Premium Essay

Tensions Between Autonomy And Responsibility

Submitted By
Words 1692
Pages 7
I. Abstract
Even though it supposedly works to advance the good of the country and its citizens, the government has been responsible for serious research misconduct in several cases. One study in particular, an examination of the effects of THC on tumors, did not produce the results that the government wanted. They then suppressed the study, even though its findings could greatly benefit cancer research. The government employed values in an unacceptable and direct role, allowing biased views to overcome the need to promote the good of all.
II. Introduction
Before examining the details of the situation, it is important to understand why marijuana became illegal in the first place. The major reasons relate directly to racism and prejudice. In the late 1920s, around the period of the Great Depression, many Mexicans were migrating to the United States to seek employment. Americans already had trouble finding jobs, so all of these foreigners entering the country and adding to the competition greatly angered them. Several Mexicans brought marijuana with them and introduced it to the country. The government viewed this as the perfect opportunity to manipulate the views of the general public, who were unfamiliar with …show more content…
This involves the necessity of anticipating both intended and unintended consequences. The pursuit of truth is more imperative than any other value, according to Douglas, and politicians should not interfere with this path. The scientists involved in the research are responsible for unreasonable actions. As scientists, they aim to pursue knowledge for its own sake and if for any other reason, then to do it for the purpose of beneficence. They clearly must have understood this, but the threat of the government’s power and influence forced

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Similarities Between Classical and Modern Liberals Are Greater Than the Differences. Discuss

...Similarities between classical and modern liberalism are greater than the differences. Discuss. (45 marks) Typically, liberalism is categorised into two separate components; classical liberalism, which was fashioned during the 19th century as a result of the industrial revolution, and the more recent Modern Liberalism which emerged as industrialisation continued within the UK. Although both divisions of Liberalism unavoidably overlap in attitudes and approaches regarding the theory behind the ideology, I believe, fundamentally, that clear tensions between these aspects of Liberalism are more evident when analysing this ideology. Some will say that both classical and modern liberalists possess a number of parallel approaches towards this political theory and its key concepts. Firstly, both strands of Liberalism believe in the necessity of some kind of a state, since life without a state, as Thomas Hobbes stated, would be ‘solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short’. Both views consider the existence of a state to be essential in order to protect individual rights. Since liberals generally considered humanity to be self-interested and egoistical, a state was needed to ensure that individuals did not exploit other individuals’ rights, through acts of stealing, harming, or even slavery, and was therefore the only thing that was capable of restraining all individuals and groups within society. Hobbes and Locke particularly stressed the importance of creating a ‘social contract’...

Words: 1729 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Ethics

...Teaching and Teacher Education 27 (2011) 648e656 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Teaching and Teacher Education journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/tate Teachers’ critical incidents: Ethical dilemmas in teaching practice Orly Shapira-Lishchinsky 1 Department of Educational Administration, Leadership and Policy, School of Education, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan 52900, Israel a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t Article history: Received 21 March 2010 Received in revised form 10 November 2010 Accepted 11 November 2010 The aim of this study is to explore ethical dilemmas in critical incidents and the emerged responses that these incidents elicit. Most teachers try to suppress these incidences because of the unpleasant feelings they evoke. Fifty teachers participated in the study. A three-stage coding process derived from grounded theory was utilized. A taxonomy of critical incidents by means of the ATLAS.ti 5.0 revealed a multifaceted model of ethical dilemmas, among them clashing with rules, standards, or norms in school, as well as a multitude of derived responses. The results encourage the development of educational programmes based on teachers’ critical incidents. Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Teaching Ethics Ethical knowledge Ethical dilemmas Schools 1. Introduction 2. Theoretical background Teachers deal with many ethical problems in their practice. They encounter issues such as inappropriate allocation of resources, situations...

