Free Essay

The Enlightenment and Its Discontents

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Viscerotonio
Words 2287
Pages 10
THE ENLIGHTENMENT AND ITS DISCONTENTS
Antinomies of Christianity, Islam and the calculative sciences

In my point of view, the main concern of this paper is about the role of ideology in retarding or advancing the Enlightenment project. Which the ideologies itself in this case are Christianity, Islam, and accounting as a calculative science because each constitute a social ideology where they are systems of belief that inform conduct in everyday life. And what is Enlightenment itself? From the explanation of Kant, “Enlightenment is the liberation of man from his self-caused state of minority. Minority is incapacity of using one understands without the direction of another. This state of minority is self-caused when its source lies not in a lack of understanding but in a lack of determination and courage to use it without the assistance of another. Dare to use your own understanding.” From the Christian dialectic, human Enlightenment decline. It is characterized by the existence of a war against the accumulation of wealth, which is considered as an obstacle to the development of capitalism. In catholic paternalism, it is seen the pressure internally and externally. Internally, there was hypocrisy of economic in the body of the Church, where they prohibit lending practices and interest rates, but the Church itself there is excess wealth. Externally, the secularization of Church function in the form of God monarchy or God monopoly, faced with land acquisition monarchy that led to growing speculation, rents, and rising land prices.
In Addition, the English revolution in the form of agricultural technology push declining Catholic morality. The exploitation of export trade wool from England and cost inflation at home led to the seizure of land for profitable redeployment to new forms of industry. Public Fields and forest previously used for collective farming and fuel were fenced off and converted into pasture for sheep grazing. Landowners, themselves beset by financial pressures, reneged on ancient understanding, and drove peasants from their lands.
The monopoly of Catholicism’s led to the Protestant synthesis. A reformation of a movement by religious people, who shared with Enlightenment thinkers a dislike of Church’s monopoly over the individual’s access and communion with God, and who could no longer tolerate Catholicism’s anachronistic hypocrisy.
Catholicism itself never escaped from its mythological ancestry. Indeed, even today, it continues to deploy pre-Christian mythological symbolism to great effect. In anthropological terms, Catholic dogma regarding papal infallibility retains elements of God-King religions, such as that practiced by some Egyptian pharaohs. Authority under such belief systems is embodied in the Almighty here on Earth; a supernatural being that supplies a terrible and divine presence. Protestantism dethroned Catholicism’s infallible Shepherd of the Lord, and (modestly) crowns man as maker of his own destiny. The mythological crowning of man is the final chapter where he becomes the master of his own destiny (Tawny, 1937). This metamorphosis of Christianity into Protestantism is the quintessence of Kant’s dictum: “Dare to use your understanding”.
The Enlightenment and Catholic campaign against myth sought to abolish superstition, exorcise the gods, and erase magic. Yet both Catholicism and science proceeded by taking-on the methods of myth (and in doing so, they eventually revert to myth). The continuity between myth and science is reflected in their common pursuit of control, and the means for accomplishing control. Science inherits from myth its reliance on repetition, shown today in techniques of correlation analysis, pattern recognition, regression analysis, etc. From the point of view of science, there is a fundamental difference between the logos and the reality and the subject with object. Classification or Cartesian dualism provides a rational thinking that separates subject and object. While Descartes count ration, empirical evidence, technology and promoting everything that can be measured, demonstrated, engineered, and the complex reality recognized only material, physical and natural. Man is seen as a thinking entity, which is rational. Knowledge is the result of the deduction of priori that known as rationally. The view of Descartes and Cartesian also makes the struggle of Enlightenment, because of the emphasis on rationality and forget the other dimension which is the dimension of human nature by holistic. Enlightenment struggle occurred because of the failure of the view of science that tends to think logo-centrism. First, the thought patterns of binary opposition considered oppressive marginal position. Second, the emphasis on practical aspect and functions remove the ethical aspects. Third, the standard form that universally regarded marginalizes local values. Christianity has long-been in the forefront of religious engagement in the formation of