Free Essay

The Effects of Advertising

In: Social Issues

Submitted By mrnevadito
Words 1494
Pages 6
Marcos Blanco Fernández
Métodos y técnicas de investigación social
2º Publicidad & RR.PP. – 2012/2013

La violencia simbólica de la música en la publicidad destinada a la infancia – Massimo Ragnedda y Maria Laura Ruiu. Università de Sassari.

I Parte descriptiva

¿Cuál es el tema general del artículo?

Este artículo presenta una investigación, llevada a cabo sobre una muestra de 282 estudiantes italianos, de edades comprendidas entre los 8 y los 12 años, dirigida a comprobar el conocimiento real que los niños tienen del mundo publicitario y su relación con la televisión.

¿Qué objetivos plantean los autores?

El objetivo de la investigación es entender cómo puede la publicidad influir en los niños, cuál es el peso que tiene en su vida, y cómo es interpretada. Al analizar

Describir muy brevemente el marco teórico.

La música en particular, en el centro de esta investigación, se muestra como un elemento de importancia fundamental para la publicidad televisiva, porque consigue que se instaure un proceso de fascinación y seducción que convierte el mundo publicitario en un lugar mágica y deseable. La música es el primer elemento que captura la atención de los más pequeños y se infiltra en los recovecos de la memoria.

¿Tiene hipótesis? ¿Cuál/es es/son?

Las claves de lectura utilizadas son las imágenes y, sobre todo, la música que, unida a las palabras, constituye una de las bases fundamentales que determinan el poder persuasivo de la publicidad televisiva.
Manipular el lenguaje equivale a manipular las mentes, los deseos y los sueños. Para hacer esto, se parte de las emociones, y la música es el camino principal para llegar al corazón y establecer un contacto empático con los niños.

Fuentes de datos y métodos aplicados.

La investigación ha sido realizada con la colaboración de algunos colegios de primaria (con niños de 8 a 12 años) de la ciudad de Sassari (Italia), entre marzo y mayo de 2009.
Se les ha propuesto la experiencia a 282 niños como si se tratase de un juego sin ninguna consecuencia, con un test anónimo (sólo había que indicar el sexo y la edad del encuestado), en el que se invitaba a los jóvenes estudiantes a expresar con total libertad sus preferencias y opiniones.
El estudio proponía dos tipos de cuestionarios:

* El primer test consistía en responder a las preguntas de un cuestionario estructurado excepto en los dos últimos puntos, en los que la respuesta estaba abierta para permitir que los niños anotasen libremente su canal de televisión preferido y para la enunciación de la marca que se le ocurre si escucha una categoría determinada de productos.

No era obligatorio responder en los casos en que ninguna de las soluciones disponibles se adaptaba a la opinión del alumno, y se les daba la posibilidad de añadir comentarios personales que se tenían en cuenta en la fase posterior de los datos.

* El segundo test se ha realizado con música: se les ha pedido a los niños que escuchasen las sintonías de cinco spots y, en base solamente a la escucha, que reconociesen el producto anunciado, la marca, los protagonistas y, finalmente, para testar la eficacia persuasiva de la música y del spot, se les ha pedido que expresasen sus preferencias entre algunas marcas diferentes de productos pertenecientes a la categoría publicitada.

Era necesario señalar una única respuesta para cada pregunta que se considerase válida. Sólo en la última pregunta, que hacía referencia a las preferencias personales para cada spot, se podían indicar más respuestas.

Tipos de análisis (exploratoria/descriptiva/explicativa; corte transversal/longitudinal, etc.).

Nos encontramos ante una investigación que se puede clasificar como:

* Exploratoria: analiza un objeto poco estudiado y sus resultados son una visión aproximada de dicho objeto. * Descriptiva: establece pautas y peculiaridades. * Explicativa: da razones del por qué de los fenómenos. * Seccional/transversal: recoge información del estudio en un momento determinado.

Resumen de los resultados.

Los datos obtenidos demuestran que los estudiantes entienden que la música representa para ellos el elemento de mayor interés, confirman que cantan habitualmente los temas que acompañan a los spots, y sueñan con las atmósferas y los mundos propuestos por la publicidad.

