Premium Essay

Simon Vs Piggy

Submitted By
Words 417
Pages 2
In “Men of a Smaller Growth”, Claire Rosenfield states that Jack is the embodiment of evil, chaos, and primal instincts while Ralph represented the good, order, and morals of civilization. Piggy was the fatherly figure of the boys who constantly followed the rules, attaching himself to the morals of society. When he is killed, the order of the island is ruined and the boys turn to savagery, turning into disorder very quickly. Although I agree with most of these points, I do not agree that Ralph is the best representative of good and morals. I feel as if the morals are related to Simon and Piggy, as they are the ones who follow the morals of societies more closely, trying to be good and not attempt to kill. Ralph is seen to be both good and

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Lord of the Flies Theme & Symbol

...Lord of the Flies Symbol and Theme "What I mean is... Maybe it's only us."... Simon became inarticulate in his efforts to express mankind's essential illness” (Page 89). In this quote from the Lord of the Flies the beast is used as a symbol to represent the inner savagery that exists within us. Symbol is something that stands for or suggests something else by reason of relationship, association, convention, or accidental resemblance. William Golding uses symbols to support the theme of Lord of the Flies which is civilization vs. savagery. This theme is present in many parts of the book but it is specifically developed using the following three symbols: the beast, the conch shell and, Simon. During the scene were Simon encounters the Lord of the Flies the Lord of the Flies speaks to him and says “There isn't anyone to help you. Only me. And I'm the Beast... Fancy thinking the Beast was something you could hunt and kill... You knew, didn't you? I'm part of you? Close, close, close! I'm the reason why it's no go? Why things are the way they are?” (Page 142). This quote completely reveals that the beast is symbolized as the innermost evil within all of us. This has a major role in the civilization vs. savagery theme because the beast represents the savagery. The beast is used yet again as a symbol for inner evil when Jack mounts the pig head on a stick. “The head is for the beast. It’s a gift” (Page 137). This shows how the boys begin to almost worship the beast as a god. It displays...

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Savagery of Human Nature in William Golding's 'Lord of the Flies'

...or the internet. People converse with others thousands of miles away through modern connections, watch live broadcasts of news in foreign lands or talk on wireless phones by use of satellites. We are governed by laws designed to protect us. We live in heated homes with fresh water and electricity. We commute to work by car or mass transit. We live by rules, values, and ideals that keep the peace. Our world is organized, convenient and technologically advanced. What would happen if suddenly our civilization disappeared leaving us with only the things we were wearing, the ideals we were raised with, the things we could find is nature and our instincts? This is exactly what happened to the boys in Lord of the Files by William Golding. Ralph, Piggy, Jack and the other stranded students find themselves on a deserted island. Golding’s motives for choosing the island setting for the novel, Lord of the Files was to have the characters isolated, where the laws of their governments could not reach them. The boys on the island represented a microcosm of world society. Golding chose children because they have not yet been fully conditioned by society to understand right from wrong and thus are guided by their instinct and what is inherent with them. Golding uses a great deal of symbolism throughout the novel. Different characters provide different symbols. Jack is a symbol of savagery and anarchy. Golding relates the inherent evil with Jack to the evil and cruelty of the larger world, which...

Words: 1465 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Nature Vs. Nurture In Lord Of The Flies By William Golding

...accepted that the environment a child grows up in impacts their decision making and behavior later in life. According to Jay Belsky, a professor of human development at the University of California, “We know that our early experiences likely affect all of us to a certain extent. . . and we know that due to variations in psychological makeup, some people are more sensitive to environmental factors than others” (Singh). This theory is commonly used in literature as a theme called nature vs nurture, an argument that describes whether the genetic makeup or the environment affects the way people behave. William Golding, author of Lord of the Flies, incorporated this theme into his book to prove behavior is dependent upon a child’s growing environment....

Words: 1757 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Harry Hook Allegory

...insert the ideology that Golding strived to do in his writing. They are both able to depict Simon and Piggy as Jesus-like characters in the sense of truth telling, and the reference of being a martyr. Jack is depicted as a devilish and totalitarian dictator character, and it is...

