Free Essay

Revolution and Romance

In: English and Literature

Submitted By freekit
Words 1575
Pages 7
Michael Bennett Page 1
Dr. Alla Boldina
ENG 110-60

REVOLUTION AND ROMANCE

Creedy: “Why won’t you die!?”
V: “Beneath this mask is more than flesh…there are ideas. And ideas are bulletproof.”
With these words, the film, “V for Vendetta” dramatically demonstrates the power of ideas to challenge and overcome the evil of oppression. In film critic Robert Ebert’s review of “V for Vendetta,” he notes the power of ideas, especially the belief that people should not be afraid of their governments, but rather that governments should be afraid of their people. Although Ebert questions the necessity of fear, and believes that governments and people should be able to happily co-exist, I think he trivializes the significance of the film’s message. Although it is an in-depth, well written look at the story, it is one-sided. He gives credit to a novel written by Allen Moore in 1983, on which the film is based, and compares “V for Vendetta” to other movies and stories. The main character, V, is described in detail, and Ebert explains his purpose in the story. The other characters, however, are not mentioned very much, leaving the reader a bit blank. I appreciate that he mentions the main idea of the film, and is generous with quotations. I do fin d his criticism a bit excessive, as he puts down the mask that V wears because the lips don’t move and his vision would be obstructed. Ebert seems biased on behalf of London’s architecture, as he expresses his disappointment over its destruction. He does admit to not reading the original work, so he cannot compare notes. In all, he gives the film a positive review, explaining its controversial nature: “To attempt a parable about terrorism and totalitarianism that would be relevant and readable, might be impossible, could be dangerous and would probably not be box office.” I think this film tells a story of man’s journey through life, death and rebirth. The main character, V, masks his facial burns from a jail fire, where he was tortured and brutalized. The mask becomes not
Page 2 only a cover for his physical disfigurement, but a symbol of his loss of individual identity as he seems to experience a rebirth of purpose. His journey of revenge in search of justice is violent , although justified. At one point V says that violence can be used for good…for justice. I think the film is unrelenting in its message that powerful ideas can change people. The main character, V, justifies the use of violence in the search for justice, especially in a world overrun by oppressive governments. However, by the end of the film, V has discovered that, although ideas can change the world, ideas ultimately do not love, nor feel pain. It is humanness, not the idea, that sacrifices for others; that experiences the freedom from fear that is able to risk change; that realizes the connections among all forms of life, as evidenced in EV’s admission, “I’d rather die,” as she goes out into the rain, and experiences revelation: “God’s in the rain!” The film’s plot contrasts the interests of a conservative, totalitarian government in London, with the people’s desire for freedom, as symbolized through the main character, V. The citizens are portrayed as couch potatoes, glued to their televisions. Suddenly the main character, V, emerges and blows up the famous building, Old Bailey, introducing his strategic plan for revolution. It is significant that the date is November 5, the date when a seventeenth century revolutionary, Guy Fawkes, was hung. V invites the public, on a television broadcast, to join with him in making Fawkes’ goal come true: to blow up parliament. Throughout the film, V hunts down and kills the people who have experimented on him while he was jailed, and who created a virus that killed thousands of people. At this point, his motivation is revenge, not only for himself, but also for the death of Valerie, a prisoner whose letter he found in his cell. Inspired by her words of encouragement, he had escaped. His journey took him through the fire, which not only burned his skin, but transformed his spirit. Fearless, V is unstoppable. It isn’t hard to identify with V’s motivation for revenge. But one must be careful that, in slaying the dragon, one doesn’t become the dragon. As if by divine intervention, V is saved by a young woman, EV, even as he saves her life first. Bringing her into his home, he shares a deep connection with EV,
Page 3 especially his vulnerability. Keeping her prisoner in his home until he can complete his mission, he asks her to help him, and she agrees, as one who has also experienced oppression. It’s interesting to watch V evolve through his relationship with EV. She wants to know who V is. She wants to see behind his mask, but V is never willing or able to remove it. He responds that who he was died in the jail. But even as V changed as a result of his love for EV, he gave EV the gift of fearlessness: by creating an illusion of jail and forcing EV to look death in the face, she experienced real freedom. At times this film seemed unrealistic: things just fell into place too perfectly. I had to view it in the abstract, focusing on the message and symbols of transformation, which were inspiring and revelatory. There were, however, many symbols, and symbolism can be understood in many different ways. V wears the mask of a revolutionary character from the past. The mask seems to symbolize many things in the film, such as the death and rebirth of the character, as he changes and transforms. When V was captured and burned in the jail during his escape, the mask covers his wounded face. I think the mask represents the death of his individual identity and priorities, in service to the birth of a greater purpose…a new revolutionary idea for society. When V mass-mails masks to the public for them to wear on the 5th of November, the date for the final act, I think the masks become symbolic of unity, of speaking with one voice, while remaining individually anonymous. I found the film very intellectual and I did get confused at times, feeling overwhelmed by all the back stories. However, as I watched the film multiple times, I was able to understand more of the message. The attention to detail was intense, as I focused on each character’s journey. To me, the story is insightful and politically rich. It connects personally righteous, rebellious ideas with social justice, violence, revolution and love.

