Premium Essay

Should People on Welfare Be Forced to Work

In:

Submitted By shara5193
Words 763
Pages 4
Should People on Welfare Be Forced to Work? With commonalities of abuse and complacency, welfare has been a topic of frustration for decades. Over the years, millions of Americans have received government assistance such as Medicaid, housing benefits, food stamps and even telephone services. Rather than setting forth the effort of self support, many of these individuals abuse the system and feel as though tax payers should contribute or “foot” their bills. While there are some circumstances where welfare is absolutely vital, there have been many issues of people taking advantage of the system. Many welfare reform programs have been set in place however a change that last has yet to come, no change with the continuance of taxpayers being swindled of their hard earned money. Where is the line drawn, at what point is a complete stand taken in forcing these dependent individuals to work? Originating in the 1930s During the Great Depression, welfare was designed to assist with massive job lost to the citizens of that time. With this plan being in place for decades, it unfortunately hasn’t had any sort of reformation or major changes put in place causing citizens to abuse the system. There are 2 categories of welfare, social and economic. Social welfare services are services that are put in place to help citizens to better function while economic welfare solely focuses on the money aspect of things. Many may argue that welfare programs are set forth to help those in need due to reasons beyond their control such as disabilities or old age, however I do feel that able bodied citizens simply aren’t putting forth enough effort to rise above some of the circumstances that would cause a need for financial assistance. Growing up in a single parent home, my mother raised two children without any type of assistance, whether it was housing assistance, food assistance, etc.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Social vs Corporate Welfare

...United States Welfare: Federally funded and governed US welfare began in the 1930's during the Great Depression. The US government responded to the overwhelming number of families and individuals in need of aid by creating a welfare program that would give assistance to those who had little or no income. The US welfare system stayed in the hands of the federal government for the next sixty-one years. Welfare system reform became a hot topic in the1990's. Bill Clinton was elected as President with the intention of reforming the federally run US Welfare program. In 1996 the Republican Congress passed a reform law signed by President Clinton that gave the control of the welfare system back to the states. The United States provides many different Welfare programs to help meet the needs of citizens with lower incomes and also programs that are intended to help citizens progress out of their current living situations. Some programs are common knowledge, but there are also other programs that most people don’t are under the Social Welfare umbrella. Why is Social Welfare a Social Problem? Social Welfare is a social problem because they are government programs citizens are forced to pay into whether they support it or not, limiting their choice of how they want their money to be used. Social Welfare is also a program that supports thousands of individuals and families who may not be able to support themselves. There is great debate on whether social welfare programs should be reformed...

Words: 1596 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Welfare

...Right or Wrong? The Welfare State in America What are welfare/transfer payments? It means many different things to many different people. A helping hand, robbery, support, way of life, wrong, right, and more. To me, welfare/transfer payments are charity that the government mandates upon people. While that may seem harsh to some, lets look at the facts and breakdown my definition. Charity is defined as: “generous actions or donations to aid the poor, ill, or helpless”, (Simpson 488) and mandatory is defined as: “authoritatively ordered; obligatory; compulsory”. (Simpson 1207)Those who are eligible to pay taxes must do so, and then the government uses some of that money to give to the “needy” at their discretion. We have to pay it, and it goes to the “needy” I think mandatory charity fits that description adequately. I view this as fundamentally wrong. I believe it is not the role of the government to decide how much money I should donate to others, if any at all; that is a personal choice. Imagine if the government began collecting taxes en-masse and donating them to help stop animal cruelty. There would be enormous uproar and people would cry that the government is wasting their money on a silly cause. Personally, I would not view this as silly, and think it would be an admirable endeavor, but many would not, which is my point. Each person who gives money to a charity does so because of his or her personal feelings. Why is it mandatory that I give to the government’s charity...