capitalism. Recently, Islam has enjoined the struggle against capitalism in a visible and sometimes dramatic manner. Unlike Christianity, Islam is not so directly concerned directly implicated in defending the ideal of the Enlightenment (the latter being commonly understood as European in time and space, notwithstanding then on-European antecedents). From the Islamic point of view, the values of Enlightenment actually have in common with Islamic Value. First, Islam is a religion that privileges “the innate” moderate and positive qualities of Man, and the importance of knowledge in their development. Material and spiritual life are not bifurcated; they form part of an essential unity. Knowledge is privileged because it fosters human integrity. This knowledge is neither cerebral nor practical, but composed of a holistic relation between belief and behavior, that gives pride of place to a civilized development of humanity. Second, Islam is “Enlightenment”, and for capitalism – revolutionary – in that it rejects the division of the secular and the non-secular, and more generally, the separation between church and state. Indeed, Islam is not merely a “personal” religion; but, as the Koran shows in great detail, is also an organization for society, its institutions, as well as a guide for conduct of individuals within that institutional and social context. Consequently, the Koran itself is the authority for resisting the kind of ceasefire-agreement with the state that Christianities in the West have acceded to, where the secular has surrendered to the non-secular the realms of politics, education, the workplace, and economic relations. Third, in the realm of science, Islam remains holistic or dialectical, where, for instance, the health of the spirit and body and mind are treated as a unity. It’s thereby stands against many of the Cartesian dualisms that typify the Enlightenment’s regression under capitalism - with the attendant subordination of man. We consider each of these areas in greater detail below. Islam is simultaneously a religion, and a social constitution, because instructs Muslims in both how to worship and how they should conduct themselves with others (individuals, group, family, nation). The West has borrowed these precepts liberally from the centuries old traditions of Islam: the principles established by the League of Nations in regulating relationships between nation states, and the ideals of the French Revolution (freedom, equality and fraternity) derive from experience from previously functioning Islamic societies. Many institutions established in Europe under Napoleon I was similarly inspired after his Egyptian campaign. There is no explicit prohibition against private property or capitalism in an Islamic social order, although many of its excesses would be deemed unacceptable. In Islam the Koran elevates both the unity of the spiritual and material character of people. It is “moderate” in its recognition that does not ordain either a purely ascetic, or an essentially materialist life. It seeks a virtuous conduct that, on one hand, must be principled, and on the other, must be practical. These qualities are disengaged in market capitalism: principles are for the home, and practicalities are for work. The civilizations incorporated under the Islamic empire celebrated unity in diversity by drawing from all sources for their development. This tolerance of difference stands in contrast with the totalizing mission of Western capitalism(although not all forms of Christianity) where colonized identities are viewed as “primitive” and in need of “civilizing” (as under such ideologies of “Manifest Destiny”, and the “White man’s Burden”). In contrast, in Islamic architecture, mosques are constructed in a style that honors local traditions (Indonesian, Tunisian, Egyptian, etc). Similarly, knowledge vital to the development of science in the Islamic empire harnessed the efforts of scholars from all religions – Christians, Jews, Indians and Muslims – who were all supported for their contributions to the human advancement The straggle of the Islamic Enlightenment happened when Jihad has been scandalized by some Muslims and Christians as a “Holy War”, however for many moderates, and in the Koran itself, pre-eminence is given to knowledge and the integrity of conscience. The “Big” Jihad is the struggle against oneself and one’s passions. It is an effort to foster a conscience to control against corruption. The “small” jihad (Aljihad alsghar) consists of repairing an injustice (at the limit, war), but even here, there is a religious prohibition against aggression because life is sacred (Surat Al-r’ad, 11, Surat al-maida, 32). According to these respected, authoritative, and thus widely accepted readings of the Koran, the representation of the Jihad – as a war to convert people to Islam – is completely false. In the rise of calculative sciences, Kant and Bacon represent seemingly opposing visions for human knowledge and control. Bacon’s focus on the experimental method represents a movement from “Reality” to “The Idea”, whereas Descartes’ quest to