Premium Essay

Scientific and Management Theory

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By wandaasteele
Words 1110
Pages 5
Scientific and behavioral management theory represents two views of management on the opposite ends of the spectrum. Scientific management theory focuses on looking at workers solely as a means to get work done, while behavioral management theory focuses on developing an organization and the behaviors and motivations of employees. Most managers find that a combination of the two theories serves them best in their business. However, both methods are not always applied to all businesses. The companies that use both methods usually apply one more than the other. The core ideas of scientific management were developed by Frederick Winslow Taylor. Frederick was an American mechanical engineer who sought to improve industrial efficiency (Copely, 1967). Frederick’s theory, also known as Taylorism, was established in the 1920’s. According to Taylor, workers were incapable of understanding what they were doing and believed that transferring control from worker to management would solve that problem. Although his workers were able to earn more than those under conventional management, the introduction of this theory was often resented by workers and provoked numerous strikes. Scientific management theory, which is classified as the classical theory, involves creating different levels of workers to improve productivity. Employees’ tasks are overseen by supervisors whose tasks are overseen by managers. Specific procedures have been tested a large number of times and are formed to maximize productivity. The workers understand the point of view of management in increasing the profitability and production of the company. Appropriate training and screening are done scientifically while picking employees for this type of management. Taylor developed the concept of work as “one best way of doing a job” (Copely, 1967).
The behavioral management theory is often...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Scientific Theory of Management

...Scientific Management Theory Frederick Taylor and Scientific Management Student Name Institutional Affiliation Scientific Management Theory Frederick Taylor and Scientific Management Frederick Winslow Taylor (1856-1915) was an inventor as well as an engineer who applied his knowledge on engineering and scientific knowhow to management and came up with a theory referred to as the scientific management theory. His books, oh the Scientific Management Theory include Shop Management (1903) and The Principles of Scientific Management (1911). The scientific management theory can be seen mostly in firms that deal with manufacturing, as well as many other types of businesses. Taylor's imprint can be found on production planning, control of production, design processes, quality control, cost accounting or ergonomics. Through Taylor's theories, one can see and understand the principles of scientific management as well as how managers produce their products and manage their staff. One is also able to comprehend the relevance of quantitative data analysis to improve the effectiveness of production and efficacy (Mullins, 2005) Principles of Scientific Management Theory In simpler terms, the, scientific management theory implies the application of principles that relate to industrial engineering to generate a system whereby the avoidance of waste is actualized, there is fair distribution of goods, improved methods of production (Mumford, 1994). . These enhancements effectively serve the......

Words: 2064 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Management Scientific Theory

...Recognizing that fact, it can be easily clarified that the relationship between organization and the study of management is very strong and so the knowledge about organization is always briefly explained before stepping further in to the discussion of management work. Basically, organization defined as a systematic arrangement of people. Every organization has distinct aims that need to be achieved by a group of people that structured into different types of role according to their capability of working. Therefore, distinct purposes, people, and deliberate structure have been known as the certain characteristics of the organization. Management work plays crucial role in the organizations. Not only take the initiative to get things stay on the track, management work should also make the process of production more effective and efficient so the goals of the organization can be greatly accomplished. To illustrate this, in the case of selecting qualified people to join the organization, the Human Resources Management gets into the vital position. According to Ali (2013), the Human Resources Management will take the responsibility getting and keeping good people to run the organization and also maintain that their commitment is always in line with the organization’s objective. Additionally, briefly explain the function of management, Fayol’s theory contains the 5 elements of management which contain, first, Planning defined as the manager task to examine the future plans of......

Words: 1645 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Critically Assess the Ways in Which F.W. Taylor's Scientific Management Theory Has Influenced Has Influenced Contemporary Management Practice

...Introduction The principles of today's management goes back to the mid 1990's when an article named the “principles of scientific management” was published by Fredric Winslow Taylor who pioneered the term ‘scientific management’ in 1911. He defined scientific management as a study to increase productivity by methodologically studying the correlation between the individual and the task for the purpose of reconstructing and improving the work process (Jones and George, 2003). In the 19th and 20th century working hours were long, intense and confined, which resulted in the workers performing their tasks slower (Brodner, 2007). These issues caught the attention of Fredrick Winslow Taylor who was from the industrial revolution era, which was previously characterized by mass production (Asyali and Bastug, 2014). His intention was to increase the efficiency of the workforce by scientifically studying how work was done and by improving each stage without wearing out the laborers (Ahlstorm, 2014). Principles of scientific management After conducting various experiments he derived 4 principles, which contributed to the various management practices upheld in the 20th century (Giannantonio and Hurley-Hanson, 2011). First, science not the rule of thumb. In the industrial revolution managers relied on their personal judgment to resolve issues also referred to as the rule of thumb but all such approaches by the managers would not be efficient. Taylor felt that to increase......

