“Sam Harris: Science Can Answer Moral Questions”

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By ncladimo
Words 576
Pages 3
“Sam Harris: Science Can Answer Moral Questions”
Critique Paper

Sam Harris began his argument by saying, “The separation between science and human values is an illusion,” adding “facts and values seem to belong to different spheres. This is quite clearly untrue. Values are a certain kind of facts. They are facts about the well beings of conscious creatures.” What is he trying to convey? Based on what he said, values are also facts about how people like us try to live a good life. If he considered values as facts, does it mean our moral values were created based on science facts? Or do scientific facts are based on moral values? We cannot say that a belief to be objectively true can be considered as a fact. He even pointed our ethical obligations towards the rock or insects. First of all, ethics concern is the morality of social beings. Since when can we talk to a rock and hurt it? He then justified that, “If culture changes us, it changes us by changing our brains. And therefore whatever cultural variation there is in the way human beings flourish can at least in principle be understood in the context of a maturing science of the mind…” I probably I agree with him in this one. People change because the people around change. But does it make it scientific? That our brains control our ethical actions? Brain controls our actions and we reason out using our brain but acting according to our ethics what make us morally right or wrong. We live our lives base on our ethics and use our brain to absorb how to decide. He also gave example, which connects with moral relativism, that Muslim women cover their body completely so as not to offend their alleged god and then telling his audience that living in a different culture, we cannot avoid judging their wellbeing because they do such practice. If we let empirical study to be the basis of what is right or wrong, scientific…...

Similar Documents

Management Information System Practice Question and Answer

...Chapter 1 + case study 1. How can information technology support a company's business processes and decision making and give it a competitive advantage? GIve examples to illustrate your answer. The term information technology refers to the various hardware, software, networking, and data management parts that are a neccessity for the system to function (pg. 8). Businesses regularly utilize computer-based information systems in order to record customer purchases, keep track of inventory, pay employees, buy new merchandise, and evaluate sales trends. Without the support of information technology, businesses would ultimately fall apart. For example if a business did not choose to use computer-based information systems, they wouldn't be able to evaluate what items were selling better than others and ultimately lose valuable information for future success. Information technology can also aid in decision making for a business. Decisions are made based on analysis provided by computer-based information systems. For example a store manager may make the decision whether to discontinue an item for sale or keep it on the floor due to analysis of sales trends provided by computer-based systems. Lastly information technology helps business gain a competitive advantage. A competitive advantage is gained through computer-based information systems by applying innovative application of information technologies (pg. 9). For example a store manager installing touch screen kiosks...

Words: 2701 - Pages: 11

Sample Answer for Novel Question

...MARKING SCHEME: CONTENT : 10 MARKS LANGUAGE : 5 MARKS TOTAL : 15 MARKS SAMPLE QUESTION & GUIDELINE ON HOW TO ANSWER NOVEL QUESTION. QUESTION :CHOOSE A CHARACTER THAT YOUADMIRE FROM THE NOVEL THAT YOU HAVE STUDIED. WITH CLOSE REFERENCE TO THE TEXT ,GIVE REASONS FOR YOUR CHOICE AND HOW THE CHARACTER HELPS YOU IN YOUR LIFE. STEP 1: Start you answer by writing the title of the novel and the person who wrote it. At the same time the character you admire the most. STEP 2: Give reasons for your choice in a new paragraph and start your sentence with something like; First of all or just as easy as firstly. In giving your reason you must give the incident that is related to the situation in order to proof your point. STEP 3: Give a few more reasons/proof from the novel to support your answer. STEP 4: Remember to answer the second part of the question after giving your reasons/proof. You can do this in each of the paragraphs or write it as conclusion at the end of your answer. STEP 5: To end your writing, give a conclusion by combining the reasons or answering the second part of the question SAMPLE ANSWER BY FOLLOWING THE ABOVE GUIDELINE (THE CURSE) Based on the novel “The Curse” by Lee Su Ann the character that I like and admire is Azreen because of a few reasons. The first reason is because Azreen is such a strong character that has great courage as she is open, positive and always fights for what she believes in. Firstly, she...

