction reactions, which always involve an electron donor and an electron acceptor. Under anaerobic conditions, some microorganisms can use other electron acceptors in energy metabolism, including nitrate, sulphate and carbon dioxide. In some cases, organic matter is used as the electron

acceptor as well as the electron donor, and the reaction is termed ‘fermentation’. Table 2 summarizes half-reactions, written as one-electron oxidation, for a series of oxidation reductions of interest to the present study [3]. The complex organic material is represented by C8 H16 O6 N, and the bacterial population is represented by C5 H7 O2 N. The nitrogen required for bacterial synthesis is obtained from the release of NH3 in reaction. When microorganisms use an electron-donor substrate for synthesis, a portion of its electrons (fe0 ) is initially transferred to the electron acceptor to provide energy for the conversion of the other portion of electrons (fs0 ) into microbial cells. The sum of (fs0 ) and (fe0 ) is 1 [11]: fe0 + fs0 = 1 (1)

where fs0 is a portion of the electron equivalent in the electron-donor substrate used for synthesis and fe0 is a portion of the electron equivalent in the electron-donor substrate used for energy. The fraction fs0 is similar to the true yield Y if it is expressed as gCOD_cell produced/gCOD_consumed. Equation (2) is a general equation that can be used for the establishment of a wide variety of accurate stoichiometric equations describing microbial processes, such as synthesis and growth [15]. The result is an equation written on an electron-equivalent basis that represents the net consumption of reactants and the production of products when the microorganisms consume one-electron equivalent of electron donor: R = fe0 Ra + fs0 Rc − Rd (2)

where R is the general equation, Ra is the acceptor halfreaction, Rd is the donor half-reaction and Rc is the cell half-reaction. The selecting of the appropriate half-reactions from Table 2 and the use of Equation (2) give the following overall biological reaction (Table 3).

Environmental Technology
Table 2. The oxidation and reduction half-reaction of the model main compound. Component COM Acetate H2 Sulphate Microorganisms Half-reaction 1 10 8 1 C8 H16 O6 N + H2 O → CO2 + NH3 + H+ + e− 33 33 33 33 1 1 1 7 CH3 COO− + H2 O → CO2 + H− + e− 8 4 4 8 1 H2 → H + + e− 2 1 2− 10 + 1 4 SO + H + e− → H2 S + H2 O 8 4 8 8 8 1 1 2 1 CO2 + NH3 + H+ + e− → C 5 H7 O2 N + H 2 O 4 20 20 5


Table 3. Overall reactions for biological growth and substrate uptake involved in the model. Uptake of complex organic material by X c 17 − 33YC 33YC H2 O → C5 H7 O2 N + (3.3 − 3.3YC )CH3 COOH+ 5 20 28 − 33YC 20 − 33YC (3.3 − 3.3YC )H2 + CO2 + NH3 20 20 C8 H16 O6 N + Uptake of acetate by X ac CH3 COOH + 2Yac 2Yac 6Yac NH3 → C5 H7 O2 N + (1 − Yac )CH4 + H2 O + (1 − Yac )CO2 5 5 5

Uptake of H2 by X h2 H2 + Yh2 1 + Yh2 Yh2 1 5 + 3Yh2 NH3 + CO2 → C5 H7 O2 N + (1 − Yh2 ) CH4 + H2 O 10 4 10 4 10 2Yac,so4 5 10 − 12Yac,so4 5

Uptake of acetate by X ac,so4 CH3 COOH + (1 − Yac,so4 )SO2− + 4 2Yac,so4 5 NH+ + 4 H+ → H2 O

C5 H7 O2 N + (1 − Yac,so4 )H2 S + (2 − 2Yac,so4 )CO2 +

10 − 12Yac,so4 5

Uptake of H2 by X h2,so4 H2 + (1 − Yh2,so4 )SO2− + 4 2Yh2,so4 5 2Yh2,so4 5 NH+ + 4 10 − 12Yh2,so4 5 20 − 4Yh2,so4 5 H+ + (2Yh2,so4 )CO2 →

C5 H7 O2 N + (1 − Yh2,so4 )H2 S +

H2 O

Uptake of H2 S by X psb 10CO2 + 5H2 S + 2NH3 + 4H2 O → 2C5 H7 O2 N + 5SO2− + 10H+ 4

Kinetics Cellular kinetics is described by three expressions (uptake, growth and decay; see Appendices 1 and 2). The key rate equation is substrate uptake, which is based on the substrate level of a Monod-type kinetics or multiplicative Monod approach when both the electron donor and electron acceptor are rate limiting. Considering that the present study is interested in substrate removal (sulphur and sulphate), the rate of substrate consumption was selected as the basic rate, while cell growth was derived from substrate

utilization. Bacterial decay was described by first-order kinetics [4]. The growth parameters for SRB and substrate consumption cannot be taken as ‘random variables’. They have specific units and ranges of values (Tables 4 and 5). In several cases, the values are constrained by cell stoichiometry and energetics [15]. The five growth parameters for PSB reported by [13] are μmax = 4.12 h−1 , KS = 1.48 mM, KI = 850 lx, Ki = 3.90 × 10−5 lx and YS = 2.9 g_cell. mol_H2 S−1 , where μmax refers to the maximum


