Free Essay

Strange Case and the Murders

In: English and Literature

Submitted By despoticwolf
Words 2041
Pages 9
Strange Case and The Murders:
Dividing Human Minds
Alexis Osorio
DeVry University

There can be no up without down, no dark without bright, and no wrong without right; the same idea can be applied to the human mind. There is some sort of duality in the human mind and has been a recurring theme of discussion in many stories. Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (Strange Case) (Stevenson, 1886) brings the topic of human duality to the forefront by observing it from a third person point of view. Edgar Allan Poe brings up human duality too from a first person point of view in his work The Murders in the Rue Morgue (The Murders)(1841). Strange Case is about an internal struggle that is externalized, while The Murders shows no struggle between the characters. The former about the concept of self-control, while the latter on mental capacity. Although both stories show it in very different ways, the underlying theme is the same, the duality of the human mind is true and apparent but cannot be separated. It may help to demonstrate the nature of human duality with another concept that is physical but not human, the wave-particle duality. This concept is derived from the nature of light, or electromagnetism. Classically, people, especially scientist, used to believe that waves and particles were two separate entities but after an experiment (the double-slit experiment) found that light behaves as both at the same time. This concept shook science from the very foundation upon which it stood and began the era of quantum mechanics. Many people assume that the human mind is one but in actuality it is two, similar to the wave-particle duality. These two minds are one in the same and cannot be separated but there is most definitely a duality to be observed. Reading Strange Case puts the reader into a character known as Mr. Utterson, a lawyer who keeps much self control over his urges. One of his clients is Dr. Jekyll, happened to write a will leaving his estate to a Mr. Hyde, an unknown character at the time. Over the course of the story Mr. Hyde is discovered to be a heinous character, trampling over a little girl and killing a member of the British Parliament. Mr. Utterson's curiosity spikes when he notices that Dr. Jekyll always ends up covering for Mr. Hyde. After Mr. Utterson's investigation, at the end of the story, the reader finds out that Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde are in fact the same person. Dr. Jekyll concocted a drug that transformed him into Mr. Hyde, his alter ego that indulged in every vice without self control, demonstrating to the reader of the duality of humans. The Murders, on the other hand, was a detective story. The narrator, an unnamed character, along with Mr. Dupin solve a crime that could not be solved by the local police. In the newspaper, Mr. Dupin reads about a savage murder of two women. A woman and her mother, rarely interacting with society, are brutally murdered in their own home but no valuables were taken, causing confusion about the motive of the murders. The story takes the reader from the initial mystery to a conclusion via Mr. Dupin's deductive reasoning skills, with the narrator asking questions a reader may have. The theme here may be a bit harder to decipher as it is less apparent but it can be brought to light by the nameless narrator who asks questions and Mr. Dupin answering them. As this analysis progresses, the theme of duality will become more evident. The first story, Strange Case, makes the duality very apparent by showing it to the reader in a third person point of view. The duality is obvious as Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde being the same person, not known until the end of the story. The author shows the reader, from the point of Mr. Utterson, that the two minds of a person cannot be distinguished and so Mr. Utterson does not discover that Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde are the same person until the end of the story. Mr. Hyde physically transforms into another person, including features such as stature and skin complexion. The author purposely makes these two characters different in physical appearance as to show how different these two characters, or minds, are. The next story makes the human duality less apparent and has to be analyzed a bit different. The Murders is written in a first person point of view, something that has to be taken into consideration. On the surface, this story falls in the genre as detective fiction but reading into the story as a whole, a reader can conjecture the duality of the human mind. Considering the fact that the narrator is nameless, a reader can safely assume to be in the author's mind. The narrator starts his story about the mental capacity of man, then tells the reader he discovers a brilliant man in the library to which he became good friends with. This marks the authors discovery of his other half. He solves a mystery by efficiently utilizing both his minds per se. The two minds concept is shown in both stories but from different perspectives. One from a distance to make it conspicuous while the other puts the reader up close. Putting the reader too close to the idea can actually obscure the concept which makes the theme more difficult to decipher, sort of like trying to read print an inch away from the eyes. Also, although the duality is there in both stories, shown from a different perspective, it is also demonstrated in two different manners. Strange Case shows an internal conflict between the two minds while The Murders shows a collaboration of the two. Stevenson creates a story that shows the two minds going in different directions. The concept is self-control, discussed further in the essay. Mr. Hyde does what he wants with disregard