Words: 2959 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

The Significance and Future of Scientific Management

...The significance and future of scientific management 1. Introduction More than a hundred years from the first publication of “ the principles of scientific management” by Frederick W. Taylor, the founder of scientific management, came into the public (Evans and Holmes, 2013). According to Hales (2013), scientific management was defined as a broader adaptation and extension of Taylor’s principles publicized by his followers. These Principles could be described into mainly three parts. Firstly, there should be new scientific methods for each element of labor to replace the antiquated management method mainly on the basis of experience. Secondly, the selection of workers should be scientific and the employers have the duty to training and educating their employees. Thirdly, cooperate with workers and ensure that all work could be finished step by step. The purpose of this paper is to discuss the significance and future of scientific management. It starts with the contribution of this theory as well as the humanistic criticism of it. Finally, the author gave an introduction of the new modern scientific management and tried to provide a different view of scientific management and explore another kind of patterns of it. 2. The Significance of Scientific Management 1. Efficiency and Economic Development It is impressive that scientific management did bring the improvement of efficiency in enterprises and workers’ welfare. A set of statistics shows that the manufacturing output......

Words: 2192 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Scientific Mangt and Hr

...BUSINESS Human Relation Approach & Scientific management Lecturers : Ms.Nguyen Thu Thuy (Assoc.Prof.Dr) Mr.Hoang Anh Duy (MBA) Hanoi, February 19th, 2014 Student's name: Pham Thi Ngan Binh. Table of Contents I. Introduction 5 II. Literature review 5 1. Scientific management 5 1.1 Father of scientific management 5 1.2 Definition and principles 5 1.3 Other theorist of management scientific 6 1.4 Positive and negative of scientific management 7 2. Human relation approach 8 2.1 Father of human relation approach 8 2.2 Definition and principles 8 2.4 Positive and negative of human relation approach 9 3. Organization 10 3.1 Definition 10 3.2 Characteristics of organization 10 3.3 Types of organization 11 3.4 Organization is an open system 12 3.5 Morden organization and traditional organization 12 III. Scientific management and Human relation approach in organization 13 1. Scientific management in modern organization 13 2. Human relation approach in modern organization 15 IV. Conclusion 16 V. References 16 Executive summary The objective of this essay is to evaluate whether scientific and human relation management are still implemented in organization in the 21st century. Many parts of these theories was considered such as definition, father of scientific management and human relation approach, other theorist of these theories and pros and corn of them. Besides, theory of or organization was......

Words: 3041 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Organsation Behavior Analysis

...As one of the core prepositions in organization management, whether scientific management is suitable for knowledge intensive enterprises in this modern society, has been discussed and tested repeatedly in many companies. And the scientific management of Tylor is the critical part of scientific management during the 20 century. The personal experience used by management method before Tylor theory, this situation will lead that working efficiency decreasing, Thus, efficiency is the critical part of output in industry, scientific management will improve efficiency of working, And the Taylor created a classical management theory form, it has scientific management thought and theory, and this theory also influence that practice and theory. The aim of scientific management is to seek the max efficiency. The basis of common prosperity is the highest working efficiency between employees and employers and make that higher wage and labor cost together, then it could improve the production of industry and development of industry. An important method to achieve the highest working efficiency is to replace the past experience management with a scientific and standardized management method. Therefore, Taylor has put forward certain essential management systems. In traditional management, the method of management according to personal experience, this condition causes the capitalists do not know how many workers in one day in the end to complete the task, but always felt they do less,......

Words: 1041 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Scientific Management

...Scientific Management - Scientific Management This essay will critically evaluate the scientific management’s importance and its contribution in the current management context. In this era of rapid economic development and industrial expansion of different nations, scientific management has enabled every nation to be involved in this global market. Scientific management is the theory which serves as the ‘backbone’ to many current management theories. Scientific management will be briefly described initially. After that, the essay will identify why scientific management is an important contribution to management theory when Frederick Taylor proposed it.... [tags: Business Employee Management] 1639 words (4.7 pages) $19.95 [preview] Scientific Management - Scientific Management Fredrick Taylor, the father of scientific management. He had a firm belief in "one best way" (Samson & Daft, 2003), of doing something. In the year 1899, Taylor held an experiment that involved German and Hungarian men, whose job involved some very heavy-duty work (Gabor, 2000). To his disappointment, men either refused to work, or wouldn't work to his expectations. The men hated him utterly; to the extent he required security when going home (Gabor, 2000). In his entire dilemma with his employers, in stepped Schmidt, a man not of intelligence but had the strength of a bull and an ox-like mentally required to reach the standards of Fredrick Taylor.... [tags: Taylorism Business Management......