Words: 507 - Pages: 3

“Sam Harris: Science Can Answer Moral Questions”

...“Sam Harris: Science Can Answer Moral Questions” Critique Paper Sam Harris began his argument by saying, “The separation between science and human values is an illusion,” adding “facts and values seem to belong to different spheres. This is quite clearly untrue. Values are a certain kind of facts. They are facts about the well beings of conscious creatures.” What is he trying to convey? Based on what he said, values are also facts about how people like us try to live a good life. If he considered values as facts, does it mean our moral values were created based on science facts? Or do scientific facts are based on moral values? We cannot say that a belief to be objectively true can be considered as a fact. He even pointed our ethical obligations towards the rock or insects. First of all, ethics concern is the morality of social beings. Since when can we talk to a rock and hurt it? He then justified that, “If culture changes us, it changes us by changing our brains. And therefore whatever cultural variation there is in the way human beings flourish can at least in principle be understood in the context of a maturing science of the mind…” I probably I agree with him in this one. People change because the people around change. But does it make it scientific? That our brains control our ethical actions? Brain controls our actions and we reason out using our brain but acting according to our ethics what make us morally right or wrong. We live our lives base on our ethics and...

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Question and Answer

... protection from creditors often award their top executives golden parachutes to leave, when workers are laid off with severance pay. Nations, like companies also are artificial creations. Random borders drawn arbitrarily for the expediency of powerful nations. Efforts to establish uniform international law to monitor humane treatment of individual countries are not well accepted by powerful countries including the USA. USA refuses to sign the treaty against genocide, the land mine treaty, the treaty for equal rights for women, and even refused to pay our United Nations dues. On the local level, a nation is only as effective as its government. When a government takes the position that government is incompetent, unable to deliver services better than private industries, the nation has no incentive to demand that government work. They prefer for government to dismantle operations, forfeiting them to private companies. When a government believes that they have responsibilities to the American people to run government efficiently, we can begin the task of nation building, & meet the challenges of nationhood. In order words, a nation run by rogues becomes a nation with no moral compass, and will not advance. A nation run by nation builder is a nation which can remain united & working towards a common goal of life, liberty and pursuit of happiness....

Words: 918 - Pages: 4

Sam Lennox Case Study Question 1

...1. Human resource management consists of numerous activities. What areas were illustrated by Sam’s schedule on this particular day? One of areas were illustrated by Sam’s schedule on that day are to ensure worker requirements for the day are met with the organization needs. On that day, Sam was told that new stockroom foreman did not come to work. He was asked to find replacement for that new worker by Al Noren urgently. It because on that day, there are two cars must be unloaded. Sam agree and will find the replacement but he fails. Next areas is, training and development. This context are includes to identify training and development needs and source provision. It also consists to provide Corporate induction programs, facilitate IiP accreditation and administer corporate training provision. In this case study, Sam is instructed to devising a program to help his company. He decide to use the management by objectives (MBO) program although him realized there are will be resistance by some plant managers. But Sam confident that this MBO is good solutions to implementation at his workplace, Lakeview Plant for improve the work setting and skill level of employees. Besides that, there is also recruitment activities. Recruitment activities covering such as provide a comprehensive advice and administration service, from advertising to appointment, for all full-time and fractional appointments across the organization. It also to provide and selecting the...

