Free Essay

Rhetorical Criticism

In: English and Literature

Submitted By hs1988
Words 1873
Pages 8
Pentadic analysis incorporates five basic elements of drama called pentads. These include act (what is being done), agent (who is doing the act), agency (the means employed by the agent to do the act), scene (the backdrop against which the act occurred), and the purpose of the action (the reason why it happened). Act is the artifact itself whatever it may be such as speech, poem, monument, event, etc as it stands for what is actually being done or happening. Agent refers to the main communicator of the artifact which could be an actor, orator, writer or manager of the act. Agency refers to the main medium of communication which includes a book or televised film, presentation or personal communication. Scene is the backdrop against which the action occurs including the actual, physical scene and the context in which something happens and is meant to be understood. Lastly, purpose is the motive or the message which is conveyed and understood.
Pentadic analysis has its roots in Burke's Theory of Dramatism which looks at life as a play where symbols and language are used to express thoughts as a way for humans to comprehend the reality of the world. Burke developed this theory as a way to attempt to understand the bases of human conduct and motives. Thus, the purpose of a pentadic analysis addresses the content of what is being done and what are the motives of a certain artifact as crafted by a rhetor.
Burke believed that ratios interconnect important terms and map out a clearer picture of the underlying intentions or motives in a situation. Act-scene and act-agent are the most commonly used for rhetorical criticism. Act-scene shows that the act can not be fully understood without taking the scene into account as the backdrop against which it happened. Act-agent highlights the importance of the agent on the act and shows their relationship of mutual dependence.
The name of the artifact I have chosen is Barack Obama’s speech “A More Perfect Union” in Philadelphia during the election race, published on March 18, 2008 for the purpose of conducting a pentadic analysis.
This analysis will attempt to discuss the reasons underlying the rhetorical choices made by the orator in his speech, the motives he was guided by and what he actually said or did.
Act
The act refers to what is being done and this quite simply incorporates the contents of the speech and the way they are presented. In this speech, Obama was responding to the great attention garnered by the highly sensationalist comments of the Reverend Jeremiah Wright who was, until recently, his pastor and an active member of his campaign team. The contents of the speech included talk on the sensitive and controversial topics of racial tensions which existed across different ethnicities and races in United States, the white privilege which implies that white people enjoy many privileges at the expense of the hardships experienced by the colored people, inequality and justice, framing his speech against the wider spectrum of the issue of race which exists in the United States. It speaks out boldly about the ‘original sin of slavery’ which led to the creation of concepts of racial superiority and inferiority, bigotry and fixated stereotypes which have fed our national psyches till today. Even while condemning Reverend Wright’s racially discriminatory remarks, he yet attempts to not exactly defend, but portray him in a softer light as a man who introduced him to his Christian faith, presided over his wedding, baptized his daughters, and taught him many good things. In this regard, he speaks about the many stereotypes which are heard in normal life, the fixed notions which are wrong but uttered without any conscious ill will as they have become embedded in our mindsets. He also mentions his mixed heritage and the impact it has had on his support and in the elections with people continuing to view and judge him in light of his race, rather than his abilities and actions as well as the way race and racism define the worldview of many who grew up with their dreams vanquished and opportunities snatched at the altar of racial discrimination. However, he stresses that the important issues which afflict the country ultimately do not discriminate between color or race but affect us all and the only way to counter them is to stand united, work together, achieve harmony and achieve a true state of the union.
Obama’s speech has all the ingredients which would appeal to the American public, from all races and colors. It is ironic that his own profile of mixed race is what would initially attract viewers from across the color spectrum to listen to his speech, but Obama also utilizes this in his speech by mentioning it not as a score point but as a fact of our national psyche. His attempts to address the issue of racial discrimination and grievances of both blacks and whites strikes the right note, being empathetic, respectful and honest, he does not alienate any group. His words addressing the challenges and problems currently afflicting the United States attempt to create cohesion by showing the commonality among Americans of all races and how important it is for them to achieve unity. His beginning words which speak about the Declaration of Independence and what it represented for America and all of her citizens is especially powerful in creating a picture of a common history and a shared vision.
Agent
