Free Essay

Resource-Based Theory

In: Business and Management

Submitted By abcABC
Words 1164
Pages 5
In the perfectly competitive market, firms cannot sustain the long-term profitability as the entrance of potential competitors can drive down the price to the point where economic profits are zero. But in reality, some firms persistently enjoy profits that are higher than its rivals. Resource-based theory (RBV) is used to explain this phenomenon by stating that ‘the unique bundle of resources that some firms have obtained help to shape the firms’ value-creating strategies which are implemented to gain a competitive advantage’. This essay will firstly examine the characteristics of the resources which are the basis of a competitive advantage, then analyze the isolation mechanism which help to maintain firms’ competitive advantage. Finally limitations of this theory will be discussed.

According to McGahan and Porter’s research, 31.71% of the factor influencing business profitability is suggested to be firms’ resources and capabilities. These resources and capabilities have to be heterogeneous and imperfectly mobile because they can be inherently non-tradable, firm-specific, and co-specialized. Moreover, resources should fulfill VRIN criteria to enjoy a competitive advantage and sustainable performance. Firstly, resources must be valuable enabling a firm to exploit opportunities and neutralize threats by improving its efficiency and effectiveness. Secondly, resources must be difficult to find among the existing and potential competitors of the firm. Hence resources must be rare or unique to offer competitive advantages. Additionally, resources should be inimitable, which means other firms either cannot obtain them or have to obtain them at a much higher costs. Fourthly, key resources need to be non-substitutable. If not, competitors will use strategically equivalent substitutes for these resources to form similar competencies (Barney, 1991).

Scarcity, immobility and non-substitutability of valuable resources are necessary to sustain the advantageous position but not sufficient. Therefore, the isolating mechanism, can be treated as barriers preventing rivals to duplicate the competitive advantages that owned by the resource and capability owner. It consists of two aspects: impediments to imitation and first mover advantage. The former impedes the potential entrants from duplicating the resources and capabilities of the incumbent firm.

There are four types of impediments to imitation. Firstly, legal restriction, such as patents, copyrights, trademarks as well as government regulation through licensing and certification can impede imitation. For instance, a certain drug of a pharmaceutical firm is always protected by its patent. However, this resource can also be mobile since it can be sold and bought, though it is scarce. The second aspect is superior access to inputs and customers. A firm which is easier to get access to high-productivity inputs, such as raw materials and information, or secures access to the best distribution channels or the most productive retail locations will be able to sustain cost quality advantage and will outcompete its rivals for customers. Also, market size and scale economy is another type of impediments. If a giant company has acquired a large percentage of the market share and its minimum efficient scale is large vis-à-vis market demand, the imitation can be blockaded. The final one is intangible barrier to imitation, which consist of causal ambiguity, dependence on historical circumstances and social complexity.

Causal ambiguity is a consequence of the tacit knowledge, thus the causes of a firm’s outstanding value-creating capabilities are obscure and only imperfectly understood. Therefore forms an efficient barrier. However the negative effect is it might also prevent the firm from translating the operational success in one of its plants to another. Barney (1991) argued that the dependence on historical circumstances of a firm makes it very difficult for competitors to replicate its distinctive competence since it is developed from the company’s history and development process. The third intangible barrier is social complexity, such as personal relationship or trust, which leads to the result that the firm’s advantage becomes really hard to imitate.