Page 4

This film is both timely and timeless. As our society continues to struggle with the effects of corporate greed and oppression, and city after city is mounting “Occupy Wall St.” protestors to rail against the evils of greed, this is a fine film to challenge the couch potatoes and inspire the angry to action. The growing assault on constitutional rights, the increasing war economy, especially on the backs of the most vulnerable, would be exactly what V would be willing to risk his life for. V invites EV to dance to a jukebox tune as he anticipates his revolution, and when she questions it, he uses a famous Emma Goldman quote, “A revolution without dancing is a revolution not worth having.” I appreciate this flowing transition and interweaving of revolution and romance. For, ultimately, it becomes the love, the connection, the willingness to trust and become vulnerable to each other, that saves and transforms them into freedom.

Works Cited
V for Vendetta. Dir. James McTeigue. Writers Wachowski Brothers. Cast Natalie Portman, Hugo Weaving, Stephen Rea, Stephen Fry, John Hurt. Warner Brothers 2006.

Ebert, Roger. “V for Vendetta.” Review Sun-Times New Group. 16 March 2006.

COMING: A NEW MONASTIC COMMUNITY IN ENDICOTT, NEW YORK

First UMC of Endicott, NY is establishing a residential Intentional Christian Community, focused on spiritual growth, outreach and service to the community. If you are interested in this project and would like to know more, please contact us at 607-748-7434 or pastor@firstumcendicott.com.

A NEW STUDY: LIVING THE QUESTIONS 2

Wednesdays, 7:00 to 9:00 PM beginning March 10
First United Methodist Church
53 McKinley Ave., Endicott
607-748-7434 or pastor@firstumcendicott.com

This is a study for the countless people of faith who have suffered in silence as the voices of certainty and fear profess the unchanging truth of Christianity. The study’s purpose is to provide a resource for the discussion of what is already believed and practiced by many faithful people still holding on within the institutional church, while harboring a conviction that what the church teaches isn’t the whole story. It may even be helpful for those who have left the church because of its refusal to take their questions or life’s situation seriously. It is not intended to spell out new doctrine or create new dogma, but to serve as a catalyst to perhaps crack open the door to the future.

Living the Questions 2 seeks not to provide easy answers, but to be a resource for people who are in the midst of a life-long conversation about the mysteries of faith and life.

All are welcome! Please contact us to let us know you’re interested in participating. Thank you!