Obama is the agent, being the orator of the speech. It is not merely his candid words but also his frank and manly style in publicly addressing topics which had previously been brushed under the carpet that mark him as a superb orator. The oratorical resonance of parallel constructs also stands out to further improve his delivery style. It has been the opinion of many that Obama’s speech sounds much better than it reads. The pace, rhythm and tone in delivery create a rhythm and flow which is not found in the text of his speech. The personal touch added to it as Obama weaves himself in the narrative or racial background and racism is also quite effective. In addition to the references to history, Obama also incorporates stylistic touches borrowed from great political leaders and orators from the past to make his oratory more powerful. The choice of words which immediately strike a chord with the public helps him connect instantly with his audience. In addition, a delivery which marks each phrase as weighty, each ideal as lofty, each grievance as important and each dream as worthy, in short, his ability to reach out to the people and show himself to be a part of them is what makes him draw the people to himself. His intonation, emphasis on certain words and subtle pauses help him highlight the points he really intends to strike home.
Agency
Agency refers to the medium through which the message is delivered. Obama’s speech was delivered directly to many, some saw it on television, some heard it on radio and some read it in the newspaper. For those who saw it on television, the combination of the body language, facial expressions and gestures was powerful enough to draw the viewers in and make them understand, respect and trust the man who was one of them, talking to them and wanting to work for them. His posture including the way he stood or leaned in to the people, his use of eye contact and facial expressions also displayed great strength, conviction and confidence. Hands are extremely powerful tools and his use of gestures such as open palms to draw the people in, joined fists to show his ideas of the unity of the people, thumping the desk for emphasis and show his strength were all important indicators of his inclination and moods. For many who heard it on the radio, the effect was not quite as powerful without the live spectacle. For those who read the speech, it was said to make some good points but incline a little towards insipidity. Thus, television was the strongest medium as his speech appeared much more powerful while being viewed and heard instead of just being read.
Scene
The rationale behind the speech was to counter the Jeremiah Wright controversy and to display his stance and attitude towards racial issues and racially antagonizing language. It was meant to provide the background on his history with Wright, show his opinion on Wright personally and on racial issues and race in general. This worked as it allowed him to portray his take on key but controversial issues with utmost honest to the public. The background of the speech was the Independence Hall, where the famous Declaration of Independence was signed by the Pilgrims who came to live in a place where there would be unity, freedom and tolerance. This particular scene was created to show the common history which the people share as a way of unifying them by linking them to the past and the shared vision which their ancestors had by making them understand that however racial divisiveness may segregate them and racial discrimination alienate them from each other, their problems and their dreams to overcome the problems still remain the same. By using Philadelphia, with the Independence Hall standing as a reminder in the backdrop, Obama attempts to recreate the same spirit and unity which marked the pilgrims.
Purpose
The purpose of the speech was to make the people understands that their main identity is not mired in ethnicities, races, religions, colors and castes but in their common nationality of being Americans. Obama attempts to clear his own stance on racial discrimination. But in the larger context, he tries to bring the people together and attempt to foster a feeling of unity, courage and enthusiasm in them, to make them look at the broader picture and the long run. An Obama was also attempting by this speech to emerge as a key political player, a powerful orator and a person who had the power and charisma to attract the masses across all segments of the society. Judging by the positive reviews and praises Obama received and the fact that his speech was widely viewed heard and read as well as shared on social networking sites and youtube Obama was successful in achieving his objectives. Lastly, Obama was attempting to pacify the white voters so as not to alienate them and his victory at the ballot is proof of his success on that score.
Pentadic Ratio: act/scene Obama’s words can not be fully understood nor the power of their meaning fully comprehended without understanding the context. His words of the racial tensions, discrimination and tensions have their roots in the history of slavery and oppression of blacks. They also represent a slight to the struggle and vision of the pilgrims as they signed the Declaration of Independence. In the immediate context, the speech was set against Reverend Wright’s remarks which has hurt and offended many.
Act/agent
Without Obama’s oratorical style, the speech would definitely not have been such a great a success. Thus, the agent is what made the act powerful.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Re: Week 10

