Free Essay

Supply Management Case Study

In: Business and Management

Submitted By llandes83
Words 902
Pages 4
Running head: Supply Management Course Case Studies

Case Studies

Case Study #1 – Krause Corporation
1. Should Steve recommend buying the pipe or making it?
Steve could go forward as planned and make the steel piping in house to save money by using the lowest cost lowest acceptable quality steel. This would be risky since the material would inferior and also the risk of toxic fumes being released due to bad welding etc. Buying the pipe already formed and of better quality would be the second option. In house machines did not provide the proper ability to make 20 foot sections of piping. This causes more seams to be welded and increases risk of toxicity. Labor cost would increase because of the extra welding and fabrication costs to include overhead costs. I would suggest Steve buying the piping. This would save on man hours to create and weld 8 foot pipes to needed length, ensure a better quality piping was procured, and show that priority was on safety with regard to hazardous materials being released through leaky seams etc. Although it appears that buying may be more costly, I wouldn’t suggest short cutting such a sensitive area.
Case Study #2 – SMC Turbines
1. What options are available to Greg through basic supplier management? What actions do you recommend?
Early supplier involvement is important in this case. Early matching of process and product is important. If the supplier can’t perform at the fixed price due to unforeseen issues, a cost plus type of contract must be considered. This would also hurt the current vendor’s chances of future business with the customer. Management can also use the prospect of future business to entice the supplier to keep price low after correcting the issues at hand. In the event the contract is a firm fixed contract the vendor costs could be high but are still responsible for correcting the issues. I would hold the vendor accountable on a cost plus basis until the original agreed on quality was established.
Case Study #3 – Crossing the Border
1. Identify and discuss the key issues in the case.
Some of the key issues include the truckers strike. Another issue is the corrupt actions of the customs agents trying to bribe the truckers for money. The maquiladora is not autonomous while TAI is. This causes issues such as loss of control, loss of client focus, lack of clarity, lack of cost control, and ineffective management. Other issues include customs officials using tougher tactics to coerce payments from bribes and also causing undue delays in delivery times. Being that such corruption was an ongoing issue I would suggest finding another supplier for the short-term and negotiating new deals with alternate suppliers for the long term. Another option that may be more expensive than trucking would be airlift delivery. This would help deliveries for just in time requests. However, this may or may not help with the corruption that exists. Another option would be to negotiate pickup by the maquiladora at the border which could prevent longer delivery times and have local national representation at the border.
Case Study #4 – Futronics Incorporated
1. Assume you are Steve Hassell. Prepare an analysis and report on this issue for presentation at the next program meeting.
Advantages of procuring external services:
1. The company could save about 6% on about 90% of its procurements by going externally. Savings could be around $49,000 annually if we calculate $900,000 x .90 x .06 = $48,600).
2. Going external would allow the store to get rid of its internal inventory. If this happens about $42,000 could be saved $140,000 x .30 = $42,000 per year.
4. Ordering costs can be reduced by contracting a long term supplier. Procurement man hours would be reduced as well.
5. Futronics has 42 stores. To save money on delivery and time, suppliers should be efficient and well stocked to support adequately.
Disadvantages of purchasing externally include:
1. Stopping internal services also takes away customer loyalty and quality by the store itself. Control of services offered may also suffer.
2. A contract may be a good idea but forces the store to be in an obligation for a specific period of time. Time must be spent is the right vendor selection and right contractual terms.
3. Discontinuing the store operations would demand a great deal of time and effort to restart in case something went wrong.
4. Unofficial inventories would need to be monitored so money is not wasted.
Managerial considerations:
5. Management must look ahead to figure out what the company’s future storage needs are.
6. Suppliers must understand what it is the company wants.
Steve needs must decide on the type of solicitation he will use. He can use negotiation, competitive bidding, or two-step bidding. I would recommend proposal negotiation. This leads to better service and price performance. When dealing with receiving operations a blanket order for the receiving and invoicing processes could be implemented. Proper audit trails could be established. Separation of duties must be implemented so that the same person is not ordering and receiving. If operations are discontinued the company must be able to accommodate elsewhere. Lastly, Futronics can test these ideas by experimenting with a small group of products before going full scale. This would allow for them to keep operations alive while testing an alternative for success or failure.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Supply Chain Management in the Construction Industry: Gilmor Engineering Limited Case Study.