C. Harerimana et al.
Table 4. Kinetics parameters and rates used in the model. Symbol μmax km, process Ys KS, process KSO4, process kdec KI , inhibit, substrate Iinhibitor, process kprocess ρj YSO4 Description Monod maximum specific growth rate Monod maximum specific uptake rate Yield of biomass on substrate Half-saturation value of substrate Half-saturation value of sulphate First-order decay rate 50% inhibitory concentration Inhibition function First-order parameter (hydrolysis) Kinetic rate of process j Yield of biomass on sulphate Units d−1 gCOD_S.gCOD_X−1 .d−1 gCOD_X.gCOD_S−1 gCOD_S.l−1 gSO2− .l−1 4 d−1 gCOD.l−1 (see KI ) d−1 gCOD_S.l−1 .d−1 gCOD_X.gSO2− 4

Table 5. Values of bacterial parameters used in some models. Ref 1 2 3 4 2 3 4 3 4 3 4 Trophic group Xc Xac μmax d−1 0.91 0.24 0.29 0.30 1.0 2.6 0.98 0.51 0.24 5.0 0.98 km gCOD/gCOD.d 6.51 6.50 8 9.62 40 35 24.24 8.8 7.1 7.0 26.7 Ks gCOD/l 0.4 0.056 0.150 0.210 0.00013 0.00003 0.0001 0.024 0.220 0.00005 0.0001 KSO4 gS04/l Y gCOD/gCOD 0.140 0.037 0.050 0.032 0.025 0.060 0.040 0.058 0.034 0.109 0.037 kdec d−1 0.016 0.010 0.018 0.050 0.009 0.010 0.025 0.015 0.030 0.010 ki gCOD/l 2.285 – 0.690 0.215 – 0.600 0.285 0.750 0.550 0.750


Xac,so4 Xh2,so4

0.019 0.010 0.001 0.010

Notes: 1. estimated with thermodynamic method; 2. according to [4]; 3. according to [12]; 4. according to [14].

specific growth rate, KS to the saturation constant for dissolved H2 S concentration, KI to the saturation constant for light intensity and Ki to the light inhibition constant. Model presentation (Appendices 1 and 2) According to the literature [16], the Petersen matrix forms a succinct summary of the complex interactions between compounds and processes. It allows alterations in processes, compounds, stoichiometry and kinetics to be readily incorporated. The matrix shows two important process aspects, namely that the reaction equation for each process is represented on the different rows and that one can observe in which conversions the compound is involved directly from the columns of each compound. By multiplying the stoichiometric factors with their respective rate equations, one gets the total conversion equation for each compound. For convenience, two extra aspects can be added to the matrix description. The first aspect relates to composition matrix in terms of conserved balances. Accordingly, it covers the chemical oxygen demand (COD), N, S and charge balance. In this respect, biomass is expressed in the stoichiometric matrix in terms of COD, but also contains

nitrogen. This is included in the composition matrix, since the composition matrix and the stoichiometry matrix effectively contain all the conserved balances. The second aspect pertains to the observed matrix, since the present work is interested not only in the compounds expressed in the dimensions as used in the model, but also in their measured or observed units. For instance, the sludge amount is usually measured as gVSS and not gCOD. The observed matrix contains these conversion values between, for example, gCOD and gVSS. Other potentially interesting observed quantities include Kjeldahl nitrogen, sulphur, volatile suspended solids (VSS) and biochemical oxygen demand (BOD).

Materials and methods The batch assay study was used to assess the sulphidogenic activity of sulphur bacteria. The biomass inoculum was obtained from an anaerobic municipal wastewater treatment lagoon located at El Jem, Tunisia. Twenty litres of anaerobic pond sewage were centrifuged at 3500 rpm for 10 min to obtain concentrated biomass. At the onset of the experiment, between 13 and 17 g/litre VSS of bacterial

