Free Essay

Standardized Test, Assessments, and Portfolios for Reading

In: Other Topics

Submitted By betsykay
Words 1178
Pages 5
Running head: Standardized test, assessments, and portfolios for reading

Standardized test, assessments, and portfolios for reading Students are constantly being “assessed” by their teachers. We examine their behavior patterns, learning styles, reading abilities, and even their happiness. The purpose of assessments is to educate the teacher on what our students know and how we can better serve them in learning the curriculum and more. State tests are administered yearly for students, and teachers give formative and summative assessments frequently in the classroom. There are benefits and downfalls to each type of assessment. Afflerbach (2005) discusses that the results from standardized reading assessments are “at best an approximation of the students’ actual achievement level” (p.158). Standardized test tell us if our student is above, at, or below proficient. They do not tell us what areas the student does well at or what skills they are lacking in. According to the work of Buly and Valencia (2002), “Students scoring below proficient on state assessments are usually placed in supplemental or remedial reading classes, which often focus on phonemic awareness and decoding skills at any grade level (Buly & Valencia, 2002). After being put in these “special help” reading classes, the student then goes back into content area classes (English, Math, Science) which all have difficult text where the student struggles with comprehension. The problem we are then faced with is students who can read the words on the page, but cannot comprehend the text. The focus for these students should instead be on fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension strategies. To help these students, we need to let go of the “surface-level approach” and supply our students with more “just right” text (Dennis, 2009). He also states that “students will benefit from explicit comprehension instruction based on text at their independent reading level” (Dennis, 2009). Mandated tests give only a snapshot of a student’s ability, whereas use of a variety of assessments gives teachers a clearer and full portrait of the students reading skills (Rubin, 2011). In most classrooms we find teachers using several different formative and summative assessments that they control. “Teachers usually have little to no say in standardized test, but can feel empowered by their capacity to use alternative assessments” (Rubin, 2011, p. 608). One reason for assessment it to determine the level of text that will challenge a student and motivate them to read rather than causing frustration. There are many different types of assessments that the teacher can use in her classroom to mix up reading instruction and gage where student learning is occurring. Also, the “Data from a variety of assessments can help advise a teacher about the text difficulty that students can handle, in addition to pinpointing their specific strengths and weaknesses in reading” (Dennis, 2009). DIBELS is a reading assessment program that test for phonemic awareness, fluency, vocabulary, and decoding. It contains many subtest for different categories and students’ scores should be recorded to compare pre-test with post-test. DIBELS is used in thousands of schools across the nation to provide formative data to schools. Scheffel, Lefly, and Houser prove through their research that some negatives of the program are that it focuses more on decoding and speed and not as much on comprehension (which is the most important part of why we read), and it can be a problem for ELL students due to its focus on decoding ( Sheffel, Lefly, & Houser, 2012). They due conclude that DIBELS is a very effective in identifying at risk readers in need of extra support ( Sheffel, Lefly, & Houser, 2012). There are Informal Reading Inventories, which focus on evaluating comprehension through post reading questions and have been recommended for reporting and recording reading growth over the course of the school year (Paris, 2002). Running records, where the student and teacher can keep record of their personal reading and progress. The cloze test which is recommended for supporting struggling readers with comprehension and vocabulary (Rubin, 2011) requires students to fill in deletions of texts, making sense of a passage. There area also many computer testing programs that will give a student post questions over a text they have just completed to check for understanding. The best assessment plan is one that contains a variety of several assessment techniques, this will ensure that we are really finding our students skill levels and identifying their areas of weakness where they need extra support.
Portfolios are a type of alternative/authentic assessment in which a student's progress is measured over a period of time during a lesson or unit. The great thing about portfolio assessment is the way it is naturally incorporated into instruction: there is no time lost on assessment. “Assessment is a true learning experience, and not external to the learning process” (NCLRC, 2012). Another bonus of portfolios is the way it promotes parent involvement for the student’s success. They truly showcase the learning that the student has acquired and documents how they came to this learning. A portfolio can be just a folder of a student’s best work and evaluations of its strengths and weaknesses, or it can be a showcase of all the work that got them to a final product, for instance the drafts and peer edits. A great idea for using a portfolio project in a language arts class is throughout the reading of a story. It will serve as the formative assessments throughout the text as well as a summative project after finishing the reading. It could contain things such as predictions, favorite character, favorite part, main character, plot of the beginning, middle, problem/solution, end, connections of story to self and world, and at the end a book review or letter to a character. Creating a folder or foldout with this information helps the student really get involved in the readings, reflect, and make connections to their own lives. Assessment is an important part of a teachers job, it informs the teacher of the needs of her students, and creates a way of communication between teacher, student, and parents. Ideally, many forms of assessment should be used to supplement the state mandated test that will be administered.

