Teenage Drinking

In: Other Topics

Submitted By zookeee
Words 636
Pages 3
Basis of Argument
“Let My Teenager Drink” by T.R. Reid and “Don’t Make Teen Drinking Easier” by Joseph A Califano are articles on opposite sides of the teen drinking debate. While Reid has experience living abroad and seeing teen drinking in a real world scenario, Califano has experience as the founder and chairman of the National Center of Addiction and Substance abuse. While both had some good points, the question remains, what are we (as a nation/parents) trying to prevent? Is it the dangers of binge drinking or lifelong alcohol problems? While Califano’s argument was more about lifelong alcohol problems, he had more facts and statistics to back up his argument. Califano’s argument was more credible and more thought out, perhaps because it was precisely a rebuttal to Reid’s. Let’s look at both essays.
Reid’s article was published first and his tone is one of a fatherly concern. He has children and looks at teen drinking with the eyes of a father. He states that he has raised kids in three environments, Tokyo, London, and Colorado. He sees the problem of teen drinking due to the fact that it is done in secret. He asserts that American teens look at drinking as “pregaming”. The goal of this is to get drunk. He maintains that teens abroad don’t have a tendency to do this because they don’t have to hide drinking. It is simply not needed because it is legal to drink there.
Reid uses a logical fallacy we call “begging the question”. He claims that the US drinking age of 21 is the cause of teenage binge drinking in America; teenagers have to hide it because it is illegal. However, there are plenty of families in America, just as in the UK or abroad that allow their teens to drink, so they learn to do so “responsibly”. Reid ends his argument with the rhetorical technique “loaded question” when he says, “In the United States, our kids learn drinking is something to be…...

Similar Documents

Teenage Pregnancy

...Amanda Jennings Mrs. Boyce English 12 Teen pregnancy is a widely debated topic in todays society. Approximately 900,000 teenagers become pregnant in the united states each year before the age of twenty years old (Frick 21). The pregnancy rate for the united states alone for girls aged fifteen through nineteen stands at a eighty four pregnancies per 1000 girls (19). Countries like the United states, Romania, Belarus, and Bulgaria have the highest rates of pregnancy above seventy pregnancies per 1000 young women (19). Teen prenancy is one of the most controversial social topics of our time. Teen pregnancy has continuosly became a problem through the years. In 1950, the right thing to do if pregnancy occurred, was to get married. In 1955, only six percent of caucasian teenage girls were pregnant outside of marriage; today it stands at forty two percent ("The Elkhart Project").The teen birth rate was fifty percent higher in 1957 than it is now ("The Elkhart Project"). In 1992, the federal goverment spent more than thirty four billion dollars on welfare for families begun by teens ("The Elkhart Project"). Overly accepting attitudes from parents pose a problem in today's outlooks on pregnancy from teenagers. According to several studies, younger siblings of teen parents are two to six times more likely to become pregnant ( Frick 77 ). People say teen pregnancy is happening because eighty three percent of the television...

Words: 1269 - Pages: 6

Drinking

...Philosophy 03/11/12 Drinking I have made many big decisions in my life, but one of my biggest ones is the choice not to drink. Many people take the chance and get their scholarships ripped up or even they could possibly get caught behind the wheel of a car and get charged for the zero tolerance law for people drinking under the age of twenty-one and possibly serve time in jail. Underage drinking is not worth the risk of getting caught. Overall, I am not going to start drinking before the age of twenty-one because there are way to many risks involved that can jeopardize my future and I honestly don’t think that it is worth it. The ethical egoism of my choice is so that I would not be charged with underage drinking charges because that will stick with me for the rest of my life. It would be hard to convince my children not to drink until they are twenty-one because I would not be able to set an example if I did not follow what I was saying. Another reason I do not drink is because of the lifetime risk. Around five thousand people under the age of twenty-one die due to motor vehicle accidents, suicide, and also falls, burns, and drowning all because they had too much to drink and could not control or think through what they were doing completely. Another dangerous effect of me drinking at my age is that my brain is not yet fully developed, so it could affect my brain from developing fully. Other affects that drinking has on a person at a young age is liver problems and...

