Free Essay


In: Other Topics

Submitted By lyla
Words 1017
Pages 5
Sweatshop is Conflicts With the Moral Standards
PMP 400
Quan Zhang ( Lyla)
Royal Roads University
Elvira Perrella
March 9, 2015

Sweatshop is Conflicts With the Moral Standards
Green, B., & Norton, S. (2011). Reading. In. W, Anne & M. Laura ( Eds.), Essay essentials with readings (pp. 336- 341). Toronto, ON: Nelson Education Ltd. In the article, before the research, like many people, the author’s attitude was old, but after the research, the author’s attitude changed. The author chose the country of Bangladeshi to illustrate her point that working in a sweatshop can be a positive experience for women in developing countries by focusing primarily on one country. First, she argued that sweatshops offer jobs for women and give them the opportunity to improve the quality of their lives. Second, women can experience some independence about managing their finances and choosing their marriages although they have the small income. In this article, the author used others’ opinion, details and facts to develop her topic. The data and cases were enough to prove the argument, and the evidence was very creditable and believable. Although this article argued in the opposite way with me, it gave my article a new perspective about the sweatshop labors. What's more, the author gave me a good evidence about counterargument, which work at the sweatshop is better than no jobs. Then I can refutation this counterargument that the sweatshop conflicts with the moral standards. In this way, I can make my argument stronger. Meyers, C. (2004). Wrongful Beneficence: Exploitation and Third World Sweatshops. Journal of Social Philosophy, 35(3), pp. 319 – 333. doi: This article argues that apparel manufacturers and their contractors do exploit workers frequently. Trough the research, the author described that sweatshops exploit their workers in various ways, paying their meager wages for long hours of toil in difficult work environment. As the laboring of sweatshops these workers at work being treated unfairly, and took the lowest benefit, which is one form of wrongful conduct. However, to continue growing rapidly, the third world needs to make the next transition, from sweatshop economy to the innovation economy. In this article, the author did lots of research and surveys from different countries; also the author used others' opinion to support own argument. The data and cases were enough to prove the argument, and the evidence was very creditable and believable. I can use them in my paper to prove that sweatshop conflict with the moral standard, especially in the third world.
Norton, S., & Green, B. (2011). Reading. In. W, Anne & M. Laura ( Eds.), Essay essentials with readings (pp. 317- 319). Toronto, ON: Nelson Education Ltd. The article exposed the truth of Walmart’s low prices. The author indicated that Walmart increases profits by paying low wages and benefits to its employees. However, the customers are hard to resist the low prices because they prefer to consider themselves profits rather than the employees'. The author wants to make the customers aware of Walmart policies. In addition, the author suggests that the government pass laws that can balance the interests of big business with the protection of labor, environmental, and community rights. This article published in 2006, the data and research are old, but it offered many useful concepts that can help me to understand the issue of Walmart. Furthermore, the article gave my research a new perspective that how the sweatshops operation, also this article is a good evidence to support that the sweatshops conflict with the moral standards. I can choose these data and cite them in my paper, and the data will make my evidence more powerful and believable. Powell, B., & Zwolinski, M. (2011). The Ethical and Economic Case Against Sweatshop Labor: A Critical Assessment. Journal of Business Ethics, 107(4), pp. 449–472. doi: The idea of sweatshop has grown increasingly has been hotly contested over the past several years. At first, the author reviews the moral and economic foundations, then argues that the sweatshops are flawed, which are the violation of labor right. The author addresses the question of sweatshops are justified in violating local labor laws. Then the author pointed out that the global market competitions are the fundamental reason for growing sweatshops. Finally, the author provides some recent literature, which applies to the ban exploitation of sweatshop labor and offers advice on modifying the behavior of sweatshops. In this article, the framework is very clear. The author mainly expounds the sweatshops are flawed and against the sweatshop labor. The author not only used data to support their thesis, but also they used others' opinions to assess the issue and gave the recommendations. The evidence is believable because the authors of this article are the professor of economics and philosophy respectively, which means they had strong academic background and abundant research experience. Some opinions of this article are very useful, such as the point of the global market competitions are the fundamental reason of the number of huge sweatshops. I can use these points in my paper and cite others’ opinions. This article is valuable to my paper.
Sauers, J. (2013). What's the Solution to the World's Sweatshop Problem? Retrieved from This article argues that how to solve the problem of sweatshop. Though the fact that the factory collapse in Bangladesh, the author analyzed that how Nike, Walmart became the global symbol of abusive labor practices, and then tried to cover up the truth. This essay points out that because of saving cost, the workers had to work in difficult circumstance, which accidents often happened. The accidents have threatened seriously works life safety. The author used data to prove a truth about Nike and Walmart became the sweatshop. The author provides a well-reasoned, and insightful analysis of the sweatshop makes workers in dangerous work environment, which is a good example of my argument that sweatshop conflict with the moral standards. These data are useful and helpful for my paper.


