Premium Essay

Sarah Talley and Wal-Mart

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Sanella1987
Words 970
Pages 4
1) Was this a Distributive or Integrative negotiation?- was it the optimum approach and why or why not.

Sarah Talley and Wal-Mart are in a distributive negotiation as they only haggle about the price for 4th of July Watermelons (Lewicki, Saunders& Barry 2011). Rather than giving a “why” Wal-Mart persists with the position that the price is “too high” (Sebenius & Knebel 2006). In price-only negotiations only one party can win. Furthermore, there is a huge power difference due to Wal-Mart’s high position of strength which is based on their size (Lewicki et al. 2011). In the end these negotiations ended with Wal-Mart having to pay higher prices and with Frey Farm selling less volume at lower profits as they became a co-managed supplier of another Wal-Mart supplier. So it was not the best outcome.
2) Other than not doing the deal, list the BATNA’s Sarah had for this deal.
According to Ury and Fisher (2011), BATNA’s are a method to improve your standing towards a stronger other party. It is a contingency plan. Sarah Talley must establish the lowest acceptable price (= her bottom line) to avoid the worst possible outcome. That makes it easier to resist pressure and temptation (Fisher& Ury 2011). Talley’s BATNAs include searching for other possible buyers. Then she might see that accepting Wal-Mart’s price might be better than losing them as a customer. She could also open a Frey Farm store to sell her products. Talley could wait with closing the deal until real prices are clear (close to July 4th) and then let them pay the market price. She could also go to another Wal-Mart representative who has more experience or market knowledge or search a mediator.
3) Discuss any BATNA’s she didn’t pursue that you would have to strengthen your position.

If I was Sarah, I would not have pursued an alternative that involves ditching Wal-Mart because of the...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Ffff

...Share Embed Like Public Sarah Talley and Frey Farms Produce: Negotiating with Wal-Mart No description by on 20 March 2014 • 1438 Comments (0) Please log in to add your comment. Report abuse Transcript of Sarah Talley and Frey Farms Produce: Negotiating with Wal-Mart Sarah Talley and Frey Farms Produce Frey Farm is a supplier of produce Frey Farm - Wal-Mart Cooperation Frey Farm started growing Negotiation with Wal-Mart Harsh weather conditions lead to high prices Looking at the future Sarah Talley and Frey Farms Produce: Negotiating with Wal-Mart Atmosphere Intermediate strategy Modes of Conflict Trust Building Model Background Collaboration Negotiation In 1997, Frey Farm became Supplier of Walmart Frey Farms & Wal-Mart Problem faced by both parties Negotiation strategy & approaches Future (Threats, challenges & opportunities) Presentation outline Sarah Talley accelerated the growth by selling produce Wal-Mart Co-Management was a concept developed by Wal-Mart In both cases, negotiation failed and Sarah Talley become a third party supplier GET STARTED Frey Farm wants to become a Co-Managed supplier Wal-Mart wants to offer local sourced produce at EDLP Objectives Market position Wal-Mart has superior bargaining power Perceived divergence of interests Conflict/Cooperation Power/Dependance Unbalanced power relationship Expectations Short-term: Wal-Mart demands lower prices Long-term: "Frey Farm wants to grow alongside Wal-Mart" Ideal position Interests and desires for......

Words: 309 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Analysis

...negociación que un individuo puede utilizar para tener una negociación exitosa. En este documento se comparan y contrastan las estrategias de negociación que se abordan en dos artículos diferentes. Sarah Talley negociación con Wal-Mart Propietarios de pequeñas empresas negociar con las principales organizaciones con el fin de obtener contratos en prácticas que producen beneficios. Las grandes empresas no se pueden considerar los intereses de la organización y entrar en una negociación que beneficie a los intereses de la gran empresa el único. Las pequeñas empresas de suministro de negociar con los principales minoristas con el fin de obtener el contrato para vender sus productos. Muchas veces se encuentran en una negociación que beneficie a los intereses de la minorista solamente. Esto puede obligar a los pequeños proveedores a aceptar un contrato que no puede befit la empresa y puede conducir a la liquidación de la empresa. En el artículo "Las negociaciones con Wal-Mart" Hanna J. (2008) Sarah Talley entra en una negociación con Wal-Mart para vender sus granjas de calabazas y sandías. Wal-Mart tiene una reputación de ser un minorista importante y entra en las prácticas de bolas duras negociaciones con el fin de mantener bajos los precios. La intención de Sarah es negociar con Wal-Mart con el fin de obtener un contrato. Primer paso de...