Environmental Technology biomass was added to the reactors. For all experiments, a basal medium was used in such a way that the C/N/P ratio did not constitute a nutrient limitation for bacterial growth. The enriched basal medium consisted of (in mg.l−1 ): NaHCO3 (1000), NaCl (1000), K2 HPO4 (500), NH4 Cl (1000), MgCl2 .6H2 O (300), CaCl2 .6H2 O (1000), yeast extract (1000), ascorbic acid (1000), resazurin (1) and a trace element solution (1 ml.l−1 ) consisting of (in mg.l−1 ): HCl (25%; 7.7 M) (10 ml.l−1 ), FeCl2 .4H2 O (1500), ZnCl2 (70), MnCl2 .4H2 O (100), H3 BO3 (6), CoCl2 .6H2 O (190), CuCl2 .2H2 O (2), NiCl2 .6H2 O (24), Na2 MoO4 .2H2 O (36) and cysteine-HCl (560). Six reactors were fed with the same level of acetate (2000 mg.l−1 ), but different levels of sulphate, that is, 260 mg.l−1 for reactor A, 480 mg.l−1 for reactor B, 535 mg.l−1 for reactor C, 1335 mg.l−1 for reactor D, 1860 mg.l−1 for reactor E and 2775 mg.l−1 for reactor F. Serum vials (125 ml) were filled with 100 ml of the sample, leaving a headspace of 25 ml. The pH of all media (basal media with sulphate and acetate) was set to a value of above 8. Nitrogen was bubbled throughout the sample for at least 5 min after the addition of sodium acetate and potassium sulphate to ensure that the wastewater sample and headspace were free from oxygen, which would otherwise inhibit the sulphate reduction processes. The water samples in the reactors were continuously stirred, and syringes were used to withdraw 4 ml of liquid samples that were immediately filtered through a 0.45 μm membrane filter. The entire study was conducted at 30◦ C, and sulphate was analysed by ion chromatography. The VSS and COD were determined according to standard methods.
Test 2 1200 1000
[SO42-] (mg/l)


Results and discussion The sulphate concentrations in each reactor were determined at regular intervals throughout the experimental assays. The typical variation of the concentration is illustrated in Figure 2. The results from the series of tests revealed that the concentration of sulphate decreased and increased alternatively. The decrease observed for the sulphate concentration was due to the sulphate reduction processes induced by SRB [17]. The increase was, on the other hand, attributed to the oxidation of sulphide by phototrophic sulphur bacteria, without oxygen and in the presence of light. Both kinds of bacteria (phototrophic and sulphate-reducing) contributed to the turnover of the sulphur cycle in each reactor. The average activities of SRB and PSB were calculated by Equations (3) and (4) and expressed as mgSO2− reduced .gVSS−1 .d−1 and 4 mgSO2− produced .gVSS−1 .d−1 , respectively: 4 υSRB = − υPSB = 1 XSRB 1 XPSB t
2− SSO4

2− SSO4

(3) (4)

2− where SSO4 refers to the sulphate concentration reduced or produced, at fixed time intervals t, assuming that the biomass concentrations of SRB (XSRB ) and PSB (XPSB ) are constant. The activities determined for SRB and PSB in each reactor during the whole experimental period are summarized in Table 6.

2500 2000
[SO42-] (mg/l)

Test 5

800 600 400 200 0

1500 1000 500 0



20 Time (h)






20 Time (h)




Figure 2.

Sulphate reduction and production curves for calculation of SRB and PSB activity. Specific rate of sulphate reduction and sulphate production. Reactor A Reactor B 1075 164,42 535 94,66 Reactor C 1470 188,78 480 149,46 Reactor D 1335 125,26 490 83,00 Reactor E 2375 128,80 1860 60,64 Reactor F 2775 145,16 1675 230,94 mg.l−1 mgSO2− reduced . gVSS−1 .d−1 4 mg.l−1 mgSO2− produced . gVSS−1 .d−1 4

Table 6.

[SO2− ] initial 4 SRB activity [SO2− ] initial 4 PSB activity

260 19,42 135 315,44


C. Harerimana et al.
[2] J. Paing, Bilan du carbone et du soufre dans le lagunage anaérobie. Contrôle de l’émission d’H 2 S pour la réduction des nuisances olfactives, thèse de doctorat, Université de Montpellier I, France, 2001, p. 218. [3] C. Harerimana, B. Harbi, and J.L. Vasel, Développement d’un modèle stœchiométrique de la sulfato-réduction par des bactéries sulfato-réductrices en lagunage anaérobie, Biotechnol. Agron. Soc. Environ. 14(S2) (2011), pp. 577–582. [4] S.V. Kalyuzhnyi and V. Fedorovich, Mathematical modelling of competition between sulphate reduction and methanogenesis in anaerobic reactors, Bioresour. Technol. 65 (1998), pp. 227–242. [5] E.F. Gloyna, Bassins de stabilisation des eaux usées, Organisation mondiale de la Santé, Génève, 1972, p. 187. [6] S. H. Chuang, T. Y. Pai, and R. Y. Horng, Biotreatment of sulfate_reach wastewater in an anaerobic/micro aerobic bioreactor system, Environ. Technol. 26 (2005), pp. 993–1002. [7] A. Rinzema, Anaerobic treatment of wastewater with high concentrations of lipid or sulphate, PhD thesis, Wageningen Agricultural University, Netherlands, 1988. [8] P.N.L. Lens and L.P. Hulshoff, Environmental Technologies to treat Sulfur Pollution, Principles and Engineering, IWA Publishing, London, 2000, p. 547. [9] R.E. Speece, Anaerobic Biotechnology for Industrial Wastewaters, Archae Press, Nashville, TN, USA, 1996. [10] C. Caumette, Ecology and physiology of phototrophic bacteria and sulfate-reducing bacteria in marine salterns, Experientia 49 (1993), pp. 473–481. [11] B.K. Rajbhandari and C. Annachhatre, Modelling response of nitrifying biofilm to inhibitory shock loads, Water Sci. Technol. 50 (2004), pp. 53–60. [12] D.J. Bastone, J. Keller, S.V. Kalyuzhnyi, S.G. Pavlostathis, A. Rozzi, W.T.M. Sanders, H. Siegrist, and V.A. Vavilin, Anaerobic Digestion Model No.1 (ADM1), Scientific and Technical Report No.13, IWA, London, 2002. [13] O. Bernard, Mass Balance Modelling of Bioprocesses, Mathematical Control Theory, INRIA, Comore, France, 2001. [14] V. Fedorovich, P. Lens, and S.V. Kalyuzhnyi, Extension of anaerobic digestion model no.1 with processes of sulfate reduction, Applied Biochem. Biotechnol. 109 (2003), pp. 33–45. [15] B.E. Rittman and P.L. McCarty, Environmental Biotechnology, Principles and applications, McGraw-Hill International Editions, New York, 2001, p. 755. [16] M. Henze, M.C.N. van Loosdrecht, G.A. Ekama, and D. Brdjanovic, Biological Wastewater Treatment: Principles, Modelling and Design, IWA Publishing, London, 2008, p. 455. [17] N. J. Kim, M. Hirai, and M. Shoda, Comparison of organic and inorganic carriers in removal of hydrogen sulfide in biofilters. Environ. Technol. 19 (1998), pp. 1233– 1241. [18] S. K. Patidar and V. Tare, Effect of molybdate on methanogenic and sulfidogenic activity of biomass, Bioresour. Technol. 96 (2004), pp. 1215–1222.

