Free Essay

Rough Point "Death at the Gates"

In: People

Submitted By rascal6842
Words 5165
Pages 21
Rough Point “Death At The Gates”

Doris Duke came into the world in grand fashion, just as she would live her life. Born in a state of the art hospital, constructed within the walls of the Fifth Avenue Mansion built just for her anticipated arrival. That arrival came on November 22, 1912, she was quickly dubbed, ‘The Richest Baby In The World’ (Thomas & Duke, 1995, p. 222). Doris Duke was the combination of passion, brilliance, indulgence, and greed. Vindictiveness was never far removed from her surface. Doris Duke was the quintessence of wealth and power; additionally, she heeded her father’s warning and trusted no one. Exit from her life was on her terms, terms, which were cold, calculated, and methodically carried out. Damage control fell into the laps of the army of attorneys under her employ. Never was this more evident than the night of October 7, 1966, with the violent death of Eduardo Tirella. While Eduardo Tirella’s death is viewed accidental, Doris Duke’s innocence is at question because evidence suggests murder covered up and masked by her influence, power, and wealth.
Doris’s father James Buchanan Duke, made provisions for her, whereupon his death she would become “The Richest Girl In The World”. On December 11, 1924 James Duke signed his name to the Doris Duke Trust. Under the provisions of the trust Doris was to receive 125,904 shares of the stock of Duke Power Company, two shares of common stock of Southern Power Company, and two shares of common stock of Great Falls Power Company. Additionally, Doris was to receive a yearly payment of two thirds of the net incomes, revenues, and profits received from the funds and properties of the trust. Upon reaching the age of 21 final distributions of all revenues, incomes, profits, and properties will be passed to said Doris Duke (Doris Duke Trust, 1981). James B. Duke's death was to come 364 days later.
In the days following his death the reading of the will took place. This would set the stage for an ongoing feud with her mother, Nanaline Duke. While his wife was left a modest trust of $100,000 per year the bulk of his estate would be left to Doris. At the tender age of 12, Doris would realize her vast wealth. In addition to the trust worth $100 million, she assumed her father's estate, estimated at $80 million. This included the assets of Duke Tobacco and Duke Power (J. Williams, Doris Duke, nd). Additionally, she acquired diverse real estate holdings in four states.
Properties included the 35,000 ft. Duke Mansion, 67,000 ft. Duke Farms, 19,500 ft.² Duke Penthouse and the 40,000 ft. James B. Duke House, and the 39,000 ft. summer cottage Rough Point estate on the Atlantic Coast of Newport Rhode Island (Inventory of the James Buchanan Duke Papers, 1770-1990). Doris continued to reside with her mother Nanaline in New York at the James B. Duke House. Nanaline, from the time of conception resented the baby in her womb. Nanaline had dreams that her son, Walker Inman Sr. from her first marriage would be the sole benefactor of Duke’s estate, but that dream was crushed with the birth of Doris and again with the reading of the will. Nanaline realized she would have to rely on 12-year-old Doris for money. With her newfound wealth, Doris, in less than a year would realize the power and influence that came with that.
At the age of 13 she used her power and influence for the first time as she amassed a collection of attorneys to battle her mother. Nanaline, seeing a loophole in the will attempted to sell off some of the estates. Litigation dragged at the hands of the attorneys, the estates were put up for auction at, which time Doris purchased them out right. Nanaline lost to Doris once again. Concluding her battle with Nanaline a then 13-year-old Doris retreated to her beloved Duke Farm estate, were she would live alone, surrounded by only servants for companionship (Harmon, 2001). Doris would continue to rely on her power and influence over her attorneys throughout her life. The many attorneys were called to action and into battle to protect her pride, nobody was to gain the upper hand no matter what the expense. Doris proved she was a force to be reckoned with. On October 25, 1943 under orders from Doris, her attorneys filed for divorce from her first husband, James Cromwell in Reno, Nevada. The divorce was granted on December 21, 1943. However, James in the New Jersey courts claiming Doris was not a legal resident of Nevada quickly contested the underhanded divorce decree. Jimmy's lawyers propose a settlement of $1 million. Doris, through her attorneys counters with an offer of $500,000 and not a dime more (Thomas and Duke, “The Heiress Goes To War,” 1995). After years of petitions and appeals the divorce is awarded on January 16, 1948. James Cromwell is awarded $350,000 (Doris Duke Papers, 1798-2003). Her refusal to settle with Jimmy would be her first win as well her established pattern in dealing with anyone attempting to exploit her. When Doris believed she was right, no expense was spared on legal fees in her fight to win. This principle continued throughout her life.
In 1946 Doris called upon her lawyers to negotiate the purchase for Danielle Darrieux's husband Porfiro Rubirosa. Danielle in exchange for a divorce accepted the $1 million offer. Doris and Porfiro married a year later September 1, 1947. On the day of the wedding under the pressure of Doris's attorneys Porfiro signed away his rights to the Duke fortune in exchange for a payment of $25,000 per year to continue even in the event of a divorce until he remarried. That divorce came a year later October 27, 1948 (Thomas Duke, “New Interest…New Men,” 1995).
Doris quickly realized she could buy whatever she desired including people. With her attorneys at her side she could free herself and discard these very same people as easily as she acquired them. This included her attorneys, friends, and employees whom were not immune to her power and influence. Act upon the calling of Doris no matter the deed or face the wrath of an angry bitter Duke. This was soon to be the reality of one Eduardo Tirella.
Eduardo Tirella was a tall, witty and handsome man living in Los Angeles. Eduardo possessed many talents as a designer of hats, a motion picture set designer, and an interior decorator. With the touch of his hand he could transform drab into a work of beauty. Working in the motion picture business Eduardo's circle of friends were powerful and famous including Peggy Lee, Elizabeth Taylor, and Joey Castro. It was through Joey's association with Doris that would bring Eduardo into her life as shown in financial records their chance meeting took place in October 1960 (Doris Duke Paper, 1798-2003).
