Premium Essay

The Drone Strikes Again

In: Other Topics

Submitted By sdeimel
Words 967
Pages 4
The Drone Strikes Again
Take a moment and imagine this: for every terrorist killed by a U.S. drone strike, 50 Pakistani civilians fall victims to these ruthless attacks. According to an article written by David Kilcullen and Andrew McDonald from the NY Times, “press reports suggest that over the last three years drone strikes have killed about 14 terrorist leaders. But, according to Pakistani sources, they have also killed some 700 civilians. This is 50 civilians for every militant killed, a hit rate of 2 percent — hardly “precision”” (Killcullen, McDonald 9). Regardless if the number of casualties of innocent people caused by drone strikes has increased or decreased, the policy itself should be eliminated if there is even the slightest chance that innocent lives will be at stake. Kant was not a consequentialist theorist; in other words, he believed that despite the outcome of an action being good or bad, what was important was the premeditated idea behind the action, was it right or wrong, unrelated to the consequences. Therefore, if actions are not based on consequences, Kant’s theory would support the argument that using drone tactics to eliminate terrorists is morally unacceptable, for the following reasons: the U.S. military is using drone tactics against terrorist without their consent, and innocent lives are being taken at the push of a button.
As humans, our moral duty is to treat people in such a way that shows them respect, as though they are autonomous beings with intrinsic value. All people have autonomy, and it is up to the individual to use their reason to act based on good will; “Kant believed that there was a supreme principle of morality, and he referred to it as The Categorical Imperative. The Categorical Imperatives determines what our moral duties are” (Anscombe). Humans have the moral duty to act simply for the right reasons. However, in the…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Pakistan Drones

...concerns though important, are dwarfed when compared to the American policy of conducting drone attacks within Pakistani borders. Interestingly, all of these concerns remain relevant to the issue of drone operations conducted by America within the Pakistani territory. The paper will analyze the use of drone attacks with a primary focus on whether the use of drones can be justified, and attempt to prove that the use of drones is in fact a moral and an administrative evil. History and Nature Of The Conflict The notion of conflict here is an interesting one. The word conflict could imply anything; from the "war in Afghanistan" to the "war on terror' and on to the "drone strikes within Pakistan". For the purpose of this paper, the major conflict would remain the initial invasion of Afghanistan, since it is from this initial invasion that all other minor tributaries of conflicts have emerged. The history of conflict is not a redundant issue, rather, only by analyzing important events in the history of conflict can it be determined whether the resulting actions taken in the light of those events are just or not. Additionally, the nature of the conflict is important, as it has the potential to impact several major players in the region, namely Pakistan, India and China. It is also important to understand the nature of the conflict to justify the premise of the paper, which is that drone strikes ensuing in the aftermath of this ongoing conflict are morally evil and......

Words: 3157 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Media Review

...Media Review Media Review Tyler Williamson SOC 110-02 Intro To Sociology U.S. Strike that Killed Hostages Could Change Drone Policies By Paul D. Shinkman April 23, 2015 3:40 p.m. Intelligence officials were unaware that hostages were at the site targeted by a U.S. strike in January despite “hundreds of hours" of surveillance, President Barack Obama said Thursday.  A signature element of President Barack Obama’s counterterrorism strategy sparked a critical backlash on Thursday, after the commander-in-chief admitted strikes in January along the Afghanistan-Pakistan border resulted in the accidental killing of two innocent hostages, along with the deaths of two American al-Qaida operatives. Obama took to the White House podium in a briefing Thursday morning to provide some details on the operations three months prior, details of which he has ordered declassified. U.S. officials confirmed in the aftermath of the strikes that aid workers Warren Weinstein, a 73-year-old American from Rockville, Maryland, and Giovanni Lo Porto, an Italian, had been accidentally killed in one strike. “On behalf of the U.S. government, we offer our deepest apologies to the families,” Obama said. Some aspects of the operation have to remain secret, he said, adding that “the U.S. is a democracy, committed to openness, in good times and in bad.” “It is a cruel and bitter truth that in the fog of war, generally, and in our fight against terrorists, specifically, mistakes and sometimes......

Words: 1348 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Morality of Warfare: Case Study Drone

...Warfare: Case Study; Drone Warfare Advancements in warfare technology and weaponry have been the defining factors in battle since the dawn of civilization. The one with the bigger gun usually wins. This is a fact that hasn’t changed much since the beginnings of warfare and holds true today and in today’s world Drones have become the next warfare advantage. Along with any advancement in warfare weaponry comes a very heated and controversial discussion about its actual real-world utilization. Many argue that the use of Drones in war is unmoral and unethical. This paper aims to take a closer look at both sides of this argument. First, I will establish and explain the moral arguments against the use of drone warfare, then the second half of the article will be in response to such claims and give the moral reasons behind the pro-drone argument. First and foremost of the anti-drone discussion is the fact that Drones are seen to be fundamentally in contradiction of international law: 
 Amnesty International stated that that “deliberate killings by drones […] very likely violate the prohibition of arbitrary deprivation of life and may constitute extrajudicial executions.” The UN suggested focused effort to maintain and preserve the security of international laws in its entirety, in response to the use of drones. This incorporates, obviously, international human rights and humanitarian standards that seem to be thrown out the window when dealing with drone strikes in warfare.......