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Marxist View of Book Pride and Prejudice

...social consciousness. Great poets and writers create in their imagination that Real Man and make him play a limited social role where he often peeps out of his social personality into his universal individuality. It is this extra dimension of those characters that is fascinating to us and renders them immortal characters. We see that the immortality of a character is his innate universality. Jane Austen’s genius captured the flavour of the French Revolution wafting across the shores of England which was anxious to restructure its society so as to avoid a bloody revolution. Mental growth that assimilates the spirit of the times can compel the body to rise to the occasion, thus avoiding the inherent violence of any revolution. England did escape the guillotine by exercising its social wisdom which was willing to unite the higher and lower strata of the society. Pride and Prejudice can be seen as a story of several marriages where the abominable pride of Darcy becomes the uncontrollable passion of his heart. Romance is the adventure of the heart for the unattainable. This approach views the story as the aristocracy descending to the commoner in its passion to preserve the society by preserving itself. It is this social power of passionate self-preservation that passes through Darcy to Elizabeth as an irresistible romantic attraction. Elizabeth is the best daughter of the gentrified Mr. Bennet and the mother of intense physical energy who is neither educated nor......

Words: 4226 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Women, Romance Novels and Shame

...Women, Romance Novels and Shame Mac H English Composition 111 22 March 2013 Introduction “Bodice-ripper”, “trashy books”, “porn for women”, these are just some of the derogatory terms used to describe romance novels. The romance genre has maintained a steady popularity among women for many decades. Afraid of women gaining power in any form, they were labeled sub par literature by a male dominated social and literary culture. This anthology will attempt to answer the question of why women who read romance novels are ashamed of their choice or reading material and why these books are vilified in the literary world. Previous generations established a woman’s place as a mother and homemaker no matter her social status. This fear of women wielding more knowledge and power through reading was born because the women depicted in romance novels were independent and free of the sexual, social, and financial constraints that a patriarchal society placed on them. Although romance novels do not come to mind when literature is discussed, if you listen carefully you will realize they are actually the subtle battle cry of the feminist movement. Romance novels fly high the flag of feminism; they are the drumbeat swelling the dynamic purposefulness of women who read them. Nevertheless, the genre is covered in a layer of disdain and scorn and women are made to feel ashamed of reading such literature. The stigma attached to these books suggest that anyone who reads them...

Words: 2646 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Play

...Our Sudan I am going to tell you a story Paint you a picture Ask you to think differently about who you are About who we are The story I am going to tell is the story of a generation My generation It is a tale of our romance with the past The losses of our age And hope for the future There is a memory of an old Sudan A torn and faded picture of the country as it was As it was told to us A warm and beautiful place imprinted in our memories as if it were our own A world of wide open boulevards and tree-lined streets Of clean roads and white robes Young men straight and proud and women wrapped in gold and finery Old men on bicycles gliding slowly through the town The early morning siren and those trains that ran on time Cinema coliseum and St James and jazz nights by the Nile 1 Khartoum University in its glory days when exams were marked in London and students had their laundry done Greek stores full of foreign goods and cars when England used to make them Weddings that lasted 40 days and 40 nights And funerals that lasted just as long Clear skies and cool nights and darkness pierced by the brightest stars Lush green gardens and seasons that broke the heat Young men and women full of passion and idealism An old world tired and in retreat and a new world resurgent and full of hope These are the stories that our fathers told us Told to us in sketches, fragments Told to us In the early mornings, as the sun crept slowly into the sky On those orange days Afternoons...

Words: 1721 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Industrial Revlolution

...Industrial Revolution In the previous class, we learned the changes of the Industrial Revolution. The Industrial Revolution had changed literally everything. Lives changed, roles changed, education changed, homes changed, health changed, romance changed; everything had changed. The elements of the home changed in quite a few ways. The home was always filled with the people that lived there because they spend their time at home. The home was made of things that you could find locally or that you could make by hand. Houses were made out of mud, wood, and straw. The family had basically slept in the same bed for less consumption of space and for warmth. Not only did they live with the entire family, however they lived with fleas, rats, and lice. This allowed diseases to be spread and in effect, the population was very little because of the severity of the diseases. After the Revolution, the home is filled with less people because the people transport to other places. The home is filled with things that you can find all over the world. Houses are made out of steel frames, wood, glass windows, and very sturdy materials in addition to the idea that specialized workers made your home. The refrigerator and toilet were invented and people slept in different beds causing an increase in the population due to the decrease in disease. The elements of man and woman had changed as well. Man and woman married each other for survival. Man and woman needed each other......

