Free Essay

Shadow Cities

In: English and Literature

Submitted By rafoster90
Words 1052
Pages 5
Predominantly within the post-modern, American context the "good life" is understood as the freedom and ability to do or posses whatever we want; a complete lack of nothing but the ability to posses anything one might desire. However, in Robert Neuwirth's book "Shadow Cities" readers are introduced to multiple people groups, more commonly known as "squatters", who's lifestyles and beliefs challenge what many might consider the good life as generally accepted by members of Western civilization. As Neuwirth takes us from Rocinha, Rio De Janeiro to Istanbul the reader is continuously faced with the same three issues plaguing our world: the fact that the worlds population is steadily increasing at an alarming rate, that everyone must have a place to live and that housing costs and must be lowered in order to provide the amount of houses necessary to sustain our world's growing population (Neuwirth xiii). In this paper I will seek to summarize Neuwirth's book, "Shadow Cities", beginning with a brief history of the squatter community. When comparing past and present examples of squatter communities Neuwirth begins by noting that, "very little has changed since the Middle Ages. The barracks of Rocinha, the mud huts of Kibera, the wooden shanties of Behrampada, or the original Gecekondu houses in Sarigazi are not far removed the dwellings that were common centuries ago in Europe and North America." With very little difference between communities of the past and present it becomes apparent that squatters have existed since the beginning of civilization. Neuwirth argues this point by pointing out that, "the history of cities teaches that squatters have always been around, that squatting was always the way the poor built homes and that it is a form of

urban development." As the earliest form of urban development and the avenue through which all cities are created Neuwirth confesses his previous ignorance concerning the legitimacy of squatters, "Before these journeys through the worlds squatter communities i thought that shantytowns were solely a Third World phenomenon. But as I began to learn more about the subject I food that i was wrong…thee's nothing third world about squatter settlements. They existed in the First World, too, and not so long ago" (Neuwirth 179). Neuwirth goes on to cover a number of squatter communities and their development throughout human history, beginning in Rome and ending in New York, " the cities were putrid places. People migrated to cities-as they do today-because the cities were hubs of manufacturing and trade." Having no place to live many new arrivals in Ancient Rome would simply build wherever they could find land. Whether that was under archways or rooftops, squatting was the most acceptable response to "land pressures that wracked city-states" . Following the eruption of people in 30 BCE many Romans were forced into difficult places, being unable to afford the costs that came with private house building, "overnight someone might close off what had been a public passage and build a house on it" (Neuwirth 181). In 19th century America squatters were, supported by two federal actions: the Preemption Act and the Homestead Act. Passed in 1841 the Preemption Act gave squatters rights to build buy land while the Homestead Act, "guaranteed a free 160 acre tract to every settler on government land, whether they applied for the right before occupying or squatted first and became legal second." This provided the foundation for gold miners of Sacremento and San Francisco to built small shanties and huts, eventually evolving into small communities, "Gold was the madness but squatting was the method" (Neuwirth 192). Neuwirth would conclude by giving a in depth description of New York and the eventual institutionalization of housing for squatters. While Neuwirth does spend a great deal of time explaining the history of squatting, even

more attention is given to his real life experiences in various parts of the world. Out of the four countries Neuwirth visited he chose to stay in only a handful of cities and experience what it meant to be a squatter. In every city the reader is introduced to the history of a certain squatter community as well as a brief glimpse into the lives of various people living within the community. Neuwirth starts in Rio Dejionaro where he records the lifestyle of Maria Das Gracias Fretas, a local worker of Pizza Lit, a restaurant in the squatter community of Rocinha, "as Maria moved between customers and the kitchen, I (Neuwirth) recognized that she had a point, not about herself, but about Rocinha, and indeed, all of Rio's favelas. Nothing is easy for squatters as it seems to be from the outside" (Neuwirth 27). Rocinha, according to Neuwirth, was created through a series of invasions; which explains the number one rule Neuwirth notes as he lived in the small community, "build nothing permanent. The early settlers assumed that building a stone or brick home would be so brazen that it might encourage the government to come out and demolish the homes." In Nairobi Neuwirth settled into Kibera, "a city of mud block houses" (Neuwirth 72). In his stay he describes the issue that plagued the community, a dangerously low supply of fresh water, "at 3 shillings per Jerry can. Kibera residents pay 10 times more for water that the average person in a wealthy neighborhood with municipality supplied, meter watered service." Observing the shortage of water, Neuwirth observes the power struggle that occurs over water control. In Mumbai Neuwirth notes the behaviors of the wealthy towards squatters, "Mumbai's middle class and wealthy-the true policymakers in the city-have always had a schizophrenic relationship with the squatters. Publicly, they deplore the unhygienic conditions and sprawl" (Neuwirth 129). However, in spite of the middle class reaction Neuwirth's companion Mukesh describes the interrelatedness of small business and slums, "when the slums get redeveloped small-scale business will decrease…businesses her don't have liscences and don't have to pay taxes" (Neuwirth 128). Neuwirth ends his journey in Istanbul and notes the