Words: 2789 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

United States Welfare Reform

...Justin Mills Welfare Reform In 1996 the federal government of the United States created the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program in an effort to move parents of welfare and into the workforce (Hildebrandt & Stevens 793). The intent of this legislation was to create an environment in which people would be able to provide for themselves without the assistance of the government. However, as of 2006 38.7 million people in the United States, including 13.28 million children, were still living below the poverty level of $22,050 for a family of four (Hildebrandt & Stevens 793). These numbers indicate that the problem did not improve and many people have become accustomed to the lifestyle that receiving welfare affords them. Further changes to the welfare system would go a long way towards resolving these issues. The United States government must reform the welfare program with pre-screenings and lifetime limits on benefits to prevent producing a society of dependent people. In 1996 Congress passed the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act, which created the TANF program (Cook et al. 249). The legislation significantly altered the provisions for extending cash to low-income families (Cook et al. 249). The new provisions imposed a federal lifetime limit of up to five years on financial support and strengthened the requirements for employment and work-related activities (Cook et al. 249). The ability of immigrants, including those...

Words: 1884 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Public Assistance

...Social Welfare Policy Paper: Public Assistance Jennifer Shellhammer University of New England Abstract This paper will discuss a Social Welfare Policy, specifically, public assistance. I have created an overview and provided a concise description of welfare and public assistance, along what social problems it attempts to address. Additionally, it will provide the historical background of public assistance and the economic and political forces which have influenced its development. Furthermore, it will explain the functions of public assistance that people observe and expect, while also addressing what functions are not recognized. Lastly, the paper will provide arguments made for and against public assistance, and what has been said by politicians, and other experts. Concluding, I have also expressed my own perspective on this issue and what changes I would propose to its current state. Social Welfare Policy: Public Assistance The term “welfare” generally refers to programs established by the federal government to assist individuals who are unemployed and poor. Assistance is provided to the poor through several types of programs, which range anywhere from food stamps, Medicare, Medicaid, unemployment, to temporary cash assistance and several forms of housing assistance. These programs were created to prompt effort and attention on specific problem areas and to prevent the deterioration of necessary and essential conditions for individuals and families to successfully...

Words: 4646 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Legal and Ethical Issues Concerning Welfare Reform

...Ethical Issues Concerning Welfare reform Alexandra Padua Dr. Jonathan Christensen MG260: Business Law I Opening statement * “I think we should acknowledge that some welfare programs in the past were not well designed and in some cases did encourage dependency.…” President Barrack Obama The beginning of welfare in the 1930’s to President Clinton’s welfare reform in the 1990’s A. Why did President Franklin find a need to begin welfare in the U.S.A? B. What welfare did for America and who it helped? C. How President Clinton reformed welfare, and why. D. How effective President Clintons changed towards welfare has been. I. President Franklin felt the obligation II. Welfare was given to the people of America as a hand up to get back on their feet. It helped anyone who needed the assistance. III. President Clinton signed the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act.  IV. President Clinton’s changes pushed able bodied person(s) to work and support themselves and their families. Legal Issues concerning welfare reform A. Immigrants B. Requirements C. Length of time I. Immigrants that need Medicaid are not eligible. II. To receive TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) people now need to be looking for a job, working or, evolved in job education. III. People who are receiving benefits are limited to the time they can receive benefits. Ethical Issues concerning welfare reform. A. Helping Americans...

Words: 2102 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Shanghai Husi Scandal Case Analysis

... management functions and scientific management principles. 2. Analysis the article with theories 3.1 Analysing the issue with ethical decision making Ethical is a criterion that people used to measure that whether their behaviour is acceptable by others or social. However, Unethical behaviour will hurt organizational reputation. According to this article, one of the reasons for the Husi Company falling into food safety scandal was that they were doing unethical work practices. People in the company did not apply ethical decision making criteria. This can be seen with three dimensions. Firstly, workers were forced to work overtime and employees were forced to change expired dates of food at the plant. These two facts can clearly show that decisions which were made by company leaders were not acceptable. Secondly, they were making unethical decisions which could not be discussed in public. They used two records to cover unethical works. One record is real, and another one is to be shown anyone who would audit the plant. And while their employees pointed out that, Husi Company ignored his pleas. Thirdly, workers and others who have important relationships with the company do not support the unethical decision. According to the article, workers were forced to do unethical works, so this can be regarded to that employees do not...

Words: 1013 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Contrary to Popular Beliefs, Entitlements Works!

