Free Essay

The Effects of Public School Uniform Policies

In: English and Literature

Submitted By Taresha
Words 1135
Pages 5
The Effects of Public School Uniform Policies
Taresha Y. Hemphill
ECPI University

Abstract

Public school uniform Policies are not a solution to all school problems. Some problems will still exist. However, the improvements that the mandatory uniform policies have made across the nation are indisputable. Public school uniform policies will continue to reduce school violence and gang activity and overall help create a productive and safer learning environment. It will take more work to correct the school systems, but they will only get worse if something is not done about them. Even though school uniforms are a small step to improving the violence in public schools in the United States, it is better to make that small step than do nothing at all.

There are vast opinions over what students should wear to school. Some see a student’s style of dress as an expression of who they are and dress code policies as a First Amendment Rights issue. Others see a student’s style of dress as a safety issue. School Dress Codes and Uniform policies have been challenged in PTA meetings, the classroom and in the court room. The main reason for having these policies is to create a safer, more productive learning environment for our children; not to strip away their freedom. We should allow students to express themselves and their individuality. However, this does not mean that their expression should be so grand that it causes destruction, disorder or interferes with class instruction. According to King, there is a definite correlation between clothing style and school violence. There is an image or stigma attached to a certain style and the most distinguished is gang style clothing. For example, a popular style of dress with young boys is saggy pants and oversized shirts. This style is closely associated with inner city gang members who wear the loose fitting clothes in order to hide drugs and weapons. This style of dress is not only linked gang activity and violence, but also bullying. After the Columbine shootings, a certain stigma was attached to students wearing all black clothing, black trench coats, black eye shadow and black lipstick. According to Kerry White, Ronald Stephens, executive director of the National School Safety Center stated that in wake of school shootings communities and schools are much more willing to embrace uniforms as well as a number of other strategies to enhance student strategies. Another issue that causes violence among school children is fashion envy. Children may resent other children’s clothing because their parents lack the financial resources to purchase the same styles. In 1985, I attended Lumbard Middle school in Baltimore MD and there had been violent acts over theft of expensive clothing and on one occasion a boy had gotten murdered for his designer jacket. Children may envy other children’s clothing and may not have the financial resources to purchase the same styles. There have been violent acts and on occasion children have gotten murdered for their designer sneakers and clothing. Furthermore, requiring students to wear uniforms may reduce the pressure to wear designer clothes, create a safer environment for our kids and instill more discipline. In 1994, the Long Beach Unified School District established a uniform policy in their elementary and middle schools. This was an attempt to reduce gang activity and gang violence in their public schools (Anderson, 2002). In 1996, During the Clinton administration, the President stated that discipline and learning needed to be placed back into our schools. He instructed the Federal Education Department to distribute manuals to the nation’s school districts advising them on how they could legally enforce school uniform policies. Now Schools across the nation have required students to wear uniforms or to adhere to some sort of dress code policy. I have spoken to parents and students at my son’s school that argue against school dress codes or public school uniform policies because they believe that they are in violation of the student’s right to self-expression and freedom of speech. Supporters of uniform or dress codes policies argue that they help students focus in the classroom by reducing distractions, preventing gang activity and making socioeconomic barriers between students less evident. Supporters also argue that uniforms or dress codes make schools safer by making it easier to identify intruders and reducing the likelihood of theft of apparel. According to Hudson, these policies have become very controversial, not only among parents and students, but also in the courtrooms. Students have sued their schools for punishments that they’ve received for not following school rules. In Newsom v. Albemarle County School Board, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals struck down a portion of a school’s dress code that disallowed clothing that displayed pictures or drawings of weapons. The controversy arose after school officials forced student Alan Newsom to quit wearing his National Rifle Association T-shirt, which depicted three silhouettes of men holding guns and bore the message “NRA Sports Shooting Camp. Hudson also stated that a federal district court in New Mexico applied the rule that a public school student did not have a First Amendment right to wear sagging jeans. In Bivens v. Albuquerque Public Schools, the judge questioned whether sagging pants conveyed any particular message? Hudson stated that sagging is not necessarily associated with any single racial or cultural group, but merely a fashion trend. The judge said that even if sagging somehow constituted a message, the student failed to establish that reasonable observers would understand any message coming from the wearing of sagging pants. There are mixed reviews on whether wearing uniforms have improved student’s academic achievements, but the Long Beach Unified School District has stated that violence and discipline issues have been greatly reduced. The primary goal of the school officials is to create a more productive and safer learning environment for our children and uniform policies or in some cases school dress code policies have achieved that goal. There is definitely a correlation between clothing style and school violence. No civil liberties are being violated. Schools, like any work environment has rules by which we’ve all have to adhere. Self –expression through style of dress should not be allowed to disrupt, interfere or distract the other children from learning or intimidate them in any way. References