unify science within mathematics represents a movement from “The Idea” to “Reality”. These early philosophical schisms threaten the Modernist Ideal, by misconstruing movement in reality in an either-or (Cartesian) manner (for instance, by reducing choice to either induction or deduction).Far more important than epistemic distortions are the shared social (materialist) precepts of Kant and Bacon: the dethroning of God, the demolition of his institutional and political (Catholic) arsenal on Earth, and the “Ascent of Man”. These antinomies at the level of the “Haut Science” of Bacon and Descartes, percolated through to the practical knowledge of algebra, geometry, and accounting to further unsettle the balance between the secular and the worldly. Calculus did not drop out of the sky; nor was it a purely a Western invention. In the West, it appeared with the advent of modern science, and followed closely on the rise of capitalism. The Great Renaissance and the emergence of European industry and the capitalist class in the fifteenth and seventeenth centuries had a tremendous influence on the development of mathematics. With the discovery of analytic geometry and the invention of calculus, mathematics was transformed from a science of constant quantities into the mathematics of varying quantities (calculus). These early developments in sciatic and mathematical competence provided an intellectual and methodological reservoir to be drawn-on by economists and accountants. Accounting’s complicity in these processes is multifarious. It intrudes into the operations of the workplace (management and cost accounting), into locating and shaping that workplace (financial accounting, tax regime analysis, mergers and acquisitions consulting), the quality and quantity of products that are generated by the workplace (budgeting, forecasting, planning), identifying more lucrative consumer segments and appraising strategies for reconstructing consumers and their tastes(market analysis), and the audit process that monitors the integrity of information and decisions operating at all these different levels, etc. There are Obstacles to developing a progressive politics; Progressive politics has been sabotaged by its own illusions, and these illusions are rampant in accounting. First, there is the allure of personal, identity, and issue-politics that are frequently conducted on territory “outside” the market. Second, following the triumphs of the 1933-1934 US Securities Acts, and 1948Companies Acts, reformist accountants today continue to favor such legislative remedies for contemporary ills, long after circumstances have rendered the elixir impotent. The SEC and the FASB were victims of the commodification of politics; they were captured by the industries they were designed to regulate. These were corporate and accounting casualties in the struggle between the market and the social, and between the modern and postmodern. The PCAOB is exposed to the same susceptibilities. The assault on the modern and its progressive Enlightenment precepts, has gained impetus from the rise of market capitalism, and the reduction of Man to a commodity for the alien purposes of accumulation. The struggle against Enlightenment regression cannot be conned to the traditional class concerns of the workplace. There is an integral relation between these issues and religion, race, gender, foreign policy, and uncommodified fields of experience (Elson, 1979). A “politics of production” includes not just the factory, but all activities that contribute to the reproduction of the factory in the home, in spiritual life, at school, in the theatre, in places of consumption, in parenting, etc.
The charge of progressive accounting in the Modernist project is to promote individual and social development by enhancing the integrity of accounting information. A moment’s reflection on the ramifications of this rubric would show that we have hardly begun work on this task. Here, we can begin outlining some of the possibilities for this new politics of accounting. Consider, for instance, the kind of educational curriculum for a properly priming of undergraduate students for the progressive work. First, the use of “live” case studies, drawn from the litany of accounting and audit failures from the last decade, to obtain this material, big firms need to be pressured into abandoning their practice of sealing court records of cases as part of their settlements. Second, an introduction to philosophy criticism that’s endows students with political acuity and philosophical skepticism as to the conservative precepts of Cartesian and empiricist analysis. And third, there is an integral connection between Islam and accounting today that underscores the exigency of broad historical, multicultural, social, and political studies – within accounting education itself. It is a responsibility of critical accountants to alert people that this is a ruse to divert attention from their own critical agenda and the problem’s engendered by this destructive social order.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