...Worksheet for Viewing The Arts of Criticism . . . Giving and Receiving Name: __Rahul Anantoju____________________________ After viewing the video, please answer the following questions: 1. What is the purpose of the self-test for someone giving criticism? To think about giving criticism making sure criticism is legitimate or not, to make situation better for everybody, to help. 2. Which comes first, your self-test or the EPM formula? Self-test 3. Have you seen others criticize like Everett did the first time? What happened? Yes I did, and my boss was angry at a colleague for not attending a meeting, and criticized. My colleague defended, as a result, things did not work well between the two. 4. Have you ever taken criticism personally? What did you do? I haven’t taken any criticism personally and always learnt from it. 5. What did Beverly have to gain from listening to the criticism? It was hurting Beverly’s career and the company, added cost and nearly lost the client for one project 6. What does EPM stand for? E-empathize P-pin point problems M-move forward 7. Read the following scenario and fill in E, P, M: a. Carlos, who has a desk close to yours, often borrows items from your desk while you are away. When he returns these items, they are often damaged – the stapler is broken, or the policy manual has pages missing. You’ve kept silent about it for several months, but now you are especially upset because the batteries are...

Words: 509 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Blankdoc

...Game Journal 6 The school of criticism that made the most sense to me was by far the biographical critique. In my opinion the vast majority of the other critiques read as though the author was simply trying to find examples for that particular type of critique where there was probably very little intentioned meaning behind it. Some of the meaning behind the game that was analyzed seemed as though it was forced. The biographical critique, however, analyzes the author’s intent behind the game using quotes from the author himself. This lends more authority to the critique and prevented it from feeling as though meaningless aspects of the game were being critiqued. In the biographical critique for Katamari Damacy the critic uses the author’s own words to describe how the author intended the game to affect his audience. This is information straight from the source and thus allows for the game to be looked at in a new light. The author intended the game’s peaceful, fun, game that is almost devoid of conflict to brighten the lives of everyone that played it and thus make the world better. The critic in a more thorough analysis could then have described whether the game is successful in doing that, and if so by how much. The biographical critique provided the author’s motivations behind making the game. This is a strong basis on which to critique the game. Analyze the author’s intent behind making the game along with how well the game imparts the author’s message. By doing this...

Words: 344 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Film

.... 7) “Write a critical study of a recent Spanish or Latin American film or play that you have seen, and that has made a social or political impact in the country in which you are living. You should bring into your study criticism and reviews, both from the press and, where possible, from academic sources, and…discuss the ways in which the film has been received and analysed, making comparisons with other films where appropriate.” Almodóvar ’s 2001, La piel que habito, received mixed reviews from Spanish critics, one favourably calling it an “irracionalidad transcendida” whereas Spanish film critic Carlos Boyero called it a “notable idiotez”. However, most critics agree that this film merits a second viewing in order to appreciate the rich texture of the film, in which a lonely and haunted plastic surgeon (Banderas) becomes dangerously entangled with his personal experiment, Vicente, or “Vera” (Anaya) whom he believed had assaulted his mentally ill daughter, provoking her suicide. The film is the director’s first exploration of science fiction, containing an amalgamation of themes concerning gender and sexuality identity, whilst at the same time exploring the prison house of the self. In this essay I will discuss the ways in which these main themes are manifested in the plot and cinematography, their effect and finally the way in which Spanish critics have received Almodóvar’s latest work. Entrapment, or, the prison house of the self, is the confinement that all...

Words: 2230 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Models Not Critics

...First Essay Discovery Draft “Young people need models not critics,” has got to be everything I’ve ever tried to explain to other adults in six simple words. I feel as though it’s in an adult’s nature to judge the younger generation in ways that no one would like to be judged. Although their assumptions could be true some assumptions are literally ridiculous. Some adults criticize our every move, some not as much as others, but for the ones who do there’s a pattern in their behavior. After they point out our flaws and mistakes, adults switch up and do the same thing they never told us to do. Now I completely understand when an adult wants us to do the right thing and not follow in their footsteps, but a lot of the younger generation goes with the slogan “seeing is believing.” In my own opinion talk is cheap, and I would rather see something actually happen in the case of critiquing. Fix yourself before you try and fix somebody else’s mistakes. Being the age that I am, I’m only speaking from the younger generation’s side. I may be wrong but my opinion on “Young people need models not critics” still holds. I do however slightly understand when adults want us to know right from wrong, and know to do the right thing. My problem with this is after or in some occasions before they preach to us about being the best we can be, they demonstrate the total opposite. Being part of the younger generation I’m not sure if I’m speaking for myself when I say we don’t need a how to. What we...

