Premium Essay

Schooling vs Education

In: English and Literature

Submitted By 1810
Words 1488
Pages 6
Schooling Versus Education School can be defined as an institution where instruction is given to educate children. Furthermore, an education is “the process of receiving or giving systematic instruction” or “an enlightening experience.” (Merriam-Webster) Every child is required to go to school whether it is public, private, or from home. The general idea of school is “to help students realize their full potential, to equip them with the skills they’ll need to achieve success and contribute to society, or to foster the development of independence, critical thinking, and strong ethical values.” (“Against School”, 141) In reality, we are thoughtlessly going through a mandatory twelve-year education system that is strict and constraining. If you were to ask a group of students what their perspective on school is, they would most likely respond with something that relates to it being boring and pointless. Considering the general “unhappiness” of students and teachers alike, what is the purpose of our schooling system if it doesn’t have a positive affect? There are so many aspects of the schooling system that could, and in fact should, be improved but nothing seems to be done to fix these flaws. One can wonder why there haven’t been any grand gestures to reform the school system. After twelve years of being put through this strict system there must be something to gain from it, otherwise what is the point.
Against School by John Taylor Gatto is a very compelling excerpt written by a teacher with experiences from working in some of the best and worst schools in Manhattan, New York City. In addition to this, Gatto is an “ardent libertarian” and “award-winning educator”. Gatto has received many awards for his teaching including New York City Teacher of the Year and New York State Teacher of the Year. His focuses involve the history, consequences, and ideology of the...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Public Education vs Home Schooling

...more and more parents are taking their children out of the public school system and enrolling them in home schooling programs. Parents question the current public school system and wonder if home schooling would be a better alternative for their children’s education. Considering that there are already more than four million children enrolled in these types of programs in the United States alone, it is not surprising that it has caused some heated debates during the past decade. Along with an average 15 to 20 % yearly growth rate, many professional educators are worried that because of this much needed funds will be kept from entering the public education system. During the year of 2007 the United States Department of Education conducted a study that showed home schooled student's test scores were much higher than others. Even the median scores for all grades were much larger than those students of public or private schools. For example, in grades one through four, average home schooled students were usually one grade higher than their peers in public school. By the equivalent of eighth grade, those home schooled students were usually considered four years ahead of those in public school. One reason for these results is that home schooled students often receive much more one-on-one attention than the average student in public or private school does. In home schooling programs the students receive much more attention than they do in a Public School because there are......

Words: 1049 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Home Schooling vs Public Schooling

...Home Schooling vs. Public Schools: Which One is Better? Thesis Statement: Many parents question what is best for their child’s education, home schooling or public school. Home schooling can sometimes provide a more direct and focused education than public schools, Public School is better in many ways including the child’s social development. I. Home Schooling vs. Public Schooling II. The Pros and Cons of Home Schooling A. Home schooling can benefit both students and parents by providing individual attention. B. Home schooling gives parents a sense of security. C. Home schooling puts financial strain on parents. D. Home schooling can cause slower social development. III. The Pros and Cons of Public Schooling A. Public schooling provides many free services. B. Public schooling allows both parents time to have a full time job. C. Public schooling allows students to participate in many activities, sports, and organizations. D. Public schooling makes students more likely to deal with bullying and peer pressure . D. Home Schooling vs Public Schooling: Which is Better? A. The pros of public schooling outweigh the cons, thus making public schooling the better choice. When children become of age, and it is time for them to start school, many parents question what is best for their child’s education, home schooling or public school. Both home schooling and public schooling has their pros and cons, but many parents often......