¿Cuánto les gusta la publicidad? Resultados obtenidos sin haber realizado la experiencia de escucha y reconocimiento de los spots.

Al 22% de los estudiantes les gusta la publicidad, mientras que a un 78% no.

¿Cuánto les gusta la publicidad? Resultados obtenidos después de haber realizado la experiencia de escucha y reconocimiento de los spots.

A un 39% de los estudiantes no les gusta la publicidad, mientras que a un 61% sí.

Horas que pasan frente al televisor.

Un 45% de los estudiantes pasan de 1 a 2 horas frente al televisor, mientras que el 55% restante pasan de 2 a 5 horas.

Actividades que realizan durante la tarde.

Un 26% contestó que salir al aire libre, mientras que el 74% restante señaló la opción de ver la televisión.

Actividades que querrían desarrollar en el tiempo libre.

Un 9% prefiere quedarse en casa, un 24% ver la televisión y un 67% salir al aire libre.

II Parte metodológica – comentarios

Forma – claridad de exposición.

El artículo establece una serie de pautas bien organizadas para una eficaz comprensión de la investigación llevada a cabo.

Comienza con una introducción, penetrando en el mundo de la publicidad, el consumo y el sistema que se ha impuesto a la sociedad actual. Procede a explicarnos la metodología usada para obtener una serie de resultados que muestra en el siguiente apartado titulado “principales resultados obtenidos”. Dichos resultados son interpretados en el epígrafe “aspectos para el debate” en el que se alcanzan los objetivos propuestos a partir de una hipótesis.

Planteamiento: cumplimiento de los objetivos…

La investigación demuestra que la música es el primer elemento que captura la atención de los niños y que, aunque no se preste mucha atención a las imágenes, es capaz de filtrarse igualmente por los recovecos de la memoria para salir al descubierto de manera repentina.

Metodología – adecuada a los objetivos, propuestas de metodología alternativas.

Considero que la metodología aplicada es correcta porque los investigadores se han visto influenciados por análisis previos con sujetos de igual edad y en un entorno similar. El aspecto cambiante es la socialización a través del actual sistema impuesto. Se han conseguido los objetivos propuestos y los resultados se han argumentado de manera clara y concisa.

Relación entre el marco teórico y el desarrollo del estudio.

Los niños entrevistados han demostrado claramente, además, que conocen a los personajes que dan testimonio de la calidad de los productos anunciados: personas que les son familiares y a las que prestan atención porque las encuentran cada día en las pantallas televisivas y depositan en ellas una absoluta confianza, para alcanzar un mundo que sueñan, que sienten como suyo, y que sin embargo sólo existe en la hiperrealidad, en la pantalla: un mundo hecho de marcas. La música, con sus toques de magia y su encanto irresistible, es la herramienta ideal, como ha intentado demostrar la investigación, para hacer que los niños se sumerjan en la atmósfera creada por los spots de televisión. Un mundo que es fantástico e irreal, pero para los niños el lugar ideal donde vivir. O al menos así lo creen.

III Comentarios al contenido

¿Por qué ha elegido este trabajo?

La elección de este artículo se basa en el análisis de tres lecturas propuesto por la asignatura “Métodos y técnicas de investigación social”. Dos de ellas tienen que ser sobre cualquier tema pero una debía seguir la temática de un trabajo grupal que se lleva como proyecto paralelo a esta actividad en la misma asignatura. Esa lectura es esta.

Comentarios a los resultados.

Se ha verificado que la música es un elemento de importancia fundamental a la hora de conseguir que se instaure el proceso de fascinación y de seducción y, con ello, para que el mensaje pueda alcanzar su objetivo.

Puntos fuertes y débiles del artículo.

Puntos fuertes:

* Los datos obtenidos demuestran la tesis que atribuye un fuerte poder de atracción, seducción y persuasión a la publicidad. * Propone aspectos para la regulación del papel de la publicidad en el proceso de socialización de los niños.

Polémica con el artículo/conclusiones.