Words: 10192 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

Shile Children Have a Legitimate Right to Freedom and Autonomy, This Is Necessarily Limited by the Authority of the Teacher to Descipline and Punish

...While children have a legitimate right to freedom and autonomy, this is necessarily limited by the authority of the teacher to discipline and punish. Children have a legitimate right to freedom and autonomy. However, these are not rights that children intuitively understand and know how to exercise. Nor do they develop naturally as the child matures. Instead they must be taught and learned. Children must be guided and educated into an understanding and appreciation of what it means to be both free and autonomous individuals within a given society. In order for this to occur, both autonomy and freedom must prevail within the classroom. Only in such an environment can children safely practise what it means to be free and autonomous individuals and learn how to responsibly exercise these rights. It is, perhaps, somewhat of a paradox that at the heart of both freedom and autonomy lie control and restraint. Children need to first learn these virtues in order to become free and autonomous individuals who are able to responsibly function within society and take full advantage of the opportunities available to them. In order for this to happen restraints may well be necessary. Teachers must have a degree of authority over children in order to educate them to exercise their freedom and autonomy responsibly. If the teacher’s authority is questioned or not respected, then the child’s successful transition into a responsible, autonomous adult may be compromised. To maintain a sense...

Words: 610 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Work Life Balance

...as positive and negative aspects of their work, and how these affect their perceptions of the quality of work life (QWL) and their career development decisions. Design/methodology/approach – This is a qualitative study using data collected from an online discussion forum. Thematic and textual analysis was performed to identify core themes associated with perceptions of QWL and career development. Data analysis was based on the researchers’ interpretations of narratives based on the online postings of 140 part-time MBA students and guided by the literature. Findings – Four major themes emerged as domains of tensions within which employees operated to construct meanings around their work life. These include: internal and external tension, private and public tension, self and otherness tension, and present and future tension. Career development support, flexibility and autonomy in job design as well as flexibility in career development planning emerged as positive career development strategies that would affect employees’ perceptions of QWL. Research limitations/implications – This research advances the understanding of employees’ perceptions on QWL and its relationship with career development planning. Future studies should include primary data gathered through face-to-face interaction to overcome the limitations of...

Words: 9993 - Pages: 40

Free Essay

Ethics Game Simulations Finale

...course to be held. For this exercise I am using Baird’s Four Core Lenses: Ethical Decision-Making. The building blocks of the four lenses are rationality, equality, autonomy and sensibility. Rights/responsibility lens is to do right even when no one is looking. Relationship is more about the community and harmony, results is the immediate situation and reputation is about the outlook (Kennedy 2011). Tension and Stakeholders The first step in the process is exploring the values in tension; according to (EthicsGame 2013) preparing the best statement of the issue should highlight the tension, but ensuing company rules and policies are enforced. Focusing on helping everyone involved, avoiding focus on single individual and preventing an unpleasant outcome. This process lead to the statement: how to ensure that Gayle can talk about what happened while meeting my responsibilities as a manger for a fair investigation. Next I had to identify the stakeholders, which are shareholders, VP of HR, Director of sales, the said victim, the excused and the Director of research (EthicsGame 2013). The third step is being reasonable with the rights/responsibilities lens and identifying my duties. This portion of the exercise I got all four duties correct, to notify HR, treat all people with respect and fulfill my responsibilities,...

Words: 822 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

My Job

...crewmembers make up the other. Dissatisfied performers create a downward spiral in productivity, and stressed crewmembers are unavailable or missing from work. The job characteristics theory of motivation is applicable to both groups to create improved job satisfaction and organizational productive by lowering stress. Improving the performers behavior by incorporating new stunts in routines can create a better aerial performance. In turn, AirDevils may begin to win awards in competition with the new routine, leading to improved job satisfaction. Some crewmembers are also aspiring performers, but too many are not able to keep pace because of injury and job stress. To reduce dissatisfaction and stressors, AirDevils must alleviate problems between performers and crewmembers through feedback. Analysis of AirDevils Simulation The AirDevils simulation provides dynamically structured scenes to build ones theory of employee motivation and the reduction of workplace stressors. The simulation depicts an aerial stunts company known as AirDevils, of which the stunt performers feel the company has become inflexible and rigid. Because AirDevils began...

Words: 1208 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Relationship Between Work and Family

...10/14/2015 Sociology/Relationship Between Work And Family term paper 16434        + 1­888­823­90­60       + 1­302­351­4405   A paper writing site You CAN trust! What We Do How It Works Our Promise 10+ years of experience in paper writing Here you can easily hire a Any assignment on any level. Any deadline! private writer in as early as 5 Open 24/7 Your essay will be done on time! minutes. With 200+ writers 200+ essay writers. Live Chat. Great support available 24/7, we can help with No Plagiarism. Satisfaction. Confidentiality. any written assignment (from simple essays to dissertations). Our writers are all Uni graduates able to work effectively on any level under time I nstant Quote  constraints. O rder Now Well­versed in most subjects and citation C ontact Support  L ive Chat  L og In to Account  styles, our writers have years of ghostwriting experience doing both academic and professional projects. Home ,  Why Use Us ,  Services ,  Work Samples ,  Client Testimonials , Sociology/Relationship Between Work And Family term paper 16434 Sociology term papers F AQ  D iscounts  F ormat Specifications  P rivacy Policy  T erms of Service  Beware of Fakes News Live support is now available round­the­clock 24/7 Disclaimer: Free essays on Sociology posted on this site were donated by anonymous users and are provided for 20,096 Client Testimonials (as of Jan 24...