As Table 6 illustrates, SRB activity ranged between 19.42 and 188.78 mgSO2− reduced .gVSS−1 .d−1 , correspond4 ing to the initial concentrations of sulphate, which ranged between 260 and 2775 mg.l−1 . These values are, in fact, comparable to those previously reported in the literature, such as those described by Patidar and Tare [18] where the bioreduction of sulphate was noted to vary between 40 and 190 mgSO4reduced .gVSS−1 .d−1 . The activity recorded for PSB was slightly higher than that of SRB, varying between 60.64 and 315.44 mgSO2− produced .gVSS−1 .d−1 . This suggested that 4 PSB were able to overcome SRB by oxidizing all sulphurs produced during the sulphate-reducing process. In fact, only a few studies are currently available in the literature on the kinetics of sulphur oxidation with PSB. These include the work by Harerimana et al. [3] where the oxidation of dissolved H2 S by PSB in fed-batch reactors and the specific oxidation rates of PSB in the fed-batch cultures were determined to be 301–767 mgH2 Soxidized .gVSS−1 .d−1 . Although slightly lower, the values recorded for PSB activity in the present study remain comparable to those previously reported in the literature. Conclusion Both sulphate-reducing and sulphur-oxidizing processes were studied in batch cultures at 30◦ C and pH 8 over a wide range of sulphate concentrations. The maximum specific rates of SRB and PSB contained in mixed culture were 188.78 mgSO4reduced .gVSS−1 .d−1 and 315.44 mgSO2− produced .gVSS−1 .d−1 , respectively. More4 over, the rate of PSB activity was noted to be twice as high as that of SRB. Accordingly, the findings indicate that PSB can be used effectively in fighting against odours. The most important environmental factors affecting the sulphur cycle in the waste stabilization pond are likely to be the availability of sulphate and light for SRB and PSB, respectively. Acknowledgements
The work was partially supported by CUD (Commission Universitaire pour le Dévéloppement) through the PIC (Projets interuniversitaires ciblés), Tunisia-Belgium.

[1] Y. Racault, Le lagunage naturel, les leçons tirées de 15 ans de pratique en France, Cemagref Editions, France, 1997.

Appendix 1. Petersen matrix of the anaerobic digestion model, including sulphate reduction and sulphur oxidation process in wastewater stabilization ponds (WSP). Component i j 1 2 Process Sc Disintegration Hydrolysis of 1 complex organic material Uptake of complex −1 organic material Uptake of acetate Uptake of hydrogen Uptake of acetate by SRB −1 1 Sac 2 Sh2 3 Sso4 4 SH 2S 5 Sch4 6 SIC 7 SIN 8 SH + Kdis Xc Khyd,c Xc 9 Rate (ρj , kg COD.m−3 .d−1 )

3 4 5 6

3.3 − 3.3Yc −1

3.3 − 3.3Yc 1 − Yac −1 Yac,so4 −1 1 − Yac,so4 0.25 − 0.25Yh2

1.4 − 1.65Yc 1 − Yac

1 − 1.65Yc −0.4Yac


Sc Xc kS,c + Sc

−(0.25 + −0.4Yh2 0.25Yh2 ) 2− 2Yac,so4 −0.4Yac,so4 2.4Yac,so4 − 2

Sac Xac I1 kS + Sac Sh2 Xh2 I2 km,h2 kS + Sh2 km,ac

Environmental Technology


Uptake of hydrogen by SRB


Yh2,so4 − 1 1 − Yh2,so4


−0.4Yh2,so4 2.4Yh2,so4 − 2

SSO4 KSO4 + SSO4 Sac × Xac,so4 Kac + Sac SSO4 km,SO4 KS,SO4 + SSO4 Sh2 × Xh2,so4 KS,h2 + Sh2 km,SO4 km,H 2S SH 2S KS,H 2S + SH 2S I × XPSB KI + I + Ki I 2