innovation found in the Geekemondo squatter community, "by 1984 the government essentially gave up the fight against squatters. It passed a new law that again gave amnesty to all existing Geekemondo communities…In 1990, the government issued a new Geekemondo amnesty, accepting all the illegal neighborhoods that had already been built" (Neuwirth 185).

Similar Documents

Free Essay

All the Dogs

...two hundred and fifty words. Let’s see how far I can get without using any extra spaces or numbers. How are you? I am good. What is the weather like over there? It’s about fifty degrees and we have not gotten snow in about two weeks. How far are you? About eighty words so far. Quite a few more for me to go. What do you think? Hm… I suppose that I can continue to listen to Eminem. Or is it Slim Shady? Only the shadow knows. Speaking of shadows, do you know if a tree falls in a forest and no one is there, does it make a sound? Yes it does, of course. I can also tell jokes. What do you call a lazy kangaroo? A pouch potato! Yes, I know that was a bad joke. I also have more jokes if you would like to hear. Here is more of my essay. How far now? About one hundred and eighty nine words. Yep. Everything looks like it is eight mile now. Really? It is a lot safer in this area than downtown Detroit. Did you know that Detroit is not as dangerous as people seem to believe that it is? Actually Hamtramck is much worse. People have to lock their doors as they drive through the city since people will come up to one’s car and try and take parts off of it as it moves. Scary, huh? All...

Words: 269 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Shadows of Paralysis: “the Sisters” and “the Dead”

...It can be said that every story in the collection Dubliners by James Joyce has a tale of its own where “paralysis” is a central theme in all the stories. The idea of “paralysis” can mean a number of different things to different people depending upon their interpretation of a certain text. In general, what “paralysis” does is inhibit a character from doing what they want to do or know they should do, as if there is a kind of shadow in their life, just lurking and haunting them in the darkness. These shadows especially play an important role in two stories from the collection, “The Sisters” and “The Dead”; they act as a sort of imprisonment for the main character. In “The Sisters”, the narrator and main character is a nameless boy. The boy says at the beginning of the story, “Every night as I gazed up at the window I said softly to myself the word paralysis. It had always sounded strangely in my ears…like the name of some maleficent and sinful being. It filled me with fear” (“The Sisters”, 2). From this, the reader sees that the boy does not really know how to respond to the priest’s inevitable death. What kind of relationship exists between the boy and Father Flynn is hard to determine because the reader only sees their relationship through the eyes of the boy. As the reader is introduced to other characters in the story, they start to learn bits of information about the nature of their relationship, but the reader is still somewhat left in the dark. Throughout the......

Words: 1081 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Hello There, the Angel from My Nightmare

...Hello there the angel from my nightmare The shadow in the background of the morgue The unsuspecting victim of darkness in the valley We can live like Jack and Sally if we want Where you can always find me And we'll have Halloween on Christmas And in the night we'll wish this never ends We'll wish this never ends (I miss you I miss you) (I miss you I miss you) Where are you and I'm so sorry I cannot sleep I cannot dream tonight I need somebody and always This sick strange darkness Comes creeping on so haunting every time And as I stared I counted The Webs from all the spiders Catching things and eating their insides Like indecision to call you and hear your voice of treason Will you come home and stop the pain tonight Stop this pain tonight Don't waste your time on me you're already The voice inside my head (I miss you miss you) Don't waste your time on me you're already The voice inside my head (I miss you miss you) Don't waste your time on me you're already The voice inside my head (I miss you miss you) Don't waste your time on me you're already The voice inside my head (I miss you miss you) Don't waste your time on me you're already The voice inside my head (I miss you miss you) Don't waste your time on me you're already The voice inside my head (I miss you miss you) I miss you (miss you miss you) (I miss you miss...