Similar Documents

Premium Essay


...Hiromi Ochi ENG112 Professor Ashley Farmer Unit 2 Essay Sweatshops and the benefits of Fair Trade The great Abraham Lincoln once said, “Whenever I hear anyone arguing for slavery, I feel a strong impulse to see it tried on him personally.” In many countries worldwide, people are being exploited on a daily basis by factories around the world known as sweatshops. A sweatshop is a term used to describe a working environment, commonly factories manufacturing textile goods that are deemed dangerous due to poor working conditions. Workers who work at these sweatshops often endure sexual, physical and mental abuse, who work long unreasonable hours with no leave, lacking any health care benefits whatsoever for meager wage. These sweatshops often employ the usage of child labor and women, as they are easier to control. Today, my research essay will be on sweatshops and how the benefits of Fair trade and anti-sweatshop activism in the long run, can be beneficial. I will explore the poor and harsh working conditions of these workers, how working in a sweatshop can affect their health both mentally and physically, how child labor is being employed in these sweatshops and how women and children are mainly the ones being exploited in these sweatshops. More often than not, many Americans assume that these acts are not ongoing today, and are oblivious to the ways we as consumers, are actually supporting these organizations unknowingly. Authorities should......

Words: 2655 - Pages: 11

Free Essay


...Are Sweatshops Beneficial? January 22, 2016 Situation Analysis What I generally know about sweatshops is they are a horrible place to work. They are the lowest of the low. You work long hours for barely any money. For my audience, being my instructor and fellow classmates, I would assume they know at least that much, more or less. For the instructor’s expectations of my paper would include a couple of things to me. First and foremost a complete understanding of the chosen core reading. Within that I will be able to educate my audience more in depth of this subject being sweatshops. Another instructor expectation would to do all that within a well-organized, proper formatted paper. As for my audience expectations I expect they would to be properly informed on this subject before I put my personal opinion in the paper. I find this subject to be especially relevant to today’s world because we are affected by it daily. A lot of the mainstream products we have and use are made by companies that have sweatshops overseas. Most people would be interested in this because of what we buy can have an effect on the workers. Even though we don’t see it first-hand here in Indianapolis, Indiana, it does matter us as a human being. With this paper I hope to enlighten my fellow classmates on the core reading. Since the paper is more pro-sweatshops I will give some of the cons to it as my response. I want this paper to help educate the reader so they can make a more informed opinion on...

Words: 1097 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...Sweatshops are immoral The vast majority of Americans are shocked by reports of brutal conditions in overseas factories. The U.S. itself has a proud practice of unions and human rights groups that work to prevent such abuses like child labor, refusal to pay overtime pay, exposure to poisonous chemicals, and unsafe working environments. Every day, people from other countries come to America for a chance to work hard in return for better treatment, higher paying jobs than the jobs they can find in their native country. Consumer demands affect a company’s business decision in many cases. Fashion being so fast paced with many companies competing for the global dollars. Every company has cut prices which in turn has them searching for ways to reduce labor costs. Unfortunately the first thing companies do is outsource and turn to sweatshops for cheap fast labor in order to make a profit and to be competitive in the market. Different ethical perspectives guide ethical decision making in the right direction, wrong direction, and walking a fine line direction. Some companies use ethical decision making as a tool to keep their company out of trouble by using proper moral judgment. While other companies could care less if they are being ethical. The ones with unethical practices will do anything to make a dollar. There are also companies that walk a fine line when it comes to sweatshops. They usually know what regulations they can bend but not break. All in all the last two...