Words: 589 - Pages: 3

Forencis Science Answer Sheet

...Name: Date: TRUE/FALSE Directions: Answer each of the following by indicating if the statement is TRUE or FALSE 1. The word forensics refers to the application of scientific knowledge to legal questions. TRUE 2. A fact is a statement or assertion of information that can be verified. TRUE 3. What we perceive about a person depends in part on their mannerisms and gestures. TRUE 4. Good observation skills come naturally to investigators. They do not need to be trained. FALSE 5. The first task of forensic scientists is to find, examine, and evaluate evidence from a crime scene. TRUE 6. The Innocence Project is an organization that seeks to get convicted killers out of prison. SKIP 7. Our emotional state influences our ability to see and hear what is happening around us. TRUE 8. If we remember seeing something happen, we can trust that is happened just as we think it did. FALSE 9. Through our senses of sight, taste, hearing, smell, and touch, we gather every single moment about what is around us. TRUE 10. Most wrongful convictions seem to be the result of faulty eye-witness testimony. TRUE MULTIPLE CHOICE Directions: Answer the following questions with the choice that best answers the question 1. One of the important tools of the forensic investigator is the ability to: (a) a. Observe, interpret and report observation clearly b. Observer assumptions clearly. c. Report...

Words: 1075 - Pages: 5

Is-3120 Lab 6 Question and Answer

...1. What are three benefits of implementing VLANs within a network? A. A more efficient use of bandwidth can be achieved allowing many physical groups to use the same network infrastructure B. Broadcast storms can be mitigated by decreasing the number of broadcast domains, thus increasing their size. C.A higher level of network security can be reached by separating sensitive data traffic from other network traffic. D. Port-based VLANs increase switch-port use efficient, thanks to 802.1Q trunks E.A more efficient use of bandwidth can be achieved allowing many logical networks to use the same network infrastructure. F. Broadcast storms can be mitigated by increasing the number of broadcast domains, thus reducing their size. G.VLANs makes it easier for IT staff to configure new logical groups, because the VLANs all belong to the same broadcast domain. 2. What are some drawbacks of implementing VLANs within a network? •Usable bandwidth is shared among all the devices connected to the LAN •ALL devices connected within a LAN can hear ALL the packets irrespective of whether the packet is meant for that device or not. It is possible for some unscrupulous node listening to data packets not meant for that. •Suppose, your organization has different departments. Using a traditional LAN, when any changes take place within the organization, physical cables and devices need to be moved to reorganize the LAN infrastructure. •A LAN cannot extend beyond its physical boundary across...

Words: 848 - Pages: 4

The Answer to a Common Question

... Joshua Glander Col. Bamberg Old Testament 20 October 2012 The Answer to a Common Question Today many people do not believe there is a God because of all the bad things that are occurring in the world. They say that if there is a God then these things wouldn’t be happening. Also, people of faith have started questioning God and their own faith because of that same statement. There are no statistics to prove this, so I base it off the fact that I have grown up in church my entire life and seen the impact that it has had not only on congregations but also on my own walk with God. In the past year though I have had a major breakthrough with this thought and am about to share the revelation that I had. God gave Moses the Ten Commandments on Mount Sinai (Exodus 19-20) to act as the rules of moral behavior for Israel, Gods chosen people. God said: Thou shalt not have strange gods before me Thou shalt not make for thyself any graven image. Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain Remember to keep Holy the sabbath day. Honor thy father and mother that thy days be long in the land which the Lord gives thee. Thou shalt not kill. (translation of this exact text for the word “kill” is debated today) Thou shalt not commit adultery. Thou shalt not steal. Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor. Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's wife nor goods. God says in Exodus 19:5 if his people obey his commandments that they would become His...

