...Hirschi’s Social Control Theory in Crime and Punishment in Suburbia Over the past few decades criminologists and sociologists have developed several theories in an effort to try and explain what causes some human beings to commit crimes. One of the most well-known theories that tries to explain why criminals commit crimes is called the social control or social bond theory developed by a theorist named Travis Hirschi. Hirschi also wanted to figure out why people don’t commit crimes instead of just figuring out why they do and he tried his best to answer those questions using his social control theory.The social control theory developed by Mr. Hirschi states that a person who has bonds with family, friends, the community, or other groups is less likely to participate in criminal activity than people who do not have those solid bonds in their life. (Glick & Miller, 2008, p. 175) Some theorists criticize this theory because they say not having bonds with friends, family, or the community has no effect on whether a person becomes involved in criminal activity or not. This paper will use the movie Crime and Punishment in Suburbia to demonstrate the validity of the social control theory by showing that not having strong bonds in a person’s life can drive them to commit criminal acts. Crime and punishment in Suburbia is the perfect movie to use in order to demonstrate the validity of Travis Hirschi’s control theory because it is about a girl named Rosanne who lacked social bonds...
Words: 1774 - Pages: 8
...The objective of this paper is to make an argument on which particular theory describes crime more. The two theories that I have chosen will be the Labeling Theory and the Social Control Theory. Social control theory elaborates further into why people commit criminal behavior, than the Labeling Theory when expounding on underage drug use. In most cases criminals have been explained by the control variables of Hirschi's social control theory. Essential tools in shaping most people's characteristics, is their upbringing and societal influences. One of the biggest influences upon people is society, family, and their peers. Personally I do not believe that crime comes from a certain individual acting alone because truly society has an impact on...
Words: 1068 - Pages: 5
...Underlying Assumption The social control theory developed by Ivan Nye in 1958 discusses how having norms, values and customs prevent juveniles from committing delinquent acts. Structure of Theory Social control theory has four types of control. The first control is direct, which is treatment that is enforced for disobedient behavior by authority (parent or family member) (Parks 2013). An example of direct is a parent or guardian threaten to take away the juvenile’s video games for fighting a classmate in school. The second control is internal, which a juvenile abstains from any crime (Parks 2013). A juvenile does not commit a crime because he or she knowns it is not the right thing to do, and the juvenile have seen someone commit a crime that disappointed their family. The third control is indirect, which a juvenile would refrain from committing such act if a family member or authority will be disappointed in his or her actions (Kierkus, Baer 2002). The fourth control is satisfaction. If a juvenile has everything he or she wants in their household, he or she will not commit a delinquent act. The juvenile parent or parents could spoil the child, so they do not need anything. Strength...
Words: 401 - Pages: 2
...Summary Social control theory examines the relationship build in society between those who are criminals and non-criminals. Within the social control theory, conflicts are developed between men and woman based on the specific labels and behavior that are placed on them and expected by society. There has been a constant swift change in power within society. Usually men are known for being the providers of the family, while woman are know for being caregivers. Woman are now taking control and are being more dominant in society than ever before. More conflict has recently risen due to the changes in society regarding the rights and privileges that women have and now share with men. Gender and association are two common and major sources that...
Words: 979 - Pages: 4
...EXAMINING THEORY PAPER INDIVIDUAL ASSIGNMENT Neil Holmes CJA/314 Criminology 06/05/14 Chris DeRicco In this paper, I hope to explain the reasons why people commit crimes and the many theories in the field of criminology. Social process theory is one such assumption and argues that criminal behavior is learned through interactions with others. There are four types of social process theories including: social learning theory, social control theory, social labeling theory, and dramaturgical perspective. This paper will analyze two of the theories and will discuss social process theory and the history of its development, also the theory’s importance to criminology, examples of the theory and any negatives or positives associated with the theory. Social learning theory is the process that occurs through observing the consequences of others and by determining if such behavior is worth replicating (Wallace, n.d.). To put in a nut shell, basically this theory advises that humans learn by watching other commit crimes. This theory was developed in the 1930s by theorists Edwin Sutherland, Robert Burgess, Ronald L. Akers...