The other aspect of isolation mechanism is first-mover advantage. As Wernerfelt (1984) suggested, it refers to the situation that the first-moving companies have already sustained some resource adversely affects the later acquirers’ profits. For example, Amazon was the first major online bookstore, seizing a head start on later entrants. Established book retailers Barnes & Noble and Borders were quick to develop their own Web sites. Four factors fall under the category of first-mover advantage. The first factor is learning curve, which indicates that firms with greater experience are able to increase volume and enhance their cost advantage over rivals. Moreover, reputation buyer uncertainty can make a brand a powerful isolating mechanism. For example, Mattel which is famous for Barbie recovered from its close to bankruptcy in 1990s by adopting core brand strategy. Thirdly, entrants have to deal with substantial customer switching costs. Finally, positive network effects, such as strong brand recognition and word of mouth, can be a powerful advantage to an early mover. Unfortunately, first-movers may be confronted disadvantages. According to Grant’s research in 1998, 11 first movers have been knocked down by followers, out of 15 product markets. The reasons might be the following four points: relatively high R&D expenses, undeveloped supply and distribution channel to develop marketable products, uncertainty of customer demands, and immature technologies and complements. Accordingly, the recommendation for established firms is to implement a fast second strategy in the case of radical innovation.

The function of RBV is considerable in a firm environment. However, there are several limitations of this economic theory also should be taken into account. Firstly, its ambiguity definitions, such as valuable, rare, inimitable, are quite vague concept. Secondly, RBV only concerns about the firm’s internal resources and capabilities but ignore external factors at the industry-level which are suggested by Porter’s Five Forces. In addition, RBV is static as it does not tell how resources can develop and change over time in its original formulation. Accordingly, the concept of dynamic capabilities, which can be defined as ‘the capacity of an organization to purposefully create, extend or modify its resource base’, is a strategic extension of RBV. The final point is that RBV is to a certain extent tautological but it misses an independent and efficient selection mechanism to explain which resources are valuable and which are not.

In conclusion, this essay firstly introduces the unique resources should be heterogeneous and imperfectly mobile with four characteristics: they must be valuable, rare, inimitable and non-substitutable. Apart from that, firms should adopt isolation mechanism to maintain its advantageous position. It is comprised of impediments to imitation and first-mover advantage. In terms of impediments, four types are mentioned including legal restriction, superior access to inputs and customers, market size and scale economies, as well as four kinds of intangible barriers. Furthermore, first-mover advantage consists of four aspects as follows: learning curve, reputation and customer uncertainty, switching cost and network effects. In the last part, some limitations of this theory are examined, which are argued as ambiguity definition, ignorance of external factors, lack of dynamics and redundance of this theory.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Resource Based Theory of the Firms

...competitive advantage of a firm. To develop the strategy we need to analyze the firm’s internal strength and weaknesses (resource based model) as well as the external opportunities and the threat(environmental models). Environmental model is based on heterogeneity and mobility of the resources and assumes that all firms have the same strategy and the resources are heterogenic and mobile so the competitive advantage are not long lasting. Where as resource based model states that resources are immobile as well as heterogenic and can have long lasting competitive advantage. Firm resources are categorized into three types – physical capital resources, human capital resources and organizational capital resources. Some of the attributes of this resources can be used for developing strategies for increasing the effectiveness and efficiency of a firm. We need to specify conditions under which we can select resources which can be used as an competitive advantage. Competitive advantage means that a firm as a value added strategy over others and competitive advantage can only be sustainable if the other firms cannot duplicate that strategy. Once the strategy is being duplicate depending upon the strategy of the competitors or due to change in economic condition it is not longer sustainable. In an industry where firms have similar resources I,e resources are homogenous and mobile, it is not possible to have sustainable competitive advantage as they apply the same strategy to...

Words: 1452 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Impact of Resource Based View and Resource Dependence Theory on Strategic Decision Making

