Premium Essay

Resistance to Organizational Change: Linking Research and Practices

In: Business and Management

Submitted By annana
Words 3094
Pages 13
Dennis G. Erwin studied critical factors influencing individual resistance to organizational change based on the literature review of the previous studies. The main objective of the current study is to give some directions to change agents and management team in the organization in order to effectively manage the resistance to change. The selected studies that the author used as the literature review combined a variety of organizational types in both different regional context and change environment.
According to the previous studies, the author categorized resistance to change into three dimensions which included behavioural, cognitive and affective dimensions. Firstly, the behavioural dimension works with the way each individual reacts against the change implementation. This behavior can be shown in either positive or negative way of resistance when he or she responses to change. In this respect, this might depend on the degree of individuals’ receptivity (‘readiness’), readiness (active or passive), openness (covert or overt) and support (supportive or resistant) to change initiatives.
Secondly, the cognitive dimension involves each individual’s attitude toward the change. According to his study based on those findings, change commitment and evaluations can lead to negative cognitive attitudes toward change. It’s not quite clear whether he mentioned the commitment from management team in the organization or employee commitment, and it’s about the evaluations from previous or current change implementation.
Lastly, an individual might resist change initiatives in the form of their feelings toward the change which was defined as the affective dimension. This kind of emotions can be shown through his or her uncertainty at individual, group and even organizational level both prior change and during change implementation (). Such an uncertainty concerns job...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Practice of Human Services Across Different Cultures

...Running head: PRACTICE OF HUMAN SERVICES ACROSS DIFFERENT CULTURES AND POPULATIONS Practice of Human Services across Different Cultures and Populations Walden University Practice of Human Services across Different Cultures and Populations In today’s society, demographics and cultural factors has caused organizations to facilitate change. The changing of new organizational patterns are definitely needed due to the increase in the American cultural patterns, (Carter, 2000). “Typically organizational literature dealt with how diversity, rather than cultural patterns, may influence corporate culture. Although organization scholars have paid attention to issues concerning diversity, less attention has been paid to examining the influence of dominant American patterns upon organization,” (Carter, 2000). Upon my completion at Walden University, I hope to become a Child and Family Counselor. As human service professionals, it is important that you are competent and aware of your client’s culture. According to the Department of Health and Human Services, “Child welfare workers can improve their practice with children, youth, and families by increasing their knowledge and appreciation of different cultures,” (US Dept. of Health and Human Services, 2013). An organizations knowledge on an individual’s culture and climate can help to influence social structure. As defined, “organizational culture refers to the shared norms, beliefs, and behavioral expectations that drive behavior and...

Words: 905 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Project Management

...Discuss the models of change management and using one change model, show how an organization you know introduced change successfully. Highlight how resistance to change was managed Table of Contents INTRODUCTION 3 CHANGE MANAGEMENT 3 ESSENCE OF CHANGE MANAGEMENT 4 Attributes of Successful change management 5 CHANGE MANAGEMENT MODELS 5 1. LEWIN’S CHANGE MANAGEMENT MODEL 5 2. MCKINSEY 7S MODEL 8 Advantages of McKinsey 7-S Model 10 Disadvantages of McKinsey 7-S Model 10 3. KOTTER’S 8 STEP CHANGE MODEL 10 Advantages 14 Disadvantages 14 4. Action Research Model 14 5. The positive model 16 6. ADKAR Change Management Model 17 Transition of WWF Kenya Country Office to WWF KENYA (National office) using Action Research Model 19 Resistance to change 22 Types of resistance to change 22 Management of resistance to change 23 References 24 INTRODUCTION CHANGE MANAGEMENT Organizational development (OD) is a field of study that addresses change and how it affects organizations and the individuals within those organizations. Effective organizational development can assist organizations and individuals to cope with change. Change is the vein that keeps an organization alive and change management can make or break the organization. Change management is technical term for the approach to change organizations, teams or/and individuals from their current state to desired future state. Change management can also be described as an...