Words: 360 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Boycotting Sweatshops

...Boycotting Sweatshops Name: Guangzhen Lyu Student Number: 300772748 Professor’s Name: Catherine Boote Date of submission: Nov 28, 2014 Boycotting Sweatshops! The sweatshop is like a juicer exploiting cheap labor. At present, going with the development of economy, cost of manufacture is increasing rapidly; many companies are building factories in developing countries. Because it can help them to reduce the production costs. Unfortunately, some factories are sweatshops. And what is sweatshop labour like? Sweatshop laborers generally work 60-80 hours per week and are not paid enough money to put food on the table; they sometimes receive only pennies a day for their labor. Often, the sweatshop environment is unsafe – workers are harassed, intimidated, forced to work overtime, and made to work in dangerous and unhealthy environments, even while sick. Workers handle toxic chemical paints, solvents, and glues with their bare hands. (Michael Conlan, 2010) And the workers of sweatshops are working in terrible working environment, enduring the huge working pressure, and losing legal rights. One of the reasons why do we against sweatshops is they usually with the uncomfortable and unsafe environment. Firstly, sweatshops can......

Words: 895 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Are Sweatshops Evil?

...It is no secret that sweatshops are horrible areas of employment. The prevalence of child labor, poor working conditions, and little pay has given sweatshops notoriety amongst the economic and political world. However, when placed in the context of the respective areas sweatshops reside in; sweatshops take on a much more favorable form. Sweatshops arise in poor areas around the world, and this actually plays a major factor when looking at the positive aspects of sweatshops. These aspects include a greater source of income than other local jobs, a better alternative mean of making money, and a positive impact upon women in poor countries. Sweatshops are infamous for providing low wages, but when analyzed in the context of other employment industries in countries where sweatshops are common, sweatshop wages are actually a steady source of income. For example, ninety percent of countries that contain sweatshops produce income that is larger than the overall average income of that respective country. In some cases, up to half of sweatshop countries yield earnings up to three times the national average (Powell). In terms of income, sweatshops allow a superior means of making money than other jobs. Any movement that tries to prohibit sweatshops has to realize that the removal of sweatshops discards a remarkable source of money that citizens desperately need and cannot get anywhere else. The growing movement towards abolishing sweatshops not only removes a decent source of pay,......

Words: 784 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Sweatshops in America

...Sweatshops in America Having a globalized economy provides easy access to just about anything we want or need; however we almost never know where these items come from or how they were produced. You don’t need to go to a third world nation to find a sweatshop as they are very prevalent in California and New York. Sweatshops exist because large retailers don’t produce their own clothing. They hire manufactures to coordinate production, and the manufactures typically enter into contracts that require quick turnaround. Sweatshops in America produce a big portion of the shirts, dresses, blouses, and skirts on the shelves of big American retailers. Retailers often claim they are unaware of the conditions in which their clothes are produced. The retailer reaps the benefits of this labor; without, taking responsibility of the cheap production. Sweatshops are back in America because in recent decades, many garment manufacturers have moved overseas and unions have become less powerful. Devastating budget cuts severely limited the U.S. Department of Labor policing of garment factories. There are now only 800 wage, and hour inspectors employed by the Department of Labor. They inspect six million work sites of all kinds in the USA making it easy to avoid inspection. It is estimated that 4,500 of New York’s 7,000 garment factories are sweatshops. These sweatshops are often mobile operations, making them even more difficult to regulate. The only equipment that is really......

Words: 972 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Sweatshop Labor

...Sweatshop Labor Tiffany Carter PHL 320 April 18, 2016 Douglas Reed Sweatshop Labor Sweatshop labor is used to increase production and profitable revenue within a company for the least amount of extra time and money. Using sweatshop labor is often times used to keep up with consumer demands, while the ethical perspectives of the company are jeopardized leaving the company's ethical environment extremely questionable. Sweatshop labor is against more than two labor laws and is a environment which is prevalent all over the world. Laws have been created to help eliminate and punish companies which use sweatshop labor. Consumer demands often times drive companies to utilize sweatshops for production. When demands from the consumer increase companies look for ways to increase production at the lowest cost possible. They fail to see the unlawfulness and ethics violations that go along with labor law violators. The rise in revenue for companies which use sweatshops is very benefiting if the company is not found to be using sweatshops. Decisions like these normally come from high ranking officials who are only thinking about the bottom line of revenue and not the violations and fines the company will have to pay for. Different ethical perspectives guide decision making when the gains are better than the current situation the company may be experiencing. The unethical decisions which are made normally benefit a few select members of a company for only their personal gains......