Words: 1089 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Drama

...Public Schools vs. Home Schools Public Schools vs. Home Schools Napoleon Butler University of Phoenix Public Schools vs. Home Schools In today’s society education is the key to success; even though they’re many differences between public schooling, and home schooling they both share major goals that are similar. The common school system in America has for a long time been considered the foundation for providing students with strong educational support. However, these same environments are considered be sometimes challenging because of the obstacles that certain students face. Traditional schooling has certain stumbling blocks such as: particular beliefs in religion and many students receive individualized instructions. The way the economy is drastically changing everyday means that every student needs an opportunity to further goals in life to succeed. To accomplish this goal all parents need to ensure that their children are attending a professional operated educational program. This is determined by the environment for the student, and the education that the student can receive while attending the school. The two most common schooling environments for students to attend are public schooling, and home schooling. Throughout attending public schools many students obtain many obstacles to overcome to actually receive a preferable education. These obstacles can sometimes lead to health issues, and bullying from other students. These students have to overcome peer......

Words: 1084 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Com155 Week 9 Final Paper

...Home Schooling vs. Public Schooling Jill Norris COM155 October 27, 2012 Dr. Melton Home Schooling vs. Public Schooling The grand cartoonist Al Capps once said, “Any place that anyone can learn something useful from someone with experience is an educational institution.”(Capps) This statement evokes thought of exactly what defines a “school.” Can any place be called a school? Certainly the home can be called a school as there are around 1.5 million children in the United States are homeschooled. Home schooled children are able to practice their religion, can have a different curriculum, and different disciplinary actions, but both can lead to a well educated student. Public schools, even with all of their bad press, are still the most popular way to educate a child (Homeschool Or Public School? 2012) According to www.hslada.org, which provides legal analysis of home school laws, someone that is interested in homeschooling their children should follow the law of the state in which they reside. Laws governing home school education vary by state and according to the 10th Amendment of the Constitution the power to regulate all forms of education belong to the states. Homeschooling is included in this protection. The Constitution states that the federal government is not allowed to interfere with or control public or private forms of education. The progression requirements for home schooled children do differ state by state and the federal government has no laws or...

Words: 1503 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

English Paper

...This type of school follows a certain curriculum that is given by the local government, as well as the state government. (Vercillo, 2012) These schools are open to any student that lives within the school district for that city. Parents choose this type of school for a lot of reasons. One reason is the convenience factor. It is close to the family’s home and transportation can be provided to and from school or they can walk. The second reason is there is no cost to attend public school. Another reason is it has a lot of diversity. Most people consider public school as the “norm.” “Children will basically fit in with society after going through standard schooling.” (Vercillo, 2012) There are many negative effects that public school education has on the child. One negative effect is that there is a lower quality of education. Some parents feel that if a child is smart they get left out because the school curriculum is geared toward teaching the children that are not that smart. (Vercillo, 2012) A second negative...

Words: 1739 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Comparison Between..

...Benefits and disadvantages of home schooling vs public schools Chancia Tokyo international University Academic composition I Those past years we have a lot of children or teenager who can decide where they want to study. They can study in a class surrounded by other students or at home, alone. Public school presents a lot of opportunity for teenagers to be social with other students, do some extracurricular activities and go outside to hang out with their friends. Also, as I mentioned before it is not the only one, there is homeschooling. By being homeschooled, students gain the same education as what the public schools students study. Thus, they can study whatever they want. It only depends on the environment and the academic contents that the parents or teenagers are using, to teach them or themselves. So what is best for the education of our children? Both of them are mainly good, the only thing that we need to do is it to give, children’s, the best education. To begin with, we all know that parents want the best for their children’s, which is not bad and apparently from an article written by Shaw I., homeschooling are getting more famous each year. The growth rate is of 15 percent. So those who are considering letting their children study at home you should be aware of those benefits. From an article written by Richardson H. in “Children should be allowed to get bored, expert says”, said that by letting our children get bored will lead them to developing a......

Words: 990 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Children Who Attend Public Schools Are Better Socialized Than Those Who Are Homeschooled

...schools are better socialized than those who are homed schooled’. This report begins with a brief abstract which compares both the home and public schooling options being explored within the American society. The second section is the introduction which highlights the various attributes that parents hope to achieve for their children, followed by the overall analysis of the topic. The final segment is the conclusion which summarizes the entire report by reiterating the key elements of both home and public schooling, and will allow you the audience to make a decision that would be beneficial to your specific needs. I would like to say special thanks to Professor Amanda Richey for granting me the opportunity to research a topic that is of personal interest and I hope that you will all enjoy reading my report. Yours Truly, Cadien Vaccianna Table of Content Title Page 1 Letter of Transmittal 2 Table of Content 3 Abstract 4 Introduction 5 Literature review 6 Importance of Home school vs Public school 8 Home school environment vs Public school 9 Socialization 10 Conclusion 11 References 13 Abstract Making the best choice for your child’s education is a crucial step that will determine his or her future direction and instill discipline, values and beliefs that will help the...