Anderson W., (2002). School Dress Codes and Uniform Policies. Retrieved from www.eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/recordDetail?accno=ED471528

Hudson D.L., (April 1, 2002). Clothing, dress codes & uniforms. First Amendment Center. Retrieved from www.firstamendmentcenter.org/clothing-dress-codes-uniforms

King K., (January, 1998). “Should School Uniforms be mandated in Elementary and Middle Schools?” New Century School Issues Forum: School Uniforms. Retrieved from danenet.wicip.org/ncs/forumuniformseval.htm

White, K.A., (February, 2000). “Do School Uniforms Fit” School Administrator 57,2: 36-40. EJ 599-101

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

...The School Uniform Debate: Measuring Effectiveness Pete Cade Jr. May 2015 Abstract With the rising numbers of violence in schools coupled with a decline in academic achievement, many stakeholders have begun to condemn the state of public school education. The situation has prompted schools across the country to look for unorthodox approaches to improve schools and the performance of their students. The result has led to a spreading initiative that dictates what students can wear. More than just a dress code policy, school uniforms take into account colors and styles from head to toe. Even with the ongoing debate of being constitutional, the trend continues to be adopted throughout the United States. The argument of limiting self-expression is far outweighed by the benefits of increased academic performance and student safety. This paper will outline the ongoing results from adding uniform policies to schools and analyze the debate of the pros and cons of wearing school uniforms. The School Uniform Debate: Measuring Effectiveness The Initial Movement Traditionally imposed by private and parochial schools, uniform policies are being implemented by U.S. public schools in rising numbers. Proponents note that school uniforms make schools much safer for students, encourage children to focus on learning and most significantly – that it puts a halt to socioeconomic disparities. On the same issue, opponents consider the mandates as an infringement on student’s......

Words: 2666 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Uniforms in Public Schools

...Uniforms in Public Schools Marla Downey Axia College of University of Phoenix COM 120 Effective Persuasive Writing Dr. Carla Lane February 21, 2007 Uniforms in Public Schools Think back to the age of adolescence, was there ever a comment made by other children on the way one dressed or did some teasing occur regarding the lack of current style? Was there an issue of being prejudged or stereotyped by others, including school faculty, based on the clothing one chose to wear? That was then, now remember how it felt. Times have changed and economic status plays such an important role in everyone’s lives, image how children of today feel. Social economics is a hard issue for adults to deal with and yet children are forced to deal with it on a daily basis in schools with their classmates, friends, and even their teachers. What solutions can be offered to change this bias for all children, regardless of age, race, and social status? One suggestion is to put school dress codes in place which would require school uniforms. School uniforms should be mandated in public schools because our children’s self esteem and education should not be determined by the clothes they wear. There is a nationwide campaign for the use of uniforms and the efforts are “gaining momentum”, states Susan Thomas (1994, p. 44). School systems are challenged with many issues, one being “ways to reduce competition over designer labels” (Thomas, 1994, p. 44). It is safe to say that both......

Words: 1977 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

School Uniform

...cons about implying school uniforms. I want everyone to know that there are two ways to view if school uniforms should be implied to every public school. There are two sides to the story, but when it comes to picking one over the other, it's your decision to make. I will explain every detail about why schools should or should not have uniforms. In this case. I am having difficulty choosing a side because I agree with both, but everyone has a different perspective. The issue of use of uniforms in public schools has produced a lot of discussion in the recent years. A high number of key stakeholders in the educational sector think that uniforms may reduce negative conduct that is connected to student dress such as school violence, absenteeism, teasing and gang related activities. The main argument that opponents are advancing is that uniforms get in the way of students right to choose dress, violating their right to speech. While public schools have always had policies on dress code, there is a need to evaluate whether uniforms in public schools have any significance.The practice of requiring public school students to wear school uniforms began during the 1990s. Proponents argued that school uniforms led to better academic Bible believers need to support interventions that work to eradicate violence in schools. Although school uniforms may have been originated from Catholic schools and English schools, isolated American school districts used school uniforms prior to the......