Words: 499 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Sweatshop and Globalization

...economies. Rate of trade within the countries have increased with the removal of trade barriers. Trade protection policy is made which protect the trade. Another force that drives globalization will be the enhanced technology in this new era. Digitalisation and invention of technology at a lower cost have massively integrated national markets. No doubt that it has opened new and better area of expansion to the multinational companies. For example, Mc Donald has seized the chance to expand itself and establish its name in the entire world by using the influence of social media. 2.0 Other Causes of Sweatshop Countries such as China and India are commonly known for their high poverty rate compared to other countries around the world. Also, we need to highlight that the amount of sweatshops in these two countries are fairly high as well. The cause of the existence of sweatshop is mainly due to capitalism. According to a graduate student from University of Denver Justin Guay, labourers today are economic terms, short term, and capital investments with high rates of return. In 1995, Newman, a...

Words: 1446 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Are Sweatshops Good or Bad?

...working conditions has caused people to form groups to make standards for every country. These groups are fighting against sweatshops and fighting for labor right on behaves of the poor. A couple of the larger groups are, The Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights, The International Labor Rights Forum formally non-as the National Labor Committee. While there are people fighting against sweatshops, there are also people fighting for sweatshops and educating people on the impact that they have in the communities and in the countries. So what is a sweatshop? According to Global Exchange (2015) sweatshops can defined in many different ways: “The US Department of Labor, a sweatshop is any factory that violates more than one of the fundamental US labor laws, which include paying a minimum wage and keeping a time card, paying overtime, and paying on time. The Union of Needle trades Industrial and Textile Employees (UNITE), the US garment workers union, says any factory that does not respect workers’ right to organize an independent union is a sweatshop. Global Exchange and other corporate accountability groups in the anti-sweatshop movement would add to this definition any factory that does not pay its workers a living wage—that is, a wage that can support the basic needs of a small family.” What countries and companies are being affected by these anti-sweatshop groups and what is considered a “living wage”? A few of the countries that are affected are: Thailand, the......

Words: 1406 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Sweatshops Press Release

...ABC co. 253 Broadway New York, NY 10007 Phone- 212-577-7020 Contact: John Doe FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Tel. 212-555-999 Cell Phone: 347-852-9555 Email: New policy to improve sweatshops work conditions and labor ABC co is proud to release a new policy to improve our work environment and labor in the sweatshops. To prevent any problems with the sweatshop we are releasing a new policy. The new policy will features strict supervision, safer environment, and provide enough income for the employees. Although there are many sweatshops, ABC co intends to offer more, having a new policy means safer work environment. In order to commit to this new policy the company supplier has to agree to it and sign a contract. This way ABC co will know what is going to be done to the factories. This new policy will have an impact on all of us not just ABC co. The consumer would be pleased with the products they purchase comes from a safe work environment. The employees will know there will be no forced labor and they will have their rights. We as a company would like to improve our work environment since most of the sweatshops work conditions are really in bad conditions. We want to have our reputation as an excellent company. We know by releasing this new policy will make a change to our company. This would be great opportunity for the company to get known as a company that have a safe work environment and treat the......