Words: 441 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Best Practices Supervisor’s Manual

...11. Demonstrating Communication Skills: Giving and Receiving Criticism Throughout a supervisor’s career, he or she will be expected to critique an employee’s performance and provide feedback. In addition, he or she will be the object of criticism, both in job performance and the way in which he or she responds to the employees. A supervisor may feel that it is only the intent of the message that matters, but proper delivery is important as well (Chambers, 74). A good critique must be necessary to the employee’s performance. It should be noted that it is a waste of time to criticize factors that are not important to the job. This evaluation should also be fair and positive and intended to improve one’s job performance. This communication should be tactful, fair and kept in a positive light. The supervisor should also be able to receive criticism. He or she should remember that these comments are intended to improve performance and to help develop a better relationship with employees. Developing Effective Listening Skills A supervisor needs to be an effective listener. In order to be effective, one must want to be effective. The first suggestion for improving this skill is to engage in active listening practices, such as repeating the information in order to confirm understanding (Chambers, 162). One might also want to time the discussion so that it takes place during the peak of the day’s energy (such as first thing in the morning). Most importantly, an individual with good...

Words: 688 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

What My School Needs

...teaching students how to professionally critique fellow classmates work and how to handle criticism of their own work. Most classes require students to present their assignments or projects to the entire class and students are encouraged to give their opinions and thoughts on the presented work. This is where I’ve noticed that many students struggle or fall short. Many are afraid to comment on others work, either because that is their friend or because they feel if they say something that isn’t boosting the presented work then others would do the same when it comes to his or her turn. Students need to able to give constructive criticism in a professional manner and not be concerned about it sounding harsh or “I did not want to hurt his/her feelings”. In the real world being able to criticize presented artwork or design work in the right manner is very important as it shows knowledge in the topic and being able to make one understand where him or her can get better. The same goes for accepting criticism. I experienced a situation where a student got so upset that she started crying because not everyone in the class thought her work was executed right. Students need to be taught on how to accept criticism and use it to better themselves rather than taking it negatively. Upon talking to a few students I’ve noticed that their main concern is they feel that their work didn’t deserve the criticism and it...

Words: 413 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Argumentative Essay

...Jenia De Silva, M.Ed NAV 501 16 March 2016 Is Criticism Beneficial? In every part of the organization, there will always be criticism involved from someone else whether that criticism is regarding business, politics, sports and among others. Most of the time people consider criticism in a negative aspect since it usually creates anger, resentment, frustration and among others to the one who usually received the criticism. Therefore, whenever we receive criticism from someone else, we immediately create an unfavorable outcome towards that person. But did you know that not all criticisms are harmful or produced a negative consequence; in fact, it would still be beneficial to the person who received the criticism? There are two types of criticism namely constructive and destructive criticism. Constructive criticism is the one that intends only to give feedback for improvement/suggestion whether positive or negative about a particular product, service or event/performance. On the contrary, destructive criticism does not intend to give feedback for improvement/suggestion to someone else’s work but rather it intends to harm someone’s feelings by giving direct insult to his/her work or personality. Both types of criticism can be beneficial; it just depends on how it was handled by someone else when the situation arises. The criticism if properly managed can give several benefits to someone who usually received the criticism from other people such as it can help improve...