Words: 2581 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

School Uniforms

...School Uniforms: Are School Uniforms Constitutional or in Violation of Student Rights Danielle Grider Ivy Tech Community College ENG111-15H-H1 March 18, 2012 Wendy Kruger School Uniforms: Are School Uniforms Constitutional or in Violation of Student Rights For the past decade, educators, parents and students have debated over the issue of regulating student dress codes. While uniforms are mostly utilized by private schools, uniforms are making their way into public schools in the United States. The question becomes are uniforms unconstitutional and do they take away students’ rights, or do they create a safer and more positive learning environment. Since uniform policies are growing more popular in public middle schools and high schools, this has become a highly debated issue. Many people believe that uniforms can create a safer and more positive learning environment for students. According to Stephen Daniels (2001), who is the director of research for the North Carolina Family Policy Council, dress codes and uniforms reduce conflict associated with name brand and gang clothing, decreases the gap between the poorer and richer students, and encourage a sense of equality that helps with the overall order and discipline. Daniels gives statistics to show the effectiveness of school uniforms according to principals that have a uniform policy in their schools: 79 percent believe uniforms have positive effects on classroom discipline; 67 percent...

Words: 1387 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Should Uniforms Be Mandatory

...School Uniform School uniforms would produce a safe and structured learning environment for students. Which is the first requirement of a good school. Students that feel safe in their environment are more apt to learn and not worry about their appearance. School uniforms in public schools are becoming increasingly popular across the nation. The public school system would benefit greatly if this policy were to be enforced. Resistance is always a problem when trying to make changes. Taking all things into account, the positive effects would be far greater than the negative effects. School uniforms should be mandatory in public schools because their use would lead to higher education, less violence, and lower cost to parents. By requiring school uniforms in public schools, education will be improved and a dress code can enforce discipline towards learning. Uniforms improve a person’s outlook toward success as students generally act the way they are dressed. With fewer distractions, students see the school as a workplace for teaching and learning. Students also have less stress in their lives because they are not in a fashion show or competition. Dress codes also lead to a change in grades and part of the change is because it would be easier for students to focus on their academics when everyone is dressed the same. School uniforms would also decrease violence in public schools. There would be less peer pressure toward trying to fit in with the in-crowd and......

Words: 944 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

...School Uniforms: The Pros and Cons in schools (Final Paper) ChaMyra Lewis-Jackson ENG 122 English Composition II Mr. Brandon Bond December 23, 2014 School Uniforms: The Pros and Cons in schools In our country many concerns and issues about safety in our schools have caused a big disturbance which have led school districts to require uniforms for their students. Long ago, some parents seem against or incapable of singling out the "clothes" line with their children, to the point where the new trending styles took a toll and started influencing the kids' attire decisions in a big way. The safety of the students and environment which was surrounded by gang violence and other concerning distractions became an important matter for a lot of individuals within the school districts. School uniforms and dress codes can play a significant role in the drastic change with student in a learning environment (Boutelle, 2008). That’s why school uniforms should be implemented as a policy for students in different districts, because many reports have shown after enforcing this policy students showed a dramatic improvement in their academics, attendance and behavior. Most advocates imply that if all students are required to wear uniforms would give the students an opportunity to find a sense of unity and equality with one another which will help with the confidence of some that didn’t feel like they belonged. Uniforms would also diminish bullying and give students a better frame of......

Words: 1683 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Questionable Love

...Uniforms in schools Opening Thought: Kids are often bullied about clothing and brand names, also Kids in school tend to be more active and wild when dressed down as opposed to those who are dressed in uniform. I. Enforcing Uniforms http://www.essayforum.com/writing-feedback-3/lets-face-music-school-uniforms-persuasive-essay-16466/ I. Introduction School uniforms have been a major issue to the school systems for many years. In the last forty years, public education has seen many changes in school dress styles. B Many private and public schools have adopted a uniform policy, but other schools do not believe uniforms make a difference. C In most present day public schools, students are permitted to choose what they wear with limited restraints. As most school Districts allow the students this freedom, The public as a panacea for the ills of society views the Schools. Schools are expected to solve America’s entire Social, economic, and political problems. California, Became the first public school system in the country in 1995 To require grammar schools and some high schools to wear uniforms However many parents across the united states feel that mandating school uniforms is a violation of self-expression at the same time many schools feel that uniforms will be a benefit because When students have continuous negative experiences in school, dropping out and Delinquency tends to be...

