The Advantages and Disadvantages of State vs. Private Prisons

In: Miscellaneous

Submitted By bigwarrior23
Words 1079
Pages 5
The advantages and disadvantages of state vs. private prisons

The advantages and disadvantages of state vs. private prisons
In both state and private prisons, it is important to keep in mind that while the prisoners are being punished, they should be treated as human beings. The treatment of prisoners is just one of the issues when dealing with both types of prisons. There are many differences and similarities in state versus private prisons. These factors result from more than just funding issues; there are several factors to look at when studying each type. The main points that many people argue about are funding, privileges, and conditions or treatment. Not one of these factors is more important than the other.
Financing for private corrections facility varies from state to state and from facility to facility. Georgia private prisons may be funded differently than a private prison in Florida. However there are two main forms of financing the capital cost earned during the construction of private correction facilities. The first option is that the corporation undertakes the construction of the private correction facility without the assistance of the public and rents the services to contracting jurisdictions. The other choice is that the facility may have the jurisdiction issue bonds to finance the development of the private facility. Private prison operators depend on cooperation from elected officials who are willing to continue funding experimentation with privatization within the correctional system.

State prisons are funded generally through state taxes and conditional appropriations given by federal and state authorities. Federal prisons get their funding through federal taxes and appropriations provided by Congress. In some cases, one jurisdiction of prisons may hold or detain prisoners for another jurisdiction. When this happens,…...

Similar Documents

Advantage and Disadvantage of Amazon

..., but it meant that I had to go back to the site and search again for the same item, and this time I had to pay a slightly higher price for the same CD. Even though the base prices in the Marketplace are generally less expensive than those in Amazon.com’s main product section, you have to be careful and remember to add the base price with the shipping. This is especially true with the new items listed in the Marketplace. With the shipping added, the price might increase to a level that makes it greater than Amazon.com’s regular price. And since Amazon.com is usually offering a free shipping offer on orders greater than $25, this can mean that the Marketplace won’t actually save you any money at all. Most of the time, Marketplace is less expensive. But this isn’t true all of the time and this is why it is so critical to check the overall price first before you make a purchase. You also need to keep in mind that newer items and top selling items will often command higher prices in the Marketplace, like you would expect. And this can mean that the Marketplace price is unreasonable, making the regular Amazon.com price the better deal. This Marketplace has a gigantic selection, like Ebay. But there are a few disadvantages. One is the lack of photos. When you are shopping for a “standard” good, there is no need for a photo because they all look the same. But in the case of a collectible or special edition, a photo would be nice. This marketplace doesn’t offer these things...

Words: 2124 - Pages: 9

State and Federal Prison Systems

...State and Federal Prison Systems Leslie Cable 4/12/2013 CJS/230 Larry Doyle State prisons hold people who are arrested by local police and sheriff departments. Federal prisons hold people who are arrested by the federal bureau of investigations (FBI). The state and federal prisons have security levels for every type of prisoners. State prisons are run by the department of corrections while the federal prisons are run by the justice department. “The Federal Bureau of Prisons was created by an act of Congress and signed into law by President Herbert Hoover on May 14, 1930,” (Foster, 2006, Pg. 134). State prisons have more inmates than they do staff while federal prisons have more staff than they do prisoners. An example of a state prison is San Quentin state prison in California. San Quentin was opened in the 1850s and housed both men and women prisoners. In 1933, the women’s prison at Tehachapi was built. Tehachapi was shut down after an earthquake hit it in July 1952 then it was reopened as a men’s prison three years later. “Despite periodic schemes to shut it down – “the prison that would not die” – San Quentin held nearly 6,000 inmates in 2003,” (Foster, 2006, Pg. 127). The only way I could explain the growth of state prisons is that more people are arrested for crimes than ever before. People are committing more crimes than he is or she is used to and then are sentenced to prison time. More people are arrested for drug...

Words: 714 - Pages: 3

Public vs Private Prison

...Poverty in the U.S. Abstract Poverty in the United States is rising at an alarming rate. One in every eight residents are homeless or living at the poverty level according to the Census Bureau. There are several programs or strategies that need to be developed by the Government to try and put an end or at least have a resolution in place to help our citizens. We are one of the richest countries, but there is more money being spent on wars, than there is to make sure people have a roof over their head. “The world is very different now. For man holds in his mortal hands the power to abolish all forms of human poverty, and all forms of human life.” (John F. Kennedy) We the United States of America need to make a commitment to ending poverty and creating strategies and guidelines in order to achieve this commitment. Putting an end to poverty will require responsibility and improved choices by individuals and more structured policies from the government. With the poverty rate remaining at a high rate of 15 percent for all Americans and 21.96 percent for children, there should be more policies being implemented and in place to help put an end to the suffering. Socrates states in his quote “It is not living that matter, but living rightly”. Living rightly would mean to look at the bigger picture and determine where cuts need to be made, and what the government can do to decrease the poverty level until it no longer exist. How can we be considered one of the richest......