Words: 3714 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Uav Ethics

...------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Figure 6 - V1 Figure 6 - V1 During World War 2, the Nazis created a UAV known as the V-1 which was a 200 kg warhead powered by a pulseset engine controlled by a guidance system. In a sense it was a flying bomb that flew across the sea towards its target. ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Figure 7- Ryan Firebees Figure 7- Ryan Firebees ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- During the Cold war, UAVs advanced again by introducing the first jet propelled vehicles known as Ryan Firebees. They were used extensively in the Vietnam War for reconnaissance and had the flexibility of being air launched and controlled by planes which stored......

Words: 7338 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Argumentaive Drones

...Is the Use of Drone Military Tactics or not? In 2002 of February 4th history was made that allowed CIA and military to use such extraordinary equipment that made it safer for pilots and national security defense to use to spy on our enemies around the world without being noticed or even harming a human life at stake. But what can we really say that these drones let alone can be worth so much money of the tax payers that we don’t see the results that they are really made for.The drone was made and it was made for just that purpose in that world to help aid in the fight in counter-terrorism let alone not let any more of our military pilots put their lives at risk in dangerous zones. But due to recent events that lead to a sort of downfall in using these pilot less drones, is it actually worth the billions we spend on it to be used in the military or is it even worth having though due to some malfunctions of the drone killed innocent civilians not only from other lands, but our own American civilians as well. Does America really needs these drones that can help with the war on terror and costing us so much money let alone deaths, or do we need something different or not even the drones at all. Back in 2008 while I was serving in Afghanistan and right now I am gearing up for another tour right after the final week of school has ended, I remember hearing about the drones and what the purpose was for. At the time I could never really see one up close and let alone be in the......

Words: 2713 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Obama Administration

...authorised airstrikes to ground Libya’s planes and thereby prevent what he reasonably feared might be a massacre of Libyan Civilians. Furthermore, more recently in 2014, Obama ordered American armed forces to begin targeting airstrikes against IS forces in Syria. Speaking from the White House, Obama had made it clear that these strikes are part of the US campaign to deliver the message to the IS, that ‘they will find no safe-haven’. Barack Obama has received widespread criticism due to its support of government surveillance On the third day of Barack Obamas Presidency, the new commander-in-chief had launched his first drone strike. Soon after, reports of civilian casualties began to emerge; the strike was far from a success as at least nine civilians had died most of them from one family. Later that day, the CIA has attacked again, proving another mistake as this time between five and ten civilians were killed- yet despite this disastrous start, the Obama administration markedly stepped up the use of drones. Since Obama’s inauguration in 2009, the CIA has launched 330 strikes, compared to his Republican predecessor who only had conducted 31 strikes in four years....

Words: 909 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Government in 1984

...have within their homes. Winston describes life in Oceania: “In the far distance a helicopter skimmed down, between the roofs hovered for an instant like a blue-bottle, and darted away again with a curving flight. It was the thought police, snooping into people’s windows.” (6) The Thought Police have the authority to enter anyone’s house who may pose a threat to the Inner Party, without a warrant or even any solid evidence. The Inner Party defeats the purpose of a home, because the citizens no longer have a place to confide in. A single, open-concept building, with no individual apartments, with patrols encircling the area would serve the same lack justice. Not only does it strip people of the respect they are entitled to, but it leads to the conviction of innocent people. The Thought Police exist today. Inhabitants of Deer Tail, Colorado are disturbed by the infiltration of surveillance drones hovering above their homes. Phillip Steel, a local resident, has Asube 4 drafted an ordinance to allow citizens to shoot down the drones, in an effort for them to reclaim their civil liberties. The drones are fitted with thermal technology enabling them to further monitor people, even in environments of complete darkness. Additionally, corporations may benefit from the use of drones to collect data from their customers. In an interview with Vice, Phillip Steels declares, “Obama declared war on us, so we’re fighting back. He fired the first volleys. Our Second Amendment......