Words: 1543 - Pages: 7

Bsb Question and Answer

...Assessment 1 – Question and Answer 1) Discuss any four ways in which you can monitor your team’s ability to meet customer service standards. Customer feedback - the customer is the only person who can tell the company how their work is useful/helpful (as the company works to satisfy their necessities). Their feedback let the company measure their satisfaction and with this information they can improve their services / products. Team meetings – the staff deal with the customers or at least make part in the service/product which is going to be delivery to the customer. If a problem happens and the customer doesn't write a feedback about it, but just gently comment with the staff about it. This small feedback is really important and is a good idea to raise it in a meeting. Other example is if the same problems is occurring with another team member, it can be same problem or same situation occurring with different customers. It worth bring up everything that we can in a team meeting. Direct observation – is the manager responsibility to watch the staff while they are working. The manager needs to make sure that the receptionist knows how to treat and talk with the customer, the cleaner is not leaving any place dirty or incomplete, etc. And not only the manager, a team member can also help another one to improve their skills at work. Review of returned goods – if a product had a problem and the customer complained and returned it, it’s necessary to report the problem...

Words: 1547 - Pages: 7

Chapter 2 Quick Answer Question

... flexible schedules, while other cultures keep tight schedules and work longer hours. With respect to work, some cultures tend to have a slower-paced lifestyle and see work as a means to an end for them, other cultures display a stronger work ethic and see work as an end in itself. With respect to cultural change, although globalization and technological advances are increasing the pace of cultural change, increasing acceptance of cultural traits, some cultures are more cautious to adjust their business. 3. Q: Describe the process of cultural diffusion. Why should international businesses be sensitive to charges of cultural imperialism? ANSWER: Cultural diffusion is the process whereby cultural traits spread from one culture to another. This process occurs naturally and gradually as new traits are accepted and absorbed into a culture. International business should be sensitive to charges of cultural imperialism because they can result in laws to protect the local culture and these laws can make the market opportunity impracticable. Quick Study 3 1. Q: How do manners and customs differ? Give examples of each. ANSWER: Customs differ from manners in that they define appropriate habits or behaviors in specific situations. Examples of manners: in Arab cultures, one does not extend a hand to greet an older person unless the elder first offers the greeting; also in Arab cultures, one does not pour tea or serve a meal using the left hand since it is...

Words: 2352 - Pages: 10

Short Answer Question/Week 3

...Short answer Question/Week 3 Debra Thompson, R.N. Nur 478/week 3 September 1, 2015 Marjorie Jessen, DNP, FNP Short Answer Question As nursing has become an advanced, specialized and independent field, her role is changing. Every action made, by the nurse, she must maintain accountability and take responsibility for all decision made. Ensure that efficient and effective care is provided to protect the hospital and the patient within her care. Within this realm of her responsibility, she must also function under the law and her nursing code of ethics. To practice within the law, and the code of ethics, decisions are more difficult with the evolving medical technology and expanding autonomy scope of practice. As the role of nursing changes, there have also been an increasing number of implications in medical malpractice cases, concerning nurses, when in the past most of these cases are, referred to physicians. Some of the causes for the nurses’ implication is because they work long hours, the stressful work environment, and the decreased staffing. With all of these added stressors related to the profession, an indicator that have been a factor and prominent problems for some of the nurses’ malpractice suits is impairment on duty. With this dilemma, what would you do if you discovered a co-worker or very close friend that was impaired by drugs or alcohol? A moral turmoil presents, as what to do with the situation, once you suspected. What would be even...

Words: 472 - Pages: 2

Bom Question and Answer Set

...[pic] MGMT 405 Operations and Production Management Answer set 1 (Reference chapters 1 – William J. Stevenson-2007, ninth edition) Discussion Questions 1. What do you understand by the term ‘Operations Management’? ANS: ✓ Operations Management is the management of that part of an organization that is responsible for producing goods and/or services. The management of systems or processes that create goods and/or provide services. i.e. Every book you read, every e-mail you send or every medical treatment you receive involves the operation function of one or more organizations 2. Identify the three major functional areas of business organizations and briefly describe how they interrelate. ANS: ✓ Finance- is responsible for securing financial resources at favourable prices as well as analysing investment proposal and providing funds for marketing and operations. ✓ Marketing is responsible for assessing consumer needs or wants and selling and promoting the organization’s goods and services. ✓ Operations is responsible for producing the goods or providing the services offered by the organization. 3. Describe the nature of operations function. ✓ ANS: The operations function consists of all activities that directly related to producing goods or providing services. It is the core of most business organizations because it is responsible for the creation of organization’s goods or services. Its essence is to add value...