* Los pequeños espectadores son “víctimas”, por un lado, de los modelos propuestos por la publicidad; y por otros lado, de los modelos propuestos en los programas de los adultos. * El mayor riesgo es “la desaparición de la infancia” como consecuencia del ataque que las imágenes llevan a cabo a la abstracción del lenguaje. La agresión del mundo de las imágenes y de la publicidad continúa con la violencia simbólica, con la redundante reproposición de esquemas de comportamiento y dinámicas de poder que llevan a interiorizar y a aceptar una visión del mundo a sujetos que sólo se están asomando a él. * Los niños son seducidos e invitados a entrar en este “mundo fantástico”, a aceptar pasivamente las imposiciones de valores y a creer que todo esto no es sólo el mejor, sino el único mundo posible.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Advertising Effects on Advertising

...Advertising effects on children Never there been a subject that has aroused as much discussion as that of advertising. These last few decades have seen a development of this powerful marketing process and major tool of communication practices. Nowadays, advertisements are present in all fields of our modern societies. The debate about the positive and the negative effects of advertisements is still relevant today. Despite the fact that the main purpose of publicity should be the informational aspect, advertisers use their influence in a distinct way. Sometimes manipulative, their controversial techniques use psychological appeals in order to increase purchases. Publicity has unfavorable side effects on individuals, especially on young and vulnerable consumers: children. The purpose of this paper is to illustrate that food habits, lifestyles and behaviors are guided by advertising detrimental models. Teenagers represented core targets for advertisers because media has become one of the most substantial socialization agents known today. Adolescents spent 140 billion dollars a year in 2004 in various products, and 12 years old kids 25 billion dollars, but they are also able to act upon a $200 billion dollar budget (Mary Story and Simone French, Food Advertising and Marketing Directed at Children and Adolescents in the US). According to the Professor Sharon Beder, “[y]oung children are increasingly the target of publicity and marketing because of the amount of money they...

Words: 2834 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

The Competitive Effects of Advertising

...“The Competitive Effects of Advertising in the US Automobile Industry, - Greuner, Kamerschen and Klein “Organizational or Frictional Equilibria, X-Efficiency, and the Rate of Innovation.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics Leibenstein “X-Inefficiency Xists-Reply to an Xorcist” American Economic Review Leibenstein Introduction paper 1: Is advertising anticompetitive? Some economists argue that advertising performs a useful social function by providing consumers with information about price, product quality, and availability, making markets more competitive and driving down profit rates. Empirical evidence on the relationship between advertising and profitability is mixed. The pioneering study by Comanor and Wilson found a positive and statistically significant relationship between advertising and profits, as did an early study by Shephard. These results were challenged by others because they treated advertising as an expense rather than an investment, overstating the true rates of return to advertising. More recently, other economists have found positive and statistically significant relationships between advertising and profits in US manufacturing. Porter and other economists failed to find a statistically significant effect. As is well known, however, the causal relation between advertising and profit is uncertain, and some of the early studies regressing profit rates on advertising fail to account for the possible endogeneity of advertising. We contribute to this...

Words: 886 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Assimilation Effect in Advertising

...Small” campaign launched the Volkswagen in America in the 1960. In the 60’s cars were fashion statement, testosterone boosters, and muscles on wheels. They were built to be fast, big , stylish and way to show off. And here came Volkswagen with Beetle it was a small, slow, ugly, foreign car that was also tied to Nazi Germany. To sell this car to a country which was still bitter about the world war? The car was always perceived to be a small and slow car so instead of trying to sell the American public a primed marketing campaign Volkswagen decided to be honest about it. The Ad copy read that the max speed was 72 mph. It also spoke about its weird looks. This cleverly made the people look into the ad and read it. It took the Assimilation effect where the receiver perceives the message t be advocating a position closer to his or her own position. So the copy then goes on to talk about the engineering of the car and how it being slow still had the best engine around. It also speaks about its good mileage and how its looks make it stand out. The Ad hooks into the consumer and makes them want to know more about it. This is also made the Volkswagen Beetle a well defined brand personality that carves itself a niche in the market place. This mad the readers from wondering if the car is socially acceptable to almost thinking of owning it. The Graphics of the ad also are kept minimalistic keeping in line with the Volkswagen performance before looks. This made it stand out from other...