From the beginning she was taken in by his masculinity and style. Even more appealing to Doris was the fact and Eduardo was openly gay. During this time Doris’s interest in men was exchanged for a love of beauty. With Eduardo, she began to envision the transformation his talent would bring to her various estates.
Rough Point, in the affluent town of Newport, Rhode Island would be the setting for Eduardo's entrance into Doris's grand life. Six years later it would become the scene of his death. Rough Point was considered the white elephant; it was cold, drafty, dark, and eerie. Hanging from the walls were huge dark tapestries, oversized ominous paintings, and gilded furniture. Noise would echo down the barren halls, trees brushing against the windows were amplified causing bone-chilling fear, which was intensified with the crashing waves of the ocean. Doris needed Eduardo and he needed her checkbook. Although talented he was a disastrous businessman offering his decorative talents to the stars at no charge. For this reason he found himself living on a mere $4,000 per year. Without hesitation when offered the job to redesign the ancient kitchen at Rough Point he accepted. This was the beginning as Doris Duke’s Interior Decorator.
Eduardo's use of his decorating gift successfully transformed the once ancient kitchen into a showpiece of inland marble contrasted only by the vast collection of copper and silver. Doris immediately hired him to redecorate a hotel in Pasadena, California that she purchased to house the headquarters of the Self Realization Society. Eduardo, becoming more aware and intrigued at the depth of Doris's bank accounts and the ability they possessed to finance his creativity (Thomas and Duke, “Death AT The Gates,” 1995). Eduardo's decorating position expanded to other estates, after the successful transformation of the 105 rooms at Rough Point (Doris Duke Papers, 1922-1997). Eduardo completed the transformation of Duke Gardens, Duke Mansion, and the Hawaiian estate known as Shangri-La. Over the years of this position transferred to that of companion.
As Doris’s companion they traveled the world, shopping for the most valuable treasures that would eventually find their way into the many estates and warehouses already filled with millions of dollars of rare paintings, sculptures, silver, tapestries, and Asian art. The two were inseparable as evident of his pay and travel records (Doris Duke Paper, 1922-1998). Doris’s affection toward Eduardo continued to grow, she was attracted to his virile and masculine looks, but he quickly let her know that a woman stood no chance in his life. Doris withdrew her advances, she could always find a man, but a fabulous decorator was a treasure. In a letter dated Thursday, January 11, 1962 Eduardo while in Paris, writes of the antique shops and Doris’s purchase of a $3 million painting. Additionally, he speaks of their travel plans to include Luxemburg, Rome, Belgium, Holland and England. Here Doris introduced him to the Duke and Duchess of Windsor. Although having a grand time, Doris was spending millions, and he was in need of money. Included with this letter was a request to Pete Cooley of Duke Power Company to wire money to avoid asking Doris for a loan (Doris Duke Papers, 1922-1998). While unknown, if this were an underhanded move on Eduardo's part evidence suggests his funding was reduced over the next year. In late January 1962 into late February 1963 Doris enacted the aid of her attorney Pete Cooley to handle a payment dispute initiated by Eduardo on January 29, 1962. Eduardo makes his attempt at a request for more money, as he feels undercut for not receiving the wage of an architect. Two things of interest take place during this time. Doris had always given freely to Eduardo, but now has her attorney dealing with his requests. Pete Cooley, who had wired the money to Eduardo earlier was now refusing his request. In his reply letter dated February 28, 1963, Pete Cooley downplays the talent of Eduardo in stating, “in our opinion, this is the job for architect who has had experience in designing buildings, in drawing up the specifications, letting bids, supervising, etc.” (Doris Duke Papers, 1922-1998). Eduardo viewed this as a fracture in his friendship with Doris as well her associates.
Over the next few years the friendship is further strained. Doris, enjoying her weekly spendable income of approximately $1 million, Eduardo was going broke. This was mainly do to the fact that Doris never carried cash and he found himself paying various tabs therefore, much of his income was spent on his benefactor. Money had become a contention between him and his benefactor. In addition to the issue of money, staff witnessed Doris yelling and barking orders at Tirella an aggression not previously witnessed.
He now found himself in a position where he could no longer keep up with the demands thrown his way. Growing tired of Doris’s mood swings and demands and fearing his motion picture design career was suffering because, his time was monopolized by Doris. This would soon to change with an incoming call (Thomas and Duke, “Death At The Gates,” 1995). In June 1966, Producer Martin Ransohoff called to offer Tirella a set design job on the film “Don't Make Waves”, which he accepted. This is supported with evidence of his last pay record dated June 2, 1966 (Doris Duke Papers, 1922-1998).
Doris panicked when told of the news by Eduardo. Her life revolved around his ability to make her surroundings beautiful. Intimidated by Doris he used the excuse of needing dental work from his trusted Los Angeles dentist. Fearing his departure, she offered at her expense to have whatever work needed to be done in New York. Tirella went to Los Angeles despite her offer.
In Los Angeles, Eduardo began receiving pleading calls from Doris offering more money and the reconsideration to finance his Big Sur Project. Anything he wanted was his for the taking if he would return to Newport. Eduardo, returned to Doris in early October 1966, but not for the purpose of work. Eduardo had come to gather his belongings but Doris had Tirella, and she was adamant she would not lose him. Over the next few days Doris tried feverishly to convince him to stay. He was offered more money and a place in history as the famous decorator of Doris Duke. Eduardo was besieged with offers and promises, but his mind was made up, he was returning to Hollywood. Eduardo's dream of set designing ended on October 7, 1966 (Thomas and Duke, “Death At The Gates,” 1955).