Words: 588 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Sweatshop Labor and Ethics

...Sweatshop Labor and Ethics What is sweatshop labor and is it unethical for clothing companies to engage in such practices? Sweatshop labor is a practice in which workers are taken advantage of by companies paying sub-standard wages and overworking them in difficult situations or dangerous environments. Sweatshops are most prevalent in the “apparel and shoe industries and in toy making.” (Meyers, 2004) Even if such exploitative relationships are mutually beneficial and driven by market demands, manufacturers are engaging in unethical labor practices and companies should forego such conduct “even when the conduct is legal.” (Mayer, 2007) Consumer Demand It can be argued that consumer demand can directly impact how companies make business decisions. Consumer demand can dictate the production of goods, which can cause companies to look towards the bottom line in order to maximize profits while minimizing cost. This can lead companies to make decisions that fall into an ethically grey area. Ethical Perspectives Ethical decision making can be guided by each individual’s ethical perspective. While each perspective has its own strengths, it also has its own weaknesses. Examining the business decisions resulting in the Challenger disaster in 1986 through a behavioral ethics perspective, analysts are able to demonstrate that ethically ambiguous decisions plague companies to this day. At the time, NASA was notified by the contractor that there was statistical information......

Words: 489 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Labor Practices - Sweatshops

...Labor Practices - Sweatshops Astrid Vargas PHL/320 April 6, 2015 Jennifer Stephens A “sweatshop” is defined by the United States Department of Labor as a factory that violates two or more labor laws. The use of questionable labor practices, popularly knows as “sweatshop labor”, is widespread in the production of consumer goods (Paharia, 2013). Major international brands such as Nike and Apple are some of the high-profile companies that have been exposed to such labor abuses. Most members of society automatically consider sweatshops as an unacceptable source of labor because they are known for subjecting employees to dangerous and unsanitary labor conditions. Research organizations have consistently found that while economists and activists disagree about the costs and benefits of such practices, consumers have a strong preference to purchase products made without sweatshop labor. Mostly because consumers are concerned and often disturbed when labor abuses occur but the demand for products that guarantee favorable working conditions remains low. Unfortunately, there are a variety of reasons that explain why this is an ongoing, conflicting situation. While surveys and research suggest that people do not endorse the use of sweatshop labor, actions speak louder than words. If consumers really cared as they stated, there would be more demand for sweatshop free products and companies to profit from such products. Consumers may not really disapprove of these practices and......

Words: 542 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Review of "Story of a Sweatshop Girl"

...After reading “Story of a Sweatshop Girl”, I could not help but feel good. This was one of those surprise stories that you would never expect to come from a sweatshop worker. Sadie Frowne was obviously an educated woman who had ambition. To read this document from her perspective was a very enlightening experience. Sadie was very intelligent and independent. She wanted to take full advantage of everything that America had to offer. Sadie educated herself by going to night classes. She recognized that through education and bettering herself she could achieve a better, fuller life. I thought it was interesting how she stated that she forced herself to go out after work instead of going to sleep. This kind of reminds me of the way young people are today. Many of Sadie’s characteristics give me the impression that she could live in today’s world. Sadie liked the finer things in life even on such a modest income. She enjoyed finer clothing in hopes that it could help her fit in with the higher class citizens. Sadie was extremely supportive of the union, yet was afraid of being associated as being a socialist. What surprised me about Sadie Frowne was her calm demeanor throughout her testimonial. She seemed to emit almost no emotion when talking about the death of her parents and the injuries some workers suffered. Sadie never complained about the hardships that she had faced. I was rather shocked at how casually she would speak about getting injured at work. “We all have accidents...

Words: 1186 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Sweatshirts from Sweatshops

...BA 3300 – BUSINESS CORNERSTONE Assessing Sweatshirts from Sweatshop 1. “According to the recent report by the WorldWeave Foundation, a nonprofit organization funded by American garment workers’ unions, Transterra owns five factories in Third World countries……” Author violates one of the Universal Intellectual standards, clarity. He states that the WorldWeave Foundation recently reported some details about Transterra Textile’s operations. Not every reader knows about that organization and the author did not provide more resources to add credibility for its report. To fix that error author have to provide more information about the organization and add two or three credible sources, so reader could learn more. 2. “All the factory employees, no matter how young, work ten-hour shifts at physically exhausting and mentally deadening jobs, and they are often forced to work overtime”. The author violates another intellectual standard, breadth. Author takes only one point of view. He does not consider that maybe workers that work for that company are happy to work there, and the working conditions that we think are horrible, are normal for them. To fix an error author would have to leave this statement out. 3. “WorldWeave observers noticed some children who appeared to be as young as eleven or twelve working with dangerous fabric-cutting machines…” Author violates another intellectual standard, Accuracy. Observers might be wrong about......

