Spreader Sourcing Decision

In: Business and Management

Submitted By youngmroville
Words 928
Pages 4
RUNNING HEAD: Scotts Miracle-Gro : The Spreader Sourcing Decision







Unit 7 Scotts Miracle-Gro : The Spreader Sourcing Decision
Kaplan University
School of Business and Management
MT460 Management Policy and Strategy
David H Brose
Professor: Zurick
October 11, 2011











Introduction
Scotts merged with Miracle Gro in 1995 to form the largest lawn and garden supplier to the do it yourselfer. The company started as a seed supplier in 1868, claiming to distribute a weed free seed. Scotts marketed fertilizer in the late 1920s. In 1930, they developed their drop spreader business and their broadcast spreader business in 1983.
Synopsis of the Situation
Scotts had developed an injection molding process that is more appropriate for their industry. The old process of “hot stamping” labels left a manufacturer expiration on Scotts product. The new “label stamping” process made for a more unique and efficient manufacturing process.
Key Issues
The manufacturing process required fewer employees to produce. The location of the manufacturing facility requires high paid production labor, leased facilities, and limited manufacturing capabilities.
Define the Problem
Scott manufactures their label stamped spreader in a state with expensive cost of living and more expensive realty. The cost of moving the manufacturing facility is unthinkable with the specialty equipment and training required for the product.
Alternative Solutions
Moving the manufacturing process to China would be costly to the company because either new molds must be purchased or the existing molds must be transported to the new manufacturing facility. Moving the manufacturing facility will save money on rent, salary, and utilities.
Selected Solution to the Problem
Moving manufacturing to China would be a way…...

Similar Documents

Ethical Sourcing

...What is ethical sourcing? It is a situation where a company deliberately buys raw materials from suppliers who process their products under ethical conditions. By this, I mean employee working conditions, fair trade practices, optimize the use of natural resources What does Starbucks source ethically? Coffee: * Starbucks purchases 86% of their coffee beans from ethically sourced suppliers * Starbucks requires that most supplies comply by the CAFÉ practices. By this I mean Coffee and Farmer equity practices which encompass guidelines covering a broad spectrum of ethical issues like employee working conditions, employee welfare, environmental impact and fair trade practices * Starbucks also ensures that the cocoa suppliers comply to the Cocoa practices program which verifies the supply chain related to cocoa beans to ensure long term supply of ethical tea ingredients Tea * Starbucks is working on CHAI which is community health advancement initiative to improve the conditions of the tea ingredients (tea and spices) manufacturers in Darjeeling and Assam parts of India where tea is grown in large scale Store * Giving customers a “Starbucks experience” is a big part of Starbucks business. * Starbucks ensures that all the store related merchandise, furniture, aprons, etc are sourced under ethical means WIP * Train suppliers to comply by ethical regulations by validating them time to time * Benchmarking ethical practices against peers (coffee......

Words: 290 - Pages: 2

Strategic Sourcing

...What specific action should the company take in the area of inventory control? Support your proposal with an analysis of its strengths and weaknesses (15 points). The company should implement a plan. As stated in the case, there was no real plan or policy in action that supported this role within the company. This has to be done if the company wants to continue to grow. They are a growing company and have a number of different products. This is strength because they offer their customers a variety of products to choose from. Another strength would be that they have commonality amongst their products. It stated in the case that they have several products that share materials. This is a good thing because strategic sourcing strategies can be implemented here. One of their main weaknesses was the lack of inventory control. This affected their raw materials all the way to their finished goods. They lost orders, had to make smaller quantity orders to meet production needs, and have growing transportation cost. They need to make use of an ERP system like SAP in order to track all of their inventory and finished goods problems they were experiencing. Having a system like this in place will let them know, when they need to re order product, the different salvage dates and cost, and other inventory management problems that they may need to solve. What is your reaction to the argument of those who oppose tighter controls? (5 points) Tighter controls need to be kept to stop the...