Words: 978 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Complaining vs Getting Involved

...complain about our pay cuts, loss of benefits, and our work conditions. I also hear about how much our job has changed, how benefits and work related rules that protect and alleviate our work conditions seem like a dream, a thing from the past. When I go to the supermarket, or even attend church I hear, my congregation complaining. It seems hard to get away from all of this negativity, and at times, trying to stay positive and non-reactive can feel almost impossible. Yes its bound to happen, we all encounter difficulties in our lives, most of them unexpectedly. I can affirm and confirm that most of us, during these difficult times will feel the need to complain, and allow ourselves to be part of this negative wave that can drive us to criticism as well as negative thinking and complaining. We often hear that famous proverb, “misery likes company.” Can this be true? Are we all compelled day-by-day to act and react?...

Words: 781 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Sometihing

...not a torture technique that involves forced simulated drowning. Less remarkable, perhaps, but possibly more relevant for most of us, we’ve heard the term “downsized” used when someone is fired or laid off. “Ethnic cleansing” covers everything from deportation to genocide. What we have to say may be important, but the words we choose to say it with can be equally important. The examples just given are cases of a certain type of linguistic coercion—an attempt to get us to adopt a particular attitude toward a subject that, if described differently, would seem less attractive to us. Words have tremendous persuasive power, or what we have called their rhetorical force or emotive meaning—their power to express and elicit images, feelings, and emotional associations. In the next few chapters, we examine some of the most common rhetorical techniques used to affect people’s attitudes, opinions, and behavior. Rhetoric refers to the study of persuasive writing. As we use the term, it denotes a broad category of linguistic techniques people use Moore−Parker: Critical Thinking, Ninth Edition 5. Persuasion Through Rhetoric: Common Devices and...

Words: 15202 - Pages: 61

Free Essay

The End of Men Essay

...starting to meet the demands of the feminists. In her article “The End of Men” from July/August 2010 in ‘The Atlantic’ Hanna Rosin addresses how the world is adjusting to the wave of dominating feminists, and how a matriarchy could be starting to occur. But could this change in the end be “The End of Men”? Rosin sets of her article with statistical facts stating that for every 2 men that achieves a college education, 3 women achieve the same. She uses these facts to prove with logos that equality for women is actually starting to come through, after saying this she asks the rhetorical question: “But what if equality isn’t the end point? What if modern, postindustrial society is simply better suited to women?”(p.1 ,ll 4-5). This rhetorical question could have been the question in Rosin’s head that made her write this article, because the article keeps coming back to this issue. By putting this rhetorical somewhat provoking statement in the beginning of the article, she also catches the reader and set the agenda for the article. Moving on she introduces the reader to the male chauvinist Ronald Ericsson. As Rosin states, Ericsson was the biologist that figured out how to isolate the male chromosome in semen, making it possible only to spawn boys. The fact that Ericsson on top of this discovery was a radical male chauvinist, had feminists worrying that they were headed for a male dystopia, as the article says. “Ericsson now 74, laughed when I read him these quotes from his old...

Words: 1044 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Manoying the Manoy

...DESCRIPTION is one of four rhetorical modes (also known as modes of discourse), along with exposition, argumentation, and narration. Each of the rhetorical modes is present in a variety of forms and each has its own purpose and conventions. Description is also the fiction-writing mode for transmitting a mental image of the particulars of a story. Description as a fiction-writing mode Fiction is a form of narrative, one of the four rhetorical modes of discourse. Fiction-writing also has distinct forms of expression, or modes, each with its own purposes and conventions. Agent and author Evan Marshall (agent) identifies five fiction-writing modes: action, summary, dialogue, feelings/thoughts, and background (Marshall 1988, pp. 143–165). Author and writing-instructor Jessica Page Morrell lists six delivery modes for fiction-writing: action, exposition, description, dialogue, summary, and transition (Morrell 2006, p. 127). Author Peter Selgin refers to methods, including action, dialogue, thoughts, summary, scene, and description (Selgin 2007, p. 38). Currently, there is no consensus within the writing community regarding the number and composition of fiction-writing modes and their uses. Description is the fiction-writing mode for transmitting a mental image of the particulars of a story. Together with dialogue, narration, exposition, and summarization, description is one of the most widely recognized of the fiction-writing modes. As stated in Writing from A to Z, edited by Kirk...