Words: 8474 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Evolution of Management Thought and Patterns of Management Analysis.

...Evolution of management thought and patterns of management analysis. Scientific management school •A theory is simply a blueprint or roadmap that guides towards achieving the goal. In other wards, it provides a systemic framework for actions. •Study of management only dates for the last century, although there has been concerns about effective management practice for over centuries Scientific management school The two earliest pioneers of management theory are: -Robert Own and -Charles Babbage Scientific management school Robert Own (1771 -1858) A British industrialist who valued the organization’s human resources. Scientific management school He advocated ideas such as, - better working condition - meals for employees - reduced working hours He claimed that people deserve more respect and dignity. Scientific management school *Charles Babbage (1792 -1871) An English Mathematician who encouraged the application of mathematics to solve efficiency problems Scientific management school His work put the basic lines of both classical and quantitative management theories. He was also the originator of modern management theory and practice The classical management theory Includes two approaches: Scientific management Classical management Scientific management Concerned with the management of work and workers. it grew from researches of five people: Scientific management *Fredrick W.Taylor(1856 -1915) He was interested......

Words: 1660 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Scientific Management

...Introduction: The Theory behind Scientific Management The definition of Scientific Management is that it is “the management thought concerned primarily with the physical efficiency of an individual worker.” (Business Dictionary, 2011) Though the famous economist Adam Smith, with his division of labour hypothesis is credited with using scientific management principles, it is widely believed that the father of scientific management is the management theorist, Frederick Taylor. Scientific Management and Taylorism are near synonymous due to the fact that the field of Scientific Management was pioneered by Frederick Taylor in the late 19th century. With the adoption of scientific management in virtually every aspect of management practice, the field of scientific management took off in a big way in the 20th century. This resulted in greater efficiencies and more productivity of the workforce as the application of scientific management theories meant that production processes were standardized and the principle of division of labour was applied leading to mass production of goods (Taylor, 2011, 80). An interesting aspect of the scientific management approach pioneered by Taylor is his emphasis on increasing efficiency from the “bottom up” where he concentrated on the shop floor to maximize productivity. When contrasted with the theories by Henri Fayol and Max Weber who favoured a top down approach, we find that Taylor’s approach is better suited to the rigours of modern day......

Words: 2545 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Business Report

...Name: Trương Quỳnh Trang Class: K52_BFA Student ID: 1301BF5901 17/5/2015 Are scientific management and human relations approaches still applicable to organization of the 21st century? Scientific management and human relations approaches had been a well-known and well-used in business management in the 1900s. It is, however, still a question whether or not those methods are applicable to organization of the 21st century. Some opinions stated that these practices are still appropriate for organizations nowadays due to the benefits and effectiveness they brought to the organization, while other people based on the grounds of different features between recent organizations and organizations of decades ago to disregard the effectiveness of any of management theories from the 20th century. Therefore, the main focus of this essay will be demonstrating the illustration of some principles of scientific management and human relations approaches, comparison between them and writer’s personal view of their capabilities to determine whether or not they are still suitable for the modern organization. Even nowadays, it is no difficult to find examples of Scientific Management, for instance the car and computer manufacturing plants, work environment and anywhere that required a strict and accurate function to serve men. In fact, these methods of working seem so commonplace and so logical to a citizen of the modern world that it is almost impossible to accept that they...

Words: 3026 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Critical Review and Personal Analysis of Scientific Management

...Critical Review and Personal Analysis of Scientific Management Introduction Comparing to the economic environment in past decades, in today’s economy, more and more large companies and firms tend to find suitable management methods to regulate and operate their labour forces in consideration of maximizing efficiency and profits. Certainly, without an applicable management method, firms and corporations will lack of dynamic and motive power to operate decently. Taylorism, also known as scientific management, is one of the most well-known and widely applied management method introduced by Frederick Winslow Taylor in the late 18th century, and this theory was peaked in the early 19th century. Taylor argued that the fundamental of seeking wealth for both employers and employees is to have working efficiency and productivity maximized; to reach this working stage, a company is required to manage and operate scientifically rather than empirically. (Wikipedia, from In fact, Taylor’s scientific management is criticized by socialists and workers as it only focus on productivity and efficiency and treat workers as ‘machines and animals’, and it is also argued to be the tool of exploitation for capitalists. Indeed, in my opinion, despite the efficiency and productivity advantages that scientific management can generate, its inconsideration of employees personal affects and emotions will not only impair the future of a company, but......

