Free Essay

Service Learning and Why It Is Bad

In: Social Issues

Submitted By hangnico
Words 693
Pages 3
The two readings this week discusses the importance of examining the limitations of service learning and the need to be critical of the services provided by student. Morton criticises the widely used Starfish Hurling story where a young individual attempts to help washed up starfishes. He considers it a miseducative analogy that simplifies the intricacies of human agency or in this case the starfish, who has no voice or say in the matter of being hurled back into the sea. In conclusion, Morton finds more merit in community service and communication between the parties involved, than individual acts of kindness without dialogue between service recipients and providers. Eby reiterates a similar position highlighting that students may learn from the service learning however; he is critical of the effectiveness of the service provided on a structural level. He points to potential negative effects of service learning such as blaming individuals, neglect in mutual communication and autonomy of recipients being compromised. He points out that a good design in service learning would include balancing the agency of the primary stakeholders which consists of the students, faculty, educational institution, service recipients, community agencies and the communities involved.

Firstly, Morton’s piece reminded me of Johnson’s piece on Privilege and Oppression we discussed last week. The one thing that stood out to me was Morton’s criticism of the narrative of individual acts of kindness by the privileged overwhelming the recipient. It alludes to a bigger problem of service learning and volunteering in a broader sense and how one’s egocentricism can overpower the agency of service recipient when we adopt a view that what we do is the right thing, it is good and just. An act of kindness in this case, without discussion or learning from the local members of a community can be self-righteous and even selfish. It is not to say as a student I do not want to feel good about the service and learning aspects but it is important to recognise the service we provide is not centred on our own narratives or our own understanding of what is good and just without consulting the community we intend on serving. It is harmful as it diminishes the autonomy of the service recipients.
Secondly, Eby highlights the concept of McService and happy meal service – quick bit size service that is comparable to putting a band aid on an internal wound. The problem with service approaches is it often times does not take into account affecting change on a structural or policy making level by targeting the root cause of problems in a community. We must be able to be reflective in our service process and extend beyond volunteering but examining social policy implications. It also makes me think about the negative consequences of voluntourism and how it has dire effects on communities it aims to serve, by entering into a community and coming up with short lived responses that require long term resolutions.
Finally, an issue I often grapple with is the idea of disability and individual deficiency. Eby points out that as providers of service we must not blame individuals with “problems”. I find this to be a very important concept that all service providers must understand. Deficiencies much like other concepts are social constructs that are simplified to be easily categorised and understood. This alleviates the need for government intervention if deviations from the norms are due to individual failings or disabilities. I feel that this view can be very ableist. Instead we should consider how our society is built to serve certain people and advantage abled bodies. We must unlearn ideas that reinforce simplistic stereotypes and blaming individuals for how our society is structured for certain categories we deem normal abled bodies. This view is useful in deconstructing not just ableism but race, gender, sexuality and class. Unlearning norms and critically reflecting on the service learning is also not a short term solution, as providers of service it is important that our learning and advocacy is also a life-long process. We must incorporate the idea of structural failings and sociological imagination in our everyday lives to better serve others.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Journal

...people not to fall in the trap, the numbers of frauds still increase in every year. In the past, I always wondering why the victims are so stupid, they already have the idea of how the frauds were happened but still being cheated. However, I know that’s not their fault after the lesson. Just taking an example of a body-fit Centre, in order to let people fall in the trap, the Centre will firstly promote their company by offering an extreme low price treatment to the customers who had never try the services before. As the customer think that they just have to spend a very little price to become slim, they go to the company to have a try. In the treatment, the staff would persuade the customer that it is very important for women to keep fit and become slim. For example, by telling them they will get better offer and paid if they are fit, they may become popular among men if they have a perfect body shape and etc… the staff just conclude the view of the society in one simple attribution—as a woman, you should be slim, and make the customer strongly believe on it. Afterword, the customer would told that they can reach that attribution if they finish a course of treatment of the company. Suffer from the entrapment of the first service offer by the company, the customer will consider paying for the course as they have already spent time and money for the first service. The staff will further promise the customer that if their course doesn’t work, they will return all the money. When...