...Management Vol. 5, No. 12; December 2010 Impact of Resource Based View and Resource Dependence Theory on Strategic Decision Making Ali Raza Nemati Riphah International University, Islamabad, Pakistan Tel: 92-345-590-5581 E-mail: aliraza.nemati@riphah.edu.pk Afkar Majeed Bhatti Riphah International University, Islamabad, Pakistan Tel: 92-333-535-9743 E-mail: Afkar_tg@yahoo.com Muhammad Maqsal Riphah International University, Islamabad, Pakistan Tel: 92-345-956-5435 E-mail: mmaqsal@gmail.com Immad Mansoor Riphah International University, Islamabad, Pakistan Tel: 92-345-580-0451 E-mail: immadmansoor@gmail.com Fariha Naveed Riphah International University, Islamabad, Pakistan E-mail: farihanaveed@riphah.edu.pk Abstract This paper aims to investigate different factors determining strategic Decision making. This study attempts to identify the role of RBV and RDT and its impact on strategic Decision making. It has been seen that different strategies has to be made to get competitive advantage keeping in mind external resources and while strategies differ when to get competitive advantage through internal resources such as Human resource and capital Resource. In this research heuristics and bounded rationality acted as moderator to strategic decision making as when decision makers (managers take decisions personal biases and heuristics also get involved. Keywords: Decision making, Resource based view, Resource dependence theory, Heuristics and biases 1. Introduction The purpose...

Words: 3709 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Evaluating Firm Strengths and Weaknesses

...analysis helps a firm: • determine if its resources and capabilities are likely sources of competitive advantage • establish strategies that will exploit any sources of competitive advantage Traditional research on firm strengths and weaknesses • Theories of distinctive competence – General managers as distinctive competencies – Institutional leadership as a distinctive competence • Ricardian economics • Penrose’s theory of firm growth Research on the skills of general managers, institutional leaders, economic rents and firm growth have been brought together to develop a rigorous model to analyze a firm’s strengths and weaknesses: the resource-based view of the firm The Theory Behind Internal Analysis The Resource-Based View • developed to answer the question: Why do some firms achieve better economic performance than others? • used to help firms achieve competitive advantage and superior economic performance • assumes that a firm’s resources and capabilities are the primary drivers of competitive advantage and economic performance The Resource-Based View Resources and Capabilities Resources: • tangible and intangible assets of a firm » tangible: factories, products ; intangible: reputation • used to conceive of and implement strategies Capabilities: • a subset of resources that enable a firm to take full advantage of other resources » marketing skill, cooperative relationships The Resource-Based View Four Categories of Resources • Financial (cash, retained earnings) •...

Words: 1556 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Strategic Management

...The theory of Industries Organisation and Resource-based view (RBV) has been the most commanding influence in the strategic analysis field for many years. In my opinion, the Barney’s (1991) Resource-Based view is the important factor in gaining competitive advantage for a multinational corporation. In order for a company to have a sustained competitive advantage over a period of time, they need to gain control and fully utilize resources and capabilities that are valuable, rare, inimitable and un-substitutable to the company (Barney and Hesterly, 2012). Basically, the RBV focuses more on the strengths and the weaknesses of the company and try to use the internal resources to ensure superior performance against its competitors. Barney (1991) emphasized three type of internal resources which is the physical, human and organizational capital resources. In today’s globalization, the economy is dynamic and constantly emerging. Madhani (2009) argues that RBV focuses on different types of resources and competencies to attain strategic importance and constantly changing and updating these elements over a period of time to keep competing in the dynamic market place. Managers of the firm need to keep track of the market place and make full use of the existing internal resources to maintain a sustaining competitive advantage. Over time, organizations need to establish a process which allows them to manipulate their services, products, routines and management in parallel with the market...

Words: 1124 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Critical Analysis

...Strategic Marketing and the Resource Based View of the Firm Strategic Marketing and the Resource Based View of the Firm John Fahy University of Limerick Alan Smithee Alloa Metropolitian University John Fahy is Professor of Marketing, Dept. of Management & Marketing, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland 353-61-213126 (office), 353-61-338171 (fax) John.Fahy@ul.ie. Alan Smithee is Senior Lecturer in Marketing, Alloa Metropolitian University, Alloa, Scotland. Please address all correspondence to the first author. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The resource-based view of the firm (RBV) is one of the latest strategic management concepts to be enthusiastically embraced by marketing scholars. This paper argues that the RBV holds much promise as a framework for understanding strategic marketing issues but cautions that, before it is adopted, it needs to be fully understood. Consequently, the paper charts the development of the RBV from its origins in early economic models of imperfect competition, through the work of evolutionary economists to the contributions of strategy and marketing scholars over the past two decades. This broad literature base has given rise to a great deal of ambiguity, inconsistent use of nomenclature and several overlapping classification schema. The paper seeks to draw together common themes of firm heterogeneity, barriers to duplication, sustainable competitive advantage and Ricardian rents within an overall model of resource-based competitive advantage. The second...