Afflerbach, P. (2005). National reading conference policy brief: High Stakes testing and reading assessment. Journal of Literacy Research, 37(2), 151-162.
Buly, M.R., & Valencia, S.W. (2002). Below the Bar: Profiles of students who fail state reading assessments. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 24(3). 219-239.
Dennis, D.V. (2009). “I’m not stupid”: How assessment drives appropriate reading instruction.
Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy, 53(4), 283-290.
Paris, S.G. (2002). Measuring children’s reading development using leveled texts. The Reading
Teacher, 56(2), 168-170.
Rubin, J. (2011). Organizing and Evaluating Results from Multiple Reading Assessments. The
Reading Teacher, 64(8), 606-611.
Scheffel, D., Lefly, D., & Houser, J. (2012). The Predictive Utility of DIBELS Reading
Assessment for Reading Comprehension among Third Grade English Language Learners & English Speaking Children. Reading Improvement, 49 (3), 75-92.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Assessing Literacy Development

...The Purposes and Methods of Classroom-Based Literacy Assessment Grand Canyon University: RDG 512 June 3, 2014 Assessing Literacy Development The purpose of the information provided is to adequately use literacy assessments and understand their purpose as well as how they benefit students and help guide teachers’ instruction. I. Classroom Assessment A. Planning for Assessment Considerations for each student include: 1. Background knowledge (What do students know about this concept) 2. Vocabulary 3. Comprehension (How well are students understanding the concept) 4. Completion of work 5. Work habits 6. Work well with classmates 7. Ability to apply material learned (Tompkins, 2000) B. Monitoring Students’ Progress There are several ways teachers can keep track of student achievement: 1. Observations—Focus on literacy, not behavior 2. Anecdotal notes—quickly jotted notes 3. Conferences: a) On-the-spot: Brief, approximately 1 minute, at student’s desk b) Planning: Scheduled with student ahead of time to discuss concepts, vocabulary, or writing c) Revising: Discuss rough draft and make suggestions to revise d) Book Discussion: Discussion of currently read book e) Editing: Correct mechanical errors in writing f) Evaluation: Discuss growth, reflect on goals met 4. Checklists-Criteria students are expected to meet (students know criteria before completing assignment) C.......

Words: 1202 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Standardized Testing Argument

...Many of us have dreaded standardized testing. I know I have, as I was always trying to prepare myself whether it was taking classes offered after class, or just putting that extra time in at home. Standardized testing shouldn't be used to measure a students ability and knowledge in school. "The Council of Chief State School Officers and the country's largest school districts have spoken out in favor of reducing the number of standardized tests students take. The national teachers unions and other traditionally Democratic groups are on board with the idea too"(Kamenetz). Students aren't provided the feedback they'd like after taking a standardized test. One thing a student always looks forward to after taking a test is see their score along...

Words: 663 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Reading Habit in Children

...Current Research IN READING / LANGUAGE ARTS Understanding Assessment: Putting Together the Puzzle SHEILA W. VALENCIA UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON, SEATTLE “No one test or assessment should be asked to serve all the assessment purposes. We need, at this point, a system made up of articulated components, glued together by their adherence to content standards and serving explicit purposes for assessment.” —National Council for Education Standards and Testing, 1992 discussions, and more. Now, 10 years later, we are hearing the same reminder (Brennan, Kim, WenzGross, Siperstein, 2001; Herman, 2001; International Reading Association, 1999). In fact, in July 2001 members of the National Education Association, the nation’s largest teacher’s union, endorsed a policy calling for a combination of standardized tests and other assessment tools such as teacher designed assessments when making important educational decisions (Blair & Archer, 2001). Assessment has always been a part of the educational landscape. However, because assessment can serve so many different purposes and can come in so many different forms, it has been confusing and, sometimes, it has been the subject of contentious debate. Unfortunately, as a result, many of us have come to view assessment as a necessary evil, a requirement rather than a helpful part of instruction. But assessment IS a critical part of instruction and it CAN be useful if we understand the pieces of the puzzle. As far back as 1992, when...