Words: 1020 - Pages: 5

Teenage Rebellion

...The two novels The Last Song and The Outsiders both display numerous characteristics of teenage rebellion, where as one is more modern while the other is in an era of irresponsible excess. The more modernistic novel, The Last Song, displays a different outlook, compared to the severity of The Outsiders. There are several reasons behind these teens rebellious outburst, such as abandonment, environment, and revenge. Also, the punishments these teenagers must face are more severe in the more classical novel compared to the more current novel. The rebellious actions shown throughout both novels are quite similar, while displaying the same actions with a modern twist. Overall, today's teens display less severity, compared to the volatile actions of the teenagers in The Outsiders. The severity of the rebellious actions varies between a more modernistic outlook, compared to a classical approach. Ronnie, the main character of The Last Song, rebels against her father by refusing to play the piano. She refuses to use her incredible piano playing skills purposely to hurt her father's feelings. Ronnie also hangs with the wrong crowd, which gets charges filed against her. Although, Ronnie seems like a troubled teen, she does not engage in usage of alcohol or any illegal substances. Ronnie's mother becomes angered with the incidents that continuously occur with Ronnie. “Mom probably believed that the louder she yelled about Ronnie's grades, or Ronnie's friends, or the fact that Ronnie...

Words: 1087 - Pages: 5

Drinking

...The drinking age should be lowered in the US By ashley_white11, Auburn, NY More by this author Email me when ashley_white11 contributes work The drinking age should be lowered in the US Image Credit: John W., Evergreen, CO The author's comments: Quotes This was my English essay and I was told to publish it on here. Quotes The drinking age should be lowered back to the age of 18. I feel that for many reasons including that people are adults at that age and should be able to make their own decisions. Setting the Minimum Legal Drinking Age (MLDA) to 21 is unconstitutional and setting the drinking age to 21 sent the wrong message to teens in the US. The drinking age should be lowered to 18 years old because people are considered adults at that age. When you are 18 you receive the rights and responsibilities of adulthood. When you are that age you can vote, drive a vehicle, get married and even join the military. So why not be able to consume alcohol? When you are 18 you should be able to make your own decisions about alcohol consumption. This includes taking the responsibilities of life or death. Another reason is that when the US lowered the drinking age it sent the wrong message about alcohol consumption to people under the age of 21. In this case it seemed like they raised the drinking age to 21 because people where more mature at 21 years old than they are at 18. So teens want to consume alcohol to appear more mature. If the drinking age were lowered it...

Words: 568 - Pages: 3

Teenage Pregnancey

... the consequences that these actions can and do have on their own bodies and their developing fetus. Some of the consequences of drinking while pregnant are that the fetus can develop fetal alcohol syndrome and there is also a risk of the fetus developing birth defects. There can also be complications when the teenage mothers give birth, mainly due to the fact that they are not done growing thereby not having the room to accommodate a growing fetus, some of these consequences are an infant with a low birth weight, pelvic bones that are to small causing an obstructed labor, and preterm labor(www.familyfirstaid.org/teen-pregnancy.html). There are many other issues that these teen mothers will face and in the following paragraphs we will be discussing these issues. The next issue that we will be discussing is what the financial difficulties are that teenage parents will face. This affects both the men and women, both parents will have to face huge responsibilities at an early age. The teenage parents will need to find jobs, an apartment, and have to provide for the needs of their child. My teenagers are unaware of just what having an infant requires such as a car seat (which many hospitals need to inspect, before allowing you to leave with your newborn), diapers, clothing, shoes, stroller, diaper bag, bottles, formula, crib, sheets, blankets, and much, much more. All of these items cost hundreds of dollars in the beginning and tens of thousands of dollars threw out the life...