Words: 1414 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The One

...1 9 programming is terrible lessons learned from a life wasted @tef 2 hello, iamtef, I am a bad programmer I took things apart to find out how they work. Now I am surprised they do. I am a bad programmer (tests, docs, apology code review, bugs) we can do better. Good and Bad Programmers How Culture Dictates Code Indoctrination vs Learning Being Successful vs Being Good 3 Not just complaints, Tips, hope. mistakes i’ve made etc. mythos. people rather than code. std disclaimer, opinions, not work, or reality YMMV HTH HAND 4 Some find useful, gives me trouble. I am wrong. Doesn’t stop bloggers. A good place to start my code is better than your code (sing it) 5 false dichotomy of good and bad programmers. they normally mean this Programmers who are like me. Programmers who are not like me. 6 cargo cult their personality -> success Programmers who use my favourite language. Programmers who don’t. 7 blub paradox. aside: unmaintainable lisp, was replaced with perl. aside: lisp would have prevented 9/11 imply good or bad. Programmers who share my political views. Programmers who don’t. 8 mash types into politics for people who understand neither. why? it is easy. simple answer to a hard question. also blog hits. especially emotionally charged/trolling 10 times 50 times 100 times 9 the myth of genius. rockstar, ninja, founder, entrepreneur drowning in puberty/machismo all bollocks, faulty study, repeated...

Words: 1384 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Research Paper Eng 253

...Analysis of the services and learning tools provided by the centennial college library Presented to Andrea Jacobs Centennial College Progress Campus Prepared by Marta Linares #300745152 Indleeb Chaudhary #300776102 Suganya Arichandran December 8, 2015 Table of Contents Executive Summary 3 Introduction 4 Purpose of the Study 4 Sources and Methods 5 Background 7 Discussion of findings: 7 Usage of services and tools provided by the library: 7 Figure 2 Usage of tutoring 9 Awareness of the services and tools 9 Figure 3 Awareness of Tutoring 10 Student Satisfaction from services and tools 11 Figure 4 Student Satisfaction with printer service 11 Figure 5 Sitting capacity at library 12 Conclusions and Recommendations 13 Marketing Actions 14 Library Development Actions 14 Service-Delivery Actions 14 References: 15 Appendix A 16 Executive Summary In September 2011, Centennial College progress campus open the new Library to better assist with the increasing student population. The modern new library provides new technology with both in home and remote approach for digital resources, in addition to print and visual media collections. The library learning focused atmosphere is fully open, dynamic and physically adjustable to suit many needs. The goal of this study is to figure out the different services that are offered by the library, if the students effectively use the library resources and services and if not, find a way to improve...

Words: 2682 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Business Admin

...Unit two: Principles of providing administrative services Assessment You should use this file to complete your Assessment. • The first thing you need to do is save a copy of this document, either onto your computer or a disk • Then work through your Assessment, remembering to save your work regularly • When you’ve finished, print out a copy to keep for reference • Then, go to www.vision2learn.com and send your completed Assessment to your tutor via your My Study area – make sure it is clearly marked with your name, the course title and the Unit and Assessment number. Please note that this Assessment document has 13 pages and is made up of 9 Sections. Name: Section 1: Using the telephone This section will help you to evidence Learning Outcome 1: Understand how to make and receive telephone calls. |Learning objective |Place in Assessment | |1.1 Describe the different features of telephone systems and how to use them |Question 1 Page 1 | |1.2 Describe how to follow organisational procedures when making and receiving telephone |Question 2 Page 2 | |calls | | |1.3 Explain the purpose of giving a positive image of self and own organisation...