...Supply Chain Management in the Construction Industry: Gilmor Engineering Limited case study. By Emmanuel Ola Elehinle Student I.D 15597305 Submitted To Laureate Online Education & University of Liverpool – Online Masters Degree In Partial fulfillment for the award of Master of Science (M.Sc.) Degree in Operations and Supply Chain Management Abstract Activities in the execution of a construction project are usually time bound and require an effective management of the supply chain network to meet deadlines but the comparison of case studies and past research works shows that there are waste and problems in the construction supply chains which are characterized by inadequate coordination. In this study therefore, analysis of the key controlling parameters of a construction company’s supply chain operations and systems is carried out with an optimization of information flow within the system to improve performance. The barriers that obstruct coordination are identified and an efficient coordination model for a supply chain is suggested to accelerate and improve the economic and operational innovations for the management of construction projects. 1. Introduction Supply chain in the construction industry is a non static one and is characterized by inadequate coordination of the key processes and parameters. According to Xiaolong & et al (2007) “Coordination is the core issue to improve construction performance in construction supply chain”. In this study......

Words: 1848 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Wal-Mart’s Supply Chain Management Practices Case Study

...Wal-Mart’s supply chain management practices case study Question 1: Wal-Mart has been able to achieve respectable leadership in the retail industry because of its focus on supply chain management characterized by: * Procuring goods directly from manufacturers bypassing all intermediaries. * Negotiating on prices and finalizing a purchase deal only when it was fully confident that the products being bought were not available elsewhere at a lower price. * Spending a significant amount of time meeting vendors and understanding their cost structure. Also, by preferring local and regional vendors and suppliers. * Having over 40 distributions centers located at different geographical locations in the US. So, Wal-Mart’s own warehouses directly supplied 85 % of the inventory, as compared to 50-65% for competitors. About 85% of the goods which were available at the stores passed through the distributions centers. * Having and using a fast and responsive transportation system. * Maintaining a strict vigil over its drivers by keeping a record of their activities through the “Private Fleet Driver Handbook”. * Using a Cross-docking approach. In this system, the finished goods were directly picked up from the manufacturing plant of a supplier, sorted out and then directly supplied to the customers. Question 2: Wal-Mart invested heavily in IT and communications systems to effectively track sales and merchandise inventories in stores across the country.......

Words: 763 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Case Study 14.1- Supply Chain Management

...Case Questions 1. A decently overseen database may help the healing center accomplish its mission by the following points: * Cost of the each treatment in similar hospital is stored in the database to compare rate with other hospital. * Physicians can gather the relevant information quickly by providing the electronic medical record for each patient. * To find which programs and methods are best, create a historical record of the treatments. * Track the important measure to provide the data and information for example, normal length of patient wait, price for each day for a patient. 3. Hospital should carefully manage some of the cost and risk of using database because in a job market, there is short supply of skills such as database designer and database administrator. Without the specific faculty, it creates a risk to manage the database. The installation and administration expenses include updating software and installing of database and hardware. The translation cost includes the converting cost of older application into database environment. Instead of converting the hospital can choose new system. There is a need for the backup and recovery because the framework expenses are connected with those strategies. A hospital must predict the data administration cost and other activities cost related to data definition, ownership and maintenance. 6. Mountain View Hospital could use web based applications in a few ways. * Internet hospital personnel......

Words: 410 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...Learning Goals At the end of your programme of study you will have achieved the following goals: * Goal One: Be independent, reflective critical thinkers * Goal Two: Be culturally and ethically aware * Goal Three: Have developed leadership and management capability * Goal Four: Have developed and applied knowledge of international business and management theory * Goal Five: Have developed a range of research skills and project capabilities * Goal Six: (Specialist programmes only) Have developed specialist knowledge about the theory and practice of your programme of study All of the learning that takes place within modules is designed to enable you to achieve the above goals and your assessment tasks are mapped directly to these goals as outlined in each assessment brief. OUTLINE STUDY PLAN 2012/2013 | | Global Supply Chain Management MO0255 | S01 | Week | Lectures | Lecture Topic | Seminar | Recommended Reading | Directed study | 1 | Lecture 1 | Module Introduction | Making the groups of 4-5 studentsCase Study ReviewIntroduction to operation management (Operation Objectives in the Penang Mutiara Hotel) | Slack, N. (2010), sixth Edition, Chapter 2 | -Reading the TLP carefully-Reading stipulated chapters 1, 2 and 3 of the Slack, N. (2010). | | Lecture 2 | Introduction to Global Supply chain and management | | Slack, N. (2010), sixth Edition, Chapter 13 | -Evaluate the supply chain performance in......