Words: 2014 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

The Lord of the Flies Analysis

...Dystopia ≠ Utopia A dystopia is a fictional society, usually portrayed as existing in a future time, where the conditions of life are extremely bad due to oppression, or terror. Science fiction (particularly post-apocalyptic science fiction and cyberpunk stories set in an imaginary future world controlled by technology and computers) often feature dystopias. Common traits of Dystopian fiction:  The setting is the future, but often with contemporary social trends taken to extremes incorporated on purpose.  A hierarchical society where there are unbending and definitive divisions between the upper, middle and lower class  Society is conditioned to fear the outside world, and one of the methods for achieving this is the restriction of information and freedom.  A corrupt authoritarian and totalitarian government creates or sustains the poor quality of life  This government makes people believe that society is proper and just, even perfect.  State propaganda makes citizens worship the state the leader of the state and the government.  There is strict conformity among citizens and the general assumption that having opinions and individuality is bad  The penal system often employs psychological or physical torture  Violence, cruelty and aggressiveness are always present.  Dystopias are frequently written as warnings, or as social satire, criticizing a current trend, norm or political system. In order for the dystopia to have an effect on the reader, the author uses characteristics...

Words: 4487 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Mercy Killing In Piggy's Death

...LOTF and LOST both explore murder vs mercy killing. In LOTF you could say two of the boys were murdered in cold blood vs in LOST where you could say they weren't trying to murder they were just trying to help. The definition of murder is the killing of a human being(doc A). This happened in LOTF when Piggy was killed by the rock. Where as Marshal’s death was more civilized(doc C) as they were just trying to help him. In LOTF I believe Piggy's death is 1st degree. It was a act of hatred from Roger. As the book says,”High overhead, Roger, with a sense of delirious abandonment, leaned all his weight onto the lever.”(doc F) As for Simon's death you can't really say because the boys were so involved in the ritual and didn't know what...

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Lord of the Flies Research Paper

...some writer’s works. In the case of light vs. darkness, light usually suggests hope, renewal, or intellectual illumination; darkness implies the unknown, ignorance, or despair. Light can also be associated with the color white, which can represent the following: “innocence”, “goodness”, and “morality,” (Archetypes). Darkness can be associated with the color black, allowing darkness to represent the following: “the unknown”, “death”, “the unconscious”, or “evil” (Archetypes). All of these things can also be linked to morality- the id, ego, and superego. The id can be classified as “the primitive and instinctive component of personality”; ego can be classified as the part of the personality that “develops in order to mediate between the unrealistic id and the external real world”, and superego can be classified as the part of the personality that incorporates the values and morals of society which are learned from one's parents and others.” (McLeod). In Lord of the Flies, Many of the evil deeds in the story are committed at night, representing darkness. A perfect example of an evil deed that is committed at night would be the murder of Simon by all of the other boys (Golding 151-153). The obvious use of the darkness is death because Simon dies; however, this event also embodies the unknown because an excuse that is used by Ralph and Piggy for partaking in the murder of Simon was that it was dark, and they could not see well. Piggy even says, “It was dark. There was that- that...

Words: 1050 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Examples Of Nurture In Lord Of The Flies

...Jack wants the boys on his side for more hunters and to make all the boys not follow rules. He knew that the boys fear was the beast. Jack had saw that as advantage to manipulate them and say he wants to teach them how to hunt just so they'll be on his side. With that the boys realize they are done trying to help, they don't want to do work anymore, they would rather have fun. This leads to the boys going to Jack’s group and then it’s just Ralph and Piggy. Jack and all the other boys go crazy, just wanting to have fun but Ralph and Piggy still want and are trying to be rescued. They end up going after Jack and the other boys to get Piggy’s glasses back to start a fire to get noticed by officers in the ocean. Throughout the fighting you realize that Samneric was conflicted to join Jack’s group. That’s really the part of nurture because it was either to them they joined his group or they was going to be abused by him. They are put in situation as to they look at the environment they're in that there is no adults, so Jack could get away with abusing them. All Samneric wanted was to join the group that was more...