Words: 1898 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

My Movie Critique of the Blind Side

...film critic’s reviews on a particular film. In some cases, if a film critic decides that a movie is good, not every movie goer will feel the same way. I have sat and listened to Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert as they either praised or destroyed a film. Whenever I chose to go and view a film they have given their customary thumbs up to I would normally not enjoy the film. It is possible that I did not see the same things within a film as they did as it was evident that I was not viewing the film in the same manner as a film critic by looking for camera angles, editing, or frames. All that I cared about was escaping for a couple of hours and receiving some enjoyment from the movie. Some people feel that this is a special time for film criticism. Never before have more people been able to express their views about a film. Being a film critic was once a profession, but it’s not a job any longer and there is not a huge financial gain by doing so. However, this opens the door for those who want to critique a film and also provides the chance for those who really care about movies and enjoy expressing themselves a forum in which to do so. Anyone with access to a computer needs only to use their internet connection in order to begin their reviews of movies. Many people are given the opportunity to write long and often expert posts on such sites as IMDb, Amazon, Rotten Tomatoes and in the comment threads of...

Words: 2094 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Linking Words

...X it is important to note Y By the same token, … But we should also consider, … Despite these criticisms, …it’s popularity remains high. Certainly, there is no shortage of disagreement within… Consequently, … Correspondingly, … Conversely, … Chaytor, … in particular, has focused on the Despite this, … Despite these criticisms, … the popularity of X remains largely undiminished. Each of these theoretical positions make an important contribution to our understanding of, … Evidence for in support of this position, can be found in…, Evidently, For this reason, … For these reasons, … Furthermore, … Given, the current high profile debate with regard to, …it is quite surprising that … Given, the advantages of … outlined in the previous paragraph, …it is quite predictable that … However, … Having considered X, it is also reasonable to look at … Hence, … In addition to, … In contrast, … In this way, … In this manner, … In the final analysis, … In short, … Indeed, … It can be seen from the above analysis that, … It could also be said that, … It is however, important to note the limitations of… It is important however not to assume the applicability of, …in all cases. It is important however not to overemphasis the strengths of … In the face of such criticism, proponents of, …have responded in a number of ways. Moreover, … Notwithstanding such criticism, ….it’s popularity remains largely undiminished. Notwithstanding these limitations, ….it worth...

Words: 477 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Honest Trailers: Movie Analysis

...Criticism-Why is it typically thought of as negative? Most times when we think of the word criticism, we think of it in a negative way. However, there are many different ways that one can critique something. For example, Siskel & Ebert “Halloween” (1978) film review expresses that you can create a gruesome, but still entertaining movie. Criticism can also be a favorable praise (Siskel and Ebert); which is what they give the entire film. The mother played in the movie is independent, intelligent, spunky and interesting.” She is not portrayed as being the typical, clumsy female in average horror films. It shows that the writer is appreciative of women and film (Siskel & Ebert). They were not knocking horror films, just a certain kind and addressing...

Words: 629 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Movie Critic Paper

...Movie Critic Devin L. Burks University of Phoenix February 23, 2015 LUCY For some months into 2015, this movie, Lucy has been hitting theater headlines across the world. It has consistently received diversified opinions from movie critics. From what I can see on the online reviews, it has received both positive and negative criticisms from all over the world. It leaves a lot of questions than answers as to why there is so much fuss around this particular film. Confused about what to believe in, I opted to watch the movie, albeit with an open mind. Lucy is a Sci-Fiction film, filled with some action and adventure. It is about a young girl, a student, who gets involved with a drug dealing boyfriend. Her boyfriend asks her to do a single drop inside a hotel while he waits outside. But the drug lord has other ideas, he kills the boyfriend and forces the girl to transit his drugs, hidden in her stomach. The drug bag busts open and she is exposed to the drug. The content of the drug sends her brain into unprecedented over-drive, manifesting the real powers of a human brain. She acquires enormous supernatural powers; she becomes a great warrior, able to understand everything around her, ranging from languages, medical conditions to mind reading. She is also able to travel through time, from the past to the present day. The movie is faced paced, quickly moving between time. The parallel transition between Lucy’s story...

Words: 726 - Pages: 3