Growth of phototrophic sulphuroxidizing bacteria Decay of Xc Decay of Xac Decay of Xh2 Decay of Xac,SO4 Decay of Xh2,SO4 Decay of XPSB






9 10 11 12 13 14

Complex Total Hydrogen Sulphates Total sul- Methane Inorganic organic acetate phides gas (kgCOD gas carbon material (kgCOD (kgCOD (kgCOD m−3 ) (kgCOD gas m−3 ) m−3 ) m−3 ) m−3 ) (kmoleC m−3 )

Inorganic Methane gas (kgCOD nitrogen m−3 ) (kmoleN m−3 )

Kdec,Xc Xc Kdec,Xac Xac Kdec,Xh2 Xh2 Kdec,Xac,so4 Xac,so4 Kdec,Xh2,so4 Xh2,so4 Kdec,Xpsb XPSB I1 and I2 : inhibition factor I1 = IpH IIN , lim I2 = IpH IIN , lim INH 3,Xac I = light intensity



Appendix 2.

Petersen matrix of the anaerobic digestion model including sulphate reduction and sulphur oxidation process in WSP (suite). 1 Xac 2 Xh2 3 4 Xac,so4 5 Xh2,so4 Xpsb 6 Xi Kdis Xc Khyd,c Xc 7 Rate (ρj , kg COD.m−3 .d−1 )

Component i j Process Xc 1 Disintegration 2 Hydrolysis of complex organic material 3 Uptake of complex organic material 4 Uptake of acetate 5 Uptake of hydrogen 6 Uptake of acetate by SRB 7 Uptake of hydrogen by SRB 8 Growth of phototrophic sulphur oxidizing bacteria 9 10 11 12 13 14 Decay of Xcom Decay of Xac Decay of Xh2 Decay of Xac,SO4 Decay of Xh2,SO4 Decay of XPSB −1 1.65Yc

km,c 0.4Yac 0.1Yh2 0.4Yac,so4 0.4Yh2,so4 0.4

Sc Xc kS,c + Sc

Sac Xac I1 kS + Sac Sh2 km,h2 Xh2 I2 kS + Sh2 km,ac km,SO4 km,SO4 km,H 2S SSO4 Sac Xac,so4 KSO4 + SSO4 Kac + Sac SSO4 Sh2 Xh2,so4 KS,SO4 + SSO4 KS,h2 + Sh2 SH 2S I XPSB KS,H 2S + SH 2S KI + I + Ki I 2

C. Harerimana et al.




−1 Sulphates reducing (kgCOD m−3 )

Complex organic Acetate Hydrogen Sulphates degraders degraders degraders reducing (KgCPD m−3 ) (kgCOD (kgCOD (kgCOD m−3 ) m−3 ) m−3 )

Kdec,Xc Xc Kdec,Xac Xac Kdec,Xh2 Xh2 Kdec,Xac,so4 Xac,so4 Kdec,Xh2,so4 Xh2,so4 −1 Kdec,Xsob Xpsb Sulphur Particulate inerts I1 and I2 : inhibition factor oxydation gas (kmoleC m−3 ) I1 = IpH IIN , lim I2 = IpH IIN , lim INH 3,Xac I = light intensity

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Position Paper

...Position paper From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia A position paper is an essay that presents an opinion about an issue, typically that of the author or another specified entity; such as a political party. Position papers are published in academia, in politics, in law and other domains. Position papers range from the simplest format of a letter to the editor through to the most complex in the form of an academic position paper. Position papers are also used by large organizations to make public the official beliefs and recommendations of the group. In academia Position papers in academia enable discussion on emerging topics without the experimentation and original research normally present in an academic paper. Commonly, such a document will substantiate the opinions or positions put forward with evidence from an extensive objective discussion of the topic. In politics Position papers are most useful in contexts where detailed comprehension of another entity's views is important; as such, they are commonly used by political campaigns, government organizations, in the diplomatic world, and in efforts to change values (e.g. through public service announcements) and organisational branding. They are also an important part of the Model United Nations process. In government, a position paper lies somewhere between a white paper and a green paper in that they affirm definite opinions and propose solutions but may not go so far as detailing specific plans for......

Words: 1657 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...------------------------------------------------- ABSTRACT: ------------------------------------------------- This paper explores the issue of early marriage in Africa. It sheds light ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- specifically on reason behind its perpetuation, its harmful consequences, shows how it ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- constitutes a barrier to education and enjoyment of girl’s human rights and how it ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- further threatens the development of countries. ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- The findings from an extensive reading of materials related to early marriage ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- suggest that early marriage is due to various factors including among others, ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- the search for economic survival,protection of young girls, peer group and ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- family pressure, controlling female behavior and sexuality, wars and......