Words: 1880 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Theories of Management

...resources efficiently and effectively, that's called management. Modern management was based on The Principles of Scientific Management (F.W. Taylor by 1911) and Administration Industrielle Et Générale(H. Fayol by 1916). Nowadays, the subject of management have more development and more theories than the past, meanwhile many theories' disadvantage was discovered. Main theories of management 1. Classical theory There are a lot of theories of management in the world; one of the parts is called classical theory. Basically, this theory is emphasis on purpose, formal structure, hierarchy of management, technical requirements, and common principles of organization. It’s also emphasis placed on planning of work, technical requirements of organizations, systematic methods of management, and assumption of rational and logical behavior. Meanwhile propose that associated with division of work tasks, clearly defined duties, control and co-ordination of work, hierarchy, formal rules. There are two major classical sub-groups: i. Scientific Management (F.W. Taylor, 1911) Scientific management also called Taylorism. In the beginning of The Principles of Scientific Management (F.W. Taylor by 1911), Taylor thought that to prove the best way of management is a real scientific subject. This subject are based on clearly defined discipline, rules and principles, and further show that the fundamental principles of scientific management applied to human behavior - from the easiest personal...

Words: 1887 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Scientific Management Styles with Modern Management Styles

...TOPIC# Compare and contrast scientific management styles with modern management styles Word Count: 1092 words Velko D Savov October 4, 2006 Table of Contents Introduction Management hypothesis………………………………………………....3 Defining of aims in past and present management styles…………….....3 Criticism of theories …………………………………………………..3 Similarities of theories ………………………………………………....3 Past theories applied in present days……………………………………3 Factors leading to a change……………………………………………..3 Past management theories used in present time………………………...3 Theory of past and present management styles………………………..4 Comparison of theories……………………… ………………………..4 Conclusion……………………………………………........5 Bibliography…………………………………………...........6 Velko D Savov October 4, 2006 Throughout this essay, I will be putting emphasis among the different theories from the different scientific and modern management styles. A clear comparison and distinguishment will be contrasted. It will be based upon past and present management hypothesis. Throughout the expansion of scientific management, the main aims were to achieve a developed approach were studies of work and their improvement could have been done. Past theories were strongly focused on the human......

Words: 1439 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay


...It is not difficult to find examples of Scientific Management in the 21st Century; the car and computer manufacturing plants, the work environments we go to everyday, the hospitals we are treated in and even some of the restaurants we might eat in, - almost all of them function more efficiently due to the application of Scientific Management. In fact, these methods of working seem so commonplace and so logical to a citizen of the modern world that it is almost impossible to accept that they were revolutionary only 100 years ago.  Although Scientific Management does play an important role in the 21st century, it is necessary to note that this method of management contains weaknesses that limit its influence in current work environments, and consequently not all of its tenants are applicable to modern organizations. Scientific Management is perhaps best seen as an evolutionary stage in management ever developing history. This essay will attempt to highlight both the strengths and weaknesses of Scientific Management in context of the 21st century through examination of its application in several modern organizations.  Scientific Management was developed in the first quarter of the 20th Century; its father is commonly accepted to be F.W. Taylor, although some variations of the theory have been developed by Gantt and Gilbreth. Taylor recognized labor productivity was largely inefficient due to a workforce that functioned by “rules of thumb,” and a mentality that equated......

Words: 2465 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Management essay writers' work. READ MORE See how we can help To what extent is Taylor’s theory of scientific management still useful in todays business The manifestation of Frederick Taylor’s theory of scientific management was a major breakthrough in traditional approach to management process. Simultaneously, as management theory evolved gradually Taylor’s theory was severely criticised and its role decreased dramatically to the extent that nowadays it is argued whether scientific management still exists. It is not hard to find examples of Scientific Management in today’s modern world; we can see the car industry which use a similar approach as well as the computer manufacturing plants even some hospitals, almost all of them function more efficiently due to the application of Scientific Management. However, as stated these organisations use a ‘similar’ approach, so therefore, in this essay I will attempt to discover if or how much is Frederick Taylor’s theory of scientific management still used by managers in its pure form. Taylor’s experience at the Midvale Steel Company led to the birth of scientific approach to management. As he worked there he recognised that the labour productivity was largely inefficient due to a workforce that functioned by “rules of thumb”. He started his experiments at the workplace in order to replace the traditional “rules of thumb” by factual scientific knowledge. The backbone of this activity was his “Time And Motion Study” where he worked......

Words: 1075 - Pages: 5