Words: 3774 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Psychology P1 and M1

...Behaviourist approach The behaviourist theory focuses on the study of observed behaviours and learning theories the three theories are; classical conditioning, operant conditioning and the social learning theory. Within the behaviourist approach there are three different theorists these are; Skinner, Bandura and Pavlov. The first learning theory was approached by the theorist Pavlov. The theory he approached was classical conditioning. This theory is pairing a reflex response with a stimuli. A reflex is an automatic reaction and a stimuli is anything in the environment. Pavlov then carried out an experiment with a dog to prove his theory; Pavlov knew that when animals see food they’re automatic reflex is to salivate, he also wanted to create a noise which the dog could respond to. An example of his experiment; Dog food salivate (reflex) Dog bell food salivate Dog bell salivate This experiment shows that when a dog hears the bell they know they are going to receive food making their automatic reaction to salivate activate. The second learning theory was approached by Skinner. The theory he approached was Operant conditioning. This theory is the reactions of others such as ‘shape’ behaviour. This theory has 3 different approaches these are; positive reinforcement, punishment and negative reinforcement. The first one is Positive reinforcement this encourages behaviour this could be using...

Words: 3058 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Psychology P1 and M1

...Behaviourist approach The behaviourist theory focuses on the study of observed behaviours and learning theories the three theories are; classical conditioning, operant conditioning and the social learning theory. Within the behaviourist approach there are three different theorists these are; Skinner, Bandura and Pavlov. The first learning theory was approached by the theorist Pavlov. The theory he approached was classical conditioning. This theory is pairing a reflex response with a stimuli. A reflex is an automatic reaction and a stimuli is anything in the environment. Pavlov then carried out an experiment with a dog to prove his theory; Pavlov knew that when animals see food they’re automatic reflex is to salivate, he also wanted to create a noise which the dog could respond to. An example of his experiment; Dog food salivate (reflex) Dog bell food salivate Dog bell salivate This experiment shows that when a dog hears the bell they know they are going to receive food making their automatic reaction to salivate activate. The second learning theory was approached by Skinner. The theory he approached was Operant conditioning. This theory is the reactions of others such as ‘shape’ behaviour. This theory has 3 different approaches these are; positive reinforcement, punishment and negative reinforcement. The first one is Positive reinforcement this encourages behaviour this could be using...

Words: 3058 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Hacking

... Candidate Number: 1156FAGD011 Session: 2012-2015 Subject: ARCS Word Count : 4538 Supervisor: Hans Kirkels Draft – Final 19th June 2013 | Abstract: Background - Piracy in the Internet is defined as the evil force that is destroying the entertainment industry. This blame has been put on since the invention of the Internet and its file sharing ability. It has recently been observed that a significant number of reasons can help in proving that piracy does have a good effect on the society. Result – Distributing the three major entertainment industries such as the music industry, gaming industry and the Movie production industry the research helps in proving the question about why is piracy good to the society. Piracy is not only the back bone of the entertainment business but is also the backbone of the internet as by doing critical analysis we find that it even protects us from the government. Conclusions - A theoretical analysis, backed up by observation and intense reading and understanding of how the Internet and the piracy works we can conclude that the piracy has had good effects on the entertainment industry. Table of Contents Abstract……………………………………………………………………… 2 Table of Contents…………………………………………………………... 3 ...

Words: 5164 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Psychology P1 and M1

...Behaviourist approach The behaviourist theory focuses on the study of observed behaviours and learning theories the three theories are; classical conditioning, operant conditioning and the social learning theory. Within the behaviourist approach there are three different theorists these are; Skinner, Bandura and Pavlov. The first learning theory was approached by the theorist Pavlov. The theory he approached was classical conditioning. This theory is pairing a reflex response with a stimuli. A reflex is an automatic reaction and a stimuli is anything in the environment. Pavlov then carried out an experiment with a dog to prove his theory; Pavlov knew that when animals see food they’re automatic reflex is to salivate, he also wanted to create a noise which the dog could respond to. An example of his experiment; Dog food salivate (reflex) Dog bell food salivate Dog bell salivate This experiment shows that when a dog hears the bell they know they are going to receive food making their automatic reaction to salivate activate. The second learning theory was approached by Skinner. The theory he approached was Operant conditioning. This theory is the reactions of others such as ‘shape’ behaviour. This theory has 3 different approaches these are; positive reinforcement, punishment and negative reinforcement. The first one is Positive reinforcement this encourages behaviour this could be using...