to others and society while Dr. Jekyll constantly tries to repair the damages done by him. Similar to a child and a parent, a child will usually run wild while the parent is compelled, by society at least, to remedy the situation. The author shows an internal struggle of the two minds by externalizing the minds into actual characters. A notable instance is at the beginning when Mr. Hyde turned a corner and trampled a little girl, without regards to her wellbeing he did not stop. The girl's father and Mr. Enfield, Mr. Utterson's assistant, ran after Mr. Hyde and threatened to make a huge scandal, with no other choice Mr. Hyde pays a sum of money for restitution. The money came out of Dr. Jekyll's account, while both being the same person, Mr. Hyde does not solve the problem on his own account, again, like a child using his parent's resources. While Stevenson shows an internal struggle of two minds, Poe shows collaboration of the two. Mr. Dupin solves the problem all on his own but the narrator provides the crucial questions that lead to the solution. It is normal for people to have questions because they do not know the answer but how is it possible to ask a question and then also provide an answer. This is only possible with two minds, one mind asks because it does not know, then another answers because it does know. The duality becomes apparent in the story when both the narrator and Mr. Dupin were strolling down a street, where neither had spoken a word for at least 15 minutes, then Mr. Dupin says something as to have had been conversing with the narrator. The narrator responds quickly as if they had been speaking for a while, then in awe asks Mr. Dupin how did he know what he was thinking. Mr. Dupin, with logic, reasons his answer but the only way he could have predicted the narrator's entire train of thoughts for 15 minutes is if their minds were one in the same. Both stories have gone in different directions, aside from different points of view, but the nature of human duality should be more clear at this point. Strange Case shows an internal conflict, that in itself can be used as proof to the human duality. Internal means it is on the inside, in one's own mind in this case, and conflict means a disagreement, a disagreement needs two parties, one to provide an opinion and another to express a different opinion. The Murders on the other hand has two minds going in the same direction sort of like a council, board of directors, or committee, all discussing a matter proactively to come to a consensus. The only difference here is that only the narrator provides the questions and Mr. Dupin provides the answers, adding quality to the story and making Mr. Dupin seem more intelligent. Poe's topic is mental capacity while Stevenson's topic was self-control. Self-control itself implies duality, perhaps the reason why Stevenson used it in his story. Young children do not exercise self-control, they cry and pout at any time they see fit. Over time a child will learn self-control as the two minds develop. One mind wants to do something and another one tells it not to. Many people do not actually develop the more intelligent mind, for lack of better words, and will act on impulse such as buying unnecessary items on credit, and eating unhealthy and expensive foods because of convenience. Mr. Utterson, from the beginning, is noted to have high self-control or as the author states in the first paragraph, "He was austere with himself." The only way to be strict with oneself is if there is one mind that wants to do something but another one recognizing that it is, in some fashion, wrong. Poe did not mention self-control but did explicitly state about mental capacity. In fact, his introduction, the first four paragraphs, concerns mental features. After trying to explain his thoughts about the mental abilities, he stays as the narrator and introduces a new character, Mr. Dupin. At the beginning of the story, Mr. Dupin is introduced as an excellent young man who had faced hardship and "had been reduced to poverty," at this point in time, Poe was 32 years young and living in poverty too, just as Mr. Dupin. The author, Poe, took the place of the narrator while also abstracting his other mind and giving it to the character of Mr. Dupin. Working together, they solved the mystery, one providing the crucial questions while the other providing the answers. The true theme in these two stories is human duality or two minds. Comparing the two provides a very valuable lesson. In Stevenson's story, these two minds were going in different directions causing chaos, ultimately leading to death in this case. Human duality is a powerful force and can be self-destructive if not harnessed as seen in the first story. On the flip side, two minds working in tandem or in the same direction can be very beneficial or favorable at the least. Mastering one's both minds can and will increase one's mental abilities as demonstrated by Poe. In conclusion, the duality of human minds is the theme of these two stories and is self-evident. Stevenson conveys this in a third person point of view while Poe does it in first person. Stevenson's story is about an internal struggle that is externalized while Poe writes about two concurring minds. Stevenson's topic is about self-control while Poe's is mental capacity, or abilities. Even with all the differences in the two stories, the central theme of human duality is present. Both stories provide enough evidence and make the nature of the two minds discernible and apparent. Alas, there is one thing that these two minds cannot do, and that is, to separate the two minds themselves. References
Poe, E. A. (1841). The Murders in the Rue Morgue. Retrieved from http://www.mysterynet.com/edgar-allan-poe/murders-in-the-rue-morgue-full/
Stevenson, R. L. (1886). Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Lizzie Borden Trial Essay