Words: 312 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Effect of Advertising Presentaion

...Welcome to WritePoint, the automated review system that recognizes errors most commonly made by university students in academic essays. The system embeds comments into your paper and suggests possible changes in grammar and style. Please evaluate each comment carefully to ensure that the suggested change is appropriate for your paper, but remember that your instructor's preferences for style and format prevail. You will also need to review your own citations and references since WritePoint capability in this area is limited. Thank you for using WritePoint. Technology has revolution the way we engage in the world today. Internet popularity and explosion of social networking sites have drastically alter people’s social interactions. At any given time, millions of people are engaged in texting, sending e-mails, surfing the web, social networking, or watching video in front of computer screens technology addicts’ nightmare, 2011. There is growing alienation between individuals, between families, and between humankind and nature. This is especially worse in children, who are [Writing suggestion: rewrite the sentence to remove "who are"] highly impressionable and still developing their social skills. From a young age, children are constantly exposed to technology in the form of animated shows in television, interactive computer software and cell phones (Brunt field, 2010). There is no more quiet time to simple relaxed and...

Words: 1232 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Effect of Celebrity Advertising in the Philippines

...Proposed title: The Effect of Celebrity Advertising in the Philippines Thesis Statement: Philippine Celebrities are very important factors in advertising nowadays because they serve as a very effective means in marketing. Problem (Background of the Proposal): A celebrity can be an actor or an actress who are usually seen in the television programs. Nowadays, many celebrities are now also commercial models and this phenomenon constitutes to the so-called “Celebrity Advertising”. Celebrities are now making a huge impact in advertisement in the Philippines. According to studies, consumers usually buy a product because of the celebrity endorser without knowing the factual effect of that certain commercial product. Specifications: • Must be able to clearly define Celebrity Advertising. • Must be able to show the effect of Celebrity Endorsing or Advertising in the Philippine commercial industry marketing. • Must be to give the different celebrity attributes on how to advertise a commercial product effectively. • Must be able to give the effect of being an endorser of a celebrity (celebrity income in a commercial). • Must be to relate brands, celebrities and consumers in the Philippines • Must be able to identify the risks involved and the celebrity arguments against celebrity advertising in the Philippines • Must be able to distinguish the impact of the brand endorsement by a celebrity on consumer behavior in the Philippines. References: • (2010...

Words: 438 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Essay On Negative Effects Of Advertising

...INDEX 1. what's advertising? 1.1 Advertising to youngsters. 1.2 Decision creating skills in youngsters. 1.3 The “tweenager market” 1.4 “tween “ market in Bharat. 2. Litreature review. 2.1 case study one 2.2 case study two 3. Famework for analysis 3.1 brand preference 3.2 peer cluster influence 3.3 pester power 4. Hypotheses 4.1 results of surveys 4.2 conclusion 5. Visible effects of advertising on youngsters 5.1 positive effects 5.2 negative effects 6. Recommendations 7. biblography DECLARATION This is to declare that the report of Amity University on the subject ‘Impact of advertising on children’ has been with success completed by Aahna Dhyani of BJMC second , beneath...

Words: 2844 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

The Effect of Advertising on Customer Choice

...THE EFFECT OF ADVERTISING ON CUSTOMER CHOICE A CASE STUDY OF CENTURY BOTTLING COMPANY LIMITED BY SEBYALA BOSCO 10/U/141910/BSE/PE A RESEARCH REPORT SUBMITTED TO THE SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF BACHELOR’S DEGREE OF BUSINESS STUDIES WITH EDUCATION OF KYAMBOGO UNIVERSITY AUGUST 2013 DECLARATION I Sebyala Bosco Registration Number 10/U/141910/BSE/PE, declare that this research report entitled “The effect of Advertising on Customer Choice case study of Century Bottling Company Limited” is out of my own effort and it has never been submitted to any institution for any award. Sign …………………….. Date……………………………. Sebyala Bosco 10/U/141910/BSE/PE APPROVAL This is to certify that the research report entitled “The effect of Advertising on Customer Choice case study of Century Bottling Company Limited” by Sebyala Bosco registration number 10/U/141910/BSE/PE has been done under my supervision. The research report is ready for submission to School of Management and Entrepreneurship with my approval as University supervisor. Sign: ……………………………… Date:……………………….. Ms. Nakatete Phionah (Supervisor) DEDICATION I dedicate this report to my beloved father Dr. Bukenya John Vicent, my beloved mother Ms. Namuli Josephine, Mr. Lubega Fred and Haji Kazibwe, Prof. Kawuma, Hajjati Sarah...