Words: 3058 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Unit 8

...mouth as she was so desperate for Amelia to get better. Now, Amelia associates the medicine with that experience and screams and shouts when she needs to take it. Her parents are at a loss on what to do. You now need to help the parents to understand what they can do to modify Amelia’s behaviour. How can you get Amelia to take the medicine using Operant Conditioning? You may even want to bring in some Classical Conditioning as well if you think you can? Describe the behaviour Amelia is exhibiting? Amelia is exhibiting this behaviour due to past experiences, in the past she has had a bad experience when taking this medication, therefore her mind associates the medication with something bad. She has been conditioned to link her being pinned down and fed to taking the medication, this is classical conditioning. The stimulus, the medication has been associated with a bad time and therefore will give off a response which is screaming and shouting. Explain what strategies can you use to positively reinforce Amelia’s behaviour? You can use operant conditioning to change her behaviour. She...

Words: 8290 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Is Ethics Natural or Learned Behavior

...Is Ethics Natural or Learned Behavior Mary Wilcox Ethics and Moral Reasoning PHI 208 Michelle Loudermilk February 10, 2014 To shoot this person or not to shoot this person? That is an ethical decision that has been going on for years, being an ex-military spouse; I have been around the military for a long time. Seeing what decisions a military person has to make, has a big ethical decision in their life. If it is not the correct decision they can ruin their career, or ruin a family when they make that decision to shoot, not only to shoot but what to do with their junior service men under their charge. Every decision that is made has an ethical part of somebodies life. You can follow the rules or break them and ruin everything around you and the junior service men under you. How they have learned to make these decisions is by a lot of training, and intelligence they get from other people. Is that person going to cause them harm, is that person going to cause somebody else harm? These are factors that a military person has to take into effect before making that ethical decision to take somebodies life in a war. For them to make these ethical decisions, they have had to learn them from somewhere, some of these things are almost natural, but most ethics are learned over a period of your life. You learn your ethics from your parents, teachers, friends, and family, anybody that has a big influence on your life, also TV and video games have an influence to a point on...

Words: 2464 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Preflection

...all the information regarding service learning and I went ahead and started to look at Chapman Hostice’s website I started to think how fragile life is. Reading about how we are going to interact with patients that have a terminal illness and where given a life expectancy of six months is somewhat difficult to process. I think we all hope that, if God permits, we will grow old and then finally rest in peace until God’s second coming, but one of my fears regarding this subject is getting to my first service learning and finding out the patient I will be helping is my age or younger. How am I going to react to that? Talking from a religious point of view, why did God decide a child or young adult should leave this earth so early? And trying to look at it from another lens, what bad karma or situation was this person in that he or she now faces a terminal illness? I hope that during my service at Chapman Hostice I put away any kind of awkward doubts and just focus on the patient. I am willing to provide any service needed in order to better the remaining quality of life for the individual or group of people I will be serving. Maybe if I was in a similar situation, I would greatly appreciate a total stranger taking time of his or her life to help me live a good life. As we were told during orientation, patients are not afraid of dying but rather fear pain and any other burden that the dying process entails. I hope this not only turns into a learning experience but rather a life-changing...

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Learning from Poor Leadership

...Learning from Poor Leadership Course Number (ORG300) – Applying Leadership Principles Colorado State University – Global Campus February 28, 2014 Learning from Poor Leadership There are many organizations and companies throughout the world that are controlled by bad or incompetent leaders. Some reasons for bad leadership are inadequate hiring practices such as hiring relatives, lack of knowledge around leadership skills, or inherit flaws of the leaders such as power trips or egotism. Whatever the reasons for the bad leadership, the results are demoralized teams and unproductive organizations (Richardson, 1994). Some of these effects are not understood until long after the damage is done or until after the leader has left the organization. In this paper I will discuss my experience with poor leadership and offer how this experience has made me a more effective leader. Joe, the Autocrat with Charisma Fifteen years ago, fresh out of the military, I started my civilian career as a technical specialist providing supervisory and maintenance services for data centers providers. Customers such as AOL, Verizon, and Sprint had a high availability requirement for their mechanical and electrical equipment and ex-military personnel were ideal for these services. The position was fast paced, required around the clock commitment, and extremely stressful. Seconds of downtime for these data centers meant millions of dollars in lost revenue for our customers. My bad leader was...