...The Famous Murder Trial’s Killer Discovered Lizzie Borden’s trial was one of most mysterious and famous murder trials in 1900’s. This murder of Andrew Borden and his wife took place in the Borden’s house on the 4th of August, 1892 in the city called Fall River, Massachusetts. The Borden’s house consisted of Andrew Borden and his second wife, Abby, his two daughters, Lizzie and Emma, and a housemaid Bridget Sullivan. About a week after the crime Lizzie was arrested for her father’s and stepmother’s murders; however, in spite of a great deal of evidence, she was acquitted. A look at the evidence of the murder case proves that Lizzie Borden was guilty of her father and stepmother's murder. On the 4th of August, 1892, Abbey Borden and Andrew...

Words: 2360 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Judge Dee Research Paper

...famous for being a just magistrate, and was popular amongst the people. The Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee translated by Robert Van Gulik takes us on a journey to see how he used Confucian and legalist principles to assist him in solving three mysteries: The Case of the Double Murder at Dawn, The Case of the Strange Corpse, and the Case of the Poisoned Bride. Judge Dee was a good magistrate who successfully upheld both the legalist and Confucian principles of his time, such as firmness, fairness, and holding high standards. Judge Dee was firm and did not waver in order to uphold the rule of the law. The legal system at the time was based off of legalism,...

Words: 853 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Summary Of The Novel 'Confessions: The Private School Murder'

...Confessions: The Private School Murder Tandy Angel is the protagonist in this novel. Tandy is a teenage girl who is living a life of wealth. She is a smart girl with long brown hair, but also a girl who has secrets, some of which she doesn’t understand herself. Her personality is rather unusual, probably due to the fact that her parents were demanding, extravagant, controlling, and strange. Tandy alongside her brothers was an overachiever. Everyone in the family was bigger, stronger, faster, smarter and rather emotionless than everyone else their age. The Angels live in an apartment complex, in New York City, and this novel takes place a few months after Tandy solved the sudden death of her parents in the first book of this sequel. In this book Tandy's family is torn apart, their parents are dead, they’re bankrupt, and in debt because of their parents. As for the theme, it’s kind of hard to pinpoint exact themes but here are some that clearly come in play: peace and love always finds the way, never give up, the truth will always come out, and to be courageous....

Words: 530 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Chaos In Paris Analysis

...There have been a lot of suspicious murders, no one knows who the killer is, but Andre-Pierre was there to solve it out. He has been detective since 16 years ago, so he is well experienced. He is the most indicated to know about criminals. He solves a lot of cases in every year. The most recent murder was in a park, an old man killed with a knife. Andre-Pierre notices there are no fingerprints or footprints as a clue, but just a peculiar smell on the victim. That smell seems familiar to Andre-Pierre. When he was in his way to his home he could feel again that weird but suspiciously familiar smell, then he look that nearby him was his friend Paul....