American Revolution

...British Empire’s sense of superiority was the most important reason. Also important was the failure of the British Parliament to address the needs and growing discontent of Americans weary of “taxation without representation.” Colonists also began to oppose rule from Britain because of ideas developing in new intellectual schools of thought like the Enlightenment. King George III’s arrogance was well founded in the 1760s, but it led to poor decision making. Early in his reign, the British had resoundingly defeated France in the Seven Years’ War to become the dominant power both in North America and on the Asian subcontinent. This dominance clearly created a false sense of security and as the British Empire continued to grow, its central authority, or ability to control its ever-expanding colonies, weakened significantly. Great Britain’s failure to recognize its weaknesses and its foolish decision to respond to every colonial expression of discontent with a tightening of the noose effectively sealed it into an everescalatingspiral of conflict. The conflict could have been avoided and King George III could have secured the colonies’ loyalty to the empire for generations if he would have simply signed off on a relatively modest series of reforms. The British Parliament failed to address the needs and growing discontent of Americans weary of “taxation without representation.” Great Britain’s indifference to colonial life, its failure to recognize the fact that Americans...

Words: 737 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Glorious Revolution DBQ

...the aristocrats through propaganda and the construction of Versailles to keep his peers busy. In Prussia Frederick the Great created a more equal society that saw Nobles become. Ore involved with national affairs by involving themselves militaristically. Russia experienced Catherine the Great and the modernization of Russian society by introducing philosophical and scientific ideas into society. The Glorious Revolution is a manifestation of the enlightenment theme in Britain. James II attempted to consolidate British power but...

Words: 605 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

French Revolution

...Writing Assignment The French Revolution in 1789 came as a surprise to many people during that time. For a country with such absolute Monarchy and was advanced in every single way comparing to other European countries, revolution is something that no one would expect. However, some Primary Sources clearly shows evidence of the need for revolution among the commoners in France. Some factors that had caused the idea of rebellion include a king that’s completely incompetent, the bankruptcy in the country and hope of liberty after seeing the success of American Revolution. In the end it is the eager for freedom and anger towards high taxes in the third estate that finally led France into the great revolution. In Arthur Young’s travel diaries, he stressed a few key circumstances that led to the outbreak of French Revolution. In his opinion, the French Revolution was not so much a surprise and the seeds of revolution had been spread and deeply ingrained in the French long ago. First, he pointed out the long unsolved financial problem that had been bothering the nation. However, the king in throne does not have the knowledge to solve such crisis nor do the court that immersed themselves in pleasure. On top of the financial crisis, the commoners wanted for some immediate change but do not know what to look up to and hope for. I think what Young is trying telling us is that the root to the revolution is the mass bankruptcy in the country. The king could have solved this primary crisis...

Words: 935 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Abigail Adams Rhetorical Analysis

...Abigail Adams was not like the other women of her time. She was bold and “saucy”, she knew what she wanted and was not afraid to express it. In her first letter to John Adams, she refers to the fact that woman are treated as inferiors by saying “Regard us then as Beings”(1). Abigail Adams’ boldness stems from her views on the Enlightenment ideas and her desire to enjoy the freedoms that men have. John Adams believes that woman are in the proper level of society and should remain there. Abigail Adams uses logos immediately in her first letter when she says “… passion in liberty cannot be Eaquelly Strong in the Breasts of those who have been accustomed to deprive their fellow Creatures of theirs” (1). She states when men speak of liberty...