Words: 1139 - Pages: 5
...ISSN 1648-2603 ● VIEŠOJI POLITIKA IR ADMINISTRAVIMAS ● 2004. Nr. 13 Accountability and Responsibility in Organizations: the Ethics of Discretion Raymond W. Cox III University of Akron Akron, Ohio, USA The article presents a comprehensive approach to the administrative discretion. The objective of the paper has been to outline a perspective and patterns of behaviour, which are helpful defining "discretion in action". Theoretical discussion on the issue has been extended towards practical implications. Author stresses, that establishing a decision-making architecture, leaders of the organization can create learning and supportive environment, which encourages appropriate and limited use of discretion. Raktažodžiai: atskaitomybė, atsakomybė, diskretiškumas, etika, korupcija, sprendimų priėmimas. Keywords: accountability, responsibility, discretion, ethics, corruption, decision making. Introduction Few aspects of Public Administration engender more controversy than the idea of discretion. For most, the attitude toward the exercise of discretion must be described as ambiguous and even ambivalent. While the necessity of the exercise of discretion is not disputed, there is little agreement on the normative foundation (Bryner, 1987) for that activity. Yet without a normative foundation, there is little basis upon which to judge the exercise of discretion. Recent literature on ethical practices in the governments of Africa has boldly asserted that discretion leads to the breakdown...
Words: 9274 - Pages: 38
...The second class of micro-level origin theories, control theories, explores the causes of deviance from an altogether different perspective. Control theories take for granted the existence of a cohesive set of norms shared by most persons in the society and reason that most persons want to and will typically conform to these prevailing social norms. The emphasis in these theories, unlike learning theories, is on the factors that bond individuals to conforming lifestyles. The bonds act as social and psychological constraints on the individual, binding persons to normative conformity (Toby 1957; Hirschi 1969). People deviate from norms when these bonds to conventional lifestyles are weak, and hence, when they have little restraining influence over the individual. Among control theorists, Travis Hirschi (1969) has made the greatest contributions to our knowledge about bonding processes and deviant behavior. Writing on the causes of delinquency, he argued that four aspects of bonding are especially relevant to control theory: emotional attachments to conforming others, psychological commitments to conformity, involvements in conventional activities, and beliefs consistent with conformity to prevailing norms. Among the most important of the bonding elements are emotional attachments individuals may have to conforming others and commitments to conformity—psychological investments or stakes people hold in a conforming lifestyle. Those having weak attachments—that is, people who are...
Words: 1230 - Pages: 5
...assess right realist explanations of both the causes of crime and the solutions to crime (21 marks) As suggested in item A, right realists explain crime to be a social problem requiring practical solutions. Realists focus on crime which is at the centre of public concern, for example street crime, violence and burglary; they are concerned with increasing measures of crime control. Wilson and Hernstein put forward a biosocial theory explaining the causes of crime; they argue crime is an activity disproportionately committed by young men living in large cities, these young men are temperamentally aggressive as a result of biological factors which predisposes them to crime. The social aspect to their theory comes from the belief that young men are socialised in the family, school and wider community in a culture that emphasises immediate gratification, low impulse control and self-expression which has reduced the restraints on their behaviour in conforming to society’s norms and value, resulting in more crime. A criticism of Wilson and Hernstein’s theory is their assumption that young males in inner cities are responsible for most crime. Right realists uses official statistics to base their theory on, thus, the assumption of young males could be based on an invalid picture presented by official statistics. The theory also ignores wider structural causes of crime, such as the increasing gap between the rich and the poor creating resentment and relative deprivation resulting in...
Words: 1073 - Pages: 5
...upbringing is of core importance in a child’s development of social skills. As seen with Jeffrey Dahmer he did not receive that socialization bond be it with his parent or other people in his life. All the way through his childhood, Jeffrey Dahmer was ignored and developed a way of perceiving himself as an outsider, rejected by society. This loneliness and sense of rejection grew until it aggravated his compulsion to commit the monstrous crimes of murder, necrophilia, and cannibalism. As seen from his biography he didn’t have close relationships that could have deterred him from committing the crime as the social control theory suggests. In his loneliness Jeffrey filled that void with dismembering animals, a behavior later seen in his crimes. It can thus be concluded that creation and nurturing of social bonds are very essential in childhood socialization and in the development of stable psychological state of mind. Jeffrey Dahmer’s Criminal Theories Jeffrey Dahmer has had many different theories applied to him, such as the social control theory, rational choice theory, and many other psychological theories. The sociological theory of deviance that best fits the criminal behavior of Jeffrey Dahmer is the Social control theory. Jeffrey Dahmer’s compulsions were not only sick, but sexual. When he began murdering, he sought out mainly homosexual African American men. He must not have cared to conform to the ‘social norm’ of a straight lifestyle when he went out to gay bars,...
Words: 789 - Pages: 4
...Policy issues paper Brandon Quisano CJA314 September, 05, 2014 Oscar Diaz Policy issues paper In this paper, I hope to analyze and figure out what causes individuals to commit crimes and the many theories in criminology. Social process theory is one such assumption and argues that interaction and interacting with other individuals certain criminal behaviors are learned. There are four types of social process theories including: social learning theory, social control theory, social labeling theory, and dramaturgical perspective. The developmental process and background of social process theories will be discussed in this paper. Also the important parts of this theory to criminology and the pro’s and con’s that are a part of the theory. Social learning theory is when consequences are observed of others and thinking about copying a behavior is called social learning theory. To put in a nut shell, this thoery explains that human beings are educated by observing others. Identifying certain patterns in behavior of the criminal kind and the values that went along with them theorists such as Edwin Sutherland, Robert Burgess, and Ronald L. Akers developed in the 1930’sLearning theory. Other well known theorists Albert Bandura also helped in this theory and developed Recipricol determinism that emphasizes how a person’s behavior, enviroment and their personal qualities all intertwined with each other. (“Learning-Theories.com”,2012). Developed by Bandura are these steps number...