Friday, October 7 started out casually. Eduardo had agreed to drive Doris to a business meeting for one of her many charitable organizations. At approximately 4 PM they got into a rented car, which suggest Doris had premeditated the event to come and did not want to damage one of many luxury cars housed at the estate. This is further supported by evidence of the Avis Rental Car Agreement (Doris Duke Papers, 1922-1998). With Eduardo behind the wheel they approached the iron gates, reaching 20 feet tall, each weighing over a ton. Eduardo got out to open the gate as he placed himself between the car and gates Doris slid to the driver's seat. The car continued to lunge forward wedging him against the gate. With the car roaring forward the gates let loose falling to the street below, the body of Tirella was caught between the car and toppled gates. Still the automobile kept moving forward. “As his body was ground to pieces by a combination of scraping iron, machinery, and pavement, the car kept pushing until the wreckage, both human and mechanical, stopped on the other side of the street, jammed against a large tree” (Thomas and Duke, “Death At The Gates,” 1955). This is further supported in the police incident report. Eduardo was left unrecognizable, in a pool blood, flesh, and brain matter, his head crushed, his ears, nose, and eyes were left amongst the rubble. Doris ran to the house in unusual fashion started to scream “Eduardo, Eduardo, Eduardo” you should not have wanted to leave. The arriving ambulance was there not for Tirella but to whisk Doris away to the hospital for minor cuts. Doris was kept in isolation overnight. Strict orders came down from Duke's attorneys that she was not to be questioned. The attorneys never worked so fast as the story became headline news. Additional orders followed. Servants worked feverishly at Duke Farms and Rough Point packing Tirella’s belongings and had them removed. Groundskeepers were dispatched to the scene to erase the blood and skid marks from the road. Landscapers restored and replaced damaged shrubbery and patches of lawn overnight, erasing the hopes for sordid photographs by the flock of reporters arriving the following morning. The gates were removed, repaired, and rehung and the rental car disappeared only to be viewed and inspected one-time and then never seen again (Thomas and Duke, “Death At The Gates,” 1955). Attorneys called in Politicians from Providence and Washington and deals were made. Duke’s lawyers knew Doris could be charged for manslaughter, or worse yet murder. All they could do was wait for the investigation to unfold (Doris Duke Papers, 1922-1998).
While there was an investigation, very little evidence remains today because all records of the investigation have disappeared. The vast collection in the Doris Duke Papers contains significant information up to the days preceding Eduardo's death then nothing, until a year later. In contacting the Newport Police and the Supreme Court of Rhode Island no records were found. What is known, Newport Police Chief Joseph A. Radice headed up the investigation along with Detective Capt., Paul J. Sullivan. Questioned at the scene were Navy Ensign Judith Thomb and her father Lewis Thomb, the first to come upon the scene, “told police they found Miss Duke wondering dazed in the road bleeding from head cuts” (Newport Daily News, 1966, p. 1). Additionally, various members of the staff were questioned regarding statements made when Doris entered the house. Doris was not questioned until Sunday.
Police Chief Joseph A. Radice said this morning Lieut. Frank H. Walsh questioned Miss Duke yesterday at Rough Point, her Bellevue Avenue home. Walsh accompanied Detective George Watts. Miss Duke's attorney, Wesley N. Fach of New York City, was present during the interrogation (Newport Daily News, 1966). The article goes on to say Miss Duke was released from the hospital on Saturday, but questioning was withheld until Sunday at the request of her doctor.
Chief Radice said this morning Miss Duke told police she had been sitting on the passenger's side of a late-model station wagon operated by Tirella, as they were driving out of the estate. When they reached the gates, Miss Duke said, Tirella got out of the car to open them and she slid over to the driver side drive out onto Bellevue Avenue. “It was something we done 100 times before,” she told police. Chief Radice said Miss Duke told police the car leaped forward and after that she could remember nothing (Newport Daily News, 1966, p. 1).
Dr. Philip C. McAllister, state medical examiner said Tirella died instantly of brain injuries. Additionally, Radice said he was waiting for the full medical examiner's report, and the investigation was ongoing (Newport Daily News, 1966, p. 1). Chief Radices’ claim that they were getting along contradicts earlier claims of them fighting shortly before the incident. Questioning of Miss Duke lasted approximately 20 minutes, and even after two inspectors from the Registry of Motor Vehicles reported everything on the car functioned properly Radice closed the case ruling it an accident (Lodi News-Sentinel, 1966).
Just as quickly as the case was closed Doris signed a check for $25,000, the recipient the commission for the restoration of the Cliff Walk. Ironically, this was the very commission she had battled from the late 50s into 1966. Doris in an attempted at keeping pedestrians away from her estate ordered staff to erect a barbed wire fence, the planting of thorny bushes, and a “No Trespassing” sign blocking access to the Cliff Walk. The city would not stop the pedestrians, under Newporter's constitutional right of access to the sea. When Doris's hand was forced to remove the fence, it was replaced with German shepherds. However, when in May 1964 the dogs attacked two intruders, the police ordered their exit from the property. The Cliff Walk was her Achilles' heel, but just eight days after Eduardo's death Doris became their largest supporter and benefactor. Speculation supported by earlier events suggests a back-room deal was made in the private meetings of her attorneys and the Politicians called in. Even more intriguing is the sudden retirement of Police Chief Radice four months after he had closed the investigation (Davis, 2009). The following month on Friday, November 18, 1966 Jack O'Brian wrote an article in the World Journal Tribunal. Although