Words: 392 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Reactionary Conservatism

...Revolution led to reactionary conservatism in Europe. Reactionary conservatism that focused on upholding tradition contrasts the increase in radicalism that characterized the French revolution. One conservative, Metternich, is comparable to Thomas Hobbes as they both supported monarchy as a way to maintain order. Metternich was Austrian. There was great disunity in Austria during this time period because of various ethnic groups that all wanted independence, reflecting the disunity of the Holy Roman Empire during the Reformation. The conservatives increased censorship that contrasted the liberty and natural rights of the Enlightenment. The type of traditional, autocratic monarchies that the conservatives supported also contrasted the enlightenment support for constitutional monarchy and natural rights. In South America, revolts were inspired by the Enlightenment like the other revolutions were, but the French and American revolutions started in the middle while the South American Revolutions were pushed from below. In 1815, France and England had relatively liberal governments that supported natural rights and had constitutional monarchies. This contrasted the rest of Europe which was characterized by traditional absolutist monarchies. Despite the relatively liberal nature of government in France and England, voting rights were extremely limited, contrasting our world in which most adults can vote. With the rise of nationalism, unified states became more unified while multinational...

Words: 1631 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

American Revolution Causes

...The American Revolution was caused by problems with religion, government, finances, freedom, and rights. All of these subjects have been presented earlier during the enlightenments, the glorious revolution, the English Civil War, and stand in the English Bill of rights which later set the basis for our country today. Without the thinkers that the Scottish enlightenment produced, our modern government wouldn’t be the way that it remains today. If it wasn’t for the English Bill of Rights, the constitution would not exist. All of the causes listed above play a part in the American Revolution, which would later result in the creation of the United States of America. Maybe the most influential character came out of the enlightenment, his name...

Words: 703 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Enlightenment in Prussia and Germany

...The Small Enlightenment in Prussia and German States The Enlightenment was an expansive intellectual, philosophical, cultural, and social movement that spread throughout much of Europe during the 1700s. The Enlightenment was largely made possible by the Scientific Revolution which began in the 1500s and represented the biggest departure from The Middle Ages. After millenniums of obedience to the Church people started to break away from a long spell of ignorance and began to question ideas relating to society and nature. A period also known as ‘The Age of Reason’ saw the emergence of intellectuals advancing knowledge unlike ever before. What resulted were pivotal discoveries in the fields of mathematics, astronomy, physics, politics, economics, philosophy, music, and medicine that shaped the Western world for decades and centuries to come. While The Enlightenment didn’t help produce a revolutionary outcome such as in France, Prussia and German states still experienced a fair share of intellectual development during this time. Since Germany was divided into a multitude of smaller states, with different languages and influences, The Enlightenment didn’t have a full blown effect. Moreover, the combination of popular discontent with the Church and a fury of dissatisfaction among the nobility and middle class such as in France wasn’t entirely present in Prussia. Nonetheless, Frederick II the Great, the King of Prussia, borrowed ideas from other parts of Europe in an attempt...

Words: 1078 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cause of the French Revolution of 1789

...The French Revolution of 1789 had many long-range causes. Political, social, and economic conditions in France contributed to the discontent felt by many French people-especially those of the third estate. The ideas of the intellectuals of the Enlightenment brought new views to government and society. The American Revolution also influenced the coming of the French Revolution. The Philosophes planted the seeds for the French Revolution. Their goals were to expose and destroy the inequalities of the ancient regime (old order). The political discontent of France was one of the causes of the Revolution. In the 17th and 18th centuries, France was ruled by an absolute government. The king had all the political powers. Anyone who criticized the government could be arrested and put in prison without trial. Louis XVI was king at the time of the French Revolution. He was more interested in hunting than governing France. He and his Austrian queen, Marie Antoinette, lived an extravagant life at the Palace of Versailles. They did not really care about the state of their country. The excerpt from the cahiers mentioned in document 3 shows that the votes in the assembly were not taken by head. The people of the 3rd estate felt a sense of betrayal when the king supported the block voting over the head voting. The first two estates worked together to outvote the large third estate to keep them from becoming a threat to the power. Lord Acton, an Englishmen, states that the monarchy being overthrown...