Words: 1452 - Pages: 6

Scotts Miracle Gro-the Spreader Sourcing Decision

...Scotts Miracle Gro The Spreader Sourcing Decision 1.What are the strategic risks and benefits of outsourcing production of the Temecula plant to a contract manufacturer(s) in China? RISKS • Perceived decrease in quality from abandoning in-mold labeling • Additional costs and problems in implementing in-mold labeling in China • Up-front investment in specialized equipment and training for the partner • Inflexibility of sourcing suppliers would result • Labor and electricity costs guaranteed to increase at uncertain rates • Undervalued Yuan; drastic shift in exchange rates would reduce outsourcing cost advantages • Net increase in transportation costs of $7 M per year • Finished goods pipeline time would force increase of safety stock by $460K BENEFITS Immediate savings in • Labor Costs • Electricity costs • Plant and Property costs 2.Financially compare two of the options (stay in Temecula, outsource to China). Include all possible relevant financial measures and explicitly state important factors not included in the financial analysis. Provide a brief assessment of the offshoring option. Temecula Costs Lease Electricity Annual Usage Hourly raye rate+surcharge Electricity Costs Labor Costs Hourly Wage Hours Days Hourly Labor Salaried Workers Average Salary Salary Expense Total Current Labor Direct Manufacturing Costs Overhead Direct Investment Discount Total Cost 2008 $3,000,000 2009 $3,000,000 2010 $3,000,000 2011 $3,000,000 2012 $3,000,000 2013 $3,000,000 2014...

Words: 4014 - Pages: 17

Sourcing

... given instance of the company’s new product development process) – each sourcing decision is taken. “No decision” represents those cases, where the decision has been taken before the beginning of the project. E.g. make vs. buy decision encompasses the decision whether outsourcing the production of a given component or manufacturing it internally. No make vs. buy decision takes place when the SC configuration, i.e. the number and locations of suppliers and production plants, is taken as given, without any opportunity for changes. The sourcing decisions that will be considered in the research are: (i) make vs. buy (i.e. outsourcing) decisions during production and design, (ii) local vs. global sourcing, i.e. suppliers location, (iii) suppliers selection, (iv) supplier-plant assignment, i.e. the definition of which contractor will supply each plant, finally (v) the relationship with suppliers, i.e. whether a collaborative relationship should be in place with the selected supplier. Collaborative relationships can be classified according to the content of in-formation shared and the main decisions that are jointly made by parties, e.g. collaboration on operational processes and/or on product design (Brun and Pero 2010). Make or Buy (production and design) Local vs Global sourcing Supplier selection Supplier‐plant assignment Buyer‐supplier relationship Product features • Position of Sourcing decisions TIMING COPD(Product Customization) • Product innovativeness • Product......

Words: 9464 - Pages: 38

Global Sourcing

... developed the Global Sourcing Principles and pre-qualification within it direct supplier. The supplier must ensure the goods and services are in acceptable standards as well as to have a continuous improvement of the goods standards. For any global sourcing of goods, whether these are clothing or food, the global sourcing principles apply. These are introduced to potential suppliers through Corporate Communications within Marks and Spencer. The application of these principles is carried out within each business unit through the procurement function at contract stage. When tenders for contract go out to suppliers the global sourcing principles are used in the decision-making process. Before any contract is taken up within Marks and Spencer locally or globally, a site visit is undertaken to ensure that product and service specifications can be met. For the foods sourcing strategy, partly of the food are manufacturing in house which is own manufacturing strategy by Marks and Spencer but the fresh material supply such as vegetables and fruits supplied by the local supplier. M&S has a strong relationship with the well-known British farmers using the third party manufacturing strategies which they have building a long term partnership and this give the farmer the best security in the future while let the customers known about the product sourced from the best possible farms. To ensure the quality and safety of the foods of M&S produces, the company invested in funding...