Words: 2784 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Home School vs. Public School

...Home schooled children are more advanced than children attending public schools. There are advantages to home schooling that can not be offered by public schools. The purpose of this paper is to bring awareness to some of the areas in which the statement , "Home-schooled" children are more advanced than children attending public schools, are supportive. Interest in this topic mainly are generated due to the decline in the public school system. As a parent of a current ninth grader I am saddend by the issues that children have to deal with in order to receive public education. Home schooling is defined as, ‘an education that is provided outside a ‘normal' school environment’. This type of education has undergone numerous debates, raising questions as to whether or not it is an effective educational program. Many people are equally divided between the pros and the cons, with people arguing that home schooling offers many benefits for children and others arguing that it affects children’s social skills and education. If the opportunity arose home schooling is an option I would consider home schooling for my current student. Acamdemic Schedule Home school students learning environments are more structured for the individual student. This is a comfortability level that can not be offered in public school. One of the pros of home schooling is its controlled environment. More personalized attention allows the student to focus on the core subjects, reading and......

Words: 939 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Public Education vs Home Schooled

...Home School vs. Public School Please use the style handbook to see how to correctly format your essay. The title should be in the same font as the rest of the essay. Rough Draft When children become of age and it is time for them to start school, many parents question what is best for their child’s education, home schooling or public school. With home schooling and public schooling have their pros and cons, but many parents often question which one is actually better for their child. Though public schools are effective in helping a child develop social skills, home schooling is a more direct and focused on your education. Home schooling can be good for a child in many ways. They have a more direct and focused method of learning because the class size is not as large as a public school class. Children as well as parents are able to have a more flexible schedule because it is up to them to set a schedule that will work out for them time wise. Home school gives parents an opportunity to be flexible. Parents feel that with home school, learning at home is the safest, most secure environment in which their child can learn. It makes sense that children would thrive in the comfort of their own homes, wearing whatever they want, with the restroom and kitchen close by for breaks. With the absence of diversions for home students, they tend to be more focused on the lessons being taught and complete the work they are expected to do. Without having to meet the pace of other......

Words: 1081 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Homeschool vs Public School

...thought about the options of home schooling vs. public schooling. You most likely have thought about how much would it cost or the amount of time it takes to teach home schooling. With the news articles out there about things that happen at schools you most likely have thought about how that would be on your child as well. One of the last things that most parents think about when choosing to home school or not are how your child’s social skills will develop. There are many different articles out there on this topic. The following essay will give you an indebt description of the difference between public and in-home schooling and its effects on the children. To start the first thing that comes to most parent’s mind is how much time and money they are going to spend in each situation. Concerning home schooling, you do spend most of your time with your children. There is no hiding that fact. Depending on your day-to-day life, this might be easy for you. This is the first thing you have to look at when making that choice for your children. Now concerning public school, you get to send your children to a different location for anywhere between four to eight hours. Now one good thing about public school is there are extracurricular activities available for children whose parents cannot be home after they get home from school. Another thing that parents are concerned about is the price difference between home schooling and public schooling. Where public schools......