Words: 1099 - Pages: 5
...Discussion Question 3 The Social Bond Theory along with the Self Control Theory both help explain why crimes and deviant behavior occur. They both do so in there own way explaining why youth get involved in criminal behavior. The Social Bond Theory is also known as the social control theory; it is the belief that forming personal relationships is the most important part of human development. These personal relationships that are formed keep the youth from committing crimes or other deviant behavior. These personal relationships can be with family, school, church, government, and within the community. The Self Control Theory explains why the majority of people choose not to participate or become involved in criminal behavior. Throughout the theory it explains how people with a high level of self-control are going to be considerably less likely to participate in criminal behavior and how if you have a low level of self control you are more likely to become involved in criminal behavior. With these two theories they talk about acts of delinquency and what might affect them but the two theories them selves contradict themselves because if you are not in a certain group you may believe that you have a sense of self control and believe that you don’t need others in your life. Even with the belief that you have self-control you may still act out because you don’t have a social bond with anyone or any group. I agree with the Social bond theory more because In my personal...
Words: 306 - Pages: 2
...Social control theory believes that crimes or what leads to crimes can be caused by a breakage in a bond that ties a potential criminal and the society such as family, friends and so on and so forth together and vice-versa. According to Miller (2009): “as social bonds increase in strength, the costs of crime to the individual increase as well.” (p. 3). I must that I agree with this theory, but I had to read it again in order to grasp the concept of it, and then it hit home for me, we have a huge significance role in each other’s life; especially our family members, friends because one can hope to be better and live by the examples of the people they are surrounded by. With that being said, I am not in compliance to a certain degree in reference...
Words: 687 - Pages: 3
...departs from social norms. While all three theories are linked under the social process umbrella and believe that people that are delinquent and those that are not delinquent share the same feelings about society and the role it plays in their lives, they have different beliefs as to how someone does deviant and criminal activities. Social learning theory proposes that people are born good and learns to be bad (Siegel, L., 2013). Criminal behavior and values are learned when an individual associates themselves with another individual that engages in criminal misconduct. Thus the styles of crimes are learned through personal bonds amongst groups. Adolescent children...
Words: 1908 - Pages: 8
...Pedophilia is defined as the fantasy or act of sexual activity with a prepubescent child. These predators are typically men that can possibly be attracted to either or both the female child along with the male child. These same perpetrators view their actions as aiding the child mature through their youth stages. In addition, they also deceive themselves into thinking that the child actually enjoys this manipulation. However, the perpetrator informs the child to keep silent about what has occurred, informing the child to not tell his or her parents. The opposing arguments within the Social Control Theory suggest that these listed behaviors are brought on by society. This same theory also explains why people are law abiding citizens. Apparently...
Words: 358 - Pages: 2
...Planning 3 Week 3: Organizing 3 Concept: Six Key Elements in Determining Organizational Structure 3 Concept: Mechanistic and Organic Structures 4 Concept: Types of Contemporary Organizational Designs 4 Concept: Types of Internal and External Collaboration 5 Concept: Stages of Group Development 5 Concept: Five Conflict Management Techniques 6 Concept: Six Aspects of Group Structure 6 Week 4: Leading 7 Concept: Early Leadership Theories 7 Concept: Contingency Leadership Theories 8 Concept: Contemporary Leadership Theories 8 Concept: Five Sources of Leader Power 9 Concept: Goals of Organizational Behavior 9 Concept: The Big Five Model 10 Concept: Attribution Theory 10 Week 5: Controlling 11 Concept: Control Process 11 Concept: Feedforward/Concurrent/Feedback Controls 11 Concept: Financial Controls 12 Concept: Balanced Scorecard 12 Concept: Benchmarking 13 Week 6: Business Ethics 13 Concept: Differences Between a Firm’s Social Obligations, Social Responsiveness, and Social Responsibility 13 Concept: Politics: Green Approaches/Shades of Green Model 14 Concept: Factors to Determine Ethical Behavior 14 Concept: Ways Managers Can Encourage Ethical Behavior 15 Week 2: Planning Ch. 8 of Management Ch. 9 of Management Concept: Strategies for SWOT Analyses |Details | |As a process...
Words: 2855 - Pages: 12
