Free Essay

Science

In: Science

Submitted By pavankalyan
Words 1626
Pages 7
Free University of Amsterdam
Faculty of social sciences
Department of political science

Globalization: The end of state
Sovereignty?

Ofran Badakhshani:
1586513
Words: 1442

Ofran Badakhshani: 1586513
Written assignment for International Relations

Index
Introduction......................................................................................................................... 3
Globalization....................................................................................................................... 3
State sovereignty................................................................................................................. 4
Analysis............................................................................................................................... 4
Conclusion .......................................................................................................................... 6
Bibliography ....................................................................................................................... 7

2
Globalization: The end of state Sovereignty?

Ofran Badakhshani: 1586513
Written assignment for International Relations

Introduction
“A specter is haunting the world’s governments, the specter of globalization”. The world order and politics are facing a new danger; the sovereignty of the nation states is under question.
According to some theorists there is a constantly growing dependency and interconnectedness between the nation states, and the governments have become weaker and less relevant then ever before. But what does this dependency and interconnectedness mean and to what extent does it affect the sovereignty and autonomy of the nation state? In other words does globalization mean the end of state sovereignty?

In order to answer the above question, an explanation of the two notions above is required. I first provide you with some contemporary definitions of globalization and state sovereignty, and then try to measure the impacts of globalization on the state sovereignty from different perspectives.
And because globalization and state sovereignty are very wide and contested notions, this paper concentrates only on four perspectives, namely economical, political, philosophical and criminological. Globalization
As has the impact and growth of globalization changed, so has its meaning during the last decades. But what is certain is that globalization is not something of today or yesterday.
Among the so many given definitions, Martin Wolf defines globalization as a “journey, but toward an unreachable destination, the globalized world. A globalized economy in which neither distance nor national borders impede economic transactions. A world where the cost of transport and communication were zero and the barriers created by differing national jurisdictions had vanished” (Wolf, 2001: 178).
But globalization is a very wide notion, which embraces the social, cultural, and political interdependency of states. Globalization refers also to the integration and interaction between different people and nations. Take the European Union as an example, where the member states share the same democratic values and norms, or the convergence and similarities of the constitutions of the member states, which could lead to a European law or constitution.

3
Globalization: The end of state Sovereignty?

Ofran Badakhshani: 1586513
Written assignment for International Relations
State sovereignty
The notion concept of sovereignty refers to the three-fold capacity of a state, which is the
“absolute supremacy over internal affairs within its territory, absolute right to govern its people, and freedom from any external interference in the above matters” (Wang, 2004: 473). So a state is sovereign if it has the ability to make and implement laws within its territory, and can function without any external power and assistance, and doesn’t acknowledges any higher authority above itself in the world of independent states. From the above definition one can draw the conclusion that either a state can be sovereign or not, since sovereignty is defined as the absolute supremacy and right of the government in a given state.

Analysis
A realist like Steven D.Krasner agrees on the collapsing autonomy of states but deny the impact of globalization on nation state, which could possibly lead to the death of state sovereignty. He argues, “Those who proclaim the death of sovereignty misread the history. The nation state has a keen instinct for survival and has so far adapted to new challenges, even the challenge of globalization” (Krasner, 2001: 20). He also argues that globalization is not a new challenge or phenomena. Even though I agree that globalization is not something of today, the question that remains is whether contemporary globalization is likely to have a different impact on the nation state then that of the past? For today’s globalization distinguishes itself from that of the past in terms of rapid communication, market liberalization and the global integration of goods, services and production.

Taking the example of the European supremacy era in world trade, and its relation with the Far
East, we can speak of a global trade and exchange of goods and services. This explains the difference between modern globalization and that of the past. Even though it might not be appropriated to compare the ancient world with today’s modern nation states, as we did not have independent and sovereign states then; we had independent regions. For example, China was not dependent on economical relations with Europe in the past; nor was Europe on China. But today there is an increasingly growing interdependency between them. The nation states are compelled to build relations with other states in order to sell their goods, services and develop a stronger and larger economy. So due to this interdependency we can undermine one of the three-fold capacities of a sovereign state -the absolute freedom from any external force, which shapes the

4
Globalization: The end of state Sovereignty?

Ofran Badakhshani: 1586513
Written assignment for International Relations conduct of the nation states. Although states are not literally forced to modify their conduct toward the international society or other states, it is in their interest to do so.
Part of the sovereignty is also the ability of a state to solve its domestic problems on its own. But since problems and threats are getting more globalized, it is almost impossible for a state to act alone and entirely independent. Taking the international crime as an example, let’s assume there is a weapon trade between two criminal organizations rooted in Germany and in The Netherlands.
In order to demolish this crime network The Netherlands is dependent on the assistance of
Germany and vice versa. This undermines the second notion of sovereignty, which is absolute supremacy over internal affairs within its territory.