Words: 264 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

I Was Scared Stiff

...mobile phone said 2:34AM. I decided to listen to some music on my iPod with the hope that I would eventually drift off to sleep. I popped my earphones in my ears and wriggled away to a hip hop tune on the bed. Amidst my wriggling my elbow bumped into what felt like someone standing right next to the bed beside me. I looked up and caught a glimpse of a shadow of a person towering over me. I jolted upright on the bed, awakening my husband at the same time. Perhaps he felt something was up and asked me "What's wrong? What's wrong?" I was unable to reply immediately because my eyes kept scanning the bedroom, seeking out for a shadow or movement. Again my husband asked, "What's wrong love?" "There's someone in our bedroom!" I said out loud. My husband turned on his bedside lamp. Naturally, no one was there. Our bedroom door was closed, and we didn't hear anyone opening the door to go out but I still felt there was a presence in the room. My husband pulled me towards him in a hug "Just pray love." We prayed Our Father and my husband turned off his lamp. After a few minutes, my eyes adjusted to the darkness in the room. Then I saw the shadow again, standing, on my husbands' side of the bed. I screamed out and clung onto my husband. He turned the lamp on again and of course, no one was there. The emotions that was running through me at that time, was somewhat mixed, but I believe I was more scared than anything else. But what scared me the most was what happened next... "Jesus......

Words: 543 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

To Kill A Mockingbird Alternate Ending

...“Cecil Jacobs is a big wet hen!” I heard a familiar voice yell. I stood up from my chair and stumbled over to the window. “Hey!” I heard another familiar voice yell as I looked over the dark lot scanning for my two kids. The lot was completely pitch dark, but I became used to the dark long ago and I could barely make out an outline of what looked like a life-size walking ham. Why would Scout be dressed as a ham? I wondered to myself. I couldn’t see Jem although I knew it was his voice I had heard. I watched as Scout as Jem approached the big oak tree. Once the kids stumbled under the big old tree, I could make out Jem walking along side Scout talking quietly to her. The kids stopped all of the sudden, and I wondered if something was wrong. They shouldn’t be out here at this time of night. Where was Atticus? The Halloween pageant! I remembered the article I read in the weekly edition of the Maycomb tribune. That must be where they were and why Scout wore a ham as her dress. It must of ended late. “Run, Scout! Run! Run!” I heard Jem yell. At that moment I spotted a man with a ripped plaid shirt on, charging at the kids. My kids, I thought. He’s going to try to hurt them. The man wore a smirk of hate and revenge on his face. I couldn’t let them be hurt. They were all I had after years of being shut up in this old run down house because of my unknown sickness. I just couldn’t stay in my house and let the kids be hurt. I had to help. I grabbed what I needed from the kitchen......

Words: 1067 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Belle En Het Beest

...Top of Form Assignment: PRESENTATION and handout For your oral exam, you will be working as a corporate analyst for your teacher. Your main responsibility will be to develop a feasibility study outlining the parameters for possible future investment in your chosen company. This process is called Due Diligence: essentially, you will play the role of an objective third party. This means that your only loyalty is to an objective account of the current state of affairs. You are to choose a company and have it approved by your teacher. You will then be responsible for analyzing the company and making recommendations either for or against future investment. You will have to defend your analysis. Remember: you are working for your teacher, not for the company: Due Diligence requires objectivity! This assignment is graded and your marks count for 5 points of your final marks. You will receive a group mark, both for content and presentation and for your performance in English. First, you must select the company you are going to analyze (week 24 – groups have to be formed by week 23) and have it approved by your teacher. To be included in your analysis are the following: - SWOT-analysis - Legal Status (pending contracts, current litigation) - Financial Status (accounting, cash reserves, recent/future investments, share price) - IT (systems involved, recent updates, future plans) - Marketing (Strategies, competitors) - Operations (management, supply/distribution networks) -......