Words: 905 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

A Case of Murder by Vernon Scannell

...A Case of Murder by Vernon Scannell Fear is an ancient emotion that has existed as long as life has inhabited the earth, from the smallest critter to the mightiest of predators, even us humans supposedly the most advanced beings that has ever seen the light of dawn can’t deny this feeling, it is a stressful feeling that can strip you of your sense of reason and common sense In this poem we are introduced to another feeling, one that most people would arguably agree only is a human feeling, guilt, the feeling that specifically makes you feel awful about a former action, one that might have had another possible outcome. Vernon Scannell deals with these feelings in his poem: A Case of Murder, in which we follow a young child at the age of 9 that is left home alone. His only company down in the basement is the family cat, a gold eyed black cat. The cat continuously irritates him by the buzzing sound that cats make when purring, he has always hated that sound. So he goes on to hit the cat with a stick, the cat hides away and hisses at him, the child joys in the cats pain, and decides to poke it. As a result that cat runs for the door in order escape this sadistic kid, unfortunately the child literally cuts off the cats escape by smashing the door into the feline, killing it. Frighten by his own excessive use of force against this cat makes him realize what just happened, he decides to hide the lifeless furry body within a cupboard. As time goes by he is beginning to hear strange...

Words: 925 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Ghost Whisperer

...Ghost Whisperer By Stephanie Nicole Schaffer 10/02/2015 OTH036 GothicLit Sec2 Sem1 I remember it like it was yesterday. I had just woke up from another one of my strange dreams. I usually dream about random people. It starts off as a nice dream but soon turns dark. I first found out that I had a gift when I turned 11. I could see things other people couldn’t. People wanted my help, and I didn’t understand most of it until now. Now that I look back I realize that those people wasn’t normal. They was dead. Now since you know my story, I’m going to tell you about the one experience that changed my life. It was Halloween. One of the nights I see the dead the most. I sat writing in my journal about the children that have went missing in Ohio. I looked outside and saw the moon. It was surprisingly big tonight. I looked at my clock. It was midnight. I decided I should go to bed now. As I got up I heard a noise in my closet. “It’s just another one of those encounters”, I said to myself. I opened my closet door and saw a young girl. Her red hair in pigtails with two blue bows tied at the top. The bows matched her blue dress. She had frilly socks with dress shoes on and she smiled it me. It was at that moment her appearance changed. She was soaked like she had went swimming in her clothes or got caught out in the rain. Tears ran down her face. One of her pigtails was undone and a bow was missing, along with one of her shoes. She mouthed “help me” then disappeared. ...

Words: 891 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The 11.05 Murders Summary

...Brian O'Hare's [i]The 11.05 Murders[/i] starts by showing the reader the events that happened at a college party, twelve years ago. We don't know what happened, but I'm sure everyone who reads this chapter comes to the same conclusion. Enters the scene, Woman Detective Sergeant Denise Stewart on her first day as a member of the Serious Crimes Unit. Her first experience as a police woman was not the most pleasant one and she has built walls around herself. But she is immediately received as one of the family by DCI Jim Sheehan and her new colleagues. In that unit, there's a concept she had never heard before: having each other's backs. A series of brutal murders are being perpetrated. Every Tuesday, at 11:05 pm, one man is murdered in a violent way. The team, composed of very different individuals, starts investigating the connection between the murders. As they make progress, strange events start happening every time Stewart and the young Detective Tom Allen are seen together. The questions start to appear: are these strange events connected to the case they are investigating? How are the murders connected? And why does Stewart, the newest agent of the unit, have a target on her back?...