Words: 1256 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Estrategia de Negociacion Y Analisis Del Articulo

...ahacer dee gran impacto n la vida de una persona. A la hora de negociar es muy importante escoger bien la estrategia que se utilizara y así lograr una negociación exitosa. Negociación entre Sarah Talley y las tiendas Wal-Mart Los propietarios de pequeñas empresas desean negociar con las empresas Wal-Mart para poder obtener un contrato donde se puedan intercambiar beneficios. Es necesario que ambos comerciantes puedan quedar satisfechos y de esta forma llegar a un buen negocio. Las pequeñas empresas desean obtener un contrato para poder vender su mercancía. Cuando se trata de grandes cadenas de tiendas como wal-mart, los beneficios terminan favoreciéndoles a las grandes empresas y a su vez los pequeños comerciantes terminan aceptando un contrato donde se ven afectados hasta el punto que pueden perder su negocio por perdidas. Según el articulo “ las negociaciones con Wal-Mart” Hanna J. (2008) Sarah Talley entra en una negociación para lograr vender a Wal-Mart, calabazas y sandías. Al Walt-Mart ser un minorista importante este entre en duras negociaciones co las pequeñas empresas para poder mantener sus precios mas bajos. La intención de Sarah es lograr coseguir un contrato con ellos. En la estrategia que Sarah adoptó esta en conseguir una comprensión prospectiva , de acuerdo a Walt-Mart sería beneficioso para la organización. Si se reducen los costos se...

Words: 741 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Case Analysis Sarah Tally

...Sarah Talley Farm Produce Submitted by Sudeshna Pande FT14273 Character profile of Sarah * CEO of Frey Farms (family owned business) * Began selling pumpkins at the age of 8 * Negotiated deals with retailers like Wal Mart who were entering the produce business * Has good business acumen to identify the trend in retail. Able to maintain amicable relationships with Wal Mart * Able to manage distributed produce operations * Passionate about the farm business * Go getter – Was able to secure the initial deal with Wal Mart extempore * Ambitious and ready to go after the big-fish * Recognized her company’s shortcoming in operations (to competitors) and her inexperience in business * Needed the Wal Mart contract for her business * She is on the weaker side of the negotiation table According to the case : * The business of watermelon * Seasonality – peak prices in May , June, early July (10-15 cents/pound) and off-season in July & August (4-5 cents/pound) * Adverse weather conditions and diseases seriously affect the produce of melons. * Watermelon prices are going up, but Wal Mart needed the prices to go down Recommendations (strategies ): * Fey Farm as a single entity has less power . But so do all the other competitors. Hence Sarah can building a coalition with all the melon producers in the region. * Emphasize on the fact that if Wal Mart wanted to satisfy its...

Words: 399 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Manajemen

...Management Revised Edition Peter F. Drucker with Joseph A. Maciariello Contents Introduction to the Revised Edition of Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices Preface 1 2 3 Part I 4 5 6 7 Part II 8 9 10 11 Part III 12 Introduction: Management and Managers Defined Management as a Social Function and Liberal Art The Dimensions of Management Management’s New Realities Knowledge Is All New Demographics The Future of the Corporation and the Way Ahead Management’s New Paradigm Business Performance The Theory of the Business The Purpose and Objectives of a Business Making the Future Today Strategic Planning: The Entrepreneurial Skill Performance in Service Institutions Managing Service Institutions in the Society of Organizations vii xxiii 1 18 26 35 37 45 51 65 83 85 97 113 122 129 131 iv Contents 13 14 15 16 Part IV 17 18 19 Part V 20 21 What Successful and Performing Nonprofits Are Teaching Business The Accountable School Rethinking “Reinventing Government” Entrepreneurship in the Public-Service Institution Productive Work and Achieving Worker Making Work Productive and the Worker Achieving Managing the Work and Worker in Manual Work Managing the Work and Worker in Knowledge Work Social Impacts and Social Responsibilities Social Impacts and Social Responsibilities The New Pluralism: How to Balance the Special Purpose of the Institution with the Common Good The Manager’s Work and Jobs Why Managers? Design and Content of Managerial Jobs......

Words: 243737 - Pages: 975