Words: 4197 - Pages: 17

Commodity Sourcing

...Commodity Sourcing Our company is currently purchasing virgin olive oil from California and I was given the duty of finding other sources of the virgin olive oil. I went to the website www.comtrade.un.org to determine other countries that could supply us with virgin olive oil. Spain was noted to have the highest net weight of virgin olive oil that was exported. Italy was determined to be the 2nd in exports of virgin olive oil and Tunisia was noted to the 3rd. Greece was 4th, Portugal 5th and Syria was determined to be 6th. Based on this information, I would choose Spain and Tunisia as our suppliers. I would choose Tunisia first as my supplier based on the lowest price at $2.85 per kilogram of virgin olive oil. My second choice would be Spain because its price was slightly higher at $2.99 per kilogram of virgin olive oil. One factor that is not known is the amount of virgin olive oil that my company needs and is this amount needed more than Tunisia can provide us based on its other customers that the country supplies. I would still try to obtain as much of virgin olive oil from Tunisia and then turn to Spain as my supplier since it is the largest world provider of virgin olive oil in 2010. Retrieved from www.comtrade.un.org Appendix: Reporter | Trade Value ($) | Net Weight (kg) | Price (Value/Weight) | Spain | 1,959,673,259 | 654,404,347 | 2.99 | Italy | 1,170,009,198 | 263,984,408 | 4.43 | Tunisia | 282,132,260 | 99,045,795 | 2.85 | Greece |......

Words: 297 - Pages: 2

Global Sourcing

...Global Sourcing What are some of the risks of buying overseas that one can avoid by buying from domestic sources? Some risks of buying overseas that can be avoided through buying from domestic sources include: Conducting business with immature suppliers causes risk as you do not have the same relationship and history with them that you do with suppliers you have worked with for years. You are unable to have regular ‘in person’ meetings and make assumptions that can taint your potential to have a great relationship. Unreliable delivery is also a risk which can be avoided (or reduced) by procuring from domestic sources. When a supplier is closer, or domestic, your timelines are shorter and more predictable. Quality can be a risk as you might not get the same quality you expected or ordered. It is more difficult to return and/or exchange the product. There is risk with foreign currency due to the fluctuations in the rate of foreign currency Transaction costs and the other costs related to communication and monitoring the network of suppliers, intermediaries and logistic providers can be reduced by buying domestically. 2. Purchase contracts issued by Barbara’s firm provide for the goods to be produced, shipped, and received within five months of the date the contract is issued. Should the monetary amounts specified in the contract be in U.S. dollars or in the currency of the nation where the manufacturer is located? Why? When your business transacts in...

Words: 1115 - Pages: 5

Sourcing and Pestel

... people, including women • Factories constantly improving and developing (e.g. Roverco ‘equipped with modern equipment’) • Language barrier • Long distance (if problems occur) • Long lead time • Cultural barriers (different national/religious holidays) • Time difference – small window of opportunity for direct communication Romania Advantages Disadvantages • Closer to UK than other sourcing regions • Less distance means shorter lead time • As regions such as Mauritius can be used for casual jersey, regions like Romania are strong in producing more tailored items • Usually more expensive to source from than the far east • Language barrier Mauritius Advantages Disadvantages • Good producer of casual jersey – important area for top department • Cheaper than Eastern Europe • Language barrier • Long distance (if problems occur) • Long lead time • Cultural barriers (different national/religious holidays) • Time difference – small window of opportunity for direct communication • Can be unreliable Types of Supplier Manufacturers/Factories: Topshop buyers deal directly with the suppliers by sending their order, and in return receive samples that have to be signed off by the buyer before the product goes into mass production. Advantages Disadvantages • Arcadia are committed to supporting the Benefits for Business and Workers Model (BBW), which involves 110 factories in India and Bangladesh over two years and will focus on improving factories’......