Words: 3547 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Causes of Workplace Stress

...Causes of Workplace Stress There are many factors that can exacerbate the causes of stress in the workplace. The challenges faced by people in the workplace make the job more exciting and interesting. However, there are challenges that can also have negative effects. The normal reaction to stress is tension, anxiety and excitement and work-life goes back to normal after a while. If however, the stress becomes overwhelming or if it happens too often, there can be a problem getting back to the normal state and one is no longer able to relax. The most common causes of stress in the workplace are the following: • Demands at work become too extreme or excessive • There is disproportion between the workload and the abilities of the employees • Fear for security of employment as a result of massive layoffs • Ineffective management which makes employees feel they are in a dead end • Dealing with reorganizations in the workplace • Dealing with workplace bullies • Dealing with sexual harassment in the workplace • Information overload which causes mental stress • A poor physical working environment • Employees who fear they will be declared as redundant Demands can be seen as a result of technological advances that make work more efficient but in the end, eventually require employees to perform more tasks. This is the contemporary cause of workplace stress. Expansion of technology demands that workers constantly perform near their peak, be competitive and constantly...

Words: 969 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Hrm 300 Week 3 Scenario Analysis Paper

...After completing a study on flexibility, four frequent factors result from too much flexibility. The variable versus fixed factor is described as, “impractical ways that flexibility policies are often implemented” (Bourke). This tension provides flexibility but is unattainable due to time limits, or may hindrance employees should they decide to use it. A second factor, supportive versus unsupportive work climates, is persuaded by the organization. Providing incentives to those who don’t choose work over family may cause employees to work longer hours rather than spending time at home. The third factor, equitable versus inequitable implementation, shows that employees may feel flexibility is only available to people in certain situations. A mother of a sick child is deemed to have access to a more flexible schedule than someone who plays sports and has games during work hours. The final factor, autonomy versus organizational control, shows how an employee is controlled. An employers may let someone take a couple days off, but require them to be “on-call” just in case. Although these tensions exhibit the negative aspects of workplace flexibility, it is ultimately beneficial for the employees, as well as the employers....

Words: 500 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

French Nationalism

...Spain. In order to tackle a subject of this complexity, this essay will review a brief history of the Basque people, including: historical ties to the land, language and literature. Furthermore, the political situation in both during the times of General Franco’s regime and post-Franco Spain are examined in order to analyze the politics of Basque Nationalism. While the history of the Basque people has been littered with political and social unrest, the Basque people have protected their culture and way of life to ensure its continued survival in the 21st century. With a collective sense of self-preservation, Basques today are not only surviving, they are growing politically, socially and economically. Tension exists, however, between the Basques and the Spanish government. This tension has led to complex and interrelated questions on a number of...

Words: 5350 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Professional Ethics

...ENGINEERING ETHICS SENSES OF ‘ENGINEERING ETHICS’ The word ethics has different meanings but they are correspondingly related to each other. In connection with that, Engineering ethics has also various senses which are related to one another. Comparison of the senses of Ethics and Engineering Ethics Ethics 1. Ethics is an activity which concerns with making investigations and knowing about moral values, finding solutions to moral issues and justifying moral issues and justifying moral judgments. 2. Ethics is a means of contrasting moral questions from non-moral problems. 3. Ethics is also used as a means of describing the beliefs, attitudes and habits related to an individual’s or group’s morality. Eg. : Ethics given in the Bhagavat Gita or the Bible or the Quran. 4. As per the definition of dictionaries – ‘moral principles’ is about the actions and principles of conduct of the people. i.e. ethical or unethical. Engineering Ethics 1. Like the ethics, engineering ethics also aims at knowing moral values related to engineering, finding accurate solutions to the moral problems in engineering and justifying moral judgments of engineering. 2. Engineering Ethics gives a total view of the moral problems and how to solve these issues specifically related to engineering field. 3. Engineering ethics is also using some currently accepted codes and standards which are to be followed by group of engineers and engineering societies. 4. Engineering ethics...