Words: 6952 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Equity and Rewards

...conclusions. This report will discuss High Commitment/High Performance (HCHP), both of which theorise high levels of autonomy and discretion but both theorise different mechanisms. HCM is said to be the vehicle to HPM and emphases ’soft’ aspects of HRM such as job security, trust, and a strong psychological contract whereas HPM emphasises ‘hard’ aspects of HRM such as restructuring, performance related pay by linking employee effectiveness towards organisational performance. The premise behind HPWS according to Ramsay et al (2000) entails management ceding a degree of control to the workers, thereby attaining the commitment and motivation of the workers through specific ‘bundles’ or ‘systems’ of HRM practices that are mutually supportive and reinforcing, thereby creating a competitive advantage and enhanced organisational success’ (MacDuffie 1994). Basically, the argument is, that while individual practices – for example, self managing teams, total quality management (TQM), performance-based pay systems – might be beneficial in their own right, suites of practices that are mutually consistent will deliver performance outcomes greater...

Words: 1157 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Resistance to Change, Annotated Bib

...Resistance to Change John Caudill Webster University MNGT 5590 Dr. Kevin Henson Abstract The topic I researched was organizational change. My search criteria were limited to ABI/Inform, for peer-reviewed, full text documents, and scholarly journals. I didn’t have a specific time frame. However, most of the articles are within the last 5 years. Some of the search keywords used was organizational change, organizational behavior, and resistance to change. The results of the article analysis found that organizational change is a very complex process. Leaders, managers, change managers and employees have a lot of factors to consider and find solutions for in order for a change to be successful. Some of the common reasons that caused changes to fail are; employee’s attitudes, lack of employee empowerment, forcing employees to change the status quo, employees felt threatened by the change, perceived loss of jobs, new boss, new responsibilities, employees don’t understand the intent of the change, change doesn’t make sense, past experiences and group dynamics play a part. Resistance can be overt or covert. The differences in value congruence and organizational culture of small working groups, the individual and the organization as a whole must also be considered. In order for the change to be a success the leaders must study, analyze, and develop the plan around these conditions. The plan has to be well thought out, the intent and goals understood by the......

Words: 4699 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Erp Implementation

...SYSTEMS Change Management: Best Practice Strategies for ERP Implementation By: Andrew Handoko 1601226176 LC11-LEC BINUS UNIVERSITY 2015 ABSTRACT The implementation of Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems, have become more complex and crucial in information systems infrastructure within large organizations. However, most of these large companies deal with common people issues. Their potential users across different departments of organization resist the implementation process for some reasons. Enterprise units are being lack of communication from top management to functional units within implementation project. As a result, companies are struggle for ERP systems practice as well as to get rid of worker’s social problem and infrastructure’s transitions from old system to a new system. Ultimately, a successful ERP implementation projects are less about technology and more focus on people and process. Change Management is the best practice for “critical success factor” in ERP implementation literature. The purpose of this research is to have a better understanding about how change management is essential to be a part of ERP implementation process. This paper describes the main success factor of Change Management in order to create a successful ERP implementation and how should organizational change be managed. KEYWORDS Change Strategies, Enterprise Resource Planning, Resistance, Organizational Change, ERP, Implementation Strategies, Business Process,......

Words: 5283 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay


...Organization Management Journal Linking Theory & Practice: EAM White Papers Series 2006 Vol. 3, No. 3, 210-231 © 2006 Eastern Academy of Management ISSN 1541-6518 Effective Empowerment in Organizations GARY A. YUKL University at Albany WENDY S. BECKER University at Albany Psychological empowerment is the perception that workers can help determine their own work roles, accomplish meaningful work, and influence important decisions. Empowerment has been studied from different perspectives, including employee perceptions, leadership behaviors, and management programs. Despite positive rhetoric, programs designed to increase empowerment seldom achieve the benefits promised. Inconclusive and seemingly contradictory outcomes stem from the fact that few companies give employees significant control and access to management information. A half century of research suggests that empowerment strategies can offer real benefits. We outline facilitating conditions for effective empowerment, including characteristics of organizations, leaders, employees, and the work itself. Keywords: Empowerment, Leadership, Teams, Power Sharing Effective Empowerment in Organizations Psychological empowerment in organizations is the perception by members that they have the opportunity to help determine work roles, accomplish meaningful work, and influence important decisions. Over the past several decades an interest in empowerment can be seen in many subject areas within......