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Alleegory of the Cove

... Page 2 The Allegory of the Cave from the faculty of Washington College, is the article I found that gave me meaning as to what Plato was trying to say . It showed that the Prisoners saw only the shadows of what the puppet men were carrying and they only said what they thought the images were . In the example the prisoners thought he “ saw a book , but he was not seeing a book , he was seeing a shadow of a book . “ Plato’s point is that they were referring to shadows they saw on the wall and not the actual item that the puppet men were carrying in front of the fire that caused it to make a shadow on the wall. The example given in The Allegory of the Cove shows us that the prisoners were no really seeing the object but the shadow of an object that was reflected on the wall , if they could have turned around , which they could not , because they were chained , they would have seen that the real item was being carried by the real item was being carried by the puppet men and they were only seeing a shadow of the item. I believe this application was valid because it shows an illusion . If the prisoners could have seen the real article that was being passed in front of the fire , all that they were seeing was the shadow of the item on the wall . The prisoners think they are seeing an item such as a book but...

Words: 524 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Cisco Case Analysis

...| | Assignment: Enterprise IT at Cisco Case Write-Up | Summary: Enterprise IT at Cisco Systems is an interesting case that demonstrates what happens when a company’s IT infrastructure is decentralized. In the case of Cisco, the word decentralized was demonstrated in how the individual departments conducted business in their own ways and not in conjunction with other business functions. At one point, this approach was encouraged as it was believed to allow departments, and the people running them, the ability to avoid company politics, to ensure their priorities were met, and to encourage each department and individual the opportunity to be creative and innovative, which is a fundamental component of Cisco’s company style. Brad Boston, CIO of Cisco, believed that it was possible to retain that company attitude of innovation in a more centralized manner to decrease redundancy and formally integrate systems. While there was a great deal of pushback from employees, and the full centralization will take a great bit of time, Boston was making the best choices for the company. 1. How did Cisco find itself in such trouble with regard to its internal IT in 2001? Why didn’t the single ERP system help more? Why didn’t this ensure more consistency? As briefly mentioned above, Cisco found itself in such trouble as a result of allowing every department and employee operate freely and with little regard for what others were doing. As stated on page 4 of the case study,......

Words: 1141 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Imagination Paper

...Imagination Paper Dustin Stone ENG/340 Ocotber 19, 2015 Korijna Valenti Imagination Paper Art is one of the best things in life, because it is objective in its appearance but appeals to every single person in a subjective and meaningful message. Art can make a story from simple lines on a canvas that all interconnect into a grand design, to the creation of characters, and invoke the sense of dark versus light. In order to have all these components one must be able to develop a story from the art work before they can incorporate characters/ objects, and introduce the elements of light, darkness, shadow and color. Story within the Artwork Smith, or Smithy is the name of the match or that’s what all matches called one another, but we will call him Smith. Smith was just sitting in his matchbox, sometimes he was knocked on to the other smiths, and sometimes he was the last of his companions. It was and still is a crazy life for a match. First, they get hot head very fast and end up setting fire to other Smith’s or objects that did them no wrong. Now this specific day was very special. It was Smith’s birthday. He has survived longer than all of the other Smiths. He had spent a whole year stowed away in a box that once felt like a crammed closet, but now felt like a mansion. Smith knew that something grand was going to happen on his special day he just knew it. Smith wonders would he be used on top of a cake, or maybe to star fireworks. To Smith it did not...