Words: 7443 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Causes of Destitution

...through eloping , this was followed by a customary marriage which was later cemented by a Church wedding. The husband works as a receptionist at one of the companies in town, and the wife supplement the family income through vending. Because of the devotion the two have for Church activities although they are young their marriage has become one of the model marriage to marvel at. (2) The family life cycle model according to Carter and McGoldrick Stage one: unattached young adult This is the first stage where the young person embarks on a life journey to be an autonomous being. If the child was nurtured and brought up in a good way he/she will grow up to be a good trustworthy young adult. We should bear in mind that this young adult is between two families, the one of his or her origin and the...

Words: 2978 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Group Dynamics

...motivation survey taught me that I am moderately motivated which speaks very true to my management style. My current role is a leadership role that also is heavily integrated into team projects. This balance of leadership and equal producer allows me to stay engaged and balance the needs of my reporting workforce. The new organizational culture requires managers to develop new skills in order to lead, direct and motivate groups to act synergistically (Barsade 2008). However, group dynamics is a concept that many managers do not yet understood. Consequently this can lead to bad group dynamics resulting in negative synergy, reduced productivity and wounded morale (Levi 2008). Managers are obliged to rectify this by building cohesion and trust between group members (Carron & Brawley 2009). Some group efforts are more successful than others? Group members, group size, level of conflict and internal pressures to conform are all factors that affect the level of cohesiveness in a group. In order to enhance a groups competitive position and benefit from different viewpoints, organizations today increasingly rely on cross-functional teams composed of members from different functional backgrounds. Based on personal experience groups tend to yield better more formulated results. Studies performed by Edward Randel suggest that employees of a corporation who had participated in training for effective teamwork reported their performance was higher in groups than alone. (Randel, E. 2008) The...

Words: 929 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Management

...post-merger success was the fact that the two merged companies were so distinct from each other. BRL was a company that sold fortified wines and took a bulk and volume approach, and thus had as one of its main assets its grape resources. Hardy’s on the other hand was a recognized, traditional award-winning brand wine that had marketing expertise and brand recognition. This essentially meant that Hardy had the know-how and innovation while BRL had the funds and resources to implement the ideas. Another reason for the success was the appointment of Steve Millar as CEO of the newly merged companies. Millar’s management placed an emphasis on turning BRL Hardy into a global powerhouse brand by emphasizing the need to decentralize risks and responsibilities while still maintaining the accountability of central management. Steve Millar also took a rational approach by focusing on the Pareto Principle, the law of the vital few (the “80-20” principle), in business. That is, he recognized that 80% of achievements roughly come from 20% of the amount of time and effort spent. He thus decided to focus his operations on getting 80% success with around 20 projects as opposed to 100% success with just one or two. The overall company strategy was also a big reason for the success that occurred post-merger. The company’s central leadership decided to emphasize the majority of their sales in the domestic (Australian) market which resulted in stately domestic bottle share and increasing company...

Words: 4045 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Afsa

...success was the fact that the two merged companies were so distinct from each other. BRL was a company that sold fortified wines and took a bulk and volume approach, and thus had as one of its main assets its grape resources. Hardy’s on the other hand was a recognized, traditional award-winning brand wine that had marketing expertise and brand recognition. This essentially meant that Hardy had the know-how and innovation while BRL had the funds and resources to implement the ideas. Another reason for the success was the appointment of Steve Millar as CEO of the newly merged companies. Millar’s management placed an emphasis on turning BRL Hardy into a global powerhouse brand by emphasizing the need to decentralize risks and responsibilities while still maintaining the accountability of central management. Steve Millar also took a rational approach by focusing on the Pareto Principle, the law of the vital few (the “80-20” principle), in business. That is, he recognized that 80% of achievements roughly come from 20% of the amount of time and effort spent. He thus decided to focus his operations on getting 80% success with around 20 projects as opposed to 100% success with just one or two. The overall company strategy was also a big reason for the success that occurred post-merger. The company’s central leadership decided to emphasize the majority of their sales in the domestic (Australian) market which resulted in stately domestic bottle share and increasing company...

Words: 4044 - Pages: 17