Words: 1243 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Edmondsonreading

...Most executives believe that failure is bad to learn from mistakes - just Ask people to reflect on what they did wrong and exhort them to avoid similar mistakes in the future X Failure is not always bad Learning is not straight forward * require to effectively detect and analyze failures; context-specific; go beyond superficial * > need to throw the old cultural beliefs and stereotypes of success & failure The blame game Old cultural belief: admitting failure = take the blame —> no psychological safety X a false dichotomy √ a culture that makes it safe to admit failure can coexist with high standards for performance. - why? the pic shows the causes of failures It is hard to find real blameworthy actions * e.g. Inattention - caused by lack of effort vs manager’s arrangement In many organizations, 2%-5% of failures detected by managers are truly blameworthy, but 70%-90% are treated as blameworthy. Not all failures are created equal 1.Preventable failures in predictable operations mistakes in processes and routine operations * ususally caused by inattention, lack of ability * Solution: 1.Checklist * 2.Toyota production system - build continual learning from tiny failures 2. Unavoidable failures in complex systems Often caused by uncertainty of work - combination of needs , people and problems never occurred before * e.g. emergency room in Hospital; start-up; complex system- nuclear power Can be averted...

Words: 646 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Business Law

...behavior is the actions a person takes to purchase and use products and services. Consumers use mental and processes that help them come up with the products they are going to purchase. Consumer perception, learning, and motivation are major factors in what products consumer purchase. Consumers have reasons why they purchase products and services. Companies use that knowledge to help consumers buy their products and services. They know what consumers want and need and use that to sell products. Perception is the process which people select, organize, and interpret information. Learning is a change in behavior caused by information or experience of something. Motivation is the internal state that drives us to satisfy needs. Once consumers realize they have a need, they have the motivation and the need to fulfill that need. Selective perception involves exposure, comprehension, and retention. Selective exposure means consumers can pay attention to messages that are consistent with their own attitudes and beliefs. Selective comprehension involves interpreting information so it stays consistent with those attitudes and beliefs. Selective retention is the information that we do not realize we have. (www.rohan.sdsu.edu) Consumer perception like other mental processes has risks to consumers. Consumers have anxieties because they cannot see the outcome of their purchase and whether or not it is a good or bad purchase. Companies try to reduce consumers anxiety and use many strategies...

Words: 2204 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Sensory Perception

...Subject Matte 1. Compare and contrast the nature of white collar crime with other type types of illegal acts. 2. Compare and contrast the typical participants of white collar crime against the participants of other types of illegal acts 3. Discuss the role of technology in white collar crime and how its role may create differences from other forms of crime. 4. Analyze the role of “opportunity” and how it contributes to white collar crime. Provide specific examples to support your response. When Edwin Sutherland first began his study/analysis under the Traditional Summary Reporting System, there was a limited amount of information available on White Color Crime. The white-collar offenses that are measured are fraud, forgery/counterfeiting, embezzlement, and all other offenses. Because white-collar crimes are not Index crimes, the only information available on these offenses is arrest information, which includes age, sex, and race of the arrestee. Additionally, all other offenses arrest category is very limited in its ability to measure the white-collar offenses included in its counts. This is due to the inability to differentiate the white-collar offenses from the others that also fall in this category. Based upon the most recently published data from the FBI, the arrest rates for the offenses of embezzlement, fraud, and forgery/counterfeiting are much lower than the arrest rates for property, crime, or for total crimes in general....

Words: 1583 - Pages: 7