Words: 1780 - Pages: 8

Sourcing and Pestel

...SOURCING ASSIGNMENT Marks and Spencer’s limited collection features a number of different garments and materials, ranging from Turkey for Denim and Acrylics to Indonesia for embellished dresses their range also covers accessories, shoes and handbags. Therefore they are going to need several different countries to cover the sourcing of the entire of their range. So, for the Purpose of this report I am going to look at the countries Turkey, China and Romania as they were the most prominent among the supply base. In the last 10 years Turkey has been steadily producing more and more clothing for the UK Highstreet. It is regarded as a great maker of Denim and currently owns a 21.8% share of the UK textile exports. The advantages of using a supplier based in Turkey include Short lead times, meaning repeat orders can be quickly processed should the demand for a particular product increase dramatically. Large Cotton supply, where other countries supplies of cotton are scares due to the 2010 Cotton Crisis, turkey produces around 900 000 tons of cotton annually placing themselves 6th in the world. This means that whilst other areas are still trying to recover from the effects Turkey found an increase in demand of work. Turkey is a first world country with lots of schooling and freedom, their workers are much less likely to be exploited than other countries in the middle east who are not as well developed. Also, the Turkish textile industry is known for good reputation for...

Words: 1749 - Pages: 7

Mro Sourcing Goes Global

...MRO Sourcing goes global Tammy Johnson Project Procurement Management: INF336 Professor Lori Deere April 09, 2012 MRO Sourcing goes global The three practices that I found to talk about from this article are; make and buy, outsourcing, and subcontracting. The best way that I could describe these steps and practices that in the company that I work are to improve using the make and buy practice. The first thing that is some of the materials and things that have there at the scooter store, like other power chairs and scooters parts to fix another scooter or power chair and then only buy new stuff when it is absolutely necessary. Most of the power wheel chairs and scooters have a lot of similar parts therefore we should not buy new parts every time we should make some of the old parts fit other chairs. Outsourcing according to the textbook “when they decide to buy something they had been making in-house previously. The outsourcing that comes to mind for the company that I am currently employed is the same thing that I spoke of in the weekly discussion. That outsourcing is the payroll being done by an outside source that is a certified public accountant (CPA) does and not anybody that works right in the company with all of us. Then nobody has to worry about friends taking care of their friend and messing over somebody else with their time and their payroll. The subcontracting that I found in the article is sort of like power wheel chairs and......

Words: 357 - Pages: 2

Spreader Sourcing Decision

...RUNNING HEAD: Scotts Miracle-Gro : The Spreader Sourcing Decision Unit 7 Scotts Miracle-Gro : The Spreader Sourcing Decision Kaplan University School of Business and Management MT460 Management Policy and Strategy David H Brose Professor: Zurick October 11, 2011 Introduction Scotts merged with Miracle Gro in 1995 to form the largest lawn and garden supplier to the do it yourselfer. The company started as a seed supplier in 1868, claiming to distribute a weed free seed. Scotts marketed fertilizer in the late 1920s. In 1930, they developed their drop spreader business and their broadcast spreader business in 1983. Synopsis of the Situation Scotts had developed an injection molding process that is more appropriate for their industry. The old process of “hot stamping” labels left a manufacturer expiration on Scotts product. The new “label stamping” process made for a more unique and efficient manufacturing process. Key Issues The manufacturing process required fewer employees to produce. The location of the manufacturing facility requires high paid production labor, leased facilities, and limited manufacturing capabilities. Define the Problem Scott manufactures their label stamped spreader in a state with expensive cost of living and more expensive realty. The cost of moving the manufacturing facility is unthinkable with the specialty equipment and training required for the product...

Words: 928 - Pages: 4

Decision

...Business Research Methods Part II QNT/HC561 Applied Business in Research and Statistics in Health Care April 30, 2012 Business Research Methods Part II Kaiser Permanente, an integrated managed care consortium, operates with 181,900 employees. The organization’s $47.9 billion in operating revenues makes the company lucrative. Even so, the health care corporation is faced with the challenge of employee performance that seems to affect customer satisfaction. Management’s growing concern regarding the substandard level of employee performance has been the reason leadership initiated an action plan. With the help of research methods the intent is to determine the underlying problem thus improving employee performance. Kaiser Permanente will explore and design an employee satisfaction survey questionnaire to determine employees’ attitude toward the job. The uses of survey information to measure performance while “Understanding employee perceptions of certain leadership practices (customer orientation, quality focus, training, and involvement); along with adequate information/job knowledge, teamwork, satisfaction, and retention, are most often related to customer and business performance measures” (Kam & Brooks, 1998, p. 2). From the investigative measure using both the intranet and personal interview the research questions structured to help managerial decision-making in solving substandard employee performance that has been negatively affecting customer...