Words: 1232 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Labor and Rights Violations

...Labor and Rights Violations MGM366 October 17, 2011 Abstract This paper will cover child labor violations as well as human rights violations, I will address each topic and then give my personal opinion about what I think about the subject and what legal recourse might be readily available to remedy the situation. Labor/Rights Violations Human rights and labor violations have and will continue worldwide due to the extenuating needs of individuals to care for their families and the greed of the everyday businessman to save or turn an easy dollar. These violations are not only found in third world countries as the United States is just as guilty when it comes to hiring children to carry out work that is often unsafe and illegal. Although many view child labor and human rights violations as a scourge plaguing the business field, some of the people that choose or are forced into such unfair practices do it as a means to help support the family unit or to try and make it out of the belly of poverty. United States (Child Labor) In May 2008 a Kosher meatpacking plant was raided by the state labor investigators and found to have 57 underage workers, some as young as 13 all illegal immigrants from Guatemala working in their plant. The workers were forced to work up to 17 hours a day often without overtime pay, being exposed to chemicals and being forced to use saws and knives which according to Iowa law are prohibited......

Words: 1305 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Global Ethical Problems

...Global Ethical Problems Donna Bistrican XMGT/216 September 25, 2010 Global Ethical Problems The Wall Street article reports on the ethical issue of freedom of speech and human rights violation in China and Google’s dilemma. Companies deal with ethical conflicts with China daily. Google Inc.’s struggled with ethical implications for doing business with China. The paper addresses the ethical problems that companies like Google, Inc. encountered that caused their decision to withdraw from China. The paper will show how Vietnam covered up corruption, freedom of speech, transparency, and supply chain ethical issues. Big companies continue to draw criticism for accommodating governments and compromise their ethical or moral standards. Companies have an enormous opportunity in China to make a bigger profit by doing business in China. The organization cannot assume that Chinese do business the same way Americans do. To do business in China a company has to follow government directives. Chinese want to do business with people they trust. Terms on contracts will not mean the same thing to them as they do to Americans. Chinese businesses do not feel they are bound to contracts. In America a company competes with 100’s of business but in China, you are competing with globally. Google Inc’s announce in Beijing their decision to withdraw from China after ethical implications of hacking into the privacy of Google’s users. Google had to limit the excess of information on the search......

Words: 1514 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Animal Test

...Opinion paper draft People Should Not Keep Pets More and more people keep pets in recent years. From a broader perspective, people should not keep pets. This paper will clarify four reasons why people should not keep pets. The issue of whether should keep pets has been extensively debated and remains relentless. According to research, there are 29.8 percents of people who keep pets in China, nearly 50 percents of people keep pets in Europe, and almost 60 percents of people keep pets in the United States (Soltanizadeh 83-94). The topic of keeping pets becomes a international topic. With the increase of number of animals kept at home, more and more people stated that people should not keep pets (Soltanizadeh 83-94). In this paper, I will present arguments in support of the topic that people should not keep pets. There are three reasons. Keeping pets not only wastes resources, but also increase the risk of health of the animals and people. And it is a violation of animal rights. My counter argument is people should keep pets because it adds to the quality of life of both the owner and the animal. There are mainly three reasons why people should not keep pets. Firstly, keeping of pets results in a huge drain on resources that could be put to better use. (Rebekah 525-537). For examples, pets are costly to keep in time, money and energy. As well as the cost to owners in food, vet’s bills and the time spent cleaning and exercising. Secondly, keeping pets is...

Words: 1254 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Human Trafficking

...two-three sentence summary the source’s main point and identifying key expert views or evidence which will help support specific points in your outline. Human Trafficking in the United States of America I.Introduction I’ve chosen to cover this topic because now more than ever news specials are being broadcast and even though each story as similar as the next they’re very captivating. The statistics on this issue is overwhelming and it involves just about every type of criminal act known. It’s become an absolute phenomenon in the United States of America. Criminal Justice entails the following in a criminal activity; gathering evidence, apprehending the accused, conducting a trial, making defense, judgment after proving the crime and eventually punishment. There are many crimes that deserve criminal justice (, 2004-2007). Human trafficking which is nothing more than modern day slavery is just one of many heavy crimes that deserve it. II. Body A. Trafficking doesn't happen in other parts of the world somewhere else; sufferers of trafficking are right here in the United States, suffering horrendous human rights infringements. The United States did not set in motion the monitoring of trafficked individuals until 1994; it began being covered in the Department’s Annual Country Reports on Human Rights Practices (, 2009). Numerous laws have been passed against it in the United States, and the U.S. has been dynamic in advocating......