Words: 6073 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Arguments Against Standardized Testing

...Standardized Testing: Is it hurting or helping today’s students Since the beginning of the modern education system, children have been tested to determine how well they knew the material that was being taught. Testing has always been the fail-proof way to see how the teaching strategy was working. Recently, standardized testing has been put into place as a way for federal government to see how the schools are performing. There has been a lot of controversy on this topic, whether or not standardized testing is correct way to determine how a school is performing. This testing is called high-stakes testing; both educators and parents are fed up with this system. High-stakes testing should be removed from the schools systems. In 2001, the Bush...

Words: 839 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Summative and Formative Assessments

...Assessment is defined as "The use of a variety of procedures to collect information about learning and instruction." (Johnson, 2013) It is a crucial part of instruction. In asking students to demonstrate what they have learned we are then able to evaluate if the educational goals and standards are being met. It can affect decisions about grades, instructional needs, curriculum, placement, advancement and in some cases even funding. It inspires three important questions. "Are we teaching what we think we are teaching?" "Are students learning what they are supposed to be learning?" "Is there a better way to teach the subject, thereby promoting better learning?" (Edutopia, n.d.) There are two basic assessment types, summative and formative. Each has a distinct purpose and answers certain questions about student learning. We will discuss these later in this treatise. It is the teachers' responsibility to interpret these assessments and utilize the data for meeting student need, tailoring the content of curriculum and lessons, and, of course, assessing student progress. Teachers must take an active responsibility for achieving a balance between assessments and content. Both summative and formative assessments contribute to the measurement of broader progress on assessment goals. Formative assessment is commonly known as "assessment for learning". It focuses on monitoring student response to and progress in instruction as well providing information to teachers about......

Words: 1391 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay


...Assessment is a valuable tool to measure students learning and achievement. It is an essential element for teacher to reflect on what and how they teach. To assess students is to collect evidence of their learning. Teachers use the information to modify their lesson plans and adjust their instructional methods; students need feedback on their performance to concentrate on their vulnerable areas. Assessment is necessary for parents to reinforce their children strength and assist them where extra attention is required. The data collected will inform school administration the parts of improvement that both teachers and students needed and for the state and federal levels, as is important to determine if additional funding is necessary to assist students in their learning and achievement. To provide the suitable service and achieve optimal result, teachers and administrators must identify their ELL students and place them in classroom that best fit with their abilities. In an interview conducted with Miss Fabiaschi, an academic dean at a charter school in my district, she said that at her school parents are providing information on home language on the application. Then they use the CELDT (California English Language Development Test) to determine which level of English proficiency for their students. She added, there are two types of ELLs, the new enrollments, which are kindergartens who enroll in school for the first time or students of higher grade levels who transferred......

Words: 1424 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The Cons of Standardized Testing

...The Cons of Standardized Testing In past decades, tests were given to students to decide their placement in classes or to determine which students needed to be placed in resources class. Today, standardized tests are used for arbitrating the success or failure of students, teachers, and schools. “Despite their biases, inaccuracies, limited ability to measure achievement or ability, and other flaws, schools use standardized tests to determine if children are ready for school, track them into instructional groups; diagnose for learning disability, retardation and other handicaps; and decide whether to promote, retain in grade, or graduate many students. Schools also use tests to guide and control curriculum content and teaching methods” (Fair Test, 2007). On top of that, should one test at the end of a school year determine if a teacher was successful? No! A teacher’s success should be determined on the children’s learning throughout an entire school year based on many different assessments; this should be the same for children’s success. Students and teachers need to be held accountable for their success but not by administrating a standardized test. Standardized testing has become a political issue. When schools are tested they are compared to other schools in there state and nationally which permits politicians to display their concerns about certain school systems. You see, in the political world politician’s show their concern with our schools by attaching......