Words: 405 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

French Revolution Dbq

...The Enlightenment was an intellectual movement that applied the scientific method and human reason to solve society’s problems. Many members of the third estate were educated in the ideas of enlightenment and wanted to change the existing system in France. They wanted to make France a republic rather than having such a powerful monarchy. The Government would protect human’s natural rights and equality would challenge the social hierarchy. The first right in the Declaration of Rights of Man later established (1789) states, “Men are born and remain free and equal in rights; social distinctions (distinctions) can be established only for the common benefit.” The members of the Estates General from the third estate went to Versailles for a meeting and found the doors locked. Assuming they were being robbed of their position, they went to the tennis court outside the palace and made the Tennis Court Oath. This oath promised to reform the French Constitution. The Third Estate Estates General members then declared themselves the National Assembly in which they would make the enlightenment ideas a reality. This act, caused by Enlightenment, was the beginning of the French...

Words: 914 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Eastern and Western Philosophers Comparison

...philosophies and Western philosophies both make quite a few compelling cases when it comes to their ideas. The particular Eastern philosophy that I find to be most fascinating is that of Buddhism. The Western philosophies of Immanuel Kant were also influential and fascinating to contemplate, though differed with reasoning for their development. These two philosophies have some undeniable similarities and differences. Buddhism is an Eastern philosophy that came to life in India by a prince named Siddhartha Gautama, also known as Buddha after he felt that he found enlightenment. In the beginning, Buddhism was the philosophical response to the problem of suffering. This made it easier to understand that there is more to suffering than one believes. Suffering does not only occur when one goes through physical pain and misery, it is also there and occurs when we go through things like disappointment, frustration, discontent and sorrow. I am almost certain that Buddha’s teachings stem from his own personal experience and the experiences of others that were around him. He was able to learn from the examples of others and himself. I feel this philosophy is very logical. When it comes to Western Philosophy, Immanuel Kant was a German Philosopher who contributed to the philosophical views of religion. He is known for inventing the most famous moral arguments on the existence of God. His criticism towards the traditional proof of God is something that is very important in literature. According...

Words: 696 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Eastern Philosophy Comparison

...A Comparison of Eastern Philosophy Asia, the world’s largest continent, consists of over one third of Earths total land are and approximately 60% of the world’s population. Further, a large percentage of Asia’s 4.3 billion people live in the countries of China, Japan, and India (Exploredia, 2011). Out of these densely populated countries three eastern schools of philosophy were born between the 6th and 4th centuries BCE, and it is these same ancient philosophies that flourish throughout Asia today. Confucianism, Buddhism, and Hinduism are three major schools of thought that significantly have impacted the political, social and religious views of Asian culture. Confucianism, which was inspired by Confucius, has been followed by the Chinese people for more than two thousand years (Confucianism, 2012, pp.1). Because Confucianism is described as a way of life, it is sometimes viewed as a philosophy and sometimes viewed as a religion, although it does not share the aspect of organization that most other religions share. The idea behind Confucianism is that wisdom and knowledge can be obtained through study, ritual practices, and learning from experiences. Humans are perfectible by wisdom and the ultimate goal is to reach a state of superior wisdom. The first principle Confucius taught is called the principle of mean, which is the importance of seeking balance and moderation in life. Any circumstance of extreme should be avoided. The second principle Confucius...

Words: 1064 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Liberalism in French Revolution Through Enlightenment

...THE LIBERAL REVOLUTION -UNDER THE IDEA OF ENLIGHTENMENT "Dare to know! Have courage to use your own reason!"-Kant Contents ENLIGHTENMENT AS AN IDEA: 3 FRENCH SOCIETY: 3 THE LIBERAL REVOLUTION: 3 CRITICISM ON THE IDEA OF LIBERALISM: 4 CONCLUSION 5 BIBLIOGRAPHY 6 ENLIGHTENMENT AS AN IDEA: “Enlightenment is man's emergence from his self-imposed nonage… Sapere Aude! Dare to Know! Have the courage to use your own understanding is therefore the motto of the Enlightenment.” Immanuel Kant (Columbia.edu) The eighteenth century Enlightenment proved to be a movement of the intellectuals who dared to prove all the aspects in life scientifically. These individuals were greatly affected by the scientific revolution. They were, in addition, advocating the appliance of the scientific methodology to the understanding of life. Throughout the age of enlightenment, science became popular and there were many philosophers like John Locke, Jean Jacques Rousseau, Adam Smith, Montesquieu, etc who applied the natural laws to the social life. These people and their writings had a huge impact on the French Revolution. FRENCH SOCIETY: Prior to the revolution, the French society was buried under the burden of taxes-levied by the State, rents paid to the lord, contributions collected by the clergy, as well as under the forced labor exacted by all three. People were reduced to foraging for food because of the recurring famines. The famines were caused by both manmade...