...popular beliefs, Entitlements works! What are entitlements? Entitlements are the payments to individuals in the form of Medicare and Medicaid, unemployment, welfare, food stamps and child support. Entitlements also include grants paid in lieu of tax credits to energy firms. Why the debate? Entitlements account for $246 billion and critics of entitlements believe it should be cut and taxpayer money could fund better projects. Supports of entitlements are usually those that have benefited from such programs. However, the shrinking number of taxpayers contributing to government revenues and the growing number of people receiving benefits is cause to worry. The constitutional laws allowing entitlements were enacted in 1860s to protect citizen from poverty or an oppressive government (Jost, 2003). Today, many that benefit from entitlements are from inner city and low-income families and are the people that need entitlements the most. Effects on the economic society Some believe that sitting around waiting on your unemployment or welfare and not actively contributing to society encourages laziness. Added to this increased burden on a shrinking tax payer pool, critics want to cut funding and believe those funds could be best spent in other areas. However, those working closely with the recipients of those funds firmly believe stop funding is not the answer. Robin Tucker, a social worker who supports entitlements say entitlements “should focus on education and job...

Words: 709 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Daycares With Diapers

...become more productive citizens. Which is why the government should provide daycares with diapers, because the high cost of diapers, which is not covered by food stamps,...

Words: 933 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Sweatshops

...under poverty line are forced to do the child labour daily even after the lots of awareness program run by the government and future welfare of society towards the welfare of the child. Children are the new flower with powerful fragrance of any nation however some people are declining the power and destroying the future of the country just for earning small money by illegally involving the growing kids. They are playing with the moral of the innocent people and their kids. Protecting children from the child labour is the responsibility of each and every citizen living in the country. Child labour is the socio-economic issue which is coming from long ago and now need to be solved on ultimate basis. After the independence of the country, various laws and regulations has been implemented regarding the child labour however it did not found its end in the country. Child labour ruining the innocence of the kids by directly destroying their health physically, mentally, socially and intellectually. Children are the lovely creation of the nature but it is not fair that due to some bad circumstances they are forced to do hard labour before their appropriate age. Child labour is the global issue which is more common in the underdeveloped countries. Poor parents or parents under poverty line are unable to afford the education expenses of their kids and they own unable to earn enough money for the family survival. So, they better choose to involve their kids in hard work to fulfil their needs...

Words: 411 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Comm215

...supporting drug addicts? I am unemployed but why am I supporting the next door neighbor and their five children? No one is supporting me or my family. I’m a good mother, I feed my children as healthy as possible. I don’t do drugs. I pay my taxes. It is time for a change in welfare. I deserve my share right? 109,631,000 Americans lived in households that received benefits from one or more federally funded program. I am not one of them, but my neighbor “Sam” does. What does she do all day? Nothing. Yells at her kids when they are not at my house eating all of my kid’s food. She doesn’t work. She is currently not looking for work either. I am actively looking. It is time for a change don’t you think? Time to get those off of welfare that choose to do nothing in life. I want to see a reform before I retire. After all it is Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF ) is federally funded - state administered - financial assistance program for low income families with dependent children and for pregnant women in their last three months of pregnancy. TANF provides temporary financial assistance while also helping recipients find jobs that will allow them to support themselves. What are these people buying with their food stamps they get? I bet just candy probably soda as well. It’s a shame, really. They get hundreds of dollars a month in food stamps and I bet most of them do not even buy a canned vegetable. I wonder if “Sam” my neighbor even cooks a good meal. I love to...

Words: 727 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Rebuilding the Welfare System

...Rebuilding the Welfare System Tyeisha Atkinson SOC320: Public Policy & Social Services Instructor: Ingrid Sanders November 13, 2013 Rebuilding the Welfare System Welfare is a very controversial topic that has divided this nation since the start of it. Welfare is an institution supported by the government to help those who lack in many different areas of their lives. “The largest increase in the share of the US population on welfare in the past 35 years occurred between 1960 and 1970.” (Deavers, & Hattiangadi, 1998). Welfare aims to help people and prevent poverty from increasing by enduring access to resources and reduce social suffering. Welfare programs include but are not limited to health care, education, SSI, housing, unemployment, food stamps and child care assistance. While this program is a great help to those who receive assistance the misuse and abuse of some obtaining benefits as well as a weakened government system has caused the welfare system to collapse. In earlier years, more Americans were working to provide for their families. Up to 1870, more than half of the Nation’s adult workers were farmers but as the economy grew so did jobs. Development reshaped the workforce. As life happened, people began to need assistance in different areas. The States and the Federal Government realized that the only way to make sure that people would not lose all that they had worked hard for over the years was to engage in insurance programs. In the US, social...