Words: 12395 - Pages: 50

Premium Essay

Tesco and Its Competitiveness

...indicators. Today, Tesco’s strategic strength emanates from its hybrid position on the strategic outlook. The company offers a wide range of branded and own brand products in clean, modern and efficient supermarkets with ample parking and facilities for children and yet appears to offer lower prices (Angwin, Cummings and Smith, 2011, p. 3). The company underpins the low prices with low costs which it enjoys from its buying power. According to the resource-based approach, an organization’s competitive advantage comes from the unique capabilities of its resources which not only define, but also generate an organization’s strategic capacity (Jones & Tilley 2007, p. 124). Resource based theorists like Grant argue that management strategies purporting to maximize opportunities are constrained by imperfections of the market and the fact that not all resources necessary for securing competitive advantage can be found and bought in the markets. Consequently, a firm’s competitive advantage lies in what is unique and embedded in its resources in terms of its core distinctive capabilities (Jones & Tilley 2007, p. 124). Therefore, distinct capabilities inform, mold, shape and generate an organization’s strategic capacity. Ideally, the current Tesco’s key indicators reflect on the company’s responsible behavior in terms of treating the environment, suppliers and buyers, local communities, its customers and the company’s current and future employees positively. Additionally, Tesco refers...

Words: 1042 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Error Avoidance in Post Modern/Complex Adaptive Systems

...management theories that can be applied in a healthcare setting would be contingency and resource dependency theories. According to Weill and Olson (1989), An Assessment of the Contingency Theory of Management Information System in contingency theory, is a class of behavioral theory that claims that there is no best way to organize a corporation, to lead a company, or to make decisions. The health care industry is constantly shifting, meaning fluctuations in medical procedures and the environment of the workplace. According Weill and Olson (1989), the theory stated that management should stay flexible and remain capable of reorganizing structurally and procedurally as needed to keep up with demands and requirements. Moreover, the theory clearly applies to the hospital setting as the administration should be willing to adjust to issues that fit the demands of the workplace. This will aid in reducing the stress within the work environment. According to Davis and Cobb (2009), Resource Dependence Theory: Past and Future, mentioned that the resource dependence theory organizational accomplishment happens when a business capitalize on its power and influences in gaining the resources necessary for the businesses’ existence. Most businesses that are deficient in resources will seek to become partners of other organizations who have more resources. The dependence connection means that organizations become dependent on each other’s ability to have access to necessary resources, and the...

Words: 447 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Ot Yup

...Different Organizational theory perspectives assist us in acquiring different understandings of apple by giving us a broader range of concepts and theories about apple's organizational structure, its goals and objectives.Understanding the concepts of apples success requires the knowledge and perspectives of organizations, theories that they implemented to run their company, and philosophy of the company. To analyze the different perspectives of the organization, we have to grasp Metatheoretical understanding of Ontology and Epistemology.According to (Hatch, M , Cunliffe A 2006), Ontology shows whether reality is real or not in terms of either being Subjective or Objective.While Epistemology is the notion of how knowledge is known.(Hatch, M , Cunliffe A 2006)For this essay a comparison of modernism and post modernism approaches results in a better understanding of the apple organization. In a Modernist context, Objectivity is the beliefs that reality exist independently of those who live in it.(Bryman, A, Bell, E 2003). Therefore, An organization can impose pressure on individuals to confirm to the laws and regulations of the organization by letting them know which jobs to do, what to do.In turn they will continue the cycle of telling others what to do. Positivism comes after objectivity as human behavior is analyzed by discovering events in organizations through the use of suitable empirical data.(Hatch, M , Cunliffe A 2006). On the other hand, Post Modernism thinking...