Words: 1593 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Neoclassical

...music to play-writing, as well as philosophy and science. Romanticisms preoccupation with themes such as man’s relationship with God, nature, and emotions came in direct and deliberate opposition to Neoclassicism’s preoccupation with logic and traditional views on artistic technique. Neoclassical art emerged out of the Enlightenment, primarily in Western Europe. Art, of all kinds, during in this period were informed by Enlightenment ideals, which were largely reactionary against the Renaissance period before it. The Renaissance was defined by its tremendous scientific and artistic progressions. However, toward the end of the Renaissance, resentment was mounting against the scientific and philosophical figures at the head of the movement. Science had deevolved into a show, with alleged scientists performing experiments in a manor that felt more like parlor tricks through repetition instead of making real scientific developments. The Renaissance gave the Western world a promise for technological and social progress, and when that never came to fruition, the Enlightenment wanted to take society to the place it had been previously promised. Thusly, the Enlightenment took to philosophy and the sciences with a new preoccupation with a new seriousness, attempting to take new leaps forward in biology, chemistry, and...

Words: 1302 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The French Revolution

...The French Revolution of 1789 had many long-range causes. Political, social, and economic conditions in France contributed to the discontent felt by many French people-especially those of the third estate. The ideas of the intellectuals of the Enlightenment brought new views to government and society. The American Revolution also influenced the coming of the French Revolution. The Philosophes planted the seeds for the French Revolution. Their goals were to expose and destroy the inequalities of the ancient regime (old order). The political discontent of France was one of the causes of the Revolution. In the 17th and 18th centuries, France was ruled by an absolute government. The king had all the political powers. Anyone who criticized the government could be arrested and put in prison without trial. Louis XVI was king at the time of the French Revolution. He was more interested in hunting than governing France. He and his Austrian queen, Marie Antoinette, lived an extravagant life at the Palace of Versailles. They did not really care about the state of their country. The excerpt from the cahiers mentioned in document 3 shows that the votes in the assembly were not taken by head. The people of the 3rd estate felt a sense of betrayal when the king supported the block voting over the head voting. The first two estates worked together to outvote the large third estate to keep them from becoming a threat to the power. Lord Acton, an Englishmen, states that the monarchy being overthrown...

Words: 1173 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

French Revolution

...were instrumental in the cause of the revolution, played a role in the process of the revolt and were altered greatly as a result of the rebellion. Due to the difficult economic situation in France, there was a lot of discontent with the way the country was being ruled. France had an unfair tax system and a large debt caused by the Seven Years War and the American War of Independence. There was a high unemployment, poor harvest due to bitter winter in 1788-1789, and food was extremely expensive. The government seemed uncaring toward the needs of its citizens and was deeply in debt. Also large numbers of unhappy French elite citizens began gathering together to complain about the political situation in France. They were discontent with Louis XIV’s rule and even more concerned by Louis the XV’s style of government. Soon this social action changed into political discussion about changes in the French government. The estates system that had been in place in France had not been functioning well, in fact the legislative assembly had not met for 175 years. Social activities lead directly to the will for political changes. By the Louis XIV reign groups of individuals began opposing abusive government. At this time, the ideas of the intellectuals of the Enlightenment brought new views to government and society. As well, many of the soldiers in France had fought in the American War of Independence where they were shown that freedom and equality were possible ideas. This made them push...

Words: 887 - Pages: 4