Words: 9742 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

Resistance to Change

...Abstract Resistance to organisational change is seen as one of the impediments to organisational expansion and growth due to its negative repercussions. This study therefore sought to investigate the factors that influence resistance to or- ganisational change at Oti-Yeboah Complex Limited. De- scriptive survey design was adopted to collect information using stratified sampling and self-administered question- naires. Descriptive statistics, bi-variate correlation, regres- sion analysis and t-test were used to analyse the data. The results indicated that less employee participation in deci- sion making and lack of trust in management contributed highly to resistance at Oti-Yeboah Complex Limited. In addition, factors such as lack of motivation, poor chan- nels of communication, and information exchange also contributed to resistance. The study suggests that manage- ment should encourage employee participation in decision making, build confidence, accept constructive criticism, be transparent and communicate clearly the need for change to employees. INTRODUCTION Organisations operate within an increasingly volatile environment and are in a state of constant change. The pressure to change stems from a variety of internal and external sources such as political, economic, social and technological factors (Boojihawon & Segal-Horn, 2006). Leana and Barry (2000) posit that organizational change is aimed at adapting to the environment,......

Words: 8122 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management, private study or research. Large-scale change initiatives often col/apse under the weight of their own complexity. To bring order to the chaos, organize the effort into three coordinated campaigns: political} marketing) and military. ~am for by Larry Hirschhorn al an • try to change organizations. Few succeed. And as most executives who have lived through change initiatives will admit, fewer still want to try again. Who can blame them for their reluctance? The process is terribly painful, the logistics are enormously complex, the organization wants deeply not to change-and the success rate is abysmal. Yet most organizations must change, and change profoundly, if they're to stay alive. It's the oldest cliche in the book, and it's also true. The good news is that organizational change is not as hard to pull off as people think. It's tough, but it's not impossible, and it can be systematized. As a researcher and consultant, I've been involved in many change initiatives at scores of companies over the past 15 years, and I've come to believe that the low rate of success has more to do with execution than with fundamental conceptualization. Most of the failures I've witnessed occurred because the intricacies of execution overwhelmed the initiatives' sponsors. The change programs that did work ANY EXECUTIVES M had one thing in common: They were managed as discrete projects, not as monolithic efforts. Successful change agents I've observed employ...

Words: 4730 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

War on Terrorism

...EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Driven by the need for organizational change, management accounting techniques have developed and proliferated at an unprecedented rate in the last few decades. Some critics, however, have charged that the changes are a "reinvention of the wheel" every few years. To put these issues in perspective, let's look at a framework created to illustrate the distinctive nature of these techniques in an organizational change context. The framework considers such factors as user resistance and organizational culture that can influence the applicability and implementation success of the techniques. After tracing the history of management accounting beginning in 1850, accounting scholar Robert S. Kaplan comments, "Despite considerable change in the nature of organizations and the dimensions of competition during the past 60 years, there has been little innovation in the design and implementation of cost accounting and management control systems." (1) All the practices employed by companies and described in management accounting textbooks had apparently been developed by 1925, despite major changes in the nature and operations of organizations. To develop the field of managerial accounting, Kaplan and others encouraged academics to conduct field research and case studies "to describe and document the innovative practices that seem to work for successful companies." (2) The pendulum swung in the other direction over the next decade as a plethora of new "techniques"......

Words: 3080 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Adoption of Tqm in Project Organisations in Kenya

...ORIGIN OF THE QUALITY MOVEMENT 4. EVOLUTION OF TQM 5. THE CONCEPT OF INNOVATION, DIFFUSION AND ADOPTION IN MANAGEMENT 6. IMPLICATIONS FOR TQM ADOPTION IN ORGANIZATIONS 7. A CASE OF KENYA WILDLIFE SERVICES 8. A CASE OF THERMAL POWER PLANTS IN KENYA 9. CONCLUSION 10. REFERENCES Abstract In the global marketplace, there is increasing competition among producers and marketers of goods and services, so that the focus for competitive advantage has come to be on quality. An attempt to improve quality in organizations has led to the advancement of the management philosophy called total quality management (TQM). The service sector is getting competitive every day. In order to be successful Quality Management (QM) practices ought to be the integral part of any organization’s strategic management. Kenya’s national parks form the pillar of the country’s tourism industry. Over one million international tourists visit Kenya annually to partake in wildlife safari and other forms of nature-based tourism. Implementation of TQM principles has a strong impact on an organization’s performance. There is a significant statistical relationship between TQM principles and quality and hence overall...

Words: 3920 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Implementing Strategies - Management and Operations Issues Ch 07

...|Policies | | |Resource Allocation | | |Managing Conflict | | |Matching Structure with Strategy | | |Restructuring, Reengineering, and E-Engineering | | |Linking Performance and Pay to Strategies | | |Managing Resistance to Change | | |Creating a Strategy-Supportive Culture | | |Production/Operations Concerns When Implementing Strategies | | |Human Resource Concerns When Implementing Strategies | CHAPTER OBJECTIVES After studying this chapter, you should be able to do the following: |1. |Explain why strategy implementation is more......