Also seen from a philosophical point of view, there is a demising process in the sovereignty of nation state. The emergence of International Human Rights Organization, which is based on the
Kantian philosophy that views the world as a community of free individuals; a community where nations and borders are no longer relevant or of any meaning.
According to this philosophy one can speak of a world, which is going toward a global civil society. It might be worth mentioning what the notion of global civil society stands for.
Originally the notion of civil society referred to, or was characterized by, a social contract. “Civil society was a type of state on the principle of equality before the law, in which everyone including the ruler at least in the Lockean conception was subject to the law”(Kaldor, 2003: 583).
But as theorists came to speak of a global civil society, its meaning changed and it referred to a
“platform inhabited by activist, NGO’s, and neo liberals, as well as national and religious groups, where they argue about, campaign for or against, negotiate or lobby for the arrangements that shape global developments”(Kaldor, 2003: 590).

There is a certain movement to perceive so to speak in the world order. States are more likely to join each other in terms of cooperation and political relations. The European referendum for the
European law can be considered as such a movement and tendency. Though there is already cooperation between the state members, but the European law, if passed, would have definitely had a different impact on the cooperation between the member states. Europe would then be more of one Europe rather then a Europe, which consists of member states. But also the emerging of negotiations on the Persian triangle, which is supposed to constitute a more widely political and economical cooperation between Khorasan (Afghanistan), Iran and Tajikistan could be another example. 5
Globalization: The end of state Sovereignty?

Ofran Badakhshani: 1586513
Written assignment for International Relations
Viewed from a criminological point, “the perceived normality of high crime rates, together with thee widely acknowledged limitations of criminal justice agencies, have begun to erode one of the foundational myths of modern societies: namely, the myth that the sovereign state is capable of providing security, law and order, crime control within its territorial boundaries” (Garland, 1996:
448). The notion of legitimate organized violence monopoly, which is of great importance for the internal order as well as for the foreign accountability of a state, is challenged by the international criminality. Since states cannot provide security for their citizens and are not capable of guaranteeing internal order, one of the fundamental elements of state sovereignty is undermined and questioned.

Conclusion
Taking the increasing growth of interdependency between the states, the emergence of transnational institutions, multinationals and benevolent organizations and the integration of international laws under consideration, one can conclude that there is a declining process to perceive in the sovereignty of the nation states. Nation states are also domestically under attack of the high rate of criminal and terrorist events. Since nation states no longer can grantee the security of their citizens and cannot independently act in order to solve their domestic problems, there is a lack of sovereignty. So the globalization will gradually lead to the demise of nation state and its sovereignty.

6
Globalization: The end of state Sovereignty?

Ofran Badakhshani: 1586513
Written assignment for International Relations
Bibliography
Garland, David (1996): “The limits of the Sovereign state: strategies of crime in contemporary society.” The British Journal of Criminology, 36/4: 448-449.
Kaldor, Mary (2003): “The idea of global civil society.” International Affairs, 79/3: 583-593.
Kranser, Stephen D. (2001): “Sovereignty.” Foreign Policy, 122: 20-29.
Wang, Guigo (2004): “The impact of Globalization on State Sovereignty.” Chinese Journal of
International Law, 3/2: 473-483.
Wolf, martin (2001): “Will the nation state survive globalization?.” Foreign Affairs, 80/1: 187190.

7
Globalization: The end of state Sovereignty?

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Science

...Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science science Science science science science......

Words: 460 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Science

...The word 'science' is derived from the Latin word 'scientia' which means knowledge. Therefore, science is about gaining knowledge either through observing, studying, experience, or practice. Entire knowledge acquired through science is about discovering truths, finding facts, uncovering phenomenon hidden by the nature. Observations and experimentation, in science, support in describing truth and realities through systematic processes and procedures. For me, science is an intellectual set of activities designed to uncover information about anything related to this world in which we live. The information gathered is organized through scientific methods to form eloquent patterns. In my opinion the primary objective of science is to gather information and to distinguish the order found between facts. What Science Means to Me as an Upcoming Scientist Science exposes several ideas along with significant themes so that I could test them independently and without any bias to arrive at solid conclusion. For this purpose exchange of data and materials is necessary. I am able to generate real and tangible facts supported by reliable evidence. Work of scientist is based on theoretical science. It means, in theoretical science, there is only a sign, just a hint on which discoveries could be made, facts could be found. While studying science I am always working for determining truth, based on my perceptions, judgment, observation, experience, and knowledge collected through several means...

