Free Essay

Stories and Consequences of War

In: English and Literature

Submitted By yponceano02
Words 631
Pages 3
It is senior year in high school and everyone starts to wonder what they will do as soon as they graduate. Some people are thinking of going away to college, others are planning on taking a break before doing anything with their life, but most of the people are thinking of joining the army. Some of them do not know what a war really is or which consequences you may face when joining the army. There are two stories that help to explain what exactly you do in the army and the effects it has on you. One of the stories is "Soldier's Home" by Ernest Hemingway and the other one is "How to Tell a True War Story" by Tim O'Brien. Both stories have similarities and differences. They are told from different points of view and different situations.
“Soldier’s Home” is mainly about a boy named Krebs. Krebs is a boy who enlisted in the Marines in 1917 and did not went back home until summer 1919. I think that Krebs is the way he is because he went away to war without being fully mature. He ended up growing up while in the war, away from his family and everyone he loved. He came home from war so much later because he did not want to face the changes that have happened in his town. I think he was scare to come home because war also changed his way of thinking. Krebs does not get involved with women once he's home because he does not want to work to get a girl. He thinks that American girls are too complicated and that he needs to go through many things to get one of them. He got used to the way European women were because without you talking to them, they would become your friend. Now, thanks to his mother's advice, he is thinking of becoming successful in live. Things like getting a job are rounding his mind.
“How to Tell a True War Story” is about O’Brien’s own experience as a soldier and a story his friend told him. The story is mainly about things that happened in the war. In the end, no one knows if it's true or not because they are inexplicable things that you would not think that would ever happen in real life. Very often it reaffirms that it is a true story, however, it also says that you would never know if the story is true or not.
I loved O'Brien's style because the way the story is told and retold helped me comprehend the story much better. Both authors use the correct language to express the right feelings concerning the story. The language is also appropriate to the times. It makes me think of the story as it was back in those days. However, the messages about the war they try to give the reader are very different from each other. O'Brien's message is that you can make friends in the war to help you get over the pain and live every day thinking about those people who brighten your day every single day. Hemingway's message is that war changes everyone's perspective about life and after the war you are not the same person anymore.
In conclusion, both stories had their own meaning and point of view even though they talked basically about the same subject. The war has its own significance to everyone. No one has the same perspective of war as you. In these stories, the authors knew how to explain their point of view and their experience. I fully understood them. War changes everyone’s life. Some changes are good and others not so good, but at the end it is a new experience and a new life lesson.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Guenica

...Neil.L Guernica American has been through many wars throughout the years. You can hear and learn about wars through textbooks, libraries, classrooms, and websites; but what about pictures and the art museums. A picture is worth a thousand words, and that is exactly what Pablo Picasso did with his painting Guernica. Guernica is a painting by famous Spanish artist Pablo Picasso. It was painted as a reaction to the aerial bombing of Guernica, Spain by German and Italian forces during the Spanish Civil War in 1937. The Spanish Republic, government of Spain, appointed Picasso to paint a large mural about the bombing to display at the 1937 World’s Fair in Paris. Guernica show the anguish, horror and pain inflicted on humanity and the innocent. It shows the destructions of war and the awareness for others to remember and never forget. Guernica is a powerful painting, considered a “Masterpiece” by Pablo Picasso and has become an anti-war icon. Guernica became a very powerful art work for many reasons but, most importantly for its usage of colors and of imagery depicting the emotions the characters are showing in the painting. Guernica consists of shades of blacks, grays and whites, representing sadness, and dark emotions for the characters and the event of the bombing. It shows the pains of the innocent, a woman wailing over a dead child in her hands, a horse ripped open, tragic events with images of soldier, flames painted to signify the town on fire and......