Words: 572 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Troy Davis Court Case Essay

...This case, in which Troy Davis was convicted of and executed for the murder of Mark MacPhail regardless of the lack of evidence and importance of doubt, drew international attention. We believe this case is not a question of “guilt” or “innocence”. It is important to keep in mind that no physical evidence was shown to the jury and the murder weapon never found. The case built against Troy Davis rested exclusively on witness testimony. Most of the key witnesses at Davis's trial withdrew or modified their testimony in sworn affidavits but these recantations were not taken into account because, as stated one of the panel-judges, “two of the witnesses had not changed their recollections” and there was “no DNA evidence was available to categorically clear Troy Davis”. Nine affidavits, containing evidence implicated another suspect, were written after the trial. In fact, one of the two witnesses who did not recant his testimony was this suspect. Regardless of the lack of evidence and serious doubt, Davis was sentenced to death and executed. Was the execution warrant setting Troy Davis’ execution unconstitutional?...

Words: 439 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Lizzie Borden

...Lizzie Borden Case The trial of Lizzie Borden is a very controversial topic and many believe the case verdict should have been ruled otherwise. The murder of Abby and Andrew Borden by multiple ax whacks to the head caused many to believe that Lizzie Borden, the daughter of Andrew Borden, did it. The case ruled ‘Not Guilty” on June 20, 1893. Based on research and evidence, I believe that Lizzie Borden was guilty because of her claimed whereabouts, the ironic poisoning coincidence, and the burning of a dress, which is the opposite of the actual court ruling in 1893. Lizzie Borden and the maid, Bridget Sullivan were the only ones home at the time of the murder of Abby Borden. Bridget was outside washing windows and Lizzie claimed to be downstairs. It’s strange that “she heard no alarming noises”. (Source J) In addition to that, there was no sign of forced entry. If an intruder committed the murders, they would have “had to hide in the house for 90 minutes or departed and then returned without being seen” (Source J) because the 2 murders happened over an hour apart. This would be nearly impossible if Lizzie was downstairs at the time of her stepmother’s murder. At the time of her father’s murder, she claimed to be in the loft of the backyard barn, searching for sinkers for a fishing trip for 15-20 minutes. The police said the loft was very hot and the “also found no footprints”(Source J) which contradicts Lizzie’s statement of where she was at the time of the murder of her father...

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Archibald Cronin. Beyond This Place. Summary

...quite unsociable and reserved. The first five years of his life Paul had spent in the North of England. He had very good relations with his father, Rees; they loved to spend time together. Later his family moved to Wortley. When they lived there, his father died because of a railway accident. Soon after that he and his mother, Hannah, moved to Belfast. When Paul was about 20 years old, he learned that his father didn’t die. He was accused of murder and taken to prison. As he was told, Rees killed Mona Spurling, a beautiful young woman who worked as a shop girl. The murder took place in Eldon, a district near Wortley. The police had 3 witnesses who had seen the murderer. They were Edward Collins, a driver of a laundry van, Louisa Burt, an Edward’s cousin who also worked in a laundry, and Albert Prusty, a neighbour of Miss Spurling. The murderer left 3 clues against himself. The 1st one was a picture postcard. The 2nd was a half burnt note. The last one was a money bag made of human skin which was lying near her body. The motive of murder was also clear – the killed woman was expecting a baby and the man who had murdered her was the child’s father. Paul decided to visit his father. Unfortunately, when he came there, he had been told that there are no visiting days. The man didn’t want to go home, so he went to Wortley to visit Mr Prusty. He was the only witness whose evidence was in Rees’ favour. Prusty said that he didn’t...

Words: 980 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Adnan Syed Case

...The last episode of Serial, “What We Know,” reviewed most of the evidence found during the re-investigation of the murder of Hae Min Lee. The state’s stance on the case was against Adnan Syed, who was accused of killing Hae, his ex-girlfriend. They presented him as a possessive, jealous ex-boyfriend who could not stand that Hae dated someone else shortly after their breakup. However, after discovering conflicting information within Jay’s stories, recent connections to another serial killer, and the previous defence lawyer’s negligence, I have more reasons to believe that Adnan is innocent. The Evidence and its Implications The state’s main evidence against Adnan was Jay’s testimony and stories from two previous interrogations. However, upon...

