Response Essay

In: Social Issues

Submitted By ermiller2012
Words 1246
Pages 5
In “The Courthouse Ring: Atticus Finch and the Limits of Southern Liberalism,” Malcolm Gladwell criticizes former governor of Alabama, James “Big Jim” Folsom. He compares him to literary hero Atticus Finch from Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird. Most people believe that both were noble people for taking the stance against racism that they did, but Gladwell presents them both in a different, less heroic image. Though I do not personally agree with Gladwell, I do understand why he believes the way that he does.
In the article, Gladwell introduces the reader to “Big Jim” Folsom by providing a brief description of the man himself. He notes that Folsom was a charismatic man who believed in racial equality in time where Jim Crow laws were in full effect. Also, most politicians would not have dared to venture into the deep-south on such a platform, but Folsom made “a proud and lonely stand for racial justice” in many ways such as not segregating the audience who attended his speeches. In Alabama, politics generally had a “friends and neighbors” effect, meaning that people generally voted based on personality rather than political issues and the state was divided into smaller island communities that were each run by a “courthouse ring.” Though he was considered something of a radical for his stance on racism, Folsom was not actually looking for a drastic change—he simply wanted privileged whites to be more amiable to black people. In spite of public disapproval, Folsom invited black congressman, Adam Clayton Powell Jr., to the governor’s mansion because it was “simply good manners.” He did not see why there was such an issue because Americans had been around blacks for many years and would continue to be around them in the future. By no means was Folsom an activist—activists wanted the full force of the law to compel equality in the way that Thurgood Marshall did; he was…...

Similar Documents

Response Essay

... the jail led by Walter Cunningham whom Finch later defends to Scout by saying that Cunningham is a good man with blind spots. Gladwell compares Finch to Folsom saying that both will stand up to racism in a sense—using “moral authority to shame them into silence,” but that neither will look at it on a grander scale. They both know racism is a problem that needed to change, but neither will actively fight for it. Folsom was willing to be more accommodating but knew that racism was a very large problem that would take years to reform. Gladwell refers to Steven Lubet, Finch’s strongest critic, who points out that, in the book, Finch did not have a strong case and tried to exchange one prejudice, blacks, for another, classless white women, saying that Mayella comes from a poor breed of whites and is bound to have the same inferior moral character that her mother had. That was simply what lawyers tried to do for blacks in those days. Gladwell leads to his concluding section by comparing his criticism of Finch/Folsom to George Orwell’s criticism of Charles Dickens. Dickens had many works that had a large impact on people and Orwell disapproves of his lack of “constructive suggestions.” In both cases, much praise is given as though they brought major change to society when, in all actuality, they only brought a personality that was different for the time that the men lived. I had a very mixed response to this essay. I understand Gladwell’s point since neither Finch nor Folsom...

Words: 1246 - Pages: 5

Critical Response Essay

...Critical Response Essay 1. If Fred were a Utilitarian, what would he do? Utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory where right and wrong depends on the consequences of one’s actions for everyone who might be affected by them. In other words, Utilitarian individuals want a system that will bring good to society than any other system. The philosophy of consequentialism is also based on the belief that the moral and ethical value of one’s action should be judged by the consequence of such action. In the case where Fred has signed a confidentiality agreement with Greyarea Inc. he is unable to leak out any information to the public about his research findings. If he were to tell anyone else that the cigarettes are more harmful, then the consequences of him being sued by the company due to a breach of the contract would be the repercussions. This is not to say that if Fred did give out the information about the truth of their newly developed cigarettes, he would be right or wrong. In the case with his company, he will be considered doing wrong. If Fred were a Utilitarian he would want to bring good to the society as a whole by letting the public know that the cigarettes in production is actually more addictive and has a higher chance of developing cancer in smokers. He would disregard the repercussions that would affect his family and career even when he is financially secure. His moral beliefs would tell him that his actions are for the greater good and so much more...

Words: 588 - Pages: 3

Life and Death the Movie Response Essay

...Life and Death the Movie Response After its independence from British colonial control and support in 1962, Jamaica struggled until it was almost wiped out financially by the gas and oil price wars of the early 1970s. Life and Death is a film about the conditions in Jamaica and its struggles. The movie starts with the images of its beautiful beaches on a sunny day and the arrival of a group of American tourist. The commentator stated that the City of arrival is Montego Bay and not Kingston Jamaica, which is the largest city and the capital, she also stated that the only document that is required to enter the country is a Driver license contrary of the majority of countries around the world that require a Pass port. However, what many people who travel to this country don't see is the high level of poverty, and vast sense of human desperation and hopelessness. As you arrive in Montego Bay, you can exchange currency at the airport and there is a shuttle driver waiting to take you to your destination. Due to Jamaica was under British colony everyone drives on the left side of the street and not on the right. The Shuttle toke them through some narrow street and poor neighborhoods which show some of the conditions the people of the island live in and base on the narrator some of them has no running water or sewerage... The prime minister during that time was Michael Manley, and he was talking about the approached to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to secure...