Words: 1802 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Setting

...Setting in Soilder’s Home In the story ‘Soldier’s Home’ by Ernest Hemingway, the setting throughout the story helps us better understand the main character and why he acts the way he does. In stories the setting helps us build a frame around the characters about the environment they live in and what they go through in their life. “In most stories they also serve as more than backgrounds and furnishings. If we are sensitive to the contexts provided by the setting, we are better able to understand the behavior of the characters and the significance of their actions (Meyer131).” In this story, the author gives us glimpses of Harold, the main character, and what he is going through in his life once he returns home from war. After the earlier wars, many soldiers would return home to no good welcomes, and people would scold them for going and fighting for their country. Many of the soldiers had very hard times getting back to reality when they came back. They had hard times getting work and being able to do things normally because of the horror they faced at war. In this story, the opening scene talks of Harold, also referred to as ‘Krebs’, going to war after being a student at a Methodist college in Kansas. It talks about a picture of him in a fraternity, with all his fraternity brothers being the same height and wearing the same kind of collared shirt. Opening the story in this setting tells us that before the war, Krebs was just a normal college student who had many......

Words: 1488 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Short Text Essay

...idea that was really worth learning about in the short stories, ‘On the Sidewalk Bleeding’ by Evan Hunter and ‘The Sniper’ by Liam O’Flaherty, was about making choices and having to face the consequences for them. This idea was worth learning about as we face the consequences we realize if the choice we made was good or bad and it helps us to learn how to think before we act. The idea of choices in ‘On the Sidewalk Bleeding’ is shown first by Andy’s choice of joining a gang. ‘That was when he’d first joined the Royals… He was a Royal. There had been meaning to the title.’ He joined because he thought he would find an identity, he would be known as somebody – a Royal. But he realizes too late that it was that name that killed him. Andy wonders if the Guardian had only stabbed the jacket, not him as an individual. ‘Had they known that he was Andy or had they dimply known he was a Royal wearing a purple silk jacket?’ The young couple, Freddie and Angela, who came by Andy, had to choose between helping Andy and not being found out by the Guardians. ‘We help him, and the Guardians will be down on our necks.’ In the end Freddie gets overcome by fear, and doesn’t want to face the consequences of getting mixed up in gang fights, so he leaves. Andy was similar to teenagers today in wanting to be part of the biggest, most popular groups. This teaches me that it is not always the best choice and could end in very serious consequences. On the other hand, Freddie thought before he acted......

Words: 661 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Poem Reaction

...the person’s feelings or action, to tell a person how one may feel about something or someone. In both stories the author's style of writing creates a tone, that gives the reader insight to the characters feelings. Which makes the characters act and say what's really on their minds. They show this by explaining why they act the way that they do throughout the stories. The character's feelings are shown within their minds, it shows how they are changing throughout the story. In “The Yellow Wall-Paper” by Charlotte Perkins Stetson, the main characters’ words and actions help the reader understand the plot and theme clearly. The main character of this story has a journal in which she records how she is feeling during her “sickness.”One can conclude from her journal especially as one reads further and further into the story, that she is going out of her mind, from this yellow wallpaper.In the story it states,“The color is repellent, almost revolting; a smouldering unclean yellow, strangely faded by the slow-turning sunlight... I’m really getting fond of the big room, all but that horrid paper”(649). The main character is giving us insight to the fact that she is becoming angry with this yellow wallpaper that is haunting her in her room. It gets to point where she starts seeing shadows and figures in the wallpaper staring at her through the night. Another example from the story, “ I tried to lift and push it until I was lame and then I got so angry I bit off a little piece at......

Words: 1526 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Lost One

...Gray-Hernandez 1302.005 Prof C J Arevalo 17 April 2013 Research Essay The Lost One “Soldier’s Home” by Ernest Hemingway is a story of a young man, Harold Krebs, who returns home in the summer of 1919 after fighting in Germany during World War I. After being away at war for two years, Krebs returns to his hometown in Oklahoma but does not get the welcome that he was expecting. As he attempts to readjust to society he embellishes his war stories in an attempt to make them more interesting, but grows tired and nauseated by them instead. At home things are not as they had been; his sisters see him as a hero and his parents see him as a man that needs to move on with his life yet they still treat him like a child. Although Krebs has been to war and has aged he does not share his family’s outlook regarding himself; instead he feels lost and cold, detached from the life he once knew. Hemingway illustrates how a soldier returning from war returns to a life and a family they no longer know and to a world they no longer recognize. Hemingway expresses the difficulties of adapting back into civilian life after being away at war and the effects on a soldier as well as a soldiers family. When a soldier returns home, the welcome they receive often helps them to reconnect to the civilian world. The townspeople had previously greeted soldiers upon returning from the war, but when Harold Krebs arrives he quickly realizes that the “greeting of heroes was over” (Hemingway 253). He......