Words: 349 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Dress Code in Schools

...Codes in Schools Com 220- Research Writing Some people believe that our schools should require their students to adapt to a dress code to improve student behavior, enhance students’ self-confidence and reduce differences among socioeconomic levels. Others may say that policies enforcing dress codes or requiring school uniforms violate students’ First Amendment rights and suppress individuality. The argument over school dress codes and school-uniform policies continue to rage in the meeting rooms, administrative officers, and classrooms of public schools throughout the country. School officials place dress code policies so there will be orderly dressing amongst the students’. Dress codes are important but they are troublesome at the same time. There is no one to police the dress code of the students when they arrive at school. And at the same time, the same dress code placed among the students should be the same as the educators. Schools should be a learning institution full of knowledge for young eager minds and not a meeting place for the latest fashion contest. Recent studies conducted in schools have shown that a fixed dress code does promote good behavior and helps students achieve higher test scores. However, parents have expressed concerns because their child or children are not being allowed to express who he or she truly is. Another issue that has many people worried throughout the United States is the rising cost of these uniforms......

Words: 2265 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Public School-Uniform: Decision Hanging on by a Thread

...Classical Argument Position ENGL 123 Public School-uniform: Decision hanging by a thread Today’s youth face a different learning environment that was not as prevalent in years past. Peer in on any one of the more than 98,500 schools, and notice the difference. Public schools have morphed into more of a hangout and social hour-type atmosphere, as well as become the new “red carpet” to display the latest fashion trends. That is not all. Reported cases of drug and alcohol use, weapons brought into school, and violence and bullying have drastically increased over the years, and not just in the high schools either, but in all grade levels. As each of these problems take a seat at the head of the class, quality education breaks for recess. Although the factors attributing to the recent increases in these issues are many, one viable solution to mitigate some of the problems is for all public schools to require their students wear uniforms. Many advocates for this initiative, me included, strongly believe that mandating the wear of uniforms will reduce the alarming numbers for violent behavior and bullying, as well as alleviate any socio-economical barriers that currently exist; therefore, they will become the catalyst which brings the focus back to education within the classroom. For those parents who oppose the idea of uniforms, and who believe that mandating their child wear a uniform while attending public schools violates the First Amendment and stifles their......

Words: 1167 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Implementing School Uniforms

...Implementing School Uniform Policy in Public Schools Jennifer Phillips Sullivan University Abstract School uniform policies have become an important debate among public schools in the United States. The school district in Long Beach, California was the one of the first public schools to adopt a mandated uniform policy. The success that this school had, along with other schools that followed this path, does not seem to be enough evidence to convince other school leaders that school uniforms has a great impact on the students in behavior and academic success. Arguments among school leaders, parents, and students range from not enough statistical research to prove that the uniforms better the student’s safety and education, to the expense of uniforms compared to every day clothes. The evidence that the public schools have that participate in school uniforms seems to outweigh the petty arguments of a few critics. Keywords: school uniforms, safety, students, faculty, education Implementing School Uniform Policy in Public Schools School uniform policy is an ongoing debate spreading across our country. According to Schatcher (2005), “by the end of 2002 twenty-three percent of all elementary schools had adopted uniforms, and several middle and high schools had followed the pattern” (p.46). Presidents George W. Bush and Bill Clinton were both supporters of mandating uniform policies in the public schools. Clinton endorsed the policy through his State of Union......

Words: 2564 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

School Uniforms

...School Uniforms By Kendall Cole June 2014 AED/200 - CONTEMPORARY ISSUES IN AMERICAN EDUCATION Instructor: Christine Duhamel University of Phoenix Since the late 1990's school uniforms have been worn in mostly urban school districts across America. Initially, they were opposed by stakeholders, especially the students. School uniforms were accused of stripping students of their creative expression. After a while, uniforms were tolerated, it was realized that wearing uniforms helped to create a positive learning environment. “School uniforms are being advocated for a range of social, educational and familial issues” (Bodine, 2003, p. 67). There are so many issues students have to deal with when they attend school. Some of these issues create negativity in the student’s educational career. Stakeholders must come up with ways to help make learning environments and experiences more positive. Wearing school uniforms will help to create a positive learning environment. Since the turn of the new millennium, school uniforms have become common place and a trend in large school districts across America. In 1996, former President Bill Clinton mentioned school uniforms in his State of the Union Address (DeCosta, 2006 p. 49). Former President Clinton said, " And if it means that teenagers will stop killing each other over designer jackets, than our public schools should be able to require their students to wear school uniforms" (Mitchell,1996). Children have so many issues......