Words: 380 - Pages: 2

Comparative Advantage vs. Absolute Advantage

...Explain comparative advantage, absolute advantage and explain what that has to do with today’s economy. A country has an absolute advantage in the production of a good relative to another country if it can produce the good at lower cost or with higher productivity. Absolute advantage compares industry productivities across countries. In the case of Zambia, for instance, the country has an absolute advantage over many countries in the production of copper. This occurs because of the existence of reserves of copper ore or bauxite. We can see that in terms of the production of goods, there are obvious gains from specialization and trade, if Zambia produces copper and exports it to those countries that specialize in the production of other goods or services. It is easy to see that if countries have an absolute advantage there are advantages to trade. However, what happens if one country has an absolute advantage over its trading partners in the production of a number of goods. Specialization and trade can still result in there being welfare gains made from trade. A country has a comparative advantage in the production of a good or service that it produces at a lower opportunity cost than its trading partners. The opportunity cost of a good is the quantity of other goods sacrificed to make another unit of that good. Some countries have an absolute advantage in the production of many goods relative to their trading partners. Some have an absolute disadvantage...

Words: 595 - Pages: 3

Media Advantage and Disadvantage

.... Yet, he will often refuse to see the doctor when he stops in for a visit. Basically, he is a whiner. He knows he is a failure, and he knows he is old and at the end of his disappointing life. He is miserable, and wants everyone around him to be miserable too. Helena: Although she is Serebrakoff's wife, she does not seem to love her husband very much anymore. She admits that she was entranced by his potential for greatness, and now she remains tied to a failed old professor. She stays mainly out of duty and social expectation. When combating the advances of both Vanya and Astroff, she seems most interested in the doctor - though she still rejects him. With Vanya, she sometimes appears friendly, sometimes pitying, and sometimes vehemently annoyed. At the end of the play she is one of the few characters who attains her desire. She wants to tell the doctor that she is "a little bit in love with him" and, acting on an impulse, she kisses him before leaving forever. A Happy Ending or a Sad Ending? As discussed in my analysis of Chekhov's dry, darkly humorous play, The Seagull, many readers and audiences are not sure whether we should laugh or cry by the end of the play. The playwright thought of his work as amusing, and yet the play ends with its characters in a heart-wrenching state of limbo, waiting for their lives to be over without any hope of personal fulfillment.As depressing as that may seem, if we compare this play to The Wood Demon, an earlier work of Chekhov's,......

Words: 1101 - Pages: 5

Advantage and Disadvantage of Entrance Exams to

... to their parents. Because Chinese people have the traditionally put a lot of emphasis on education and families will make the big sacrifices to make sure their children get the best education and the best chance in life. So, regardless of being the parents or the children looks the college entrance examination is very heavy. Of course, the examination is also very important to Americans’ students. Although the college entrance examination has the advantages and disadvantage. Now I will statement my opinion. First of all, the examination can determined our real ability and manifest fairly. No pains, no gains, the maxim will be shown before our eyes. Many of them have paid difficulty and diligent to reach their hope and expectations. But it sometimes still has not changes the position. Because many students in order to reach their aim, they cheat in college entrance examination. The university entrance exam cheating is still occur from time to time, serious disruption of the examination order, and destroyed the entrance of the fair and equitable. Recently, the Ministry of Education issued a "unified national higher education entrance examination. Examination Work" (hereinafter referred to as "Regulations"), a clear test, marking and other details from the system for the college entrance examination again to add the "insurance valve”. In addition, The College Entrance Examination has been around in China for nearly 20 years. It helps many people change their life...

Words: 999 - Pages: 4

Advantage and Disadvantage of Rh Bill

...Advantages and Disadvantages of RH BILL The statement that reproductive health means "free sex, use of contraseptives,abortion if contraception fails." is not found anywhere on that bill. Use of contraseptives,yes, but free sex and abortion if contraception fails?! If you have read the bill, that'sdefinitely putting words into the authors' mouth. The word "prevent" is not synonymousfor "killing" the catholic church stand for using this method shows that using this methodof preventing is a way killing one's life, they say that sperm and egg cells are the victimof this method, but they doesn't have a life yet they are only a part of a humans' lives,so if they are saying that contraception can "kill" those cells then I consider that allteenagers, young adult, adult or even some of the elderly males are "killers" because itis a nature and normal for the males to "masturbate" and if the orgasm occur the semenwill ejaculate from the males reproductiveorgan and the one content of semen aremillions of sperm cells and in a matter of seconds the sperm cell will die if they areexposed to air, so we kill millions of it and "killing" is a mortal sin. "Killing" is only whenthe two cell are develop and formed as fetus then you terminate it and try to removefrom your womb, that is already "killing" and it is called "Abortion." The advantages of the RH Bill include the couple's choice in the number of children they may like; theselection of the family planning method they will use; and...