Words: 1048 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Consensual Relationship Agreements Case Study

...| 2 “To date or not to date: that is the question: Whether it is nobler in the workplace to suffer the slings and arrows from outraged Human Resource personnel, Or to take the pen to their CRA and by signing love forever.” My apologies to William Shakespeare and his soliloquy from Hamlet (Act 3, Scene 1) but such is the state of affairs for many U.S. companies, human resource personnel and office personnel in today’s litigious world. Since of the days of World War II and later McCarthyism, women have moved into the U.S. work force in greater and greater numbers, filling positions ranging from oil field roustabout to mail room clerk to Chief Financial Officer and CEO. In the meantime, the U.S has experienced a major “sexual revolution” as well as associated changes in the attitudes affecting women in the work place. One of these is dating in the work place. Although no-dating policies are no longer the norm, the advent of anti-sexual harassment laws and the subsequent growth in the number and cost of lawsuits related to these laws, have lead the majority of companies to have in place policies that review the definition of sexual harassment, their company’s rules against it and the possible results to a person who engages in the sexual harassment of another person or group of people or one who creates a hostile work environment. Some companies have or are putting into place an additional policy to define and manage personal relationships that cross over......

Words: 2332 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

As We Move

...we move into the twenty-first century, it is clear to see that we have become more and more dependent on computers and information technology. This technology now reaches into almost every area of our lives and it is easy to predict that this phenomenon is only going to grow. My personal belief is that this presents a variety of dangers. It is highly likely that in the future there will be comparatively few aspects of our lives that will not be influenced by computer technology. The probability is that it will control more and more forms of communication, transforming fields such as education and business when video-conferencing platforms become more stable. It might even affect romance with more people forming relationships online. While there may be benefits to this technological revolution, there are also a number of potential dangers. Perhaps the most serious of these would be that if people rely on computers too much for communication, they could in fact begin to communicate less well. For example, if every member of a family had their own computer screen and smart phone, they might speak less and less often to one another and simply look at a screen. This would be serious because our ability to communicate is an essential part of our humanity. My conclusion is that the growth of computer technology is inevitable, but that this may not be entirely positive. Just one area in which it is possible to foresee dangers is communication, and if we are going to ensure......

Words: 298 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

1920s Taxi Dance History

...In the era of the 1920s, they weren't listening to Hip-Hop and dancing Dubstep, like you might be today, but the 1920s had its own music and dance revolution. For the first time, dancers were closer together, some were even touching, and the music was faster, more soulful, and louder than ever before. In spite of the horrors that the nation lived during this time of the Great War, the dancers took to the ground great movements in styles like the Shimmy, the Charleston, the Foxtrot, the Tango and the Waltz (study.com). The Shimmy is a kind of ragtime dance in which the whole body shakes or sways back and forth, and at the same time leaning back and forth to the beat of the music. Charleston, named for the town in South Carolina, involved turning...

Words: 606 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Politics

...General Vladimira.dvorakova@vse.cz Petr.vymetal@vse.cz Midterm november 8th Multiple choices Short answers, brief definitions Open questions Short essay questions Final test before Christmas December 20th Final: 302 SB 20.12.2011 Power point presentation Seminar starting next week (every other week) 10:55 Treason – Verrat Day 1 Ethnical and religious cleavages in central and eastern Europe Does Europe exist? Where should be the borders? Russia and Turkey had a big influence on Europe as well. They dispatched parts of Europe for a long time. Of course the path dependency is present in these regions. The process of European integration started later there. European identity is difficult to describe. Distinction between east and west means post-communism (eastern). Central Europe: Czechs feel like being central Europeans (since they don’t want to be part of eastern Europe.) → idea of central Europe is based on Austrian-Hungarian-Empire + parts of Germany eg Bavaria. The link is also the way of making decisions, working, doing things, tradition, waking up early (Franz Josef) → many similarities. Lot of conflicts in Europe are still connected to events that happened hundreds of years ago. Poland (republic) Linguistic Group: Western Slavic Religion: Catholic (important part of national identity) Ethnical Minorities: German, Ukraine, Belorussian (small and not important) Often divided (Russia, Germany, Austria-Hungary) Is called state of wheels...