Words: 1380 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Position Paper on the Proposed Ordinance

...POSITION PAPER ON THE PROPOSED ORDINANCE Human rights standards prohibit all forms of corporal punishment. Hitting people violates their fundamental rights to respect for their physical integrity and human dignity, as set forth in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Children are people too and equal holders of human rights. This is confirmed in the United Nations Convention on the Right of the Child, the first international instrument to require protection of children from “all forms of physical or mental violence” (article 19). The Committee on the Rights of the Child, Treaty Body for the Conventions, has consistently interpreted it as requiring condemnation and prohibition of all corporal punishment, in the home, in schools, in institutions, in alternative care system and in all other settings. Corporal punishment is defined as the deliberate infliction of pain and suffering, including humiliating or degrading punishments and other forms of violence against children in order to change their behavior or to punish them. It consists of acts that are intended to inflict physical or emotional pain on the children because of an offense that they have committed. It usually pertains to the use of physical force with the intention of causing some degree of pain or discomfort no matter how light. However, there are other non-physical forms of punishment that are equally cruel and reprehensible. These......

Words: 1518 - Pages: 7

Free Essay


...ethical dilemma that zoos pose regarding animals’ rights, freedoms and natural behavior. Many people consider zoos amoral and cruel while others have the notion that they are ethical because they help in research, conservation and proper treatment of wild animals. This sensitive topic has induced different reactions and sparked great debates as people strive to do the right thing. According to Tuyl (2008), Zoos are enclosed spaces and cages that abode animals. Hutchins and Keele (2006), argue that, zoos provide excellent conditions for wild animals, as they are liberated from their natural habitats, which are harsh and unforgiving. They argue that wild animals are better placed in the zoos because they are provided with free meals and a life that is free from parasites, and harsh weather and predators. However, there are various reasons that explain why zoos are unethical. This paper explains why zoos are unethical to animals. To confine wild animals in enclosed spaces, denies them freedom and the ability to develop their natural behaviors. In addition, zoos promote the transmission of zoonotic diseases (Tuyl, 2008). Therefore, concerning animal rights and freedoms, zoos are highly unethical and should be banned to endow wild animals with an opportunity to lead lives free from human interferences. It is amoral to keep animals in the zoos because they act as cages that retract the wild animals’ freedom. Various animal rights organizations advocate for the freedom of......

Words: 742 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...Argumentative Research Paper Preventing immigration because of nationalism and racism is a violation of human rights. Immigration has become the topic of many legal and political discussions. Not a very long time ago, approximately 80 years, some countries, because of their nationalist and racist ideologies tried to stop immigration and even implemented racial cleansing, while others defended immigrant rights against the ideas of pure-blood and xenophobic insanity. Actually this case has not closed yet. The majority of governments still refuse to accept immigration as a human right. Standards for immigrants are generally very poor; they do not share the equal rights of the citizens of the country. While some countries have some laws and regulations to solve this problem, generally most nations are not welcoming of immigrants. Preventing immigration because of nationalism and racism is a violation of human rights. Xenophobia is a fear of anything or anyone that is strange or unknown. Many nations’ immigration policies are based upon xenophobia, and this has come to inform policies and attitudes of nationalism. Jeong (2013) defines nationalism “as a feeling of superiority and contempt for foreigners’’ and in his study he describes the effects of national feelings on immigration. Jeong claims there is a connection between restricted immigration and high levels of nationalism. For instance, many US citizens have concerns about whether there will be anyone called......

Words: 1087 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Animal Rights

...Animal Rights in Medical Research As the declaration of human right states that all human beings are free and equal in dignity and rights. The issue of whether or not to grant animal rights such as those that humans have is greatly disputed over years, but without success. Animal right is an extremely complicated issue that involves the question of animal intellect, animal rights groups, and the pros and cons of granting animals their rights. I have worked with and observed chimpanzees in early 2000 in a research lab in Alamogordo, NM as an animal caretaker and seen how these primates communicate with each other. I feel this subject is very important and I will be sharing my reflections, thoughts and experiences in this paper. Researchers all over the world, who have studied primates argue that these animals hold the capacity to communicate. The researchers go on to describe that a communication barrier is all that separates humans from animals. Chimpanzees are more superior on using their hand and feet than humans. I observed them using their hand to peel bananas, use hands and feet to swing, open doors and even had a water faucet sticking out of the wall with a button that they pressed to drink water. I also got a chance to see a chimp using sign language. This particular chimp in his early life was on TV and commercials, can walk upright, and was harmless. His owner decided to part ways due to the chimp’s age and turned him over to the research facility. They can...

Words: 758 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Title Ix Court Case

...Court Case Research on Title IX Court Case FIRST M. SURNAME INSTITUTIONAL AFFLIATION TITLE IX Court Case Introduction Title IX is a part of the Education Amendments of 1972. The amendment protects the citizens from discrimination from academic programs on the basis of their gender(Carpenter & Acosta, 2005). It provides that persons of either gender can be granted an opportunity in any education program within taking into consideration their gender. Title IX protects all the students enrolled in government sponsored institutions from discrimination. As much as the code of Civil Rights caters for the protection against such there are still areas where discrimination can arise (Boland, 2002).. For instance, enrollment in some degree programs or some sporting activities might be based on discriminating nature. The Amendments also guard the student against sexual harassment. This paper will look at the process of filing a Title IX lawsuit. It will analyze based on a sample case study on how to overcome the case based on the current provision of the Education Amendments as well as other relevant laws that pertain to that case. It will observe the consequences of the outcome of the case to the participants of the case. The evaluation will consider all the other external factors that are involved in the process of the filing process and representation in the court of law. Statement of the Court Case The case to be analyzed for the purposes of this paper involves......