Words: 343 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Nike and Sweatshop Labor

...单薄的一句承诺,终其一生的等待 ——《狼族少年》影评 这是一部讲述狼族少年与普通少女爱情故事的影片,或许情节略显老套,但是没有猜忌,没有误会,没有撕心裂肺,只有纯粹的感动,却是直戳人心底最柔软的角落。《狼族少年》塑造了一个温情的氛围。像是旧时期的家庭剧,昏黄色调的画面中,大人孩子围坐一桌吃着热腾腾的饭菜。 他,本是茹毛饮血、野性难驯的狼孩,是需要被掩盖的实验半残品,他不懂规矩,为了觅食,闯入她们家。当众人避之不及,警局不予过问时,是她善良的姐姐收留了他,给他人的待遇,面对他的抢食,姐姐只是温暖的抚慰抱怨的三个孩子,下顿我多做点,他那么可怜,你们多同情下他。 她,本是身体孱弱、性格孤僻的小孩,被一个无耻的爱慕者苦苦纠缠,对突然闯进的他,最初她看不惯他的粗鲁和愚笨,很是排斥。可是只会像狼“哼哼”的他,会帮她搬重物,会为她驱赶骚扰者,会在钢筋掉落时,护住她和家人,由于他一点一滴的介入,她开始走出孤僻的世界,融入孩子们各种各样的游戏,重拾欢笑。  她拿着训狗书慢慢学习,用食物做饵,教他如何细嚼慢咽,如何刷牙、系鞋带、写字、画画,她会弹琴唱歌给他听,把他打扮的稀奇古怪。而他,只要一个土豆、红薯或玉米,就能欢快的乖乖听话,每次学会做对后,他讨赏一般把头伸到她面前,满心期待的等着她温柔的抚摸,每次嬉戏玩耍时,都会对她察言观色,开心着她的开心。在他身上,人性的善良与单纯,美好的让人向往。 然而,现实社会怎么会那么简单的包容一个异类?在他的观念里,没有道德法律伦常,只有守护自己在乎的对象,所以,当她遇袭时,他愤怒的变成野性难训的狼人,全力守护,不惜杀人。人类对于未知的恐惧,只会加大我们防患于未然的防护,宁可错杀一千,不可使一人漏网。   他被关进了圈养牲畜的肮脏铁屋,脖子、脚脖都被手腕粗的铁链牢牢拴住,门外若干手持枪械的人一刻也不松懈的把守,或许我该为他庆幸,至少他没有像实验用的小白鼠被人化验,探究他为什么会变身,为什么抗打击,又为什么体温高于常人,衰老缓慢!   残酷的现实里,只有她一家人体谅他,默默为他清扫脏臭的铁屋,姐姐依然关心他的吃住,她依然会去陪伴他。但是,现世没有他的安身之所,他想带她逃离,她却不愿成为世人追踪他的线索。听着他嘴里磕磕巴巴的第一次吐出不成句的“不要走”时,看到这里我的眼泪一下子就掉下来了。而她哭到崩溃,却也只能不停打他,用石头扔他,说着“对不起”驱逐他离开,而他只是愣愣的流着泪,不知所以然的看着她转身离去。 第一次分别,一晃就是47年,她早已远走他乡定居美国,因为老房屋的买卖重回故土,夜半,冥冥之中似乎有所牵引,她避开熟睡的孙女独自走向记忆中脏臭的铁屋。当她在响动中拉开了关着他的那个小铁屋子的门,早已经没有了当初的恶臭,只有他搬来的各种各样山花,她走向最里面用来关他的房间时,里面透出温暖的橙黄色的光。在她开门的瞬间,没有吱呀的声音,门被打开了,看到了嘴唇干裂的他。他的容貌没有改变,还是一如从前的他,依然在等着,坐在床上的屁股抬起来,想起身又怕她生气,就递给她一张纸条。那是她当年离开时留下的,当她接过纸条,看着上面模糊的字迹,写着“等我,我会再回来的”时,眼泪再也抑制不住了。...

Words: 338 - Pages: 2