Words: 2190 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Postmodernism and Consumerism

...Abstract This essay employs a visual analysis to compare and contrast Andy Warhol’s ‘Blue Marilyn’ with Roy Lichtenstein’s ‘In the Car’ in association to the postmodernist theme of Consumer Culture and more explicitly, the introduction of Pop Art, born from post-war consumerist societies. The argument refers to eight scholarly research sources, three of which are scholarly journal articles. POSTMODERNITY AND CONSUMERISM: WIT, INVENTION AND THE AFTERMATH OF WAR Research Statement: Using a visual analysis, compare and contrast Andy Warhol’s Blue Marilyn with Roy Lichtenstein’s In the Car in association to the postmodernist theme of Consumer culture and more explicitly the introduction of Pop Art; born through post-war materialisation. The Postmodernist Cannon of the latter twentieth and twenty-first Century Art is a crucial anthology, signifying radical and innovative movements that differentiated from Modernist art practices. It signifies a period of time whereby practitioners sought to contradict the rebellious experimentational aspects of Modernist art through re-visioning and revitalising media to fit the metamorphosing culture. Incorporated within the Cannon were several movements that were heavily influenced by the rise of Consumer cultures, dictated by the post-war explosion of advertisement in the 1950’s, compelling practitioners to manipulate and transform their style in either awe of the perpetually adapting society or in rebellion towards the mass......

Words: 2088 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Romantic Poetry

...thought and expression, an idealization of nature, and a dreamlike or visionary quality.  The Romantic Movement is both a revolt and revival .This movement in literature and the revolutionary idealism in European politics are both generated by the same human craving for freedom from traditions and tyranny. The Romantic Movement revives the poetic ideals of love, beauty, emotion, imagination, romance and beauty of Nature. Keats celebrates beauty, Shelley adores love, Wordsworth glorifies nature Byron idealizes humanism, Scott revives the medieval lore and Coleridge amalgamates supernatural. As a result, the Romantic Movement revolts against the ideals, principles, intellectualism, aristocracy and technicality of Augustan period and smoothed the run of broad emotional gallery of substance relinquishing the rigidity of ‘form’.   From sociological and political perspective it is not unfair to say that Romanticism and French Revolution are synonymous. In fact, Rousseau’s social theory roughly embodies in the familiar phrase of ‘the return to nature’ while the battle cry of French Revolution – liberty, equality and Fraternity – are influential on the youthful imagination of Romantic poets. Rousseau establishes the cult of the individual and championed the freedom of the human spirit. Rousseau’s sentimental influence touches Blake, Wordsworth and Coleridge; his intellectual influence Godwin, and through Godwin Shelly. Byron and Shelley also share the champion of liberty and......

Words: 806 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Retail

...Long since I have known business, it was of the form when a vendor used to give free candies and a smile along with the grocery - provided I am staring at the candies, now who says that consumer calling back then was not incentive driven :-)        Well, that is not the topic of my comments, my take is on "Retail Sector back then and now". I take you to the era after 1991, when McDonald was unknown to most of the Indians but it existed for half a century in the outside world, when telephone, TV were the commodities of rich, when 1 rupee on the palms of children was meant for 16 orange candies, when Mahabharata and Ramayana had the highest TRP and when Shahrukh was spreading the magic of romance. This was the time when organized retail was in the design phase of its existence in India and unorganized retail was the way of living.Then something hit India which is considered as the best reflection of Indian political fraternity till now, and it was Liberalization, Privatization and Globalization (LPG).       Though the idea struck in 1991, the slow process of opening up the retail sector to FDI started in 1995 when a free trade policy passed by WTO directed India to allow FDI in cash and carry(wholesale) which ultimately got materialized in 1997 and Indian government allowed 100% rights subjected to government’s approval . If we talk about the situation of retail at ground level that time, there was not much change except the expansion of Indian middle class and their......