there is no mention of its contents Duke's lawyers jumped into action calling for a retraction. In a letter Doris's attorney recounts a telephone conference with Joseph J. Cohen, a reporter with the World Journal Tribune. In the letter attorney Wesley N. Fach states, “The Doris Duke Foundation had helped Mr. Cohen’s retarded son for a number of years and I believe Mr. Cohen had been helpful on previous occasions” (Wesley N. Fach, personal communication, November 29, 1966). Additionally, the letter talks of Mr. Cohen retracting the comments if requested however, there is worry a retraction may give credence to the original story bringing attention to the item a second time. As a possible action “Tell them Miss Duke has requested a retraction of the statement to be made in the column, and failing such retraction, has authorized her attorney to take whatever action may be appropriate” (Wesley N. Fach, personal communication, November 29, 1966). Subsection (c) includes the following, “In any lawsuit of this type, it would be difficult to keep both the newspaper and opposing counsel from bringing out any and all past activities and Associates, including those which have no biases in fact,” (Wesley N. Fach, personal communication, November 29, 1966). The article was retracted and all records have disappeared. Doris was again successful of ridding her accusers, but this would change. Doris was served notice of an impeding claim filed against her by Eduardo Tirella’s heirs in October 1967.
The filed claim caused panic in the Duke camp. Attorneys began drafting letters in hopes of resolve. As letters went out, evidence-supporting murder were coming in. One such letter was received from the Nolan Agency, Inc. addressed to Duke's attorney Wesley Fach stating, “please be reminded that we are waiting for a copy of the lease agreement which Miss Dukes signed with Avis Rent A Car System, Inc., we would appreciate your forwarding it by return mail” (personal communication, December 5, 1966, p. 1). This is damaging because Miss Duke had over 200 servants to carry out her task. Therefore this supports the theory Doris had premeditated the act. In another letter Duke's attorney Pete Cooley writes to Doris,
Yesterday I had a meeting with the two Tirella brothers, their lawyer and the lawyer for Avis. It boils down to this; Tirella’s are seeking $600,000 and a settlement out of court.
The next step awaits the reply of the Avis Insurance Company. I do not, of course, know, but I feel the answer will be no, with perhaps an offer of a smaller amount. After that we will just have to wait and see. Hope and pray a court battle can be avoided (personal communication, January 25, 1967).
This also supports the claim of murder because from the earliest age of 12, Miss Duke welcomed the opportunity to do battle in the courts, no matter what the expense. In this case all attempts are made to avoid this. In another letter Duke's attorney Wesley Fach, makes reference to holding out hope of a settlement.
A settlement could not be reached and on December 12, 1967 after two months of negotiations the lawsuit was officially filed. However, the stakes were now raised to $1,250,000 -plus interest and cost (Doris Duke Papers, 1928-1998).
Attorneys for Miss Duke proved successful in tying up litigation in the courts and the trial does not get underway until June 1971. Lewis Perrotti assistant to the registrar of motor vehicles, and Chief Field Investigator Alfred Massarone, informs the jury that the brakes and gas pedal were fully functional, which disputes the claim the car jumped forward on its own. Perrotti further claims he went to Rough Point on several occasions to get Miss Duke's account of the fatality but was turned away with each attempt. Doris took the stand claiming she could not remember if she stepped on the gas pedal, or if she slipped it into gear from park to drive. This goes against her earlier account when questioned by police two days after the accident (Newport Daily News, 1971). The trial concludes finding Doris guilty in the wrongful death suit further proving her guilt in the murder of Tirella. Victory was bittersweet for the Tirella family as the award was reduced to $96,000. An appeal on the ruling was immediately filed keeping the account in the headlines for another two years. However, on May 4, 1973 the Supreme Court of Rhode Island upheld the original ruling (Court Records, 1973). This ruling is the only document remaining, as in usual fashion court records of testimony are not in existence just as the case in the first trial. It was during the time leading to the first trial Doris would extend her hand of wealth. Within days of Eduardo's death in what most agree to be another backroom deal that would free her from murder charges she would fund a restoration project for the town.
The Newport Restoration Foundation was officially announced in 1968. Following the death of Tirella and leading to the announcement of the foundation work was underway as many details had to be worked out. In the beginning, it was unclear where to start, but it was soon decided the dilapidated colonial homes sitting on the beautiful seaport were in desperate need of repair. With the buildings identified and Doris’s funding the remaining hurdle was the need for a well-known and powerful figure to head up the foundation. Their prime target was Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis, another prominent wealthy resident. It is not known how long the talks took, but when the announcement came to surface Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis was at the helm as the most prominent board member of the foundation. Doris’s last-ditch efforts with the help of her attorneys and the announcement of the foundation finally put to rest the murder of Eduardo Tirella (Newport Restoration Foundation Records, 1968-1999).
Doris Duke’s innocence remains in question some 46 years later. In revisiting the facts there can be no doubt her power, wealth, and influence played a role in the investigation of Tirella’s death. Considering the circumstances, there is no logic behind a twenty-minute interview of the prime suspect, dismissal of facts that the vehicle was fully operable, no questioning of staff, and closure of case that resulted in a horrible death. Doris Duke’s vindictiveness was not secreted; entrance and exit into her world was on her terms. In viewing the preponderance of evidence, Eduardo Tirella’s death may have in fact been covered up and dismissed due to Doris Duke’s influence, power, and wealth.