Words: 1744 - Pages: 7

State and Federal Prison Systems

...Assignment: State and Federal Prison Systems Denise Silven CJS/230 July 10, 2011 Joseph Micieli Assignment: State and Federal Prison Systems An example of a state prison system would be the Texas Department of Corrections located in Huntsville, Texas. This facility was established in 1849 and to this day is the headquarters of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. Additionally, this facility became the “control model in Texas prisons” and “emphasized farm work and strict discipline within a centralized bureaucratic environment.” The growth of state prison populations is the result of “get-tough” legislation which sends more people to prison and keeps them there for longer periods of time. (Foster, 2006). In my opinion, United States corrections professionals could solve the problem of exponential growth in state prison systems by implementing stronger rehabilitation programs. Upon entry in the state prison facility, inmates could be given an incentive to enter and complete one or more rehabilitation program depending on the degree of severity of the crime or crimes that the inmate committed. I believe that an inmate that sees a program to completion is possibly dedicated to changing their behavior in order to avoid becoming a repeat offender. The security levels in state and federal prisons are maximum-security, close-high-security, medium-security, minimum-security, and open-security. The differences in these levels are: (1) maximum...

Words: 419 - Pages: 2

State and Federal Prison Systems

...State and Federal Prisons Systems The Auburn prison system has also been referred to the congregate system. The State of New York was the first to use this system in 1819 (The Auburn System (n.d.). By combining traits from the Philadelphia system with traits such as uniform silence, hard labor , and togetherness; side by side during meals, work, and prayer. The tier system of housing is used. Each level is offense specific and uniform coded by color. Prison growth has been on the rise with our current economical troubles. As times get rough, the amount of crime rises. The acts of society toward past inmates can often dictate if they are going to possibly become a repeat offender. Stress, financial troubles, employment issues, and drugs are among the top reasons a person reoffends. To help reduce the number of repeat offenders, correction personnel need to start the rehabilitation process within the prison walls. Preparing inmates for the real world can play a large role in their success. Having community resources available when times get rough can make or break a person. Just knowing they are not on their own is a huge stress reliever. With hands-on programs and true support, anything is possible. Each state has their own system for security levels. In Missouri, our levels are numbered and categorized. They are numbered from one to five; one being minimum and five being maximum. Minimum prisons have inmates with a custody level ranging from one to...

Words: 404 - Pages: 2

State and Federal Prison

...Jail and Prison Paper Tameki Reed CJA/204 05/31/11 Robert White Jail and Prison Paper When it comes to jail and prison, there is a distinctive set of differences. Jail is a place of incarceration that is locally operated, while prisons are conducted by the state government or the federal government. Within the United States, there are about 3,600 jails but there are only about 100 federal prisons or rehabilitation facilities. Jails house inmates who have been convicted of a misdemeanors and their sentence is no greater than two years. In addition, a person may be held in jail while awaiting trial, has an unpaid bond, or was recently jailed. If a person is convicted of a state crime he or she will serve their sentence in a state prison as opposed to federal crimes which lands offenders in federal prisons. A jail’s amenities are very limited because of the light sentence and short periods of time spent there. A county jail offers work release, substance abuse programs, and may provide basic necessities to inmates. Prisons also offer work release programs, vocational training, halfway houses, as well as recreational facilities. Inmates at prisons will serve decades within the facility while others have to serve lifetime sentences behind bars. A major concern of prison staff and administrators is disruptive and violent behavior. Their concerns pertain to the safety of inmates as well as employees of the prison facility. Disruptive and violent behavior is not tolerated...

Words: 884 - Pages: 4

Jail vs Prison

...Federal Prison Comparison Matrix Angel Kennedy CJS/255 March 7, 2016 Richard Gilbert Jail vs Prison Is there a difference between jail and prison, and if so, what factors separate the two? The belief each place is practically the same is a common misconception, however; there is one fundamental component in which governs the temporary or permanent placement of an offender. A jail’s and prison’s quality of food, facility resources, and availability of rehabilitative programs are all different, but; “the fundamental difference between jail and prison is the length of stay for inmates” (HG.org, 1995-2016) Jail and Its Place in Corrections The correctional mission of jails today is to use the combination of incarceration and rehabilitative methods to deter criminals from recommitting. Once officers have detained an offender, he or she is escorted to a local jail. Upon arrival, the criminal is taken into the "booking area" where he or she will undergo a process in which will determine placement: finger printing, photographing, stripping of personal property, examination, and bathing. If the criminal cannot make bond due to lack of funds or a bond was not given, the criminal will remain in custody until a trial is set, usually within the first twenty-four hours. According to BI, the average jail stay is twenty-three days, a sixty-four percent increase from fourteen days (2015). Rehabilitative programs are offered to those who have been sentenced to a year or more. The...