Words: 783 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Wood Grouse on a High Promontory Overlooking Canada

...Analysis and interpretation - Wood Grouse on a High Promontory Overlooking Canada The text “Wood Grouse on a High Promontory Overlooking Canada”, 1996, is an American short story. In the short story we hear about the relationship between two brothers, the brother Bud and the older military brother Gary. The theme in this short story is brotherhood. These two brothers reconnect after spending time apart, and they grow to appreciate each other. Bud is a boy who is 15 years old. Bud is a bit naive. We can see that when he throws the rock at a bird. Gary asks him why and he replies, “I didn’t mean to hit one, Gary” p. 4 l. 46. This shows that he is a bit naive, and he is not thinking about the consequences of his actions. Another example is when he asks, “I was young and I didn’t know any better. So instead I asked him about the thing on my mind: “Did you kill anyone in Vietnam?” p. 4 l. 70-71 This also shows that Bud is naive when he asked without thinking about Gary’s feelings. After Bud asked this question he could see that it was hard for Gary to talk about and he therefore felt ashamed “And then I couldn’t fall asleep that night; I felt ashamed of myself.” p. 3 l.92. You can say that he acts, and then thinks about the consequences later. Gary is an adult who have been in war in Vietnam. Gary keeps on mentioning the beautiful things he is seeing around him, which is a big contrast from what he came from down there. “They’re beautiful” Gary said......

Words: 516 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Rhetorical Analysis Essay

...Brianna Harden English 214.05 Baldwin April 12th, 2013 Emotional Consequences Faced By Veterans and Their Families Many books, articles, or even essays that are read throughout one’s life, can at times be slightly unclear about what precisely the main idea is or what the authors true purpose is for writing that text. Most people do not understand that every writer uses rhetorical strategies throughout their writing to make their text clear and understandable for the reader. These rhetorical strategies are particularly important because they help with the clarity of complex ideas and assist the writer in getting their point across. In doing so, writers are able to make their text more effective for a wider range of people to read. In the article “Iraq, Afghanistan War Veterans Struggle With Combat Trauma,” by David Wood, and in the short story, “Gold Star,” by Siobhan Fallon, the authors use numerous amounts of rhetorical tools to help guide the reader through the text. While “Gold Star” is a short story about a wife who has lost her husband due to the war and “Iraq, Afghanistan War Veterans Struggle With Combat Trauma,” is an informative newspaper article about how the war can have severe consequences on not only the soldiers themselves but their loved ones back at home too, both text use emotive appeals that aim to inform the general public of the various emotional and psychological tolls faced by veterans and their families today. Furthermore, throughout both......

Words: 2264 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Guests or Enemies

...addition, personal background also helps authors to grasp themes or prospects better so that their stories are more plausible and readable even though they are fictional. Frank O'Connor is a writer who did this. “Guests of the Nation” is definitely a story based on his own experience. Frank O'Connor puts his personal thoughts and experiences to arrange the characters in order to talks about the relationship between personal duty and humanity during the war, which also implies the relationship between political conflicts and the hope of peaceful life for humans. Though out history, at the beginning Ireland was a British colony, the economic depressed and had a time of hardship. By 1900, the Irish Civil War loomed. In the summer of 1913, Dublin workers went on strike for 5 months, indicating that the proletariat had become the Irish independent political force. During World War I in 1914, the Irish national fighting moved to further. Easter Rising broke out in April 1916. In 1919, the Sinn Fein refused to attend the British Parliament, but held their own in the Dublin parliament and the creation of army. In 1921, the Irish Civil War occurred; the Irish people started fighting for national independence, autonomy for land rights, and the struggle to recover. The Republic of Ireland was established (Lambert). O'Connor's background change strongly related to the history of the Irish Civil War. He experienced a difficult childhood. On the main page of New World Encyclopedia......