Words: 14817 - Pages: 60

Premium Essay

Positive And Negative Effects Of Advertising

...Adolescence, age group typically from 13 to 18, have many challenges for individuals irrespective of gender. These challenges include that on an emotional, physical and psychological level. These challenges may differ between males and females but the level of difficulty in trying to cope with the changes both physically and psychologically are equally difficult Young people of this age group are particularly vulnerable to external influences such as advertising as they are self-aware and are trying to define and assert themselves in the world around them. They are trying to find themselves and therefore are easily influenced.“Maturation does not stop at age 10, but continues into the teen years and even into the 20’s. What is most surprising...

Words: 1264 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Effect of Banner Advertising on Internet Purchasing

...being reviewed in this reading brief paper,“ The Effect Of Banner Advertising on Internet Purchasing ” investigated the relationship between banner advertising and purchasing patterns on the internet. The authors used a behavioral database that consists of customer purchases at a Web site and individual advertising exposure. The authors measure the impression of banner advertising on current customers’ probability of repurchase while accounting for duration dependence. (1) The authors formulate a model of individual purchase timing behavior as a function of advertising exposure. A survival model was used to model the probability of a current customer making a purchase in any given week (since the last purchase). The duration dependence in the customers’ purchase behavior is captured through a flexible, piecewise exponential hazard function. The advertising covariates enter through a proportional hazards specification. These covariates, consist of strictly advertising variables, such as weight and quality, as well as advertising/individual browsing variables, represented by how many and which pages expose customers to advertising. The model is cast in a hierarchical Bayesian framework, thus enabling the authors to control for unobserved individual differences in the advertising response parameters and to investigate the impact of targeted advertising strategies. The authors concluded that banner advertising have a positive effect on Internet purchasing. Key Learning points: the...

Words: 1003 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Americans Are Obsessed: The Isolation Effect In Advertising

...bodies of Americans, according to a 2011 survey (“Americans Are Obsessed”). Taking advantage of the amount of food Americans consume, food companies are offering “natural” and “organic” alternatives, but these alternatives are not as good as they sound. Alexia, one of the newest “all-natural” companies, sprouted up and has been causing damage since early 2015. But little to the Americans’ knowledge, Alexia is abusing the power of advertising to sell products that...

Words: 1707 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Blood Donations: the Causes and Effects of Advertising

...Blood Donations: The Causes and Effects of Advertising There are many people walking the face of the earth at this very moment because of the unselfish benevolence and caring of blood donors throughout the United States. This generosity, without a doubt, is responsible for saving an immeasurable amount of lives each and every year. Many individuals simply don’t know what is involved with donating blood, so they don’t or can’t bring themselves to do it. For the scores of people who can’t, they could volunteer in other areas, including making financial contributions that would help with advertising costs. Educating the general public on the pros and cons of blood donation should be at the top of the list when advertising. When the twin towers were attacked on September 11, 2001, a record number of Americans donated blood in support of the tragedy on that day. According to Korcok (2002): So much donated blood was wasted after last year's Sept. 11 terrorist attacks that US blood banks have struck a special task force to ensure that it doesn't happen again. More than 200,000 units of whole blood had to be thrown away after Americans donated 500,000 extra units in September and October. Donated blood is discarded if it remains unused after 42 days... fewer than 260 units were actually needed to treat victims of the attacks in New York and Washington. This special task force is responsible for developing consistent advertising campaigns which will focus on specific...