Words: 1416 - Pages: 6

Teenage

...My Life as a Teenager My Life as Teenager Teenage life is a critical days for teenagers.   It is the time wherein we experience identity crisis… we were troubled of so many things around us.   The physical changes that occurs commonly to a teenager… also we experience some emotions or feelings that is difficult to explain.   In this stage some of the teenagers feel in love in which some find it difficult to handle.   They become obsessed and others become rebellious to their parents thinking that, they’re parents could not support nor will be against with what they want. Teenage life must not be confused.   Teenagers should not make the flow of his life too fast… explore it but remember there’s limits or boundaries that should be consider.   Being careful with everything is more important than regretting one single wrong action done. Teenagers should take the advices of their parents or elders for these advices will help them understand their self better.   It will help them become a better person. My life as a teenager is such wonderful.   Though sometimes, I experienced doubts and some teenagers will say that my life is a boring one, I’m very much sure that I’m in the right track for my parents guide me always. I’ m proud of being myself… thinking and analyzing everything to make my life as teenager good as ever, no regrets but good memories to reminisce when time comes. Teenage life is the most exciting, memorable experience that one should treasure!   Just enjoy......

Words: 256 - Pages: 2

Teenage Depression

...Depression is a disease that deflects the human psyche in such a way that the afflicted tends to act and react abnormally towards others and themselves. Therefore depression is strongly linked with teenage suicide. Adolescent suicide brings more deaths in youngsters of age 15 to 19 than cardiovascular disease or cancer. The reason why depression is often over looked in children and adolescent is only because” children are always able to express how they feel”. Sometimes the symptoms of mood disorders take on different forms in children than adults. Adolescence is a time of emotional turmoil, mood, swings, gloomy thoughts and heightened sensitivity. It is a time of rebellion and experimentation. A psychiatrist observed that the challenge is to identify depressive symptomatology which may be super imposed on the back drop of more transient but expected developed storm”. Therefore, diagnosis should not lay only in physicians hands but be associated with parents, teachers and anyone who interacts with parents and teachers on daily basis. Unlike adult depression symptoms of youth depression are often masked. Instead of expressing sadness, teenagers may express boredom and irritability or may chose to engage in risky behaviors’. Mood disorders, substance abuse and suicide, all of which can hide depressive symptoms. The sign of clinical depression include mark changes in mood and associated behaviors that range from sadness...

Words: 518 - Pages: 3

Teenage Drinking

... 21 is the cause of teenage binge drinking in America; teenagers have to hide it because it is illegal. However, there are plenty of families in America, just as in the UK or abroad that allow their teens to drink, so they learn to do so “responsibly”. Reid ends his argument with the rhetorical technique “loaded question” when he says, “In the United States, our kids learn drinking is something to be done in the dark, and quickly. Is that the lesson we want to teach them about alcohol use?” Califano starts his article with the statement that Reid’s piece is a “dangerous example of what happens if we let anecdote trump facts”. The scope of Califano’s argument is a little different than that of Reid’s however. While Reid talks about teen “binge” drinking that has been so lamented in the news recently, Califano’s talks about the effect of teen drinking on the teen’s growing body and the teen’s future relationship to alcohol. While some may say these are one in the same, the fact that there have been numerous news stories, articles, etc., on the dangers of teen binge drinking makes the basis of these essays a little different. Califano states that alcohol is a “major contributing factor in the three leading causes of teen death – accidents, homicide, and suicide – and increases the chances of juvenile delinquency and crime.” However, Reid states in his article that his teens “did their drinking at a bar, concert, or party. There were adults – and, often, police – around to......