Words: 1529 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Science

...Science is the concerted human effort to understand, or to understand better, the history of the natural world and how the natural world works, with observable physical evidence as the basis of that understanding1. It is done through observation of natural phenomena, and/or through experimentation that tries to simulate natural processes under controlled conditions. (There are, of course, more definitions of science.) Consider some examples. An ecologist observing the territorial behaviors of bluebirds and a geologist examining the distribution of fossils in an outcrop are both scientists making observations in order to find patterns in natural phenomena. They just do it outdoors and thus entertain the general public with their behavior. An astrophysicist photographing distant galaxies and a climatologist sifting data from weather balloons similarly are also scientists making observations, but in more discrete settings. The examples above are observational science, but there is also experimental science. A chemist observing the rates of one chemical reaction at a variety of temperatures and a nuclear physicist recording the results of bombardment of a particular kind of matter with neutrons are both scientists performing experiments to see what consistent patterns emerge. A biologist observing the reaction of a particular tissue to various stimulants is likewise experimenting to find patterns of behavior. These folks usually do their work in labs and wear......

Words: 306 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Science

...Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science Science......

Words: 462 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Science

...Chapter 132 - Science and Technology Section SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Science and technology provide people with the knowledge and tools to understand and address many of the challenges. Students must be provided with opportunities to access, understand, and evaluate current information and tools related to science and technology if they are to be ready to live in a 21st century global society. The study of science and technology includes both processes and bodies of knowledge. Scientific processes are the ways scientists investigate and communicate about the natural world. The scientific body of knowledge includes concepts, principles, facts, laws, and theories about the way the world around us works. Technology includes the technological design process and the body of knowledge related to the study of tools and the effect of technology on society. Science and technology merge in the pursuit of knowledge and solutions to problems that require the application of scientific understanding and product design. Solving technological problems demands scientific knowledge while modern technologies make it possible to discover new scientific knowledge. In a world shaped by science and technology, it is important for students to learn how science and technology connect with the demands of society and the knowledge of all content areas. It is equally important that students are provided with learning experiences that integrate tools, knowledge, and processes of science and......

Words: 8232 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

The Importance Of Science In Science

...Our project specifically focused on the DNA sequence analysis of the genes in duckweed and how those genes fit into bioremediation. As an intimidated and shy freshman with a strong yearning to be part of the science community at my school, decided to join the intensive program with barely any knowledge about biology. It didn't seem like a smart move at the time, but I'm glad that I had persistence because I learned so much about the field through the guidance from the team. Exploring PCR and Restriction Digests, my group and I were able to publish new proteins on the national GenBank. I learned more about biology and how to work/perform in a team. This motivated me to join the Science/Biology Olympiads where we do independent research and come together as a team to compete. I found that these opportunities along with the research in my science classes not only help me learn actual science but provide me with valuable life skills that will help in the...

Words: 918 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Science

...1. Describe how fishing has changed at Apo Island, and the direct and indirect effects on people’s lives. Apo Island’s marine preserve allows fishing with hand-held lines, bamboo traps, large mesh nets, spear fishing without SCUBA gear, and hand netting. Fishing with dynamite, cyanide, trawling, and Muro-ami are forbidden. This has increased fish populations and made it easier to catch the fish needed to support a family. The healthy reef community now attracts ecotourists and provides jobs for islanders. 2. What are some basic assumptions of science? 3. Distinguish between a hypothesis and a theory. A hypothesis is the second step from the scientific method that forms an educated guess based off an observation. A theory is the information that was gathered to support the proof of an observation and confirms the hypothesis. 4. Describe the steps in the scientific method. 7. What’s the first step in critical thinking? The first step in critical thinking is 8. Distinguish between utilitarian conservation and biocentric preservation. Name two environmental leaders associated with each of these philosophies. Biocentric preservation emphasizes the fundamental right of living organisms to exist and to pursue their own good. While utilitarian conservation emphasized that resources should be used for the greater good for the greatest number for the longest time. Two environmental leaders associated with the biocentric preservation philosophy are John......