Words: 3348 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Operation and Chain of Supply

...Page » Business and Management Operations and Supply Chain Case Studies In: Business and Management Operations and Supply Chain Case Studies Operations and Supply Chain Case Studies In today’s environment of global shopping where the demand for products is as wide as the number of firms offering them, orders can be placed in advance or at a moment’s notice from across the globe. The question of the manufacturer or reseller is how to best manage production across the supply chain. This paper will have two parts to it; part one will review the case study of the Realco Breadmaster. It will provide analysis on the current supply chain management and will make recommendations for a more strategic approach. Part two will focus on a case study for Toyota. This case will focus on quality and the Lean philosophy. First, it is important to provide some foundation support of what operations and supply chain management entail. Every firm or organization must make a product or provide a service to someone that is needed or valued. Operations are the collection of people, technology, and systems that are in a firm whose primary responsibility is to provide the company’s products or services (Bozarth & Handfield, 2008). “Supply chain is the network of manufacturers and service providers that convert and move good from the raw materials state through to the end user” (Bozarth & Handfield, 2008, p.4). Planning and controlling operations and supply chains are......

Words: 526 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

American Conector

...SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT DESIGNATION PROGRAM MODULE THREE Logistics and Transportation ©Supply Chain Management Association Supply Chain Management Professional Designation Program Copyright © 2013 by the Supply Chain Management Association No part of this material in this manual may be reproduced without the prior written consent of the Supply Chain Management Association. 777 Bay Street, Suite 2701, P.O. Box 112, Toronto, Ontario M5G 2C8 Tel: (416) 977-7111 Fax: (416) 977-8886 Web Site: Use of this material is restricted to SCMA and its Provincial/Territorial Institutes for the express purpose of delivering the Supply Chain Management Designation Program. No other use is authorized, expressed, or implied. This material must be used in its entirety. © Supply Chain Management Association Supply Chain Management Professional Designation Program Module Three Logistics and Transportation Information and Overview .................................................................................................... IO – 1 General Information ........................................................................................................ IO – 2 Module Overview ........................................................................................................... IO – 4 Module Readings ............................................................................................................ IO – 7 Session and......

Words: 6233 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay


...Publications Management School 1-1-2009 Commonalities and differences between service and manufacturing supply chains: Combining operations management studies with supply chain management Ming Zhou San Jose State University, J. Yi. Saint Joseph's University, Philadelphia, PA T. Park San Jose State University Follow this and additional works at: Part of the Business Administration, Management, and Operations Commons, and the Organizational Behavior and Theory Commons Recommended Citation Ming Zhou, J. Yi., and T. Park. "Commonalities and differences between service and manufacturing supply chains: Combining operations management studies with supply chain management" California Journal of Operations Management (2009): 136-143. This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Management School at SJSU ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of SJSU ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact Commonalities and Differences between Service and Manufacturing Supply Chains: Combining Operations Management Studies with Supply Chain Management Ming Zhou • Taeho Park San Jose State University, San Jose, CA John Yi Saint Joseph's University, Philadelphia, PA The service sector of the US economy has been gaining importance. As the service sector evolves, the study of......