References

Davis, B. (2009). Gilded: How Newport Became America's Richest City. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Retrieved on September 21, 2012

Doris Duke. (1798-2003). Administrative Records. Doris Duke Papers (Box 7, Folder 1). David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 25, 2012 from: Duke University. Durham, NC.

Doris Duke. (1922-1998). Avis Rent A Car Agreement. Doris Duke Papers (Box 3, Folder 7). Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Historical Archives, David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: Duke University. Durham, NC.

Doris Duke. (1922-1998). Doris Duke Papers (Box 7, Folder 6). Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Historical Archives, David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: Duke University. Durham, NC.

Doris Duke. (1922-1998). Doris Duke Papers (Box 166, Folder 4). Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Historical Archives, David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: Duke University, Durham, NC.

Doris Duke. (1798-2003). Eduardo Tirella Pay Records. Doris Duke Papers (Box 7, Folder 4). David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 25, 2012 from: Duke University. Durham, NC.

Doris Duke. (1922-1998). Inventory. Doris Duke Papers (Box 7, Folder 4). Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Historical Archives, David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: Duke University. Durham, NC.

Doris Duke. (1922-1998). Nolan Agency, Inc. Schmelz, R. E. (personal communication, December 5, 1966).. Doris Duke Papers (Box 3, Folder 7). Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Historical Archives, David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: Duke University, Durham, NC.

Doris Duke. (1922-1998). Pete E. Cooley (personal communication, January 25, 1967). Doris Duke Papers (Box 3, Folder 7). Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Historical Archives, David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: Duke University. Durham, NC.

Doris Duke. (1922-1998). Rough Point Residence. Doris Duke Papers (Box 3, Folder 5). Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Historical Archives, David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: Duke University. Durham, NC.

Doris Duke. (1922-1998). (Wesley N. Fach, personal communication, November 29, 1966). Doris Duke Papers (Box 3, Folder 7). Doris Duke Charitable Foundation Historical Archives, David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: Duke University. Durham, NC.

Doris Duke Trust. (1981). James B. Duke. Retrieved on September 13, 2012 from: http://www.dukefamily.org/ddt.htm

Harmon, M.H. (2001, November). The Tragedy of Doris Duke. Biography Magazine, 5(11), 1. Retrieved on August 19, 2012 from: http://web.ebscohost.com.ezproxy.apollolibrary.com James Buchanan Duke. (1777-1990). Property Deeds. Inventory of the James Buchanan Duke Papers (Box 12). David M. Rubenstein Rare Books & Manuscript Library. Retrieved on September 25, 2012 from: Duke University. Durham, NC.

Newport Restoration Foundation. (2009). About Doris Duke. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: http://www.newportrestoration.org

Supreme Court of Rhode Island. (1973). Alice Tirella Romano v. Doris Duke. Retrieved September 24, 2012 from: Supreme Court of Rhode Island, Court Records Department. Providence, RI.

Thomas, J. & Duke, P. (1995). To Rich: The Family Secrets of Doris Duke. Retrieved September 9, 2012 from: http:// www.amazon.com/kindlefamily

Williams, J. M. (n.d.). Learning To Give and the Center on Philanthropy. Indiana University. Retrieved on September 11, 2012 from: http://www.learningtogive.org/papers/paper190.html (1966, October 10). Death of Miss Duke’s Friend Ruled ‘Unfortunate Accident’. Newport Daily News. Retrieved September 10, 2012 from: http://www.newspaperarchive.com/newport-daily-news/1966-10-10/?tag=Eduardo+tirella&rtserp=tags/?plo=Eduardo-tirella

(1966, October 8). Doris Duke Kills Friend In Crash. Newport Daily News. Retrieved September 10, 2012 from: http://www.newspaperarchive.com/newport-daily-news/1966-10-08/?tag=doris+duke&rtserp=tags/?py=1966&pf=doris&pl=duke

(1966, October 12). Heiress Cleared In Death Of Movie Set Designer. Lodi News-Sentinel, p. 3. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from: http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=2245&dat=19661012&id=BWgzAAAAIBAJ&sjid=pzIHAAAAIBAJ&pg=6926,884029

(1971, June 24). Registry Tells Jury Car Was Operative. Newport Daily News, p. 19. Retrieved on September 10, 2012 from:
http://newspaperarchive.com/newport-daily-news/1971-06-24/page-19/?tag=newport%20daily%20news%20june%2024,%201971&rtserp=tags/?plo=newport-daily-news-june-24,-1971

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Gates of Hell Auguste Rodin

...AUGUSTE RODIN’S GATES OF HELL The Gates of Hell (conceived in 1880 – 1917; by Auguste Rodin (1840 – 1917) is housed at the Musée Rodin in Paris, France. (Musée D'Orsay). This impressive gateway was commissioned by the French state. (Gerald) The new appointed Secretary of Fine Arts, Edmond Tuquet (1836 – 1914), venerates Rodin’s art pieces and commissioned the sculpture on August 16th 1880 for the Musée des Arts Décoratifs. The original arrangements for the Musée des Arts Décoratifs were discarded three years later. (Musèe) Therefore, Rodin left and focused on experimenting and redesigning the portal for the next 20 years. At that point, the sculpture was still remained at its plaster stage; the gateway was not molded in bronze until Rodin’s death in 1917. Rodin’s Gates of Hell was reputed as a distinct piece considering his unique interpretation of its rough surface texture and shape that demonstrates the illustration of Dante Alighieri’s famous poem, The Divine Comedy (1308 – 1321). A few of Rodin’s most famous sculptures including The Thinker (1880 - 1925), The Kiss (1888 – 1889) and The Three Shades (1902) are inspired by the alto relievo sculptures in The Gates of Hell. This masterpiece was created anon after the Franco- Prussian War (1870 – 1871) during the installation of the French Third Republic (1871 – 1940). Auguste Rodin accepted the commission for The Gates of Hell anon after the Franco- Prussian War between French and German Empires. After France has lost the......