Words: 2297 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Con Side Debate Summary

...want high school students to wear uniforms. My arguments would be that wearing uniforms, I could restrict students from their freedom of expression, meaning that students could loose their constitutional rights of speech and expression when entering the school doors. School uniforms promote everyone to be alike instead of promoting individuality meaning at a time when schools are encouraging an appreciation of diversity, enforcing standardized dress sends a contradictory message. Most public schools that has uniforms are place are in bad economic neighborhoods take away from the real issues at school. Meaning most public schools with uniform policies are in poor neighborhoods, emphasizing the class distinctions that uniforms were supposed to eliminate. Uniforms have an effect on self-image I believe when students have to wear the same outfits, rather than being allowed to select clothes that suit their body types, they can suffer embarrassment at school. Also students would rather not have uniforms. Pamela then began to explain her side and said that what I said is true. They are also very popular in private and Catholic Schools so the environment could be a perception of how the school addresses the issue. This can take away from individuality but also sets standards and guidelines for children to abide by. The importance of wearing the uniforms should be the value and the lesson that it teaches not the appearance of the child. Children that have to wear uniforms......

Words: 534 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Final

...By Justin Simmons Eng 122 Instructor Michelle Klingfus 2-21-2014 Uniform in Public Schools? Requiring students to wear uniforms in the public school system is this the right decision? I chose this assignment for two reasons, one because I have four beautiful children who attend public schooling and the other reason is because I have seen some of the damaging incidents that these children are enduring behind the brands being sought out that are quote to be cool. I experienced some of the same issues growing up as a child as many others reading this have. Coming up in the urban parts of Port Arthur, Texas a small town with a population of 53,818 I have seen people robbed for their shoes killed for shirts or jewelry all through middle school and high school. But the goal of my story is simply to inform and educate on the following those that are for it, those that are against and those that are stuck in the middle. I am personally for it but not basis about the matter I do want kids to have there freedoms of speech while living life through artistic framing, however I do not want children killing themselves over clothing/brand names with no one to blame. It starts at the home. What are we teaching our kids? Are the TV commercial and infomercials about different products raising our children? Or is it the top sports athlete or entertainer with the hottest song or movie? The answer is complicated, because living in a society where most of the day you are amongst......

Words: 1101 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Richman

...IMPLEMENTATION ANALYSIS The full policy process is often described by the following steps: 1) problem definition 2) alternative generation 3) analysis of alternatives 4) policy adoption 5) policy implementation 6) policy evaluation While this course has focused on the first three steps, the last three steps are equally important. A thorough policy analysis will include some consideration of policy implementation, monitoring, and evaluation. The policy analyst can sketch out an implementation plan for the most highly ranked alternative(s) that considers: 1) relevant actors and their interests 2) required resources and who might provide them 3) facilitators and barriers likely to be encountered 4) reasonable time frame Implementation analysis might involve writing a "best-case" scenario and a "worst-case" scenario for each policy alternative, as well as the "most likely" outcome. The idea is to think systematically through the implementation process, identify potential problems, and develop actions that can be taken to either avert catastrophes or reduce losses.   POLICY MONITORING Policy maintenance refers to keeping the policy or program going after it is adopted. Policy monitoring refers to the process of detecting how the policy is doing. To monitor a policy, some data about the policy must be obtained. A good implementation plan will suggest some ways in which ongoing data about the policy can be generated in the regular course of policy......

Words: 635 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Leadership

...of the most common moral, legal and ethical concerns in education that are most often faced by the givers and receivers of education, along with the education institutes, management thereof and, sometimes, parents and guardians of students. Educational Resources With Respect to Special Education: The passing of the Education for All Handicapped Children Act in 1975 by the Federal Government marked the first milestone in special education of children with disabilities. Prior to this act, handicapped children had no other recourse but to attend general public schools and curriculum which were not appropriate given their special requirements. Post this act, funds were given to states for the development of educational curricula for children with disabilities and the Education for All Handicapped Children Act, 1975, made available to all handicapped children between 3 years and 21 years of age the right to a Free, Appropriate Public...

Words: 1063 - Pages: 5