Words: 1229 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Sniper Interpretation

...Name: Tram Dang Level: 112 Civil War: Brother vs. Brother How do people feel when they fight with their brothers or their family members? How do they feel when they hurt or lose any part of their body? Do they feel good? Those are exactly the things that the sniper in Liam O’Flaherty’s story has to suffer. Liam O’Flaherty was a great Irish novelist and short story writer. In his story “The Sniper”, which is about the civil war between Republican and Free Starters in Ireland, the main character has to shoot and gets shot by another sniper who is actually his own brother. By telling this story, O’Flaherty wants to show everybody the huge destruction of wars, especially civil wars. The first part of war destruction is the human mental state. In the war, human feelings are not stable. They change into different moods every second from happy to sad, from eager to angry, from callous to sensitive. The obvious reason for this is killing or being killed, shooting or getting shot. The sniper doesn’t have any choice, but to fight for his life. “[H]is eyes had the cold gleam of the fanatic. They were deep and thoughtful, the eyes of a man who is used to looking at death” (par.2). Although he is described as an experienced killer, which means that he has observed death many times before, his mental state still changes differently and unpredictably after killing his enemy. “The lust of battle died in him. He became bitten by remorse. The sweat stood out in beads on his forehead......

Words: 813 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Things They Carried

...that were automatically bumped up into manhood. The author treats the inner conflict that each soldier had to bear during the Vietnam War while fighting for their country. Witnessing horrific scenes of war and the emotional and physical burdens that each of them carried, O’Brien unfolds how these men had no choice but to fulfill their patriotic duty. As the leader of the platoon, First Lieutenant Jimmy Cross goes through an inner conflict between love and duty, carrying his orders in his mind and Martha in his heart. But how far can war or following orders, impair the human side of compassion and love? Although, soldiers become men at war, O’Brien focuses in a story where war makes men emotionally handicap, leaving mental scars that may never heal. The story is told by a third person’s point of view, however, O’Brien includes a touch of his personal experiences during the war where he spent a year in Vietnam (Hicks). As Josiah Bunting said, “The things he carried into war are very different from what he carried away from it” (Bunting) expressing O’Brien’s experience at war and how his experience as a soldier would convince readers to believe that the different traumatic moments really happened. Although his personal experiences are counted as relevant, some critics consider his storytelling to be “nothing new about trying to tell war stories- that the “truths” they contain “are contradictory”, elusive and this indeterminate”. Kaplan goes on saying that “representation......

Words: 1662 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Comparison "Soldier's Home" and "Speaking of Courage"

..."Speaking Of Courage" To be engaged in war is to be engaged in an armed conflict. Death is an all too ordinary product of war. It is an unsolicited reward for many soldiers that are fighting for their country’s own fictitious freedom. For some of these men, the battlefield is a glimpse into hell, and for others, it is a means to heaven. Many people worry about what happens during war and what will become of their loved ones while they’re fighting, but few realize what happens to those soldiers once they come home. The short stories "Soldier's Home” by Ernest Hemingway and "Speaking of Courage” by Tim O'Brien explore the thematic after effects of war and how it impacts a young person's life. Young people who go to war come back dramatically changed, and as a result, it is challenging for them to return to their homes. Hemingway’s character, Krebs, and O'Brien’s character, Berlin, similarly demonstrate the consequences of war on the lives of these young returning soldiers. Although they came from historically different wars, Krebs, from World War I, and Berlin, from Vietnam, both experience disillusionment. With regards to the stories’ tones, one can infer that both Berlin and Krebs are men who’ve seen their ideas of valor disappointed. Many join the war in the hopes of becoming somehow closer to their country or their ideals of masculinity, only to see these ideals crushed by war’s harsh reality. These boys both hold stories from their respective wars, and they’re sure that......

Words: 1104 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Women in War

...During the American civil war lots of men where forced into the battlefield. They had to obey orders. Several men very killed, other turned into cold-blooded murders. Men who used to be good working fathers, where thrown into the war. ”The thing you want” is a short story written by Jack Trammell. The short story deals with the topics; war, desire, madness and power. It pictures a man after the war and the consequences of his participation in the American civil war. The short story is told though a third person narrator and he is using past tense. “At that moment someone else entered the room. Cabe had the sixth sense common to survivors of war…” At some points in the text the third-person narrator seems omniscient, because we have access to the characters feelings and mind. “They assumed it was abandoned…” “No one asked any questions. Something inside of him was dead, though, and at the same time, a tiny spark was flickering.” There is used direct speech in the story “,,Looking for food, sir” ,, You won’t find it in her dress, Private”” This narrative mode gives a “filmic-twist” to the story, because we often connect direct speech with manuscripts. The short story starts in medias res and takes place in the real world, in continuation of the Great War (WW1). It elapses chronological and lasts no longer than 1 hour in the “great brick house”. The language is formal and very describing. “A withered, languorous old woman stared at them blankly.” The sentences are......