Words: 1756 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Organisational Theory

...Introduction Organization theory is the study of organizations to identify problem solving technics, increase productivity and achieving the goals of stakeholders. There are four perspectives of organization theory namely modern, symbolic-interpretive, critical and postmodern perspectives. In this essay, we will look into organizations from a modern and critical perspective and through it; develop an in-depth understanding of a detailed analysis on how power, control and resistance play a part in an organization. In comparison to the two chosen perspectives, we will spot its similarities and differences by doing a compare and contrast analysis. The fundamentals of this will help us apply the perspectives and theory to Apple and its organizational environment. Theoretical Framework In order for us to do a comparison of the perspectives, we need to study the differences between epistemology and ontology to help us understand the modernism ways better. Ontology is concerned with what we perceived reality to be. Our assumption will decide on the subjects to be treated as real while disregarding others. These assumptions on whether or not a particular phenomenon exists or if it is just an illusion stirs debates between those who have conflicting perspectives. On the other hand, epistemology is concerned with knowledge that we are able to attain. The answers an epistemologist would want to derive from are are: how we as humans obtain the knowledge, how we differentiate between...

Words: 3094 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Envorinment

...aspects‬‬ Under-developed concept of globalization and information age, practice, and approaches ...‬‬   Postmodernism as a system of thought in the social sciences, aims to get rid of established thought patterns, all kinds of scientific research and accumulated know-how critical, is a kind of revolt that established order, which represents a point of view sees everything relative.‬ Differences in terms of management encourages creativity.‬ People the "right" to impose s, rather than leave them completely free and should be given opportunity to make their own wish.‬‬‬‬       Organizations to adapt to their environment to provide informed viewing decisions taken opinions as "adaptation-adaptation approach" is called.‬‬     Organization theory, the "ecological vision", "population ecology" or "organizational population ecology model", also known as the main idea of this view is the following:‬‬ How do living things in nature is a natural choice (selection), sieved and finding a part of life evolved over the lives of others is processing an evolution, it is similar to the situation in the world of organizations.‬‬     Eliminated in stopping the activities of the selected candidates is able to survive.‬ Thus, the environment, is in control of the organizational population.‬‬‬ Adaptation (adaptation) approaches‬‬       Contingency Approach‬‬   Structure and functioning of business organizations, environmental conditions in which businesses properties, affects the size...

Words: 1005 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Analyzing Intent

... Problem statement The study evaluates whether it is possible to apply the convergent views of institutional and resource dependence to predicting the strategic responses for institutional processes. Purpose or goal statement The purpose of the article is to identify the various strategic responses that organizations can apply in light of increased institutional pressures towards conformity and to develop a preliminary conceptual framework that can predict the emergence of alternative strategies (Oliver, 2009). Research questions 1. Which factors influence organizational strategy in response to the institutional processes? 2. What is the degree of organizational conformity or resistance to institutional pressure? 3. Is there convergence in institutional and resource dependence insights to institutional process? Research hypothesis Organizational theory is able to accommodate interest-seeking and other pertinent and active organizational behavior where the institution’s response to organizational pressures and expectations are not presumed as almost passive and conforming across all organizational conditions. Key variables 1. Institutional factors or framework 2. Resource factors How they are operationally defined The operational definition of these key variables is based on assumptions about two critical elements within the organizational process i.e., the context and motive of organizational...