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Plato: the Allegory of the Cave

...Ashleigh Wheat April 24, 2011 Comm. And the Media Matthews Plato: The Allegory of the Cave Imagine a life of only looking at the shadows on a wall. Not knowing what the outside world was like or even what a person looked like. Just monstrous shadows projected on the wall in front of you. The prisoners in Plato’s story were born in a cave and chained in a way they only knew the wall in front of them. In the allegory of the cave the prisoners were not allowed to look at anything but the wall. They were chained with a “bridge” behind them. I refer to it as a bridge because people walked across it carrying their water or camels. I used the youtube video: “The Cave: An adaption of Plato’s Allegory in Clay” as a reference. It helped me understand the story more in depth but yet there was a lot more to tell through the text “Plato, The Allegory of the Cave.” I believe that my favorite sentence from the article I chose would have to be “…and you will see, if you look, a low wall built along the way, like the screen which marionette players have in front of them, over which they show the puppets.” (Kreis, 2000) Once I read this I could see a picture in my head. I felt that I was trapped in the chains and was restricted to just the wall. Plato’s story shows me to respect life. Enjoy what God gave you instead of taking advantage of it. The prisoners were not allowed to see the outside world. They didn’t know what the sky looked like or what a voice......

Words: 803 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Where Are You Going Where Have You Been Reflection

...neck to glance into mirrors or checking other people’s faces to make sure her own was all right.” However, due to Arnold’s sunglasses Connie is not able to “check” his face in order to see how he is viewing her, therefore leading her to feel insecure. The repetition of shadows utilized by Oates may represent the darker side to the characters within the story. A darker side of Connie may come to light as Oates writes “Connie would rise her eyebrows at these familiar old complaints and look right through her mother, into a shadowy vision of herself as she was right at that moment: she knew she was pretty, and that was everything.” The “shadowy vision” that Connie looks into may be symbolic of a darker, obsessive side of Connie. Although Connie may seem very confident to her family and friends, she may actually be suffering from self-loathing and crimpling internal insecurities. The shadow described around Arnold, however, tells a slightly different story. In fact, in Arnold’s case his eyes are entirely without shadow. This is seen as Oates writes, “He took off the sunglasses and she saw how pale the skin around his eyes was, like holes that were not in shadow but instead in light.” The absence of shadow around Arnold’s eyes may represent that his eyes are the only true window into his true self. According the University of Michigan eyes are “the most important symbolic sensor organ. They can represent clairvoyance, omniscience, and/or a gateway into the soul.” In......

Words: 1028 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Hello

...レオナルド・ダ・ヴィンチ 『絵画論』 ▪ レオナルド・ダ・ヴィンチ(1452 -1519) o イタリアのルネサンス期を代表する芸術家 o 本名はレオナルド・ディ・セル・ピエーロ・ダ・ヴィンチ (Leonardo di ser Piero da Vinci ) o 絵画、彫刻、建築、音楽、科学、数学、工学、発明、解剖学、地学、地誌学、植物学など o 万能人(uomo universale )、「飽くなき探究心」と「尽きることのない独創性」 o 肖像画『モナ・リザ』と宗教画『最後の晩餐』 o 絵画作品、レオナルドが残したドローイングや科学に関するイラストが描かれた手稿、絵画に対する信念 ▪ 手稿 o ルネサンス人文主義 o 13,000ページ、手稿にドローイング o 芸術と自然哲学が融合したもの o レオナルドが興味と関心を持ったあらゆる分野の事象が書かれている。 ▪ 「絵の本」から 絵画とほかの芸術との  • 絵画と詩人との相違 • 絵画と音楽との相違 • 絵画と彫刻との相違 遠近法 Perspective • 線的遠近法 • 色彩遠近法 • 消失遠近法 • 空気遠近法 光、影、色 ▪ 参考文献 杉浦明平訳 岩波文庫 レオナルドダビンチの手記 (上) The Notebooks of Leonardo, Da Vinch Irma A. Richter, Oxford University Press -絵画とほかの芸術との 画家は、自分をする美を見たいと思えば、 肝をつぶす:to be amazed 実際この宇宙の中に本質として、現在としてあるいは想像としてあるものを、かれはまず頭の中に、次は手の中に所有する。そしてそれは非常に優秀なので、それらがいかなるものであろうとも、同時に一眸の中に均衡のとれた調和を生じる。these are of such excellence that they can present a proportioned and harmonious view of the whole, that can be seen simultaneously, at one glance, just as things in nature. 絵画は自然から生まれる、自然の孫。 絵画を軽蔑するものは哲学をも、また自然を愛していない. he who despises painting loves neither philosophy nor nature. 絵と詩の 絵と音楽 音楽は絵画の姉妹という以外に呼びようがない。 眼に比べて第二次的な感官たる聴覚に従い、 for she is depending on hearing, the sense which comes second[1],and her harmony is composed of the union of its proportional parts sounded simultaneously, rising and falling in one or more......