Words: 1185 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Geography and the Diffusion of Human Society

...Assessment in No Child Left Behind The Controversy over Standardized Testing and it’s Effects on Young Children Cynthia M. Kirchner Western Governors University Sherry Lawler HJT1 Task 1 #54425 Nature of the Controversy: No Child Left Behind (NCLB), Accountability and Standardized/High-Stakes Testing No Child Left Behind (NCLB): is the newest iteration of a decades-old education law, the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA). The original law provided funding to school districts to help low-income students. Today, NCLB holds Title I schools that receive this federal money accountable by requiring them to meet proficiency targets on annual assessments. Standardized or High-Stakes Testing: These are the tests that are administered by the individual states and consist of multiple choice and true/false questions. The tests are designed to evaluate students in the subject areas of mathematics and reading. These tests have been given to students in grades three through eight. The goal of the No Child Left Behind Act is that students will receive 100% proficiency level on these tests by 2014 Accountability: Accountability is the concept that each state set standards for the type and amount of information students know and learn. Children are tested yearly and the scores are reported to the government. Schools that need improvement are identified and they work over the next school year to raise the students’ test scores (Robertson, 2009) Nature of the......

Words: 1507 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Student Assessment Methods

...abilities of reading, writing, and arithmetic, yet we are finding that 40 percent of students entering college do not have these basic skills at the college level. We also assumed that if a student obtained a Bachelor’s degree, they were qualified for entry level work. Yet surveyed employers are stating that “that they are not pleased with the level of critical thinking, analytic reasoning, and writing skills recent graduates possess”. What is happening in our classrooms that are hindering students from being successful beyond their school years? This paper will discuss two established methods of assessing student learning, CCSS and PARCC, their strengths and weaknesses as well as discuss issues involving the assessment of student learning. Standardized Tests Standardized testing was established under the premise that it would improve teaching practices and methods, therefore improving schools. In essence it is deemed as the “report card for the community” and the efficiency of our schools performance. Besides state specific standardized test, other national standardized tests include: * Secondary School Admission Test (SSAT)- administered to students applying to private secondary schools and some public secondary schools * Preliminary SAT/National Merit Scholarship Qualifying Test (PSAT/NMSQT)- voluntary test given to secondary school students in year 10 or 11 to assist them in preparing for the SAT and to qualify for national merit scholarships *......

Words: 879 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Standardized Teindergarten

...Standardized Testing Should Not Take Place in Kindergarten Kourtney C. Robles-Stewart Rasmussen College English Composition G124/ENC1101 Section 04 Teresa Kelly March 4, 2016 Abstract Standardized testing in kindergarten has become a very controversial topic across the nation. While there may be advantages of implementing standardized tests in schools, the disadvantages seem to be never-ending. The following paper will analyze the effects standardized testing can have on children of all ages with an emphasis on kindergarteners. It will look into the factors that impact test scores and how the tests compare to normal classroom activities and behaviors. A brief look into the role the United States government has played in standardized testing across the nation will also be covered. Standardized Testing Should Not Take Place in Kindergarten It’s a normal Monday morning when a mother is getting her, normally, very eager five-year-old ready for school. Her daughter has never missed a day and has always been overly-excited to get back to class after the weekend off, however, today is not the same. The little girl who once loved going to school to see her teacher and friends, now wants nothing to do with it, she simply doesn’t want to go. Her reasoning, “it’s not fun”. Unfortunately, this scenario is becoming more common across the nation as curriculum modifications are being made by educators to prepare young students for standardized tests. Since "No Child Left......

Words: 1963 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...Cost Planning: There are various types of costs involved in a project fixed, variable, direct, indirect, and sunk. Fixed costs do not change. Whereas, variable costs fluctuate throughout the life of the project. Direct costs are those that come directly out of the budget and are often seen as outsourcing or contracting expenses. Indirect costs are often shared expenses across various projects. Sunk costs are costs that bring no value to the project, often a result of a mistake or a result of something going wrong in a project. Due to lengthy projects, I have never personally encountered the cost involved, but I am interested in if anyone has personally dealt with sunk costs and how this may have affected the overall budget or outcome of the project. Earned Value Analysis: I also found when researching the history of EVM that there are 32 criteria that are used to determine an organizatin performance with Earned Value Management Systems. There are 5 categories with a total of 32 criteria. It's an interesting read because so far there is a relationship to the chapters we have read so far. Category 1: Organization ( A lot around Work Breakdown Structure and organization of costs) Category 2: Planning and Budgeting (Scheduling, sequencing, time phase planning for the ability to measure costs against budget, budget against work packages, reserves and undistributed budget.) Category 3: Accounting Considerations (Work Breakdown Structure, Direct costs, indirect costs...