Words: 473 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Why War Is Bad?

...from the 21st century, my first and quick answer will be war Wars have been going on for centuries. War unavoidably.Brings death, destruction and suffering, which both ruin lives and nations. The most unjustifiable consequence of war is the loss of innocent civilians' lives. Civilians, who could have lived to make a huge impact on the world, pose no direct threat to the 'enemy' and might not even share the motives of the side they have been presumed to support. War eradicates hopes and dreams of millions, destroys homelands, frightens and oppresses people. Nothing that, in the end, brings more bad than it does good can be justified. Any kind of war is unjustifiable because it involves only killing. And what kind of victory does one get? Victory over millions of dead human flesh.Victory over the broken hearts of the family and relatives. We must not forget the horrors of the two world wars. In these wars, there was mass-killing and destruction of property. Thousands were made widows and orphans. War brings hatred and spreads falsehood. People become selfish and brutal. Finally I believe Wars are not the solution of the problems. Instead they generate problems and create hatred among nations. War can decide one issue but gives birth too many. Hiroshima and Nagasaki are the greatest horrible faces of the consequence of wars. Even after 60 years people are suffering from the miseries of war. Whatever be the cause of war, it always results in destruction of life and property at...

Words: 1148 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Poerty

...How to the War Story Told I decided to choose the “A Soldiers Home” by Ernest Hemingway and “How to tell a War story” by Tim Obrien. I will explain each story and how the story are very similar in theme. “How to Tell a True War Story” examines the complex relationship between the war experience and storytelling. It is told half from O’Brien’s role as a soldier, as a reprise of several old Vietnam stories, and half from his role as a storyteller, as a discourse on the art of storytelling. In Tim O'Brien's short story, "How to Tell a True War Story", Rat Kiley's friend is killed. He writes to his friend's sister and when no response is given, he becomes frustrated. Due to this frustration he calls her a "dumb cooze." Following this O'Brien argues that this is a true war story because it is not moral, never to believe a war story if it seems moral. Next the story jumps to a forest where men need to be quiet for weeks. After a period of time goes by they are no longer sane. They begin to hear noises that scare them, and when they cannot take the silence and the creepiness of the forest they return to camp. When question about their return, the men do not respond, their story is in their eyes and that is enough for anyone who knows that a true war story "never seems to end," it is continuous even after it is done being told. A true war story is also never moral and does not generalize. The truth is so hard to reach. A person can go looking for the moral of the story, but......

Words: 867 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

I Spy Analysis

...before (page 38 line 13). In 1930 smoking cigarettes was a standard practice to do. Therefore, he take the matter into his own hands and steal a cigarette from his father’s Tobacco shop, even though he knows it is wrong and illegal (page 40 line 3-5). Charlie knows it is illegal, but he think it is more important to get the cigarette than the consequences of being caught with his hands in the cookie jar (page 40 line 3-5). The other protagonist in the story is Charlie’s father, Mr. Stowe. Charlie does not really like his dad, he describes him as an “unreal wraith” (page 38 line 18). As the story continues, we find out that Mr. Stowe has been taking to charge for being a German spy. The two men who escorts Mr. Stowe have identical suits, bowlers, mackintoshes that were how the Bobbies were dressed. The Bobbies probably come from the British MI-5. Mr. Stowe has just come to his house to get his jacket before he probably will go to trial and in worst-case execution. We get a little clue about Mr. Stowe being a German spy, because he is a tobacconist and tobacco comes from Turkey, which were a German Ally through the First World War. He probably became spy because he could have connections with Turkey through the tobacco shop. Otherwise, he started a tobacco shop, because he was a spy, and a shop is a great gathering place where you can easily pass information back and forth. About where the novel was reading (1930), Great Britain had lost...

Words: 791 - Pages: 4