Words: 636 - Pages: 3

Drinking

...Old enough to fight, old enough to drink Brandon Molett Sociology: 120 Instructor Daniel Beteta April 23rd 2013 There has been an age old conflict regarding the United States military. If you are old enough to fight and die for your country, why are you not old enough to enjoy an alcoholic beverage? Marines who are 18 can be thrown into the very teeth of it. They face death in battle. They make life-and-death decisions in split seconds. But here's a simple choice they can't make: “Miller or Bud?” (Stetz, 2007) Some may argue that 17, 18, 19, and 20 year olds are not capable of handling the responsibilities that go along with consuming alcoholic beverages. To those people I say, if you do not trust someone under the age of 21 to be responsible when it comes to alcohol consumption, then why do you trust them to carry firearms into battle and make life and death situations? In 2007 the United States Marine Corps listened to these complaints from the Marines and decided that Marines, who were overseas, in ports of call where the drinking age was under 21, would allow those Marines to consume alcohol. It is also up to the commanders’ discretion to approve beer being served on special occasions such as returning from war. These Marines would only be allowed to drink on base though. These young people are being asked to make enormous sacrifices, said John McCardell, the former president of Middlebury College in Vermont who runs Choose...

Words: 1208 - Pages: 5

Teenage Pregnancy

...Teenage Pregnancy Unit Teenage pregnancy: an overview of the research evidence Introduction In 1999 the government’s ten-year national Teenage Pregnancy Strategy was launched. The main aims of the strategy are to: • Reduce the rate of teenage conceptions with the specific aim of halving the rate of conceptions among under-18s, and to set a firmly established downward trend in the rate of conceptions among under-16s, by 2010 • Increase the participation of teenage parents in education, training and employment to 60% by 2010, to reduce their risk of long-term social exclusion. This briefing presents headline findings from key research relating to teenage pregnancy and parenthood which has emerged (mainly) since the launch of the strategy. The topics covered include research on young people’s sexual behaviour; sources of sex and relationships information; what works in preventing teenage pregnancy; who is at risk of becoming a teenage parent; how to support teenage parents, and many more. It draws on a range of sources including systematic reviews of the effectiveness of prevention and support interventions, national surveys and primary research studies. The emphasis is on the UK and specifically English research. It was compiled by Catherine Dennison, Research Manager supporting the Teenage Pregnancy Unit. Although not representing a systematic or exhaustive search of the published literature, the briefing is intended to be of use to those engaged in implementing the...

Words: 7408 - Pages: 30

Drinking

... if you were drinking the maximum penalty is $5000 and you can lose your vehicle. Additional to legal fees your liability insurance may not cover an accident and you could be sued. The only way to be drinking and driving is to have a plan before you go out. First, you could have a designated driver; you could also stay over at a friend’s house, or give your car keys to someone that would not let you drive home. You could use public transportation or a cab. If you plan to drink and drive home, make sure you drink slowly. Eat a good meal before you start drinking. If you feel you had too much to drink, stop a couple of hours before you plan to drive home. Listen to your friends and accept their help. Every 30 minutes someone in this country is killed in an alcohol related accident. Last year alone over one million people were injured in alcohol related accidents. About one in every three Americans will be involved in an alcohol related accident in sometime in their life. About one third of those arrested or convicted of drunk driving in the United States are repeated offenders. As many as 76% of convicted drunk drivers nationwide continue to drive with a suspended license. More than 40% of teenage deaths occur in car accidents. Law prohibits bartenders, waiters and others from providing alcohol to under age and intoxicated people. Anyone violating these laws can be held liable for damages caused by DUI. The damages caused by drinking and driving are priceless and terrible......

Words: 1089 - Pages: 5

Teenage Pregnancy

... Risk for Low Birth Weight C. Negative Effects on Overall Quality of Life 1. Lower Level of Education 2. Less Money Earned 3. Depression 4. Social Isolation 5. Limited Job Opportunities D. Transition Sentence IV. Many Problems Arise When Teenagers Raise Babies A. The Majority of Teen Moms Are Unmarried and Undereducated 1. Lower Income a. Lack of Nutrition b. Difficulty Obtaining Childcare c. Decreased Options of Continuing Education 2. High Rates of Poverty a. Unsafe Feeling b. Lowself Esteem c. Lowself Efficiency B. Transition Sentence V. Teenage Mothers Tend To Have Poor Prenatal Care A. Mothers and Unborn Childern Suffer From Malnutrition 1. Lack of Information 2. Lack of Money B. Teenagers Tend to Slack on Prenatal Doctors Visits 1. Less Screening for Potential Problems 2. Less Preparation and Counseling C. Mothers Do Not Receive Counseling on the Actual Birthing Process D. Important Information on Appropriate Behavior for the Mother Is not Received 1. Smoking 2. Drinking 3. Drugs E. Transition Sentence VI. Conclusion Now i just need a Introductory Paragraph. Which I have no idea how to start. My teacher told me to turn it in to a story and entertain the reader....