Words: 4672 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Commonalities and Differences Between Service and Manufacturing Supply Chains: Combining Operations Management Studies with Supply Chain Management

...Commonalities and Differences between Service and Manufacturing Supply Chains: Combining Operations Management Studies with Supply Chain Management Ming Zhou • Taeho Park San Jose State University, San Jose, CA John Yi Saint Joseph's University, Philadelphia, PA The service sector of the US economy has been gaining importance. As the service sector evolves, the study of service supply chain starts to gain attention. In this study, we conduct an exploratory review on the studies of manufacturing and service supply chains. We focus on the studies that explore the differences and commonalities between manufacturing and service supply chains. We combine operations management literature with supply chain studies in order to provide an interdisciplinary framework that brings up both the operational and strategic views on the management commonalities and differences between the two types of supply chains. I. INTRODUCTION The study of services has lagged the study of manufacturing. When Fred Harvey proposed that services can be standardized and managed systematically, standardization and systematic management had been applied in the manufacturing sector by pioneers such as Eli Whitney and Frederick Taylor. The first business school course that focused on service management was not introduced until 1973 (Heineke and Davis, 2006). Despite the lag of academic attention, the service sector has been gaining importance as the US economy becomes more and more service-centric....

Words: 4515 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Case Study McDonalds was supply chain management. Supply chain management involves creating a balance between minimising wastage as well as at the same time meeting customers’ needs. Wastage is reduced by two major steps:- * Accurate forecasting (product is not ordered in excess) * Accurate supply control of raw material. Supply chain management involves creating balance between customers need at the same time minimising wastage of product including raw material. It is believed to be very tough to balance. In order to fulfil changing taste of customers, McDonald’s needs to introduce new products to their existing menu, which in turns make it even harder to minimise wastage. Importance of required change In early days, stock ordering was so easy at all McDonald’s restaurants. Stock ordering was responsibility of restaurant manager. They order stock using their local knowledge, as well as data on what the store sold previous day, week and month. For example, if last week's sales figures showed they sold 100 units of coffee and net sales were rising at 10%, they would expect to sell 110 units this week. However, this was a simple method and involved no calculations to take account of factors such as national promotions or school holidays. By this most of the restaurant managers were spending lot of time to look up the stock and leaving behind no time for concentrating on the quality of food they aims to supply to their customers. Supply chain management – The new......

Words: 2493 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Supply Chain Issues by David-Simchi

...Supply Chain Management COURSE OUTLINE TERM WINTER 2014 A. INSTRUCTOR AND CONTACT INFORMATION | Instructor: | Mr. Hanif Ajari | Office #: | Korangi Sector 30 near Singer round about | Telephone: | 0321- 2666071, 021-34933003(Res) | E-mail: | | Office Hours: | Normal University hours | B. COURSE OBJECTIVE | Objective of this program is to generate basic level understanding and translating conceptual exposure in very congenial atmosphere among the students and professional that why supply chain management is among the top initiatives for businesses of all sizes. Yet most purchasing, operation, planning, and finance managers feel they don’t have good control over their supply chains. Even the best informed are saddled with questions about establishing organization buy-in, defining metrics and benchmarks, optimizing material and transactional flow, and conducting relevant competitive analysis to define business opportunities. The challenges involved in optimizing a company’s supply chain are substantial. The proposed course outline grew out of a number of supply chain management courses or workshop conducted in Executive Education programs I have taught extensively in many universities within and outside Pakistan over the past five years as well as number of projects I have handled in the field of designing the supply chain model within Pakistan or and other countries of the world. The course outline is more or less similar to the......

Words: 1531 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at Supply chain risk management and performance A guiding framework for future development Bob Ritchie Lancashire Business School, University of Central Lancashire, Preston, Lancashire, UK, and Supply chain risk management and performance 303 Clare Brindley Head of Department, Lancashire Business School, University of Central Lancashire, Preston, Lancashire, UK Abstract Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to examine the constructs underpinning risk management and explores its application in the supply chain context through the development of a framework. The constructs of performance and risk are matched together to provide new perspectives for researchers and practitioners. Design/methodology/approach – The conceptual and empirical work in the supply chain management field and other related fields is employed to develop a conceptual framework of supply chain risk management (SCRM). Risk in the supply chain is explored in terms of risk/performance sources, drivers, consequences and management responses, including initial approaches to categorization within these. Two empirical cases are used to illustrate the application of the framework. Findings – A new framework is presented that helps to integrate the dimensions of risk and performance in supply chains and provide a categorisation of risk drivers. Research limitations/implications – SCRM is at an early stage of......