Words: 1189 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Traditional Education vs. Online Education

...Online Education vs. Traditional Education Online Education vs. Traditional Education There are different ways to access higher education, either through online education or traditional education. For centuries, online education could not compare to traditional education. Today, online education competes with traditional education in many ways. Though online education has become very popular, how does one know which is best for him or her? Identifying the pros and cons through flexibility, communication, interaction, skills development, and affordability will help the student decide the best option. Although online education seems to be taking over the traditional means of education, both are great options in different ways. The bottom line is that the world is becoming technologically smart. For one juggling home, school, and a job, it can be difficult commuting to class every day. Online education eliminates the need to attend class. Online courses allow the student to access coursework from an Internet site. Motivated, responsible, independent learners can work at their own pace, whenever is suitable for them. This allows the flexibility that a traditional classroom setting does not provide. However, one who struggles to be self-motivated may fall quickly behind. In a traditional classroom setting the student has to attend class on campus. Traditional education is for a learner who needs more lecturing to understand and also needs to be able to ask questions as he...

Words: 1058 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Home School vs Public School

...Home School VS Public School Home school and public school is a debated subject. Parents are disputing whether home school education or a public school education is more beneficial for their child. An education that fits the need of a child is important; that’s why there are things to be considered when choosing an education path for a child. The socializing scene plays a major role in children’s lives. It is very important that children get to play and talk to their peers. The students who are home schooled are more likely to be shy compared to public school students. Being around your peers helps you build up your self-esteem. Physical fitness is something that students need to do to stay healthy and in shape. Public schools have recess where the student gets to run around and play with their classmates. Every child needs to get some kind of exercise in each day. Home school students are less likely to get exercise because they do not have anyone their age to play with unless their siblings are home schooled as well. It is very important that students have access to their teacher when needed. In public schools, the students have their teacher in the classroom with them. They are able to walk up to them and get help whenever needed. Home ...

Words: 426 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Dewey's Theory Of Education

...he points out is that the main reason for traditional concept for not being in effect is for the reason that there is no teacher-student exchange of ideas and the innovative mind is repressed. Freire criticized this model of education because he supposed it made students into lifeless objects to be act on behalf of the teacher. In log-term this will result in the students uncomplaining and adapting...

Words: 1312 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Education

...To some people finding the right type of education that fits in your lifestyle and needs is complicated. Some options for parents are private schools, public schools, and home schooling their children. Depends on what the parents choose is best for their children. Since private schools and public schools fall under the category with traditional schooling, lets compare and contrast traditional schooling vs. home schooling. The two are both types of schools. The student can earn a diploma with either way of schooling program. Both of the ways of schooling have the same main courses needed to graduate.Something that might be different is how many credits are needed to graduate. Most are 21 credits with four credits from the main classes like science, English, history, and math. Also a half credit from gym class. For some home school students getting that grade is hard. They might need to go to a park and play basketball or find something to do outside. Some parents don’t want to hire a teacher so they enroll their kids in the online home schooling. The two types of schooling ways also let the student progress through the course. For example if you pass your first year of regular science you have the option to further into biology, chemistry, geology, and psychics. Both ways of schooling offer different classes you can take like computer classes, second languages, art class, Hom-each,accounting, and etc. A major difference is the pace of learning. Home schooled kids can......

Words: 769 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Online Versus on-Campus Learning

...Annotated Bibliography Educational Technology Issue Question: Should online higher education courses replace traditional on-campus learning? Arguments for online courses replacing traditional learning: Clark, K. (2009, April 2). Online Education Offers Access and Affordability. US News Education. Retrieved November 8, 2012, from http://chronicle.com/article/Why-Online-Education-Wont/133531/ Summary: US News Education provides rankings of the best universities and provides valuable insight for college students. In this article, the author argues that recent improvements in the quality of online courses are attracting millions of students. It also states that adults who are time-stressed and already worried about commuting to a campus university find convenience in online courses. As the economy began its decline, there has been an increase of students enrolling in online courses. Coleman, S. (2005, August 14). Why Do Students Like Online Learning? Worldwide Learn. Retrieved November 6, 2012, from http://www.worldwidelearn.com/education-articles/benefits-of-online-learning.htm Summary: Worldwide Learn is an online resource for students’ educational needs. This article contains a list of reasons why more college students are enrolling in online courses. It provides a convincing argument that includes accessible course material 24/7 and allows for a broad spectrum of content. The article praises online courses for its flexibility, accessibility and quality of content....

Words: 1094 - Pages: 5