Words: 1383 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Macbeth

...In the novel written by Robert Louis Stephenson, The strange case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde and William Shakespeare’s play Macbeth, I will explore the struggles the main characters’ have within themselves in their fight for good over evil. How Macbeth and Dr Jekyll change throughout the stories and explore the similarities of each of them and why they came to change. These two books are worlds apart from one another. ‘Macbeth’ is about a great warrior who fights for the King and is set in medieval Scotland, while ‘The strange case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde’ is set in the upper classes of Victorian England where everything is done correctly and bad behaviour or wild ways are not tolerated. Dr Jekyll is a Physician who is curious about separating the good side of a personality with the bad and begins to experiment and invent potions to control the evil side of a person. However, both of these books have mystical themes about them, the witches in ‘Macbeth’ that can see the future and plant the seed of success in Macbeth’s head and the strange disappearances of Dr Jekyll and the sudden mystical appearance of a Mr Hyde. These main characters, Macbeth and Dr Jekyll evolve from being heroic, well-respected men into twisted, ruthless killers and their nature completely changes throughout their lives. Both characters become so obsessed with ultimate control they are prepared to remove anyone who gets in their way or tries to stop them from reaching their final goal. The obsession of their...

Words: 1523 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Bund Bundy Case Summary

...Bundy’s first arrest happened in August 1975. It always seems to be the case that the break in a major case is because a patrol officer does his job and observes things that are out of the ordinary. The Utah Highway Patrol officer that stopped Bundy took a closer look at Bundy’s tan Volkswagen Beetle after he failed to stop. The officer observed that the front seat was missing from Bundy’s Volkswagen Beetle. When the officer searched the car he found two ski masks, handcuffs, trash bags, rope, an ice pick and items usually thought to be burglary tools. Bundy was eventually released because the detectives could not find any evidence to link him to the crimes. The major break in the case came shortly after Bundy’s release. Close to a month after his release, Bundy sold the tan Volkswagen Beetle. When police found out about this, they quickly impounded the vehicle from its new owner. During the forensic examination of the Beetle, police found evidence from three of the victims. It is highly improbable for evidence from three separate victims to be in one location (Michaud & Aynesworth, 1999)....

Words: 503 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gone Girl Analysis

...completely unharmed he is hauled to the station for further questioning. He reveals that his name is Martin Willow. Following these puzzling circumstances, detective Jason Smith is appointed to spearhead the investigation. After hitting a complete cul-de-sac in the case he finally unravels a terrifying pattern in these morbid events. On Christmas day, the young girl awakens from her comatose state and divulges a crucial piece of evidence- a snippet of a song she’d heard just before she was...

Words: 1039 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Dudley And Stephens Case

...This case, R. v. Dudley and Stephens, surrounds the unfortunate events that surrounded the sinking of ship in 1884 far off the coast of Cape of Good Hope, South Africa. There are many facts that surround this case. The boat left with exactly four men (Tom Dudley, Edwin Stephens, Edmund Brooks, and Richard Parker). They were heading from Southampton, England to Sydney, Australia. They left on May 19, 1884. The boat sank on July 5, 1884, about 1600 miles off of Cape of Good Hope, South Africa. The four men all survived the sinking of the ship by getting into an open lifeboat. They had no water and only two 1-lb cans of turnip. The two pounds of canned turnip lasted for three days. On the fourth day, the men managed to catch a sea turtle. They ate this for several days. They drank sparse rainwater that they caught in their hats. After the twelfth day, they had no food to eat. Talk started to arise on the 18th day that a sacrifice could be made by one of them so that the other three could live. The conversation surrounded Richard Parker, who was often unconscious and sickly due to intense hunger and drinking seawater. Dudley and Stephens considered killing Parker...

Words: 810 - Pages: 4