Words: 825 - Pages: 4

Critical Response Essay

...Critical Response Essay: Fred’s Dilemma In respect to the given example of Fred, the view of utilitarian would propose that the person should do whatever is going to offer him or her the most pleasure while obtaining the least pain possible from it. Considering this case, the utilitarian perspective would most likely indicate that Fred should keep the job because by doing so it would provide him with pleasure in many different ways. Some of the reasons he might consider keeping the job are his desperate need for money to support his family. On the contrary, a utilitarian would not consider keeping the job because the company is adding more addictive and toxic ingredients to their products which can cause cancer and many other diseases to their consumers. According to the given scenario, it would not matter if Fred quits his job, because then the company will offer the position to some other applicant who will gladly accept the job with full benefits. Also by quitting the job, Fred would not be able to expose the company’s activities because he signed the confidentiality agreement. In addition, through this theory it is possible to consider that the pain he would obtain if he does quits the job, would be higher due to his financial situation to support his family and also due to finding a another job anytime soon because of the economy. Therefore, the view of a utilitarian would propose that Fred should keep his job because he would obtain more pleasure for him and his...

Words: 444 - Pages: 2

Response Essay to News Article

...Response to “The generations at work” Recently as I was flipping through the Star newspaper entertainment section, I came across an article titled “The generations at work” written by Jean. It was such an intriguing article that it made me ponder for some time but I won’t agree or disagree to it, it is simply just my point of view. The article talked about the Generations that the X and Y, of the old timers and the restless young ones in the working industries. About the differences of how things are done between these two generations and ideals. “YOUR generation is just too materialistic! All you think about is money, money, money. There’s more to life than that.” (pgh.1) Well, it goes without saying that money makes the world go round. I won’t deny this true albeit fact of our current generation. I do agree that there is more to life than money alone such as love, friends and family. Money simply cannot buy true love, real friends or the bonds a family provides. It cannot buy happiness in the long term or more importantly, life itself. “When I was your age, I never thought about money. True, it is important. But what was more important then was having a job and supporting our own families.” (pgh.4) “Next came loyalty and integrity. Once we started working, we would stay with the company until we retired” (pgh.4) this sentence caught my attention as I was reading through the article. Unlike the current generation of youngsters (Generation Y) who jump ship...

Words: 746 - Pages: 3

Response

...Critical Response Essay Utilitarian Approach: Fred is faced with a difficult decision because he must decide what is more important to him. Is keeping my job more important than contributing to something I don’t agree with? That is the crucial question he must answer. Is that would allow him to keep his job and persuade Greyarea to manufacture less toxic cigarettes. According to the consequentialist theory of Utilitarianism, if he wore to abide by this theory, Fred would respectfully resign from this job. Under principle of utility, the right action is the one that produces the greatest balance of pleasure over pain, or happiness over unhappiness, for everyone affected by that action. He believes that his contribution to the companies harmful products isn’t for him, because the consequences are far more important than maintaining his current job. This is something a consequentialist believes in and respects. Fred would rather spend more time searching for jobs and struggle to provide for his family, than work for a company who profits at the expense of consumers. Fred knows if he were to release the information about toxic additives in Greyarea’s new cigarettes, he would be terminated and presented a lawsuit. But, being consequentialist, he believes his actions are for the greater good and it outweighs the consequences he would receive upon forfeiting such information. As a utilitarian, its in his power to step away from Greyarea and Deontologist Approach: If...

Words: 382 - Pages: 2

Response

... so that we could involve ourselves in discussions. In addition to the sort of inadequate methods of gives of classes, I still have several experiences of nice classes. The professors still give lectures but weave group discussions, presentations and films watching into the course schedule; consequently, the stuffs enrich the classes and make them absorbing and interesting. When the instructors lecture, we listen carefully and take notes about the teachers’ summaries, explanations, and comments of articles and essays. As for presentations, we have to report in team works so we look for and collect information collaboratively. After presenting, we could get the sense of achievement. When it comes to watching movies related to what we learn, the films give us profound impressions and new viewpoints varied form previous thoughts. In these ways, students are able to response their reflections and instructors can also get feedback. This kind of instruction is a little bit difficult to practice but seemingly better for students and professors. David Daniels has pointed out the defects of lecture system which has passed down and rooted in the education system. Nonetheless, whether it is proper or inappropriate depends on how professors instruct. What’s more, no matter students, instructors, faculty, or administrators, they are supposed to try to find the balance between lectures and small discussion classes. As a result, both lectures and discussions have advantages and......