Words: 2284 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Terrorism

...extremist elements to use it to their advantage. on the eastern side ,Pakistan has decades old animosity with india. This, too has led to rise in extremism. Israel and india are violating the basic human rights of Palestinians and kashmiris, respectively. From time and again, they have refused to international solutions to the issues.consequently, innocent blood is shed almost on daily basis. propenents of Palestinian and kashmiri cause use Pakistan as a pedestal to attract global attention. Political instability and lawlessness has also allowed terrorism to develop roots in Pakistan. since her inception, Pakistan has witnessed decades of dictatorial control under the 4 successive martial laws. this has, as a result, led to the failure of establishment of strong political parties. the tug-of war for power between civilian government and martial law has caused the diversion of attention from terrorism to political issues.  Probably, drone strikes are the largest contributers to the unprecedented increase in terrorism.U.S.A,in a bid to destroy the militants and their safe havens in Pakistan, started launching the drone attacks in 2002. nevertheless,the strategy backfired. Affectess of the drone strike, including mutilated and relatives of the killed were filled with anguish. they resorted to terrorism to avenge their loss.  Terrorism has affected each and every aspect of political and social culture. it has stunted the economic growth of the country by posing a......

Words: 2178 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Amazon

...shareholders is the economy that he would rather sell many items at lower costs versus fewer items at a higher cost. The organizational structure for Amazon is decentralized overall however, the CEO, does tend to be very actively involved in the daily workings of the corporation. According to Geekwire.com, as of July 25th, 2013 Amazon employs 97,000 people. Also, according to Marketwatch.com, sales and revenue for 2013 was $74.45 Billion that was a growth of 21.87% from the previous year. Amazon has been in the spotlight again lately for the discussion about the drone delivery of items that are up to 5 pounds to your front door in as little as 30 minutes beginning as early as 2015; they have been breaking barriers in all manners of technology so this is not surprising for Amazon’s next step. Although there are still some obstacles that such as clearance with the FAA that need to be overcome, the idea of my next generation phone delivered in 30 minutes by drone sounds better than driving to the mall, finding a spot to park and then finding the person with the key to unlock my device, then standing in line to pay for it. In order to maintain the contemporary characteristics of Amazon, several strategies need to be implemented. In a post on September 25th, 2013 on Geekwire.com, Todd Bishop outlined the three part strategy of Amazon in its current state. He stated that the first strategy is to, “offer premium products at non-premium prices.” This strategy is to do the best that......

Words: 3484 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

The Reagan Doctrine

...when they pulled out in the late 1980’s. Now the United States is mired in a war they cannot possibly win in Afghanistan. The Afghanistan people are becoming increasingly anti-American and Hamid Karzai has threatened to align Afghanistan with Moscow. (BBC News 2009) Relations become even more strained when drone strikes kill innocent civilians. Most of the infrastructure in Afghanistan has been destroyed over the last 40 years of wars leaving the country beyond the level of a third world country. The United States wants hard answers on the drug trade and corruption before trying to lend money to the government. Joe Biden made a visit to Afghanistan before being elected Vice President; he labeled Afghanistan a “Narco-State” after not receiving the answers he wanted to hear. Many times over government leaders in the United States question the effectiveness of the Afghan government, but yet they refuse to see that they brought Afghanistan to this point. The burning desire of the Reagan Doctrine allowed the Soviets to be defeated, it allowed the Taliban to rise to power, and then the United States ignored this group. Now Afghanistan is Vietnam for the United States all over again. On the other hand the United States has Pakistan. This is a nuclear country that has provided an open border to the United States in the past, but once the United States stepped foot in Afghanistan relation began to crumble. The success of both Pakistan and Afghanistan are intertwined and the United......

Words: 2293 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

National Secuirty

...States armed forces. One situation was when Osama Bin Laden was with a leader of Dubai in a place where US forces had drones and bombs ready to be dropped to get rid of Bin Laden but they were called off by President Clinton. The other instance occurred when Bin Laden was at one of his training camps (terrorist schools) with other people with the idea of becoming a member of al Qaeda. US troops were ready once again to take him out but along with him, there was all the families of these men. Their wives and little children would have been caught in the fire of these attacks so once again they were called off by President Clinton. The public relations end of these attacks could have been an even bigger disaster as all people would have seen was American forces killing women and children for the death of Osama Bin Laden. President Clinton may or may not have made the right call but one can only wonder if 9/1 would have even occurred if Bin Laden had been dead years prior to the attacks. The main issue of present day national security is the rise of terrorist extremist group known as ISIS. The U.S. has been carrying out a slow but steady military campaign against ISIS in Iraq and Syria, one that Washington hopes will keep the terrorist group too busy to plot more attacks like the one in Paris last fall that killed 130 people. But ISIS is “determined to strike the U.S. homeland,” James Clapper, the Director of National Intelligence, told Congress on Feb. 9, warning that such......