Words: 1027 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

'the Environment Suffers Because Business Has No Ethics.' Discuss

... An effective and good corporate governance cannot be explained by one theory but it is best to combine a variation of theories, addressing not only the social relationships but also emphasize on the rules and legislation and stricter enforcement surrounding good governance practice and going beyond the norms of a mechanical approach towards corporate governance. Corporate governance theories emphasizes on empathy, healthy social relationship, loving care for each other and the avoidance of harm. In an organization, to care for one another is a social concern and not merely a profit centred motive. Ethics has also to be seen in the light of the environment in which it is exercised. This is important as an organization is a network of actions, hence influencing trans communal levels and interactions (Casey, 2006). Resource Dependency Theory is one the corporate governance theories that would be discussed below. Resource Dependency theory was originated in the 1970s with the publication of The External Control of Organisations: A Resource Dependence Perspective by Pfeffer and Gerald R. Salancik. Resource Dependency Theory (RDT) can be defined as an explanation of how the external resources of an organization affect the behaviour of said organization. RDT argues that in order to survive, an organization must acquire resources (Pfeffer and Salancik, 1978). In a traditional manufacturing company, resources would be things like money, a skilled labour...

Words: 824 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Organizational Taxonomy

...Organizational Theory Taxonomy Organizational Theory Taxonomy Title and Theorist Name | General Description | Example of Theory | Other Attributes | Agency Theory, Jensen & Meckling, 1972-1976 | The agency theory applies classical economic thinking to problems of organizational control and design (Tosi, 2009). Agency theory offers a useful way of understanding the complex authority relationship between top management and the board of directors. An agency relationship is when one personal “the principal” delegates decision-making authority or control to another “the agent” (Jones, 2010). | In 2005, Time Warner came under attack because top management had made many acquisitions such as AOL that did not led to increased innovation, efficiency, and higher profits which creates an agency problem that the agency theory addresses (Jones, 2010). | Agency theory views a firm as a legal entity that serves as a nexus for a complex set of formal and informal contracts among different individuals. A typical firm consists of the shareholders or the boards of directors are principals, and top managers or CEOs are agents (Jones, 2010). Agency theory dictates that principals will try to bridge the informational asymmetries by installing information systems for monitoring (Shapiro, 2005). | Contingency Theory, Burns & Stalker, 1961 | The contingency theory shows how some organizational designs will adapt to the environment, depending on the nature of the environment. The contingency...

Words: 1354 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Yahoo

...managers should chart the forces in the organization’s specific and general environments, noting (a) the number of forces that will affect the organization, (b) the pattern of interconnectedness or linkages between these forces, (c) how rapidly these forces change, and (d) the extent and nature of competition, which affects how rich or poor the environment is.” (Managerial Implications, p. 73) Conduct a specific analysis of Yahoo’s environment, identifying each of the 4 factors listed above. 3.      “Taking that analysis, managers should plan how to deal with contingencies. Designing inter-organizational strategies to control and secure access to scarce and valuable resources in the environment in which they operate is the first state in this process” (Managerial Implications, p. 73) 4.      How is Resource Dependence Theory illustrated in Yahoo’s relations with its environment? 5.      Illustrate the concepts of symbiotic and competitive interdependence, using Yahoo’s case history. Did Yahoo effectively manage its interdepencies? 6.      As a consumer, how would you rate Yahoo against its major competitor Google? Why? Part I.  Identification of Problems (2-4 pages) Using only the information provided in the case, identify and explain the problems that the company is having.  In other words, identify (1) areas where there are significant and meaningful differences between desired and actual behavior and/or desired and actual results and (2) areas/parts/components of the organization...

Words: 450 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Communications

...They are willing to take a little thing and turn it into something with the proper guidance. An open-system wants stability and has a purpose to exist and achieve great things. A closed system is a system that doesn’t depend on anything to help run it. It is run by itself and is independent from any other outside help. “Closed-systems assume relatively little complexity,” this just proves how basic and simplistic their organizational skills really were. The closed system strategy did not believe in change or looking at your surroundings and what was actually needed to get ahead of the competition. A closed system is like a closed minded individual, not willing to look at the big picture. The resource dependence perspective as it relates to organizational theory is that an organization is not run by just one individual. It takes a well written plan, with individuals that believe in the goals of the organization with the necessary skills to get the mission done....

Words: 478 - Pages: 2