Words: 9155 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay


...Advanced Supply Chain Management Course overview Course code: 315.075.301 Course title: Advanced Supply Chain Management Credit points: 3 |Course |Campus |Career |School |Learning Mode | |Code | | | | | | |Understanding the supply chain |1 |Definitions of supply chain and its |Read Chapter 1 and answer the | | | | |characteristics |discussion questions | | |Supply Chain Performance: Achieving |2 |How to achieve strategic fit and scope through |Read Chapter 2 and answer the | | |Strategic Fit and Scope | |supply chain management |discussion questions | | |Supply Chain Drivers and Obstacles |3 |Deeper understanding of the elements of supply |Read Chapter 3 and answer the | | | | |chain performance |discussion questions | | |Designing distribution network and |4 |Significance......

Words: 709 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...Course Outline School of Business Program: International Business Management Option: Start Date: January 6, 2016 Total Hours: Hours/Week: 30 Total Weeks: Lecture: 3 TDMT 4322 Global Supply Chain Management End Date: 10 1 Lab: Prerequisites: TDMT 3301 Logistics1 2 March 4, 2016 Term/Level: Shop: 4A Course Credits: Seminar: 2 Other: Prerequisite for: TDMT4411 Industry Projects  Course Description This course develops an understanding of relationship management within the global supply chain sectors. Topics are delivered based on international influences, value creation, aligning incentives, creating partnerships, sharing resources and finding mutual benefits within the supply chain. An emphasis will be based on building flexible and strategic partnerships and managing changes and shifts in strategies. These methods are aimed at driving supply chain profitability and competitive advantage. Students will do team based case studies relating to Supply Chain Management and 1 term team project and presentation.  Evaluation Assignments Term Team Project Participation & Professionalism Mid Term Exam Final Exam TOTAL 20 15 10 25 30 100 % % % % % % Comments: A student must achieve 50% combined grade on the exam scores before the marks for the assignments will be incorporated into the calculation of the overall grade.  Course Learning Outcomes/Competencies At the end of this course...

Words: 844 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Scm Usage and Defnitions

...control of today’s complex supply chains. This is because companies of today are not independent entities but part of a multi company, multi country global network of organizations and corporations. The rapid development in technology in both the manufacturing as well as the information sectors has increased the cost pressure and demand from customers [1]. Information technology (IT) has become a matter of serious concern for managements today. With developments in telecommunications there is an increasing trend for information systems to span boundaries between countries, organizations and the relatively separate components of large, geographically dispersed corporations. Traditional production – distribution schemes have been drastically changed over the years. The emergence of low-cost communications and information processing has made it possible for companies to revolutionize the way they operate internally, especially in distributing information throughout their organization on new and existing products, production and shipping schedules, engineering and technical requirements, and costs of manufacturing and distribution [2]. Despite the acknowledged importance of the use of IT in supply chain management (SCM), the number of studies assessing the use of IT in the supply chain context is limited. A study conducted by Forrester Research indicates that U.S. manufacturers are increasingly dependent on the benefits brought about by IT to: improve supply chain agility,......

Words: 3148 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay


...MBA 382: SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT Credit Units: 03 SESSION PLAN- SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT FACULTY: PROF.A.RAMASWAMY IYENGAR Marks: Hundred. Objective: The aim of this course is to develop the understanding of the various components of the integrated supply chain. The learning is focused on developing the supply chain to suit domestic as well as global markets. Session No | Topic | Pedagogy | Student name | evaluation | 01 | Introduction of Logistics and SCM | Interaction Lecture | Manoj P | | 02 | Evolution of Logistics and Importance of Supply Chain Management in the Overall Organization Functioning, Inter-functional coordination, | PPT & Case study | | | 03 | Customer Focus in Supply Chain, | Lecture | | | 04 | Supply Chain Logistics Operations, | Industry visit | Avinash K | | 05 | Objectives of purchasing, Purchase strategies, Outsourcing in SCM, Vendor Management and Development | PPT Lecture | | | 06 | Liquid Logistics, Cold Chain Operations. | Class room session | | | 07 | Strategic Issues in Supply Chain Management | Group discussion | Priyanka B | | 08 | Value chain and value delivery system, Inter-corporate cooperation, | PPT lecture | | | 09 | Different Modes of Transportation, Choice for Transportation, | Video lecture | | | 10 | Concept of multi-modal transportation and infrastructure needs | Lecture | | | 11 | Third Party Logistics, Fourth Party Logistics,......

Words: 472 - Pages: 2