Words: 742 - Pages: 3

Smoke Signals Response Essay

...Ashilay Dillow SIU850015144 SOC215 November 14, 2013 Film Response to Smoke Signals The film Smoke Signals is about two young Native American men, Victor Joseph and Thomas Builds-the-Fire, who venture off their reservation in Idaho to go to Phoenix, Arizona to pick up the ashes of Victor’s dead father. The film opens with a house fire on the Fourth of July, 1976. Infant Thomas is saved from the fire by Victor’s father, Arnold, but is also left parentless when his parents aren’t so lucky. Twelve years later, Victor’s drunk and abusive father abandons his family and leaves the reservation. Twenty years later, Victor learns of his father’s death and decides that he should go retrieve his father’s ashes in Phoenix. Knowing that Victor does not have the funds needed for the trip, Thomas offers to pay for it as long as he can come along. After arriving in Phoenix, Victor learns of one of his father’s secrets. He learns that it was his father that accidently started the fire that killed both of Thomas’ parents and that is was that guilt that resulted in much of his father’s drinking and him leaving the reservation and his family. Both men come home with a better understanding of their pasts and Victor is finally able to come to terms with his father’s mistakes and absence. One of the first lines is a great example of an illusion in this film. During Thomas’ voice-over during the house fire he says, “A fire rose up like General George Armstrong Custer and swallowed up my...

Words: 756 - Pages: 4

Summary and Response Essay

... intended audience would be for anyone who has strong opinions about men and women equally playing roles in history. For example, Thatcher Ulrich states that “history is an account of the past based on surviving sources, but it is also a way of making sense out of the present” (658). This pinpoints the intended audience because history is an explanation of the past based on originations that already exist, and an idea of creating understandings of what is currently happening (Thatcher Ulrich 658). Thatcher Ulrich also states that “we re-create past events from fragments of information, trying hard to distinguish credible accounts from wishful thinking” (659). This also identifies another example of the intended audience, because people can create situations over again from chunks of facts and analyze written descriptions from events in the past (Thatcher Ulrich 659). It also identifies the intended audience, because the author was not referring to a specific gender. Anyone could read this article and think that women can establish meaningful history. The author uses both essay and article formats in order for the intended audience to understand in a more complex manner. Thatcher Ulrich chose the essay genre because she told a story of how her unintentional recognition became a success in public. For example, the author gives credit “to a single line from a scholarly article she published in 1976” (Thatcher Ulrich 656). Thatcher Ulrich gave appreciation form an article she...

Words: 1197 - Pages: 5

Response

...In response to the reading I found myself open minded to the stereotypical episodes of what a black man goes through. Personally, I found it difficult to relate to because I’m not black or a big man. I can however, imagine through the words of the author what he was feeling as well as what others (victims) were feeling. Then I somehow, found myself recalling times that I too had displayed worry when coming down a dark street, at a club, or even in an empty train cart that would have me alone with a big man, on the other end of it and me feeling like the echoes of the rails would keep me distracted from my fears of something bad happening. For example I can recall a time when I was mugged while walking down my own street. It was during the summer and it was 11pm. I rarely walk the streets at night but this was an exception. My mother’s flight got in last and she was hungry. I decided to walk to the pizza shop at the corner of my street and as I walked down my street I had noticed two men; one black and one white turn the corner together but split up when they saw me. I knew something was going to happen. Sure enough one of them ran towards my purse. WE both spun around and dropped to the sidewalk. As you can imagine I had a strong grip on my purse and the purse itself was made of camel skin. Another time I can recall minding my business waiting for my train in Chinatown and a black man decided to expose himself to me repeatedly until my train......

Words: 373 - Pages: 2

Response Essay

...Overcoming Hardships In the article “Coming into language” Jimmy Baca describes to readers his personal experiences of growing up on the streets without his parents and the struggle of being illiterate. Baca’s description on his struggles could motivate and bring hope to people who are currently undergoing downfalls in their own lives and help them rise above it. People will relate to Baca’s story as an example of overcoming hardships through perseverance, and being able to heal and be heard through reading and writing. Many people go through difficult circumstances that are not quite how we expect, and it is through perseverance that we are able to break through. Baca is determined to read as he states, “I had always thought reading a waste of time that nothing could be gained by it. Only by action, by moving out into the world and confronting and challenging the obstacles, could one learn anything worth knowing” (6). I agree and relate to this statement, it shows that if we put our minds to it than anything is possible. I have experienced hardship myself. Being a mother of 4 boys and not working, I often wondered how I would make ends meet. I was determined to make changes and only until I mentally did that was I able to make those changes. Baca states, “For a while, a deep sadness overcame me, as if I had chanced on a long-lost friend and mourned the years of separation. But soon the heartache of having missed so much of life, that had numbed me since I was a...