Words: 1078 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Adolescence In Lord Of The Flies

...terror. In Lord of the Flies by William Golding, the meaning of adolescence is represented by innocence as well as terror which shapes the theme, savagery vs. civilization. The boys’ adolescence is represented by the amount of innocence they present when first arriving on the island. “Ralph pursed his lips and squirted air into the shell, which emitted a low, farting noise. This amused both boys so much that Ralph went on squirting for some minutes, between bouts of laughter”, (Golding, 17). Ralph and Piggy find a shell while walking around the island and try to figure out how to use it. Their innocence is shown through the happiness and enjoyment they get from making a funny noise with the shell. The scene represents their innocent characters before conflicts arise and change them for the worst....

Words: 452 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Lord of the Flies

... | B Samenvatting Maak zelf een samenvatting met een richtlijn van 200 woorden. Zorg dat het echt je eigen woorden zijn. Het bestand gaat immers door de plagiaatcontrole. (aantal woorden vermelden) |Een groep jongens komt na een vliegtuigcrash op een onbewoond eiland terecht. Als Ralph en Piggy(biggie) elkaar op het strand | |tegenkomen, gaan ze ervan uit dat ze op een onbewoond eiland zijn beland. Als alle kinderen bijeen wordt er een stemming gehouden over | |wie de leider zou moeten zijn. De verkiezingen om het leiderschap word gehouden tussen Ralph en Jack. Ralph heeft goede kenmerken en hij| |kan ook de oorschelp bespelen, het gene wat de kinderen bijeen heeft gebracht, maar Jack is de leider van een koor en dus luistert er al| |een groep naar hem. Ralph besluit ook dat er een vuur moet komen op de berg, zodat voorbijvarende schepen het signaal kunnen zien. Er | |komt een splitsing tussen Jack en Ralph`s groep. Als de kinderen een dode parachutist op het eiland zien, denken de kinderen dat het een| |beest is. Simon, die niet geloofd dat er een beest is, gaat opzoek. Als hij een al eerder voor “het beest” opgeofferde varkenshoofd | |ziet, denkt hij dat hij er tegen hem gepraat wordt. Als hij flauw valt en later bijkomt, gaat hij de berg op en komt de dode...

Words: 1574 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Savagery vs Civilization--Lord of the Flies

...Savagery vs. Civilization The civil and savage nature lies in all human beings, each instinct dominant when the other is not. This is the overall theme of William Golding’s novel Lord of the Flies. William Golding was a British poet, playwright, and novelist, most famous for Lord of the Flies. This novel is about the internal struggles of young boys marooned on a tropical deserted island. They fight to maintain their civil ways, in which each boy learned, isn’t all that easy. When civilization isn’t present in a person’s life, the savage beast inside them takes over. Roger, Ralph, and Simon all have entirely different struggles with the opposing forces within them. Some succumb easier than others. Roger lost the civilized life he was used to and because of that the natural savage instinct inside of him took over, and a bully and eventual murderer was created. In this quote, the sadistic Roger is beginning to blossom, but he still has a stronger civil instinct in control. “Roger gathered a handful of stones and began to throw them. Yet there was a space around Henry, perhaps six yards in diameter, into which he dare not throw. Here, invisible yet strong, was the taboo of old life Round the squatting child was the protection of parents and school and policemen and the law” (Golding 56). Roger is so tempted to throw these rocks at Henry, a younger boy, but his socially acceptable standards at home are still burned into his mind, for he reluctantly backs down. The invisible...