Words: 1536 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...Globalization and Religion Abstract In this paper I will explain how globalization is very beneficial from an economic and business point of view. Globalization can be argued as a tool for economic growth, advancement and prosperity through co-operation between the developed and developing countries. The pro-globalization critics argue that the benefits that globalization brings to developing nations surpasses or outcasts the negative impacts caused by globalization and may even go a step further to state that it is the only source of hope for developing nations to prosper and stand out. However, the real question to be asked is as to what extent are the positives argued upon without taking into account the negative aspects of globalization towards developing countries. There are many developing countries benefiting or even prospering from globalization Therefore, my paper will dispute that the growth and advancement provided by globalization to developing countries is beneficial in short-term, but in the long-run, it will only bring upon negative impacts and challenges due to the obstacles involved such as exploitation of labor and resources, higher increase in poverty, and effects of multi-national corporations on local businesses and the economy, and to an extent the effects on the developing country itself.  One of many negative effects that comes with globalization on developing countries is exploitation of labor. With a competitive global market, inflation, and......

Words: 1028 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ethics in Management

...Individual Paper: Evaluation of Business Code Ethics Francisco Pacheco PHL/323 - ETHICS IN MANAGEMENT September 9, 2012 Donna Falloon Individual Paper: Evaluation of Business Code Ethics In the business world, every company, large or small, has a set of guidelines and standards that describe a person’s expected behavior at the work area. Everyone, including employers, must follow these regulations because it describes organizational expectations for all employees. Business organizations often develop several different policies, rules and guidelines for administering their business. Code of ethics and guidelines do not exist to govern all behaviors, but just enough so that everyone can harmoniously work together while at the same time being productive so that the business or organization can prosper. There are many big and small companies in the business world, and they all have a set of code of ethics that help to establish order and integrity. Even one of the largest oil companies in the world, Shell, has a code of conduct and ethics. They share core values and honesty, integrity and respect for everyone in their foundation and are required to conduct their affairs in accordance with those same principals. Shell Code of Conduct provides basic rules, standards and behaviors that are necessary to achieve the agenda. They are expressed clearly and concise for all their employees on a number of enterprise-wide risk areas and employees are reminded to remember that......

Words: 1205 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

"Terrorist Activity" in Austria

...People's Friendship University of Russia Department of International Relations Student: Stefan Unertl Student-ID: 1032115182 Research paper „Terrorist activity“ in Austria The Association Against Animal Factories (VgT – Verein gegen Tierfabriken) and its struggle for animal rights by Stefan Unertl Moscow, December 2011 Table of content 1. Introduction 2. The Association Against Animal Factories (AAAF) and its activities in Austria and 2.1. The AAAF against Kleiderbauer 3. The trial 4. Outcome/Conclusion 1. Introduction The Association Against Animal Factories is a non-governmental organization which is active not only in Austria but also in Switzerland and has good connections to the worldwide animal rights association, PeTa. Its main goal is to improve animal rights in Austria. Their work is dedicated to the reduction of exploitation or abuse of animals. Due to their ongoing activities, the association has to face many difficulties in Austria. Not only that their actions of protest are supervised by the police but also that every organization, like an NGO, can be convicted as a “criminal organization” based upon the paragraph 278a in the Austrian criminal code when this organization is supposed to commit frequently acts of violence or has a structure resembling it to a criminal organization (Mafia, etc.). Due to this vague article it had been criticized by many people not only in politics but also in the population. The first time this article gained......

Words: 1352 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Principles

...Ethical Principles Paper Joe Garcia PSY/305 June 29, 2016 Dr. Christa Branton Ethical Principles According to the American Psychological Association (2016), “in psychology, APA’s Ethical Principles of Psychologists lays out the standards of psychologist and identifies behaviors that deserve punishment” (Ethics). It also identifies the Ethical principles issues, issues that have been violated, diversity implications that are involved, and strategies to mitigate those ethical issues. The Issue “Some people behave in a certain way because they don’t think they’ll be caught, whereas others know the difference between right and wrong and do what’s right even if they can get away with it” (Landrum & Davis, 2016, "Ethical Issues for Psychology Majors"). According to several studies done throughout the nation, approximately 40 to 60 percent of college students self-reported that they have cheated at least once during their college career. Over 50 percent of that number stated they cheated regularly (Landrum & Davis, p. 163, 2016). Colleges and Universities have a hard time legislating ethical behavior even with set academic dishonesty policies and honor codes in place. According to Landrum & Davis (2016), “Cheating is a short-term solution that leads to bigger problems” (p. 164). I agree with Landrum & Davis’ statement. You can only so as to say “wing it” for so......

Words: 1122 - Pages: 5