Words: 633 - Pages: 3

Response Essay "The Achievement of Desire"

...-20T22:50:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:51:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:51:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:51:00much Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:52:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:52:00how much Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:46:00Horace Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:46:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:46:00Horace Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:46:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:43:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:44:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:45:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:44:00i Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:42:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:43:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:41:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:42:00Unknown Author2015-09-20T22:41:00temporary brightness Professor Graham BowmanEnglish 116/ Fall 2015 #Reading Response 3 My Nguyen September 21, 2015 The achievement of Desire “The value of an effective life” is what comes at the end of an elite education. The education which is fulfilled with “unsolitary, richly passionate and spontaneous life” requires an ambiguous desire. This desire is not only defined with achievements, it is also better defined with a reflective period in which the learners could contemplate and earn new values throughout their education (and self-improvement) pursuit. Why does the value have to come up in the end of education? Is the sole goal of a perfect education a total absorption of knowledge? What makes a person's life coherent? Does the Achievement of Desire turn out to lead every learner, as well as contemplating people, to their final intention of an...

Words: 1275 - Pages: 6

Response

...I am writing the following in response to Ms Hoa's request to write comments for Language Skills 4A. First, the Language skills subject is an excellent course to take. It is very informative. And it has provided me with the foundation that I will need to make further advancement in Foreign Language coursework. The instructor, Ms Hoa, works very hard in class to get his ideas across to the students. I really enjoy the way she uses her voice to command students' attention. Ms Hoa is very thorough in lecturing. However, you already knew that we have to practice writing, reading, grammar. I think the pace of this course is hard and fast. the students can not manage their time effectively in order to receive quality materials day-in, day-out. I was reminded of the old adage, "Practice makes perfect”, Those exercise assignments took hours and hours to complete! But we do not have time enough. The pressure on time made it difficult be prepared. I was still surprised at the intensive pressure, especially when the final examination of the semester was approaching. Personally, we should separate 4A and 4B into: Listening and Speaking, Grammar and Writing, and Reading and Vocabulary. And I would like to have seen more real practice given in the lectures. For me, this helps to crystallize the definites, grammars by placing them in context. Finally, the book which we used is too old, we need to choose other materials. I'm sorry if this is offensive, but that's the way I feel. I......

Words: 288 - Pages: 2

Critical Response Essay

...Critical Response Essay Life is full decisions, some harder than others, but those hard decisions have to be made sometimes for the wellbeing of others. Medical technology is beginning to take of the medical field and is making ethical decisions and issues a thing of the past. Due to this there are has been some debate on whether or not the technology in the medical field is harming the medical profession or not. Some people agree with the topic others do not and think that the medical team should be the ones making the decisions not the computers. The passage, Medical Technology and Ethical Issues by William E. Thompson and Joseph V. Hickey, explains the dilemma of technology in the medical field, and the different sides of it. The technology that is being referred to is the RIP computer. This is a computer program that doctors us to help make decisions about whether to administer lifesaving actions to patients that are dying or to let them die. In the passage critics and supporters take opposing sides to the issue of technology being used in the medical field. Some believe computers will be making the decisions, while others believe it just provides data to make decisions on who to treat. On the debate of the use of the RIP in medical field has two main positions, the critics and the supporters. The critics disagree with the technology because, they say that it is a “frightening example” of the overreliance of computer technology that makes decisions that should...

Words: 796 - Pages: 4

Ideas for Structuring Your Essay Response.

...Ideas for structuring your essay response. In your opening paragraph: • Reveal your understanding of the key concepts in the question including how key words such as discuss or describe, frame what you are required to do. Are you being asked to discuss (identify issues and provide points for and/or against), describe (provide characteristics and features) or evaluate ( make a judgement based on criteria or determine the value of)?Ensure you understand the requirements of the key words and their implications for your response. • Acknowledge which area of content you are focusing on. • Outline who the artists/critics/historians are, that you will be writing about. Set the scene in your next paragraph: • Establish your stance or position • Address aspects of the content area in relation to the question. For example if the question relates to an artist practice, provide information about the artists world and experiences that may have contributed to their artmaking practice. The main body of your essay: • Elaborate and develop your position. • Present a well-reasoned and informed point of view. • Refer to artists, craftspeople, designers, architects, art historians or art critics that support your position. • Refer to significant artworks that support the focus requirements of the question • Use quotes to emphasise an important point you are making to support your position. Depending on the requirements of the question, you may include: • How the artworks evolved...

Words: 894 - Pages: 4