Words: 1352 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Savagery Lord Of The Flies Quote Analysis

...Golding develops savagery as a symbol using various methods. Golding uses savagery as a central theme in Lord of the Flies. Jack uses hunting as an outlet for his rage, putting it over other imperative projects. “The fire’s only been out an hour or two. We can light up again.” (Golding 70). This quote from jack shows his apathy toward keeping the signal fire burning and putting in the effort to assure their rescue. Ralph identifies their need for safety and tries to persuade Jack about the importance of the signal fire, but he is uninterested. Many of the younger boys follow in Jack’s footsteps, attending the hunts and feasts Jack has to offer. As the hunts become daily, the children become more barbaric, eventually leading to the death of Simon. “There were no words, and no movements but the tearing of teeth and claws.” (Golding 153). The kids have become completely savage as they butcher a boy who had done nothing wrong. Savagery is contained within all humans, but when in peculiar situations, it can overcome your mind. Individualism ties in with savagery in Lord of the Flies as other’s feelings and emotions are abolished during times of very high stress. When Ralph is chosen as the leader, multiple issues appear with survivors who disagree with Ralph’s opinions. Jack immediately opposes Ralph’s announcement as leader ‘”I ought to be chief’ Jack said with arrogance” (Golding 30). Throughout the beginning of Lord of the Flies, Jack and Ralph are at a constant disagreement as to...

Words: 755 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

How Does Piggy Use Symbols In Lord Of The Flies

...means of survival which is why he never lets go of his spear, and he even encouraged the other boys to make their own spear. He let his spear rule over his mind and body which led to Simon’s death. The sow’s head literally became the Lord of the flies. As it was left propped on a stick, it’s blood attracted the flies and soon became covered with it. To Jack it was their gift or offering for the ‘beast’ so that it will not come after them and do them harm. But to Simon, it was a face within recognition, a voice that kept him company – encouraging him, taunting him. It was his deep longings, his frustrations, his fears. It was the sow’s head that made him came out of his hiding place and learned about the dead man they thought was the beast. These images shows some reasons as to how the boys slowly fell from civilization and into savagery. I chose to create this model to represent Piggy as a major character and the events, people, and objects in the novel that held significance in the theme of civilization vs. savagery....

Words: 608 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Examples Of Savagery In Lord Of The Flies

...Savagery Vs. Humanity Often times we like to ignore the darker times of humanity, because we know the darkness resides in us. “The Lord of the Flies” is a perfect portrayal of how when given the chance the darkness will take over our humanity and leave us with the decision of how we are going to deal with it. All of this is shown in “The Lord of the Flies”, a book driven by Golding’s desire to portray how the theme of the book is “an attempt to trace the defects of society back to the defects of human nature” (Golding, 204). His idea assists in showing how savagery derives not from the brutal society they have created but themselves and their human impulse, which they intend to act upon. The boy’s behavior...

Words: 696 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Literatura Proizvedeniia

...1. W. Shakespeare « Hamlet» (Renaissance) Character List Hamlet -  The Prince of Denmark, the title character, and the protagonist. About thirty years old at the start of the play, Hamlet is the son of Queen Gertrude and the late King Hamlet, and the nephew of the present king, Claudius. Hamlet is melancholy, bitter, and cynical, full of hatred for his uncle’s scheming and disgust for his mother’s sexuality. A reflective and thoughtful young man who has studied at the University of Wittenberg, Hamlet is often indecisive and hesitant, but at other times prone to rash and impulsive acts. Hamlet is extremely philosophical and contemplative. He is particularly drawn to difficult questions or questions that cannot be answered with any certainty. Faced with evidence that his uncle murdered his father, evidence that any other character in a play would believe, Hamlet becomes obsessed with proving his uncle’s guilt before trying to act. Claudius -  The King of Denmark, Hamlet’s uncle, and the play’s antagonist. The villain of the play, Claudius is a calculating, ambitious politician, driven by his sexual appetites and his lust for power, but he occasionally shows signs of guilt and human feeling—his love for Gertrude, for instance, seems sincere. Gertrude -  The Queen of Denmark, Hamlet’s mother, recently married to Claudius. Gertrude loves Hamlet deeply, but she is a shallow, weak woman who seeks affection and status more urgently than moral rectitude or truth. Polonius -  The...

Words: 9533 - Pages: 39