Words: 1870 - Pages: 8

Global Sourcing

... globalisation say it leads to exploitation of the worlds poor, and the environment, opponents claim that countries individual cultures are becoming overpowered by Americanisation. (O’Rourke, 2012, Lecture) According to John Carolan head buyer of the childrenswear at Sainsbury’s the decision the retailer has to make on where to source is based on price, availability and speed to market, fashion pitch and fabrication, the quality in which the supplier produces and ethical aspects of production. Carolan says that direct sourcing to a factory is the most profitable route, direct to factory requires a fuller visibility of ethical production concerns and requires decision and management of country of origin, however controls needed mean it is a tougher assignment to carry out rather then going to an importer to fulfil product range development. An organisation will need certain tools to effectively carry out direct to factory sourcing, an ‘on the ground’ sourcing organisation, design route, time for factory briefing and an effective design route. Sourcing direct to factory is the fastest way to source and only takes up to 4 weeks, also the control of production is more flexible to reaction to change. However this does higher labour costs, lower intake margins and lower profitability. (John Carolan. Lecturer. 2012) Global Sourcing Global sourcing is a procurement strategy aimed at exploiting global efficiencies in production, and a standard step in the global...

Words: 5637 - Pages: 23

Sourcing Style

...TYPE OF SUPPLY BASE When choosing what type of supply base to source from HL for COS must first decide whether they want to source from a narrow or wide supply base. Both have advantages and disadvantages, for example a wide supply base offers choice and flexibility as well as variety but a narrow supply base creates greater negotiating power as you build up a closer relationship with the supplier. As HL for COS is a carefully selected range of just 32 pieces a narrow supply base is more appropriate in this case as it offers the chance to have a greater involvement and control over the production of the garments. This would be a necessity when creating the HL for COS range. SOURCING STYLE The H&M group use Hubs when sourcing their garments this means that they have smaller offices regulating and controlling the factories they use during production of garments this helps with communication between the supplier and the company as well as regulating and monitoring the working conditions of the people employed by the supplier and ensuring that garment production runs smoothly. The choice of using a hub is one of many, including working directly with the supplier, sourcing from a wholesaler and using an agent to source product. Each method has its own pros and cons such as working directly with the supplier builds up relationships and allows tighter regulating of the process. However it will cost more to continually travel between the UK based HO and the country the...

Words: 563 - Pages: 3

Out Sourcing

...SPECIAL TOPICS IN IT-2 International Outsourcing of IT Chapter -1 Abstract: Researchers in information technology purpose several reasons why firms outsource their IS, including reducing costs, generating cash focusing on core competencies, and gaining access to technical expertise The authors survey few upper level IT professionals across the United States to assess what they are outsourcing now and what they will likely outsource over the next three years. The results show that the areas of applications development, applications maintenance, personal computer (PC) maintenance, and systems maintenance will experience tremendous growth, while data center operations, systems development and Telecommunications/LAN will experience very healthy growth. PC acquisition and project primarily management will experience a lesser expansion. This growth will be led by what are now large IT departments. This result have implications for IT professionals and firms across the US and around the world.ananlysis of change in financial characteristics reveals an increase in long-term debt and financial leverage and declining growth rates prior to the outsourcing event. We argue that firms enter into large-scale IS outsourcing agreements to reduce costs and to generate cash Introduction: Out sourcing is nothing but In today's world, outsourcing is defined as the strategic means through which companies make contract with outside vendors to perform various IT functions or services...

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5