Words: 925 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Consesnsual Relationship Agreements

...Consensual Relationship Agreements By: Vickie Gonzalez Bus 520 – Leadership and Organizational Behavior Professor: Dr. Marilyn Carroll October 24th, 2012 Workplace romances are now one of the challenges that organizations of all sizes have to address. How they address them varies from organization to organization. Some businesses and organizations strictly prohibit them in any form or fashion, while others prohibit them when the participants are in certain roles within the organization. Some companies have chosen not to address the issue at all and others are using a more formal method of documenting and mitigating the risk they feel these relationships pose. One of the methods of documenting, and potentially mitigating, this risk is known as a consensual relationship agreement or CRA. In the text that follows I will argue for the use of CRA’s in the workplace. Secondly, I will present a counter argument for the use of CRA’s. Then we will then look at the ethical principles involved in the use of CRA’s. Lastly I will present another option that may be available for addresses these consensual relationships. First, let’s look at what brought about the need for CRA’s. On June 28th, 1914 Gavrilo Princip, of Sarajevo, assassinated the Archduke and heir to the throne of Austria, Franz Ferdinand (Collins, 2008, p. 9). Thirty-seven days later World War I began, and with it, so did what some see as the beginnings of women entering the workplace. The Munitions of War......

Words: 1499 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Sexualized Society

...repression against it. Despite the warnings about venereal deceases, unprotected sex for soldiers resulted in millions of lost lives because there was no medical cure. Sex during the war mostly happen with prostitutes from Europe, and those men who survived the war, came back home with new knowledge about sex. This knowledge together with other changes in American history, launched the early 20s known as “roaring 20s”. Prior to 1920s, American cities began overcrowding with new immigrants coming from Europe to seek for the new opportunities. Women were able to find jobs, and at the end of the day everyone wanted to socialize by going out on dates or movies. Film, a fascination of the technological revolution, became an essential element in the development of sexuality. By seeing romance and kissing in the...

Words: 1786 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Russian Music History

...A term paper discussing Russian music Presented to: Michel El Zoghbi Prepared by: Maher Moubarak Mirna El Khoury Outline: 1. Abstract 2. Introduction 3. Literature Review 4. Centuries 5. Instruments 6. Effects on Russian Music: * Effects of War * Problems caused by Russian Climate 7. Conclusion 8. References Abstract: This term paper will be discussing the history of the Russian music and its evolvement. Moreover, it will include some native instruments and the effect of weather, war, and religion on the Russian music. Introduction: Beginning from the sacred music of the Russian Orthodox Church and passing through diverse centuries, the Russian music was and will always be legacy in the history of international music. Two major genres formed the early history of the Russian music. These genres are: the secular music used for entertainment and the sacred music of the Orthodox Church . The sacred music draws its tradition from the Byzantine Empire. Neumes were developed for musical notation, and as a result several examples of medieval sacred music have survived, among them two stichera composed by Tsar Ivan IV in the 16th century. Literature Review Folk music is certainly the oldest type of Russian music. The roots of Russian folk music dates back to the middle of the first millennium AC. Russian music started with the Slavic tribes that settled in the European part of the current territory of Russia.......

Words: 1785 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Karl Marx Essay

...and he was also a Jew (World Book Encyclopedia 236M). On August 26, 1824 Karl and his whole family were baptized, so his family turned away from its traditional Jewish teachings to Protestant Christianity (Payne 21). At the age of twelve Karl entered the Friedrich Wilhiem Gymnasium. He stayed there for five years excelling in foreign languages, but not really caring about mathematics and history (Payne 23). Karl’s father decided that Karl would attend the University of Bonn to study law (World Book Encyclopedia 236M). Karl became an active member of “poetry clubs,” while studying at the University. The poetry clubs of Marx’s time was more of a revolutionary club than anything. The club members would sit around and practice the art of revolution (Payne 43). Marx only stayed at the University of Bonn for two semesters. Karl then went on to attend the University of Berlin where he grew more distant from his father (Payne 52). Marx’s father died on May 10, 1838 at the age of fifty-six. Marx...

Words: 1210 - Pages: 5