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Science

...Blueprint to address Australia’s lack of science strategy unveiled Chief scientist makes series of recommendations to improve the country’s skills in science, technology, engineering and maths Australia’s chief scientist, Ian Chubb, has unveiled a blueprint to address Australia’s lack of a science strategy, with proposals aimed at improving skills, supporting research and linking scientific work to other countries. Chubb has made a series of recommendations to the federal government to increase focus on science, technology, engineering and maths skills. The strategy is partially aimed at addressing the declining number of students taking advanced maths in year 11 and 12, as well as the shortage of qualified maths and science teachers. Chubb said each primary school should have at least one specialist maths and science teacher, a policy currently used in South Australia and Victoria. This would be encouraged by improving incentives, including pay, for teachers. Other recommendations include supporting research potential, improving research collaboration with other countries and doing more to stress the importance of science to businesses and students. Chubb said: “We are the only OECD country without a science or technology strategy. Other countries have realised that such an approach is essential to remaining competitive in a world reliant on science and science-trained people. “Science is infrastructure and it is critical to our future. We must align our scientific......

Words: 510 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Science

...Science: A Blessing Or A Curse Everything in the universe has its uses and abuses. The same applies to science. Science has revolutionized human existence and has made it happier and more comfortable. Modern science has many wonders. Electricity is one of its greatest wonders. It is a source of energy. It can run any type of machinery. With the help of electricity, we can light our rooms, run buses and trains and machinery, lift water for irrigation and can accomplish a multitude of other tasks. Much of the progress that mankind has made in different fields right from the stone age to the modern age is due to the progress made in the filed of science. Not only material progress but also the mental outlook of man has been influenced by it. Agriculture, business, transport, communication and medicine to name a few are all highly indebted to the wonders of science. We have become scientifically much more advanced than our ancestors. This is because the world has undergone a tremendous change because of the rapid strides made by science and technology. The discovery and development of a large number of powerful energy sources – coal, petroleum, natural gas, electricity etc. – have enabled humanity to conquer the barriers of nature. All these have facilitated the growth of fast modes of transport and communication, which have metamorphosed the world into a global village. Science has given man the means of travelling to the moon. Science is a great help in the agricultural......

Words: 2098 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Science

...Blessing of Science Blessings of science are numerous. Science has completely changed the living style of man. Now man is living in a totally 18 century. From home to office, from farm to factory, form village to town, in short everywhere in life now we can see the unlimited blessing of science. At home, we find that science has provided many comforts to the human beings. Whether it is kitchen, lounge, shaker, chopper, toaster and many other appliance have brought a revolution in the working of a kitchen and a housewife. Although it is a fact that science can not fight with fate and it often fails to defeat nature yet it has done a lot to minimize the disastrous effects of nature. Scientists have invented such machines like air conditioner and heater that can give comfort to the man in hot summers and in extreme winters respectively. Now there are such instruments, which can warn man against floods, earthquakes and windstorm. After getting such warnings human beings are able to take preventive measures. Travelling and transportation were very difficult and paining in the past but now the miracles of science have made the travelling a luxury. Now there are variety of means of transportation like buses, cars, trains and aero-planes that have decreased the distances and have made the journey a comfort. Now hundreds of people can travel from own country to the other country in one train or in one aero-plane. The distance that could be covered by the people in the months...

Words: 1787 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Science

...Advantage Science gives us safe food, free from harmful bacteria, in clean containers or hygienic tins. It also teaches us to eat properly, indicating a diet balanced in protein and carbohydrate and containing vitamins. The results is freedom from disease and prolonged life. In pre-scientific days, food was monotonous and sometimes dangerous; today it is safe and varied. It is varied because through improved sea, land and air transport food can now be freely imported and exported. Science has also improved clothing and made it more appropriate for climatic and working conditions. Man-made fibers and versatile spinning machines, today enable us to dress in clothes both comfortable and smart without being expensive. Home, school and office all bear witness to the progress and application of science. Nowadays, most homes possess electric lighting and cooking, but many also have washing machines, vacuum cleaners and kitchen appliances, all designed to increase comfort and cleanliness and reduce drudgery. Science produces the fan which cools the air, the machinery which makes the furniture and fabrics, and hundred and one other features for good living. The books and papers are at school, and again everything from the piece of chalk to the closed-circuit television of instruction are the direct or indirect results of scientific progress. Learning is therefore easier. And clerical work is made far more speedy and efficient by the office typewriter, quite apart from the hundreds......