Words: 1658 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Terrorism in the Homeland

...confused people with a inability to separate fact from fiction that from every demographic across society itself, the rich, the poor, the intelligent, the informationally challenged, people from broken homes and folks that grew up in good solid family structures. Once good people, looking for a cause to believe and take part in that again, caters to their perspective of the way things should be, a cause that they can take part in, a cause that they are all to willing in making the ultimate sacrifice, a self sacrifice that they believe will change the world into a better place that will treat the next guy better than they were treated as a result of their last act on Earth. When we look at the media and over all television programming, music, gaming, and the radical information on the Internet promoting violence everyday I ask you, what kinds of information are we blasted with on a daily basis? If your truthful in your response, you will say that most of it is highly negatively violent and disastrous information over all and thus, when the confused or weak minded is perpetually bombarded with this same type of information over and over again I wonder how will they perceive this information and furthermore, how will they choose to respond to it? So the first reasonable way to approach this is through the information sources themselves however this would infringe on the first amendment for a good many, wouldn't it? And their would be lawsuits flying everywhere as a......

Words: 1404 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The State Has the Power to Commit Crime and to Legitimate Its Crime. Do You Agree?

...that there is an inseparability of “great power and great crime”, noting that the economic and political elites often found in state leadership positions can affect entire human groups via the creation of criminal systems of oppression and exploitation. States too benefit from the idea that they have national sovereignty to the extent that international organisations such as the United Nations may be weary of intervening in any state crimes. Despite recent examples such as the ethnic cleansing of Bosnian Serbs and Croats in the early-mid 1990s seeing UN forces intervene, the power of the state means that it is well placed to hide its crimes and to evade punishment for them. Examples of Nazis fleeing to South America never to be seen again contrast with high ranking members of Pol Pott’s regime who were sentenced to prison in recent years. In addition, by the State fundamentally being the source of law within a country, it is too down to the state to define in itself what constitutes any crime, including state crime. The states power co create law can undermine the system of justice and allow it to avoid defining its own harmful and oppressive measures. By legitimising the mass killing of Jews in the Third Reich through laws such as Nuremberg Laws, the Hitler Regime in essence broke no laws. In addition, the State control of the criminal justice system means it can freely persecute its enemies within the confines of its own criminal justice system. Dissidents of the......

Words: 1138 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Beloved

...“You’ll pind whateber you pind. It is what it is.” His smile widened at this. “That’s the kind of answer a Follower would make. She needs your help theophilos. I couldn’t think of anyone but you.” The girl looked at me and smiled. The radiance behind her swelled to nova bright – bright enough to nearly hurt. “Joe Sotto say’s that you’re a FINDER. He says that you’re the best . . .” I raise an eyebrow at Joe, “Is that true Mr. theophilos? Because I’ll pay anything . . . in money or currency, whichever you wish.” Again the smile. I wondered to myself whether the smile was enhanced by pheromones or whether she was born with it. The nova went super once more. I turn and face detective Sotto, “Listen Joe, I hebent pinished my last commission and he’s already transperred currency. I can’t take anader case. Not wid-out returning currency and I’b already spent hap op it.” Without missing a beat he says, “She’ll pay the refund, and she’ll pay for you to take up that assignment again. I know how you pride yourself in finding – to – finish. I know how you Finders’ are. Your reputation will remain intact. I’ll contact your current consumer and inform him of the need of the police for your services.” “Please Mr. theophilos” she pleads. And I felt the silence speak through me. “Ip you can get my current consumer to gib up his case till I’m done here, den I agree. You can Googel my terms and agree to da contract when he’s conceded.” “I agree to your terms Mr. theophilos.” And with......

Words: 20252 - Pages: 82

Premium Essay

The End of the Iraq War: Unrest in the Middle East

...groups can vary widely from political goals to profit-making. It seems to me that the state actors are to morbidly set on destroying the country and its people in a mad quest for power as tensions between Sunni and Shia Muslims, exacerbated by wars in Syria and Iraq, are creating new fissures among Arabs. Sunni leaders largely snubbed a 2012 summit in Baghdad, reflecting their rejection of a Shia-led Iraq with close ties to Iran. Those who did attend traded barbs during their speeches, dashing an opportunity to foster closer between Iraq and its Sunni-majority neighbors. Even as the Arab League condemns the Sunni extremist group known as ISIS, and Sunni powers such as Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Jordan, and the United Arab Emirates launch air strikes on the terrorist organization, few Arab countries are willing to coordinate efforts with the Iraqi government. Iraq, for its part, has invited Iranian military advisers and deployed Tehran- right-wing activist Yehuda Glick, who was shot at close range after leaving a conference. Public Opinion-The war of words between Israeli and Palestinian leaders, meanwhile, is in full swing. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said incitement by Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas was partially to blame for the assassination attempt; Abbas, meanwhile, called the closure of the Temple Mount a "declaration of war." Palestinian anger elsewhere is also close to boiling over: In Gaza, nearly 2 million people are seething over the lack of......

Words: 1906 - Pages: 8