Words: 1792 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

To His Coy Mistress

...affair with a married man - A person in- charge (manager, caretaker, courtesan) - A patron or a female sweetheart in 1650’s - The female equivalent of master * Coy -Pretending to be shy or reserved -Olden days referred it to the feeling of shyness - “To coy” (v) means to stroke - The lady is no easy catch * His - Third-person possessive pronoun -Refers to the young man The tying of both the words ‘mistress’ and ‘coy’ brings about the beauty of the poem which talks about complicated relationship and complicated communication between the speaker and his mistress. It’s a plea to a young lady by his lover. THE PERSONA (The Young Man): * First-person point of view * Presentation as the plea of another man (fictional) who is the persona of the poet * The young man is impatient, desperately so, unwilling to tolerate temporizing on the part of the young lady * His motivation appears to be carnal desire rather than true love; passion rules him. Consequently, one may describe him as immature and selfish. SETTING: * Our Imagination * The poets imagination * No specific place is mentioned * Hypothetical situations * Written in 1651-1652 and Published in 1681...

Words: 5928 - Pages: 24

Free Essay

Mormon Exodus

...burning of two hundred Mormon homes and farm buildings in 1845, and mob violence in 1846. Due to unforeseen difficulties the trek west was split off into two sections: they would travel in wagon trains from Nauvoo, Illinois to Omaha, Nebraska in 1846; and, Omaha to the Salt Lake Valley of Utah in 1847. By 1856, the number of converts traveling to the valley reached a point that wagon trains were too expensive and the church leader at the time, Brigham Young, decided that handcarts would be cheaper, and faster for such a large number of converts to reach the valley. The first trek starting in February of 1846 from Nauvoo, Illinois to Omaha, Nebraska was much harsher due to death and tragedy resulting from black scurvy, Cholera, Typhoid Fever, Tuberculosis, and maternal deaths, and the weakening of the body and mind by stress, while February marked harsh weather and winter cold. Due to being practically forced to leave their homes in a hurry most had left important provisions behind and went out with no experience and with no organized leadership. The 500 wagon long train faced miles of axle-deep mud bogs and rough, obscure trails along the way. Yet along the way they became more organized and began to travel in groups of 10s, 50s or 100s. While also...

Words: 2581 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Essay

...marry other partners. As Catherine Earnshaw dies halfway through the novel, which pair of lovers is meant to carry our approval, Catherine and Heathcliff or young Catherine and Hareton? Moreover their voices reach us through a medley of others: Mr Lockwood, Nelly, Isabella, who are often ignored by readers. A parable of a natural equilibrium disturbed by an external force and eventually somehow restored. The theory that a principle of calm and storm informs the novel provided a comprehensive interpretation. The two aspects (calm and storm) are not necessarily conflicting and will ultimately lead to a state of equilibrium. The world described by the novel is pre-moral, and the drives of the main characters seem to reach beyond their death and strive for transcendence. (Early Victorian Novelists, Lord David Cecil, 1934) A restless force, represented by C and H, which continually pushes against a framework of religion, propriety, social expectations. The novel represents a clash of social classes and economic interests where the respectable farming class (the Earnshaws) is progressively destroyed by the newly wealthy capitalists (H) and the traditional gentry (the Lintons). Lockwood and Nelly represent, from different class perspectives, the normal views of society (family relationships, class characteristics, social etiquette, duty, responsibility) whereas C symbolises vitality, the spirit...

Words: 1164 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Nightburn's Short Story

...“Most of our supplies are carried in from other areas of Heczar, obtained through bartering, or if that fails, raiding from those who would not barter.” They finally cleared the marshlands and made their way through a narrow, rough terrain mountain pass. Sara had no doubt that General Zhousbek had been this way before. He knew his way through the mountains like the back of his own hand. She and the General had remained on horseback, weaving their way through the narrow pass which was proving extremely difficult for the horses. Ice and snow covered the trail making for very difficult footing for everyone. The goblin soldiers showed no sign of discomfort or weariness and continued their relentless trek through the pass, slowed only by the two horses ahead of them. Most armies would be demoralized by this type of terrain, but that was just one benefit of the many benefits of having a goblin army. They could go on for days and never slow their pace. Suddenly Sara asked. “General, if we keep this pace, wouldn’t your goblins protest?” General Zhousbek turned to her, not slowing his mount’s pace and replied. “Goblins do not suffer from exhaustion as humans do. They do not suffer mental anguish. When we get to Cormyth, they will be ready to fight to their death. When Parsis sees our numbers, they will be the ones demoralized. We out number every man, woman, and child in Parsis, four to one. Our sheer numbers will overwhelm them.” He then turned back and continued guiding......

Words: 1668 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Djbfj

...not read this to the students. This is a description for teachers about the big ideas and key understanding that students should take away after completing this task. Big Ideas and Key Understandings Companionship demonstrates great loyalty and risk for a true friend. Synopsis The Dog of Pompeii centers on a blind boy, Tito, and his dog, Bimbo, his life-long devoted companion during A.D. 79 in the city of Pompeii. Bimbo is crucial to Tito’s survival because he brings him along the city, provides food for him, and keeps him safe from harm. During the course of the story, a volcano erupts and causes mass panic and death. Bimbo risks and loses his life to save his beloved companion. 2. Read the entire selection, keeping in mind the Big Ideas and Key Understandings. 3. Re-read the text while noting the stopping points for the Text Dependent Questions and teaching Tier II/academic vocabulary. During Teaching 1. Students read the entire selection independently. 2. Teacher reads the text aloud while students follow along or students take turns reading aloud to each other. Depending on the text length and student need, the teacher may choose to read the full text or a passage aloud. For a particularly complex text, the teacher may choose to reverse the order of steps 1 and 2. 3. Students and teacher re-read the text while stopping to respond to and discuss the questions, continually returning to the text. A variety of methods can be used to......