Words: 1239 - Pages: 5

Advantage and Disadvantage of Social Media Essay

...Only a few technology-loving, mind-stimulating and idea-generating individuals out there are still unplugged with social media. I am sure those too will join soon as well since social media is not just a platform for easy and simple advanced online marketing, it is also the revolution of our century! Many people have tried to capture the importance of social media. In today’s post, we will introduce to you the most must-know advantages and disadvantages of social media so you’ll be aware of how to use it in the safest and most valuable possible ways! 5 Must-Know Disadvantages Of Social Media: The wrong online brand strategy could put you at a viral social disadvantage and may even damage your reputation, i.e, when you make a mistake offline, a few will know but when you make a mistake in front of hundreds or thousands of you online audience, most of them will know! Using social media for marketing and advertising could be more time consuming than companies expect. In order to get social media’s full effect, you need to understand how it works, when and how to use it and which channels to focus on depending on your end goal of using social media. Social media can have a negative influence on worker productivity. Employees may waste valuable time using social media channels such as Facebook and Twitter. They can also use social media to attack the company’s reputation! When social media is used excessively or in the wrong way, it could have serious detrimental...

Words: 429 - Pages: 2

The Advantages and Disadvantages of State vs. Private Prisons

...The advantages and disadvantages of state vs. private prisons The advantages and disadvantages of state vs. private prisons In both state and private prisons, it is important to keep in mind that while the prisoners are being punished, they should be treated as human beings. The treatment of prisoners is just one of the issues when dealing with both types of prisons. There are many differences and similarities in state versus private prisons. These factors result from more than just funding issues; there are several factors to look at when studying each type. The main points that many people argue about are funding, privileges, and conditions or treatment. Not one of these factors is more important than the other. Financing for private corrections facility varies from state to state and from facility to facility. Georgia private prisons may be funded differently than a private prison in Florida. However there are two main forms of financing the capital cost earned during the construction of private correction facilities. The first option is that the corporation undertakes the construction of the private correction facility without the assistance of the public and rents the services to contracting jurisdictions. The other choice is that the facility may have the jurisdiction issue bonds to finance the development of the private facility. Private prison operators depend on cooperation from elected officials who are willing to continue funding experimentation...

Words: 1079 - Pages: 5

Private V Public Prison

...Prevailing theories about human behavior, the causes of crime and ideology about how to address criminal behavior have always influenced how and why society uses prisons. Prisons are intended to meet a variety of social goals, including incapacitation, deterrence, discipline, punishment or retribution, and rehabilitation or reformation. Some have argued that public prisons are better at all of the above while most support private prisons. The term prison privatization commonly refers to the policy of contracting out the management and operation of prisons and jails to private, for-profit companies. Prison privatization is a controversial issue, with ongoing debate over the ethics of delegating the punishment function of the criminal justice system to private actors, weather private prisons cost less to operate than public facilities, and if the quality of security and conditions of confinement differ between public and private prisons. In 2005, approximately 200 private correctional facilities operated in the United States, housing a total of 107,000 inmates. Four companies provide more than 90 percent of private prison capacity. About 6 percent of all state inmates and 14 percent of federal inmates are incarcerated in privatized facilities. The idea of privatizing prisons emerged in the 1980s as a policy remedy to the problem of growing incarceration rates, severe prison overcrowding, and constraints on increasing government funding of new prison space. Public...

Words: 1405 - Pages: 6

State and Federal Prison System

...State and Federal Prison Systems CJS/230 May 21, 2012 Frank Merenda The number of prisons in each state, today, range from “three in North Dakota to over 100 in Texas”.(Foster, 2006) Although there are many state prisons they were all basically based on the Auburn model, established in 1816. Federal prisons also began this way and in 1930 the Federal Bureau of Prisons was created and the federal prisons of today have not changed much since then. The Texas Department of Corrections (TDC), established in 1849, located in Huntsville Texas, is a good example of a state prison system. Today, the central unit in Huntsville is still the headquarters of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice and it known as the “capital of capital punishment”. (Foster, 2006) It is said this facility carries out more executions than any other prison. Be that as it may and even with the state and federal prison systems separated the state prisons growth still continues. The “get-tough” legislation and the “War on Drugs” have tripled jail and prison populations. (Foster, 2006) Today a lot of the state prison growth comes from parole violators and increased confinement of violent criminals. The growth has slowed some from the past but it still continues. To help slow the growth in the state prison systems U.S. correction professionals could try spending more on treatment and rehabilitation to keep nonviolent offenders out of prison. The drug problems of today seem to be filling...

Words: 667 - Pages: 3