Words: 2511 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Welfare System

...Running Heading: Welfare Fraud Welfare System In America and Its Effects on Society February 22, 2013 Why does poverty exist and why do people end up being poor? Welfare in the United States is referred to the federal government welfare programs that have been put in place to assist the unemployed or underemployed. These social policies and public reform have been consistently at the forefront of American minds. Welfare reform has been a major controversy in the realm of social policy. This is very much debated by Americans as legislators are looking more closely at this topic. Many people agree with it and others don’t. How many really understand the purpose or the intentions of the welfare system? Welfare agencies across America have a goal to strengthen and support individuals and families by promoting cost effective and comprehensive services that foster independent and healthy families. INTRODUCTION Welfare was first introduced in 1935. When the Great Depression hit, many families suffered. It is estimated that one-fourth of the labor force was unemployed during the the Great Depression era. With many families suffering financial difficulties, the government stepped in to solve the problem and that is where the history of welfare as we know it really began. Under President Franklin D. Roosevelt, the Social Security Act was enacted in 1935. Welfare in America has become a debatable subject since its formation.  What is welfare? Welfare is when an individual receives government...

Words: 4165 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Welfare Reform

...Welfare, it is on just about everyones' mind, whether it is Medicare or the A.F.D.C. Some believe there is too much and others think there is too little. As the years go by, the need for welfare reform increases. President Clinton had pledged in his 1992 campaign to "end welfare as we know it". Only time will tell by what extremes welfare will change. As technology continues to increase and jobs continue to go overseas, the United States must decide what direction the welfare system should take. As they exist today, welfare systems are an evolution of the thoughts laid out in the 19th and 20th centuries. Before the Industrial Revolution, the responsibility of helping the poor was mainly given to the churches or local communities. As machines took the place of workers, governments were looked upon to help the unemployed. In 1883, Otto Von Bismarck, the German Chancellor, setup the first form of Modern Welfare when he enacted a sickness and maternity law. He followed up this law with a work injury law and an old-age assistance law in 1884 and 1889 respectively. Today European countries such as Germany, Norway, and Sweden have highly sophisticated Welfare systems (Bender, 13). Welfare did not reach the United States, however, until shortly after the Great Depression with Franklin D. Roosevelt's "New Deal." The New Deal brought on new economic and social welfare legislation. This is the first time that the United States Government used federal and public funds to finance...

Words: 1812 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Human Services

...alcohol use while collecting welfare and other state benefits. The money that is meant to get the parents back on their feet and provide for the children is being grossly misused. Many people who are collecting benefit checks, food stamps, and medical benefits are unable to pass a drug test so in essence are not able to work. They seem to be able to afford cigarettes, alcohol, and drugs but run short on bills, diapers and household goods. The dilemma is that on one hand it might be a violation of rights to ask people to be drug tested, but it’s no more intrusive than providing social security #’s, birthdates, and mother’s maiden named, or pay stubs. According to the American Civil Liberties Union, (2008) the 1996 Welfare Reform Act authorized - but did not require - states to impose mandatory drug testing as a prerequisite to receiving state welfare assistance. This is in part to the fact that some think that testing people for drug use is a violation of their civil rights. The big question is should people be allowed to collect benefits from the state if they are misusing the money for drugs? If the person cannot pass a drug test to get benefits they cannot pass one for a job. This means they have no intention of getting a job in the first place unless they are forced. If the people are not working they get lazier and more likely to produce more children. I would side on testing, because if the money is used for the purpose it was intended for most people will not mind but those who...

Words: 336 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Exploitation Of Child Labour

...operations. Exploitation in general terms can be defined as taking unfair advantage of someone else’s weakness. A person, who is being exploited, accepts voluntarily the deal offered because it makes them “better off”. There are different forms of exploitation such as forced labour, child prostitution, human trafficking for sex work and the abuse of migrant workers. Exploitation at the workplace is largely considered as an unethical behaviour on the part of the employer. Exploiting...

Words: 1529 - Pages: 7