Words: 2837 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Ofero

...Anthony Perraglia Professor Mattern Eng 10 10 December 2013 Orfeo ed Euridice During the transition from the Baroque to Classical period, opera slowly became entertainment focused on the middle class. There were less operas written about kings and queens, and more about mythical figures. The reform of opera might not have been started by him, but Christoph Willibald Gluck (1714-1787) is said to be one of the first operatic composers to adapt his newer works to the reformation styles. ( Hanning, 324) Some examples of the style included new stories appealing to the middle class, less attention directed at the singer, and more attention to the music. One of his first operas, Orfeo ed Euridice, is a prime example. Although Gluck’s 1762 production of Orfeo ed Euridice in Vienna is his greatest success, it was an opera previously used by Monteverdi, titled L’Orfeo. (Boyden, 79) Orfeo ed Euridice is somewhat similar to L’Orfeo, seeing as the two follow the Greek myth of Orpheus. Though there were similarities between the two, no evidence was found stating that Gluck was influenced by the previous production, or if he was even familiar with Monteverdi’s work. The myth describes a young shepherd, Orpheus, whose music had the power to tame the animals and win the affection of others. (Boyden, 79) On his wedding day, while walking through the fields of Thrace, he receives word that his wife, Eurydice, has died. (Boyden,......

Words: 2170 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Leaving a Legacy Through Art

...We are all the victims of time; we spend our lives striving to leave our legacy in order to beat the vicious clock that controls our spot on this Earth. What can be defined as a legacy? Values, wealth, a personal memory? Each legacy someone leaves can be powerful in its own way and each legacy is different. William Shakespeare’s Sonnet 18 exemplifies how you are able to immortalize someone through the legacy of art. Ironically “To the Virgins” by Robert Herrick and “To His Coy Mistress” by Andrew Marvell both were written on the theme of Carpe Diem, about not fixating on the future but about “seizing the day”, yet evidently they have managed to leave a legacy as we still today discuss and analyze their works of art. Shakespeare captured in Sonnet 18 how someone is able to leave a legacy through art. The sonnet compares a boy to a summer’s day and describes him as “more lovely and more temperate” meaning that the youth’s beauty is more perfect and gentle than the beauty and violent excesses of a summer day. The poem then shifts and speaks about how “summer’s lease hath all too short a date” and that just like how the summer months are always too short and come to an end, the lease that this boy has on life has abruptly come to an end all too quickly as well. The next few lines “sometime too hot the eye of heaven shines, / and often in his gold complexion dimmed, / and every fair from fair sometime declines,” illustrates that even though the sun shines, it is usually dimed......

Words: 1662 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Hazard Vulnerability Assessment

...possible contingency plans in the event that a catastrophe occurs. This assessment is designed to identify and assess hazards to which the Baxter Treatment Plant is ill-prepared to respond and strengthen these weak areas. Methods We, as a group, conducted site visits and surveys of the property. A point of contact was established within the Philadelphia Water Department, but the Water Department policies dictate that written approval for a site visit must be approved by higher level management. These policies and the limited amount of time in the accelerated semester did not allow us to complete an internal site visit. As a contingency, we evaluated the site from the exterior. Physical surveillance was conducted allowing us to observe the visible security of the premises. The building is surrounded by a cyclone fence topped with barbed wire. Each of the entrances is secured by a motorized gate and a guard shack. The guard shacks did not appear to be occupied during the visits. The gates were activated by authorized personnel using magnetic key cards. Besides the lack of visible security guards, we noticed that there was a delay of 15-20 seconds prior to the gates closing. This...

Words: 4007 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Incident Essay (Law)

...Kenxxxx x xxxx xx Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Incident at Boeing simulator operations by Kenxxxx x xxxx xx This report is to bring forth the incident at Boeing Simulator Operations on May 18th, 2008. It is a work related accident and in reviewing the key points that I hope to bring out with this report, it will show that it should not have happened and could have been prevented; as a result of this accident my future has been altered and very uncertain with permanent injuries and a forced changed way of life. First I’ll explain the events leading up to the accident, how the accident happened, the aftermath of the accident, and then how it should have been prevented, as well as, pointing out major flaws in the operation and procedures happening at Boeing Simulator Operations. I was just hired on to Boeing As a Simulator Device Technician Level III on April 25th, 2008 after being away from Simulators for about 2½ years and writing Technical manuals on simulator operation and maintenance for 5½ years before that; See Figure 1 for picture of a Simulator. We were on the second week of doing overtime on the weekends to do hydraulic oil flushing on 2 different simulators that are considered extremely old and the flushing was years overdue; when finishing up on the second simulator (the 757, oldest), all of the hydraulic pumps had been turned ‘ON’ to circulate the oil through the system and after a little while, a pretty bad leak was noticed on one of the......

Words: 2531 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Mystics

...itself regardless of the outcome. Mystics bear witness to this realized oneness with a sense of respect even reverence for life, for all things, manifested most concretely as love. As the Buddhists say, compassion is the body of emptiness, Aquinas, charity is the form of faith, that love is the shape of our faith, that faith configures itself as love. The mystic is hidden in the world as God is hidden in the world, but some are called upon to be mystic teachers, called upon to offer guidance and encouragement to us who feel interiorly called to this path of realized oneness. To be amazed and humbled that this applies to you, to be interiorly awakened in this way to this oneness and to live in fidelity to it. They also know that at some point as you get into it that it is filled with unexpected obstacles and surprises and blessings and they offer suggestions of how to navigate through the intimacy of these things. When they speak of this path they use metaphors under the auspices of which it provides them a way to talk about these...