Words: 572 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Science

...One of the major shortcomings of science supposedly is a lack of communication between scientists and the general public. Many argue that too often, science is only presented in written academic journals that are not so easily obtained by the general public. This is discussed on a daily basis and was argued in the aftermath of the 2011 earthquake and tsunami in Japan, as well as in on-going debate about other scientific theories and ideas. However, people fail to realize a few things. One of the major things is that, in terms of an earthquake or tsunami, you simply cannot predict anything like that. You cannot blame scientists for not being able to predict an earthquake like a meteorologist can predict weather events. Scientists can study things like seismic activity and they can make assumptions as to what may happen should an earthquake of a high magnitude hit and cause something catastrophic like a tsunami. Yet, some fail to realize that some safety measures were taken, and even inspectors that visited the Fukushima Nuclear power plant asked Japanese authorities to increase safety measures further. According to a France24 news article written three months after the catastrophe, “A three-page summary was issued at the end of the 18-member team’s May 24-June 2 inspector mission to Japan. It said the country underestimated the threat from tsunamis to the Fukushima plant and urged sweeping changes to its regulatory system. Japanese authorities have been criticised......

Words: 769 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Science

...SCIENCE My second month in Gusa Regional Science High School! Do you want to know what are the activities and what have I learn this month? As we all know this month is “Nutrition Month,” so I am excited what are the activities that would be held in celebrating the nutrition month. Come! and let us know what happened this July. On the first day of July we answer our wortext. We answer page 17, 1-5 in ½ lengthwise. The next day we had a contest about the scientist. We were gouped into two groups, group a and group b. Group a scored 27 while group b scored 31. Group b win with the score of 31, while group a lose with the score of 27. Group a’s punishment is they have to dance. The boys did it but the girls pleaded that they will just sing rather than dance. Teacher Cass agreed, and in the middle of singing “Nasayo Na Ang Lahat,”Teacher Cass gestured to the boys to join the girls singing. The boys didn’t insist in joining the girls. On Thursday, the rain was falling hard so teacher Cass is the one who come to us. We were trapped in Teacher Lory’s classroom. We had another game same us what we did yesterday. This time its boys vs girls. The girls won the game and as expected boys got a punishment. Their punishment was they did a fashion show. ......

Words: 372 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Science

...In this essay I will focus on the events surrounding the regulation of Alar (diaminozide) up to and including 1985, as a case-study of knowledge and decision-making amidst uncertainty (418-19). I pick this time period in particular, because it is when the NRDC and other public interest groups began their campaign in protest against the EPA's decision to not ban Alar. My analysis of the events surrounding Alar will take shape around a critique of Michael Fumento's article "Environmental Hysteria: The Alar Scare," in which he paints the NRDC as "fanatics" launching a "smear campaign" not founded in any rational decision-making. This is an important argument to counter, because it has not only been taken up by many to condemn citizen-group action in the case of Alar, but to criticize their activities in many other regulatory processes. The chief framework used to devalue public action in these cases is the technocratic model, wherein it is believed that decisions can be best made by objective, rational experts acting based upon scientific knowledge. In this case, we can see a perfect example of when a decision was decided by scientific experts, in accordance with the technocratic model. Fumento and other supporters of the technocratic mode privilege the scientific knowledge of bodies such as the Scientific Advisory Panel in this case over other forms of knowledge. He denounces NRDC as fanatics based on his claim that they acted in spite of, and in contradiction to......

Words: 2159 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Science

...Scientific papers are for sharing your own original research work with other scientists or for reviewing the research conducted by others. As such, they are critical to the evolution of modern science, in which the work of one scientist builds upon that of others. To reach their goal, papers must aim to inform, not impress. They must be highly readable — that is, clear, accurate, and concise. They are more likely to be cited by other scientists if they are helpful rather than cryptic or self-centered. Scientific papers typically have two audiences: first, the referees, who help the journal editor decide whether a paper is suitable for publication; and second, the journal readers themselves, who may be more or less knowledgeable about the topic addressed in the paper. To be accepted by referees and cited by readers, papers must do more than simply present a chronological account of the research work. Rather, they must convince their audience that the research presented is important, valid, and relevant to other scientists in the same field. To this end, they must emphasize both the motivation for the work and the outcome of it, and they must include just enough evidence to establish the validity of this outcome. Papers that report experimental work are often structured chronologically in five sections: first, Introduction; then Materials and Methods, Results, and Discussion (together, these three sections make up the paper's body); and finally, Conclusion. The......

Words: 373 - Pages: 2