Words: 1925 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Leaders Are Born Not Made

...CLASSROOM ASSESSMENT CHAPTER 10 l Classroom Assessment LE ARNI NG OUTCOMES After studying this chapter, you should be able to: 1. Define assessment; 2. Explain the basic concepts in assessment; 3. Explain how to plan for assessment; 4. Describe types of assessment in the classroom; 5. Explain what is teacher-made tests; 6. Describe what is standardized tests; and 7. Explain what is authentic assessment. 254 CHAPTER 10 CHAPTER 10 l CLASSROOM ASSESSMENT INTRODUCTION One of the most basic and difficult task that teachers face in their work is the process of assessment. Classroom assessment includes all the process involved in making decisions about students learning progress. It includes the observation of students’ written work, their answers to questions in class, and performance on teacher-made and standardized tests. According to (Koyalik, 2002 as cited in Eggen & Kauchak, 2004): i. It facilitates teachers in decision making about learning progress through systematic information gathering. Besides that, assessment also accomplishes two other important goals; increasing learning and increasing motivation. The relationship between learning and assessment is very strong. Students learn more in classes where assessment is an integral part of instruction than in those where it isn’t. Brief assessment that provides frequent feedback about learning progress is more effective than long, infrequent ones, like once-a-term......

Words: 7585 - Pages: 31

Premium Essay

Reading Report on Intelligent Intelligence Testing

...Reading Report #2 Intelligent Intelligence Testing By Etienne Benson Monitor staff Having read the above named article, I found three points that are worthy of emphasizing. These are as follows: 1. Intelligence tests unfairly categorize students by race, gender, class and culture. 2. Propagates the idea that people are born with an unchangeable endowment of intellectual potential that determines their success in life. 3. Practitioners want tests that can help them design interventions that will actually improve students’ learning. My Reaction As I read this article, my eyes were focused on the “one size fit all” mentality that exists in most of our Jamaican classrooms. The reality is that many of our students are left behind due to the advent of standardized intelligence testing which focuses on the product instead of the process. I believe standardized intelligence testing has its part to play, but in a holistic sense, it is ineffective and should be removed from the education system. One can reflect on the many students who are said to “fail or underperform” in the Grade Six Achievement Test (GSAT) each year to clearly understand that this form of testing must give way to something that is more holistic and student friendly, which focuses on the many steps the student had to take to reach where he is at. Students learn differently and therefore perform at various levels. If a student who has a learning difficulty sits a standardized intelligence test such...

Words: 760 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Nt1310 Unit 4 Study Guide

...Create 4 CRITICAL questions directed at the reading. 1. Does assessment determine curriculum? Or does curriculum determine assessment? I have been taught both of these ideas, it seems as if authentic assessments drive curriculum. But which is correct? 2. Should authentic assessments require a rubric to assess? Some of the assessments types such as performance-based assessments or play-based assessments are very open-ended and can easily become invalid when the skills needed for those assessments do not reflect the targeted skills. 3. Are the authentic assessments types like interview-based, performance based, and portfolios meant to be graded? Or is their only purpose to gather information on students? 4. If we use authentic assessments in our classroom, how will we...

Words: 569 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Philosophy of Education

...Philosophy of Education Ruth Taylor University of Mary Washington, School of Education Introduction My thoughts and beliefs of the purpose of education is where my philosophy of education begins. I believe that the purpose of education is to ensure that all students, regardless of their abilities, are able to gain the knowledge necessary to be productive members of society. Although I believe that higher education is extremely important, there are a great deal of students that may never be able to attend any type of higher education institution. For these students, it is imperative that we as educators teach them the basic skills in order for them to be as independent as possible after their 13 years of formal education. As educators, I believe that most of us come into the profession because we want to make a difference in the lives of young people. Our students are the future of our world. They are the generation that will make a difference. We teach so that our students will be able to reach their highest possible potential in life. Since my primary focus is in the field of special education, I feel that I have a slightly different view on the purpose of education than do my regular education counterparts. My goal is to ensure that my students will have the skills needed to accomplish all of their dreams and goals, regardless of their academic abilities. We as a society learn so that we can be productive members of society and live within the societal......

Words: 1700 - Pages: 7