Words: 439 - Pages: 2

Teenage Pregnancy

...Teenage Pregnancy Teen pregnancy is something that affects over one million young teens in the United States. For some, these pregnancies are planned but 85% of these teens the pregnancy is unplanned. This can cause a lot of endless problems in the life of the teen and the newborn child. There are a lot of things that can cause an unplanned teen pregnancy, such as teens experimenting with sexual encounters at a young age. Another major cause is the lack of guidance due to guardians that are blind or do not want to believe in such activities. These causes can have devastating effects on the teen and the newborn in the household. Some effects of early pregnancy will include an unexpected rise of responsibility for the teen and can cause many health concerns for both teen and newborn child. Teens experimenting are the leading cause in the unplanned pregnancies. As a teenager in high school ages there are a lot of peer pressures. Such as experimenting with alcohol and unprotected sexual intercourse. Drinking and the use of narcotics also largely have an impact on the judgment of the teen before the pre-pregnancy comes about. Experimenting can cause many effects on the teen and the relationships at hand, including the relationships with the baby’s mom or dad and also the parents of the teens. Another way of experimenting is the pregnancy caused in the sequel of either a long-time dating of the boyfriend or the other case of those random one night stands or hook-ups...

Words: 926 - Pages: 4

Teenage Life

...Carlos P. Egipto BM14116 Teenage Life Entering the world of teenage is one of the toughest but most exciting part of life that one person goes through. As we develop physically, our minds also develop and acquire learnings from our own experiences in life. Teenagers experience a great deal of life changing events and some studies even suggest that the teenage years may be the most stressful time in people lives. Things will be scary, confusing and different but that’s not what makes the teenage life difficult. It is being in the process of adjusting because as we enter the world of teenage, we will encounter different things in life and there are changes that we will experience. Some of these changes come from maturation but most come from learning through what we experience or encounter. There are a lots of changes between childhood and being a teenager, and most of these changes are unexpected. Before, as a child, we constantly hear others complaining about being a teenager. They complain about being themselves because they cared too much about how they look, especially the girls. This happens because as a teenager, we may be dealing with lots of physical changes in our lives. Our life is changing just like our body as we enter the adolescence period. In this period, we have already completed the process of puberty. Girls have already started their menstrual cycle. This is sometimes very difficult for girls as some of their friends may have entered and completed......

Words: 328 - Pages: 2

Reader Response - Teenage Drinking

... old and wanting to go to parties which will be overflowing with alcohol? Her daughter’s curiosity will return, and she will know of the dangers linked with the activity. The inclusion of this information would have given a more accurate link to Liam Donaldson’s report; it would have shown her opinion on teenage drinking, a large issue that Donaldson is addressing. Many people say that such drinks should not be given to children as young as seven, no matter what quantity. There is a legal drinking age for a reason, and the law should be accepted. However, in France alcohol is a significant part of a meal, and is introduced at a very young age. It is commonplace for a twelve or thirteen year old to have a glass of slightly watered down alcohol with the family meal. If this is accepted in some cultures, why is it so opposed in others? I agree with Dr McCartney’s article. I do not believe that it is acceptable for people under the age of eighteen to be getting drunk but I also believe that it is good practise to introduce alcohol in a safe environment, such as the family home, to physically teach about the dangers of alcohol, and to allow children experience it first-hand among adults who have been drinking for many years. Yours Sincerely,...

Words: 729 - Pages: 3