Words: 5496 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Gwhs

...INSTRUCTIONS * Read the notes on sonnets. * Read the sonnets and answer the questions that follow each. * Complete the writing assignment Shakespeare’s Sonnets: The Mysteries of Love Shakespeare. The name calls to mind the great plays whose characters have come to life on stages around the world: Hamlet, Macbeth, Romeo and Juliet, Othello. Yet had Shakespeare written no plays at all, his reputation as a poet, as the author of the Sonnets (1609), would still have been immense. There are 154 sonnets altogether; their speaker is male, and their chief subject is love. Beyond those three points, however, there is little agreement, only questions: • Is the sonnets’ speaker a dramatic character invented by Shakespeare, like Romeo, Macbeth, or Hamlet, or is he the poet himself? • If the sonnets are about the real man Shakespeare, then who are the real people behind the characters the sonnets mention? • Is the order in which the sonnets were originally published (probably without Shakespeare’s consent) the correct or the intended sequence? Could they be arranged to tell a more coherent story? Should they be so arranged? These and dozens of other questions about the sonnets have been asked and answered over and over again—but never to everybody’s satisfaction. We have hundreds of conflicting theories but no absolutely convincing answers. About the individual sonnets, though, if not the whole sequence, agreement is perfect: They are among the supreme utterances in......

Words: 2445 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Notes of Macbeth

...Act 1 - Three witches are planning to go see Macbeth - The captain (injured and part of the fight) explains to the king (Duncan) how the fight went down Macbeth and Banquo fought and beat Macdowald He then had to fight against the Norwegian since the Thane of Cawdor (Nobility) betrayed them Macbeth = Tough&Brave - King Duncan demands that the current Thane of Cawdor be killed and that Macbeth becomes the new one - Witches are bonding then meet up with Macbeth (In thunder) and tell him he’ll be thane of Cawdor, and then King. - They also tell Banquo he won’t be king but his kids will - Description of the witches (Page 12 or 2) - Ross and Angus step in once the witches leave and tell Macbeth he’s the new thane of Cawdor like the witches predicted - Macbeth and Banquo side talk about believing the witches theory. Banquo warns Macbeth that the witches are bad news and to fulfill their theory he’s going to be led through evil - Macbeth is considering killing Duncan (the evil Banquo is talking about.) - Macbeth thinks he might actually hot have to do anything to fulfill his destiny (He’s experiencing doubt. He so far knows better) - Duncan wants to know if The thane of Cawdor is dead yet - Malcom says his bodies not arrived but that he died with deep regret. Duncan doesn’t care (27) - Duncan thanks Macbeth and tells him that his son is prince of Cumberland - Macbeth thinks the son is going to be in the way of him becoming king, making him reconsider......

Words: 3214 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Ethics

...WAYLAND BAPTIST UNIVERSITY SAN ANTONIO CAMPUS CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE AND CHRISTIAN ETHICS A RESEARCH PROJECT SUBMITTED TO DR. JOHN M. ANDREWARTHA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR BASIC CHRISTIAN ETHICS RLGN 5323 SUBMITTED BY ROBERT L. JOHNSON April 14, 2008 Table of Contents Introduction…………………………………………………………………….……....1 Part I: Definition of Civil Disobedience………………………………………..….…..1 Part II: Definition of Christian Ethics…………..……………………………….……..1 Part III: Biblical and Historical Practice of Civic Responsibility.……………………..2 Part IV: The Rise of Political Power in the Church and the Struggles Associated…….7 Part V: The Necessity for Civil Disobedience..………………………………………..9 Part VI: What Difference Did the Civil Rights Struggle Make? ..................................12 Conclusion…....................................................................................................................16 Bibliography…………………………………………………………………………….18 INTRODUCTION This research will focus on the topic of “Civil Disobedience and its Relativity to Christian Ethics.” The research will address whether it is ever justifiable to disobey the laws of secular governments. In doing so, it will discuss the Doctrine of Civic Responsibility as it relates to Christian Ethics. Furthermore, Romans 13:1-7 will be referenced to provide additional insight into how the Church has historically responded to civil......

Words: 5181 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Battle of Hue

...107.576°E / 16.47525; 107.576Coordinates: 16°28′30.9″N 107°34′33.6″E / 16.47525°N 107.576°E / 16.47525; 107.576 Huế, South Vietnam | Result | Tactical South Vietnamese and US victory[1] | | Belligerents |  South Vietnam  United States | North Vietnam Viet Cong | Commanders and leaders | Ngô Quang Trưởng Foster LaHue | Trần Văn Quang | Strength | 11 ARVN battalions 2 U.S Army battalions 3 U.S Marines battalions | 10 PAVN and NLF battalions | Casualties and losses | ARVN: 452 killed 2,123 wounded U.S.: 216 killed 1,584 wounded[2] Total: 663 killed 3,707 wounded | PAVN figures: About 2,400 killed and 3,000 wounded (from 30-1 until 28-3)[3] MACV estimate: 8,113 killed[4] 98 captured[5] | 844 civilian deaths and 1,900 injuries due to accident of battle, 4,856 civilians and captured personnel executed by communists or missing according to the South Vietnamese government[6] | [show]v · d · e Military engagements of the Vietnam War | | | Laos - Sunrise – 1st Ap Bac – Go Cong – Hiep Hoa – Chan La – 34A – Long Dinh – Kien Long – Quyet Thang 202 – Nam Dong – Thanh Hóa – An Lao – Bình Gia – Pleiku airbase – Thanh Hoa Bridge – Song Be – Ba Gia – Đồng Xoài – Starlite – Chu Lai – Plei Me – Minh Thanh – Hump – Gang Toi – Ia Drang Valley – Crimp – Masher/White Wing – Suoi Bong Trang – Cu Nghi – Kim Son Valley – A Shau – Birmingham – Xa Cam My – 1st Dong Ha – Wahiawa –...

Words: 4508 - Pages: 19