Words: 1463 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Glory and Wreckage O

...third of all fatal car crashes. If this amount of people speeding could be cut in half, thousands of innocent lives could be saved. Driving too fast has become an issue ever since cars were put on the road but society feels it is time to put an end to this. There are many advertisements and commercials on the television and on billboards, but they don’t seem to be doing the job to stop the speeding. Ecovia, a transit company, is trying to get the message across in a different way. They are tying the message of “don’t speed” in with a very popular issue, of violence against women. Is speeding just as serious as violence against women? That is the question this image is trying to get humanity to think about. The use of text, color, shadows and contrast make this image prove that driving too fast is equally as appalling as domestic abuse. This ad portrays an image of what seems to be a man’s fist striking the jaw of a woman. Right above the man’s arm there is a text box with the words “STOP THE VIOLENCE DON’T SPEED.” The words “DON’T SPEED” are written in the color red. On the man’s hand there is a painting of a red truck. On the woman’s face there is a painting of a yellow SUV. The red truck makes the red writing really stand out. It also draws the message of don’t speed to the red truck to make it seem as if the driver of the red truck is the guilty party in the crash. Also, red represents anger or strength, which makes the man appear as if he is punching the......

Words: 1165 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Art Response Paper

...Justin Baker’s “Brian, rose and square” is a black and white photograph that evokes deep emotion and mystery. The photograph is composed of a large glass vase placed on a shelf that is also made of glass. Inside the vase is a decaying rose that is severely drooping off to the left. The vase is also filled with cloudy, old looking water. The shelf is hung on a white wall that seems to have many imperfections on it. Along with the shelf, there is also a picture of a man hung on the wall. This picture is taped to the wall, rather than securely fastened like the shelf. There is very high contrast of values throughout the photograph, darker shadows towards the edges, and brighter in the middle. The darkness of the water draws in the eye by being placed next to the starkness of the white wall. There is also a light shadow being cast on the wall from the vase and stem. This photograph has a centered composition, and has no items that continue off the page. This photograph contains a high amount of uncertainty and mystery regarding the subject and meaning. If I were to try to come up with my own meaning, it would be that this is the view of a girl who recently went through a break-up. The picture taped on the wall is of her ex-boyfriend, “Brian”, and the flower in the vase was given to her by him before they broke up. The decaying of the rose symbolizes the end of their relationship and the loss of hope that she now has. The darkness of value around the edges, and......

Words: 500 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Adult Education

...that are not necessary. A man spends his whole life fishing in himself for something grand. It’s like a lost lunker, big enough to break all records. (1-2) (Brown) In my opinion the author is stating in our everyday lives we have a routine, searching for our best accomplishments. We are looking for one that is bigger than what we feel is expected of us. Maybe it is one that will surpass everyone’s expectations of us. But he’s only heard rumors, myths, vague promise of wonder. He’s only felt the shadow of something enormous darken his life. Or has he? (3-5) (Brown) We hear praises from others about thing we’ve done or accomplished, but do not believe that our great accomplishment exists. We feel we can do better and often judge ourselves hard; thinking that perhaps someone else has done better. Through all the praises we still feel confused or uncomfortable accepting the praise from others. Maybe it’s the shadow of other fish, greater than his, the shadow of other men’s souls passing over him. (6) (Brown) In the part of the poem, the author is asking us a question. Is it that we are trying to live our life competing against someone else’s accomplishments? Trying to better someone else’s expectation but not sure if we can. Each day he grabs his gear and makes his way to the ocean. At least he’s sure of that, or is he? (7-8) (Brown) Every day we gather our thoughts and think of all we have accomplished. We sit back...

Words: 719 - Pages: 3