Words: 1321 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Claude Herne The Effects Of Advertising On Women

...By presenting, in a caricatured way, scenery where the woman must be a ‘woman’, advertising-a refl ector and agent of society, confi rms as a fact a ‘natural’ behavior that is not at all according to the interests of women’s world itself» (Herne, 1993: 31). Th e conclusion made by Claude Herne in 1993, shows clearly the power of advertising in helping society to defi ne specifi c models of behavior for men and women and submitting the latter to a specifi c and limited role. Th e analysis proposed by Herne does not come out accidentally in the end of the 20th century. With the boom of technology and economic growth in the second half of the century, the western urban woman fi nds herself on the threshold of her fi nal emancipation from the household....

Words: 464 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Effect of Celebrity Advertising in the Philippines (Topic Proposal)

... Hum 3 X 2010-19195/CEAT February 19, 2013 TOPIC PROPOSAL FOR HUM 3 Proposed title: The Effect of Celebrity Advertising in the Philippines Thesis Statement: Philippine Celebrities are very important factors in advertising nowadays because they serve as a very effective means in marketing. Problem (Background of the Proposal): A celebrity can be an actor or an actress who are usually seen in the television programs. Nowadays, many celebrities are now also commercial models and this phenomenon constitutes to the so-called “Celebrity Advertising”. Celebrities are now making a huge impact in advertisement in the Philippines. According to studies, consumers usually buy a product because of the celebrity endorser without knowing the factual effect of that certain commercial product. Specifications: • Must be able to clearly define Celebrity Advertising. • Must be able to show the effect of Celebrity Endorsing or Advertising in the Philippine commercial industry marketing. • Must be to give the different celebrity attributes on how to advertise a commercial product effectively. • Must be able to give the effect of being an endorser of a celebrity (celebrity income in a commercial). • Must be to relate brands, celebrities and consumers in the Philippines • Must be able to identify the risks involved and the celebrity arguments against celebrity advertising in the Philippines • Must be able to distinguish the impact of the brand endorsement by a celebrity on...

Words: 280 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Point-Of-Purchase Advertising And Its Effect On You, As A Consumer

...point-of-purchase advertising and its effect on you, as a consumer. Comment on how effective this type of advertising was to you. Include the following elements: Short description of three different point-of-purchase advertising/promotion that you have recently come across (ads in-store, personal selling by a cosmetic counter salesperson, etc). For each point-of-purchase advertising/promotion, discuss the following: Did you buy the product? If so, how much did the point-of-purchase advertising/promotion influence your decision to buy? How did you feel about the point-of-purchase advertising? Was it annoying, helpful, etc.? Most importantly, in the role of a marketing executive for the brand, would you recommend that the brand continue to spend part of their advertising budget on this form of media? Why/why not?...

Words: 768 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Effect of Celebrity Advertising in the Philippines (Topic Proposal)

...Mc-Donald Vs Domino’s - Comparative Analysis Determinant Of Choosing Fast Food Restaurant And Their Service Quality BY:- ANUJ CHAUHAN (FINANCE + MARKETING) ITM UNIVERSITY, SITHOLI, GWALIOR ABSTRACT SERVICE QUALITY Parasuraman et al. (1988) introduced a 22-item scale, called SERVQUAL, for measuring service quality, the model has been widely adopted across industries. The scale was tested in 4 service settings different from those of the original test: a dental school patient clinic, a business school placement center, a tire store, and an acute care hospital. In service industries, customer satisfaction is always influenced by the quality of interactions between customers and the personnel involved in the contact services (1994). In the last decade, the movement towards quality had started to spread from the manufacturing sector to the service sector. The shift of focus to quality is basic for the service business to survive the competition, get acceptance from society, and be able to achieve its missions. In principle, the two main things closely related to services are expected quality and experienced or perceived quality. The first is the customers' expectations of service quality and the latter is the customers' perceptions of service quality. The customers will always assess the services they experienced by comparing them with whatever they expected or wished to receive. Services are behavioral rather than physical entities and have been described...

Words: 7210 - Pages: 29