Words: 1267 - Pages: 6

Question and Answer

... opportunities, we must consider both the risk and the expected return of the investment and we face a trade-off between risk and expected return. These three reasons reveal that profit maximization, by itself, is an unsuitable goal. Maximize shareholders wealth According to me “maximizing shareholders wealth would be appropriate goal to maximise profit” let us see why Current theory asserts that the firms’ proper goal is to maximize shareholders’ wealth, as measured by the market price of the firm’s stock. A firm’s stock price reflects the timing, size and risk of the cash flow that investors expect a firm to generate over time. In this theory, financial managers should undertake only those actions that they expect will increase the value of the firm’s future cash flow. Theorical and empirical arguments support the assertion that managers should focus on maximization shareholder wealth. Shareholders of a firm are sometimes called residual claimants, meaning that they have claims only on any of the firm’s cash flows that remain after employees, suppliers, creditors, governments and other stakeholders are paid in full. As you see, shareholders stand at the end of this line so if the firm cannot pay the stakeholders first, shareholders receive nothing! Shareholders also bear most of the risk of running the firm. So if firms did not manage to maximize shareholders wealth, investors would have little incentive to accept the risks necessary for a business to succeed. Take a......

Words: 595 - Pages: 3

Mba Question Paper Answer

...Examination Paper of Marketing Management IIBM Institute of Business Management Examination Paper MM.100 International Marketing Management Section A: Objective Type & Short Questions (30 Marks)    This section consists of Multiple Choice & Short Note Type Questions. Answer all the questions. Part One carries 1 mark each & Part Two carries 5 marks each. Part One: Multiple choices: 1. International marketing includes activities that direct the flow of goods from: a. One country to one country b. One country to another country c. One country to multiple country d. All of the above 2. ETC stands for______________ a. Expert trading companies b. Essential trading companies c. Export trading companies d. None of the above 3. Till 1950-56 there was no clear exim policy and no __________ restrictions of any kind. a. Import b. Export c. Both a) & b) d. None of the above 4. Tariffs have been one of the classical methods of regulating ___________ trade. a. International b. National c. Domestic d. None of the above 5. The world trade organization (WTO) was established on 1st January____________ a. 1996 b. 1995 c. 1997 d. None of the above 6. Export documentation is a very important area in ___________ management. a. International b. Import c. Export IIBM Institute of Business Management 1 Examination Paper of Marketing Management d. None of the above 7. Methods of export pricing are_____________ a. Cost plus...

Words: 3028 - Pages: 13

Common Interview Question and Answer

...Questions You Should Ask 1. Do you have any hesitations about my qualifications? 2. Do you offer continuing education and professional training? 3. What have you enjoyed most about working here? 4. What is the single largest problem facing your staff and would I be in a position to help you solve this problem? 5. What is the next step in the process? Interview Questions 1. Tell me about yourself? Good morning. My name is, or you can call me David. I recently received my Bachelor’s degree of Accounting with a first-class honours from University and have completed a total 11 months of internships with KPMG as well as private entities in the past three years. I've worked hard in my education as well as internships to prepare myself to become a world class employee in my role. In my most recent position as a, I have had the opportunity to initiate and develop numerous accounting and financial-related report to Business Director and I’m proud to say that I have suggested and implemented new policies on the workflow within the company which saving the company over 40% of paper wastage. In addition, my internship at KPMG has proven my ability to be a quick-learner and adaptor when being placed in a fast-paced working environment. I believe this experience and training has prepared me to take the next step and pursue a full time position for a company where I can be a part of a team as well as allowing me to focus my energy on professional growth. 2...

Words: 6929 - Pages: 28