Words: 6208 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay


...wants to compete effectively and globally, Todays Companies need to realize that they longer have is now essential to be knowledgeable about and be able to communicate with people of different nationalities cultures and religions. Corporation realizes that they must embrace that diversity in the workplace brings. What is Work place Diversity Workplace diversity refers to the variety of differences between people in an organization. That means diversity encompasses race, gender, culture, ethnic group, age, personality, cognitive style, tenure, organizational function, education, background and more. Diversity not only involves how people perceive themselves, but how they perceive others. Those perceptions affect their interactions. For a wide assortment of employees to function effectively as an organization, human resource professionals need to deal effectively with issues such as communication, adaptability and change. Diversity will increase significantly in the coming years. Successful organizations recognize the need for immediate action and are ready and willing to...

Words: 1397 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Term Paper - Information Technology Strategic Plan

...CIS500 Information Systems for Decision-Making Term Paper - Information Technology Strategic Plan April 12, 2015 1. Write an introductory statement of the company including but not limited to the type of the company, the location, the industry in which it competes, and the organizational vision and mission that encompasses the nature of the company. Being the largest not-for-profit Catholic healthcare system serving the Delaware Valley, Mercy Health System is part of Trinity Health and sponsored by Catholic Health Ministries. Their mission is to serve in the spirit of the Gospel, which means serving the entire community with compassion and healing presence while addressing the diverse factors that impact the health needs of the whole person. Even though they treat people from all walks of life, they have a special concern for the poor and disadvantaged. The goal of Mercy Health System is to be recognized as the leader in improving the health of the community and everyone they serve. Currently, they employ approximately 6,500 caring, highly skilled personnel who are focused on creating positive patient-care. Mercy Health System is a diverse, integrated system that embodies: Four Hospitals acute care hospitals: | Mercy Fitzgerald Hospital | A 213-bed teaching hospital in Delaware County and Southwest Philadelphia | | Mercy Philadelphia Hospital | A 268-bed community teaching hospital serving the needs of West and Southwest Philadelphia communities | |...

Words: 3162 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

A Critique of the Identities of Middle Manager

...controversial role of middle managers Middle management is the intermediate management in organisational hierarchies, are responsible for implementing the executive management’s policies and plans and above the lower levels of junior staff (Uyterhoeven, 1972). Although there is a coincident definition of middle management, the controversial performance of middle management has been discussed in many literatures. Following the definition of middle management, middle managers should have skills that receive strategic plan from top manager and deploy it successfully by control over junior staff (Harding et al., 2014). However, they have not been considered part of the strategy process (Floyd & Wooldridge, 1992). They just like ‘a passive linking pin’, doubtfully carry out the instructions of the top managers and fully implement throughout the organisation (Rouleau & Balogun, 2007). The prescriptive responsibilities of middle mangers are considered a kind of top-down strategic management. Traditional management style can reduce productivity and cause bottlenecks, since the power was centralised. Instead, bottom-up approach is increasingly popular because it empowers employees to think more creatively. Therefore, middle-level...

Words: 1279 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Macro Economics

...Effective HR systems: The impact of organizational climate and organizational strategy on strategic behaviour Industrial and Organizational Psychology Bachelor Thesis Student: Ludwig Fritzsch 0095605 Docents: Prof. Dr. Karin Sanders Drs. Ivy Goedegebure University of Twente Enschede, 30th of July 2009 Preface Within my bachelor education in industrial and organizational psychology at the University of Twente, I conducted this research and immersed myself into relevant scientific literature to build a theoretic basis for my topic, the impact of organizational strategy and climate on strategic employee behaviours. This paper presents the final assignment of the bachelor degree in psychology and is solely written by the author. The introduction part consists mainly of a screening and elaboration on prior scholar’s work. Data from five companies were gathered collectively with other students. At this place my thanks go especially to the employees of the company Nedap N.V. for participating in my research. Nedap inspired my a lot. Furthermore my thanks go to my fellow students for their efforts to find companies to participate. Abstract This paper investigates which configurations of organizational climate and organisational strategy lead to strategic employee behaviour which is crucial for organizations to reach their goals. Based on literature research and empirical research in five companies in the technical sector in the......

Words: 10942 - Pages: 44